My top 5 episodes? 1. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Remake with AVGN (It's my go to review when I'm feeling bummed.) 2. The Cell 3. IT (Which made it onto the top 5 list! Wooo!) 4. The matrix trilogy 5. Face/Off. I wanna see Critic do the Mission Impossible series with Tom Cruise.
Channel Awesome Apparently only two of mine made it into the top 10 . . . take a guess on which ones. 😜 Hocus Pocus It Suicide Squad Swan Princess Signs P.S. Nearly time for an Old vs New for Beauty and the Beast. Speaking of, maybe you could do Old vs New for the Parent Trap, Cheaper by the Dozen, and Yours, Mine, & Ours. Also, could you add The Last Unicorn, The Black Cauldron, Miss Peregrine's, and A Series of Unfortunate Events to your list of movies to review (if you haven't already)? Thanks!! 😊
This just reminds me of how epic I think Doug Walker's character, The Nostalgia Critic is. It also reminds me that there are an unbelievable amount of haters. People who think he's a liberal nutcase, people who thinks he runs a shady business, and people who just find his voice annoying. I know that it's just like, my opinion, man, but I just don't understand how people don't fucking love this man.
Luigi369 Foodfight and Last Airbender reached 3 million views on his other channel before Sharkboy and Lavagirl...in fact, that review still hasn't gotten there yet.
10 years ago today Nostalgia Critic was born 99 years ago today Steve Rogers was born. 241 years ago today the United States was born. Today's a good day.
J Grandmaster Speak for yourself. Here in France, we've got to wait a bit longer for Bastille Day to come along so that we can start blowing stuff up in celebration and eat some dodgy barbecue.
I want a worst list too. Part of growing up and looking back at old work is looking at the bad parts and seeing how you've improved and what you still need to improve upon.
worst is probably The Good Son (he lost his voice so Microsoft Sam did all the dialogue in the review) or the live action Scooby Doo (the last one before he originally retired Nostalgia Critic).
DefenestratedMessiah I would say Christmas with the Kranks, but that might be a personal bias because nothing pisses me off more than someone being passive aggressive towards their criticisms when a majority of people had valid critiques.
Interesting idea. It'd be nice to have everyone admit about the ones they just didn't find funny. Unfortunately, I feel like it would just unleash an endless amount of people who are just biased against all the videos 2013 and forward.
Jake Parks #1 Tom and Jerry Movie #2 Batman and Robin #3 Top 11 Mindfucks #4 Bebes Kids #5 Avatar the Last Airbender (note this might not be my exact top 5 since there are so many episodes and I can't remember them all)
"Signs" is my absolute favorite!! I love the alien translation. I was litterally crying from laughter through that review.Congrats on the 10 years! I have followed for 7 years! (sheesh time goes by fast)
10 years, 3 channels over 300 reviews, over 273 videos of original content from other people, 3 movies, 1 dvd, over 2 shows, over 104 crossovers, and he still doesn't have 1 million subscribers. WOW🤔🤔😧
The phenomenal ones This channel has only been around for a very short time. There have been a few over the 10 year span due to copyright strikes and such, so it's not at all representative of all of the people that have subscribed to him or followed his content before. In fact, a lot of people hold up the critic as kind of an internet legend still and he's inspired a lot of people. So in reality, it's just that the channel is so new compared to the amount of time he has been making content, not that barely anybody recognizes him. Though it still is weird that this channel has so few subscribers
I'm surprised the Christmas Tree didn't at least make the honorable mentions. The jokes surrounding the mayor alone had me in stitches. Simple effects, but I haven't laughed as hard as I did watching that review for the first time in quite a while.
The Last Airbender review is easily my favourite since watching it a few months back convinced me to watch an incredibly awesome show that passed me by as a kid.
I've been along for the whole ride. It all started with a genius idea, a AVGN rival, .. and.... a reaction video to the 6th Harry Potter book coming out? Lol.
you know, I have to congratulate you doug on making 10 year worth of video and making almost all of them solid. people like avgn's new video's aren't as good as his older video but every single video you have made is atleast decent.
My favorite episode was the Moulin Rouge review. You could tell a lot of effort and love went into it and it also was the episode that birthed his theme song.
Best episode has to be when they introduced Bill. He added so much to the show that I barely recognise the episodes before him, just such a great inclusion to the team. He, in essence, _was_ the team!
Wow, ten years. The years really do spin on don't they? My Top 5: 5. Old Versus New: Spiderman 4. Batman and Robin 3. Son of the Mask 2. Top 11 Best Villain Songs 1. The Neverending Story 3 Honourable Mentions go to The Wickerman, The Best/Worst episodes of Avatar, The Christmas Tree, The Grinch, Signs, and Dungeons and Dragons.
Olivia Martin the room was mine too and i thought food fight would be on there as well as the wickerman or ghost rider lolAlthough i disagree with what he said about once upon a forest i still love his jokes about it lmao
Honestly I consider Doug Walker to be the best skit writer on youtube. I know a lot of people complain about how long they can get, but I'm seriously impressed at what he can do with his movie footage-free reviews.
I was kind of disappointed by the voting, as it skewed toward the older stuff. I have been watching all 10-years (I honestly don't remember how I found it), but the quality from the beginning to now is night and day. I have gotten so that I much prefer the clip-less, or mostly clip-less work to see the growth of Doug and Rob as story-tellers, and their great cast and crew, from Malcolm, Tamara, and Rachel to Jim and Barney. Doug began as a comedic critic, but now he's so much more. Early reviews on this list like It and The Room ARE classics, but I voted for Pixels and while the Room would definitely be top 5 for me, it might not be top 3 anymore. There are critics who have done some things similar to what Doug was doing in 2007, and no doubt his show might never have existed without the legends at MST3K paving the way, but no one is doing what he does now. He's like Walter White in Breaking Bad when he compared the 'competition' to himself as 'grade school tee-ball vs. the New York Yankees.' Or, to honor the Chicagoans who make this show: Doug, Rob and co. are Phil Jackson the head coach, and their competitors are Phil Jackson the President/GM.
Pixel is my first ep from NC, I know him from AVGN That ep is amaze me since I though he will just rant about movie, but he not, he also put great message to Adam Sandler Later I watch all his ep that I can find for me I like Jurassic world most, although I like movie but many thing he said is spot on that I LMAO
Heath D L Well, I can only speak for myself but at least for me the older episodes simply are thousand times better than the newer episodes. The comedy in the older ones is just way funnier IMHO. Back in the days of the older episodes I used to love NC because I laughed out loud with pretty much every episode. But when it comes to newer episodes I just don't find them anywhere near as funny as the old ones. I mean sure, there are some really funny ones (Christmas Tree & Jack and the Beanstalk) but mostly the new ones just don't have the same comedic timing and jokes that make me burst out laughing. And the acting in them tends to still be a bit too cringey for my tastes. I will admit that everyone's gotten way better with their performances over the years and I don't find the newer clipless reviews nearly as embarrasing to look at but they still don't have me in stitches like the older episodes did almost without exception. But as I said this is simply my opinion and not meant to be a knock on anyone but I get the feeling that for many NC fans it's similar where they just feel that the older NC episodes were funnier on average & had more classic great episodes (Titanic cartoons, The Room, It, Thomas the Tank Engine, Suburban Commando, Garbage Pale Kids, Care Bears movies, Cartoon All-Stars Drug PSA cartoon, Howard the Duck, Captain Planet, Cool As Ice, TMNT films, etc.). And the fact that a lot of the old episodes spawned memes that took on a life of their own also supports that. But obviously some like the newer ones more and that's fine too but for majority most of the classic episodes are the older ones.
Some Guy You make a lot of good points, and having been watching since 2007, I concede that I probably laughed out loud more frequently at some of the earlier episodes than at the more recent ones, but the newer ones are very funny and are better stories. Early episodes were short and closer to the MST3K format than to what Doug and co. are doing now. But for a while now, Doug's been making a TV-quality show that airs a new episode bi-weekly. I don't guffaw at every episode of South Park or It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, but I enjoy even episodes without side-splitting humor as long as I'm entertained and laughing throughout. An example with Always Sunny would be the excellent 'Charlie Work,' episode from a few seasons ago, which had few laugh out loud moments, but was funny and is considered by many to perhaps be the best episode of the entire series. Doug and Channel Awesome are simply playing at a far higher level today than ever before, and while I was initially skeptical of the clip-less or mostly clip-less reviews, they are now my favorites and if I did my own top 10 (or 11?) list of my favorite NC episodes, I believe the majority would be episodes in the last few seasons.
10 years and you still don't have a million subs... You should be at least 5 million by now!! This is probably the most under subbed channel I've ever seen. Love your vids
Fan 4 Shtik, if that is how its written, is definitely the best review. You have no idea how hard I laughed about the 'dark room' problem and actually, I haven't even watched the movie yet. All the same, this channel is amazing. Congrats!!
Congratulations!! You have lightened up my life so so so so much for the years and I cannot even put into words how much you and your entire team mean to me. THANK YOU for all your hard work!
Same. One of my favorite reviews was A.I. I loved the TMZ side plot throughout the review. Another one I enjoyed was the Langoliers. "Scaring the little GIRL!?"
I was thinking about that, but I ended up giving my vote to the winner. I love Star Wars but Tommy's scene in the roof is just too much for this world. Even so, I'm surprised it isn't in the list, the SWHS is one of the most awfullest things ever...
I'm still peeved that Alone in the Dark wasn't a voting option. I mean c'mon! Spoony and Linkara and NC talking through text-to-speech combined with the horrors of the Boll will just always seem to be film critique perfection to me.
I've been desperately waiting for somebody to do a review of that movie. If he does do it though, he needs to have an Aussie RUclipsr help him out, because only we Aussies can truly understand how bad that movie is.
My top 10 episodes (In no order): 10. The Last Airbender 9. The Cat in the Hat 8. Disney Afternoon 7. The Neverending Story 3 6. Sonic the Hedgehog 5. The Christmas Tree 4. Garbage Pail Kids 3. North 2. Captain America 1. Mortal Kombat: Annihilation Honorable mentions: Short Circuit, The Care Bears Movie, Batman and Robin, Alone int he Dark, Superman IV, Balto,
Huge congrats on 10 years guys! I found NC & Channel Awesome somewhere around a year, year and a half ago, and I've watched so much of your content since then, and loved every second of it. It's been so much fun, and it's taught how to view films through a critical eye and has added a whole new level of enjoyment when watching movies, or pretty much anything actually. I find myself noticing and appreciating all these little things that go into making a movie I never noticed, and in some cases never even knew about before, and it makes me love great movies even more, and even to appreciate the hidden gems here and there in otherwise crappy movies. But, more than anything, you've made me smile and laugh during times of great pain and depression, and every time I see a charity shoutout, you give me hope in people that some days, I have a lot of trouble finding. Seeing you use your platform to spread the word about charities doing good work is amazing, and while your content is more than enough for me to love you guys, the charity shoutouts made me truly admire and respect you. So, for all these reasons and many more, congratulations om 10 years of NC, and thank you so much for letting us take this crazy ride with you. Oh, one last thing, where's the best place to recommend a charity for a shoutout? There's one charity and disease in particular that it would mean the world to me to see you give a shoutout.
Ok, I have to say that Barney is the possibly the best Dad in the world, since not only does he support his son all the way through he also helps him with his productions which is amazing! So good for you guys.
Too bad that Suicide Squad only made it into Honorable Mentions. What I love about this episode is that the entire Channel Awesome cast has assembled. The costumes look great and the humor is on point (The scene in the dark room always cracks me up). Jim playing Jared Leto playing the Joker is one of the best characters, and it finally gave us a satisfying conclusion to Bill's incredibly well thought-out arc. Seriously, he's one of the best characters in modern media.
Happy 10th anniversary, guys!!! 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗. I'm really glad you guys decided to make this show. Since the beginning, NC has always made me laugh. Keep up the good work!!!! 😁😁😁
My Top 5. 1-Thomas And The Magic Railroad. 2-Care Bears. (Any of Them) 3-Master of Disguise. 4-Cats And Dogs. (Please review the sequel. It makes the first look like Shawshank Redemption.) 5-Ghost Rider.
I feel like Titanic the Animated Musical and the Star Wars Christmas Special deserved a spot on this list. But I won't argue with IT, Avatar and The Room
I'm genuinely surprised 4/5 are from the old Nostalgia Critic, with only 1 from the relaunch. I mean I love the old stuff, but the new stuff is so next level. They're real productions ya know? Ah well, still great stuff. Happy 10th anniversary Doug. Here's to 10 more awesome years of NC.
Thank you, Doug. Really, sincerely thank you. I've been watching your reviews for eight years now, throughout primary school and high school, if had ever had a crappy day, me and my sister who put on an episode. Now I'm at college and I'm still watching! :)
My favourite NOSTALGIA CRITIC video is his review of Lês Miserables, sure, moulin rouge is a great review but the songs in Lês Mis are just so catchy, I just love it, Paul and Kyle have amazing performances, I love it.
Man, these ten years have flown by unbelievably fast. I'm glad I've been watching since the start, and I can't wait for another ten years with you guys. *Keep on critiquing!*
TEN YEARS!!!! Thank you all for watching!
What are your picks for Top 5 Best Nostalgia Critic episodes?
Please review the Simpsons movie
you guys are amazing keep making vids let's try for a Twenty year anniversary
Here's for infinite more years... and where's my goddamn hand cake!
My top 5 episodes? 1. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Remake with AVGN (It's my go to review when I'm feeling bummed.) 2. The Cell 3. IT (Which made it onto the top 5 list! Wooo!) 4. The matrix trilogy 5. Face/Off.
I wanna see Critic do the Mission Impossible series with Tom Cruise.
Channel Awesome Apparently only two of mine made it into the top 10 . . . take a guess on which ones. 😜
Hocus Pocus
It
Suicide Squad
Swan Princess
Signs
P.S. Nearly time for an Old vs New for Beauty and the Beast. Speaking of, maybe you could do Old vs New for the Parent Trap, Cheaper by the Dozen, and Yours, Mine, & Ours. Also, could you add The Last Unicorn, The Black Cauldron, Miss Peregrine's, and A Series of Unfortunate Events to your list of movies to review (if you haven't already)? Thanks!! 😊
Why is this not top 11? How dare he not go one step beyond.
Joseph Robinson I would watch 2 hours of this, no joke
I think so too.
Because this isn't an NC video. This is Walter's show Top 5. Thus...top five.
'Cause Walter can only go up to 5.
"Why Top 5? Because he likes to go six steps below"
Let's hope for another 11 years! Why not 10? Because this channel likes to go one step beyond.
Nekotrap ha i get it
Well said.
This just reminds me of how epic I think Doug Walker's character, The Nostalgia Critic is. It also reminds me that there are an unbelievable amount of haters. People who think he's a liberal nutcase, people who thinks he runs a shady business, and people who just find his voice annoying. I know that it's just like, my opinion, man, but I just don't understand how people don't fucking love this man.
DrChadd990 shady business?
DrChadd990, why do people think he's liberal?
Profiting off the hard work of others.
Nicolo Lagravinese: One reason is he called Chuck Norris a homophobe just because.
Jesus (not putting the rest): Such a mature and well thought out username (sarcasm).
you are tearing me apart lisa
Tyson Nichols I did not hit her. I did not! Oh hai Mark.
Halo ‘Tis not dead Anyway how’s your sex life?
phrasing!
He remembers it, so we don't have to. Happy 10th Anniversary, Nostalgia Critic.
Angel- Movie and Marvel Maniac. not to mention commercials
He gives us the ultimate sacrifice..
BobbyJay I strongly agree
Can someone list the reviews and their links? I don't want spoilers in this vid.
Always wanted to ask
He remembers WHAT?)
*But the chart says...*
I can't understand his accent
I don't care what the chart says!!!
But the chart says it should be sharkboy and lava girl it got the most views!!!!!!!!!
Luigi369 Foodfight and Last Airbender reached 3 million views on his other channel before Sharkboy and Lavagirl...in fact, that review still hasn't gotten there yet.
I'm not asking the chart, I'm asking you!
10 years ago today Nostalgia Critic was born
99 years ago today Steve Rogers was born.
241 years ago today the United States was born.
Today's a good day.
J Grandmaster Speak for yourself. Here in France, we've got to wait a bit longer for Bastille Day to come along so that we can start blowing stuff up in celebration and eat some dodgy barbecue.
Cailus Griffin
Cailus Griffin
True, very true. Have a good Bastille Day on the 14 of July.
J Grandmaster coincidence?! I don't think so.
Steve is 97. He was born 1920
The Critic's 10th anniversary was yesterday.
I put the Wickerman as the best for Tamara's intro, and the bear jokes
Max J Papa bear thinks this bitch is to CONSCIOUS!
I seriously nearly passed out from laughing so much there.
Only you can prevent not getting your ass kicked by Nicolas FUCKING CAGE
STABBED THROUGH THE HEART
AND YOU'RE TO BLAME
YOU GIVE BATMAN A BAD NAME
Shot through the heart!
And you're the 'tard!
You give Batman a
*BAT CREDIT CARD?!?*
Shot through the heart!
And the hate for you triples
You gave them both... BAT NIPPLES!
Shot through the heart!
You wrecked my mood,
YOU MADE ADAM WEST'S BATMAN LOOK GOOD!
Adam West's batman is good XD
I couldn't think of a rhyme ;)
here's a question for NC. After a full 10 years can he finally... FINALLY tie his own tie?
I love how I know how big a fan you are just from that statement!!
I hope so :D
James' wife is on the hotline whenever somebody unties his tie
I want a worst list too. Part of growing up and looking back at old work is looking at the bad parts and seeing how you've improved and what you still need to improve upon.
Witty Username number 1 has to be hocus pocus
Nope. It's his Let's Play Bart's Nightmare.
worst is probably The Good Son (he lost his voice so Microsoft Sam did all the dialogue in the review) or the live action Scooby Doo (the last one before he originally retired Nostalgia Critic).
DefenestratedMessiah I would say Christmas with the Kranks, but that might be a personal bias because nothing pisses me off more than someone being passive aggressive towards their criticisms when a majority of people had valid critiques.
Interesting idea. It'd be nice to have everyone admit about the ones they just didn't find funny. Unfortunately, I feel like it would just unleash an endless amount of people who are just biased against all the videos 2013 and forward.
This is probably better than NC's actual video this week, a brilliant retrospective that warms the heart. which is good, because I WAS FROZEN TODAY!
็How about one can of "Frying COKE"
I tried, but the machine won't accept my BAT CREDIT CARD!!!
Cheer up! Sparkle sparkle sparkle!
Andrew Molenaar it's July. How?!
Johnny Doe South Hemisphere.
my top 5
#5 the smurfs
#4 the lorax
#3 the room
#2 alien vs predator
#1 cat in the hat
Jake Parks
#1 Tom and Jerry Movie
#2 Batman and Robin
#3 Top 11 Mindfucks
#4 Bebes Kids
#5 Avatar the Last Airbender
(note this might not be my exact top 5 since there are so many episodes and I can't remember them all)
But the chart says...
DarkBeast 27 I'm not asking about the chart; I'm asking you.
Devil... 'Nough said!
Who else predicted that The Room review was going to be number 1?
I voted for The Room episode. Actually didn't think it would make the top 5 let alone #1.
I did (after I read this)
Holy cap!!! It's been ten years already????? Congrats to Doug and Channel Awesome!!!!!!
If the god Doug Walker wears it...it must be really fuckin holy
fatalshot009 holy cap indeed
What if Doug Walker walked dogs? Doug Walker the dog walker.
amiibler doug from up
amiibler 😐😮😲😀😄😆😂
This Comment is so Powerful, I'm holding back tears
Boy shut yo sensitive ass up
Nevermind I just cried
I'm actually disappointed that Commando wasn't on the list, also, FOODFIGHT WAS AN HONORABLE MENTION?!?!?
Nikes Gray Yeah and what about Twister, Congo, Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter The fucking Movie? 😢
The animated Titanic movies were my favorites! Getting the Jagarmeister out during every review always cracked me up!
Yeah the Titanic ones were the best.
"Signs" is my absolute favorite!! I love the alien translation. I was litterally crying from laughter through that review.Congrats on the 10 years! I have followed for 7 years! (sheesh time goes by fast)
Even I wouldn't give Batman a Bat credit card!
10 years, 3 channels over 300 reviews, over 273 videos of original content from other people, 3 movies, 1 dvd, over 2 shows, over 104 crossovers, and he still doesn't have 1 million subscribers. WOW🤔🤔😧
correct me if I'm wrong.
The phenomenal ones And, 11 clipless reviews.
The phenomenal ones This channel has only been around for a very short time. There have been a few over the 10 year span due to copyright strikes and such, so it's not at all representative of all of the people that have subscribed to him or followed his content before. In fact, a lot of people hold up the critic as kind of an internet legend still and he's inspired a lot of people. So in reality, it's just that the channel is so new compared to the amount of time he has been making content, not that barely anybody recognizes him. Though it still is weird that this channel has so few subscribers
Crabby Dragoon thanks
well he did on a different channel
Happy 10th, Doug. Here's to 11, because I like to go one step beyond.
I see you're a man of culture as well
Exactly!
Holy shit
I agree, I was more of of an eleven man myself.
I'm surprised the Christmas Tree didn't at least make the honorable mentions. The jokes surrounding the mayor alone had me in stitches. Simple effects, but I haven't laughed as hard as I did watching that review for the first time in quite a while.
Go Isles the moral of the story is DON'T FUCK WITH MRS HOAKWELL
Ugh the eyes thing reacting to your child's death gets me every. single. time.
Go Isles That's right Two Whole Money Bags! Oh my ride is here *leaves in a shoe*
Go Isles IKR it's my favorite by a long shot. Its funny, solid, and a really heartwarming review that's become a tradition for me.
Did he just have a Vietnam flashback?
"I have enough here to buy all the children new clothes..."
"FALL BACK!!! FALL BACK!!!"
that editing in beginning credits was incredible
The Last Airbender review is easily my favourite since watching it a few months back convinced me to watch an incredibly awesome show that passed me by as a kid.
kingkong381 bet you regret not watching it back then huh
kingkong381 the show is so amazing
Holy Shit, has it been 10 years already?!
How time flies.
StickMaster500 well.... fuck dude
I've been along for the whole ride. It all started with a genius idea, a AVGN rival, .. and.... a reaction video to the 6th Harry Potter book coming out? Lol.
I hope Doug remembers me so I don't have to
Barney TheDinosaur 69 likes
you know, I have to congratulate you doug on making 10 year worth of video and making almost all of them solid. people like avgn's new video's aren't as good as his older video but every single video you have made is atleast decent.
It's been an amazing ten years, but.... WHAT ABOUT BOOMER?!?
dknights411 Boomer will live.
He will live!
boomer will live
dknights411 Boomer will live
😂😂😂😂
"SCARING THE LITTLE *GIRL?!*"
SPARKLE SPARKLE SPARKLE!
Landon Hood
Fuck yeah, Sparkle Sparkle Sparkle!
FUKEN BUBBLES
Fuck yeah, SPARKLE SPARKLE SPARKLE!
Shit yeah, SPARKLE SPARKLE SPARKLE!
Landon Hood SPARKLE SPARKLE SPARKLE?
I voted Foodfight! just because it has his best mental breakdown.
Godzilla 123 The wicker man was a good one too
Godzilla 123 I know right? I picked that one too
My favorite episode was the Moulin Rouge review. You could tell a lot of effort and love went into it and it also was the episode that birthed his theme song.
Master of disguise meltdown was brilliant
ՏѦBѦH what about the Christmas reviews
There should be a video on the history of Nastolgia Critic
Maybe if there was one on the Nostalgia Critic. That Nastolgia Critic guy is an asshole.
8Bit_Nerd_2003
Nasalgastic critik
8Bit_Nerd_2003 mister metokur did one
I plan on doing one for Phelous, I could do one for the Nostalgia Critic too.
The Metokur video is mostly in a negative light though.
Best episode has to be when they introduced Bill. He added so much to the show that I barely recognise the episodes before him, just such a great inclusion to the team. He, in essence, _was_ the team!
What do you mean? Bill has always been around. How don't you remember how long we've had Bill?! Lol
What are you talking about, Bill had his own show, and it was the first video on the channel! Doug was just a side character, and still is.
I think the only time Bill WASN'T in a review was whrn he became the temporary King of Iceland.
Damn... I voted for 'Rise of the Commercials'
The Minion Hunters same!
If there's anything I got out of my awkward sort of friend, it is that she introduced me to anime, and nostalgia critic. I owe her my life, literally.
TheAnonymousNalliox Your awkward sort of friend sounds like an awkward sort of good friend for that sort of good taste, awkward as it is
Wow, ten years. The years really do spin on don't they?
My Top 5:
5. Old Versus New: Spiderman
4. Batman and Robin
3. Son of the Mask
2. Top 11 Best Villain Songs
1. The Neverending Story 3
Honourable Mentions go to The Wickerman, The Best/Worst episodes of Avatar, The Christmas Tree, The Grinch, Signs, and Dungeons and Dragons.
Congratulations, NC! I don't have a television anymore, it's your voice that feel the void of nonsense in my life. Never stop nitpicking!!!!!
10 YEARS CONGRATS !
(Do Something With The X-files pls.)
Okatakiye Ofori Bum reviews
The A.I. Artificial Intelligence review is severely underrated. It's my favorite
Ah such a good video, what a trip down memory lane- *AH BALD DOUG!!!*
The Room was the first video of NC I ever watched. My uncle showed it to me and it was the most hilarious shit in the world to me.
Mine too! I saw the Pewdiepie video about The Room and knew I had to find a full-fledged review of it.
Foodfight was the first one I watched. ^^
lmao I love the Food Fight review too!
Olivia Martin the room was mine too and i thought food fight would be on there as well as the wickerman or ghost rider lolAlthough i disagree with what he said about once upon a forest i still love his jokes about it lmao
DragonShade100 His Foodfight review is my favourite.
My fav Nostalgia Critic eps:
5-Ferngully
4-Godzilla
3-The Room
2-Batman & Robin
1-Moulin Rouge
The Variety Vendor 3 out of 5 of your choices are on this list.
The Variety Vendor my top 5 are:
1-star wars the holiday special
2-osmosis jones
3-a troll in Central Park
4-IT
5-Felix the cat the movie
The Variety Vendor my number one is les mis
mine-every Stephen king review
Honestly I consider Doug Walker to be the best skit writer on youtube. I know a lot of people complain about how long they can get, but I'm seriously impressed at what he can do with his movie footage-free reviews.
I was kind of disappointed by the voting, as it skewed toward the older stuff. I have been watching all 10-years (I honestly don't remember how I found it), but the quality from the beginning to now is night and day. I have gotten so that I much prefer the clip-less, or mostly clip-less work to see the growth of Doug and Rob as story-tellers, and their great cast and crew, from Malcolm, Tamara, and Rachel to Jim and Barney. Doug began as a comedic critic, but now he's so much more. Early reviews on this list like It and The Room ARE classics, but I voted for Pixels and while the Room would definitely be top 5 for me, it might not be top 3 anymore.
There are critics who have done some things similar to what Doug was doing in 2007, and no doubt his show might never have existed without the legends at MST3K paving the way, but no one is doing what he does now. He's like Walter White in Breaking Bad when he compared the 'competition' to himself as 'grade school tee-ball vs. the New York Yankees.' Or, to honor the Chicagoans who make this show: Doug, Rob and co. are Phil Jackson the head coach, and their competitors are Phil Jackson the President/GM.
Pixel is my first ep from NC, I know him from AVGN
That ep is amaze me since I though he will just rant about movie, but he not, he also put great message to Adam Sandler
Later I watch all his ep that I can find for me I like Jurassic world most, although I like movie but many thing he said is spot on that I LMAO
Heath D L Well, I can only speak for myself but at least for me the older episodes simply are thousand times better than the newer episodes. The comedy in the older ones is just way funnier IMHO. Back in the days of the older episodes I used to love NC because I laughed out loud with pretty much every episode. But when it comes to newer episodes I just don't find them anywhere near as funny as the old ones. I mean sure, there are some really funny ones (Christmas Tree & Jack and the Beanstalk) but mostly the new ones just don't have the same comedic timing and jokes that make me burst out laughing. And the acting in them tends to still be a bit too cringey for my tastes. I will admit that everyone's gotten way better with their performances over the years and I don't find the newer clipless reviews nearly as embarrasing to look at but they still don't have me in stitches like the older episodes did almost without exception. But as I said this is simply my opinion and not meant to be a knock on anyone but I get the feeling that for many NC fans it's similar where they just feel that the older NC episodes were funnier on average & had more classic great episodes (Titanic cartoons, The Room, It, Thomas the Tank Engine, Suburban Commando, Garbage Pale Kids, Care Bears movies, Cartoon All-Stars Drug PSA cartoon, Howard the Duck, Captain Planet, Cool As Ice, TMNT films, etc.). And the fact that a lot of the old episodes spawned memes that took on a life of their own also supports that. But obviously some like the newer ones more and that's fine too but for majority most of the classic episodes are the older ones.
Some Guy You make a lot of good points, and having been watching since 2007, I concede that I probably laughed out loud more frequently at some of the earlier episodes than at the more recent ones, but the newer ones are very funny and are better stories. Early episodes were short and closer to the MST3K format than to what Doug and co. are doing now. But for a while now, Doug's been making a TV-quality show that airs a new episode bi-weekly. I don't guffaw at every episode of South Park or It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, but I enjoy even episodes without side-splitting humor as long as I'm entertained and laughing throughout. An example with Always Sunny would be the excellent 'Charlie Work,' episode from a few seasons ago, which had few laugh out loud moments, but was funny and is considered by many to perhaps be the best episode of the entire series.
Doug and Channel Awesome are simply playing at a far higher level today than ever before, and while I was initially skeptical of the clip-less or mostly clip-less reviews, they are now my favorites and if I did my own top 10 (or 11?) list of my favorite NC episodes, I believe the majority would be episodes in the last few seasons.
I generally agree, though I think it's a fair trade-off.
It is 'Nostalgia' though... we miss old Critic sometimes I guess.
Woah. 10 fucking years.
I started watching NC in middle school and this year I'm gonna be a college sophomore. It's crazy how time flies.
So early that RUclips isn't drunk. Also Happy 10 years Doug! #NC4EVER
No video made me Laugh more then the review of Devil. Like that shit made me laugh for hours.
j e l l y s i d e d o w n
Ub3r Hobo That scene when Doug, Barney and company bash each other in terror always has me rolling around in laughter.
One of my all time favorite bits of Doug is the bubble thing commercial.
+Pe pi FUCKING BUBBLES
5: Wicker Man
4: The smurfs
3: Avatar: The last air bender
2: Wonder Woman
1: Foodfight
So am I the only one who IMMEDIATELY looked up to see if he really did do Schindler's List?
Warrior Studios did they?
Picnic Basket Sam No
this feels like a DVD special feature
Travois the awesome It totally does! I wonder if it was on purpose...
One of the best Top Five lists of all time!!!!!! I especially loved the end joke with Doug, the Nostalgia Critic, himself!!!!!!
10 years and you still don't have a million subs... You should be at least 5 million by now!! This is probably the most under subbed channel I've ever seen. Love your vids
Reality is a bitch, my friend
Fan 4 Shtik, if that is how its written, is definitely the best review. You have no idea how hard I laughed about the 'dark room' problem and actually, I haven't even watched the movie yet.
All the same, this channel is amazing. Congrats!!
Where is Son of the Mask that was the funniest shit I've ever seen!
Munjee Syed. Heart Attack Take Medication!
Nicholas Koskey you know...a FAAAMILLY picture!
YOOO!!! RIGHT!!! I DIED LAUGHING! I ranted above. EASILY EASILY MY FAVORITE. HILARIOUS!!
I hoped it would at least make honorable mentions.Too bad tho.
I love Nostalgia Critic!
Notepad Pop Culture who doesn't am I right. 👌
Notepad Pop Culture Me too man he's one of the greatest RUclipsrs of all time
Luke Skywalker the 2nd BAT CREDIT CAARRRDDD
Notepad Pop Culture I love that one! :)
He loves you too random citizen.
And then Linkara DESTROYED the bat-credit-card joke. lol
10 years of remembering it so we don't have to. I tip my hat to you, sir.
Bobsheaux Hey, ever considered doing a crossover with the NC?
Oh hey, didn't know you watch and comment on these videos as well, what a surprise :o
IHE got enough cr*p from the creator of that atrocity, I doubt NC would want a repeat of the fight they had with the creator of "The Room".
Derek wouldn't fuck with someone as big as he Critic.
So glad IT was on the list. The first review I ever watched and I can remember being in absolute hysterics! One of my favourite shows of all time
Congratulations!! You have lightened up my life so so so so much for the years and I cannot even put into words how much you and your entire team mean to me. THANK YOU for all your hard work!
Kinda sucks that most of the Nostalgia Critic episodes that I remember the MOST of weren't on the list to vote on.
But oh well...
That just goes to show you that there are so many great episodes in a span of 10 years
Agreed. I wanted to see Dungeons and Dragons on here.
Same. One of my favorite reviews was A.I. I loved the TMZ side plot throughout the review. Another one I enjoyed was the Langoliers. "Scaring the little GIRL!?"
cooldude56g My all time favorite review was Les Mis. I can't *believe* they didn't put that on the list!
Damn it I voted for Star Wars the holiday special
Pancake Face Productions Me too. We all love Santa Christ.
I was thinking about that, but I ended up giving my vote to the winner. I love Star Wars but Tommy's scene in the roof is just too much for this world.
Even so, I'm surprised it isn't in the list, the SWHS is one of the most awfullest things ever...
Pancake Face Productions I voted Moulin Rouge
+Pancake Face Productions That was amazing.
I didn't vote because when I decided the couldn't take any more votes
Glad you embraced the baldness Critic...I did too #BaldIsBeautiful
Suicide Squad was my favorite.
"I'm a dinosaur."
did i just watch nostalgia critic nostalgia? seems ironic somehow.
I'm still peeved that Alone in the Dark wasn't a voting option. I mean c'mon! Spoony and Linkara and NC talking through text-to-speech combined with the horrors of the Boll will just always seem to be film critique perfection to me.
Anthony Hiebert That was the episode that introduced me to Linkara. I loooove that one ^_^
It was not.
Certainly that my favourite one. :)
Me when I saw bill in the intro: OH YEA BILL IS HERE THIS IS GUNNA BE EPIC
Happy 10th Anniversary Nostalgia Critic! Cheers to 10 years of good 'ol Doug
Wai what? Schindler's list? I don't remember Doug reviewing schindler's list
muttonsword ikr
What do you mean? Bill was in it.
@@proboy2372 By the way, it was my favorite performance, Bill surpassed himself.
My Top 3 favorite Nostalgia Critic Episodes:
1. Devil
2. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
3. Man of Steel
You are wrong, no prize! GOOD DAY SIR!!
Dayum, Walter went SpongeBob Movie at the end.
"BALD! BALD! BALD!"
You have to do a kangaroo jack (2003) episode
that movie is awkward as fuck
That was one of my favorite movies as a kid. It's probably stupid, but I still think the twist at the end is clever.
OMFG when the kangaroo starts rapping the LL Cool Jay song... dude, I was only 16 but that was my first time experiencing what an acid trip is like.
Bass Box so orange
I've been desperately waiting for somebody to do a review of that movie. If he does do it though, he needs to have an Aussie RUclipsr help him out, because only we Aussies can truly understand how bad that movie is.
My top 10 episodes (In no order):
10. The Last Airbender
9. The Cat in the Hat
8. Disney Afternoon
7. The Neverending Story 3
6. Sonic the Hedgehog
5. The Christmas Tree
4. Garbage Pail Kids
3. North
2. Captain America
1. Mortal Kombat: Annihilation
Honorable mentions: Short Circuit, The Care Bears Movie, Batman and Robin, Alone int he Dark, Superman IV, Balto,
Dungeons and dragons is best
Amir Elkassed where's the grinch
Amir Elkassed The Room?
Huge congrats on 10 years guys! I found NC & Channel Awesome somewhere around a year, year and a half ago, and I've watched so much of your content since then, and loved every second of it. It's been so much fun, and it's taught how to view films through a critical eye and has added a whole new level of enjoyment when watching movies, or pretty much anything actually. I find myself noticing and appreciating all these little things that go into making a movie I never noticed, and in some cases never even knew about before, and it makes me love great movies even more, and even to appreciate the hidden gems here and there in otherwise crappy movies. But, more than anything, you've made me smile and laugh during times of great pain and depression, and every time I see a charity shoutout, you give me hope in people that some days, I have a lot of trouble finding. Seeing you use your platform to spread the word about charities doing good work is amazing, and while your content is more than enough for me to love you guys, the charity shoutouts made me truly admire and respect you. So, for all these reasons and many more, congratulations om 10 years of NC, and thank you so much for letting us take this crazy ride with you. Oh, one last thing, where's the best place to recommend a charity for a shoutout? There's one charity and disease in particular that it would mean the world to me to see you give a shoutout.
Loved the ending! The look on Walter's face was priceless! Congrats on ten years and hope to see you on YT for ten more!
No Master of Disguise? Was it not turtley enough?
Jane Ross Tuuuuuuurrrrrrrrrtle!
Jane Ross 29 reviews go into the water, 24 reviews come out of the water, and the shamalan, he took the rest.
shouldn't it have been top eleven? It is nostalgia critic
CN TheBlueJay But this is a Top 5
It isn't Nostalgia Critic's review, though.
Kinda wish this was a top 11.
jjstarA113 So do I
Or atleast top six
Why Top 11? Because I like to go one step beyond.
jjstarA113 critic would have wanted it on that style
Ok, I have to say that Barney is the possibly the best Dad in the world, since not only does he support his son all the way through he also helps him with his productions which is amazing! So good for you guys.
Too bad that Suicide Squad only made it into Honorable Mentions. What I love about this episode is that the entire Channel Awesome cast has assembled. The costumes look great and the humor is on point (The scene in the dark room always cracks me up). Jim playing Jared Leto playing the Joker is one of the best characters, and it finally gave us a satisfying conclusion to Bill's incredibly well thought-out arc. Seriously, he's one of the best characters in modern media.
You know, FOR KIDS!!!
Happy 10th anniversary, guys!!! 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗. I'm really glad you guys decided to make this show. Since the beginning, NC has always made me laugh. Keep up the good work!!!! 😁😁😁
It is like a little documentary!
I love their dad so much. He always reminds me of my dad and the Dad jokes he makes ☺️
Holy crap! He did it. The bastard reviewed himself!
Rachel Hollars hes done it before with his movie
After 10 years he should have at least 10 million subs
My Top 5.
1-Thomas And The Magic Railroad.
2-Care Bears. (Any of Them)
3-Master of Disguise.
4-Cats And Dogs. (Please review the sequel. It makes the first look like Shawshank Redemption.)
5-Ghost Rider.
TIME FOR A GAME OF DISSAPEARING BEARS
Ham Is My Favourite Colour darkkkkkhearrtttt
Ham Is My Favourite Colour Sparkle! Sparkle! Sparkle!
JamcalX Hell yea sparkle sparkle sparkle
I feel like Titanic the Animated Musical and the Star Wars Christmas Special deserved a spot on this list. But I won't argue with IT, Avatar and The Room
MY LIST!!!!!!!!
1. Food Fight
2. The Last Air Bender
3. Master of Disguise
4. Son of the Mask
5. Commando
Whenever I feel sad I watch the animated titanic trilogy. I can't not laugh!
Even when I'm not sad but I just want a great laugh. That and the review of The Room are pretty much my go to
I'm genuinely surprised 4/5 are from the old Nostalgia Critic, with only 1 from the relaunch. I mean I love the old stuff, but the new stuff is so next level. They're real productions ya know? Ah well, still great stuff. Happy 10th anniversary Doug. Here's to 10 more awesome years of NC.
ITS A FAMILY PICTURE!!!
Psih Opat ARE YOU HAPPY?!
JamcalX Timing
Bring the kiddies!
I WAS FROZEN TODAY!
oh hi doggy
I like how linkara explained the bat credit card
Thank you, Doug. Really, sincerely thank you. I've been watching your reviews for eight years now, throughout primary school and high school, if had ever had a crappy day, me and my sister who put on an episode. Now I'm at college and I'm still watching! :)
My favourite NOSTALGIA CRITIC video is his review of Lês Miserables, sure, moulin rouge is a great review but the songs in Lês Mis are just so catchy, I just love it, Paul and Kyle have amazing performances, I love it.
This is going to be nostalgic...
Nostalgia Critic. A FAAAMILY PICTURE.
I want you to make 4 more of these and then make a "Top 5 Top 5 Episodes" list.
Man, these ten years have flown by unbelievably fast. I'm glad I've been watching since the start, and I can't wait for another ten years with you guys.
*Keep on critiquing!*
I love how your dad was going to flip us off before Rob stopped him :) Love your work!