Comparing the Elad FDM DUOr to the Icom IC-R8600: Bloomberg Radio 1130 kHz New York

Hi there, two very different, but great receivers. I wonder which you think nailed this signal from the other side of the atlantic the best? There's not much in it for sure. Let me know.
Recorded in Oxford UK on 05/11/24 at 03:03 hrs UTC using a Wellbrook ALA1530 magnetic loop