MLP Theory - Applejack's Parents' Cutie Marks Were Not Apple-Related
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 окт 2024
- Patreon link: biturl.im/POw3o
Lauren Faust's FAQ on her Deviant Art page:
fyre-flye.devia...
1st Picture of Applejack's parents was drawn by Lopoddity and can be found here:
lopoddity.devia...
2nd Picture of Applejack's parents was drawn by LugiaAngel and can be found here:
lugiaangel.devi...
Moliminous' Video "[MLP] Apple Bloom Is Applejack's Daughter?" can be found here: biturl.im/oOXAm
DISCLAIMER: I AM NOT AFFILIATED WITH HASBRO IN ANYWAY, AND DO NOT OWN MY LITTLE PONY: FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC.
With Season 7 Episode 13, your theory is half correct.
Yung Houn exactly.... and their families are two fruits, one being an APPLE
So, its entirely proven false they're travelers, unless its to family reunions.....
They could have died from timber wolves on the way home from a reunion one night.....
They meant the cutie mark thing
Your right
I was thinking that.
Literally!
As adult Spike says in the last episode, "Well, you're half right."
Ironically he was right because in season 7 episode 13 since the mom had a 🍐 cutie mark so good guess dude 👍 up 😎
It was a jar of pear butter, easily mistaken for apple butter or some other jam/jelly/preserves.
Only half right because their dad has an apple
That may also explain why Applejack's both aunt and uncle are Oranges. The Wikia said they're also Babs Seed's aunt & uncle so someone from the Apple family must have married one from the Orange family.
Same for how the Apple and Pinkie Pie's family are related.
You are right about Applejack's mother being a non-apple. As for explorers, that topic is very much true for Scootaloo's parents, as she is often looked after by her aunts and other ponies in Ponyville.
Actually, Big Jim mentioned that the reason they weren't present in where the apple lies is because they were on vacation. Which is around the time Apple Bloom was conceived. So once they got back, they must have announced her mom was pregnant. Also, around the time Filthy Rich and Spoiler milk must have got married and could have conceived Diamond Tiara later on. After she was born, some speculate that that's when her parents died. Which is why they weren't seen in any of her baby pictures. This would also explain why we didn't see Apple bloom in Applejack's cutie mark flashback cause she wasn't born yet.
This will prove you wrong when we see that episode "Going to Seed", Bright Mac and Pear Butter were ALIVE when Apple Bloom was still newly born. But after that episode we get no mention anymore of BM and PB. And this also the same time where Apple Jack and Big Mac are younger, like in "Where the Apple Lies".
ruclips.net/video/wxW_DY9a0H8/видео.html
OK apparently Big Mac was younger than I thought in this episode than versus Where the Apple Lies, he's a colt still, Applejack being a much younger filly, and Apple Bloom being a newborn filly. My bad
Yeah you're probably right
I'm supposed to have an apple cutie mark, but this one talent keeps kicking my ass.
You mean kicking your flank?
meow point1
Touché...
I wish I thought of that XD
is it the talent27?
I know how you feel bitch
Sea Agate omg legend27 reference XD
haha nope her mom had a pear cutiemark
there is a episode about that
but nice theory
I agree 😄
Also her dad had a apple cutie mark but they may have still gone on a adventure for maybe some magic fruit? I don’t know
This video came out BEFORE the episode. May I remind you that this video came out THREE YEARS ago
@@AugustOfTheWinter the comment made 2 years ago. I am sure they already knew it by now
@@sesilliasandra2820 the comment still stands
bright Mac and buttercup bright Mac had a apple cutie mark butter cup (pear butter) was a jar of pear butter
Okay, hear me out: What if Applejack's mom wasn't even an Earth Pony? What if she was a pegasus, which enabled her to escape the tragedy that struck her husband. Rather than go to the family he belonged to, which would help her share and recover from her grief, she instead went into hiding, determined that she wasn't ever going to lose somepony close to her again, and so she covered her tracks, assumed an alternate name, and decided to always work alone from then on. To help herself deal with the memories, she started writing her stories down, eventually gaining the emotional strength she needed to continue her exploits.
Yes, I did just suggest what you think I did.
so basically she's daring do?
Yes it fits pearfcly whith daring doo
nope
In all honesty, this would also make sense why Applejack is adventurous and usually willing to be an element of harmony. On the flip side, it could also explain why she's always telling Rainbow Dash to slow down and not make hasty decisions.
Well, turns out their mother's isn't at least.
If this was for Scootaloos parents, you would have been spot on 👍
And you are right
I really don't think that the Cutie Marks been not Apple-Related would be a reason to be kickt out of the family, becuas Uncel oder Aunt Orange, one of them must be a sibling of ether the Father or the Mother of AJ, Big Mac and AB. And also there father or mother, depens of who is bonr in the appelfamily, must not have a apple CM, because that ponys could not come from the familie or we would have some dirty familie.
And in the end, it doesn't really matter what their CM's was, it only matters that they are the parents of the Applesiblings.
Soo lonf
Remember that episode with the Chimara that almost killed Applebloom when she tried to prove she was old enough to deliver the goods by herself? AJ was freaking out and scared she was going to lose her sister. What if their parents were making a delivery through there and got killed by the chimera?
Their mum was a pear and the apple family didn’t like the pear family while their dad was a apple they met when they were children and grew up to fall in love
This is told in one of the series
this theory video was made BEFORE the episode with Bright Mac and Buttercup came out **facepalms**
good point plus it makes sense if you also factor in grannies parents were also exporers before celestia gave them the sweet apple acres lands
How about another theory about the rivalry of Applebloom and Diamond Tiara before "Crusaders Of The Lost Mark"? or Why Diamond Tiara and Zippoorwhill are the fillies wearing tiaras? One of those may be your future video.
Well this theory just got blown out of the water
Here's a theory that I call how the elements of harmony turn to stone
Here how the theory goes in Session 1 Episode 2 we see the elements are stone but in Session 4 Episode 2 we see the elements are not stone when we see the elements being use on Luna for the first time they aren't stone so here where im going with this rant what if the elements after been use on 1 out of 2 of there holders the elements just didn't have harmony. Here proof in Session 2 Episode 1 celestia stated that sents her and Luna doesn't have power of the elements discord curse broke so maybe when Luna turn into night mare Moon she didn't go after elements now yes she could haven't knew about them but in Session 5 finally part 2 she states the following
NOW WITH THIS I CAN GO BACK TO MAKE SURE THE ELEMENTS ARE NEVER FOUND
And she didn't ask celestia what the elements are like discord because night mare Moon is Luna she like midnight sparkle in Friendship games in that Sunset says to human Twi
YOU DONT KNOW ABOUT MAGIC
And after midnight sparkle is made she says
YOU WERE RIGHT I DIDNT UNDER STAND MAGIC BEFOR BUT I DO NOW
So after Luna banishment to the moon elements go to stone celestia moves to the castle away from the old one and twilight and friends break the curse with harmony
Erm, I have another theory about them... They could be some kind of horticulturists, like some of the explorers back in the 15th century. Their cutie marks could be about discovering new species of apples or whatever. That could work as an apple related cutie mark, while letting them explore the world. I personally don't think they passed away, despite Lauren Faust's state of mind or whoever that showrunner said during an interview (I think she worked on the MLP movie, but I don't remember her name). They are still alive, but far, far away, missing ponies that are presumed dead, but that Applejack could reunite with as she could have some clues that they are still alive but can't reach Ponyville for some reason. That ould be an interesting idea for an episode, and after that there could be moments in other episodes where Applejack and Apple Bloom aren't too comfortable with their "brand new" parents and vice versa. That might be even more interesting rather than having them just dead.
Ok I like this theory, but how did the explorer thought come into mind?
Starlight Glimmer Lauren Faust's Deviant Art page.
what about the apple family reunion pics could it be one of those people
In one of the original My Little Pony comics, after Apple Bloom was born, Rarity was in danger and AJ' s parents helped, but then died because the bridge fell. They tried to get her parents back to land, but it was too late... ☠️
Kimberly Bridgham yeah, but that was fan made
Ya, Applejack's mom has a pear jelly cutiemark, not apple jelly, I thought that was interesting, you couldn't tell them apart, and this was found out when Applejack with the other two siblings (forgot how to spell their names) went out to find out about their parents, their dad worked on the apple farm, and their mom worked at the pear farm across from them, the only reason we don't see the pear farm now is because the pear family moved, and Applejack's mom wanted to stay, and so, Applejack's mom and dad got married, even though their families hated each other.
Turns out you're actually right about one of them! :O
or they're still alive but trapped somewhere maybe like an island and can't make it back home? Just another theory cause why both be dead what if one died and the other one got amnesia or both of them have it if they are traveling ponies. What if they forgot they had children and continued on with their life not knowing they left a family behind. Who to say their actually gone gone, it would be a nice episode if they came in town and tho they might not know their own family but it would be a great episode to see them try to remember and reunite with their children.
Jess A nope,they are dead
This theory was disproved, sort of, in season 7 Apple Jack's fathers Cuttie Mark was Apple related but Apple Jack's mothers Cuttie Mark was a jar of peach jam
I think Pear Butter, or Buttercup, died while giving birth to Apple Bloom shortly after the flashback of *Where the Apple Lies* while Bright Mac died a couple of days later of a broken heart.
As stated your theory is half correct as AJ's mom was a Pear and had a Pear Jam jar!
I think the apples parents are still alive just not shown up yet
I'm the same. Maybe Big Mac was crying simply because they were absent upon Apple Bloom's getting her cutie mark. It doesn't mean they're dead.
same here
And they haven't been even visiting after AppleBloom's birth? Such a Hard-hearted couple, I'd say.
horseandpony palsforever they dead because in the episode where they get there cutie marks she said IF mom and dad were here they would be so proud
Actually, there is one other possibility, everyone THINKS they're dead, but they are not. Say the got lost on their last expedition (or stranded on a desert island). That actually could be a good basis for an movie, applejack hears a rumor and goes on an epic quest to find her parents.
i've always thought that maybe the we're on a mission to find some kind of rare apple and the family never heard from them again and assumed the worse they could be dead or something is stopping them from returning ^^
I think that they were exploring a cave or temple, and it caved in because of the noise they were making or a bear, or any wild animal attacked them and they were unfortunate enough to pass away
I just realized season 7 episode 13 wasn't made yet, and we know that her mother was a pear and her dad was a apple. So it's half correct.
I believe that the two ponies have passed away because..
If they weren’t dead yet, they would’ve attended their annual Apple Family Reunion..
Their parents names are Buttercup and BrightMac and they are dead BC of Timberwolves is in "the perfect pear" Season 7 I think, that's all
Well all of this is debunked after A perfect pear.
Yes we do know a lot about Applejacks parents. Also it's orange and apple family
That's it
Sorry for debunking all your headcanons and theories, but Applejack's mum was from the pear family and her dad was an apple. Confirmed in Season 7, Episode 13
Apple Jack's mothers cutie mark is actually a jar of Pear butter, hensing her name and her father's cutie mark is a green apple with a star on the corner, Bright Mac.
I like to think their cutiemark a were Apple related, but we never see them because they were always travelling to find new types of apples
That actually makes makes perfect sense that their parents were explorers...
5:28 I love the picture of apple jacks parents!
Da, pretty cool. For a western pony.
even more proof that they don't have apple realated cutie marks is that there brother and sister (aunt orange and uncle orange) have orange cutie marks. They may have some kind of fruit as their cutie marks as well. not certain proof, but it could be used.
Plot Twist tell Me Why Rainbow And Daring Do Look the same And Twilight and moondancer???? Are they twins?
JoyceAnneMarie Offenberger check out The Brony Notions theory on the second one
true that
i think rainbow dash and daring are sisters they just don't know
like they were seperated when they were fillies
LPScoolPawsPaws Paws um it's either daring wants to be rainbow dash but daring ignores rainbow all the time or the set designers got lazy
LPScoolPawsPaws Paws nopony knows that answer
Cool theory. Although Bright Mac and Pear Butter didn't end up being explorers, Pear Butter did have a different cutie mark
Now just a quick thought, what if their parents are not really dead but currently trapped or are unable to reconnect due too something happening on their latest exploration...heck, if they got amnesia during their last expedition then they'ld have no memories perhaps that they have kids waiting for them or that their family is the apple's because their cutiemarks don't relate
In Estonia, in mlp magazine, there was a comic about Apple Family Reunion, and in the family picture I saw-surprise surprise-unicorn fillies!!!
Nice theroy but you are only half right because the mother was a pair but their dad had a apple
i have a theory about this too, maybe on one of their journeys they ran into trouble and got lost maybe even got into another dimension, i'll have to watch season 7 when i'm done season 8
fun fact Applejacks parents will apere in season 7
Yes
your first suggestion sounds pretty good.
Well, you were right about the one parent
Even with the whole episode showing how the parents got together it didn't actually show or explain what they were doing while they had kids
I think it hinted to they're dead but never said how but I guess that kind of makes sense
However consider how Apple bloom is supposed to be then they died recently ....ish
Well, you were half right that's for sure.
I think that they may have been explorers but what if they worked with siencetist ponies and Hospitals and explored to find new Herbs and plant for new medicine to help other ponies?
Happy hearts warming eve everypony 😁😁😁😁😁
This needs to be updated.
Bluelover(cortney) I am/well their mom is a pair and their dad is an apple sorry if I spoiled it probably you guys that are in the comment section would read this and probably you guys already watch the episode were some people who know.... never mind I might spoil it hehe.......
That died on a travel theory how if applejack has her dad's hat she says it mult5times
I like this, and there could be a chance that their parents are alive and just stuck somewhere. :D
Wasn't it confirmed in the Nightmare Rarity comics that Nightmare Moon actually IS a spirit that corrupted Luna?
But the comics aren't canon of course.
WeegeeSlayer Actually they're B-cannon. Until the show disproves it, it's cannon.
Suddenly, A Wild The Perfect Pear Appears!
Now we know that their mom was a pear pony and their dad was an apple pony..
actually applejack's father is an apple and applejack's mother is an orange. you can see it in The Cutie Mark Chronicles Episode in her aunt and uncle orange because her mother is an orange, but maybe apple now because her mother is married to her apple-related father, get it?
It's possible that they didn't die but got lost and could not find their way back home and are now traveling all over Equestria trying to find their way back home kind of like Cranky did for Matilda
Or maybe they have been captured and are being held hostage by some villain or found another civilization and started living with them
THEORY HALF CORRECT IM SO PROUD
Applejacks dad was pretty close but needs to be more vibrant. I mean the one in the video
Oh, this theory is awesome! I totally agree with it, and think this should be cannon! =D
You do know that apple blossom is apple jacks sister right? So they were born to the same father and mother so that makes your theory half true
Future: You were correct about the mom, Bright Mac on the other hand????
I could see the organes kicking Applebooms mother out of this family but not the apples that would explain why they stayed at the apples instead
Optimus Prime454 I like this channel
Your theory is half correct boiii
I’m watching in 2020
Also Bright Mac and Pear Butter are the parents
I could totally say that you're Theory is half correct, because in season seven episode 13 " the perfect pear" almost your entire Theory was proven wrong
*2017*
DragonTrainer: NOOOOOOOOOOO
But now, we know... Her mom was a pear!
The mother had a pear jam jar as a cutie mark. Tell me thats not farming related. I always theorized that the mother died during child birth to applebloom and the father left shortly after. I forgot what episode but apple bloom never met their parents.
There is a episode about their parents how they actually look like
Yes but this is a year old video
I think her mom died in child birth, this would explain why they don't mention her: they don't want applebloom to feel like she caused her mother's death.
I still go by the theory that they died when both of the kids were really young and applebloom is the daughter of applejack.
Well you were right about one thing
Well...you were half right
If apple jacks parents were not Apple cutie mark related it would be more possible that Apple jack, Apple bloom and Big Mac would not have Apple related cutie marks
What if Flim and Flam were siblings to applejack?!? What if they took over the "family business" of traveling sales ponies?! Or even half siblings?? Or maybe cousins??
I personaly think that the special talents of Applejacks parents weren't related to apple-farming, but at least one of them must have had an apple-related cutie mark. Even if Applejacks father (or mother btw. Why did you assume Applejacks father was Ganny Smiths son and found himself a mare out of the family and not the other way around? Is there any evidence?) had a talent that wasn't farming-related, his cutie mark would still refer to apples simply because he was a member of the Apple Family. Take a look at Applebloom and Babs Seed. Both of them have talents that are not apple-related at all, but their cutie marks still are apple-shaped. So even if one of Applejacks parents left the family to be an explorer, his / her cutie mark would still be apple-related. Perhaps an apple-shaped globe or compas, or a treasuremap with an apple on it...
Oh and please don't judge my spelling to hard, I'm a german brony...
I would love it if somehow they weren't dead... like, maybe just missing but then show up
what if applejack is not an apple? in episode 8 season 3 one of the apples found applejack under a table and he didint know her name! what if that was the day wen they found applejack? but there is one thing she had alredy a name! but what if granny said that so applejack didint find out that she is not an apple? what do you think? sorry if i didint spell somethin right i´m from finland so i cant spell evrything right! hope you all can understand what i ride!
she had apple in her name forgot to ride that! sorry
and maibe daring do is her mom?????????? we will never know.....
lps random applejack is half pear
Kidland Funny Times and half Orange
You predicted pear butter
In the family picture the pony with buckteeth in the bottom right corner he is a painter not a part of the Apple family.
There is an episode coming up that may give us an answer: The Perfect Pear. When will it come out? No idea. But I'm excited for it.
0:09-0:30 You can still do these theories now, in 2017, then please let everyone know about it when you finish. I can't wait to hear them from you. Sadly, I'm not a brony, but I don't mind seeing those theories come to life. #LoveAndPassionInYourHeart
This was kinda (?) proven right in S7 Ep13. (SPOILERS AS AT THE TIME OF WRITING THIS COMMENT IT HAS ONLY BEEN RELEASED IN CANDA)
AJ's mother had a pear-related cutie mark.
they are not explorers they are just normal farmers
This video was made before that episode was released!
well I just found out the question on first video of yours I watched
you is a crystal pony
I understand I think they are missing and I think that applejack should go looking for them then she would request the help of her friends to help find her parents
You are technically correct
The mom is not an apple while the dad is an apple
maybe they found the pony version of shangrila
This is possible
Good job dude
I still think that their cutie marks are related to apples and oranges possibly as I think they might have traveled to sell apples and make extra money for the family. I think they may have sold both apples and oranges at least.
***** Another reason I think that they did both, in "Somepony Watching Over Me", it is mentioned that they deliver apple pies to two very difficult and dangerous towns a good distance from Ponyville. Somehow, that relationship would have been established. I think their parents would have done that for them.
Well, you got it partially correct :/