The Meaning of Secularism in India | Subramanian Swamy | Arth - A Culture Fest, Kolkata

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2020
  • Watch as Subramanian Swamy and activist Anuraag Saxena have an entrancing conversation on 'The Meaning of Secularism in India' at Arth - A Culture Fest, Kolkata, powered by Mongia Steel Limited & Special Partner Future Gaming Sikkim Dear
    *Lottery ticket will be available for sale in West Bengal, Maharashtra, Punjab and in states where sale of lottery is permitted.
    Subscribe to our channel: / arthaculturefest
    Follow us on our social handles:
    Twitter: / arth_live
    Facebook: / arthlive
    Instagram: / arth_live

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @JaiChavan
    @JaiChavan 4 года назад +1160

    Long live Dr. Subramanian Swamy for another 100 years. Jai Hind.

    • @KRChin
      @KRChin 4 года назад +5

      Not possible, another 100 years bitch

    • @gvbhnnnnnnhh
      @gvbhnnnnnnhh 4 года назад +25

      @@KRChin Are you dumb? 😑 Do you not understand the what he meant to say between the lines.

    • @KRChin
      @KRChin 4 года назад

      @@gvbhnnnnnnhh could you please educate me a little bit

    • @atul1024
      @atul1024 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/Am6UvmKRJuw/видео.html

    • @influendil
      @influendil 4 года назад

      is he worth listening?
      ruclips.net/video/DHdjc_kbwO8/видео.html

  • @nivanray6674
    @nivanray6674 4 года назад +647

    Thus Man is a blessing to Indian right wing.

    • @AbhishekSharma-co6dx
      @AbhishekSharma-co6dx 4 года назад +18

      So true sir..absolutely..he shud live for anothet 1000 years to carry the movement..

    • @akpawar651
      @akpawar651 4 года назад +21

      There's no right wing. Only leftist wing. Right wing means we consider one group superior to others. Hindus don't do that. So let's say we have a indian wing instead or Indic wing.

    • @King-ul4nb
      @King-ul4nb 3 года назад +4

      Indic wing

    • @King-ul4nb
      @King-ul4nb 3 года назад +1

      @autonomous psyche I am not saying that I know everything about it and whatever you said is absolutely correct, BUT,
      As per my knowledge, right wing takes pride in their culture and religion even if the religious practices are nonsense and ludicrous (for eg. Consider a right wing government in MALAYSIA, which is a Muslim country and everybody knows about that PISSFUL community)
      But the religion of INDIA has always been SANATAN DHARMA which speaks of spirituality, seeking, and scientific progression and we HINDUS have never taken any initiative to attack or convert people of other community(which Pissfuls and Christians did, so even if the Leftists of such religious majoritarian country criticise their respective majoritarian community, they may be right , but this has never been the case with Hindus but HINDUS or SANATANIs are getting bashed for what was not a part of our culture)
      Secondly, right wingers are supporters are CAPITALISM but we never had such a concept and still before invasions INDIA was the richest country in the whole country with a GDP of whopping 33%.
      Hence I am saying that the right wingers of INDIA are actually INDIC wing.

    • @King-ul4nb
      @King-ul4nb 3 года назад +1

      @autonomous psyche so you are bringing HINDUISM and other ABRAHMIC religions at the same level🤦‍♂️
      Hinduism was never a religion but a way of life .

  • @minashreetapan3953
    @minashreetapan3953 4 года назад +521

    Dr Swamy, a man of wisdom

    • @prana2946
      @prana2946 4 года назад

      @Minashree Tapan wisdom planted by USA

    • @draupadisaristripratethous2909
      @draupadisaristripratethous2909 4 года назад

      Swamy's beseach for a portfolio or a ministry

    • @venkatnarayanantg3262
      @venkatnarayanantg3262 3 года назад

      Why not Dr Swamy interfere with the Tirupati Tirumalai Devasthanam Board where Christians and Muslims are employed in this famous Temple?

    • @mohit5496
      @mohit5496 3 года назад

      @@venkatnarayanantg3262 interfere to do what ?

  • @dr.padmanabhareddyp2543
    @dr.padmanabhareddyp2543 4 года назад +449

    I like his clarity in any topic , long live swamy ji

    • @subhamdeb2554
      @subhamdeb2554 4 года назад +4

      He is just speechless a precious juel in the BJP. It's my wish to see him as the pm of the country

    • @prana2946
      @prana2946 4 года назад

      @SUBHAM DEB BJP will be reduced to double digits..if Swamy is PM face
      The Next PM material after Modi is Devendra Fadnavis...but not for at least 15 years...

    • @subhamdeb2554
      @subhamdeb2554 4 года назад

      BJP people will surely not elect swami as pm as they r also afraid of his daring attitude he always speaks the truth whether it's bitter in taste. He always faught for our country's progressiveness and unity. I can see a glorious tomorrow of our country in him serving as a pure divottee (pm) towards the mother land of INDIA 🇮🇳

    • @prana2946
      @prana2946 4 года назад +1

      @SUBHAM DEB Swamy always says publicly that he knows history of Sonia...
      Modi doesn’t say anything but he knows the history of Swamy...
      how he was speaking against 370 removal, Hindutva, Vajpayee, BJP, etc
      He has always been in some sense a USA agent and Modi Shah’s BJP has let him fight with Russian agents and leftists..
      India that is Bharat does not need the extremes of that.
      Swamy as a capitalist can never think of toilets building, opening bank accounts, Ayushman yojna, etc.
      Swamy as a person will never wash the feet of Dalits and Cleaning Workers.

  • @boyanagaraju2385
    @boyanagaraju2385 4 года назад +124

    Most honest person in our country.... Dr. Swamy sir 🙏

  • @suppiahmurugesan8343
    @suppiahmurugesan8343 4 года назад +718

    Absolutely. Uniform Civil Code MUST be the next move.

    • @shekarroy6892
      @shekarroy6892 4 года назад +24

      TO DECLARE INDIA SECULAR COUNTRY CONGRESS SHOULD BRING BACK PAKISTAN, BANGLADESH.

    • @niteshagate474
      @niteshagate474 4 года назад +2

      I am sorry we might agree on a lot of things (based upon the kind of videos we watch) but I respectfully disagree when it comes to UCC, however, instead of just opposing you I'm more interested in knowing what you are basing your opinion on mainly what is it that you think we will gain by UCC, what do you think we might lose and are the gains worth the losses?
      Just to give an idea about my approach, I agree the constitution demands it and that it would mean equality in a larger sense but I think we as Hindus by insisting on UCC have more to lose than gain. I may be wrong hence I am more interested in knowing rather than debating.
      regards

    • @vmike7946
      @vmike7946 4 года назад +3

      @@niteshagate474 UCC if comes it vl cover only few things , like marage and birth of 2.

    • @niteshagate474
      @niteshagate474 4 года назад +2

      @@vmike7946 which in my view can be done anyway without even UCC like population control bill, for marriage and might I add for a share in the ancestral property to girls we can pass a separate regulation, which will apply to all. in fact these regulations except the population control already apply to Hindus. So what do we have to gain while we risk losing all the benefits?
      take this example on a lighter note, the current situation with personal laws allows a Muslim man to have 4 wives and a Hindu can claim various economic benefits for an Undivided family. So a Muslim man ends up paying more for 4 wives while Hindus save money under 80C.
      now we lose those benefits for ensuring that Muslim man won't have more than one wife doesn't make sense to me.
      See I am trying to understand your point, in my view people who ask for UCC want it for equal treatment of people which cause of personal law boards is hindered in some sense and as you say if it will cover only a few things then that purpose is defeated anyway cause after this whole exercise we would still have a few contentious laws.
      So whether or not the UCC is beneficial is something that can be interpreted only once we know what it covers and we can ascertain gains vs losses properly. perhaps then we can decide whether it should be applied or not.
      I'm sorry it got wordy, but I'm eager to know more about it specifically in terms of what we as a community gain vs lose.
      Thanks for responding.

    • @vmike7946
      @vmike7946 4 года назад +3

      @@niteshagate474 India needs population control bill, they can separetly introduce this bill in sansad. As far UCB we vl see

  • @arinbhakta9707
    @arinbhakta9707 4 года назад +493

    We need more right wing politicians like him...he has the power to change our thinking...

    • @InduCute
      @InduCute 4 года назад +6

      that is y SONIA is intimidated XD

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад +6

      India needs change but right wing ideology is dangerous

    • @InduCute
      @InduCute 4 года назад +24

      @@whynot4828 How ? Trump won the Elections . Europe is Turning right and we are already Right.
      Don't you see Right is the Right

    • @arinbhakta9707
      @arinbhakta9707 4 года назад +10

      @@whynot4828 absolutely dear!
      Let's form a party ... HUMANITARIAN
      N.b - atleast Hinduism has provided us the room for criticism ...that's why we are called a progressive ... Do you know any other religion which has a space for the religious criticism?

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад +1

      @@arinbhakta9707 Noted the sarcasm .
      But what has religion got to do with good governance.
      Middle East is in turmoil because of being rigid in their views and being non secular

  • @Vishal-
    @Vishal- 4 года назад +253

    Lesser known fact: Dr Swamy used to sit in Harvard law lectures when he was a prof of economics there.

    • @satishpatel5260
      @satishpatel5260 4 года назад +12

      To Vishal Tiwari ;Shri.Dr.Swamy also done 'law ' as here he said truth of lawlessness done leaders in congress and in oppositions .

    • @satishpatel5260
      @satishpatel5260 4 года назад +5

      To ;vishal Tiwari ;Shri.Dr.Swamy also done 'law 'as here he said truth ,lawlessness done .

    • @prana2946
      @prana2946 4 года назад +1

      And yet GST is a success of Jaitley..

  • @gautamsaha6345
    @gautamsaha6345 4 года назад +403

    So many times Swami proves sonia a liar. Great Swami

  • @AbhishekKumar-de1cg
    @AbhishekKumar-de1cg 4 года назад +107

    Dr. + Swami = This man, नाम ही काफी है🙏

  • @anurag-kumar20
    @anurag-kumar20 4 года назад +863

    The only problems with Subramanian Swamy is that he is 80 years old and getting older.

    • @jagdeepkumar975
      @jagdeepkumar975 4 года назад +22

      Sir plz aap swamy sir boliye request hai sirf swamy nahi.....meri aap se haath jod k vinti hai

    • @anurag-kumar20
      @anurag-kumar20 4 года назад +8

      @@jagdeepkumar975 "I am not your yaar"

    • @anurag-kumar20
      @anurag-kumar20 4 года назад +28

      @@jagdeepkumar975 pehli baat to kisi ke naam mei sir/ma'am ni lagane se respect kam ni hoti hai. Shri Shri 108 laga lo, wo aapki marzi hai. And dusri baat, mera reply aapko shayad samajh ni aaya. RUclips pe search kijiye jo maine reply kiya for context. Point being you are an offense-taking sissy who has edited your comment now to tone down the hate you were spewing, and so have I 😂.

    • @bonran
      @bonran 4 года назад +6

      @@jagdeepkumar975 Kyun bole sir??? Uska baap hai kya Swamy?? If he wants to give respect to Swamy woh dega ya nahi dega. Teri gaand kyuon jal rahi hai papa??

    • @eminentasif
      @eminentasif 4 года назад +1

      @@arjunnarayanan5474 bro Jagdeep jaise chu.. ek dhundenge tou sav milenge. Ignore him.

  • @lovemessage9041
    @lovemessage9041 4 года назад +177

    India needs at least 3 like him.

  • @yashwantkumarsingh157
    @yashwantkumarsingh157 4 года назад +59

    Mr. Swami is true son of Bharat Mata. He is living a meaningful life & teaching his country men to live as same.

  • @RanjitGodbole
    @RanjitGodbole 4 года назад +193

    Swami as always “Brilliant”. Also, the questions and overall comments by the interviewer were good. He did his homework.

  • @mukeshshelat5072
    @mukeshshelat5072 4 года назад +301

    His not being a part of the Government is the nation's loss.

    • @KM-ff2gm
      @KM-ff2gm 4 года назад +9

      I politics you need to be agile. He is too stiff.

    • @bigsmokefan8768
      @bigsmokefan8768 4 года назад +4

      He is above 75....

    • @lesmonkmorison2828
      @lesmonkmorison2828 4 года назад +14

      thats the nation's strength and not loss and also the reason that he has been delibrately kept out... because being out of the cabinate he can say things to both sides without them taking prejudice against him....

    • @shekarroy6892
      @shekarroy6892 4 года назад +5

      TO DECLARE INDIA SECULAR COUNTRY CONGRESS SHOULD BRING BACK PAKISTAN, BANGLADESH...

    • @lesmonkmorison2828
      @lesmonkmorison2828 4 года назад

      @@shekarroy6892 get a life

  • @abantibhattacharya809
    @abantibhattacharya809 4 года назад +34

    I am in complete resonance with him. I salute him. And thank God to have such a learned man in our country.

  • @udayhotshot
    @udayhotshot 4 года назад +63

    Mr. Swamy ... King of the constitution

  • @rameshrochiram9136
    @rameshrochiram9136 4 года назад +55

    Dr Swami is just a amazing gentleman, long live.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @dibakarworld
    @dibakarworld 4 года назад +50

    Dr.Swamy should giving FM, it's been 2.5 year in every conversation occasion we have been discussing it and hoping it. Now the time, we wants him as our FM.

  • @sharadksoman
    @sharadksoman 4 года назад +101

    Though roasted well by Swamiji the host is good in manners and approach

    • @anuraag_saxena
      @anuraag_saxena 4 года назад +8

      Its an honor to have been roasted by Dr Swamy :-).
      Anuraag Saxena
      twitter.com/anuraag_saxena
      facebook.com/Anuraag.Saxena.Official/

    • @dumbf7604
      @dumbf7604 4 года назад

      Anchor did a great job ...

    • @vybhavi.b
      @vybhavi.b 4 года назад

      @@anuraag_saxena well, both of you, are on the same team. I don't think he was roasting you. I'm still listening, to.the interview, though.

    • @vybhavi.b
      @vybhavi.b 4 года назад +1

      @@anuraag_saxena but yeah, even being roasted by Dr. Swamy is an honour.

  • @alfsharma3888
    @alfsharma3888 4 года назад +446

    Uniform Civil Code is a must

    • @atul1024
      @atul1024 4 года назад

      Alf Sharma
      ruclips.net/video/Am6UvmKRJuw/видео.html

    • @humanfirst1367
      @humanfirst1367 3 года назад +1

      @little neo what do u mean about unity in diversity..a strict discipline required for country's growth but u believe in victim card

  • @rajn694
    @rajn694 4 года назад +36

    We many reapetedly saying , Jai Jai SS (Subramanian Swamy ) is consider to be God Sri Krishna of our times. Brilliant , courageous , Genius , High knowledge , Great thinker many many. He is Simply Supper. India needs many such. God bless for him ever. Jai Jai SS.

    • @DkDk-ek9wm
      @DkDk-ek9wm 4 года назад

      Ss absolutely correct

  • @yashgupta7315
    @yashgupta7315 4 года назад +142

    Free temple on government control🚩🚩🚩

    • @influendil
      @influendil 4 года назад

      is he worth listening?
      ruclips.net/video/DHdjc_kbwO8/видео.html

    • @influendil
      @influendil 4 года назад

      @saby king bhai aage link bhi tha, uska pucha tha

  • @19683
    @19683 4 года назад +28

    The meaning of secularism in India means being anti-Hindu.

  • @hno53
    @hno53 4 года назад +38

    Thoroughly enjoyable interview of swami. Can’t get enough of him, it’s sad he is 80. I wish he lives a healthy 20 more years.

  • @shreedharbhatt4137
    @shreedharbhatt4137 4 года назад +11

    the person in black pant and coat is standing for about 1:30 hrs .what a man.

  • @snd27580
    @snd27580 4 года назад +52

    No body in any political party tries to mess up with him.

  • @Mirnakrish
    @Mirnakrish 4 года назад +20

    My most favorite person ever 🤩🤩🤩 long live. Subramaniyan swami jee

  • @rajk-qk7ne
    @rajk-qk7ne 4 года назад +36

    Secularism is the first step to imposing sharia..secularism buys them time to grow in population..
    Grow, riot, and conquer was the strategy used for partition of india..

    • @Tilak-Chatterjee
      @Tilak-Chatterjee 4 года назад +1

      and still its going on in front of our eyes

    • @user-gb6wf8of8x
      @user-gb6wf8of8x 4 года назад +1

      @@Tilak-Chatterjee yes .😑😑😑😖😖😖

    • @LhnAran
      @LhnAran 3 года назад +1

      Haha indian secularism say you can practice the religion you want (Just like hinduism), by insulting it u r saying, Sikh i will not allow u to practice sikhism, to buddhist no more buddhism, to jews no more judism, to hindus no more hinduism.

  • @AshokKumar-ro4lx
    @AshokKumar-ro4lx 4 года назад +14

    We want to see Mr Subramanyan Swamy as our Finance Minister at the earliest

  • @deepakdimri9657
    @deepakdimri9657 4 года назад +29

    Watching it late but loved swami’s factual answers. He seems so accurate.

  • @shivramshetty3277
    @shivramshetty3277 4 года назад +66

    no need change in Hinduism it's perfect

    • @Karthik-zj3yf
      @Karthik-zj3yf 4 года назад +2

      What about Cast varnas system ?

    • @theannunaki3871
      @theannunaki3871 4 года назад +5

      @@Karthik-zj3yf Cast should be demolished, RSS cheif once said about that. But dont know if BJP would do that.

    • @mohit5496
      @mohit5496 3 года назад +1

      @@theannunaki3871 not till next decade atleast but it will enventually happen when there is no poor in india

    • @soorajnair150
      @soorajnair150 3 года назад +3

      @@theannunaki3871 well it's difficult bcoz casteism is vote bank

    • @AyushRaj-rt6bb
      @AyushRaj-rt6bb 2 года назад +1

      @@Karthik-zj3yf Caste based vote bank politics is the root cause of casteism.

  • @udayhotshot
    @udayhotshot 4 года назад +169

    " Either my way or Highway " in separate parts ... Hahaha ... Radical Islam

  • @mrinalsinha8832
    @mrinalsinha8832 4 года назад +51

    Dr Swami the don no one can win with him in debate, respect sir

  • @dkroy3806
    @dkroy3806 4 года назад +132

    swami ji: roast the host

    • @bvssrsguntur6338
      @bvssrsguntur6338 4 года назад +6

      Why?he had been a good host

    • @anuraag_saxena
      @anuraag_saxena 4 года назад +6

      Glad to be toasted by the one and only sir :-)
      Anuraag Saxena
      twitter.com/anuraag_saxena
      facebook.com/Anuraag.Saxena.Official/

    • @biebersucks27
      @biebersucks27 4 года назад +5

      @@anuraag_saxena Areyy Sir. You were a wondeful host and sport. :)

    • @anuraag_saxena
      @anuraag_saxena 4 года назад

      Varun S Thanks sir.

    • @smitaswarup8562
      @smitaswarup8562 3 года назад

      My parents lost everything in partition. My grandfather was killed. A good Muslim advocate, a friend of my grandfather, took the women to their airport for three days at great danger to himself till they got on the plane to Delhi in burkhas and with all their valuables. My great grandfather, my other grandparents, my parents and my aunts and uncles, never harbored hate despite all the trauma of partition. They never brought us up with hate. They were proud of their sacrifices for the nation. Please listen to the words (IN VIDEOS, LINKS AT BOTTOM OF THIS NOTE) of my father, Prof Shanti Swarup, 96, freedom fighter who passed away in March 2020 on Secularism 101--Various good people are muddying the waters about secularism. In my humble view, conceptually and in very simple terms, secularism was something consciously adopted and accepted by people who were tired of civil war and killing each other. It is why Gandhi, Nehru, Patel, Ambedkar, Maulana Azad pursued it for India even if it was formally added into the constitution later. It is the same with the concept of democracy, and the concepts of liberty, fraternity, equality. The whole idea of a constitution. Secularism was never something, anywhere in the world, that people developed or accepted spontaneously. People accepted it because they were tired of hate and wanted to improve their lives and live in peace. People various religions practice their religions privately. In a new democracy, secularism is supposed to be superimposed on various religious groups so they can live together peacefully within one territory and pursue other objectives such as healthcare, food, education, competing with other powers like China. Why are people in India going down the rabid path of looking for cultural causes of the failure of secularism--this is only going to muddy the water further so we make things worse, not better. We have to create a common vision for India together. Yes, reversing Shah Bano judgment was a big mistake for which we have been paying a heavy, heavy price. But we need to move on towards a more perfect union. This why USA, UK, Australia, etc have pursued secularism and they are also trying to move towards a more perfect union. It is why India chose secularism and we must continue to pursue a more perfect union. It is the crux of the point that my father, Professor Shanti Swarup, was covering in his videos here.
      Please do give a few minutes of your time to review the issue of secularism, specifically in the videos. Thank you. Dhanyawad. Shukriya, bahut meherbani.
      ruclips.net/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/видео.html
      ruclips.net/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/видео.html

  • @hitender7
    @hitender7 4 года назад +250

    Free temples from government control. How can I contribute for the people who are fighting for this cause.

    • @bvssrsguntur6338
      @bvssrsguntur6338 4 года назад +15

      Join vhs india

    • @LearnTheSageWay
      @LearnTheSageWay 4 года назад +9

      Understand Iskcon and support Iskcon

    • @prakritivarma2503
      @prakritivarma2503 4 года назад +11

      We should ask j sai deepak who is fighting for this in court,anybody know how to do that

    • @pintotop1
      @pintotop1 4 года назад +12

      Support Indic Collective, Sai Deepak ji is their legal counsel.
      Please watch his talks on freeing Hindu Temples on RUclips.

    • @sriharshanamuduri8694
      @sriharshanamuduri8694 4 года назад +4

      H S I have watched at least 3-4 hr talks by Supreme Court advocate J Sai Deepak & he comes across as the most knowledgeable and practical oriented with clarity on the subject and I would only give my contribution to Indic collective!!

  • @rahulkalkura
    @rahulkalkura 4 года назад +82

    Who the hell can debate against this Man??!! Anyone?!

    • @bilalomer1675
      @bilalomer1675 4 года назад +3

      On what topic?

    • @bilalomer1675
      @bilalomer1675 4 года назад +3

      He has a habit of imploying fallacious argumentative strategy in almost every debate and even in monologues... Otherwise I studied many orators throughout history and he seems to stand out in no way, except that his audience do not or are incapable of subjecting his articulation to rational and intellectual reasoning.

    • @theordinarycitizen6970
      @theordinarycitizen6970 4 года назад +9

      @@bilalomer1675 Hahaha..

    • @rahulkalkura
      @rahulkalkura 4 года назад +14

      @@bilalomer1675 tell me one point where he is completely wrong?

    • @dibakarworld
      @dibakarworld 4 года назад +4

      Ye chupp saitan kahi vi ghuss jate he, bina soche bina samjhe kuch vi boll dete he. Sale himmat he to apnaa profile picture dalta kyu nahi. Fake account bana ke ajate he #omer.

  • @KkKk-gq8os
    @KkKk-gq8os 4 года назад +12

    Swamyji OMG india is blessed to have you. Great Human. Love you 😍😍😍😍😍😍

  • @prashantbhosle3524
    @prashantbhosle3524 4 года назад +39

    India needs Swami to head Finance.

  • @gvbhnnnnnnhh
    @gvbhnnnnnnhh 4 года назад +16

    This man is such an inspiration.☺️☺️☺️ He is amazing

  • @goilee9716
    @goilee9716 4 года назад +10

    oh please God, give this man long health and life and make him a finance minister and then PM

  • @dhruvghosh8826
    @dhruvghosh8826 3 года назад +13

    Secularism means giving respect to other religion not humiliating a religion for appeasing a particular religion for vote bank politics

    • @Noname-oq9mk
      @Noname-oq9mk Год назад

      No brother it is not, please read the origin of the word secularism,nijer mon theke ja Khushi Boolle hobe…..(of course for vote bank politics and unconditional appeasement).

    • @pkmkbalways
      @pkmkbalways Год назад +1

      Secularism should mean humanity, free thinking, equality and nation first above everything.

  • @AJ-bb9oo
    @AJ-bb9oo 4 года назад +9

    God please add 30 more years to his life. We need swamy ji!!

  • @dr.padmanabhareddyp2543
    @dr.padmanabhareddyp2543 4 года назад +188

    Till now secularism means growth of minorities with suppression of Hindus,Now with BJP justice under way ,long live BJP.

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад

      "Growth of minorities " could you elaborate

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад +7

      @Hari Om from Wiki :
      The total Indian population in 1951 was about 36 crore and currently (2017) about 130 crore. The population-share of Hindus in 1951 was 84% and those of Muslims 10%, while currently, these percentages are about 80% and 14.5% respectively. In other words, the Hindu population grew from about 30 crore to 104 crore from 1951 to 2017 (about 3.5 times), while the Muslim population grew from 3.6 crore to 18.20 crore (about 5 times). What this means is that the larger Hindu population has grown at about 1.82% every year, while the Muslim growth rate has been 2.45% year on year. Happily, according to the 2011 survey, the population growth rates are now much lower, at about 1.6% for Hindus and 2% for Muslims.

    • @jagdeepkumar975
      @jagdeepkumar975 4 года назад +1

      Well said sir....Love u

    • @dudeitsme5753
      @dudeitsme5753 4 года назад +2

      @@whynot4828 you are expecting answer from an anpad andh bhakts 🤣🤣 lol

    • @dudeitsme5753
      @dudeitsme5753 4 года назад +1

      Tomorrow BJP will say Hindus have become minority now and these andh bhakt chutiyas will agree blindly 🤣🤣🤣 and when asked all they can say is "check the census"....btw, I'm an educated brahmin

  • @shivramshetty3277
    @shivramshetty3277 4 года назад +26

    declaration of hindutva best no confusion

  • @rajeshsharma4153
    @rajeshsharma4153 4 года назад +15

    Thanks to Arth for organising this beautiful talk.

  • @prnbnspt1983envs
    @prnbnspt1983envs 4 года назад +158

    I would like to see him as FM.

  • @renukasahoo6927
    @renukasahoo6927 4 года назад +8

    Truly speaking Swamiji. India is not dharmasala for Pakistan n Bangladesh.

  • @VijayKumar-ix1ng
    @VijayKumar-ix1ng 4 года назад +18

    Overall I am happy. Modi sir is doing great job. Swamy plus Amit sir in addition is great.
    Do we have egos as usual . hope our strong present developments are not hurt.
    Any which wau. Cudos to you all. May God.s blessings prevail at all times.

  • @ramugmp3650
    @ramugmp3650 4 года назад +13

    If subramanyam Swamy Finance minister The Bharath will be no: 1 in 5 years I think Jai Swamy Jai BJP Jai Bharath Jai world 🌎

  • @meenas2222
    @meenas2222 4 года назад +27

    great personality, I don't have words how amaze I am to hear your replies and opinions. just awasome!!!!

  • @user-ftcjuiyrsyuyti
    @user-ftcjuiyrsyuyti 4 года назад +314

    I want to him as pm after modi

    • @rishuuuuuu
      @rishuuuuuu 4 года назад +4

      I agree

    • @scffconinfratec6433
      @scffconinfratec6433 4 года назад +44

      Make him FM, that's all I want NOW

    • @suchisingh9421
      @suchisingh9421 4 года назад +15

      The need of hour is to make him FM and in future PM May be.....i am a big fan of mr Swamy the man of facts

    • @saratc985
      @saratc985 4 года назад +11

      It's difficult man. He's already 80 years old.

    • @Zhang158
      @Zhang158 4 года назад

      Make him now

  • @ritikadas4322
    @ritikadas4322 4 года назад +43

    exactly..equal laws for equals. don't measure hunter and hunted using the same yardstick

  • @kdas996
    @kdas996 4 года назад +9

    Swamy sir and Anurag sir .....both legends in their respective field.

  • @yogeshthakur7319
    @yogeshthakur7319 4 года назад +117

    Modi is leader because he knows how to lead and manage people, for economy watch what Former President Mr. Pranab Mukherjee or other economist said.
    Modi knows politics very well and good in comparison to today's politicians that's why he is the Prime Minister.

    • @yogeshthakur7319
      @yogeshthakur7319 4 года назад +3

      @@srpratap Every Indian Company is making good money, only few are failed by their owners.
      Swami is good to poke any politician but his age and experience shows he is not a good minister, some times toppers fails but average give best of their knowledge.

    • @smitaswarup8562
      @smitaswarup8562 3 года назад

      My parents lost everything in partition. My grandfather was killed. A good Muslim advocate, a friend of my grandfather, took the women to their airport for three days at great danger to himself till they got on the plane to Delhi in burkhas and with all their valuables. My great grandfather, my other grandparents, my parents and my aunts and uncles, never harbored hate despite all the trauma of partition. They never brought us up with hate. They were proud of their sacrifices for the nation. Please listen to the words (IN VIDEOS, LINKS AT BOTTOM OF THIS NOTE) of my father, Prof Shanti Swarup, 96, freedom fighter who passed away in March 2020 on Secularism 101--Various good people are muddying the waters about secularism. In my humble view, conceptually and in very simple terms, secularism was something consciously adopted and accepted by people who were tired of civil war and killing each other. It is why Gandhi, Nehru, Patel, Ambedkar, Maulana Azad pursued it for India even if it was formally added into the constitution later. It is the same with the concept of democracy, and the concepts of liberty, fraternity, equality. The whole idea of a constitution. Secularism was never something, anywhere in the world, that people developed or accepted spontaneously. People accepted it because they were tired of hate and wanted to improve their lives and live in peace. People various religions practice their religions privately. In a new democracy, secularism is supposed to be superimposed on various religious groups so they can live together peacefully within one territory and pursue other objectives such as healthcare, food, education, competing with other powers like China. Why are people in India going down the rabid path of looking for cultural causes of the failure of secularism--this is only going to muddy the water further so we make things worse, not better. We have to create a common vision for India together. Yes, reversing Shah Bano judgment was a big mistake for which we have been paying a heavy, heavy price. But we need to move on towards a more perfect union. This why USA, UK, Australia, etc have pursued secularism and they are also trying to move towards a more perfect union. It is why India chose secularism and we must continue to pursue a more perfect union. It is the crux of the point that my father, Professor Shanti Swarup, was covering in his videos.
      Please do give a few minutes of your time to review the issue of secularism, specifically in the videos. Thank you. Dhanyawad. Shukriya, bahut meherbani. Bari merbani.
      ruclips.net/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/видео.html
      ruclips.net/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/видео.html

    • @yogeshthakur7319
      @yogeshthakur7319 3 года назад +1

      @@smitaswarup8562 Anti India activities on name of secularism is not acceptable at all. In my opinion & understanding there is no word "secularism" because we all are follower of one religion or you can say inspired by one, you must have nationalism and think as an Nationalist for your Nation first Ex:- Japan. Secularism overlap with Equality before law, concept. U.S., U.K., Australia,etc have Nation first policy and then concept of equality. These Nations consider extreme Islam as danger and same with communism. We people of Bharat are working on strong & unite Bharat, we know what we are doing.

    • @smitaswarup8562
      @smitaswarup8562 3 года назад

      @@yogeshthakur7319 I don;t favor fundamentalism. I find you hindutva guys have no answers and keep throwing arguments. Ek dusre ko nigal jaoge. China will invade. Us me khush rehna. Divided you will fall like you always have for centuries. Sidhe ho jao. Ek dusre ke sath bana ke rakho. Jo ho gaya so ho gaya. Eye for an eye se kuch nahi hoga. ruclips.net/video/FuFcR7NPqVo/видео.html

    • @yogeshthakur7319
      @yogeshthakur7319 3 года назад

      @@smitaswarup8562 Accept it, if you don't have right answers/arguments for my facts. We did mistakes, we thought forgiveness and peace come together but Mughals proves us wrong, impotent leaders are dangerous- we learned this. Now we are a reflection to others, if anyone wants friendship we become true friends eg. Russia, Israel, Japan, etc. if you want to fight we will fight. Hindutva is not a word, the ideology is "Sanatan" :- way of living life. "Hindu" used by Mughals for Bharatiya, we all are Hindu/Bharatiya or English says Indian. We have the capability to Change or accept, Mughals try to convert but get merged, Christians try to convert us they also get merged in Sanatan. We want to live in peace and prosperity but if you try to attacks us, try to interfere, or any type of anti national agenda- not acceptable. Yes we will retaliate and you have to face consequences.

  • @Shinoj4852
    @Shinoj4852 4 года назад +31

    It will be a crime to not see him as a minister again..

  • @ravichandra2705
    @ravichandra2705 4 года назад +26

    Anurag has handled the interview very well and had good knowledge of the subject

    • @anuraag_saxena
      @anuraag_saxena 4 года назад

      Thanks. Appreciate it.
      Anuraag Saxena
      twitter.com/anuraag_saxena
      facebook.com/Anuraag.Saxena.Official/

  • @Explorelife764
    @Explorelife764 4 года назад +7

    Most intelligent and knowledgeable man in Indian politics.

    • @parmar__12
      @parmar__12 3 года назад

      Might be in woke world
      But i wont say it

  • @kumarmeanprince7275
    @kumarmeanprince7275 4 года назад +14

    Secularism means vasutheva kutumbakam = Hinduism

  • @AJ_.._
    @AJ_.._ 4 года назад +16

    Match for Swamy - " Not Found " 😝

  • @tamals22
    @tamals22 4 года назад +13

    Modi listens to this man and still doesnt tell him.anything rather listens to him . To all those who thinks Modi doeant tolerate his critics . Swamy Criticizes Modi based on facts and never does it score any political mileage win election being from same party . ITS A RAW TRUTH THAT MODI HIMSELF BROUGHT SWAMY TO BJP .

  • @samprithpatel6578
    @samprithpatel6578 4 года назад +16

    Salute to swamyji

  • @tanmoykundu4634
    @tanmoykundu4634 4 года назад +12

    Swamy ji has more views than all channel combined

  • @randomVlog555
    @randomVlog555 4 года назад +5

    Swamy ji knows almost all articles.... great intellect sir 🙏🏻

  • @doordie5171
    @doordie5171 4 года назад +4

    We, need a people like Dr. Swami.....

  • @Chidanand21
    @Chidanand21 4 года назад +3

    My de facto guru, Dr Swamy. My knowledge just got increased once I started following him.

  • @shivramshetty3277
    @shivramshetty3277 4 года назад +23

    Dr subramanyam swamy 100% correct

  • @TheVRockzzz
    @TheVRockzzz 4 года назад +2

    I hope Mr Subramanian Swamy lives for at least 15 more years. Respect!!!

  • @VinayKumar-ep6vd
    @VinayKumar-ep6vd 4 года назад +13

    Long live swamiji

  • @Alokitam
    @Alokitam 4 года назад +3

    Sir May god send millions and millions like you . Sir
    I much love and respect for you.

  • @vaishaksudesh783
    @vaishaksudesh783 4 года назад +2

    This man should be the PM of India. . . 😍. . We respect you Swamy

  • @radhakrishnathommandra5841
    @radhakrishnathommandra5841 3 года назад +1

    Our dear Nation requires more number of people like Dr. Subramaian Swamy. Long live Sir. You are our ideal. You are our role model.

  • @gargoldenentevents3646
    @gargoldenentevents3646 4 года назад +9

    Bravo to Mamata who has single handedly fought the communists who have broke the back bone of Bengal and destroyed it. Somehow, Modi and Mamta should get together, they should put aside politics and work together to take Bengal to the next level.

    • @prashanthtalla
      @prashanthtalla 4 года назад +3

      Didi is no less than communists, she has also ruined Bengal, I don't see any great improvements being made to the state since she came into power, but rampant goondaism increased.

  • @anupkundu193
    @anupkundu193 4 года назад +3

    Sir You are Living Legend ❤️❤️...
    You are Genius sir ji..
    We need more politician like You in Right wings Party🙏🙏🙏

  • @rishiksharma1210
    @rishiksharma1210 4 года назад +14

    40:58 swamiji, reminding anurag to ask him about tirupati

  • @judearulraj4401
    @judearulraj4401 4 года назад +4

    Superb 👍 opening statement by Dr. Genius Swamy.
    Good if Swamy becomes PM.

  • @satishpatel5260
    @satishpatel5260 4 года назад +4

    Truth ;by Shri.Dr.Swamy ,always truth .👍👏🌏🙏👍.

  • @jasongeorge4859
    @jasongeorge4859 4 года назад +3

    we are prosecuting Arundhati..thats due process. thats awesome....love it

  • @thefunnyone9148
    @thefunnyone9148 4 года назад +14

    Everyone should support ucc we want uniform civil code

  • @blackforest1132
    @blackforest1132 4 года назад +13

    Islam: my way or highway that too in separate ways😁 that really cracked me up🤣🤣🤣

  • @RajeshR-zi7cn
    @RajeshR-zi7cn 4 года назад +17

    Swami ji 🙏🙏🙏

  • @55gourabroy14
    @55gourabroy14 4 года назад +4

    Majestic words and glory of this man my ideal glad to see you sir in Kolkata

  • @MrYashrocks1000
    @MrYashrocks1000 3 года назад

    May God Bless Dr. Subramanian Swamy

  • @Supervisor-entertainment
    @Supervisor-entertainment 4 года назад +243

    Stop conversion by misionery

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад +8

      By converting to another faith the individual escapes from the clutches of casteism.
      Before condemning conversions people should understand why it is so easy for an individual to switch faiths.
      If tripple talaq is bad then casteism is worse.

    • @Supervisor-entertainment
      @Supervisor-entertainment 4 года назад +19

      There no castism in NE india jst deluded by misionery If u convert becum minority wat d use to accept white supremacy who wil protect indegene religion of india dats simple xcuse to justify.Wat about black wil they convert again atrocities done by whites dnt justify

    • @noname13years62
      @noname13years62 4 года назад +15

      @@Supervisor-entertainment At least there are Christians like you , who speak against the missionaries . Thanks for the support . We need to force the government to apply Uniform Civil Code for everyone , no privileges based on religion whatsoever!!.

    • @shekarroy6892
      @shekarroy6892 4 года назад +17

      10 years jail for Religion conversion

    • @whynot4828
      @whynot4828 4 года назад +2

      @@shekarroy6892 why ?

  • @vinaykella8780
    @vinaykella8780 4 года назад +34

    which university protested against bringing down picture of JINNAH
    was JINAAH secular ??

  • @Vigneshwaran018
    @Vigneshwaran018 4 года назад +21

    I belong to Schedule caste ..I support to remove all the reservations.. Let everyone get jobs and college seats based on the skills..

    • @tamilselvi1461
      @tamilselvi1461 3 года назад +1

      Reservation is not about anything else, but representation. Every group should be in there any institution or government departments. So that they can understand you better. Think of honour killing, that is nothing to do with honour. Who is always affected, why there is denial of justice. no strict laws against it. why? think.... equal representation is not there...

    • @indiatas
      @indiatas 3 года назад

      🙏👍

    • @indiatas
      @indiatas 3 года назад +1

      @@tamilselvi1461 but without merit? Even after 40 years begging for quota? Incapable idiots

    • @tamilselvi1461
      @tamilselvi1461 3 года назад +1

      @@indiatas without merits? On what basis EWS group is getting reservations ? They only said others are on reservation, so the quality is going down. Now when they (OC) get it, quality will be maintained ? SX reservation is a reparation

  • @pkr9305
    @pkr9305 4 года назад +1

    Thank you Arth, for bringing Swamy on your platform

  • @priyanshugupta5873
    @priyanshugupta5873 4 года назад +6

    #Dr.SwamyisALegend ❤❤❤❤

  • @AbhishekVerma-iz2hl
    @AbhishekVerma-iz2hl 4 года назад +6

    As usual, learned a lot from u sir. 🙏🙏... Bonus is, good to know "Mamta Di" is not as, we have been thought so far, in her personal life.
    🙏🙏

  • @lalkitab1952
    @lalkitab1952 4 года назад +6

    Dr Swami is a Hindutva icon

  • @noelcastelino6790
    @noelcastelino6790 4 года назад +1

    Every time I lose hope in this man he turns round and restores my faith...

  • @venstomon931
    @venstomon931 4 года назад +1

    What a fascinating discussion.. Great questions and what amazing clarity and knowledge by Mr. Swamy when answering the pointed questions.

  • @mini3460
    @mini3460 4 года назад +6

    Such a learned person. Respect.

  • @Civilsuresh7
    @Civilsuresh7 4 года назад +14

    Modi should appoint swami as finance minister

    • @Civilsuresh7
      @Civilsuresh7 4 года назад +1

      @@nirjharoberoi economy is not doing well
      No jobs

    • @125bbna8
      @125bbna8 4 года назад +1

      @@Civilsuresh7 he will definitely do when he will face economy collapsed and he has nothing to do and his sinhasan is shaking like indra.

    • @yogeshshidhaye7332
      @yogeshshidhaye7332 4 года назад

      SURESH KUMAR Modi ki jalti hai

    • @Civilsuresh7
      @Civilsuresh7 4 года назад +1

      @@yogeshshidhaye7332 i don't think in that way

    • @Civilsuresh7
      @Civilsuresh7 4 года назад +1

      @@yogeshshidhaye7332 मसले कुछ और हैं

  • @itmatters5997
    @itmatters5997 4 года назад +2

    Love This Guy!! This is the calibre of Politicians we want in the Country!!

  • @shivashakthi1918
    @shivashakthi1918 4 года назад +1

    Excellent discussion, interview. Thank you for sharing..

  • @ak3549
    @ak3549 4 года назад +15

    BJP's next Ace of Spade Subramanyam Swami... for next election...
    0:00 suggests...👍🤔

  • @ramennaidoo162
    @ramennaidoo162 4 года назад +3

    This Swamyji is a walking talking constitution bible of our dear mother India. Its for this and many other reasons he is regarded a very well articulated student who is very free and fair. Many opposition politicians distance themselves from getting involved with him in any debate, fear of getting exposed. Swamyji is our one man army, may he be blessed with good health and a long long life.

  • @shaillyvarun
    @shaillyvarun 4 года назад

    “ there should be no adjustments made in the constitution” woah 🤩
    Mr Swami !!! It’s always enriching, mesmerizing and exciting listening to you. Not just it is factual, but straight forward and witty at the same time. Huge respect to you sir. Wish to see you as our finance minister ❤️

  • @troublekick
    @troublekick 4 года назад

    Hats off to Mr Swamy! One is yet to be born to debate him ! Absolute intellect hands down