Charles Schwab Built This Mansion in Manhattan and Died Penniless!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 апр 2022
  • To have it all and lose it, that was the fate of Charles Schwab. He built his New York City mansion in 1906 to be the most modern house of its time, but what happened to it? Meander through the luxurious rooms as we hear Schwab's story in this video.
    Charles Schwab Built This Mansion in Manhattan and Died Penniless!!
    • Charles Schwab Built T...
    Location: Manhattan, New York
    Check out our Merch: thishouse.media
    Join our Membership program:
    / @thishouse
    Like, Comment, and Share our video!!
    Subscribe if you enjoyed this content!!
    Photos from: Museum of the City of New York, historicfresno.org, Smithsonian, Albert Ledoux
    Follow us on Facebook: / thishousemedia
    Check out our website: www.thishouse.media
    Follow us on Instagram: / thishousemedia
    Music from Epidemic Sound

Комментарии • 1,2 тыс.

  • @scottdecarrillo3082
    @scottdecarrillo3082 2 года назад +1964

    The destruction of such buildings across America, commercial or residential, with NYC certainly leading the list, is horrid. Penn Station alone is a loss unlikely ever to be replicated in our lifetimes. And then we wonder why we visit Europe, with all it's preserved (or rebuilt) grand structures....

    • @twistoffate4791
      @twistoffate4791 2 года назад +93

      That's what I was thinking. We average folk enjoy & appreciate this level of beauty, but we cannot find much of it left in our own country, so we end up going overseas to get to see it.

    • @Dina52328
      @Dina52328 2 года назад +69

      @scott, my thoughts exactly. All across the nation from big cities to small towns, beautiful, historical structures were demolished to make room for parking lots, ugly brick buildings, etc. . . If it wasn’t for the historical societies like the one in Newport who preserved the mansions there, we and future generations would not be able to look and admire the beautiful architecture of long ago. SMH 🤦‍♀️

    • @talmadge1926
      @talmadge1926 2 года назад +57

      In England (and I say this because the figures exclude Scotland Ireland and Wales) between 1900 and 1960 one thousand two hundred stately homes were demolished. Not until 1968 were they finally saved from demolition. However there are still problems concerning the wonderful examples of late victorian and of edwardian architecture as the listing system only extends to buildings built before 1840. Public opinion however is now so militant that many of this era have been saved. Albeit with an uncertain future. Mentmore (one of the Rothschild mansions) a prime example. The National trust wont take it on because they "already have another Rothschild mansion" So it stays empty and decays while officialdom twiddles its thumbs.
      The fate of american golden age architecture is really embodied in Joni Mitchells "Yellow Taxi"
      "Dont it always seem to go
      That you dont know what youve got till its gone.
      They paved paradise and put up a parking lot"
      I have read that this specifically refers to the demolition of Marion Davies (mistress of William Randolph Hurst) pink beachouse on route 66 below Hurst Castle (thank God preserved).

    • @greeneyedwarlock882
      @greeneyedwarlock882 2 года назад +27

      Could NOT POSSIBLY AGREE WITH YOU MORE. And that heinous tragedy will neverrrrrrr stop being so tragic or painful to those of us with the brains, class, sophistication & education to know it.

    • @wondergranny2299
      @wondergranny2299 2 года назад +6

      Exactly!!!

  • @loridresser9420
    @loridresser9420 2 года назад +933

    It is so sad that NYC didn’t pass a “historical district” on all the buildings surrounding Central Park. It would have added so much.

    • @juniorsir9521
      @juniorsir9521 2 года назад +28

      It’s like nobody lives in mansions like those anymore today. Everything is basic boxes now it seems

    • @daisyaviles8936
      @daisyaviles8936 2 года назад +1

      M m

    • @jasoncarter3921
      @jasoncarter3921 2 года назад +2

      @Smoggah not Schwab that’s for sure, they had two boxes on the census at the time how many children you had and how many of them were still alive, living conditions nearby were terrible but this was a very fancy house

    • @bradypetty5434
      @bradypetty5434 2 года назад +9

      @@juniorsir9521 how surprising that we don’t live in 200 million dollar mansion. Mind blowing.

    • @juniorsir9521
      @juniorsir9521 2 года назад +15

      @@bradypetty5434 it’s not that dummy. What I meant to say is that houses have no beautiful architecture nowadays. Look in the suburbs for example. Houses are built like basic boxes with a garage. houses can be built designed to look better but they are not. Not only that but houses are built so close together. Again look at suburb areas. You have windows so close together. Neighbors can see everything you do. Knowing that there is so much land around and houses being built So compressed is when you know you have a serious problem-Greed. Those 200 million dollar mansions you speak of most have been demolished to make room for parking lots.

  • @melissalentz32
    @melissalentz32 2 года назад +152

    I live only a few blocks from the present “Schwab House”. I had no idea that such a magnificent home had been on the site. As one who deeply appreciates the craftsmanship that goes into magnificent buildings of that era, I am sickened to learn of the sad demise of yet another treasured building in NY.

    • @low_key_f_key3237
      @low_key_f_key3237 Год назад +2

      Sure, but to be fair the new bldg houses a lot more people

    • @melissalentz32
      @melissalentz32 Год назад +5

      @@low_key_f_key3237 Agreed, but that doesn’t alter the fact that the old mansion now gone was a magnificent achievement and a nod to craftsmanship and inspirational beauty, while the Schwab house is just a big old brick pile which has no lasting architectural value.

    • @arslongavitabrevis5136
      @arslongavitabrevis5136 Год назад +5

      @@melissalentz32 Excellent observation Melissa, you obviously are a person with a high regard for beautiful buildings. people like us are bound to suffer a lot in this horrible era in which we live. Everything is PROFIT / UGLINESS! Have a nice weekend!

  • @aileenjackson1706
    @aileenjackson1706 2 года назад +66

    What an absolute shame to destroy such a home.

  • @DementedDistraction
    @DementedDistraction 2 года назад +53

    It's absolutely astonishing to me that such a grand structure was demolished to make way for some generic, disposable apartments.
    That mansion could've been repurposed as a museum, school, or corporate office - anything besides razing it. It makes me wonder if the powers that be at the time were lobbied or otherwise incentivized by the apartment developers to tear down the mansion.

    • @colihestonpottones4188
      @colihestonpottones4188 2 года назад +5

      Yes unfortunately it occurs worldwide. I have seen some lovely mansions replaced with concrete block apartment subdivisions.

    • @amandagardner565
      @amandagardner565 2 года назад +2

      that would have to be a huge monetary YES

    • @amandagardner565
      @amandagardner565 2 года назад

      there was a huge estate near Melbourne Victoria Australia, which was know as Kew Cottages (a mental hospitalfacility), that was sold off in the 1980(?) and redeveloped as inner city residential properties.
      how odd that one of the local government politicians pushing to the sale was also a partner in the real estate business that handled the rezoning, and sub-division of the ENTIRE project, they didn't even try to hide the blatant corruption the bastards.

    • @arslongavitabrevis5136
      @arslongavitabrevis5136 Год назад +2

      @Demented Distraction: Yes, you are right. That is democracy for you, the rule of the uneducated billionaires where the only thing that matters is PROFIT.

    • @melissalentz32
      @melissalentz32 Год назад +4

      As often happened, many of these families found themselves in difficult financial circumstances following 2 world wars and the introduction of income tax. Often these properties were sold to companies/corporations just for the amount the family would receive from the sale of the land. There’s an old family legend I was told that something similar happened to my family regarding property they owned where Macy’s now stands!

  • @deniseroe5891
    @deniseroe5891 2 года назад +332

    These homes were so incredible, the craftsmanship and technology for the time is unbelievable. I know the cost of maintaining them today would be prohibitive, but still it’s a shame that they are gone. The opulence of these homes were some how timeless and tasteful, unlike the mansions that are build today.

    • @clairetremblay3023
      @clairetremblay3023 2 года назад +8

      Could not agree more... @Denise Roe. It is very sad indeed, that these houses are destroy and not preserved. These architectures and contructions where so beautiful and well done compare to these days...

    • @darbyheavey406
      @darbyheavey406 2 года назад

      Compare this beautiful home to the monstrous home that Bill Gates built.

    • @nonelost1
      @nonelost1 2 года назад +2

      At the very least, I hope they cannibalized the exquisite interior and exterior artwork to be auctioned, rather than simply putting them to the wrecking ball. That's what they did with Titanic's sister ship, Olympic, when she was scrapped in 1934.

    • @Untilitpases
      @Untilitpases 2 года назад +5

      Maintenance cost isn't prohibilty expensive. Poorer countries can keep whole cities with neoclassical buildings. (Think central european countries, even some balkan ones like Croatia.)

    • @rpraetor
      @rpraetor 2 года назад +6

      @@Untilitpases Check out the maintenance costs on the New York State Capitol building. Your central-European solution was achieved under the same conditions these places were built: WITH CHEAP LABOR. Tourist revenue has to justify the expense of repair, at least until you solve capitalism. Give your cost argument to the 636 families who have housing due to the destruction.

  • @marksherrill9337
    @marksherrill9337 2 года назад +94

    I’m a carpenter and really wish these homes had been preserved. I suppose even that was too expensive. And to think there was a row of these homes and the interiors were more opulent than their facades. Unbelievable. In todays dollars, the costs translate to billions.

    • @rustysmith5809
      @rustysmith5809 2 года назад

      Ditto.Im a building contractor and this really irks me.

    • @veronicaroach3667
      @veronicaroach3667 Год назад +2

      My reaction to the demoition is - so who took all the incredible fittings & fixtures from the inside of this building - and what a ghastly building they put up in it's place !

    • @Coffeendonuts
      @Coffeendonuts Год назад +2

      I worked restoring row houses in the back bay of Boston as a general contractor for 2 decades. Many of Boston’s opulent mansions from the gilded age are very well preserved. I worked on the Hooper mansion. The 20000 s square foot mansion on a corner lot was sold to the church of Scientology and they preserved much of the original ornate moldings, pocket doors, coffered ceilings wainscoting. Unfortunately the developers who bought the building gutted it and put in custom luxury condos I was happy about the exterior being restored to its original glory. We redid all the copper on the dormers, repaired the slates and Touret. It was an amazing project to run

  • @lila6117
    @lila6117 2 года назад +28

    So sad that it wasn’t repurposed, can you imagine touring this beautiful building today.

  • @buzzkincaid5521
    @buzzkincaid5521 2 года назад +438

    When I see what was lost, and will never be replaced, I mourn what might have been. A culture that that lost diversity of architectural treasures. Had we reused these mansions as places to gather,art museums , clubs, think tanks, and other high minded causes , we would have built on our past as a bridge to our collective future.

    • @Jack-eo5fn
      @Jack-eo5fn 2 года назад +18

      Hear hear!

    • @Carol-D.1324
      @Carol-D.1324 2 года назад +7

      Incredibly well said.

    • @GenXGranny
      @GenXGranny 2 года назад +12

      We’ve devolved so badly, it’s sad. A banana taped to a blank canvas is “art”. All of the “art” at tjmaxx people buy, any 10 year old could paint. Everyone is too hypnotized, staring at a screen to create anything beautiful. 😞

    • @utube9000
      @utube9000 2 года назад +7

      Agree 100% - destroying that piece of art was a crime against high culture.

    • @mrtelevision8079
      @mrtelevision8079 2 года назад

      But then how this or that developer would have made another fortune? Capitalism! If the old building wasn't profitable, down it goes!

  • @Joe_Peroni
    @Joe_Peroni 2 года назад +225

    The demolition of this wondrous structure was a gross act of vandalism.

    • @brianpeck4035
      @brianpeck4035 2 года назад +8

      I hope you are just making a point and don't truly believe that. Obviously it's not anything of the kind. I've seen a few urban exploration videos of old abandoned mansions in Europe. Sometimes people buy them to renovate and get way to deep in expense and have to sell. These houses are beautiful nostalgic money pits. The pattern seems to be that the old owners, sometimes families that have owned it for hundreds of years, have financial difficulties and start selling off the land to keep the mansion/castle going. Then they sell the artwork and furnishings to keep it going and then they fail to sell the house and leave. These architectures of the gilded age are money monsters and very difficult to make financial sense of. It's wonderful when they do but saddling the city with such regular expense isn't reasonable.

    • @carolspencer9396
      @carolspencer9396 2 года назад +7

      The demolitions of grand structures like this was a gross act of viciousness, selfishness, greed , disrespect and total disregard for history and it's worth.

    • @davidkhouri8219
      @davidkhouri8219 2 года назад +16

      @@carolspencer9396 Lol. Building a $200 million dollar home for two people sounds a lot more selfish, greedy, and disrespectful if you ask me.

    • @BenDover-wm7wf
      @BenDover-wm7wf 2 года назад +4

      Some people just want to live in a museum. The irony to me is the Charles Schwabb is today an investment company trying to sell people on their expertise and stability. Yet Charles was wiped out by a stock market crash. I contrast this with Warren Buffet, living in his childhood house in Omaha, eating hamburgers at the kitchen table…

    • @davidkhouri8219
      @davidkhouri8219 2 года назад +8

      @@BenDover-wm7wf Ya this is a funny coincidence. Charles Schwab (born 1937) has no relation to Charles M Schwab (born 1862). It is odd to think how one of them lost it all in the market while the other made their fortune.

  • @leewhite-graham753
    @leewhite-graham753 2 года назад +16

    It is criminal to waste such beautiful art and architecture, IMHO.

  • @1aikane
    @1aikane 2 года назад +51

    What a great loss to have such a beautiful work of architecture removed for a bland apartment building.

    • @deanwilliams433
      @deanwilliams433 2 года назад

      True, but hundreds of people live in those apartments versus one rich family.

    • @JoelEmmettMcGarrity
      @JoelEmmettMcGarrity 2 года назад +3

      @@deanwilliams433 I would rather have that house preserved. Than demolished.

    • @deanwilliams433
      @deanwilliams433 2 года назад +1

      @@JoelEmmettMcGarrity What you want and what's best for a growing city are very different things. You can't preserve everything based on where it was located.

    • @Polemodrome
      @Polemodrome 4 месяца назад +1

      It could have been repurposed as a music academy, apparently, it had the acoustics to greet an orchestra! I guess there was a higher priority concern in accomodating the growing population, during the baby boom... Still, it stinks! This building was an irreplaceable jewel!

  • @christopherkraft1327
    @christopherkraft1327 2 года назад +150

    How exciting it must have been to live in this gilded age & stroll through the streets of New York. It's also sad that so many of these gorgeous mansions are gone!!! ☹️

    • @bellthandian
      @bellthandian 2 года назад +9

      You should see Heidelberg Hall in Schaefferstown PA! It’s a large 30 room fully gilded age furnished 12,000 sq ft 1882 Victorian mansion. The owner has been fully restoring it to historical accuracy and is now open for tours. There is an Instagram account with frequent posts showing it’s many interiors. One of very few full gilded age homes open for tours with such accuracy to the period.

    • @Helloverlord
      @Helloverlord 2 года назад +3

      ...between 1929. and 1939. it would be a blast!

    • @leroybrown505
      @leroybrown505 2 года назад +2

      The Tartarian age.

    • @marka.graffakasnakebitenat3736
      @marka.graffakasnakebitenat3736 2 года назад +2

      Concerning homes. Former Houston Rockets Center, Hakeem Olajuwan demolished a mansion built in the 1920's to put apartments on the site. The house is in Pasadena, Texas in the Clear Lake area right next to Clear Lake. The land was a ranch for many years until our government purchased it and that land became The Johnson Space Center for NASA.

    • @arslongavitabrevis5136
      @arslongavitabrevis5136 Год назад

      @@bellthandian Thank you so much for this information. I love art and architecture from 1600 to 1900. I hope they have a website as I do not live in the USA. Regards!

  • @tobygoodguy4032
    @tobygoodguy4032 2 года назад +4

    In 1910 my great-grandfather was making about $2/Day for a 10 hour shift at 'Steels' McKeesport works.
    He didn't die penniless.
    Ironic, ain't it. 🤠

  • @workoutmom2b1g
    @workoutmom2b1g 2 года назад +2

    Awful. Why do we take everything down?
    Great video Ken and Crew! ✌🏽

  • @marlenalinne7958
    @marlenalinne7958 2 года назад +25

    The fact that these incredible buildings have been destroyed is one thing. What they've been replaced with is a crime.

  • @lalaboha
    @lalaboha 2 года назад +7

    Ugh! Bad call New York. How could you let such a masterpiece be torn down? 😢

  • @gregakinson2800
    @gregakinson2800 2 года назад +17

    It is so disgusting what happens to these grand old mansions. I cannot even stand to go back to my home town because of how it has been degraded so much.

  • @brokenglass849
    @brokenglass849 2 года назад +37

    Somehow I think few people thought of it as a loss when it was demolished in 1948. I had read that in the 1920s, Victorian houses and their furnishings were seen as vulgar. That distaste persisted, at the very least, through the 1960s.

    • @StevenTorrey
      @StevenTorrey 2 года назад +8

      I myself didn't find it attractive; I thought it was too "busy".

    • @sherriianiro747
      @sherriianiro747 2 года назад +12

      In the 40's, 50's & especially the 60's the people back then all wanted "modern" structures and did not appreciate and took the craftsmanship for granted. I am sure they regretted it later when those same buildings fell apart and looked blighted years later.

    • @brokenglass849
      @brokenglass849 2 года назад +20

      @@StevenTorrey Everybody has a different take on the various styles of architecture that have existed here in the US, but it's not so much an issue of personal taste, it's issue of preserving our heritage. These buildings represent an important interlude in our development as a nation.

    • @baylorsailor
      @baylorsailor 2 года назад +10

      @@sherriianiro747 you are so right. I live in a town in northern New York and they tore down many of the beautiful mansions to build mid-century office buildings and apartments. Many of those buildings are already demolished or are abandoned today. It was a rather selfish move on their part to tear down our architectural heritage for cheap materials. The lack of preservation and foresight in the mid to late 20th century is baffling.

    • @veronicaroach3667
      @veronicaroach3667 Год назад

      Whereas homes still existing from Georgian times in the 1700's are very fine & delicate in taste with beautiful paneling & dainty banisters to the stairs - the Victorians obviously loved over the top gaudy & rather ridiculous design. Hence so much of that era is now regarded as stuffy & ugly & for a time much of it was demolished. I don't think there is any comparison with the 2 eras in terms of which is the more elegant ! However it's a shame when historical places are just destroyed. But give me a 1720 Gerogian Manor House any day over something like this horrible Victorian monstrosity !

  • @mscarolynnigro
    @mscarolynnigro 2 года назад +4

    What a disgrace to destroy these buildings. It makes no sense .

  • @Packard3spdOD
    @Packard3spdOD 2 года назад +72

    His summer mansion, Immergrün, in Loretto PA, is extant and the grounds are open to the public. His private rail cars are also extant, at the North Carolina Transportation Museum in Spencer and at the rail museum in Altoona. His starter mansion in North Braddock PA, now known as Schwixon, and within sight of the Edgar Thomson Works, Carnegie's first steel mill which he became superintendent of in 1889, is also extant. I'm writing this from the library.
    Also, the Jean-Léon-Gérôme statues, Metallurgical Worker (aka The Puddler) and the allegorical Metallurgical Science that once graced Riverside are extant as well, at the Allentown PA Art Museum.
    Architectural artifacts were sold off before demolition. If anyone knows of any items with a provenance from Riverside, please reply to this comment.

    • @arslongavitabrevis5136
      @arslongavitabrevis5136 Год назад +1

      Thank you so much for this information, very kind of you to share it. Although I do not live in the USA I shall try to find out a website or videos about these properties. Have a nice day! Greetings from Buenos Aires, Argentina; a city that was once known as the "Paris of South America" by the great number of magnificent mansions in it. Like in the USA, most of them are now sadly gone, victims of the stupidity, ignorance, and greed of the people and the politicians.

  • @gwendolyn7462
    @gwendolyn7462 2 года назад +4

    I CANT believe they tore that house down: American has so few historical houses. NEW YORK TO SHAME

  • @ardiffley-zipkin9539
    @ardiffley-zipkin9539 2 года назад +45

    I recall that the stories depicting demolition of these grand homes in NYC led to NYC’s laws on preservation of historic sites. Unfortunately, many places were lost before citizens and city leaders came to their senses.

    • @StevenTorrey
      @StevenTorrey 2 года назад +12

      The demolition off Penn Station in 1963 was the specific impetus for the Landmarks Preservation Law....in NYC.

    • @donnatlaw6172
      @donnatlaw6172 2 года назад +8

      Many thanks to Jaqueline Bouvier Kennedy Onassis for this law.

    • @rpraetor
      @rpraetor 2 года назад

      Hopefully the cost of labor has been updated since then too.

  • @SpanishEclectic
    @SpanishEclectic 2 года назад +42

    I found the design of this mansion, as well as the way it was set back from the street, much more pleasing and tasteful than others that were just huge and ornate. Perhaps it was the European Gothic touches. I too am sorry a civic use could not be found for this beautiful building. During the Depression, most of the very wealthy were in the same boat; no one could afford to buy them out. From BBC documentaries, I've learned that many estates and country homes in England were entailed, which meant only a particular family member could inherit them. Inheritance taxes were horrendous, and after WWII, few of the families could afford to maintain/restore the properties; many of the homes were 200 to 500 years old. Some were used as Military hospitals, and others turned into boarding schools. It's interesting to see the homes of the people who founded companies that still exist today.

  • @giusimastro9722
    @giusimastro9722 2 года назад +17

    that demolition made me cry, I can`t belove that America destroyed all the splendid architecture of the Gilded Age the only period in American History that produced so much beauty, I would call it the American Renaissance if Europe did destroy everything we would never be able to study History of Architecture and History in general

  • @dahby2724
    @dahby2724 2 года назад +8

    Although I love these stories...they make me sad...such beauty... gone.....

  • @scottnyc6572
    @scottnyc6572 2 года назад +9

    This has to be the most hideous ending of a rags to riches back to rags story.The palatial mansion ended being demolished and replaced with a dark brown brick monolithic housing project..

  • @Robrulz666icloud
    @Robrulz666icloud 2 года назад +6

    I watched this video in absolute disgust thankful to see such magnificent design and beyond sad to see so little respect shown.

  • @EclecticDD
    @EclecticDD 2 года назад +71

    That was really interesting, especially the fact that the house had its own power station and then served as a small clothing factory. The mansions that used to exist still seem (to me) to have been elegant even if they were built by what was considered new money at the time. I wonder if the houses were considered tacky by some back then?

    • @tamick2000
      @tamick2000 2 года назад +9

      To the average person, they were probably considered the epitome of elegance, but among the elite, yes I am sure some thought certain homes were not up to their standards.
      I am sure that within a decade of being built they were considered dated, as by then new mansions with the latest in style and innovations were built and praised.
      If you study, just a bit, the Beverly Hills, Holmby Hills and Bel Air real estate market, it is shocking how many homes are purchased and torn down to build a new McMansion. There are a lot of 20's and 30's homes with classic styling that just do not work for modern lifestyles and need a lot of work to update, so they get torn down.

    • @KCKingdomCreateGreatTrekAgain
      @KCKingdomCreateGreatTrekAgain 2 года назад +3

      True. And everyone wants those blasted open floor plans.

    • @kendallsmith1458
      @kendallsmith1458 2 года назад +9

      I don't think a bunch of rich girls hand sewing constitutes a clothing factory.

    • @missourimongoose8858
      @missourimongoose8858 2 года назад

      It was most likely a DC system which requires a power station to be close by

    • @joeb7168
      @joeb7168 2 года назад

      @@missourimongoose8858 unless it was an ether harvester

  • @trj1442
    @trj1442 2 года назад +3

    An excellent episode. A new sub in me.

  • @twistoffate4791
    @twistoffate4791 2 года назад +19

    It's amazing how quickly one man can go from having it all, to almost nothing. I would have liked to have seen all that pink granite, and look out one of the turret's windows, Rapunzel style. It was nice, though that Eurana (unfortunate name, just my opinion) invited the ladies in who sewed for the Red Cross.

  • @christians.7019
    @christians.7019 2 года назад +2

    Time to sit back and relax again☺️

  • @dawnwheeler2649
    @dawnwheeler2649 2 года назад +3

    So much more beautiful as well as quality built. Compared to todays crap it is so sad to see these beauties destroyed

  • @xc5gensttsn3egcx57
    @xc5gensttsn3egcx57 2 года назад +15

    An absolute crime that this work of art was destroyed.

  • @ItsJustLisa
    @ItsJustLisa 2 года назад +31

    What’s especially sad is that in the late 40s and into the 50s, there almost certainly weren’t architectural historians and builders specializing in historic restorations that would have been able to go into the house before demolition to rescue pieces like the marble pillars, the hand carved paneling, or any other fixtures or structures such as ceiling medallions, bannisters or stained glass windows that could be repurposed somewhere else. They were so hellbent on destroying the past that there was no thought to historical value in the future.
    The house no longer exists, but if a rescued fireplace or mahogany panels was able to help restore another historic building, part of the legacy would live on.

    • @ravenhoule948
      @ravenhoule948 6 месяцев назад +1

      I read that before demolishing they did auction off things. Probably not as much as they should've though.

  • @billcordell9797
    @billcordell9797 2 года назад +3

    So sad it was torn down. Would have been such a wonderful museum n event space today

  • @amitisshahbanu5642
    @amitisshahbanu5642 2 года назад +14

    This shows how fleeting life is and not to build stuff that can't be maintained.

  • @andiscott8470
    @andiscott8470 2 года назад +21

    It really is saddening to see what happened to some of these amazing works of art. Same in the UK when we look at what happened to a lot of country estates, quite often after WW1 or WW2, the late 60's and early 70's was a sickening time for historic architecture fans.

    • @DanaTheInsane
      @DanaTheInsane 2 года назад +4

      There is an ersatz "stately home" in Iowa, and its pieced together with architectural bits brought over in the teens and twenties from England when you could pull apart 4-600 year old buildings and pack them off anywhere you liked and nobody cared.

    • @edmurks236
      @edmurks236 2 года назад +1

      @@DanaTheInsane sad.

  • @RSMMD
    @RSMMD 2 года назад +12

    These Gilded Age mansions were not just homes. They were quite literally works of fine art. The fact that so many are lost is criminal.

  • @hortensemason4073
    @hortensemason4073 2 года назад +4

    Loved this information. Thank you 😊💓.

  • @channeldoglover9944
    @channeldoglover9944 2 года назад +11

    I'm from Tucson Arizona, there was an iconic building with incredible architecture in the 60s called the El conquistador hotel. It was torn down in 1968, and I actually cried I think. It was replaced by the first mall in Tucson. I think it would be a great story :)

    • @sandybruce9092
      @sandybruce9092 2 года назад +1

      I lived in Phoenix for 48-1/2 years before moving to NC and many of the historical buildings have been destroyed just since 1955 when we moved there. I do know that there is a new El Conquistador hotel in Tucson as we used to go down over the 4th of July for their fireworks display. Tucson, being even older than Phoenix has lost much of its historical buildings - many of which weren’t big fancy places but still very historic, especially as Arizona as a state isn’t nearly as old as many of these mansions that have now been demolished. Had friends in Tucson so got down there quite a bit (plus my son graduated from UA - I graduated from ASU!!!).

    • @channeldoglover9944
      @channeldoglover9944 2 года назад +1

      I guess this is manly about mansions not hotels but every time I see the demolition of beautiful old buildings it makes me sad and I think about the El conquistador.

  • @texxxann
    @texxxann 2 года назад +4

    What a crying shame it was demolished. A tragedy. It should have been put to public use and preserved for future generations, what a poor decision to let it go.

  • @desertsunman5880
    @desertsunman5880 2 года назад +3

    You have great taste - thx 😉😎

  • @smilingskull7827
    @smilingskull7827 2 года назад +3

    That mansion would have made a beautiful library.

  • @massabielle2821
    @massabielle2821 2 года назад +5

    You’ve got to be kidding! They DEMOLISHED this architectural, pristine, stunning gem?! An absolute sacrilege of historical proportions. SMH. 😔

  • @angelmarcano6747
    @angelmarcano6747 2 года назад +6

    This is shame that structures like that are not around, and that this country has no concept of historical buildings and history in general

  • @kslinaz5668
    @kslinaz5668 2 года назад +6

    What a beautiful building and how sad that it was torn down

  • @BulgadariXR
    @BulgadariXR 2 года назад +2

    The incredible part is that it was built in four years. Unions take three years to build four million dollar public restrooms in New York parks.

  • @kenelliott8944
    @kenelliott8944 2 года назад +5

    I just love this channel!! So interesting!!

  • @lourdesmilchorena7007
    @lourdesmilchorena7007 2 года назад +3

    To sad, they demolished those beautiful homes

  • @garyjones2582
    @garyjones2582 2 года назад +2

    It's really sad to hear of stories like this..

  • @kenziej4301
    @kenziej4301 2 года назад +4

    I’m ready to move in 🤩

  • @baylorsailor
    @baylorsailor 2 года назад +3

    😭... They should of turned the existing mansion into a library or apartments in my opinion.

  • @lj5801
    @lj5801 2 года назад +17

    Schwab went the same way as Sir Henry Pellatt builder of the magnificent Casa Loma in Toronto: had it all; lost it all. At least Casa Loma is still standing and open to the public. Excellent video.
    In addition to others that I've already mentioned, how about videos on Rose Terrace in Grosse Pointe, MI; the mansions that once lined Euclid Avenue (Millionaires Row) in Cleveland; or William Rockefeller, Jr's Rockwood Hall in Mount Pleasant, NY? There could also be a video that starts with Marjorie Merriweather Post's 1107 5th Ave mansion and segues into her 56 room penthouse (reputedly the 1st in NYC) in the building that replaced it.

    • @ThisHouse
      @ThisHouse  2 года назад +1

      Thank you for the recommendations!

  • @shawnathon60
    @shawnathon60 2 года назад +1

    I usually add these to my Education List,, very good job!

  • @catherinemtc7795
    @catherinemtc7795 2 года назад +2

    Ooohh LORD I can’t believe they knocked that beautiful house down. How awful. That is so sad.

  • @roadrunner381
    @roadrunner381 2 года назад +4

    When those beautiful mansions are demolished, I feel as though a glimpse of the past has been destroyed forever, never to be seen again, what a shame!

  • @stevenkaskus6173
    @stevenkaskus6173 2 года назад +5

    Worse than sad that this beautiful grand home with all its beautiful craftsmanship wasn't saved and put on a Nat'l historic registry.

  • @anteeker
    @anteeker 2 года назад +68

    That beautiful structure, with all that amazing woodwork, stonework, stained glass, etc, and replaced with yet another ugly plain high rise. NYC could have been such a beautiful city had they not torn down all these amazing buildings and replaced them with ugly concrete, glass and steel - buildings that you drive by and don`t even notice because they all look the same and have no architectural significance. Blah blah blah boring.

    • @talmadge1926
      @talmadge1926 2 года назад +3

      I asked a friend of mine (an architect) why are new buildings lacking any attempt at "facade" or grace. His answer was unfortunately definitive. "Because the client wont pay for it"

    • @mport09
      @mport09 2 года назад +2

      Boring because they're dull and ugly. Seeing many of the same gorgeous structures would still feel stimulating, like in many towns where houses are very similar, but stunning.

  • @t.b.1596
    @t.b.1596 2 года назад +5

    Great presentation but a very sad story. So much of our history is lost to the wrecking ball!

  • @StamperWendy
    @StamperWendy 2 года назад +3

    Fabulous, thank you! This house is the perfect dwelling to have as a subject...

  • @juacuri
    @juacuri 2 года назад +4

    Love your videos... Can't get enough of all this gorgeous buildings.. Thanks for the information... Super interesting

  • @lisasargent2841
    @lisasargent2841 2 года назад +1

    I love your channel. Thank you very much for making the wonderful videos for all to learn & enjoy.

  • @Jakecooks
    @Jakecooks 2 года назад +2

    such a shame that a home like that had to be destroyed. Seeing his fate should teach people today to be careful with your money, just never know whats going to happen.

  • @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki
    @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki 2 года назад +15

    Central heating (and air conditioning) came in right around this time. There's a stone house in Victoria that was built near the turn of this century, but without central heating it's extremely expensive to maintain. That doomed a lot of these stone edifices. They were just too short of their time. Plus remember there was no income tax in those days, so maintenance was where the cash went.

    • @StevenTorrey
      @StevenTorrey 2 года назад +6

      The land ended up being more valuable than the house.

  • @stevenrice9221
    @stevenrice9221 2 года назад +4

    That was very informative I didn’t know anything about that mansion! Thank you 🙏

  • @jacobmoses3712
    @jacobmoses3712 2 года назад +21

    It's interesting how several of the wealthy people whose homes you have featured, were mot good stewards of their wealth and blew a large part of their fortune on a magnificent house and didn't consider that circumstances or tastes would change and their houses would end up albatrosses around their necks

    • @rcs3030
      @rcs3030 2 года назад +1

      And yet we still have such big spenders in the Hollywood world today.

    • @hewitc
      @hewitc 2 года назад +2

      Like all the waterfront mansions in Miami Florida that will be underwater because of rising water levels. People refuse to consider the future even if it's just around the corner.

  • @jimwiskus8862
    @jimwiskus8862 2 года назад +10

    Heartbreaking how nearsighted bureaucrats can be.

  • @kurtwollermann2210
    @kurtwollermann2210 2 года назад +3

    those beautiful houses would make fantastic libraries

  • @martentrudeau6948
    @martentrudeau6948 2 года назад +3

    It was a beautiful castle and replaced by ordinary apartment building. Kinda a shame, isn't it!

  • @jeffpetrie7744
    @jeffpetrie7744 2 года назад +1

    Beautiful house!! Almost as beautiful as the Pittock Mansion in Portland, Oregon.

  • @lenoreleitch5297
    @lenoreleitch5297 2 года назад +2

    Noooooo. Demolishing a piece of art, a piece of history, for that hideous apartment tower block?? Unreal.

  • @JDSFLA
    @JDSFLA 2 года назад +3

    Destroying this house is equal to razing the classic Pennsylvania Station in Manhattan.

  • @PanteA..
    @PanteA.. 2 года назад +3

    I am very sorry to see what they did to that magnificent mansion. Not cool.☹☹☹

  • @SAXONWARLORD1000AD
    @SAXONWARLORD1000AD 2 года назад +2

    WOW - HOW INSANE IS THAT , KNOCKED DOWN THEN REPLACED WITH THE MOST HORRIBLE LOOKING BLOCK YOU COULD IMAGINE

  • @antoniafoster8264
    @antoniafoster8264 Год назад +1

    Such a sad story!!! I cannot believe it was demolished! Makes me physically sick! And, what was put in its place is disgraceful & ugly.

  • @muffassa6739
    @muffassa6739 2 года назад +12

    I wish I could have seen these beautiful mansions before they were torn down. We have some here in Michigan that you can see, but many many more have been torn down. If you're interested and in Michigan check out Meadow Brooke in Rochester Hills

    • @ThisHouse
      @ThisHouse  2 года назад

      Thank you for the recommendation!

    • @erikh9991
      @erikh9991 2 года назад

      I drive around Beverly Hills but there are too many trees and gates to see most things. Google maps is my friend.

  • @anthonyboarman3833
    @anthonyboarman3833 2 года назад +4

    The property the houses stood on, became so expensive they were sold for redevelopment.

  • @StevenTorrey
    @StevenTorrey 2 года назад +1

    The phrase "ugly ostentation" comes readily to mind.

  • @bobcaygeon6799
    @bobcaygeon6799 Год назад +1

    Sometimes I wish I'd not watched these videos 😞 You don't know what you're missing...until you do. Thank you 'This House' all the same.

  • @timcsont6985
    @timcsont6985 2 года назад +3

    a building like this should of become a museum, a centre of the arts, hotel.... something that would keep the historical fabric of the area, because you can't replace something like this.

  • @A808K
    @A808K 2 года назад +4

    As a follow-up it would be fun to know how the marble columns, mahogany paneling, stained glass windows, art work, etc were repurposed.

    • @monicaluketich6913
      @monicaluketich6913 10 месяцев назад

      They probably were not re-purposed. That in itself is a shame. Things like those windows will never be recreated again.

  • @k.6160
    @k.6160 2 года назад +2

    Wow. Interesting as a former Schwab employee. It's a shame the grand home couldn't have been saved.

  • @donovanreimer2324
    @donovanreimer2324 2 года назад

    A terrific video in all ways. Thank you!

  • @christophermyers3758
    @christophermyers3758 2 года назад +5

    Thank you for this video about the
    Charles Schwab mansion! 🤗
    I was wondering when it was demolished 😠 in 1948, if any architectural details ie. wood paneling, stained glass windows,
    the organ, or even furnishings were saved? And what happened to his art collection? Did anything go to museums, ie. The Met?
    As for the horrible high-rise that rose on the site, I would be ashamed/embarrassed to be known as the architect "responsible"! 😔

  • @sandrabateman3015
    @sandrabateman3015 2 года назад +3

    What a crime. House should have been saved.

  • @snowvalkyrie
    @snowvalkyrie 2 года назад +1

    Hello, This House! I stumbled on your channel after watching a documentary on New York during the great depression. The documentary was mediocre at best, but this channel looks like an absolute gem of a find!

  • @geoffreyselvage1673
    @geoffreyselvage1673 2 года назад +1

    Magnificent subject matter and commentary as usual.

  • @AT-cy7im
    @AT-cy7im 2 года назад +3

    Horrid, just horrid how they demolished that marvelous place and built the ugly apartments. Would you Excuse me please, I am going to trow up now.

  • @phyllas121
    @phyllas121 2 года назад +2

    It’s sad how they destroyed this beautiful house !!

  • @PandaBear8795
    @PandaBear8795 2 года назад +1

    That was a heartbreaking story 💔 but thank you for sharing it

  • @OnyxMoneyDrops
    @OnyxMoneyDrops 2 года назад +6

    I have 2 suggestions for videos for you, both in Toronto Canada
    - Casa Loma (castle in downtown Toronto which still stands)
    - smallest house in Toronto (was built in a driveway between 2 houses and was featured on Ellen many years ago)
    Great content and I’d love to see your take on these places.

    • @ThisHouse
      @ThisHouse  2 года назад +2

      Thank you for the suggestions, cheers!

  • @cassandraralph5906
    @cassandraralph5906 2 года назад +6

    This particular house is the victim of so called progress in the US of America!!! Really?! Thank you for this most interesting and educational video!

  • @stuffchat
    @stuffchat Год назад +1

    I always wanna cry at the horrid end something so beautiful was made to come to.

  • @amyjones8696
    @amyjones8696 2 года назад

    That is so very sad!! What a beautiful place to loose the history!!! Thank you for sharing!!

  • @twmcmahan
    @twmcmahan 2 года назад +3

    The house is beautiful. The person is not. All of that wealth extracted from steel towns and moved to Manhattan, enough to build that giant monstrosity of a house... and now those steel towns are ghost towns.

    • @milieu675
      @milieu675 2 года назад

      There's no correlation there. If you want to bring industry back then lend your voice to a movement and send a message to globalist politicians to get out of bed with China by voting them out of office. Cheap Chinese steel killed American steel.
      Imagine the greed of CEOs who decided to import cheap Chinese steel instead of producing it domestically.

  • @TaDarling1
    @TaDarling1 2 года назад +8

    It's a shame that more can't be done to preserve these beautiful structures as museums where their beauty can be appreciated by all. That's why I love cities like Galveston.

  • @papichullo8451
    @papichullo8451 Год назад

    Keep up the great videos. Watched 2 already. Love it

  • @lindadeal3344
    @lindadeal3344 2 года назад +1

    Loved the video...I am a subscriber!!!

  • @vincentschicchi4647
    @vincentschicchi4647 2 года назад +3

    When I watch your channel. I always end up being sad. Such a loss. Check out the history on an old Elizabethan home from Long Island “ Inisfada”. Sadly demolished just 3 years ago. This country NEEDS To protect its history before there’s nothing left

    • @ThisHouse
      @ThisHouse  2 года назад

      Thank you for the suggestion!