I'm pretty sure one exists that's not very different. I recall one... either you escape from the troll or you fight it. >_< Unfortunately, "vague memory from half a year ago" isn't easily googled.
What I'll change is instead of disadvantage rolls use a point system. Go a day without food or water -3 to whatever you roll and -5 for no sleep. Not just rolls for exhaustion but any encounters. Go 3 days with no food & water is -18 and need 19 or 20 to succeed.
@@adamloga3788 yeah, it sounds like the point of this is when it's obvious that you can't possibly win against the pursuers. The best you can hope for is to escape the encounter alive
you call this awful but, maybe with a few small adjustments to scale it back a touch, this actually seems like a great option for a table that wants more trackable progress on survival elements that normally get handwaved or glossed over. I'd definitely prefer this over 5e's default nonexistent "chase" and tracking rules.
It's a little strange unless the party has means of tracking their pursuers though. The players know how far away the enemies are because of the tokens
Scale it back? Scale it UP DOT MAPPING. NODE TO NODE TRAVEL, BRANCHING PATHS, RETURN BY DEATH RESET LOOP FOR PARTY WIPE. New D&D game mode, "A Travel-Node Campaign".
@@DanielLCarrier That sounds like a problem with mounted combat rules in 5e, which are equally terrible. But 5e's chase rules are just "hey what's your con score? okay that's how long your can run, basically." It is one of the driest and least interactive things you can run in 5e.
@@jettlucashayes8508 depend on the encounter make up and level of group, if it's suppose to be a notable challenge or like a literal miliary platoon(18 to 50 people) who's been sent to hunt the group , then a Goodberry (a lv1 spell ) is a good trade off
This actually makes the Ranger’s new tireless ability very good, as they can effectively skip sleep and gain lead tokens with no consequences, as long as they can take at least an hour break every day
@@theactorsdungeon3898 Exactly why a campaign like this is the perfect place for them to shine. Just like how a monk will shine extra bright in a campaign that routinely features being captured and separated from your equipment, or where fights break out when you're at parties like high society balls or whatever where it's inappropriate to wear armor and carry weapons.
@@RoninCatholic and dont forget that monks are generally applied wrong, they are not a bruiser class like fighter paladin or barbarian, treat them more like rouges/your dedicated anti spellcaster measure
I know it's a more complicated random encounter table, but it's probably the only random encounter table I'd be able to use while being able to keep track of everything, so good job!
Zee: "I've made a complex minigame as an abstraction for survival/pursuit in 5e, but I hate it" Me: "I don't even remember what half the weather does RAW, but I'm gonna add some wacky shit anyways like Wild Magic Storms"
I honestly really like this! As long as most encounters are fast to resolve (they're short and self-contained, or handled via montage), I think you avoid most of the pacing issues you'd otherwise run into by getting into granular timekeeping. You still need to come up with about 8*days prompts, but you could probably crowd source a bunch of them. My one gripe is "D&D combat is pretty fast" , but if you aren't getting regular long rests maybe you can get tension from shorter combats.
@@Manoplian I was irked by the "fast" bit as well, but you're probably right about that being what he meant, that the time spent fighting is so small it's not really worth tracking, not that you get through combat encounters fast when they happen (because in my experience D&D has some of the longest combat encounters of any RPG that does not go full on simulationist)
This is basically adding an entirely new game to a D&D campaign - and I would TOTALLY play it. It seems fun and exciting, and a great example of resource management and risk calculation in gameplay. Serious credit for innovative DMs.
I like it because the players are aware and complicit in the random encounters instead of just not knowing what happens. More tensions built that way. Also, very glad to hear the cold Road is not dead!
This seems really cool. Reminds me of those traveling movies where the heroes are trying to reach a location as the bad guys follow their trail. Like the Indiana Jones movies where people are trying to find an ancient temple as the bad guys pursue them or track them so they get lead to it
Can I just say that, Bashew your art has improved so much and it’s amazing to see the progress you’ve made over the years, I always rewatch your old episodes and I’m always overjoyed when you upload new ones, thank you so much for all you do
While yes, the end result is still random encounters, it's random encounters decided by how the party chooses to explore and spend resources, increasing agency and immersion. Not bad if it doesn't get too fiddly
It's got some fundamental differences with a random encounter chart. Previewing the rolls needed is one. Another is once they avoid an obstacle it's something already generated that was avoided vs having to roll on random encounter. If you dodge the tarrasque encounter and it was the only time it showed up that's different then having to dodge a 1/100 chance of that fight every failed roll. I think more asymmetry and assorted nature on the day to day would help. Don't have encounters listed every day. Have some rolls affect the odds and rate. "Took wrong path, add 2 encounters to next 2 tiles" for example would change the difficulty of next two days. Maybe have some encounters be "face up"; after all some things don't require dice roll. A face up encounter could be obvious signs of bear in the woods but can you avoid the bear successfully. Another key thing to add is more player choice and agency. If it's just down to die rolls of course it feels like a random encounter chart. Take a lesson from something like slay the spire. A random layout of paths where players can choose which path they're taking. In slay the spire, the first act 1 elite fight is random chance out of 3 options. However, the player knows its an elite and can learn what all 3 fights are. So they have a lot of information to work with when deciding to path into the elite fight. One other potential idea to handle the "random encounter chart" feel is pre-trip research. Have some ahead of time rolls that can reveal what exact encounters exist along the path. Going from City X to City Y in a desert? Wouldn't city X have information on the giant monster scorpions that are usually in groups of 2, bandit activity, and rumors of a caravan finding an artifact indicating a dungeon in the sands? So now players can know one of the encounters is a giant monster scorpions, and another is bandits but not when/where on the path.
I don't know, I like it. I think this gives players A lot more information up front to make decisions and then they can't complain about it when they say they didn't know that that would happen. Having a board game like setup for this helps with keeping track of very specific rules
Honestly reminds me a lot of Band of Blades, which is a ttrpg built around the idea of the players leading a mercenary company across a kingdom in a panicked dash away from an army of the undead after the real party of adventures TPK'd against the big bad evil lich.
If you now think this system is awful, I'd kind of like to see one of the un-animated discussion videos on what you see the issues with it being and how you'd improve it if you were running it now, because on the face of it, it doesn't seem inherently terrible. The biggest issue I see with it is more just that having a high CON save lets you not engage with the mechanic at all, which isn't a fatal flaw by itself.
I would assume it's a balance issue. Exhaustion is an extremely severe condition in DND, even just one level of it gives you disadvantage on skill checks. It can easily spiral into a viscous cycle where your exhaustion leads to failing to gather resources, which leads to you failing the exhaustion check again the next day.
A little too punishing IMO. Feels like one of those board games where you only win 20% of the time. You don't get enough lead tokens to search basically anything and if you play a character with a middling-low CON just go ahead and kill them.
imo its horrendus the LAST thing most dnd games is; 1. more freaking math 2. more tokens 3. more crap on the table 4. more dice rolling 5.. more distractions from the storytelling and improvisation if you want numbers and stats go play a final fantasy or world of warcraft. if you want dice and tokens go play a board game. if you want to improvise a story with your friends while playing a game, play dnd. dnd is not a video game and its moving away from being a board game. and its better for it.
You sir, have me excited for the next telling of Cold Road. I have sorely missed hearing the brutal campaign where a couple bad rolls turned the campaign for the worst.
It honestly doesn't come off as that complicated, you really just wanted to incorporate resources into a long form chase in a digestible way. I guess we'll see the result in the next Cold Road, but I can seriously imagine running this with great success in my group. If anything it inspires more ways to gamify resource management, it reminds me of a very similar game I used when my players got hit with community service after being arrested for their shenanigans and it ended up being my favorite session in the whole campaign.
For a second I thought you meant your players had to do community service and not player characters, which, look, I'm not going to judge anyone for needing to serve a sentence, but ALL of them??
@@mooncrime4998 it's been a while but if I remember correctly they all broke into a guy's house and assaulted him, they had their sentence drastically lightened through the use of some favors and better call saul chicanery in the court. They were still surveiled after this because they were affiliated with a violent street gang but it wasn't provable
I mean, I thought when I clicked on this video it as a product he was selling. Seems like I will need to craft this on my for my party. I think anyone who likes resource management games like Dead of Winter will appreciate this. Especially because I made a homebrew of Golden Kamuy, I can rework this to match the more travel aspects.
This is awesome. I might have to try this in my game. Thank you for sharing, Zee. I've always had trouble trying to keep track of how rations are used in games. Your way seems to make that easier. And it makes encounters travel have some worthwhile meaning to them.
I think that's part of the problem. it's stopping the D&D gameplay loop for a whole new game. that could work well for some groups, but for others it would be more fun and faster to just use random encounters.
I thought this sounded like nonsense, then I thought about a massive underground dungeon thats basicly just a straight line between two massive long forgotten underground civilizations.
turn 1: "I'm not running. I spend my lead and resources preparing to ambush the pursuing force. Better than dying from an arrow in the back, exhausted from running for days."
I could see players enjoying this *specifically because* it's more complexificated than just a roll table. Same as how folks will play a TTRPG system instead of just doing freeform, just a variance of degree. Or how some wizard players would gladly, happily play a wizard who somehow is less powerful than the simpler barbarian they could play. More "Rules Toys" to play with. What you did was take a roll table and add *decisions* for the players. Built-in points of choice to play with.
Right? I thought this was cool. It adds decisions about how long you can afford to stick around in an area, and can force the party to move onwards. Downside is you may have prepped a dungeon for nothing if they don't have the spare lead tokens to explore it lol
Tbh this to me feels a bit better than how the 5e regular rules would have you run survival. This feels like it could be fun and not just a painful slog where every few minutes people have to do really menial tasks without much excitement involved.
True, 5e regular rules have survival being completely trivial. Although in order to still not trivialize this system, some spells would need to be banned. Goodberry, Create Food and Water, etc.
"what do you mean I have to eat and drink?" - the one guy who wasn't paying attention during session zero You would not believe how many people cycled in and out of my pick up game of Dark Sun back on Mythweavers because they didn't read the GIGANTIC BOLD TEXT saying "SURVIVAL THEME".
Oh god, you basically invented a board game. I used to do stuff like this too but stopped doing long wilderness journeys/encounters entirely at some point. I just describe the journey now so we actually get to play meaningful content every session.
yep. while i enjoy explorative microadventures like the first hour of final fantasy 12 and the first few hours of hyper detailed games like witcher 3, story will always trump immersion. story is the meat, world building and immerssion are the seasonings. the world building is supposed to bring out the flavors of the story and not the other way around.
That seems extremely fun as a one time high stakes chase. At least if the encounters and findable things are interesting. A lot of work for the dm, but should really pay off.
Zee, I don't understand half your mechanics, nor have I played D&D since the days when I played it religiously back in the 2nd AD&D days. But your videos are my favorite things on RUclips It's literally the only videos I'll stop what I'm doing and watch several times. So Thank you man
One modification. Dont let the players know their "Lead/Time" token count. When being chased, unless they SEE how far the pursuers are behind, the players have no idea how much time/lead they have on the threat.
Depending on the situation, there are ways to have an obvious indication they're being chased. If it's an orc hunting party or something going for them, maybe they see smoke in the distance, always on their trail
It might be a good idea to force lead tokens to be one pool for the group. Since this is a multi-day thing, one player having more lead than another insinuates splitting the party, and anyone overspending dooms everyone anyway.
@@TlalocTemporal Assuming that the party stays together, a parties strength is as high as its weakest link, so only the minimum lead count of the group is considered when testing if the pursuers catch up because the week would be holding everyone back.
Been watching (and lurking) for a few years and came to the realization I never subscribed! I'd always just seek out your videos manually or get them recommended to me due to my D&D related viewing history. A few years late, but subscribed! o7
Conceptually, I think this is REALLY COOL. It's a little overcomplicated, but some streamlining with the same vibe in play, I'd absolutely love to use this.
I actually love this. It may need some slight streamlining but I think it is a very good way of running an FTL-esq resource management game where stakes are dire.
I like the overworld/chase mechanic from Double Cross. It also uses a board grid to keep track, but skill rolls will have you move forward by varying amounts depending on the tier of success, and certain numbers are thresholds for key events to happen.
Honestly this sounds like a really fun set up for a short 3-5 session long mini campaign. I can see it being a cool break from a longer higher level campaign where the group makes some level 5 characters that are trying to get something to the main party within a time period with the mini campaign ending with the side party and main party teaming up to fight the bad guys chasing them
I'll be honest, I needed this. A means to track resources and time for travel. I think I'll try something similar (if a bit less complicated) next time I run a game.
For a quick and easy setup i would use Settlers of Catan resource cards for food, water, shelter, monster encounter, and travel delay. Pull 4 from the deck face down (or behind the DM screen) and Roll 4d6 with each d6 representing the task (choose 6 skills to use in your specific scenario) to acquire the resource or avoid the obstacle/monster. I really like this and will definitely use it in my next campaign.
This reminded me a little of Torchbearer or Mouse Guard, and the way that they are more focused on tracking food, water, and light. Those games were a nice change from dnd in how much these little things mattered for your survival.
Кино
![Rich Dunk (Ft. DaBaby) - BIG DAWG [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Pz2ewsSKAEM/mqdefault.jpg)
With a few changes you could make a new boardgame with how complex that was
I'm pretty sure one exists that's not very different. I recall one... either you escape from the troll or you fight it. >_< Unfortunately, "vague memory from half a year ago" isn't easily googled.
My thoughts exactly hahaha
Yeah wtf he should spend time on that, I know I would buy it, very interesting concept
What I'll change is instead of disadvantage rolls use a point system. Go a day without food or water -3 to whatever you roll and -5 for no sleep. Not just rolls for exhaustion but any encounters. Go 3 days with no food & water is -18 and need 19 or 20 to succeed.
Almost a darkest dungeon vibe for a board game.
Imagine you prep everything and the party decides to make an ambush for the pursuers instead.
Judging by how he was talking, I'm guessing that they'd only make that mistake once.
@@adamloga3788 yeah, it sounds like the point of this is when it's obvious that you can't possibly win against the pursuers. The best you can hope for is to escape the encounter alive
Perfect location for that: near the mimic house.
@@CandlemancerThat sounds like something someone that doesn't know how to set up an ambush would say
It’s almost like you know my players…..
The next cold road?!? Do my ears deceive me?!
I am as excited as you - nay, more!
Cold Road? On this time of a year ? In this place ?
@@kacpadestro8086 Localized entirely on this channel??
May I see it?!
@@pdomo415 ... No.
you call this awful but, maybe with a few small adjustments to scale it back a touch, this actually seems like a great option for a table that wants more trackable progress on survival elements that normally get handwaved or glossed over.
I'd definitely prefer this over 5e's default nonexistent "chase" and tracking rules.
It's a little strange unless the party has means of tracking their pursuers though. The players know how far away the enemies are because of the tokens
Scale it back?
Scale it UP
DOT MAPPING. NODE TO NODE TRAVEL, BRANCHING PATHS, RETURN BY DEATH RESET LOOP FOR PARTY WIPE.
New D&D game mode, "A Travel-Node Campaign".
@@Sheeprwer yeah thats most abstracted chase systems its really not a problem.
Chase rules are important. Without them, you can kill a Tarrasque with a repeating crossbow infusion and a horse.
@@DanielLCarrier That sounds like a problem with mounted combat rules in 5e, which are equally terrible.
But 5e's chase rules are just "hey what's your con score? okay that's how long your can run, basically."
It is one of the driest and least interactive things you can run in 5e.
This is a perfect follow-up to Zee's video on the worst spell in survival games - Goodberry.
Yep , a good berry user would sap like 1/3rd of the difficulty of the situation away
Add the ranger class ans tiny hut and you can pretty much ignore survival
@Ike_of_pyke or just beating the shit out of your pursuer since its probably easier then running from them
all survival hand wave spells are banned from my games
like goodberry, create water, that dimensional mansion one, ect.
@@jettlucashayes8508 depend on the encounter make up and level of group, if it's suppose to be a notable challenge or like a literal miliary platoon(18 to 50 people) who's been sent to hunt the group , then a Goodberry (a lv1 spell ) is a good trade off
This actually makes the Ranger’s new tireless ability very good, as they can effectively skip sleep and gain lead tokens with no consequences, as long as they can take at least an hour break every day
And Rangers are the class that _should_ do best in a situation like this, followed by Druids and Barbarians.
I find a lot of the time the Ranger's unique survival abilities don't always have a use.
@@theactorsdungeon3898 Exactly why a campaign like this is the perfect place for them to shine.
Just like how a monk will shine extra bright in a campaign that routinely features being captured and separated from your equipment, or where fights break out when you're at parties like high society balls or whatever where it's inappropriate to wear armor and carry weapons.
@@RoninCatholic oooh, that's clever!
@@RoninCatholic and dont forget that monks are generally applied wrong, they are not a bruiser class like fighter paladin or barbarian, treat them more like rouges/your dedicated anti spellcaster measure
Between this and the Animated Keg, we can see Zee's love of visually representing aspects of D&D, which I fully support.
YOU HAD ME AT NEXT COLD ROAD
"D&D Combat doesn't take that long" _Monkey Side Eye Meme_
Well, in-universe time wise it doesn't, players exist outside their flow of time and experience it much differently
Hours can pass in seconds, and seconds can take hours.
Dude a 20 turn combat is 2 in-game minutes.
To be fair, dnd combat shouldn't be all that slow if players act fast. Like, implement 1 minute turns and a round is 5-10 minutes?
In-universe D&D combat is extremely fast and brutal. Almost all fights are over in less than 2 minutes
More Cold Road? YAY! always good to see more content from you my man.
I know it's a more complicated random encounter table, but it's probably the only random encounter table I'd be able to use while being able to keep track of everything, so good job!
Zee: "I've made a complex minigame as an abstraction for survival/pursuit in 5e, but I hate it"
Me: "I don't even remember what half the weather does RAW, but I'm gonna add some wacky shit anyways like Wild Magic Storms"
I honestly really like this! As long as most encounters are fast to resolve (they're short and self-contained, or handled via montage), I think you avoid most of the pacing issues you'd otherwise run into by getting into granular timekeeping. You still need to come up with about 8*days prompts, but you could probably crowd source a bunch of them. My one gripe is "D&D combat is pretty fast" , but if you aren't getting regular long rests maybe you can get tension from shorter combats.
He meant that dnd combat doesn't take much in-game time, so it doesn't matter to the chase.
@@Manoplian I was irked by the "fast" bit as well, but you're probably right about that being what he meant, that the time spent fighting is so small it's not really worth tracking, not that you get through combat encounters fast when they happen (because in my experience D&D has some of the longest combat encounters of any RPG that does not go full on simulationist)
Watching this in the middle of my Stormlight Archives re-read and I spot "Stormfather" on a drawing?! Kudos for the easter egg
This is basically adding an entirely new game to a D&D campaign - and I would TOTALLY play it. It seems fun and exciting, and a great example of resource management and risk calculation in gameplay. Serious credit for innovative DMs.
I like it because the players are aware and complicit in the random encounters instead of just not knowing what happens. More tensions built that way. Also, very glad to hear the cold Road is not dead!
This seems really cool. Reminds me of those traveling movies where the heroes are trying to reach a location as the bad guys follow their trail. Like the Indiana Jones movies where people are trying to find an ancient temple as the bad guys pursue them or track them so they get lead to it
Can I just say that, Bashew your art has improved so much and it’s amazing to see the progress you’ve made over the years, I always rewatch your old episodes and I’m always overjoyed when you upload new ones, thank you so much for all you do
Honestly even if it's not the best way to run survival mechanics it is always good to get more videos from you
While yes, the end result is still random encounters, it's random encounters decided by how the party chooses to explore and spend resources, increasing agency and immersion. Not bad if it doesn't get too fiddly
It's got some fundamental differences with a random encounter chart. Previewing the rolls needed is one. Another is once they avoid an obstacle it's something already generated that was avoided vs having to roll on random encounter. If you dodge the tarrasque encounter and it was the only time it showed up that's different then having to dodge a 1/100 chance of that fight every failed roll.
I think more asymmetry and assorted nature on the day to day would help. Don't have encounters listed every day. Have some rolls affect the odds and rate. "Took wrong path, add 2 encounters to next 2 tiles" for example would change the difficulty of next two days. Maybe have some encounters be "face up"; after all some things don't require dice roll. A face up encounter could be obvious signs of bear in the woods but can you avoid the bear successfully.
Another key thing to add is more player choice and agency. If it's just down to die rolls of course it feels like a random encounter chart. Take a lesson from something like slay the spire. A random layout of paths where players can choose which path they're taking. In slay the spire, the first act 1 elite fight is random chance out of 3 options. However, the player knows its an elite and can learn what all 3 fights are. So they have a lot of information to work with when deciding to path into the elite fight.
One other potential idea to handle the "random encounter chart" feel is pre-trip research. Have some ahead of time rolls that can reveal what exact encounters exist along the path. Going from City X to City Y in a desert? Wouldn't city X have information on the giant monster scorpions that are usually in groups of 2, bandit activity, and rumors of a caravan finding an artifact indicating a dungeon in the sands? So now players can know one of the encounters is a giant monster scorpions, and another is bandits but not when/where on the path.
I don't know, I like it. I think this gives players A lot more information up front to make decisions and then they can't complain about it when they say they didn't know that that would happen. Having a board game like setup for this helps with keeping track of very specific rules
Honestly reminds me a lot of Band of Blades, which is a ttrpg built around the idea of the players leading a mercenary company across a kingdom in a panicked dash away from an army of the undead after the real party of adventures TPK'd against the big bad evil lich.
Wait wait wait, a new cold road episode is coming ? That's the best news of the week \o/
If you now think this system is awful, I'd kind of like to see one of the un-animated discussion videos on what you see the issues with it being and how you'd improve it if you were running it now, because on the face of it, it doesn't seem inherently terrible. The biggest issue I see with it is more just that having a high CON save lets you not engage with the mechanic at all, which isn't a fatal flaw by itself.
I would assume it's a balance issue. Exhaustion is an extremely severe condition in DND, even just one level of it gives you disadvantage on skill checks. It can easily spiral into a viscous cycle where your exhaustion leads to failing to gather resources, which leads to you failing the exhaustion check again the next day.
I think Zee made it quite clear why it was a fairly awful system. It's basically just an over-complicated encounter table.
As a DM who enjoys wilderness survival, resource management, and exploration, I actually liked all of this!
Gonna have to rewatch Cold Road in prep for the new episode! Been waiting for this for a while! Looking forward to it!
you had me at 'the next Cold Road'.
This honestly doesn't seem that bad, complicated yes but not awful by any means.
A little too punishing IMO. Feels like one of those board games where you only win 20% of the time. You don't get enough lead tokens to search basically anything and if you play a character with a middling-low CON just go ahead and kill them.
imo its horrendus
the LAST thing most dnd games is;
1. more freaking math
2. more tokens
3. more crap on the table
4. more dice rolling
5.. more distractions from the storytelling and improvisation
if you want numbers and stats go play a final fantasy or world of warcraft.
if you want dice and tokens go play a board game.
if you want to improvise a story with your friends while playing a game, play dnd.
dnd is not a video game and its moving away from being a board game. and its better for it.
complicated = bad
ESPECIALLY for an already complicated game like dnd
As he noted, this boiled down to a random encounter chart with extra parts
@@aa-tx7th complicated = not your preference
HOLD UP, a new Cold Road episode is being released? I thought it had been shelved. Looking forward to it, that story had great ambiance.
Even if it's just a more complicated version of encounters, it seems more immersive and much more exciting
Nice Cosmere reference at 2:33
Stormfather!
caught that too lol
It's so complex, and yet I love it so much
Love the updated version of the classic see Wizard design.
He took "running down a hallway" and made an entire game out of it. I really like the sound of it.
You sir, have me excited for the next telling of Cold Road. I have sorely missed hearing the brutal campaign where a couple bad rolls turned the campaign for the worst.
Don't apologize, lol. This is great. It's DND Death Road to Canada.
I'm super excited for when Zee inevitably just makes his own RPG
Honestly, this has the bones of a great minigame to shake things up a bit!
I'm all for anything that adds a fun mini-game into a DND session.
It honestly doesn't come off as that complicated, you really just wanted to incorporate resources into a long form chase in a digestible way. I guess we'll see the result in the next Cold Road, but I can seriously imagine running this with great success in my group. If anything it inspires more ways to gamify resource management, it reminds me of a very similar game I used when my players got hit with community service after being arrested for their shenanigans and it ended up being my favorite session in the whole campaign.
For a second I thought you meant your players had to do community service and not player characters, which, look, I'm not going to judge anyone for needing to serve a sentence, but ALL of them??
@@mooncrime4998just a lil B&E with the boys never hurt anybody
@@mooncrime4998 it's been a while but if I remember correctly they all broke into a guy's house and assaulted him, they had their sentence drastically lightened through the use of some favors and better call saul chicanery in the court. They were still surveiled after this because they were affiliated with a violent street gang but it wasn't provable
someone needs to make and sell this. fully release this to the world.
be the change you want to be in the world my man
my grandparents made board games
all it takes is some scrap wood and paint
I mean, I thought when I clicked on this video it as a product he was selling. Seems like I will need to craft this on my for my party.
I think anyone who likes resource management games like Dead of Winter will appreciate this. Especially because I made a homebrew of Golden Kamuy, I can rework this to match the more travel aspects.
This is awesome. I might have to try this in my game. Thank you for sharing, Zee. I've always had trouble trying to keep track of how rations are used in games. Your way seems to make that easier. And it makes encounters travel have some worthwhile meaning to them.
Ah heck yeah. Loved the cold road series, excited to hear we get to learn more
yooo new cold road announcement
Awful? Or ingenious!
This system is the core for an entire game
I think that's part of the problem. it's stopping the D&D gameplay loop for a whole new game. that could work well for some groups, but for others it would be more fun and faster to just use random encounters.
I thought this sounded like nonsense, then I thought about a massive underground dungeon thats basicly just a straight line between two massive long forgotten underground civilizations.
turn 1: "I'm not running. I spend my lead and resources preparing to ambush the pursuing force. Better than dying from an arrow in the back, exhausted from running for days."
“The cold road” is amazing! I can’t wait to watch it over and over!
So…you made a new ttrpg?
I could see players enjoying this *specifically because* it's more complexificated than just a roll table.
Same as how folks will play a TTRPG system instead of just doing freeform, just a variance of degree.
Or how some wizard players would gladly, happily play a wizard who somehow is less powerful than the simpler barbarian they could play.
More "Rules Toys" to play with.
What you did was take a roll table and add *decisions* for the players.
Built-in points of choice to play with.
Right? I thought this was cool. It adds decisions about how long you can afford to stick around in an area, and can force the party to move onwards.
Downside is you may have prepped a dungeon for nothing if they don't have the spare lead tokens to explore it lol
Yeah, it seems more interesting than a table to me.
Reposition dungeon elsewhere.
Maybe even save it for after hunt over.
Hearing “next cold road” definitely woke me up.
Thank you for this, everything you've provided us, and for everything yet to be seen.
Most excellent, always.
Tbh this to me feels a bit better than how the 5e regular rules would have you run survival. This feels like it could be fun and not just a painful slog where every few minutes people have to do really menial tasks without much excitement involved.
True, 5e regular rules have survival being completely trivial. Although in order to still not trivialize this system, some spells would need to be banned. Goodberry, Create Food and Water, etc.
Omg!! New cold road!!!!!
"what do you mean I have to eat and drink?" - the one guy who wasn't paying attention during session zero
You would not believe how many people cycled in and out of my pick up game of Dark Sun back on Mythweavers because they didn't read the GIGANTIC BOLD TEXT saying "SURVIVAL THEME".
Yes! Another one. Love these bro keep ‘em coming
Oh god, you basically invented a board game. I used to do stuff like this too but stopped doing long wilderness journeys/encounters entirely at some point. I just describe the journey now so we actually get to play meaningful content every session.
yep. while i enjoy explorative microadventures like the first hour of final fantasy 12 and the first few hours of hyper detailed games like witcher 3, story will always trump immersion.
story is the meat, world building and immerssion are the seasonings.
the world building is supposed to bring out the flavors of the story and not the other way around.
That seems extremely fun as a one time high stakes chase. At least if the encounters and findable things are interesting. A lot of work for the dm, but should really pay off.
That sounds fun as hell dude. That makes travel time way more interactive then just rolling on a chart.
Zee, I don't understand half your mechanics, nor have I played D&D since the days when I played it religiously back in the 2nd AD&D days.
But your videos are my favorite things on RUclips
It's literally the only videos I'll stop what I'm doing and watch several times.
So Thank you man
One modification. Dont let the players know their "Lead/Time" token count. When being chased, unless they SEE how far the pursuers are behind, the players have no idea how much time/lead they have on the threat.
Depending on the situation, there are ways to have an obvious indication they're being chased. If it's an orc hunting party or something going for them, maybe they see smoke in the distance, always on their trail
change the word SEE to PERCEIVE and that is exactly what I said.
It might be a good idea to force lead tokens to be one pool for the group. Since this is a multi-day thing, one player having more lead than another insinuates splitting the party, and anyone overspending dooms everyone anyway.
@@TlalocTemporal Assuming that the party stays together, a parties strength is as high as its weakest link, so only the minimum lead count of the group is considered when testing if the pursuers catch up because the week would be holding everyone back.
I heard "next cold road" and now I'm excited
I'm just about to run an oregon trail game and was looking for survival videos. Thank you zee for hearing my cries!
Been watching (and lurking) for a few years and came to the realization I never subscribed! I'd always just seek out your videos manually or get them recommended to me due to my D&D related viewing history.
A few years late, but subscribed! o7
What a great intro to make us watch this affront to RPGs. Great video as usual :D
great video as always I can't wait to watch the next cold road video.
YOU HAD ME AT “NEXT COLD RUN”
I love it zee, please keep up the longer videos!
HA! This is wild! Really cool ideas! I like how it makes the tension the fiction match the transparent mechanics of the game!
CoC chase system: "look what they need to mimic a fraction of our power"
I’m new to being a DM and your videos are helping me make my game fun
Considering I like intricate homebrew (especially with my monsters), this sounds like a blast. Thanks for giving me more of your stuff to steal, Zee!
Great video
Super excited for the next cold road
no wait. this all makes some semblance of sense. I WAS PROMISED ANGER
Really appreciate the return to 2d with these recent vids.
Hell yeah!
I've been waiting for more Cold Road!
Every time zee makes a video my day gets better.
Wait… Did you say next Cold Road???!!? LETS GO!!!! Love those!
Cold road? COLD ROAD?!? What beautiful news, my day just improved significantly!
Conceptually, I think this is REALLY COOL. It's a little overcomplicated, but some streamlining with the same vibe in play, I'd absolutely love to use this.
I actually love this. It may need some slight streamlining but I think it is a very good way of running an FTL-esq resource management game where stakes are dire.
I look forward to seeing the next episode!
I love how you just made an entirely new board game for this one encounter.
Seriously, it wouldn't take much to make this playable as a separate game.
this sounds like you just made the darkest dunegon inventory mechanic for 5e.
Amazing animation as always!!
I like the overworld/chase mechanic from Double Cross. It also uses a board grid to keep track, but skill rolls will have you move forward by varying amounts depending on the tier of success, and certain numbers are thresholds for key events to happen.
Keep it up Zee, love your videos man.
This is very inspiring. I will be incorporating this into my games.
I just rewatched Cold Road a bit ago so hearing that there's gonna be more is exciting
Much more interesting and engaging than a random table though, and lots of incorporation of the players' skills and choices. I love it.
Honestly this sounds like a really fun set up for a short 3-5 session long mini campaign. I can see it being a cool break from a longer higher level campaign where the group makes some level 5 characters that are trying to get something to the main party within a time period with the mini campaign ending with the side party and main party teaming up to fight the bad guys chasing them
I can only read "mimic house" as the dean yelling "ROBOT HOUSE!" from that episode of futurama.
This looks like a system I would run one time just to mix things up, and then subtly use as a threat to keep the party in line forever after.
This is an aspect of 'Forbidden Lands' that I really appreciate.
This honestly looks like a lot of fun. I might give it a try!
I'll be honest, I needed this. A means to track resources and time for travel. I think I'll try something similar (if a bit less complicated) next time I run a game.
you could use this for like a one-shot the survivor lives on the tell the tale and sets up a future quest for a main D&D group
thank you for the hitpoint press ad, bought one straight away XD
For a quick and easy setup i would use Settlers of Catan resource cards for food, water, shelter, monster encounter, and travel delay. Pull 4 from the deck face down (or behind the DM screen) and Roll 4d6 with each d6 representing the task (choose 6 skills to use in your specific scenario) to acquire the resource or avoid the obstacle/monster. I really like this and will definitely use it in my next campaign.
I did something like this for an adventure hex crawl.
@@ADayintheLifeoftheTw How'd it go? Any hiccups or things you would change or tweak?
This reminded me a little of Torchbearer or Mouse Guard, and the way that they are more focused on tracking food, water, and light. Those games were a nice change from dnd in how much these little things mattered for your survival.