Which Racing Game has the best Sound?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 июл 2024
  • Special thanks to "FRENCHY" for the Forza 7 footage.
    So, let's avoid the stupid war between fanboys and let's discover together which game has the most accurate engine sounds!
    I've passed 4 days on internet watching a lot of videos about real car sounds. I accuarately selected the videos with the best sounds: HD, less muffed as possible, clear, less wind noise, less distorted as possible.
    Of course, in some cases they can't exactly replicate the HD microphones used for the engine recordings, but if you watch the video, you'll notice some racing game sounds are exactly the same!
    Trying to evaluate sounds in racing game it's obviously subjective, but I've been UNBIASED to give you my honest opinion about them.
    I rate the sound according on how close is it compared to the real sound.
    Gran Turismo got the bad sound reputation during theses years with the previous chapters. But GT Sport was a real improvement in this aspect, even if it still got the LOWEST rating for the OUTSIDE sounds at the end of the video. But concerning the INSIDE cockpit sounds, honestly Polyphony did a good job.
    About Project CARS 2, I think the main problem is the high notes are too high, "destroying" the clear sound of the car. Moreover, some sounds are recycled: for example the Porsche Carrera GT and the Lamborghini Huracan have the same sound in PC2. And it's a shame, because as you saw the Aston Martin in this video has the best sound.
    About Forza Motorsport, sounds are quite average. Some of them are realistic, others are more "synthetic". Some fans of the series complained about a lower sound quality compared to the previous chapters.
    About Assetto Corsa, inside cockpit sound are the TOP. But cornerning the outside sounds, it has bad and good sounds, so quality is quite inconsistent in my opinion. Most of AC outside sounds are recorded from static position, and in some cases they aren't good. But overall, I think AC has good sounds.
    About Dirt Rally 2.0, it wins this challenge, especially for the outside sounds. Almost all engines sound realistic, not distorted or muffed. The real counterparts are perfectly recorded and integrated.
    Anyway, I hope you'll appreciate the effort I put into this. :-)
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 894

  • @Batooony
    @Batooony 4 года назад +391

    I feel engine sounds in games/sims are to clean. I mean they might sound loud and brutal but they lack those dirty, metallic sounds of real race cars.

    • @xlays1934
      @xlays1934 4 года назад +4

      Forza motorsport 7 has that sound in some racing cars but in the interior not the exterior

    • @user-rt2zq4jv8x
      @user-rt2zq4jv8x 3 года назад +2

      Tire sound in most games not existed at all.

    • @allevosyndicate2475
      @allevosyndicate2475 3 года назад

      Amen

    • @ItsATrap614
      @ItsATrap614 2 года назад

      check out RaceRoom sounds, it does exactly what you described
      ruclips.net/video/Oq1D7c7w33M/видео.html

    • @darodism
      @darodism 2 года назад

      BRUH. EXACTLY what i just posted.
      It needs to be unique, it needs raw sound, creativity, interpretation etc etc.
      This shit sounds terrible

  • @eloiaragonesrius1789
    @eloiaragonesrius1789 5 лет назад +430

    6:53 "do a barrel roll"

    • @Redlineshadow29
      @Redlineshadow29 5 лет назад +1

      Holly Shit that bad ass barrel rol

    • @ohthatplaneguy9347
      @ohthatplaneguy9347 4 года назад +2

      Eloi Aragonès Rius SAMIR YOU ARE BREAKING THE CAR

    • @justherebro
      @justherebro 3 года назад +1

      Star fox

    • @magical5181
      @magical5181 3 года назад

      “5 right, into barrel roll” 😂👍

    • @k.r.99
      @k.r.99 4 месяца назад

      Scandinavian flick

  • @artemiris6708
    @artemiris6708 5 лет назад +686

    6:52 this is fine

    • @treerexaudi
      @treerexaudi 5 лет назад +8

      what in the world

    • @astronaut6418
      @astronaut6418 5 лет назад +8

      About to write it but you were faster

    • @abyssoulzenith
      @abyssoulzenith 5 лет назад +41

      Do a barrel roll

    • @_nicolasayala
      @_nicolasayala 5 лет назад +14

      lol like nothing was happened. Imagine seeing that in rl

    • @codyrap95
      @codyrap95 5 лет назад +1

      Realism FTW 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @LorikQuinn
    @LorikQuinn 5 лет назад +617

    Project Cars sounds are engineered to make you go deaf

    • @deltazero3796
      @deltazero3796 5 лет назад +7

      Totally.

    • @guily6669
      @guily6669 5 лет назад +50

      Real life is the one that is engineered to make you go deaf... It sounds so much more powerful than any record and FAR, FAR from any game, when the Porsche GT3 passed by here on the Rally jeez, even my ears bleed lol what a huge POWERFUL sound specially at just inches from it since I was a road commissionaire or whatever its called for the rally so I was just at the edge of the track.

    • @LorikQuinn
      @LorikQuinn 5 лет назад +19

      @@guily6669 I really appreciate the realism the game tries to emulate, but I don't think that's the wisest choice when it comes to gameplay, since beginner players/casual players can easily get a headache while racing

    • @michaelagustinsantos3015
      @michaelagustinsantos3015 5 лет назад +33

      Pedro Barcellos
      "Let's make the sounds super realistic!"
      "This is perfect. But do you want realistic or super realistic?"
      "All the way brother."

    • @casscroute8706
      @casscroute8706 5 лет назад +2

      Project cars is a really good game but the sounds ruin it

  • @cironicola2141
    @cironicola2141 5 лет назад +324

    I think that Dirt Rally deserves both a 10/10 for that Audi Quattro sounds, for me they are on point no doubt

    • @Cafferssss
      @Cafferssss 5 лет назад +14

      Totally.

    • @lockettlv
      @lockettlv 5 лет назад +28

      Agreed, codemasters know how to make good engine sounds

    • @ThePower1037
      @ThePower1037 2 года назад +1

      I too agree!

    • @dadokajic
      @dadokajic 2 года назад +2

      just lacks better turbo sounds

  • @JumbleDrops
    @JumbleDrops 5 лет назад +355

    But i will say, the studios use HD microphones to record audio, and those vids have mid tier mics. Just sayin

    • @emreozdemirgale
      @emreozdemirgale 5 лет назад +64

      Also, testing environmentn and acoustics plays a huge, HUGE role.

    • @caerphoto
      @caerphoto 5 лет назад +45

      The exterior videos are also mostly trackside, so there's a bunch of doppler effects and reverb from the scenery affecting the sound, compared to the chase-cams used in-game.

    • @JZStudiosonline
      @JZStudiosonline 5 лет назад +31

      They aren't even mid-tier. It's literally a go-pro. At best it has a dead cat on it, but based on all the wind noise I'd say no. Makes the GT86 sound like a fart can.

    • @AdrianOkay
      @AdrianOkay 5 лет назад +3

      MID TIER?????? THEY LOOK LIKE THEY ARE HANDMADE MICS

    • @GrimZJako
      @GrimZJako 5 лет назад +5

      Also.. In PC2.. He used a Cabrio 458 and as the Real it was Hard Top.. 4/10 for inside sound. Like wow.

  • @josef733
    @josef733 5 лет назад +237

    Gran Turismo has come some way from its Vacuum days of GT5

    • @teslaboi1822
      @teslaboi1822 5 лет назад +38

      GT1-GT6 are vacuum GTs. But there are very limited cars that actually sound real during those times. The 787B, LFA, Gallardo LP 560-4, more.

    • @tacoengineer6660
      @tacoengineer6660 5 лет назад +17

      @@teslaboi1822 The Viper sounds very real in GT4. In GT5 it sounds like a 4 cylinder

    • @f.hegerfeldt128
      @f.hegerfeldt128 5 лет назад +4

      @@teslaboi1822 well if you can make realistic sounds withe PS1 Hardware.

    • @teslaboi1822
      @teslaboi1822 5 лет назад

      @@tacoengineer6660 yes. The SRT-10 '03 sounds like or almost the real thing.

    • @Hanschepu
      @Hanschepu 4 года назад

      @@teslaboi1822 gt1 had some great sounds, specially turbo sounds.. quite better than gt3, 4 and 5

  • @rianheroking
    @rianheroking 5 лет назад +51

    Notes: Gt5 and Gt6 has your own unique sound for every car, but if you mod the exhaust, the sound really looks a vacuum cleaner.

    • @cjwavy3929
      @cjwavy3929 5 лет назад +1

      HerokingLKT well at least technology has advanced

    • @rianheroking
      @rianheroking 5 лет назад +1

      @@cjwavy3929 true.

    • @D_LGND
      @D_LGND 2 года назад +1

      I thought the racing exhaust for the McLaren MP4-12C in GT5 was bad but when I attached it in GT6…

  • @Trojan20WWA
    @Trojan20WWA 5 лет назад +27

    Im 2 Subarus owner. Dirt Rally is when you want to hear subaru sound.

  • @gianlucatravaglia11
    @gianlucatravaglia11 5 лет назад +207

    And the people that do the sound file for project cars are deaf

    • @retardedpepega8831
      @retardedpepega8831 5 лет назад +11

      PC2 put Huracan sound into Carrera. They deserve to be last.

    • @Haltzo
      @Haltzo 5 лет назад

      @@retardedpepega8831 exactly

    • @galia2843
      @galia2843 5 лет назад +21

      @@retardedpepega8831 Don't forget about the fanboys defending it...
      iTs A v10 ThEy AlL sOuNd ThE sAmE XD

    • @casscroute8706
      @casscroute8706 5 лет назад +1

      @@galia2843 lmao facts

    • @galia2843
      @galia2843 5 лет назад +5

      @@casscroute8706 I know right? PC2 is by far not a bad game but it's average simcade at best. With Rallycross which doesn't even have proper physics, but... yeah. Average.

  • @VoidSixx
    @VoidSixx 5 лет назад +49

    Anyone who can't recognise that Codemasters has been lightyears ahead in the sound game at least since GRID 2 is genuinely deaf.

    • @Butterx22
      @Butterx22 5 лет назад +5

      And their 'Toca Race Driver 3'.

    • @marceloalbuja
      @marceloalbuja 4 года назад +7

      Absolutely, i still love to play Grid Autosport on my phone because the sounds are shockingly good

    • @legm5298
      @legm5298 3 года назад

      Agreed

  • @justinl2009
    @justinl2009 5 лет назад +28

    Anything from Codemasters usually sound pretty good.

  • @prowarrior0155
    @prowarrior0155 5 лет назад +5

    Good video. I can see a huge amount of effort was put into this! 💯%.

  • @sick_d_cars_and_pommes7562
    @sick_d_cars_and_pommes7562 5 лет назад +46

    i really dont understand why you Rate the Outside sounds in Assetto Corsa for the 458 and the quattro so bad... they sound nearly as original ..?

  • @leov4751
    @leov4751 5 лет назад +4

    There's a lot to say about comparing sounds, but I tend to agree with your scores.
    Very brave to post this, I'm assuming there will be a huuge discussion :-)

  • @beatlestaute221
    @beatlestaute221 5 лет назад +95

    6:53 show off
    How did that happen tho
    Edit: with your racing guides (I’m talking about the attack/defence ones) how can I practice this, what if I’m by myself

    • @cjwavy3929
      @cjwavy3929 5 лет назад +2

      Luck

    • @MrCasebi
      @MrCasebi 5 лет назад +3

      It's a classic Dirt Rally technique that existed in the first game as well. It's called being God of luck. It happened to me playing the first game while driving the old WRX

    • @legm5298
      @legm5298 3 года назад

      @@cjwavy3929 PLUCK

  • @f45tT4g
    @f45tT4g 5 лет назад +14

    7:56 Made me check, "Who's messaging me in steam?"

  • @marceloalbuja
    @marceloalbuja 4 года назад +20

    I think the shifts are something really important to the sound immersion; and many developers neglect that
    Unpopular opinion(?)

  • @theofilosgrigoriadis9840
    @theofilosgrigoriadis9840 5 лет назад +73

    The speciale you used in PC2 for the inside sound is a convertible one and the sound of the real one is not. So the sound would definitely be different. Or I'm completely wrong 😂

    • @lalxl
      @lalxl 5 лет назад +5

      You're not wrong. I thought the same thing

    • @chrissss696
      @chrissss696 5 лет назад +3

      Nope, the tone in PCars 2 is totally different, it doesn't change that much with the roof open/closed

    • @koukous95
      @koukous95 5 лет назад +6

      @@chrissss696 It will definitly change!
      they didn't get it that good but it was a little close to the real one, but it's a convertible like compared with a non-convertible one xD

    • @chrissss696
      @chrissss696 5 лет назад +2

      No no no, it's too high pitched, having the roof open increases the volume, reduces the muffled effect but doesn't increase the pitch

    • @justsomeguy6060
      @justsomeguy6060 2 года назад

      Plus different times of the day. Differences in temperature in real, life alter the speed of sound. And also what kind of environment you're driving in. So yeah, that might also affect the quality of sound.

  • @fphilip01
    @fphilip01 5 лет назад +1

    Man, that took a lot of effort and thank you!

  • @wheelspin6178
    @wheelspin6178 5 лет назад +68

    6.5/10 for Assetto Corsa’s 458, are you high? They were practically identical!

    • @mahlenbiznes3419
      @mahlenbiznes3419 5 лет назад +19

      The interior is a 9.5/10 at the very least, same goes for the Audi quattro interior.

    • @pegador6
      @pegador6 4 года назад

      Same for gt sports outside sound for a110

    • @pegador6
      @pegador6 4 года назад

      @@mahlenbiznes3419 you mean 8

    • @santir3690
      @santir3690 4 года назад

      Think he's deaf un one ear lol

  • @rtx_____
    @rtx_____ 5 лет назад +61

    Assetto Corsa definetly scores higher than whats given in this comparison, for example the 458 outside sound in AC sounds nearly identical to the real life counterpart.
    IMO Assetto and Driveclub are at the top in terms of sound design

    • @projectr2451
      @projectr2451 5 лет назад +4

      I think Gran Turismo Sport wins for the 458 Italia. Here’s a better video because this has a camera on the car in real life, here the real life video is a flyby so it’s not reliable and he should’ve used a replay view for the flybys.
      ruclips.net/video/uJ0knCvlzBU/видео.html

    • @edgiebraahhh7280
      @edgiebraahhh7280 5 лет назад +1

      Have you tried Raceroom? By far the best

    • @marcellogiovannini9072
      @marcellogiovannini9072 4 года назад +2

      Also NFS has some nice sounding cars

    • @fanaticofmetal
      @fanaticofmetal 2 года назад

      Driveclub sounds are nothing like real life, they all sound like if you were inside a tunnel, meanwhile AC has muffled and bad recorded sounds, althought they are very realistic, far better on interior, same in Driveclub

  • @LNM822
    @LNM822 5 лет назад +93

    I think the assetto corsa 458 sound is a 10

    • @carl.2868
      @carl.2868 5 лет назад +1

      Versus 194 me too

    • @lonedri2890
      @lonedri2890 5 лет назад +3

      not really... because in the video it's inside a building... the 458 in assetto corsa resound too much

    • @cjwavy3929
      @cjwavy3929 5 лет назад +1

      Columb_art he just said he think

    • @chrissss696
      @chrissss696 5 лет назад +8

      I think outside sounds were recorded from a stationary position on a racetrack, that's why it resoinds so much. Inside sounds are mostly spot on

    • @Zack-qr3py
      @Zack-qr3py 5 лет назад +1

      same

  • @nikosator
    @nikosator 5 лет назад +58

    i just feel like the creators of the soundfiles for most racing games just forget to put suficent amounts of bass in them. like the the 86 in the beginning, sound have a little more rumble not much but a little the alpine 2, make it fill the headset or room if ur using speakers with sound, so it sounds like you are at a race track, maybe not as loud as one but the rumblimg atleast. like if a v10 super car passes you a low speed u hear that deep rumble. ok now im just ramblimg so im gonna stop it here. if any car sound file creators are watching this pls use jut a little more bass, :D

    • @hakim10080
      @hakim10080 5 лет назад +6

      It's like they all have shitty sound systems and don't seem to understand the benefit of a well balanced sound, it doesn't need to be overly loud. I agree that most sounds in these games have a bias towards highs, sometimes mids, but never fully employ the low end, which makes lots of engines lose their character

    • @HeroManNick132
      @HeroManNick132 5 лет назад

      NFS is arcade game but it get mostly the sound right

    • @nikosator
      @nikosator 5 лет назад +1

      @@hakim10080 good point there. maybe the sounds guys got a budget cut everytime and they get some shitty old microsoft headsets. those super tiny ones XD. the audiophile grade headset i have atm really gets all the sounds in. and somtimes i just feel like dying after hearing some of the sounds and then what car it is. its horrible.

    • @richardmatthews244
      @richardmatthews244 5 лет назад +1

      nikosator I was thinking exactly the same about the lack of bass. I have done some sound mods for GTR2 and GT legends, it seems most makers of racing sims regard the sounds of the cars as an afterthought. I'm sure most people could modify these sounds to make them better if they had the right software

    • @dvdbox360
      @dvdbox360 5 лет назад

      Should've used heavy metal equalizer sound with bass boost instead

  • @mondodimotori
    @mondodimotori 5 лет назад +6

    That real interior sound of the Impreza sounded like, in the beginning, like an MG-42.
    LOL.

    • @nitro8718
      @nitro8718 3 года назад +1

      Haha german go nyoooom

  • @captainleam4031
    @captainleam4031 5 лет назад +8

    Theses cars are pretty famous, this test basically tells us that assetto gets everything right. I wonder though what if you tried with less known cars like the Renault Mégane (i think its in GT Sport and Forza and i know its in PC2) in older gran turismo games you could really hear the vaccum cleaner sound on theses sorts of road cars.
    Still this test is pretty interesting, i thought GT Sport and Forza were going to be miles away from sims like assetto or PC2, but apparently PC2 doesnt really care about car sounds and Forza and GT Sport are not that far of, that's good to know thank you for making this !

    • @ZunaZurugi
      @ZunaZurugi 2 года назад

      Forza 7 has sadly the worst sound design of any Forza game. Forza 2-6 was pretty much on point.

  • @PaneledPear
    @PaneledPear 5 лет назад +47

    You should have got somebody to record Forza Motorsport 4 footage! Most people consider that game to be basically perfect in terms of engine notes.

    • @Adam63545
      @Adam63545 4 года назад +6

      PaneledPear6555 Too bad that game is ancient history

    • @joostinatortje
      @joostinatortje 3 года назад +1

      I still have Forza Motorsport 4. But no, compared to Forza Motorsports 2, the sound made a big downgrade in 4.
      Yes, there are additional detailed sounds from exhaust pops and transmission whines in Forza 4, but the sounds of the engines themselves was by far the best in Forza Motorsport 2. Also know that exhaust upgrades in Forza 2 had their own separate audio files. So the sound of the car would not just get amplified and less muffled when upgrading an exhaust, it would literally be a recording of an engine with an upgraded exhaust. This made it sound much more realistic.

    • @PaneledPear
      @PaneledPear 3 года назад

      @@joostinatortje It really depends on the vehicle. I think overall Forza Motorsport 4 had more accurate, higher quality engine notes, but the number of vehicles may have degraded the quality of certain examples from Forza Motorsport 2 and Forza Motorsport 3. Still, I think overall it has the best engine sounds of any game.
      Them neutering upgraded sounds though was kind of unfortunate. At least we're seeing that in Forza Horizon 5 which sounds fairly solid so far.

    • @joostinatortje
      @joostinatortje 3 года назад

      @@PaneledPear do you have more information on how Horizon 5 is comparing to Horizon 4 regarding car sounds?
      btw if you want really realistic sounds: Assetto Corsa is the most realistic that I have experienced so far. Im not saying all cars have the most realistic sounds as there is quite some variation in quality between cars, but overall it's really realistic in terms of internal car sounds and car sounds from external tv camera's etc.

    • @PaneledPear
      @PaneledPear 3 года назад

      @@joostinatortje Besides that Playground games sound preview video, the stream they did, and a bunch of comparisons between the sounds shown so far and Forza Horizon 4, nah. That video though did show a massive improvement and I can only hope most other cars live up to that.
      Assetto Corsa has a couple of very accurate engine notes and solid cockpit audio simulation, but it's the shift sounds that kind of kill it for me. Shifting up especially sounds extremely unrealistic. If that was fixed, then some cars would sound amazing in that game. Assetto Corsa Competizione doesn't have that issue, but you're basically limited to a couple race spec vehicles, of course. I think that game sounds incredible though.

  • @jiska111111111111111
    @jiska111111111111111 5 лет назад +14

    Asetto P1 gtr 10/10??
    Was like really sound clips cut from recordings and pasted straight in the game xD

  • @GUIZEX000
    @GUIZEX000 5 лет назад +2

    Hello Viperconcept, my name is Daniel. I see almost always that I can your videos and I admire your work a lot, your videos are great and you play very well, congratulations for your excellent performance in all games and for your great charisma in your videos.

  • @ragingsky1401
    @ragingsky1401 5 лет назад +1

    cool but i wonder why did u not do the outside sounds from the replays? (like real videos)

  • @seanbrady400
    @seanbrady400 5 лет назад

    can i ask a question did you race in gt online against lime better and anthony paris please reply i need to know

  • @chiefmaker465
    @chiefmaker465 5 лет назад +2

    In Forza Motorsport 2, when you upgrade your car with a race exhaust, it actually changes the sound. This was back in 2007, and I'm not sure if Forza has implemented it in a game since. Anyway, another great video viper :)

    • @chrissss696
      @chrissss696 5 лет назад

      Oh yes, sound changes quite a lot in some cars when using a race exhaust

  • @theitalianjojo3440
    @theitalianjojo3440 5 лет назад +17

    6:52 "Do a barrel roll!"

  • @davidwright1605
    @davidwright1605 5 лет назад +14

    My conclusion. The sounds on these games are not that different to each other and although your reference "real" sounds were dreadful in a number of cases, the games do sound like the real thing.

  • @gonwp9856
    @gonwp9856 5 лет назад +1

    I think that the fact of the P1 going away in the real clip changes the way you listen to it, so maybe I'd change some marks, but was a really good video

  • @Cafferssss
    @Cafferssss 5 лет назад +21

    Best sounding game for me is dr2. 0
    The rwd historics sound amazing. And so do the group b cars. The delta s4 is brain shattering nice.

  • @Adam63545
    @Adam63545 4 года назад +13

    Remember when people just played racing games for fun rather than over obsessing the car sounds? Yeah me neither

    • @lethalpenguin61
      @lethalpenguin61 4 года назад +3

      Adam yeah because the sounds used to be good. They cut corners nowadays and it shows big time

  • @jiska111111111111111
    @jiska111111111111111 5 лет назад +3

    That first clip is a GoPro and directly above exhasut. That sounds really different

  • @papapalpatine5735
    @papapalpatine5735 5 лет назад +4

    I still think the Alpine A110-50 from DriveClub is the most ear splitting (yet lovely) sound I've ever heard from the games I've played

  • @Qimchiy
    @Qimchiy 5 лет назад +37

    Put Driveclub in this. Most of the time it'll score more than 7

    • @LITTEULCEVENN
      @LITTEULCEVENN 5 лет назад +3

      Yes please add Driveclub. Some of the recordings they made were actually kept by some companies (Mercedes for example) because of their quality and accuracy.

    • @Qimchiy
      @Qimchiy 5 лет назад +17

      @Gibbon Oh I forgot Forza 7 is totally not arcade. Totally not just talking about sound and not physics.

    • @lilquincy6292
      @lilquincy6292 5 лет назад

      @Gibbon for sounds

    • @rtx_____
      @rtx_____ 5 лет назад

      Gibbon why hating? Why being such a pain in the ass

    • @Manuel-zc7po
      @Manuel-zc7po 3 года назад

      This channel is about Sim racing, no full arcades and shitty games

  • @allthehandlesweretaken
    @allthehandlesweretaken 5 лет назад +5

    13:55 they sound way diffrent when the interior is stripped and fitted with a roll cage, not sure that is a fair comparrison :/

  • @Hzuuuu
    @Hzuuuu 5 лет назад +8

    No RaceRoom Racing Experience? That game, by far, have the best sound of all.

  • @Kimx922
    @Kimx922 2 года назад

    Wow nice intro clip, I got some nostalgia from that xD

  • @fontheking5
    @fontheking5 2 года назад +1

    Actually the the EJ22 engine was not used in the Group A rally Imprezas shown in the clip, they always used the 2 liter EJ20 to comply with the rules. The 22B used the 2,2 liter EJ22 engine, but not the rally-cars. The exhaust rumble you hear in the real sound clip is due to the unequal lenght exhaust headers which gives a lovely boxer rumble, this design was used on the Legacy RS Group A rally car from 1990-1993 and the Impreza 555 Group A car from 1993-1996, then in 1997, the new " World rally car " rules came into play, which allowed more freedom, and Subaru designed their stunning looking 2-door Impreza WRC for these new rules, and installed equal length headers on it, thereby changing the sound to a more flat sounding noise, and between 1997-2008, all Wrc Imprezas had equal length headers, Dirt rally 2.0 did a really good job with both the Group A Subarus and the later Wrc Subarus, the difference is clear to hear. The Subaru road cars still used the unequal length headers, so the 22B uses them in stock trim, hence they sound mote alike the Group A Subarus, than the Wrc Imprezas.
    The 22B was a special road car based on the 2-door Wrc car bodyshell, and it arrived in 1998 as a homage to the wrc cars.

  • @TO__FU
    @TO__FU 5 лет назад +2

    From vacuum cleaners, blenders and lawnmowers to some pretty accurate sounds.

  • @pietrosal9629
    @pietrosal9629 4 года назад

    Awsome video🔥🔥🔥

  • @Santi-mx3hv
    @Santi-mx3hv 5 лет назад

    Another great video from you

  • @castin5244
    @castin5244 5 лет назад +4

    GT Sport goes for a stock engine sound
    Forza goes for a straight piped sound
    and Assetto Corsa and Project cars are somewhere in the middle.

  • @AdamsAppleseed
    @AdamsAppleseed 5 лет назад +7

    Im just not sure about the validity of many of the recorded interior, and even exterior, sounds. I feel like the cameras recording could be toning down the real sound of the cars. Maybe its just me though.

    • @boppe2235
      @boppe2235 5 лет назад

      Yeah, especially on the GT86.

  • @wdowa94
    @wdowa94 2 года назад +1

    IMHO Codemasters nailed every car sound outside. And that doppler effect out of every object! In cab sounds are very good too beause of that resonance filter and a bit of reverb

  • @Smoky232
    @Smoky232 5 лет назад +2

    From what game are the sound effects and the music in the intro? I know them so well and brings back memories but I forgot which game its actually is... Can anybody help me? 😄

    • @Kurosaki_Dan
      @Kurosaki_Dan 5 лет назад

      Is the soundtrack of the Demo 1, a demo disc that was sold with the PSX back in the day!
      Vid: ruclips.net/video/KVQq6lYWII4/видео.html

  • @renangoncalvesflores
    @renangoncalvesflores 5 лет назад +1

    Nice.
    You should rename the name of this video to "Which racing game has the best ENGINE sound". Also I miss RaceRoom Experience in this list. I don't play this game, but it has one of the best overall sounds in racing games (I'm not certain about the engine sound thou).

  • @Cris_86
    @Cris_86 5 лет назад +1

    Wow!, that starting menu sound are from the N°1 demo disco for the first Playstation 👌

  • @mikereyes2488
    @mikereyes2488 5 лет назад +1

    The drive away videos are kinda hard to judge, unless you recreated the game version in replay mode of selected car driving by in comparison to real video so they can match distance/sound, idk that what I would have done. other than, that was an awesome video

  • @rxiden7167
    @rxiden7167 5 лет назад +14

    5:08 hold up. Something seems suspicious hmmmmm. I thought youre reviewing a toyota 86 😂

    • @elvitu8038
      @elvitu8038 4 года назад +4

      They're basically the same model so...

    • @ZeldaACFan17
      @ZeldaACFan17 4 года назад +6

      Subaru and Toyota made the BRZ/86 together. They are essentially the same car with a few tweaks to the body and badges.

    • @elvitu8038
      @elvitu8038 4 года назад

      @@ZeldaACFan17 exactly. Sone people think they are different just because of the badges.

  • @Zakkura
    @Zakkura 4 года назад

    I wonder if these games use a 3d binural microphone when they record the in car sounds

  • @adaptivehackerkhan
    @adaptivehackerkhan Год назад

    what's that constant aeroplane sound in Assetto Corsa external view? Anyone else hearing that "dry" terrible sound? It kinda sounds like that old Racer pc game, I think it was renamed Dolphinity.

  • @Night-Tid3
    @Night-Tid3 4 года назад

    We need more this kind of comparison with real sounds so we can actually compare how accurate it is.

  • @OcmeoXoHgPo3
    @OcmeoXoHgPo3 5 лет назад +1

    Driveclub has surprised me nice with its sound few years ago.. it was something fresh after many games. I've never heard its real cars, but I really enjoyed virtual engine sounds in my headphones - that's the only rule that really something mean for me.

    • @trievoluzione8868
      @trievoluzione8868 5 лет назад

      most wanted 2012 also had good car sounds you should hear how the lfa sounds in that game! sadly driveclub servers are shutting down :(

    • @OcmeoXoHgPo3
      @OcmeoXoHgPo3 5 лет назад

      @@trievoluzione8868 NFS series is out of my interest since Carbon and Undercover. Its pain to play for me.

    • @fanaticofmetal
      @fanaticofmetal 2 года назад

      The sounds are very realistic but way too muffled and tunnel-sounding

  • @nenapse7750
    @nenapse7750 5 лет назад

    I only can say that I fully agree. Thx for the effort done.

  • @minners71
    @minners71 5 лет назад

    Do you have psvr as the cars sound so much more meaty when playing gt sport in vr.

  • @DennyNFT
    @DennyNFT 4 года назад

    That fucking into brought me back

  • @jormateras3073
    @jormateras3073 5 лет назад

    Hearing how the 458 sounds like in GT Sport I'm amazed how accurate it was in GT6 with the stock exhaust. Worth checking that out.

  • @Schnitzelwario
    @Schnitzelwario 5 лет назад +13

    GTR2 is still the benchmark.

    • @ZetaRidge7
      @ZetaRidge7 5 лет назад +1

      GTR2 is a 2006 PC racing sim game and still has amazing engine sounds for the most part, especially the BMW E46 M3 GTR and cars like the Ferrari 550 GT1 and Lister Storm. =)

  • @santiagoibarra1137
    @santiagoibarra1137 5 лет назад

    Hey Viperconcept you should do a video explaining how does the downshifting "rhythm" affects the speed in the begining of a corner

  • @Trid3nt861
    @Trid3nt861 3 года назад +1

    Wow... in GT Sport they were able to afford and upgrade to the new Dyson models.... Impressive.

  • @stupidstormy36
    @stupidstormy36 5 лет назад +6

    Things to keep in mind.
    -The footage of the real car sounds are of lower quality than what you may hear in game, interior and/or exterior. This will also affect the dynamic range of the audio, leading to false differences.
    -The positioning of the camera can affect the quality as well.
    -Certain sounds are absent from the interior cam, such as wind resistance, chassis rattle, etc., real or game.
    -Certain sounds are absent from the exterior cam, such as superchargers, turbo chargers, etc., real or game.
    -The location as to where the audio (environmentally) was recorded can affect the acoustics of the audio.
    -Exterior shot are usually track side. This means certain aspects such as the Doppler Effect is absent in the exterior shot of the in game shots.
    -This topic will always be objective. Everyone's opinion will differ in one way or another.
    My results:
    Dirt Rally 2.0: Good all around. My only real complaint is the transmission whine.
    Forza Motorsport 7: A little over done in some places. Good environmental interactivity.
    Gran Turismo Sport: Has come a long way, but still needs improvement in certain areas. It does one thing the best in my opinion though. Environmental reverb in replays.
    Assetto Corsa: Great interior, weak exterior.
    Project Cars 2: The volume is just TOO DAMN LOUD!!! It sounds like some of the audio is peaking a bit.

  • @patrickbonfim3803
    @patrickbonfim3803 5 лет назад +1

    Forza 7 had a sound patch recently for +30 cars, but still need to improve a lot. If you want, I can record some videos for you, Viper.

  • @KristianLyubenovYT
    @KristianLyubenovYT 2 года назад +1

    you giving the ac brz a 8/10 for the outside sound is so peculiar to me, considering it sounded like a uel fa20 instead of a el fa20

  • @jacobgove6718
    @jacobgove6718 5 лет назад +1

    A lot of people complain about Project Cars and their love of really really loud cars, but honestly for some of the cars its realistic. Race cars are not quiet at all. But I'll agree with the fact that the 86 sounds way off.

  • @firstlastnamefirst1498
    @firstlastnamefirst1498 4 года назад

    I have yet to see a game capture that raw sketchy bouncy shifting

  • @TheRamdix
    @TheRamdix 5 лет назад +1

    did u used ratchet & clank song at the beginning?

  • @bokc_nonpopularsalt1011
    @bokc_nonpopularsalt1011 3 года назад

    Would like to see an updated version about this..

  • @vitty5995
    @vitty5995 5 лет назад

    Viper, alcuni dicevano che i suoni delle auto su driveclub erano buoni come la grafica e addirittura alcune case avevano aggiornato i loro archivi con i suoni registrati dal team di sviluppo del gioco. Lo puoi confermare?

  • @ernestochang1744
    @ernestochang1744 5 лет назад +1

    i think asetto corsa is a pretty good bet for not only sound but physics as well, its definetly one of the more refined simulators out there, and i think it would have won had it not been for dirt rally 2.0 having a vehicle that asetto corsa does not

  • @pipipupu1964
    @pipipupu1964 5 лет назад +47

    Project cars 2 gt86's sounds like takumi's AE86. AND Green gloves? Is that a keichi tsuchiya reference??

  • @benzene6598
    @benzene6598 5 лет назад +3

    Assetto Corsa delivers most of the time, some of the sounds in that game have great depth. If on pc though, you can take it up a notch and get the Fonsecker sound packs, the FXXK sound is the best I have ever heard.

  • @taarunjain6012
    @taarunjain6012 5 лет назад +3

    6:52 rather than sound I was shocked by that barrel roll though(sorry it's off topic 🤣)

  • @Alex-sy3ks
    @Alex-sy3ks 5 лет назад

    Hello! Dude, i really appreciate your work, talent and pacience. I'm a guy from Romania, with same story as you.
    I have a big potential for the racing games, but i can't afford a PC/Console and a steering wheel. What should i do?

    • @viperconcept
      @viperconcept  5 лет назад

      Have you tried to see some prices for an used console and steering wheel?

  • @xCynder
    @xCynder 5 лет назад +1

    The McLaren P1 GTR has the meanest sounding V8 I’ve heard in years. Oh the things I would do to even own one let alone drive one in reality

    • @xCynder
      @xCynder 5 лет назад +1

      Oh god don’t even get me started on how it sounds in Assetto Corsa

  • @xlays1934
    @xlays1934 4 года назад +1

    Its hard to recreate or record a boxer engine
    sound but dirt just nails it

  • @diszylam1018
    @diszylam1018 5 лет назад

    If you’re doing experiments like this you must have constants. Especially the 458 experiment when you didn’t specify if it was the speciale and when you used a dyno clip instead of the one you used before. I think this would help judgements be more accurate and believable

    • @viperconcept
      @viperconcept  5 лет назад

      The 458 accelerating on the track was a Speciale.
      The 458 on the dyno was a stock Italia.

  • @Drunken_Hamster
    @Drunken_Hamster 5 лет назад +1

    I have a serious question, though. Could you please add "sound" to your racing game chart? Or, at least an average sound rating 1-10 next to a given games' point on the graph?

  • @dairyfarmer77
    @dairyfarmer77 10 месяцев назад

    Wow your into sound brought me back so many memories.

  • @simonmartinezdamia2285
    @simonmartinezdamia2285 5 лет назад

    Why in racing games the inside camera car sounds like if the car had no glasses in the windows?

  • @BatuhanD.
    @BatuhanD. 5 лет назад +3

    9:19 go in replay mode and the sound will be fixed

  • @TheDragonfly256
    @TheDragonfly256 5 лет назад +1

    It is surreal hearing Gran turismo now, when I remember how 5 sounded...

    • @Starfire_Storm
      @Starfire_Storm 5 лет назад

      The outside sounds are still not that good, but the interior ones are very good

  • @MrNiceKnife
    @MrNiceKnife 5 лет назад +2

    All need more bass, especially inside.

  • @DJveyron5
    @DJveyron5 5 лет назад +1

    0:22 is that R&C soundtrack? because it sounds like it xD

  • @huskyluva2180
    @huskyluva2180 5 лет назад

    What is important between these comparisons is the fact that the games audio comes form high quality audio recording devices, the ones in the videos down the bottom left, are low quality

    • @viperconcept
      @viperconcept  5 лет назад

      They are the highest quality I found on interent.
      Read the description, please.

  • @vortifyne
    @vortifyne 5 лет назад +4

    Project Cars 2 F458 sound is super realistic, how is that a 4 and 6??

    • @lilquincy6292
      @lilquincy6292 5 лет назад +1

      No it doesn't

    • @georgejakob1451
      @georgejakob1451 5 лет назад +1

      nop its not i can here a murcielago when it hits high revs😂

    • @aaronrojo636
      @aaronrojo636 5 лет назад

      You better be joking, or deaf

  • @iGearhead
    @iGearhead 5 лет назад +3

    There are few arcades worth mentioning. My favorite sounding game of them all without doubt is NFS 2010. Hands down, no competition.

    • @fanaticofmetal
      @fanaticofmetal 2 года назад

      The best NFS game in sounds is absolutely MW 2012, every car sounds just like real life

  • @johnli8471
    @johnli8471 5 лет назад +10

    I was hoping to see raceroom but sadly it's not a popular racing game.

    • @TheDownloader86
      @TheDownloader86 5 лет назад +2

      No laser scanned tracks only nordschleife and the game looks really, really outdated. And the system of buying cars and tracks via external shops - VRP, real money... FFS.

    • @shinryohji
      @shinryohji 5 лет назад +1

      @@TheDownloader86 Beside, it is not available on consoles.

  • @TheRobphobos
    @TheRobphobos 5 лет назад +1

    Most of them don't have proper ambient sound (ie, cabin or outside environment reaction), and seem to lack low end too. For me that's a key factor that's largely missing.
    Obviously the mic's are all different but they could still get impulse responses from the cabins and tracks at various parts to give it a better 'feel'. DR2 does a pretty good job!

    • @soundfx68
      @soundfx68 4 года назад

      Dirt Rally does that "impulse responses from the cabins". But it's generic. Nice to read an informed comment.

  • @TNTMatiStudio
    @TNTMatiStudio 5 лет назад

    Why don't you use Rfactor2/iracing in your videos?

  • @andreachinaglia462
    @andreachinaglia462 5 лет назад

    What videogame from the song of the intro??

  • @dGCyanide49
    @dGCyanide49 5 лет назад +1

    Problem I find is that camera quality, position and also acoustics play a huge part in the real life footage.

  • @lilithlianshi2094
    @lilithlianshi2094 5 лет назад +10

    you know what game that nailed every car sound in their game ? NFS mostwanted 2012

  • @DoomTrooperTV
    @DoomTrooperTV 26 дней назад

    This is indeed a niche video but I'm SO glad you made it

  • @nicorosbergfan6753
    @nicorosbergfan6753 5 лет назад +17

    One of the best realistic sounds in PC2 is the Sauber C9

    • @rtx_____
      @rtx_____ 5 лет назад

      As well as the huracan, it sounds exactly the same in pc2 as in brooks huracan vs svj video