How To Talk Minnesotan | Full Length Film

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @amyomeara2515
    @amyomeara2515 Год назад +247

    when we walk them to the car, we have a farewell song that we sing as they drive away. I'm not joking.

    • @7mild7
      @7mild7 Год назад +2

      oh my lord thats normal?

    • @stuff4826
      @stuff4826 Год назад +10

      @@7mild7 of course, we carry around poppy seeds in our pockets and throw them at people when we meet.

    • @ScottWiecenski
      @ScottWiecenski Год назад +24

      That's different!!

    • @its_marie91
      @its_marie91 Год назад +11

      I... I'm afraid to ask, but what is the song? 😅

    • @Euterpe416
      @Euterpe416 Год назад +4

      @@its_marie91 I want to know too, don't leave us hanging!

  • @buzman1985
    @buzman1985 2 года назад +235

    He passed away 9/4/22 at the age of 83. Rest in Peace, sir. Thanks for all the laughs.

    • @Seven7eIeven11
      @Seven7eIeven11 7 месяцев назад +4

      Rest in peace ✝️❤️ you bet! ❤️

  • @jasontibbetts2852
    @jasontibbetts2852 Год назад +97

    I got a little weepy remembering my Minnesotan grandfather waving until we were out of sight, every single time.

    • @TwinCitiesPBS
      @TwinCitiesPBS  Год назад +8

    • @Seven7eIeven11
      @Seven7eIeven11 7 месяцев назад +1

      I think it’s a northern thing! We do that in the U P and in Wisconsin

    • @WonBrainCell
      @WonBrainCell 6 месяцев назад

      Me too, this reminds me of my grandparents every time 😂

    • @GovenorMcLovin
      @GovenorMcLovin 3 месяца назад

      @Seven7eIeven11 idk. My grandma born in Oklahoma did that as well. I think it's just an old person thing.

  • @pockethealer3592
    @pockethealer3592 Год назад +268

    A tip for avoiding the long goodbye during the colder months. Start your vehicle early stating that you’re just letting it warm up. You now have a hard deadline since you “can’t go wasting’ fuel, what with gas prices and all” and now when they follow you out to the vehicle you don’t have to attempt to warm it up while being told to “ah, come back inside, I’ll make some coffee and warm the food back up. I’d hate to see you freeze out here.”
    Note: the goodbye will still take a while for you folk who aren’t used to it, but you will be able to get home for supper today instead of tomorrow.

    • @TwinCitiesPBS
      @TwinCitiesPBS  Год назад +25

      I like it!

    • @winstonsmith480
      @winstonsmith480 Год назад +11

      You are a genius!

    • @supergeeky7529
      @supergeeky7529 5 месяцев назад +2

      I just married a man from NY. My husband will just say bye and leave! lol

    • @Kenji7761
      @Kenji7761 3 месяца назад +3

      True Minnesota spotted. Even better if you have a remote start so you don't have to try to put on your jacket or shoes first. It's stealthy and hard to counter. I know it's new school Minnesotan to have remote start, but hey technology is there to make our lives easier.

    • @nicaskey1
      @nicaskey1 2 месяца назад +1

      You bet yer.

  • @happsk1211
    @happsk1211 2 года назад +702

    made the fatal mistake of accepting lunch during the long goodbye, and the cycle repeated. problem is, I'm real hungry, so I keep falling for it. I've been stuck here for 14 years now

    • @Mathyoou
      @Mathyoou 2 года назад +7

      Iv been stuck in the cycle for years now wish me luck 😂🥲

    • @SimonVanliew26
      @SimonVanliew26 2 года назад +4

      Lmaoo this guy

    • @PinchTheBarb
      @PinchTheBarb 2 года назад +5

      Shout out to Charlie Behrens!

    • @agustusfarnworth3379
      @agustusfarnworth3379 2 года назад +6

      Welcome to your happy marriage

    • @realPenrodPooch
      @realPenrodPooch 2 года назад +11

      @@agustusfarnworth3379 It could be worse and he's not unhappy.

  • @Zeppelinfaktor
    @Zeppelinfaktor 2 года назад +417

    Being Minnesota is really a long series of being held as a tacit hostage by the ones you love.

    • @stolearovigor281
      @stolearovigor281 2 года назад

      Anything with "pbs" in name is garbage

    • @BaldManBeardFace
      @BaldManBeardFace 2 года назад +31

      @@stolearovigor281 Could you elaborate? Are you saying The Public Broadcasting System is not good? What about such great as Bob Ross and Mr. Rodgers?

    • @stolearovigor281
      @stolearovigor281 2 года назад

      @@BaldManBeardFace yes you got me right. Everything with pbs label is garbage

    • @TheClash115
      @TheClash115 2 года назад +32

      @Stolearov Igor Whoa! You’re so cool for sharing such a hot take, bruv 😎

    • @stolearovigor281
      @stolearovigor281 2 года назад

      @@TheClash115 roflmao

  • @DirtPerson
    @DirtPerson Год назад +138

    I find that Wisconsin goodbyes are very similar to Minnesota goodbyes except the whole experience is just one long stage 2. You're at the door, coats are on, and you stand there for four hours.Occasionally, during a lull in conversation, you might shuffle a few inches away or go down another step on the porch stairs. Once everyone in your party is off the porch, the ceremony is complete, and you may flee. The host isn't allowed to follow you to your car.

    • @jijitters
      @jijitters 8 месяцев назад +4

      This definitely happens with Minnesota good-byes when you're at a neighbor's house instead of further away from home. If you're close enough to your house that it would be absurd to ask someone to stay the night, then we end up at the door for hours lol

    • @KrustyKrab-x3j
      @KrustyKrab-x3j 2 месяца назад

      Canada is no different. You have to strategically try to leave or send your friends off at 7, knowing no one's really leaving until 9 or later.

    • @averynorthern5361
      @averynorthern5361 Месяц назад +2

      The North Dakota one is similar. Your children are at the door next to you, trying to inch their coats off since the heat is blasting, but you insist they keep them on, since "We're about to leave." You continue to talk with your host as your children slowly die of heat stroke. However, when you carry their lifeless bodies out to the car, your host DOES follow you and talks through the window as in Minnesota.

    • @Nesetalis
      @Nesetalis 4 дня назад

      I'm from Nortern Wisconsin, and this whole video kicked me in the ass. xD

  • @liammoodyfilms
    @liammoodyfilms 2 года назад +566

    This is kind of a masterpiece. I really couldn’t tell if this was a parody or satire for a while because his presentation is flawless and the nostalgia production values tie it in so well. This is underrated

    • @metaloverdose
      @metaloverdose 2 года назад +54

      I feel the same. I feel like this would be right at home on Adult Swim.

    • @ts4gv
      @ts4gv 2 года назад +52

      turns out it was first published in ‘87. I really thought this was a modern nostalgia masterpiece.

    • @nicklikesradio
      @nicklikesradio 2 года назад +45

      The humor is dryer than the drought this year, eh?

    • @hydrocarbon82
      @hydrocarbon82 Год назад +31

      @@nicklikesradio You bet

    • @seebeearr600
      @seebeearr600 Год назад +20

      @@nicklikesradio could be worse

  • @snowyminnesota6028
    @snowyminnesota6028 3 месяца назад +18

    Tim Walz BRINGS IT.

    • @markh9675
      @markh9675 9 дней назад

      Sorry, I wasn't listening. What?

  • @nicko9130
    @nicko9130 3 года назад +556

    I think the line “they’re different out there and don’t seem to realize it.” might be the most brilliantly desiccated insult ever committed. Especially after learning the true meaning of the term ‘that’s different’.

    • @Micolash_is_behind_you
      @Micolash_is_behind_you 2 года назад +4

      lolololol

    • @thrawl
      @thrawl 2 года назад +10

      That is the greatest insult of all time

    • @MinecraftMartin
      @MinecraftMartin 2 года назад +5

      As a west coast person who spent a couple years living east coast, yes yes yes. It's like the land of the over-tanned party animals, bleached teeth and all

    • @DingDongDaddyFromDumas933
      @DingDongDaddyFromDumas933 2 года назад +7

      You bet.

    • @DanaTheInsane
      @DanaTheInsane 2 года назад

      That's different is like the southern "Bless your heart" basically code, for you are pretty stupid aren't you?

  • @SnausageKing
    @SnausageKing 2 года назад +196

    Waiting for the third offer has caused some issues in my blended family. Mexican sister in law looks very hurt when she offers food and I turn it down thinking there’s 2 more offers. I’ve had to learn to actually say what I mean and it causes me physical pain.

    • @llamasugar5478
      @llamasugar5478 2 года назад +15

      Thank you for your efforts in bridging cross-cultural gaps!

    • @mydogslikeboiledeggs7094
      @mydogslikeboiledeggs7094 Год назад +27

      Gotta learn how to say yes in a very passive way. When someone offers me food, I always say, “Are you sure? Only if there's extra."

    • @emiliavenka
      @emiliavenka Год назад +16

      Born and raised in MN and I never grasped the "3 times" rule. I would immediately say yes or no, I was considered a very rude little kid.

    • @SnausageKing
      @SnausageKing Год назад +4

      @@mydogslikeboiledeggs7094 that is an incredible tip, thank you

    • @sfmc98
      @sfmc98 Год назад +3

      Yes, generally when Mexican folks offer you something, they expect you to accept it or take your no for an answer.
      And also a little jarring is the reverse of that if you politely, half heartedly offer something and they do accept immediately! Can't exactly go back on that haha.

  • @Wigfield84
    @Wigfield84 3 года назад +213

    “That’s different” is now “interesting”.

  • @grantgpr
    @grantgpr Год назад +30

    I had somehow never heard the phrase "A guy could almost be happy today if he wasn't careful" in all my years here, but now I am absolutely using it

  • @commandrogyne
    @commandrogyne 2 года назад +96

    Born and raised minnesotan- this is painfully accurate. The only thing left out is the relatively recent "well i shouldnt keep you!" deployed as a secret weapon by anyone wanting to get out the door before noon. Acceptable followups are making up chores you have to do, sudden interest in obscure sports that will be televised soon, and kids you gotta pick up from somewhere nonspecific like the barn. Use sparingly! Too many 'well i shouldn't keep you's can appear impolite and speedy.

    • @gxlorp
      @gxlorp Год назад

      Fuck dat. Just say your gonna go. This is coward shit, and really werid

  • @srmtav
    @srmtav 2 года назад +762

    It's really nice to see this again, and also really nice to see people still enjoying my father's work

    • @tanya5322
      @tanya5322 2 года назад +63

      Hello!
      If he’s your dad, then your mom taught some of my classes when I was a Math Education major in Marshall many years ago.

    • @lisabauch854
      @lisabauch854 2 года назад +63

      I think of your dad every time I do the one-finger wave to my neighbors or the long goodbye with my family (Just last night, it took an hour to leave my sister-in-law's house, which is a block away from ours). Seriously, he seemed he had that rare gift of both intelligence/insight and a kind and gentle heart. My condolences on his passing.

    • @jerkboxjojo
      @jerkboxjojo 2 года назад +50

      I show this to people who are not from here after they've had a stay here for a bit. Hands down one of my favorite videos that when it comes on, I watch the whole thing. He was a satirical genius with the straight-faced humor that just kills me! So many of the mannerisms he displays are on point and I still see them with people today. The part about 2 guys talking and how they stand, absolute GOLD. Thanks for sharing him with us :)

    • @dspiffy
      @dspiffy 2 года назад +28

      God bless your dad! This video captures growing up in the midwest better than anything I could describe. I've shared it so many times.

    • @joeymorrison6743
      @joeymorrison6743 2 года назад +34

      Not to bad pass the butter please

  • @thessalian
    @thessalian 4 года назад +338

    For those who wanted to know, this was produced by KTCA and first broadcast January 1, 1993 (per Wikipedia).

    • @Craigthepope
      @Craigthepope 3 года назад +23

      This is comedy gold.

    • @stubbystudios9811
      @stubbystudios9811 3 года назад +10

      there is also a book written by him in 1987

    • @donkeydan5996
      @donkeydan5996 2 года назад +2

      Thanks ! was wondering when this was made 😊

    • @phanic.at.the.disco.
      @phanic.at.the.disco. 2 года назад +2

      thank you bruh i was looking for this comment

    • @CiroSantilli
      @CiroSantilli Год назад +1

      Link: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Talk_Minnesotan

  • @bob8776
    @bob8776 2 года назад +51

    I love the fact that this feels like a recent parody of 90s public TV programs even though it's actually from the 90s

  • @jkfecke
    @jkfecke 3 месяца назад +17

    You know, this video is not too bad. Just as good as most of the other videos on RUclips, and possibly better than some of 'em.

    • @swedishpsychopath8795
      @swedishpsychopath8795 Месяц назад +2

      Should we answer with "whatever" or "you bet" ?

    • @markh9675
      @markh9675 9 дней назад +1

      Hold on, this video is NOT better than some. NEVER admit that and do not speak of this again. You're obviously a non-Minnesotan that encourages a public display of pride/fame. Not cool.

  • @jeffburnham6611
    @jeffburnham6611 2 года назад +451

    The Long Goodbye had me laughing. As a native Minnesotan my family would spend summer vacations with relatives. One of my parents would start the goodbye by saying we had a 5hr trip back home, and before you knew it, we were staying for lunch, a few games of cribbage, a couple bars and coffee lol. What started out shortly after breakfast, usually turned in to a departure sometime between 3 and 4pm, with relatives following us out to the car, leaning at the door, trying to get us to stay for dinner in an hour. By the time we got home, somebody would inevitably say next time we have to leave earlier lol.

    • @theobserver9131
      @theobserver9131 2 года назад +12

      OMG. That's where I got that trauma from! That's one thing I will never miss about Minnesota.

    • @mjd3879
      @mjd3879 Год назад +8

      I didn't grow up in minnesota but the long good byes are hilarious I think I may have some minnesota blood because when I try to leave somewhere I feel like it ends up exactly like this!!!

    • @theobserver9131
      @theobserver9131 Год назад +7

      @@mjd3879 even though I spent my first 18 years in Minnesota, the long goodbyes always annoy the hell out of me. When I am ready to go, I go. If I'm trying to leave sticky people, sometimes I sneak away, or even come up with an emergency so I can escape.

    • @Annieisnthome
      @Annieisnthome Год назад +9

      "Long goodbyes" hit a little different when one of your parents is a narcissist, ha. I say goodbye, get in my car, and nod and wave at the people still trying to talk to me. I imagine they're still there in the driveway, chattering away and the fact that I've gone just doesn't register until they realize there kind of chilly and no one else is there.

    • @nuns8126
      @nuns8126 Год назад +4

      This long good bye was typical of my childhood. It's definitely a cultural thing. I think it is the result of trauma. Separation anxiety. Nostalgia for the old farm family life characteristic of Scandinavians.

  • @EsmieShroom
    @EsmieShroom Год назад +21

    My lord that passing wave bit is so spot on. In the small farming community I grew up in if you failed to wave at someone as you passed by them on the road you bet your ass you'll have some old ladies talking shit about you at coffee and donut hour after church service

  • @SuperPhexx
    @SuperPhexx 2 года назад +40

    As a rural Norwegian with relatives in Minnesota this feels wery relatable.

  • @xpkareem
    @xpkareem 2 года назад +81

    My grandparents lived in Minnesota, my grandmother had a strong accent. I love the understated, laid back, somewhat sardonic attitude. A Minnesotan could insult Californian (or even a Southerner) three ways from Sunday and they would never know it, they'd walk away thinking they had a pleasant, if a little boring, interaction. You bet.

    • @yoboy6319
      @yoboy6319 2 года назад +1

      Weird, we just tell people we don't like them up north.

    • @HubertofLiege
      @HubertofLiege 2 года назад +23

      @@yoboy6319 that’s different

    • @captainclark2337
      @captainclark2337 Год назад +1

      @@yoboy6319 Welp, that's a little brash if I'd say so myself

  • @etzool
    @etzool 2 года назад +191

    As a middle-aged Minnesotan living in Tokyo, I'm going to show this to my friends as cultural exchange. It's just too perfect. :D

    • @brad2299
      @brad2299 2 года назад +21

      Minnesota kind of seems to be the Japan of the US. Extremely polite, and passive aggressive when angry lol

    • @emiliavenka
      @emiliavenka Год назад +11

      @@brad2299 No way! Minnesotans are pretty blunt, in a polite way. In Japan it's considered better to lie than admit you don't know something, all to save face. Minnesotans don't particularly care about saving face, we're much more humble.

    • @samaraisnt
      @samaraisnt Год назад +11

      @@emiliavenka That's incorrect. They will only be polite because you're foreign, in a familiar context they will be LIFE SHATTERINGLY blunt about your work, your apearance, your vocation and their true opinion about you...Ofc you'll never get that side but watch the Miyazaki meetings to see true Japanese bluntness in action.

    • @stubbystudios9811
      @stubbystudios9811 Год назад +3

      As a Minnesotan your both correct lol

    • @PhunkMaster-VivatChristusRex
      @PhunkMaster-VivatChristusRex Год назад +2

      I've always wondered what other cultures (especially people like the Japanese) would think of us. As far as Americans go, us Minnesotans are a bit goofy.

  • @liquemascis
    @liquemascis 2 года назад +130

    This is the most important historical document of native Minnesotans we have.

  • @MyAltdraco
    @MyAltdraco 2 года назад +305

    Born and raised in eastern North Dakota, I can say the same rules apply here. Although this sounds like a parody, it is probably the best advice video for our cultural nuances. That is to say, it's not too bad, one could almost applaud this if they weren't careful.

    • @Rosseloh
      @Rosseloh 2 года назад +21

      Eastern South Dakota as well. Goes to show that things don't often change instantly because of a line drawn on a map.

    • @jamesstuart3346
      @jamesstuart3346 2 года назад +8

      Canada too

    • @buzman1985
      @buzman1985 2 года назад +4

      A parody of what?

    • @Smurfman256
      @Smurfman256 Год назад +2

      Born in South Eastern Minnesota and grew up in Western North Dakota. Rules still apply over there

    • @thevashfan12392
      @thevashfan12392 Год назад +2

      @@Rosseloh definitely not in sioux falls though....my firsthand experience is the folks around here are a mix of pleasant and "ain't too pleasant"

  • @SanktePer
    @SanktePer 2 года назад +302

    As a Swede it's nice to see that there still some cultural overlap from the time our ancestors settled Minnesota. I definitively have to visit some day.

    • @gallowglass3764
      @gallowglass3764 2 года назад +56

      I actually spent a month in Sweden a few years ago. My great grandfather came to America from Sweden, so it was cool to visit my roots. As a native Minnesotan, I was blown away by the similarities. Your country sides are almost like the Boundary Waters here, and Skövde felt a little like Duluth. When asked by the locals if I'd been enjoying my visit, I laughed and jokingly said, "it's like I never left home!"

    • @hoobaguy
      @hoobaguy 2 года назад +30

      Minneapolis looks like Somalia nowadays. It's a real shame.

    • @flutebasket4294
      @flutebasket4294 2 года назад +15

      Yeah, especially all the Muslims! 😅😅😅

    • @DanaTheInsane
      @DanaTheInsane 2 года назад +14

      I live downtown, with the Somali people these guys get so upset about. They are ok people. But you want this kind of thing you have to get fifty miles out of the cities.

    • @christophereichten9005
      @christophereichten9005 2 года назад

      @@hoobaguy I’m glad you’re an open racist. Now people will know to avoid you.

  • @CaptainCarrotzz
    @CaptainCarrotzz Год назад +76

    Man, over the holidays with my in laws:
    "Could I getcha a beer?"
    "Oh no, you don't have to do that."
    "Oh it's no trouble, really."
    "Oh no no, don't worry, I'll grab one myself."
    "I was just about to get one myself, no worries."
    "A grain belt then if you please, thank you kindly."

    • @npxmnpxm
      @npxmnpxm Год назад +6

      Grain Belt! That's worth a trip right there.

  • @shanecarlson9076
    @shanecarlson9076 Год назад +16

    Talked to the owner at a fly shop. It wasn't until I left and was well on the way home that I realized we had the whole conversation at a 45* angle, arms folded while staring at the shelf of terminal tackle across the room. This is literally baked into us like a can of cream of mushroom soup.

  • @ashleyjohnson7496
    @ashleyjohnson7496 4 года назад +159

    I've lived in Minnesota my whole life and never know "not to bad" and "could be worse" was a Minnesota thing.

    • @josephsmith961
      @josephsmith961 3 года назад +4

      Iowa too.

    • @lowresgamr
      @lowresgamr 3 года назад +3

      Same boat here, that's a huge part of my speech too. I say it instinctively

    • @clarkevanmeter2676
      @clarkevanmeter2676 3 года назад +11

      @@josephsmith961 Yeah, most of this is Iowa as well. Streets full of people talking at 135 degrees.

    • @robdyrdek1354
      @robdyrdek1354 3 года назад +6

      could be worse. you could still not know

    • @Jake-uc8mb
      @Jake-uc8mb 3 года назад +1

      Yeah I also thought all this was perfectly normal 😅

  • @galaxys7650
    @galaxys7650 2 года назад +312

    I'm a native Minnesotan and still live here. This was so spot on. I laughed the whole time. Best video on RUclips

    • @Denis_Dolgov
      @Denis_Dolgov 2 года назад +9

      Whatever ;)

    • @blazefairchild465
      @blazefairchild465 Год назад +4

      I have never been but I am an Icelandic American and I see many Icelander settled in Minnesota, so many traits are the same if not every point you hit on.

    • @GrunOne
      @GrunOne Год назад +3

      Canadian here. Something about cold places makes people this way eh

    • @emiliavenka
      @emiliavenka Год назад +5

      @@GrunOne I've actually thought about this and I think it's exactly because of the cold weather that we have this type of "friendly" culture. We need to stay on good terms because you might need a stranger to help you shovel out your car. Winter makes us work together! 😂😂

    • @reaperthemad8731
      @reaperthemad8731 Год назад

      Most of the Midwest outside of cities in my experience

  • @Jefff72
    @Jefff72 Год назад +12

    I'm a Minnesotan now living in Germany. This video made me homesick.

    • @SomeFreakingCactus
      @SomeFreakingCactus 5 месяцев назад +1

      You should've stayed for lunch! Then you'd never get to leave.

  • @aStrix171
    @aStrix171 4 года назад +283

    As a born and raised Minnesotan, this is hilarious.

    • @IRLTheGreatZarquon
      @IRLTheGreatZarquon 3 года назад +16

      It's so accurate that it hurts, especially the Minnesota Long Goodbye

    • @Hikari_Sakurai
      @Hikari_Sakurai 3 года назад +3

      Bri'ish here learning how to Minnesotan and omg this is hilarious. XD

    • @chessplayer6632
      @chessplayer6632 3 года назад +9

      Ohhh...It sure is different donchaknow

    • @veronika4870
      @veronika4870 2 года назад +5

      is true with those three reply phrases?

    • @jontheguitarman
      @jontheguitarman 2 года назад +5

      @@veronika4870 yep, you betcha

  • @kathyjuola6317
    @kathyjuola6317 2 года назад +209

    I have this on VHS! I picked it up at a garage sale somewhere. I remember watching it with my dad and he laughed so hard. My phone is totally listening to me. I made some hotdish tonight for dinner, now this comes up as a suggestion.

    • @stubowl1
      @stubowl1 Год назад +1

      you bet!

    • @gxlorp
      @gxlorp Год назад +4

      Yeah haha. It's soooooo funny we're all being spied on. We're definitely totally not living in a science fiction dystopia. SooO○oO○OoO○ funny. 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

    • @bh7622
      @bh7622 Год назад

      Hot dish… wow. Haven’t heard that in years. Grandparents lived in Thomson, Iowa. Anyway, off to have dinner then supper later.

    • @DelGTAGrndrs
      @DelGTAGrndrs Год назад

      @@gxlorp at least you get it, it’s sickening

    • @man0ver
      @man0ver Год назад +1

      What is the copyright date on the tape? Just curious to know what year this came from! Thanks!

  • @Jakob165
    @Jakob165 2 года назад +195

    I'm a Minnesotan and I can't tell if it's a joke or legit, which just goes to show you how spot on their presentation is. XD

    • @teuast
      @teuast 2 года назад +13

      it's a classic case of "truth presented comedically"

    • @kocahmet1
      @kocahmet1 Год назад +6

      you bet

  • @Sharpodiplomat
    @Sharpodiplomat 25 дней назад +2

    I'm from Skåne, the southernmost part of Sweden, and the "ask three times" is still quite common in the countryside. When I was a kid I used to ask my sister's very polite friend only twice if she wanted dessert...

  • @milky.funland
    @milky.funland 2 года назад +173

    As a Finn I can relate to everything on this video. 😂 If you changed 'Minnesota/Minnesotan' to 'Finland/Finnish', it would still be 100 % accurate.

    • @darthcreepio
      @darthcreepio 2 года назад +28

      Good to know my credits from this course will transfer to Finland!

    • @elkinkku
      @elkinkku 2 года назад +31

      @@darthcreepio you bet! You just need a couple supplementary lessons "never sit next to anyone in the bus even if there is space" and "don't approach the deli counter until you're completely sure what you want to get" and you're golden.

    • @marcalvarez4890
      @marcalvarez4890 Год назад +5

      Thats exactly what i was thinking!!!

    • @jijitters
      @jijitters 8 месяцев назад +2

      As a Finnish Minnesotan this is validating!

  • @marcalvarez4890
    @marcalvarez4890 Год назад +9

    In a world where the internet delivers 24 hours of an unlimited amount of novelty, dopamine, and porn.....this youtube channel is like falling back into the 1970s and its 3 channels and PBS.
    Y'all are wonderful.
    Thank you.

    • @KnittingTinker
      @KnittingTinker 6 месяцев назад +1

      Ya should come visit Minnesota

  • @3ggshe11s
    @3ggshe11s 3 года назад +86

    I'm from lower Michigan. People talk like this in the Upper Peninsula too. It was like a whole different world, culturally, linguistically, and everything else. And I always loved it.

  • @CR7966
    @CR7966 Год назад +2

    I’m a born and bred Bostonian, but my girlfriend is a Duluth girl. This video was indispensable in the early days of our relationship.

  • @XbunkerXballerX7127
    @XbunkerXballerX7127 Год назад +3

    This is the best thing PBS/TPT Has ever made.

  • @notpsicoh2107
    @notpsicoh2107 Год назад +88

    "...they're just as friendly as your next door neighbor, but without all that sarcasm that hurts so much."
    Something about that delivery just kills me every time. Its so genuine.

  • @amandaknapp8955
    @amandaknapp8955 2 года назад +44

    I mean...He isn't wrong in any way. When I was a kid my dad used to make me go sit in the car so he could pry my mom out of family gatherings faster. I would often have to sit there for 20 minutes or more. Pre cell phone or Gameboy mind you. If I was lucky he'd have the car running so I at least had air or heat.
    Which is to say that this was spot on and hilarious

    • @sfmc98
      @sfmc98 Год назад +2

      "If I was lucky" lololol

  • @djt8937
    @djt8937 Год назад +12

    17:08 I love how he acts genuinely superior at the moment "and besides, those are BARS..." flaunting his superiority/contempt over the guy in the example.

  • @nothingmaster9432
    @nothingmaster9432 Год назад +3

    After growing up in Indiana and living in Michigan for 10 years this video will help anyone struggling to speak either Michigander or Hoosier.

  • @ZackeTheBrute
    @ZackeTheBrute 3 года назад +64

    As a scandinavian it sounds almost like home.

    • @emiliavenka
      @emiliavenka 3 года назад +20

      Minnesota was settled primarily by Norwegians and Swedes!

    • @ZackeTheBrute
      @ZackeTheBrute 3 года назад +16

      @@emiliavenka And the Danes went of to Oregon for some godforsaken reason. Danes, never to be trusted.

    • @erichamilton3373
      @erichamilton3373 Год назад

      Probably a cultural influence but the accent comes from the Northern Yankee settlers coming from Upstate New York. Later Scandinavian and Getman settlers just adapted to that.

    • @ZackeTheBrute
      @ZackeTheBrute Год назад

      @@erichamilton3373 Not the dialect but the things they say.

    • @jijitters
      @jijitters 8 месяцев назад

      @@emiliavenka Everyone always forgets the Finns when they say this 😔

  • @anybodyoutthere3208
    @anybodyoutthere3208 Год назад +19

    I’ve watched the LONG GOODBYE almost every night for two weeks.
    Just love it
    Parts of it are like how it was at my parents house in the 60’s and 70’s
    Thanks all and good night
    Whatever

  • @aaronsaunders6974
    @aaronsaunders6974 4 месяца назад +3

    That’s different-the most unique thing Minnesota has ever said 😊

  • @NorthernKitty
    @NorthernKitty 2 года назад +28

    I lived in Minnesota for nearly a decade. I discovered I went from answering "How are you doing today" with "Great!" to "Oh, I guess I'm surviving." 😁 I got the negative thing down, you bet.

    • @katherinemurphy2762
      @katherinemurphy2762 Год назад +2

      I lived in Minnesota for a decade as well (from 3rd grade through hs graduation) and it wasn't until I saw this that I realized "That's different" ended up in my lexicon exactly as this tutorial describes it should be used. 😂

  • @kumquatmagoo
    @kumquatmagoo 2 года назад +15

    I'm from England. This was an absolute joy to watch. Amazing deadpan delivery, though that might just be Minnesotan.

  • @usa91787
    @usa91787 2 года назад +7

    Location: Salt Lake City International Airport 1987.
    I'm on a flight from Salt Lake City to Boise, ID going back to where I was stationed in the Air Force. Had been in Billings, MT.
    As I'm sitting in my seat two people in their 70's sit next to me. A husband and wife.
    The man gets situated and immediately starts fiddling around with the tray. After a few minutes he looks at his wife and says
    "Ya nooo. A guy could...."
    Two things at play had me doing all I could to keep from laughing hysterically - having just read "How To Speak Minnesotan" and being from Minnesota.
    How I managed - without laughing to say "You're from Minnesota aren't you?" is beyond me.
    The man says in his best Northwestern Minnesota accent:
    "Ya. Howdja no?"
    Me: "I'm from Minnesota too."
    Him: "Ohhh ya. We just flew in from Da Cities. We live in Teef River Fallss."
    Greatest book ever.

  • @tonys7675
    @tonys7675 4 года назад +98

    I finished grad school in 1997 and moved to Florida nine months later. I never knew "uff da" was a Minnesota thing until the first time I said it in Florida and people looked at me like I was crazy.

    • @larryvaughn5843
      @larryvaughn5843 4 года назад +9

      Oh for sure. I attended UMC in Crookston and moved down to Florida a year or so later. Oh for hot.

    • @thatnorwegianguy1986
      @thatnorwegianguy1986 3 года назад +32

      Uffda is Norwegian and can be translated to ... Oh Dear but not surprising given that Minnesota is just a Norwegian province just hiding amongst American states.

    • @d.harrison1570
      @d.harrison1570 3 года назад +1

      That's fantastic.

    • @HrHaakon
      @HrHaakon 3 года назад +9

      ​@@thatnorwegianguy1986
      Nah, oh dear is sympathetic, uff da is not necessarily sympathetic. It just acknowledges that something suboptimal happened.

    • @thejohnbeck
      @thejohnbeck 2 года назад +4

      @@HrHaakon so Homer Simpson's "DOH!" is a good equivalent, albeit a bit too exciting?

  • @Arkylie
    @Arkylie 2 года назад +27

    "Not too good" being worse than "not too bad" makes sense to my dialect (Pacific Northwest). "Not too good" is a mild negative, while "not too bad" is a mild positive. And yeah, it's pretty weird now that I think about it, even though it feels natural to me.

  • @Zak_How
    @Zak_How 6 месяцев назад +3

    This will prepare me for the move

  • @martintrj5620
    @martintrj5620 3 года назад +29

    11:37 so polite he didn’t even try to offend that fly by hitting it with his hand, he kept them either folded or hanging down. Great job!

  • @coreygossman6243
    @coreygossman6243 2 года назад +64

    As Minnesota born Iowegian, let me just say, bars are a work of art. A lot of the culinary style comes from not having access to variety of foods that get shipped to other places in the country. Even though we are generally wealthy (usually land rich) and live in the wealthiest country in the world, its good form to be a cheap ass and make do with what you've got. So cheerios glued together with a little marshmallow and peanut butter, drizzled with almond bark or chocolate, everything that goes into a midwest meal usually keeps in the pantry for months, if not years.
    I actually really love my home and I want to preserve the Minnesota character, I would even like to see it expand and be adopted by others. If the whole world was Minnesota, that wouldn't be too bad of a world.

    • @distaffpope2603
      @distaffpope2603 2 года назад +3

      This comment would be traced back to being the origin of the Minnesotan crusade.

    • @dingusdingus2152
      @dingusdingus2152 Год назад

      In all fairness, Minnesotans have an insufferable bad habit of spitting out inappropriate aphorisms on every occasion. Insipid platitudes, like things that football coaches say. The absolute all time most annoying of them is "when life gives you lemons, make lemonade"...

    • @dingusdingus2152
      @dingusdingus2152 Год назад

      People in Minnesota will stab you in the back, twist the knife, and say have a nice day...

    • @coreygossman6243
      @coreygossman6243 Год назад

      @@dingusdingus2152 At least they say have a nice day 😊

    • @dingusdingus2152
      @dingusdingus2152 Год назад

      @@coreygossman6243 et tu, brute?

  • @vakire83
    @vakire83 3 года назад +182

    I've been thinking of moving to MN, so in Googling this video came up, and I haven't laughed so hard in a long time. This video is great!! I want to move to MN now!!

    • @Jake-uc8mb
      @Jake-uc8mb 3 года назад +20

      The funniest part is that it's pretty much all still true! Not bad.

    • @martintrj5620
      @martintrj5620 3 года назад +10

      That’s different lol

    • @jordbjor1
      @jordbjor1 3 года назад +2

      Don’t come we are stocked up on brainwashed dummies

    • @Nealiosaurus
      @Nealiosaurus 3 года назад +13

      Whatever... It's not too bad.

    • @WileHeCoyote
      @WileHeCoyote 3 года назад +10

      You Bet! It could always be worse, at least the gas prices are not too bad, and the hot dish will keep ya warm when the temperature drops lower than an old possum's wrinkle berries

  • @thomaskittock2866
    @thomaskittock2866 2 года назад +50

    This is one of the greatest things I have ever watched. I thought I was on an episode of Best of the Worst for second, but this truly was a work of art.

  • @EpicCookies
    @EpicCookies 3 года назад +33

    This is pretty accurate for swedish people too.

    • @johnjay1147
      @johnjay1147 3 года назад +11

      So, native Minnesotans.

  • @snowyminnesota6028
    @snowyminnesota6028 3 месяца назад +3

    He's killin' it! Snowy Minnesota here, and my guy is repping us!

  • @karlhungus5554
    @karlhungus5554 3 года назад +124

    This video is truly a work of art. I'm on my fourth viewing in two days and still laughing aloud. Brilliant.

  • @Blessed_by_Yeshua
    @Blessed_by_Yeshua 2 года назад +30

    I love this!
    My family are from Boston, from Ireland, England, and Prince Edward Island. I grew up in a family where crying isn’t even done at funerals. A lady saves her sadness for her pillow. A man’s only emotions seem only to be happy (when sharing a beer and a ball game) or angry (when kids stand in the way of the tv while guys are having a beer and watching a ball game.
    Spice is called salt and pepper and most meals contained a meat, potatoes, some green colored vegetable and bread and butter. Milk for dinner. And then most grownups have a cup of coffee or hot tea. Iced tea isn’t a thing.
    Fish on Friday or Pizza. That’s not negotiable.
    If you are waiting for a compliment, don’t bother. Compliments are said about a person, not to a person. “Wow! Isn’t she becoming quite a lady!”

    • @gxlorp
      @gxlorp Год назад +3

      Get out of here Boston. This is about Minnesota. It's too far away for you to put in your 2c

  • @jasontheflyingfarrierhays
    @jasontheflyingfarrierhays Год назад +7

    This fella is the Red Green of Minnesota 😂
    I’m from northern Michigan and this video feels just like home. To all who worked on this project, it’s not too bad. 😂

  • @NationalDevin
    @NationalDevin 3 года назад +44

    My D&D game thanks you for giving me voice and speech education for my characters, and I just want you to know I respect how you approach your show and your adverts.

    • @finleylemma4934
      @finleylemma4934 2 года назад +1

      Glad I’m not the only one here for D&D!

  • @tedstrikertwa800
    @tedstrikertwa800 2 года назад +24

    This is hilarious. The dry subtle humour Is utterly brilliant.

  • @krimbii
    @krimbii 2 года назад +105

    I live in Ohio and feel like I can relate to all of this. The way my dad always talked to his buddies while they faced the horizon. The long goodbye. The single finger wave (but only if you're out driving in the country). The way we always refuse something when someone offers you something because you genuinely don't want to trouble them, but then they insist 😂😂😂

    • @KristianWontroba
      @KristianWontroba 2 года назад +5

      Agreed. I experienced much of this when I lived in Toledo and visited Michigan, in both places. 😂 A lot of this is totally a white, midwestern thing. 😅

    • @waoh2010
      @waoh2010 2 года назад +5

      I just moved to Ohio from CA and I find this all amusing. Midwesterners are an interesting bunch. I’ll never fit in but I do love y’all.

    • @gxlorp
      @gxlorp Год назад

      @@waoh2010 California is a big place. But you guys have Hollywood. It's not a culture, its a mental illness

    • @captainclark2337
      @captainclark2337 Год назад +2

      I was debating commenting the same thing. Boy am I glad I found this. I feel the biggest thing not mentioned here, however, has to be the holding of doors for people, especially if they're at least twenty feet away. As long as you sense they're a-coming, you'll stand there and wait for them. And, of course, there's the whole "ope" thing. That said, I'm not too sure if Minnesotans actually use that fateful word or not.

    • @nuns8126
      @nuns8126 Год назад

      Isn't ope what the Norwegians say?

  • @Pretermit_Sound
    @Pretermit_Sound 2 года назад +39

    I’m from NE Minnesota, and have the book “How to Talk Minnesotan” by Howard Moore. Neat to see a televised version of it. It’s painfully hilarious how accurate some of this stuff is 😅

  • @yetiornot5726
    @yetiornot5726 3 года назад +56

    Oh gahsh, I don't think I've ever seen a more accurate satire of our culture.
    ... Sorry I flew off the handle like that.

  • @SamanthaBartonYAY
    @SamanthaBartonYAY Год назад +1

    ive recently moved out west and the never say yes until the third time is so spot on! i either deny once and they never offer again or im the one offering and i keep doing it and it turns out they never wanted it in the first place and now i sound pushy!

  • @jaenmartens5697
    @jaenmartens5697 2 года назад +13

    When I made it over to Norway finally I found the origin of hotdish! Brown chopped or ground meat(moose in our case) saute it with an onion, a bell pepper if you have it handy, stir in a cup or so of sour cream and bake til it is steaming hot.

  • @LearnwithJanice
    @LearnwithJanice 2 года назад +2

    Hello from Kansas 🇺🇸

  • @annki3837
    @annki3837 3 года назад +81

    It's so fun to hear that you've kept a lot of phrases that we still use in Norway and.. btw the hand wave, finger and the long goodbye ;-P

    • @HrHaakon
      @HrHaakon 3 года назад +5

      The long party does not apply at parties in Norway. After all, we don't want to make a big deal out of it, or get in someone else's way, so we'll leave, and at worst, have a goodbye with the host so they don't worry about us being kidnapped or something.

    • @annki3837
      @annki3837 3 года назад +1

      @@HrHaakon Maybe today, but it might was a habit from our grandparents....

    • @HrHaakon
      @HrHaakon 3 года назад +8

      ​@@annki3837
      Parties are not the same things as visits though. Saying goodbye *properly* takes time.

    • @farmingwithaustin
      @farmingwithaustin 2 года назад +3

      my family has lived in the same spot in minnesota ever since we came to america 1882

    • @annki3837
      @annki3837 2 года назад

      @@farmingwithaustin That's cool! Immigrants from Scandinavia or others?

  • @whatsit50
    @whatsit50 Год назад +1

    im from Minnesota, but ive been living in AZ for a few years now. Seeing this makes me miss home.

  • @rossradtke
    @rossradtke 2 года назад +20

    "...and besides that, those aren't cookies on the tray, they're bars..."
    👍

  • @its_marie91
    @its_marie91 Год назад +2

    Our long goodbye includes a horn honk in a specific pattern as they or we drive away (to the tune of "skunk in the barnyard"😅)

  • @Tinyflypie
    @Tinyflypie Год назад +4

    Hi! I am fascinated by the Minnesota accent and expressions. Kind of strange since I live in Australia 🇦🇺

  • @candykane4271
    @candykane4271 Год назад +1

    The two old dudes talking reminded me of my own grandpa going to town to hang outside the post office, to talk to the other retirees. And he definitely had the monotone Minnesotan way.

  • @americangamer1632
    @americangamer1632 2 года назад +24

    Baking the hotdish at 400-700 got me howling

    • @DeepBlooded
      @DeepBlooded 6 месяцев назад +2

      "Turn off the smoke alarm" 😂😭😂

  • @Lauri2014
    @Lauri2014 2 года назад +30

    They act kind of like Finns in their awkwardness, but unlike Finns who avoid interactions, they sort of force the social interaction.

  • @justins21482
    @justins21482 2 года назад +8

    The whole turn down an offer until the 3rd time...I know this is supposed to be funny but for the longest time I was that way...I swear my grandmother who raised me must be from Minnesota lol. Eventually with age I stopped caring and if you offer, ill accept if i genuinly would like whatever it is you are offering! No need to decline twice prior. But I 100% understand the way of thinking.

  • @DCJMS
    @DCJMS Год назад +1

    what a gem

  • @wintersknight4406
    @wintersknight4406 2 года назад +25

    I’ve always instinctively followed the “don’t accept until the 3rd offer” and never realized how rude that guy at 16:50 sounds, but people from Wisconsin are a bit different

    • @IgneousExtrusive
      @IgneousExtrusive 2 года назад +1

      Here in Illinois, we can accept on the first or second offer, but if you were to ask for any additional items without being offered you must say something like, "Do you mind if I have one'a those creamers too?" "D'ya mind if I grab a bar too?"
      Also, instead of outright refusing on the first offer, we'll probably say something like, "you sure?" or the noncommittal "Oh, maybe, thanks!"
      So still a bit of beating around the bush but way more direct. The rules might be different up in northern Illinois too.

    • @DeepBlooded
      @DeepBlooded 6 месяцев назад

      ... didn't even say PLEASE!!!

  • @GbuHgz62
    @GbuHgz62 2 года назад +4

    Gems like this are why I spend hours on youtube.

  • @MinecraftMartin
    @MinecraftMartin 2 года назад +39

    Howard and the coffee interaction is funny as hell. Love the way he manages to sound bull headed, yet is anything but imposing.
    RIP Howard. Just happened to pull this video up for my wife and kids a few days ago, had no idea you passed. Thanks for the cultural insights.
    EDIT to add that my wife is Japanese and found much of this relatable to Japanese culture. Accepting on the third offer, the long goodbye, avoid sticking out, adamantly concerned with being a bother to anyone else. Who would have thought lol

  • @dillonrose3428
    @dillonrose3428 Год назад +1

    This is my souls favorite comedy.

  • @gabrielwillemssen5167
    @gabrielwillemssen5167 Год назад +4

    i’ve lived in minnesota my whole life but recently moved to chicago. seeing this really made me realize how much I miss our ways back home! lol

  • @KeeliaSilvis
    @KeeliaSilvis Год назад +2

    When new colleagues & students come to the University of Minnesota from out of state, I always send them this. So then they can go "Ohhhh NOW I get it!"

  • @erikengheim1106
    @erikengheim1106 2 года назад +41

    Hahaha as a Norwegian I got to say a number of things are quite recognizable Norwegian or Nordic traits. We are kind of low key and don't like to talk too positive about things. People rarely express anger directly but more in a passive aggressive manner. Although having been in Minnesota I still think it felt very different from Norway. A lot of the attitude is perhaps a bit more typical of inland Norway, while most of us live in the coast. It is Norwegian inland farmer culture. For a contemporary Norwegian Minnesota and North Dakota will seem overly conservative.
    Expression such as "cannot complain" or "it could be worse" is certainly stuff you would hear in Norway from older people.

    • @eckligt
      @eckligt 2 года назад +12

      I was also thinking of Norway's inland regions, especially the joke that goes: Did you hear about the fella out by Hamar who loved his wife so much, he almost told her?

    • @evelynwaugh4053
      @evelynwaugh4053 2 года назад +3

      @@eckligt Always loved that joke!

    • @MyAltdraco
      @MyAltdraco 2 года назад +3

      Everything you said rings true with what I've heard from other Norwegians. And growing up in eastern North Dakota, having lived everything shown in this video, it was always attributed to our Scandinavian ancestry. This was only further proved true when I moved to the middle of North Dakota where the culture is mostly German ancestry. You wouldn't think there would be that much of a difference, and there is a certain amount of overlap, but it really is different. I suspect the same amount of difference you describe as going from coastal Norway to the inland farming area.

    • @salionshatterstar
      @salionshatterstar Год назад +4

      I always love “can’t complain” because with the tone of voice it’s delivered in, it sounds like a complaint!

    • @MyAltdraco
      @MyAltdraco Год назад +2

      @@salionshatterstar Oh that is so true. There is a certain intonation with this phrase-I don't think I could say it differently if I tried-and it always sounds like there is an unspoken "but..." after it. Which if the reply was honest, it would be more like "I can't complain, but if I could I have a number of things I could list!"

  • @Felice_Enellen
    @Felice_Enellen 2 года назад +12

    Remarkably similar to life in southern Saskatchewan. I feel like a lot of people will watch this and think it's all a silly farce, but no... life in the north central plains _really is_ like this, or at least it was when I left them around the time this was set. 😆

  • @pmfmpls
    @pmfmpls 2 года назад +52

    As a recently retired college professor, I ALWAYS introduced international students to the complexities of Minnesotan English. Oh, ja, that's different! Usually means we don't like it! Potato salad. Your accent. That color.
    This is a great video!!

  • @inuchan74
    @inuchan74 Год назад +2

    I couldn't begin to guess how.many times I've heard "a thing of beauty and a joy forever." Or said it myself lol.

  • @markh9675
    @markh9675 Год назад +3

    Glad to see this recording on the youtube! Trust me, the Minnesota "good-bye" is a real thing.
    I've said too much.

  • @michellem2892
    @michellem2892 2 года назад +21

    Pure genius. I’m from Indiana and I’ve Been with my Minnesotan husband for 30 years. This education would’ve cleared up a lot of confusion over the years. I can’t believe I’m just now finding this resource but better late than never I guess, whatever (I’m learning ; ).
    By the way, I’m recovering from surgery and it was not a good idea to watch this because it hurts to laugh a the moment… a wise person (especially an outlander who’s been married to a Minnesotan for a long time and has never come across this information) would wait until they’re a little farther along in recovery : D

    • @TwinCitiesPBS
      @TwinCitiesPBS  2 года назад +3

      We love that you're enjoying this and hope that surgery went well! Don't bust any stitches!!

    • @claykeiser3379
      @claykeiser3379 Год назад +1

      Fellow Hoosier here. I found so much of this relatable! Long goodbyes, the one finger wave, and the body language, too.

    • @pirateslife4me
      @pirateslife4me Год назад

      @@claykeiser3379 Agree! I thought we had the market cornered on the long goodbye! 😄

  • @eddieromanov
    @eddieromanov Год назад +3

    I’m from Pennsylvania and the bit with the coffee is painfully accurate.

  • @timpani25
    @timpani25 Год назад +1

    i love the 'singing saw' in the fade-out music.

  • @ajjackson1526
    @ajjackson1526 Год назад +5

    Might a bit exaggerated, but everything in this video is so accurate! Especially in Rural MN in those little Lutheran towns.

  • @janryset1805
    @janryset1805 Год назад +1

    I am from Norway and must say this felt right at home. I could easily live in Minnesota,I think .😄

  • @blinkerk5102
    @blinkerk5102 2 года назад +19

    As an American applied linguist. I APPROVE OF THIS ✅

  • @willeveleigh5633
    @willeveleigh5633 Год назад +5

    Having grown up in Iowa, much of this culture is shared, but hearing the language rationalized shines a particular light on my own sarcasm and “whatever’s” and refusal of food until the third time.

  • @AgentFortySeven47
    @AgentFortySeven47 8 месяцев назад +1

    I'm from Canada and so much of this resonates with me, we really do share a lot in common with Minnesotans. Your state will always be my favourite to visit.

  • @uneedtherapy42
    @uneedtherapy42 2 года назад +3

    I’ve lived in Minnesota my whole life without ever actually living there. I am these people