LIVE: Hannah Payne Sentencing | Car Crash Vigilante Trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 дек 2023
- LIVE COURT CAM: Hannah Payne faces a potential life sentence after she was convicted by a jury of murder for the death of Kenneth Herring. Loved ones of both the victim and the defendant will give statements. Should the judge grant her the possibility of parole?
After 1 hour and 29 minutes, the jury in Georgia found defendant Hannah Payne GUILTY of fatally shooting Kenneth Herring during a traffic dispute. Payne, 25, faces a possible life sentence for shooting Kenneth Herring, 62, in the abdomen when she was 21.
#CourtTV What do YOU think? Is this justice? ⚖️👇 #CarCrashVigilanteTrial MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/hannah-pa...
#hannahpayne
TRIAL NOTES
00:03:28 Defense Attorney Matthew Tucker Apologizes to the Court
00:05:14 State & Defense Opening Statement
00:10:50 STATE’S FIRST WITNESS - VICKIE LYNN HERRING, victim's sister
00:15:50 STATE’S SECOND WITNESS - JACQUELYN HERRING, victim's sister
00:20:57 STATE’S THIRD (FINAL) WITNESS - KEITH HERRING, victim's brother
00:25:21 EVIDENCE OF EXTENUATION AND MITIGATION
00:26:43 DEFENSE FIRST WITNESS - REANA NOVOTNY, longtime friend of the family
00:39:15 DEFENSE SECOND WITNESS - Melissa Morris, co-worker of Hannah Payne
00:46:40 DEFENSE THIRD WITNESS - VICTOR SNEED, Hannah’s neighbor
00:51:34 STATE’S CLOSING ARGUMENT
00:58:23 DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT
01:05:56 Short recess so Judge Scott can consider her sentence
01:19:45 SENTENCING
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE www.courttv.com/trials/
WHERE-TO-WATCH www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
TRIAL NOTES
00:03:28 Defense Attorney Matthew Tucker Apologizes to the Court
00:05:14 State & Defense Opening Statement
00:10:50 STATE’S FIRST WITNESS - VICKIE LYNN HERRING, victim's sister
00:15:50 STATE’S SECOND WITNESS - JACQUELYN HERRING, victim's sister
00:20:57 STATE’S THIRD (FINAL) WITNESS - KEITH HERRING, victim's brother
00:25:21 EVIDENCE OF EXTENUATION AND MITIGATION
00:26:43 DEFENSE FIRST WITNESS - REANA NOVOTNY, longtime friend of the family
00:39:15 DEFENSE SECOND WITNESS - Melissa Morris, co-worker of Hannah Payne
00:46:40 DEFENSE THIRD WITNESS - VICTOR SNEED, Hannah’s neighbor
00:51:34 STATE’S CLOSING ARGUMENT
00:58:23 DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT
01:05:56 Short recess so Judge Scott can consider her sentence
01:19:45 SENTENCING
Thank you
The State hit the nail on the head when they referenced Hannah's audacity and sense of entitlement whether it was due to race or being young and stupid is irrelevant. For whatever sick reason or flawed thought process, she believed that she had the right to intervene in a matter that didn't effect her, chase, detain/hold hostage another person, and ultimately shoot and kill him without regard for his life for in her own words "hitting her car." There absolutely is a sickness of entitlement in society. People believe they can do anything no matter what because they are entitled to do it even when told by authority to stop. Her comments after shooting him showed an overwhelming sense of entitlement because in her mind her car was more valuable than his life, and it underscores her belief that she had a right to do it. It really is sick. The State didn't invoke race in its presentation. However, the media did. The fact that Hannah dated a couple black men does show that she is open to relationships with black men and possibly may not be racist. However, it doesn't mean that race was not a motivating factor here. We all see color and our perceptions are filtered through that lens both good and bad. It is likely that her ideas and perceptions surrounding his race caused her to act in a different manner in that situation than if he had been white. I find myself asking the question, "If he were white, would it have ended the same way?"
Thanks 😊
Thank you!
She was 21-years old when she did this. What the heck was on her mind when she chased the guy then killed him?! She was so young, now look… she will be at least in her forties when she is released. Stupid girl! These red necks rarely think before they act. Morris the pity 😢!
Her demeanor is striking. That prosecutor did her job at the end!!! Kudos!!! The REAL HANNAH PAYNE is a screaming, cursing, aggressive, lying, murdering monster thug.
Yes! For sure she has to be an angry person to take the law in her own hands when it’s not her family or herself, or anyone that she know, just wow!!! Angry and vindictive!
I couldn't have said better....thank you!!!
Yes The DA said what she said! I was cracking up while she was talking about the murderer's character watch the first witness face!
Yep a Thug
💯
Her attorney is the most disrespectful man. Talking while witnesses are speaking from their heart and shaking his head at everything... just to name a few things over the course of this trial. What a jerk.
That was horrible for tge family 😢
Clicking his pen the entire time he was talking, drove me crazy!!
and don’t forget showing up late cuz he was “sick” smh
Me too!@@WhiteRabbit1209
Knew he wouldn’t be on time.@@angieb5720
Hannah never apologized to the family. She has no remorse.
Yes that part 🤣 her up bringing.
Black lives aren’t valued as high to her
They don’t deserve an apology.
@@lsdvd4206 I see that you are really mad that this Karen went to jail. Get over it and stop spreading hate.
@@lsdvd4206
The fact that she didn’t speak at her own sentencing and offer some sort of apology to the Herring family makes her 43 year sentence even more justified.
@@shindles life with parole in GA = 30 years before you’re eligible + 8+5 ran consecutively = 43 years
@albertblandshaw7790
You only serve 85% of your time in state, and 100% in federal.
@@ericfitzpatrick5319 I served 17 years in federal prison, you serve 85%
never showed an ounce of remorse, knowing the hurt and grief she put on this family. she's incredibly selfish and incredibly callous. its easy to picture her as a racist because she acts like Mr. Harring's existence offended her.
@@ericfitzpatrick5319
We see u got your law degree from the University of Law & Order & passed the Nancy Grace School of Teevee Lawyers Bar examination.
Don't worry. 99.5% of the commentors here in Youboob land don't even have those certifications. So congratulations on that.
So because she dated a black guy that means what? Irregardless of if she is racist or not she murdered another human being and the law says you must pay for that crime point blank period
He gave a interview and said he is not black that he is Dominican
Yes that part 🤣
What does race to do with ANYTHING? STOP MAKING IT AN ISSUE, bc its not.
@@priscilliacarter1144 i no black i Dominican 😂😂
@@hanifmartin7505I thought Dominican people were black. 🤷♀️ idk. Ppl say Mexicans are white too and I thought they were Hispanics. Not trying to be argumentative it’s just confusing. Only in America. Other countries don’t seem to label.
The nerve of the defense lawyer to say "she HAD to pull her gun to PROTECT herself and it went off. Thank God she wasn't shot by it." Like wtf.....lock his ass up too!! 🤬
RIGHT?! Audacity ran rampant on that side....explains why he's her attorney. SMH
I agree to lock his ass up for acting stupid. Not only that, he tried to make the witness look like she was a criminal, lawyers should not be allowed to bully witnesses.
I am still shaking from his assessment. This defense attorney is as dangerous and evil as she is!!
I think she used a Groupon hiring this attorney. I think she stood no chance no matter who the attorney was.
Lock up your emotions. His job, as is part of the justice system, is to give an emphatic and zealous defense of his client. Without that, we would potentially have mob rule trials. She's guilty af, but the justice system still needs to run its course.
Why was Hannah so helpful, thoughtful and kind to everyone around her, but so harmful and deadly to Mr. Herring?
Yes that part 🤣
Yeah that’s where I’m at…
This!!! I don't buy her little miss mother Theresa act, personally...
Good point🤔
Yall gone and say it cause he was a black man
I don’t care what Hannah did at work…she sh*t that man in cold blooded murder! She just should have minded her business and kept it moving! Under the jail is where she deserves to be. No matter what race the victim was, he did not deserve this.
🎉 Exactly! Thats it thats all. No other commentary needed.
This woman has no remorse. Helping people doesn’t mean-to chase down and murder them.
It’s the Card that she thought she would play
lol. He attacked her right?
@@malinoisnation9392lol, she attacked him, cut him off in traffick and brandished her gun, right, before shooting him. He had EVERY right to defend himself.
Correct
@@malinoisnation9392no!!!!!
The defense attorney is so disrespectful. He attacks and blames everyone for his client’s actions. I’m am so glad the brother of the victim called him for trying to paint the victim as a nobody and a drug user when he had no drugs or alcohol in his system.
Hannah Payne had no right to box the victim in and try to force him out of his car by gun point like she was law enforcement.
Every word of that defense Attorney got my blood boiling! She deserved life without the possibility of parole.
He's an idiot
That's his JOB as a defense attorney, dummy.
That is what a defense attorney is supposed to do even though they know she killed that man they’re supposed to “defend” you. It’s insane
@@jamesreynolds4487
You can defend your client without being an a hole to the witnesses. Actually being rude and unlikable in the courtroom doesn’t go over well with the jury which doesn’t help your client
This could have gone so different if she just apologized for her wrong doing. In my opinion it’s the lack of remorse and inability to see the victim as a victim that led to this sentence. She wanted to blame the victim and that’s unforgivable. Nobody believes that he shot himself.
She covered her shirt before the police got there so we don’t actually know when it was ripped and ripped all her acrylic nails off and put them in her pocket in the interrogation room. I think she watch too much TV & thought it was going to be complicated that they were going to need DNA etc. She never bargained for the video.
I’m glad it didn’t. Just because someone apologies dosent mean anything unless it’s sincere. I’m glad she showed her true colors because she doesn’t deserve anything.
No evidence is what lead to this sentence she can keep the same energy she had on that day she going to need it while incarcerated !
She can apologize all day it wouldn’t mean or change a thing because she’s a heartless evil person
Even if he shot himself were the case ..she's still responsible like the prosecutor said she should have minded her business
When the lady was talking about her dating black men and other races that annoyed me greatly as that has no bearing on being racist. Good riddance to her and I’m glad that justice was served.
Dating a black person doesn't mean that you're not racist. 🥺
Apparently she thinks if you date them, you can murder them!
Thank you for understanding that.
@@gloriajohnson3865sometimes they are the most racist just hiding it well, get her mad enough n words start flying false allegations
It’s possible for someone to date a person of a different race and be racist towards that race.
I’m so glad she was held accountable for her actions.
I can’t stand Karen’s either.
This woman lied her entire testimony. She was belligerent and arrogant. It’s hard to feel sorry for her.
Yes that part 🤣
If not for video evidence that was then collaborated by independent eye witnesses, her lies would have prevailed. Thank God for folks who capture videos.
@@chetcee77 yes that part 🤣
she was assaulted and took down a criminal. you’re the liar
@@lsdvd4206 That poor guy didn't deserve to die. He'll never see daylight. After 13 years she will be free on good behavior.
Notice she never cried while his family spoke only cried when it was about her and her family SMH NO REMORSE
She only cried for herself
Absolutely. Hopefully she will learn compassion and remorse while she is incarcerated. This shouod give her time to reflect instead of deflecting
She didn't shed any tears until she was found guilty. It's a tragic loss for two families due to her vigilante justice. To add injury, the nerve to say she dated a "black man" and to bring up prayer and use a black character witness is disturbing. Really? She made her choices, she has to face the consequences. May God have mercy on her. Her choices have devastated two families & others. Such a tragic situation. Her defense made this about race, not the prosecution. Mr. Herring's family will never get to see him alive again. 😢 And she never once apologized or accepted responsibility for her actions!
Yes that part 🤣 crying because she got caught 😭
Right. We already knew she carried racial hatred, but they had enough to nail her without using racism or hate crime charges. Her lawyer was also trash. Glad she was found guilty on all charges- the jury did a great job, the prosecutors and the judge. 👏🏻
I absolutely agree with you. She took the law into her own hands. She’s no hero she's a killer. Shame on her for taking this man’s life.
Anytime a white person does something to a person of color, they try to interject race, so understand trying to show she isn't racist. Never works that way in reverse.
@@yvettemoreel4237 yes that part 🤣
Proximity to blackness, doesn't mean you're not racist
Why are YOU making it about race?
I think they were just commenting on the statements made in her defense. They didn't just pluck the thought out of thin air. 😊
I get it, so often people argue, "So-n-so isn't a racist, they have black friends."
It is a pretty lousy argument.
I don't think Hannah was racist; I think she was stupidv and entitled.
@@charsiu_808😂 that criminal is jail for life 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why does the black lady in yellow have on a shirt that says “black voters” etc .. I didn’t catch it’s meaning. What if white people wore a shirt that said the opposite would that portray discrimination? I’m so confused on this racism issue. No race should feel more superior than the other. I do believe Hannah was labeled a racist and she didn’t get a fair trial. She didn’t have a chance. She was guilty -
not saying she wasn’t but her fate was sealed the moment the trial started. Shady witnesses taking the truth of what happened and putting a spin on it. I was glad to hear about Hannah’s character however she made a terrible decision and caused the death of poor Mr. Herring, may he Rest In Peace. My condolences to his brother and sisters. Their memories of him were touching.
@@suzannaj3834it’s about making black votes matter to black people 😂😂😂 it’s has nothing to do with white people or being superior 😂😂😂
Congratulations Hannah you played yourself! RIP to the victim and only victim in this whole senseless situation …..⚖️💔
The prosecution was absolutely phenomenal. They did have a lot to work with considering all of the witnesses, video and audio evidence, but they still did a great job for Mr. Herring and his family.
She has to do almost 40 years before she goes before the parole board. She's 25 now, so she'll be more than 60 when she asks for parole. Now that's justice!!
Thank you. Sro does that include the consecutive time?
In GA, it is 30 years before seeing that Board, and THEN she has 8, followed by 5. 43 altogether before the possibility of being released. 25+30+8+5=68. She will be older than Mr. Herring. Pretty sad when you think about it all.
@@sus-tw2lsin Georgia, where I served 27 years on a life plus 30 years sentence, the parole board will merge everything into the life sentence, so the consecutive sentences won't matter by the time it gets to the parole board. Since I was convicted the minimum time that must be served on a life sentence has been increased tremendously. The minimum time when I was convicted in 1991 was 7 years (of course no one was ever paroled that soon) now the minimum is 30 years. She will not make her first parole unless she has accomplished exemplary things in prison. So it's my guess that she'll see about 37 years
@@aletheaskinner8888the consecutive sentences will not have to be served. The life sentence is the overriding sentence. You're correct on the 30 years minimum but incorrect about the consecutive sentences. The parole board automatically merges them. Trust me, I'm not proud of it but I was sentenced to life plus 30 years in Georgia, back when the first parole hearing was only 7 years after conviction. But the board didn't seriously consider letting lifers out until we had served 25 years. Now that the minimum is 30 years, I think she'll serve about 35-37 years.
I agree that the defense lawyer showed no respect during the entire trial and his weak, meaningless words to Mr. Herring about “closure” on the death of his brother was trite and heartless. What was amazing was the incredibly graceful response of Mr. herring’s brother of “Thank you.”
The word and even the concept of "closure" is over rated. When a loved one is taken at the hands of another, the grief is different than that of one who died from disease or perhaps an accident.
His brother showed character in his response to her attorney. He is a Southern gentleman in his manner.
She deserves life in prison
No
The best part of her life is gone.the glory days
Life in prison at 22 😂 for one stupid decision. Would you say that if races were reversed?
@@SKA343what? Yes.
@@SKA343HELL YES!!!! She executed that man!
I can’t think of a single coworker I’ve ever had that I would testify as a character witness for to justify them murdering someone.
That shows how nice Hannah is.
@@Woodman-Spare-that-tree Yea, she so nice that she chased a man down not knowing if he was having a medical emergency or not because in her mind he was drunk and ran from the scene of an accident so she so high and mighty that she jumped on her high horse and chased after a man then pulled a gun on him and shot him DEAD!!! Then LIED and said he shot himself!! SHE IS A MURDERER & A LIAR!! She is not NICE!
@@Woodman-Spare-that-treeare you part of the kkk
She never justified it imo
She may be a 'jack of all trades' at work but it didn't qualify her to be a law enforcement officer or to take a life. She disobeyed a direct order from somebody in authority. She needs to stop trying to take charge wherever she may be. It pays to be humble and take a backseat at times in my opinion. RIP Kenneth Herring and strength to your family.
Bullseye
Yes that part 🤣
Even if we ignored the fact she’s a murderer, she sounds completely insufferable in general
She is super woman
Her attorney is terrible, and probably got her that extra 8 years. She deserves every bit though.
No complaints here
Extra 13
13 years before she can go before the parole board. But will she show any remorse then?
Yeah that 🤡 didn’t do her any favors
😂😂😂😂😂
When I hear WP say...
I'm not racist, I have black friends"...
I just SMH at their lack of awareness with that statement.
Oh gee' thanks for being our "Friends", we don't know where we would be without your friendship. 😮
And the fact that the prosecution never mentioned race during the trial. Why would Hannah's character witness get on the stand and say that ignorant stuff. 😮
That’s a brilliant comment. They’re so self-absorbed, they cannot see how offensive and patronizing that ‘I have black friends’ claim is.
I get it and need these kind of reminders about how racist a statement like that really is even though I am a privileged white woman in Canada. We do the same sort of thing with our bias against First Nations people here in Canada. I cannot deny that it continues to happen but I do not want to continue to be one of them. I need this kind of education to see the stereotyping. 😊I am biased due to my continuous exposure from my parents and all those around me that perpetuate the stereotyping. I need to hear from people like you to help me change that
Continuous bombardment of derogatory statements and to understand that such statements are NOT harmless.
Guess we just won't be friends then 🤷
All she had to do was call 911 and wait for the police!
She called 911 they told 4 times not to follow
She didn't want to hear that not to follow, She just had to kill a black person 😠
She did, gave them the tag number and still chased him after 911 said don't multiple times.
@@styner3 She's crying 😭 because she is going to prison. She never showed any remorse.
@@gloriajohnson3865 race had nothing to do with it! Even the victims sister said it wasn’t a race issue!
The defense attorney was also disrespectful in the whole trial. He never made light of how important this man was of how important his human life was. He rolled his eyes, shook his head when the prosecutor got up there and said that this man should be alive today spending the holidays with his family. I thought that was very disrespectful and the judge should’ve caught that and called him up to the sidebar. instead, this man got to sit there as a lawyer and act so unprofessional shake his head his face when the prosecutor was discussing that this man was a human that he had a life he had a family. He’s been disrespectful throughout the whole trial. He’s been unprofessional to say the least.he made the court wait for 30 minutes today and then he doesn’t even understand the sentence. He needs to have his degree suspended until he gets some continuing education.
That's because he's a good old white boy from down south who doesn't regard a black person's life the same way as he regards a white person's life!
He's a defense lawyer , why would he
I thought she had a horrible lawyer. I wouldn't want him defending me for anything.
What do you expect, the family probably hired him because his racist views aligned with theirs
😮😮😮😮😮😮😊😅😊😅😅😅😊😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😊😮😊😊😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😊😊😊😅😢😊😅
Old girl looked ROUGH today. Guess that’s what facing consequences does to a person. 🤷🏻♀️
Wow she really did 😮oh well.
🧐👀🤦🏾♂️🤣👏🏾
She gained a lot of weight, and yes, she looks horrible. Reality has set in. No welcome home party.
She still can’t believe no one believed her story
When not one of her family members had a statement....that speaks volumes. Smh
They had a lot to say to the press when she was initially bonded out years ago. They said enough, and they're as delusional and unapologetic as she is.
She cold ass ice .
They know the real Hannah
The prosecutor brought it home in the end 👏👏 "The real Hanna was the one on the 911 call..she didn't cry for the victim she only cried for herself" 🎉
The defense attorney stated the witnesses were disrespectful. I’d like him to watch a video of himself during this trial. He was one of the most disrespectful attorneys I have ever seen.
Yes he was, even with that half hearted apology to the brother of the victim. He's the one who was very disrespectful to all in my opinion.
He didnt put any effort in this case because he knew it wasnt much to fight for. He was defeated already. He knew the prosecution was going to eat him alive.
That is one hell of a disrespectful defence attorney!!!
This is very interesting to watch…Hannah is crying for herself, she feels no remorse for her actions. This entire situation could have been avoided if she had just minded her own business and NOT followed him, let alone pull a gun out on him and threaten him with it. Hopefully she’ll think twice before acting.
My Dad was very fond of telling me to "mind my own business" (which I do). This case demonstrates how a person can ruin their life by not minding their own business. She played a stupid game and won a stupid prize.
She only cries when people say nice stuff about her🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
We all get empty chairs at the table as our loved ones leave us but to have a chair made empty because of a stranger’s choice, a stranger that had no business sticking her nose in in the first place
Lord Vickie had me bawling ❤RIP Ken
Edit: Hannah needs to put on her big girl’s underwear now and stop the crying
This pitiful excuse for a defence lawyer needs to be disciplined.
Those crocodile tears should've been shed for the man you murdered, not the verdict & subsequent penalties...
Well said
Did he hit her ?
@@malinoisnation9392did she block him in?
@@malinoisnation9392if you attempt to run someone off the road, break check, you trap them, the fault is yours. Agree or disagree?
Facts. She never shed a tear for that man and that was very clear.
The idea that he can call the witnesses “disrespectful” when his client quite literally murdered a man for no reason is almost laughable, except since someone died because of her actions, it’s more asinine.
Yes that part 🤣
She still and her family believe she was justified in her actions 😢 horrible family. Hes life meant something
Thankfully it doesn't matter what they think, she will serve her sentence. Theyre sick people and we have plenty of those running around, unfortunately.
Yes it was Hannah up bringing. Black life doesn't matter to them.
Reality has set in. No welcome home party.
Bad people
@@JP-gx8fc yes that part 🤣
By the time she gets paroled, her parents will be gone and her friend's and extended family members will be busy with their families and grandchildren who won't know her from a hole in the wall. She is the one who brought sorrow to her own family members and also grief to Mr Herring's survivors.
Mine your business
This lawyer is horrible. She deserves what she got but her lawyer definitely did not help her at all.
Blame it on the system- there’s not to many good defense attorneys to help a guilty person out. Seconds can turn into Life 😢 -
Agree. Her attorney continually tried to lead her during his questioning, and the only defense he gave was that she is young, she killed that man but had good intentions and that she is a good person. And when he asked if she would change anything, she said she would never "help" anyone again?? Even with him so obviously trying to lead hereto show a bit of remorse, she just could not do it because she feels she had the right to do what she did. Her lawyer helped seal her fate. She deserves every second of her sentence.
Agree
@@trishwedin4664SHE SHOULD BE FREED AND GIVEN A MEDAL FOR TAKEN A WORTHLESS CRIMINAL OFF THE STREETS
And he needs to stop clicking that damn pen
That Bisquit story broke my heart…God help that family !
Hannah still couldn’t be bothered to express any remorse or contrition. She could have still maintained her innocence but said that she’s sorry Mr. Herring died. She deserves the sentence she got. She’s lucky she even got the chance for parole. That’s better than Mr. Herring’s fate.
Totally agree.
She will get paroled. She don't deserve it.
She seemed emotionless until she heard that guilty verdict. It's horrible, quite narcissistic! No apology for her actions, and blame-shifting, and she took no accountability. She took the law into her own hands.
This
@@michael4647the victims family gets to speak at the parole hearing. So you never know.
So her friends can say what she did was wrong, but Hannah cannot. She had 4 years to show remorse but no, it’s all about her. State described her perfectly.
That good person and outstanding citizen, should serve her well in prison. She will have all the time needed to help those in need, mow plenty of lawns, and work in the vegetable patch. She will at the very least have time to cultivate new friends.
Do you write when you’re drunk?
@@Millerx1-rq1gpTheir writing is excellent and funny.... yours is garbage. Let's see you write a paragraph that funny and well written ?
@@Millerx1-rq1gp
No, but know that it becomes more prolific when I do.
It spoke wonders to me when Hannah's response to what she would do differently consistently has been, " I just won't help people anymore." She never grasped that her originally stopping to be a witness for the original accident was not the problem.
Her attorney is also deluded.
You can have friends and partners who are minorities, you don’t have to be a full fledged white cloaked racist, and still hold biases and act on them. But I understand why people who are close to her feel how they do. She got lucky with parole.
there's a lot of anti white racists on this board. What a sad people on here for you are to use color as a weapon for your defense.
Are you kidding? Lucky with parole? I live on the south side of Chicago where armed “people” commit robbery, home invasion, car theft with guns and get like 3 years and parole. The state never even proved who pulled the trigger in this case. Chock full of reasonable doubt. This is another mob justice trial.
She tried to play Iam not racist and I have black friends, please!! Give her life without parole like Mr.Herring got. We are SO TRIED OF THIS WHITE ON BLACK CRIME. SO SICK OF WHITE PEOPLE THINKING THAT THEY ARE SUPERIOR TO BLACK PEOPLE. LET THIS SEND A MESSAGE JUST LIKE THE AMARD AUBREY CASE WITH THOSE WHITE RACISTS. THIS IS GOING TO STOP 🛑WE ARE TRIED OF THESE PEOPLE POLICING BLACK AND BROWN PEOPLE LET THIS BE A LESSON.THIS IS NOT THE OLD SOUTH WE ARE NOT HAVING IT.
Her parents look pretty old. She’ll be lucky if they’re alive if she ever gets out. She’d be 68 at the youngest.
@@MKUltra42She wont ever get out. She has a life sentence plus 8 and 5 years
She is George Zimmerman
Once Zimmermann got away with murder alot of them had dreams of pulling the same act off but it's a roll of the dice to say you'll getaway with murdering someone and crying self defense when you initiate the violence
@@dionellwalker9762 well said
These people putting a good light on her is sickening she murdered an innocent man
Not innocent
You haven't been following this properly HAVE YOU?!🤦
He wasn't innocent, he ran a red light and could have killed someone. Not that he deserves to die but she in her turn deserves everything she got.
@@Manu_Lemoine_FR Car accident, leaving the scene of an accident? Those are indeed crimes. No one was harmed in the accident. Property damaged at most then minimal as it was a commercial truck.
So what whenever somebody commits a crime? You call the police the police investigate make a rest and the person goes to court and is held accountable.... That didn't happen. Why? Because this woman took it upon herself to track down, attack, pull her weapon, shoot and kill this man because she felt that she had the superior moral obligation to hold this man accountable, be the judge and jury... And ultimately his executioner.
Saw some dickhead in chat saying it was a "biased far-left judge who bases everything on race". I didn't hear anything about race or hate crimes in the sentencing. Regardless off race or gender, a confused person having a hypoglycemic shock was murdered by an angry driver who hunted them down and shot them for refusing to get out of their vehicle after an auto accident.
Her motivations are meaningless in the larger context of what she actually did.
@@adoculos4521 Irony.
That male lawyer needs to be tested for drugs. What a clown and a circus he performed in court….an embarrassment
This should be a cautionary tale about your responsibility as a gun owner.
Agreed
No one should own a gun 💩
The defense Attorney talking to Hannah during witness testimony is SO disrespectful. Is this his game
I was just going to write the same thing. So very disrespectful.
Like them or hate them or the deeds they are accused or found guilty of, it is a defense attorney's job to do all in their ability to provide representation to their clients.
The case was already lost. The only way he can represent her at that point is to try to get the best sentence for her. Nothing he said it was directly disrespectful. With that said it wasn't genuine or heart felt and that wasn't lost on the court. Think of it like your my mom telling me to clean my room... It can look clean or it can be clean. Meaning I can actually clean and organize my room or I can throw everything under the bed so you don't see it. This could have been the equivalent of him throwing everything under the bed. He is legally obligated to represent her to the best of his ability regardless of whether or not he believes that his client is guilty. If you know your client is guilty and they have already been found guilty...
I'm just glad after walking around for damn near 4 years that she is getting life. She will still be in prison as his brothers and sisters, family, take their last breath. If she is eligible for parole... No one that she harmed will have to live through this trauma again. I hope that she slips and falls in the shower repeatedly while serving her sentence.
@@dianaarriola6109how is he allowed to do this?
You guys are being silly..of course he can speak to his client at any time..respectful or not
@@scott_madsenright these comments are real unintelligent
This woman did what she did. There is no excuse for this shooting and taking a man’s life. It's sad for sure this whole situation but this woman still committed a serious crime even when asked not to proceed by the dispatch from the police. It doesn’t matter who she is or what she might accomplish in her life. She took a man’s life from him.
Yes that part 🤣
And her actions were unnecessary. So sad 🛐
Carrington guns in America doesn't help. Too easy for these outcomes. There was the popcorn shooting in a theater over using a cell ph.Guy throws popcorn on old fellows face that was complaining. Old man feels threatened for his life,pulls a gun and shoots him dead. His wife says you didn't need to do that .He says fn shut up.Anyway his life didn't look threatened at all.But he walks free.
Right they act like just because she is helpful that gave her a right to kill a man who did nothing to her.
I don’t care if she was a humanitarian philanthropist who served God with all her heart. She did what she did and should get lwop.
The prosecutor team, this Judge and Jury are fantastic! 💕
I looked up her actual sentence, she has to do at least 30 years in jail BEFORE she is eligible for parole
Great
Yes and then the 13 years on the other charges. (could also get reduced but it will hopefully be 35 at minimum)
By then, it's likely Herring's siblings will be gone and won't have to endure parole hearings 😢
Just for that life sentence. Then 8 years for the other charge and then 5 years for the other one because they’re consecutive. So minimum 43 years before parole eligibility
"I'M SAFE.... BUT HE AIN'T"
~Hannah R. Payne
Georgia State Prison 😅
😂😂😂😂
The lawyer for her is insaaaannnne 😂 “well she won’t help anybody else “ THANK YOOOOU TF
If that's what her help looks like I certainly don't want it
😂
😂😂
Right. Like THANK YOU JESUS PLEASE KEEP YOUR HELP TO YOURSELF. Gtfo delusionallllllll
i am convinced this defense attorney has never worked a trial before. he literally doesn’t know what to do!
Yeah someone had to tell him the state goes first smh
This is why you mind your business no matter what is happening ever. Turn and walk away. Period.
all she needed to do was call 911 and mind your business
But she wanted a reason to act out. She’s a psychopath
I don’t 100% agree with that
Or don’t bring a gun to a fist fight. She was out of line
@@tasharichellejamesto call it a "fist fight" is disrespectful to Mr. Herring. He was defending himself from a crazy woman with a gun
Her lawyer is 🤡 it’s just ridiculous😂
Yes that part 🤣
Despicable people testifying that Hannah would never want harm to come to the victims family. Good grief, should be ashamed of themselves. And the defense attorney getting up there and telling victims brother basically no offense that I called your brother a drug user. Hope you have closure ?! Wtf🤬
Yeah. That was very disrespectful of the lawyer telling the brother to move on smh.
Neither of her parents spoke for her? Wow sad.
Because they didn’t want to get up there and perjury they self because like the old folks would say if you don’t have nothing good to say about a person don’t say nothing at all her parents knew there was no good and in her just evil
I never seen a defense attorney address a family member during sentencing .
Yes that part 😮
That man is NASTY
Yeah that was cringe
He is a repulsive man and terrible attorney.
He should be disbarred! 😮
I can’t believe Hannah’s friends or coworkers brought up race!
They’re completely lost. If they think she did nothing wrong they are insane
They brought it up because society did. I'm just saying it as a fact.
But look at the people over there supporting her they have several biracial people .
That is a bigoted statement, it makes you look just as bad. @@__BA__
She ran after that man like a slave catcher!!! They going to learn, when the 911 caller tell you to "STAND the F DOWN" YOU BETTER STAND DOWN!!
You can expect more of this in anyone can carry a gun states. At 21 she did not have the emotional or mental maturity to carry a gun.
Even worse... she was 18 at the time.
I agree. I’m trained and have lots of experience. But I’m also getting old and frail, so I don’t carry anymore. I figure I’m too easy to disarm and that’s more likely to happen these days. So I decided I’m not gonna be part of the problem. 🤷♀️ I draw the line at home, I’ll defend that, but leave public places to defend themselves.
@@Somewhere-In-AZI agree yet I don’t own a gun. Your own gun can also end up killing you .. I cringe when I see someone in public carrying a “concealed” gun and I’m not talking about law enforcement. I saw a lot of it during the pandemic when people lost their minds. We thought the world was coming to an end. Felt like it..
THIS lady, the sister of the victim, has heartbreaking tears!! Hannah Payne’s tears are self-pity. She is a monster
All she had to do is apologize, but she blamed everyone but herself
When she read the Zimmerman guide she skipped the part that said hang up with the 911 dispatcher before committing the act so that audio that proves your guilt isn’t recorded.
U forgot the part do it under the cover of darkness but that ego couldn’t help itself
Wow she ruined her life , A life sentence at only 24 !
Now do 24 +43 she's going to be eligible for parole at age 87. Praise be 🎉
A caring person who would pull over and offer assistance to a person in need. Maybe mister Herring thought this miss Payne was going to do just that.
Hannah Paynes that day was going to offer assistance with a gun in her hand a man who obviously needed help, she didn't ask if he was alright. A determined vigilante in a rage before she approached Mr. Herring and commenced to beat the hell out of him. This man was fighting for his life.
She sat home in comfort for 2-3 years. In my opinion if they could, they would have swept this under the rug!
4yrs
Absolutely
4 1/2 years
Judge Jewel Scott is a very good judge.
Just ask God and the family of this man for forgiveness girl! You threw your whole life away because you wanted to pull the trigga on a “N***a You cried and lied l, when the evidence and witnesses said otherwise. You’re young, but I pray that only God has mercy on you and not the court.
I could listen to that judge all day. Her voice is so soothing!
The fact that she chased down this BLACK man, as WHITE woman, doesn't have to be the forefront of this case but it is very much the elephant in the room. There is no black person alive that would have even been allowed to walk away from the scene had the rolls been reversed. There would have been an all-out take down of the black person that would have done that. Then again, nobody would have just injected themselves in a hit & run like that. Just because she is big, where did she even get the balls to approach a male... oh wait, people get real aggressive when they have a gun. SMH!
Facts
Sounds like you have a victim mentality. You've got to get over this thing about white people oppressing you. 😂
Agreed
Big facts!!!
And she was on bond for over 4 years, I don't even believe she thought that she'd be found guilty
These witnesses for Hannah (with the exception of the neighbor) and her attorney did her no favors. We went from - BUT SHE HAS BLACK FRIENDS to her attorney making the worst arguments ever and insulting eyewitnesses.
I really thought she showed herself on the stand. The prosecutor nailed it in her closing when she talked about her demeanor on the stand, and how she acted like she knew better than everyone else. I’m glad this family gets justice
Gee, by the words of Hannah’s friends and co-workers about how loving and caring she was to people she knew of all races and even animals found by the side of the road - well, never mind. You get it. My condolences to the Herring family.
Based on her friends statement, one would think Hannah was Mother Teresa. However, Mother Teresa never shot anyone.... Hannah wasn't remorseful, so now she gets a big time out to think about her actions.
This is a hard, hard path that Hannah unwittingly chose for herself when she overstepped the role as a Good Samaritan, becoming a vigilante. She was like a bull seeing a red cape, she just couldn't seem to stop herself! She jumped into super-hero mode without one thought of impact. She had no boundaries or filters. Her supporters don't realize that she really did what is said she did. Mr. Herring did not pull the trigger. Even if he had, what was a gun doing on the scene in the first place. Who was she to yell at this older man like she was his authority?! She took the life of a man who was very valued by his family and community, and sh has sentenced her parents to life out of prison. Ego can take anyone down. We all would do well to remember that...
Well said. Rarely do people understand that our choices have a weight to them. If we make wise choices with prudence, the weight will place us on a track to future wise choices or at least to a greater propensity to see the difference between wise and foolish options. Pride, or ego as you call it, and self-righteousness blind us and make us more likely to draw from the wrong/foolish pool of choices when we confront new situations and highly charged interactions. I've come to understand that I should be circumspect of my own perception of doing good to others or doing the right thing. Outside of the 10 commandment, most situations and the possible options we can even conceive if offer up a whole lot of ambiguity. Doing what is good or bad is bound to be highly subjective at best. Exercising self-control in most of life's encounters is very necessary, especially if we are naive or wearing rose colored glasses. Never take for granted that our desire to do good will cause good choices and/or good outcomes. Human beings are so much more complex than that, as is life itself.
Its insane of you to imply that any of that is hero behavior 😂 or attempted hero behavior, all of it is dark and disturbing and people not reacting to it and feeling some sense of sympathy is HIGHLY DISTURBING. WTF DO YOU MEAN GOOD SAMARITAN? WHERE? She literally could have ONLY blocked his car and maybe she could be considered that! The publics reaction to this has at times, been mind boggling.
The witnesses saw otherwise with evidence/facts. Sad this 🌍 lacks humility amongst other destructive behaviors. God help us 😢
So you mean to tell me, that she thought she was speaking to a state trooper, but she had to chase the guy and get the plates. Also, if it was for him to pay for what he did when she had his plates after Balint and Lee being told not to chase him, he when I got away with anything they could’ve found him. This is senseless‘.
That’s white people cant mind there F Business
Disappointed that this judge had no sincere words of scolding the criminal and/or consolation to the family prior to reading the sentence. Many trials like this, the judge expresses their own feelings and viewpoint and why they sentenced a certain way. The sentence is too lenient for this mentally unstable, narcissistic, Thug!Anyway, may Mr. Herring's soul find eternal peace.
I'm actually glad she kept her feelings and speeches out of it since it was a trial by jury not a judge. Here the Judge is required to be supposed to be fair and impartial.
Did her coworker really use the “she can’t be racist she dated a black man” excuse on the stand???
You taught her to say please, thank you, yes Sir, no Sir, yes Ma'am, no Ma'am. You clearly never taught her to say she was sorry.
My heart and prayers goes go out to his family! Glad the jury got this right hard not to cry with his family so senseless to take his life praying for the family xo
Well it sounds like Hannah will be very helpful to all the inmates in prison😢😢
That part
Hannah crossed the line from being a Good Samaritan to a vigilante. Why? Uncontrolled emotions took over her rational thought. This happens far too often in our country. Parents do not teach children that emotions should not dictate every decision they make and neither do schools. If we had better mental health education and mental health services for children and adults, half of our prisons would be empty.
If you think it's unique to this country, you haven't been reading/watching the news. It's a human condition if you can call this monster human.
She shouldn't have been emotional to begin with. It was not her accident. The problem lies with people who think they have the right to do law enforcement job. If she wanted to get the bad guy, she should have signed up for the job. I'm glad they are finally holding people accountable for "being emotional".
There is no excuse for cutting him off getting out of her car with a gun banging on his window then shooting him and then trying blame him. How is any of any of that good intention.
Emotional inteligence shpuld be more important than math class and yet....
@@Daaaanielle not sure about you, but I need math for my career. I know what u mean though.
Not her coworker getting up there saying she carried on a long term relationship with a black man……like have SEVERAL SEATS & KEEP those prayers beloved. The neighbor was just as bad.
Right..🙄😂
I applaud the State's Closing Argument. I feel they helped serve the victim's family justice. Kudos on an excellent summation of character, ma'am. Well done.
Every1 of her character statements proved Hannah liked to get involved in other ppls business to "help" even when not asked. Yet the ☝🏽 time she truly needed to help some1 she murders them 🤨. If she was so helpful when she walked up to his vehicle & saw his condition why didnt she offer to drive him to the hospital for his safety and every1 elses since she was so concerned about every1 safety 🤔
It’s possible for ppl to be one way with friends and family and be a totally different person to others. And Hannah Payne is the true definition of that person!
Her co worker forgot to say a prayer for the victim and his family
She did not cry until she was found guilty. She so caring and she was sooo abusive and unkind and merciless toward someone who was of age to be her father.
Grandfather!!
The defense attorney didn't know that the prosecution goes first with statements? Wow. He's awful.
Incompetent quack
She is going to argue Ineffective conunsel when she appeals and she might get a retrial due to his incompetence
@@kennyroberson6216 unlikely
Hannah and George Zimmerman have a lot in common!
She was given the option to take a plea. Because she did not take it, she should not be allowed a chance for parole. She rolled the dice hoping to not be found guilty. She wasn’t. She was not a child, she was a grown woman. Anyone else would not have been out on bail for nearly 4 years. Her attorney is a joke and he is the most disrespectful of everyone.
She helped an old lady cross the street once. We get. Who cares? She shot a man and killed right after she helped that old lady across the street and help the man push his car.
I do feel for her family. They are shattered and it must be awful to have such shame in their lives. But Mr Herring was murdered by this young woman. She is responsible for every tear, every broken heart, every cry of rage. 43 years to life - it should have been LWOP but I highly doubt she will see freedom ever again.
She's in her early 20s. She'll be the same age as her victim when she's released. Fitting punishment. She'll never be able to pull Social Security when she gets out, and she has no kids, so her life will be over once she gets out of prison.
I don’t feel for her family. They were saying she was just trying to the right thing and were implying that the victim was at wrong.
She white she might come out one day
They're worried about her feelings, but what about the man she shot dead? Help me understand...
Why is the judge’s voice so soothing though