like 1 lol. back in my day it was the original members. i also saw of Mice and Men not long after. was a glorious time to be into this genre of music. @@Farfarawai
People with Attack: ACTUALLY there’s only 2 members so it’s more cover band than anything People with Chelse Grin: YEA. LETS GO BEST LINEUP EVER. CHELSEA GRIN WOOO
Peak AA! in my opinion was on This Means War with drop-F tuning and raw Caleb Shomo vocals. Kudos to the Andrews for keeping it going. As a fellow Andrew, I can relate to how it feels to not wanna let a band die.
Yea, this is just weird. It's like some tribute band covering attack attack lol. I'm glad Johnny stayed out though and has all of his focus on Bilmuri.
I mean... Andrew and Andrew being there is supposed to count, but the problem is they were never the standouts of the band. Austin, Johnny and Caleb were. That's why it feels weird.
"Attack! Attack! is back, baby!" Um no, 2 members are back with basically an entirely new band riding on the recognition that comes with the name. A!A! was always a weird band anyway, especially with there last record where Caleb basically made it a Beartooth demo. But this is a random band reusing the name. Johnny, Austin, and Caleb were the main talent of the band and it shows
well i think this new unclean vocalist (chris) is good (studio-wise) but for live he needs to put in some work. while for the clean vocals dude, idk hes ok but meh.
Saw these guys in Rochester two nights ago. They put on an awesome show. Got to meet them before the show. They are great people. Super down to earth. I respect them as musicians and as people. My wife and I will be fans forever.
@@plprooo I miss the crabcore days. Check out the band Graupel. It's a band in Japan but they sing in English. Crabcore screamo in 2023 is absolutely beautiful. I would love the mosh pit in Japan. They're fu**ing CRAZY! 🤘🏻🔥🤘🏻🔥🤘🏻
This sounds like a kick ass show and fun as hell. Just reading through some of the comments holy hell why do people have to be so jaded “2 actual members left it just a cover band now” ok so what that remaining two want to keep AA! Alive. the band is human and want to keep it going and the new content is awesome! Also those jaded comments can be said for bands like In flames, Underoath, Senses Fail, escape the fate, emmure, Chelsea grin, Ice nine kills, in dying arms, and technically we came as Romans, etc. Are they all cover bands if your answer is no then neither is AA!🤣🤣🤣🤣
I don’t even really care that it’s a new lineup because I like the new songs and I understand why the old vocalists wouldn’t return. And this show was really fun (I’m in the shot for a good part of this video)
Idk why everyone is freaking out calling them a cover band… The Andrews were in the band from the beginning… yea they got a new singer but did y’all forget how many singers they had during the initial run? Besides it’s either this or nothing, lighten up
I'll take nothing, please! This is a tarnish towards their legacy. Like jag suddenly wanting to use the asd name after the og lineup announced a reunion, no one cares about asd now!!!
@@blaky626 or Chelsea grin. Hell ice nine kills is on top rn, and Spencer’s the only original member. People are just hating because it’s always been trendy to hate on aa. It was the same even when Austin and Caleb were still in the band.
FUCKYEAH That was fun! I would’ve stayed for longer and maybe give some backing screams, but I didn’t want to fully steal the show. Next time! Here’s another angle of my crab stance up there! ruclips.net/video/tIL4Ol9-f6I/видео.htmlsi=7oeZatzzw0Bk6rVj
Idk why everyone is complaining about the lineup not being "real Attack Attack" because theres only 2 original members. By that logic, Emarosa isn't "real Emarosa" because the only OG member currently is their guitarist. DGD only has Will, Jon and Matt. Of Mice and Men only has 2 OG members. Times change, line-ups change. As long as they're still making new and exciting music while sticking to their roots, I don't see the issue.
@@condorsalesman so when you say ‘original members’ are you talking about the line up before Corey? I would consider anyone who was on the Self titled album to be an original member. No one knew who tf Slipknot was during MFKR era and before
Emmure, Chelse Grinn, Suicide Silcene loosing Mitch Lucker, Lynyrd Skynyrd loosing their singer. I could go on, and on, and on. Band members change, it's part of life.
but where are the iconic crab stances? 🦀 synchronized guitar lifts with the air kicks? running in place? or the proper voice mixing for the synth breakdown? there's not even a keyboard (synthesizer) from what i can see. don't get me wrong they sound fine, it just doesn't feel the same or scratch that nostalgia itch 🥺 RIP crabcore i luckily saw them back in early 2012 before caleb left and that was indeed an experience ♡
People - ☹️ there sound has changed, it's not same anymore Band performs old music People - hey it's not same members, they're just trying to market on their old image
Johnny and Caleb seem to be the things that made AA special. The special sauce. This can be considered AA, there’s no real rules about lineups , however I think most of us notice this isn’t much more than a cash in.
At the time I didn't think Johnny added much to the band tbh, but now I've heard what he's done with Bilmuri it literally sounds like what AA should have been, maybe he lacked confidence back then but I'm glad he's killing it now
I'm so glad I got to see the original band live back in 2010, with ISMFOF!
how many of those were on the original lineup? i dont recognize them, lol
like 1 lol. back in my day it was the original members. i also saw of Mice and Men not long after. was a glorious time to be into this genre of music. @@Farfarawai
Back when they fucking sucked?
Pretty good cover band imo!
Basically 😆
Right? Honestly don't have a clue who these people are. I love Attack Attack though.
Not the same without Austin. Agreed Great Cover lol
I disagree
@@jamongi1 johnny was this entire band but yeah, austin had a distinct scream
this band is now a real example of "Ship of Theseus" paradox :)
Have you heard the zao song with the same title
I only know this because of Wandavision.
@@SickIncKamikaze same
Haha great analogy
chelsea grin has them beat
2:10 when you wanna do your old stage moves but you're not 19 anymore and it hurts too much
aww hurts so much, tell than to Jean-Claude Van Damme in volvo commercial
Where grown up men became kids again... and it was that concert... their nostalgia.. and all their love for this band! hehe
People with Attack: ACTUALLY there’s only 2 members so it’s more cover band than anything
People with Chelse Grin: YEA. LETS GO BEST LINEUP EVER. CHELSEA GRIN WOOO
that's because the new chelsea grin is actually good
Lmfao so true legit people be sayin this shit. I’m over here like idgaf both bands still make good ass music.
@Garphels I’m aware. It’s just a joke lol
VALID
Meh. You haven't seen Chelsea Grin until you've seen them with the Oceano singer
The crowd singing with makes this so wholesome❤
Peak AA! in my opinion was on This Means War with drop-F tuning and raw Caleb Shomo vocals.
Kudos to the Andrews for keeping it going. As a fellow Andrew, I can relate to how it feels to not wanna let a band die.
^^ this 100%
Nice last name
That was a fantastic album. The wretched is still in rotation.
Nativ was also great
this means war was an elite album
Not the same without Austin, Caleb, or Johnny.
Yea, this is just weird. It's like some tribute band covering attack attack lol. I'm glad Johnny stayed out though and has all of his focus on Bilmuri.
@@Rob_Cary they have the original lead guitar and drummer. Wouldn’t call that a tribute band
@@drnkds That's it though. The vocalist isn't even near the same style as Austin or Caleb. And the cleans are bad
I mean... Andrew and Andrew being there is supposed to count, but the problem is they were never the standouts of the band. Austin, Johnny and Caleb were. That's why it feels weird.
@@davidcurtis8427 c’mon you cannot say that the cleans are bad 😂
"Attack! Attack! is back, baby!"
Um no, 2 members are back with basically an entirely new band riding on the recognition that comes with the name. A!A! was always a weird band anyway, especially with there last record where Caleb basically made it a Beartooth demo. But this is a random band reusing the name. Johnny, Austin, and Caleb were the main talent of the band and it shows
ill take this then no AA in general
attack attack have had a constantly changing line up tbh.
well i think this new unclean vocalist (chris) is good (studio-wise) but for live he needs to put in some work. while for the clean vocals dude, idk hes ok but meh.
AA is better at old time ago
A A! Stands for Andrew Andrew! Lol
I was there last night! My 2010 scene kid self can die in peace now that I’ve heard stick stickly live
This feels like running into your ex girlfriend and her new boyfriend only to notice he’s wearing the clothes she bought you
😂😂
I'd attack attack on sight
Saw these guys in Rochester two nights ago. They put on an awesome show. Got to meet them before the show. They are great people. Super down to earth. I respect them as musicians and as people. My wife and I will be fans forever.
Man I'm totally out of the music scene since covid. I live in Rochester and had no idea lol
It's awesome to see Wetzel brought back the bell
That was a fun night with a sick lineup lol for getting in the way it was me that got up to crab stance air guitar during the mid verse XD
dont be sorry it literally made the entire video. Ur a fuckin legend
0:17 "What happens if I can't check my MySpace when we get there?" Classic
I love when bands interact with fans during mid show. Allowing people on stage is amazing!
“Allowing” they’d Spartan kick them off if they could
@@plprooo I miss the crabcore days. Check out the band Graupel. It's a band in Japan but they sing in English. Crabcore screamo in 2023 is absolutely beautiful. I would love the mosh pit in Japan. They're fu**ing CRAZY! 🤘🏻🔥🤘🏻🔥🤘🏻
The guitarist singing is Ryland Raus who is the former vocalist of Inhale Exhale
he's the only guy who was on point. unlike the vocalist
Inhale exhale need to come back
@@kixs4020 agree
Nice. It'd be perfect if they also did the crab stance 🦀
They old now, the crab stance can hurt them 😁
@@kotelwader19 poor knees lmao
Imitation Crab..
Me at 2:11
me gusta!! gracias x regresar
This sounds like a kick ass show and fun as hell. Just reading through some of the comments holy hell why do people have to be so jaded “2 actual members left it just a cover band now” ok so what that remaining two want to keep AA! Alive. the band is human and want to keep it going and the new content is awesome! Also those jaded comments can be said for bands like In flames, Underoath, Senses Fail, escape the fate, emmure, Chelsea grin, Ice nine kills, in dying arms, and technically we came as Romans, etc. Are they all cover bands if your answer is no then neither is AA!🤣🤣🤣🤣
I don’t even really care that it’s a new lineup because I like the new songs and I understand why the old vocalists wouldn’t return. And this show was really fun (I’m in the shot for a good part of this video)
Jags A Skylit Drive should tour w them....
Idk why everyone is freaking out calling them a cover band… The Andrews were in the band from the beginning… yea they got a new singer but did y’all forget how many singers they had during the initial run? Besides it’s either this or nothing, lighten up
People dickriding Caleb,Austin and Johnny too hard calling it a cover band when the Andrews were in the band longer than Austin and Johnny combined.
Exactly. All I needed was for them to be good live, and they were. I was at this show, hell I’m in this video
I'll take nothing, please! This is a tarnish towards their legacy. Like jag suddenly wanting to use the asd name after the og lineup announced a reunion, no one cares about asd now!!!
Such a dope Cover guys
you can tell the people in the crowd haven't showered in months. I love this song sm
Thank you for uploading this. I was suppose to go tonight in Rochester and ended up getting sick and didn't want to get other sick as well.
Everyone likes to complain complain and complain but no one appreciates the fact that attack attack got back together to perform for us
it's a mere cash grab my man
@@girraffesrox then they can take my money. It's still attack attack. Nobody was ignoring Underoath when they had a complete lineup change.
@@blaky626 or Chelsea grin. Hell ice nine kills is on top rn, and Spencer’s the only original member. People are just hating because it’s always been trendy to hate on aa. It was the same even when Austin and Caleb were still in the band.
That’s because Spencer is the mastermind of the band lol
@@woeiseutu6304 and the vocalist....they can get away with lineup changes...
Sounds great for a cover band
Just remember when i was in junior high school in 2009 😄😄
I saw them at warped tour in Kansas City when two people died that year!!!
Man riding the people onto the stage for a perfect timing WHOOO! fuck yea
FUCKYEAH That was fun! I would’ve stayed for longer and maybe give some backing screams, but I didn’t want to fully steal the show. Next time! Here’s another angle of my crab stance up there! ruclips.net/video/tIL4Ol9-f6I/видео.htmlsi=7oeZatzzw0Bk6rVj
this is sick!
Idk why everyone is complaining about the lineup not being "real Attack Attack" because theres only 2 original members. By that logic, Emarosa isn't "real Emarosa" because the only OG member currently is their guitarist. DGD only has Will, Jon and Matt. Of Mice and Men only has 2 OG members. Times change, line-ups change. As long as they're still making new and exciting music while sticking to their roots, I don't see the issue.
That dude falling onto the floor at 2:26 was amazing
The legend is back
THAT. ENERGY. IS. WHAT. THE. SCENE. IS. ALL. ABOUT.
When you're a little older and have to put a knee down to crab core.
A banger is a banger
Also man in the back scream "catfish soup!!!" xD
people in this comment section acting like there isnt hundreds of bands in this scene with 2 or less original members left.
this song old but gold
I went to music school with their drummer. Pretty cool kid.
Minha música preferida
Nossa kkk
@@jonaspereira9583 show
Who are these guys and where’s 2010 warped tour attack attack 😭
My highschool life in one video. Cant wait for July !!!! Tulsa ok!!
yeah disco time
Are there any original members left?
Yeah, Andrew Whiting and Andrew Wetzel.
The lead guitarist and the drummer.
Andrew and Andrew
Now it's Just Andrew Wetzel, Andrew Whiting left the band
Isso ainda é AA?????
Austin, come back.
that snare drum though !!
Good crowd some bands just fun ass songs that are kinda timeless from this era
for those saying there's only two members left.. just Remember that Clown is the only original member left in Slipknot
Is this supposed to be a joke or are you being serious?
@@Naltddesha it is true
@@Naltddesha i mean he’s right
@@condorsalesman so when you say ‘original members’ are you talking about the line up before Corey? I would consider anyone who was on the Self titled album to be an original member. No one knew who tf Slipknot was during MFKR era and before
Why they get a vocalist who can’t scream 😵
They shouldve bring Nick Barham at least lol
@@MRandyEvan Nick slapped in Brightwell!
@@Donny214 IKR , but yea sadly no more music from them since their EP Alpha
@@MRandyEvan yeah I know Tanner joined Youth in Revolt, and Nick opened up a brunch house in Michigan, and the drummer Arvin does solo music now,
@@Donny214 damn man you know stuffs too, legend
yall need to get one of the singers back for me to even consider this attack attack
Never gonna happen
Yeah at least Johnny Franck
Damn, this OP SE hits different in 2022
Who are these people?
If you replace every piece on the boat over the years, is it still the same boat?
Emmure, Chelse Grinn, Suicide Silcene loosing Mitch Lucker, Lynyrd Skynyrd loosing their singer. I could go on, and on, and on. Band members change, it's part of life.
How they got Ryland Raus, Vocalist of Inhale Exhale, one of the best hardcore bands to never breakthrough to do this gig is beyond me.
but where are the iconic crab stances? 🦀 synchronized guitar lifts with the air kicks? running in place? or the proper voice mixing for the synth breakdown?
there's not even a keyboard (synthesizer) from what i can see. don't get me wrong they sound fine, it just doesn't feel the same or scratch that nostalgia itch 🥺 RIP crabcore
i luckily saw them back in early 2012 before caleb left and that was indeed an experience ♡
They’re all old and have bad knees lol
People - ☹️ there sound has changed, it's not same anymore
Band performs old music
People - hey it's not same members, they're just trying to market on their old image
this the type shit they should b dropping!!!
WHAT THE FUCK THAT SNARE IS INSANE MAN!!!
are they not the same personil ?? whos still in the band?? can you tell me guys
Love this
Crabcore is back
The guy Singing the cleans is he that guy from Project Night Fall ? night fam ???
What babd cover it is?
Back to 14 years ago maybe?
Where is the crab?
Nostalgia
nice cover
No Crab?
Johnny and Caleb seem to be the things that made AA special. The special sauce. This can be considered AA, there’s no real rules about lineups , however I think most of us notice this isn’t much more than a cash in.
I never understand that criticism. A cash in? Its literally THEIR music. I say make all the money you can off your intellectual property. Milk it.
Oh yeah, beyond a cash grab, clearly!!
At the time I didn't think Johnny added much to the band tbh, but now I've heard what he's done with Bilmuri it literally sounds like what AA should have been, maybe he lacked confidence back then but I'm glad he's killing it now
Cover bands don’t have original band members. I know it’s not the same as before, but AA! Is still going, and it’s a good thing to see.
So many people hating in the comments 😂😂 the metal community is so feminine
Where is the crab? Where is the core?
Brazil please !
Mom: we have Attack Attack! at home.
Attack Attack at home:
Is that the Guitarist from Story of the Year?
From story of the montho
I’ll lever get tired of listening or playing this song
Forgot the intro's title. What was it?
is this what 2022 stage performaces look like dam
Lmao guy from the crowd screams better than Chris 🤣
They need a live synth player or it won’t ever be the same
project nightfall singing?
0:42 Domhnall Gleeson on the left
Dude couldn't even scream the jntro 😂😂
bassist that was touring with traitors for a bit ?
So how many of them are original members? It’s just seems like a puzzle that’s too hard so you force them pieces together out of frustration
Wtf I don’t recognize any of them. Who are they?
How can they even keep the name???
Bc of the founding members Andrew lead guitarist and Andrew the drummer
0:19 Catfish Soup!
There isn’t an original member left
Lars wants his St. Anger snare back.
Not feelin this lead vocalist. No stamina. No vocal dynamics or range to screams. Presence was WEAK.
Hey man he’s just starting out thing will pick up one step at a time
You're weak
He doesn’t have to be great the song is great and ppl gonna make it a fun time
But I get you🙏
Is this bad worth it to see if I'm showing up for Eskimo callboy? Never heard of them.
with the line up, no
Where crab moves?
Who are these people? I don’t recognize anyone. Lol