India alone has the potential to defeat China in a war, argues Subramanian Swamy | ThinkEdu 2022

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 июн 2024
  • 'The Chinese Model: Can India Catch Up?' was the question posed to Subramanian Swamy at the 10th edition of India's foremost education conclave ThinkEdu. Swamy's answer was rather simple. "I don't want to catch up with them I want to overtake them," he said.
    Swamy underlined that "before the Ching dynasty, for more than 2,000 years, China was under the cultural influence of India. In China, it is dictatorship and I don't want to follow it." #SubramanianSwamy #ThinkEdu2022 #China #IndiaChina #Russia
    Also Read Full Story-www.newindianexpress.com/citi...
    ThinkEdu Conclave 2022:
    Over nearly 30 sessions, 50 speakers are set to shine a light on the evolution of India’s education system and the path it is on at ThinkEdu 2022. This year marks the 10th edition of what has consistently been India’s biggest education conclave for a decade. March 8 and 9 will see some stalwarts of India’s academic, economic and political ecosystems bring ideas, ideologies and reflections on the past, present and future of India’s education system. The sessions will be viewed by a live audience, in addition to the 2,750 registered users on the conclave’s digital space.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    We are active on social media! Follow us:
    Facebook: / thenewindianxpress
    Twitter: / newindianxpress
    Stay updated with our Apps:
    For Android users: bit.ly/2EdIaWW
    iOS users: apple.co/2SrVdHf
    For more videos: www.newindianexpress.com/videos
    For all the important news: www.newindianexpress.com/

Комментарии • 886

  • @cheramanirumborai7181
    @cheramanirumborai7181 2 года назад +49

    Never mind about defeating China. Give us some input on how to destroy domestic enemies Dr. Swamy!

    • @sauravsingh926
      @sauravsingh926 2 года назад +4

      💥💥🥳🥳

    • @ajay262134
      @ajay262134 Год назад

      Exactly, commi, liberals and Islamists pose biggest problems to India, to some extent, greater than China.

  • @sreekandhank7541
    @sreekandhank7541 2 года назад +158

    Swami ji's view on casteism is absolutely correct and is being supported by our spiritual Masters at time to time.

    • @channasuc1726
      @channasuc1726 2 года назад +9

      No, he is stupid sage and intelligent person - he has knowledge, quite smart, but don't know how communicate with people - his ego is his problem. When in BJP, he should learn how to behave, not criticizing PM publicly.

    • @pradyumn2692
      @pradyumn2692 2 года назад +5

      @@channasuc1726 I think it's necessary to have a strong critic for the PM. Congress and leftists don't provide valid criticism. They increase hate everything Indian and Hindu.

    • @ramavijaya148
      @ramavijaya148 2 года назад +2

      It is NOT paractical.

    • @haophong64
      @haophong64 2 года назад +3

      I think this guy is smoking crack because the way he talks it's all nonsense

    • @ladybug4364
      @ladybug4364 2 года назад

      @@haophong64 He takes the same crack as Eleven Ping and his daughter.

  • @biprapatnaik3059
    @biprapatnaik3059 2 года назад +10

    In 1962 we were not defeated by china but Nehru had let us down...👍
    Its always a pleasure to hear Dr Swamy...

    • @gurbirbhullar8549
      @gurbirbhullar8549 Год назад

      Did you focus on 5 negative things he said about Modi ?

    • @mysmartkryptonite354
      @mysmartkryptonite354 Год назад

      It's pure defeat of India. Whether you accept it or not. China can defeat you now very badly.

    • @dustudent1637
      @dustudent1637 6 дней назад +1

      @@gurbirbhullar8549 Modi is better than Nehru as he is n;ot someone to stumble down before en;emy.

  • @tushars4038
    @tushars4038 2 года назад +47

    I disagree with economic policy thing, there were a few blunder but overall reforms & direction of economy has been good. Focus on Infrastructure & entrepreneurship instead of job creation in a country as big as India is good.

    • @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos
      @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos 2 года назад +7

      swamy is becoming old and is becoming grumpy as a result

    • @gopalakrishnankrish1178
      @gopalakrishnankrish1178 2 года назад

      @@JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideost

    • @chandrasekaranvenkataraman2997
      @chandrasekaranvenkataraman2997 2 года назад +1

      Yes infrastructure and entrepreneurship is developed automatically jobs are created and in turn economy will become good.

    • @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos
      @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos 2 года назад +2

      @@NarendraBhusan-ias yes but he is old now and wayy past his prime

    • @manishsramon
      @manishsramon 2 года назад

      @@NarendraBhusan-ias So you're telling me that Harvard conventional academicians are superior to Silicon valley think tanks!?
      Those 1960s economic theories are invalid in 21st century let that sink in.

  • @amolghadge9011
    @amolghadge9011 2 года назад +27

    Intelligent people at times don't justify the meaning of word "intelligent".

  • @adnyat
    @adnyat 2 года назад +22

    Problem with all intellectuals is that they never make mistake. As they do not make mistake (that's what they feel), they never learn.

    • @abhijitbarman7541
      @abhijitbarman7541 2 года назад +1

      Their problems is they always know that they are right..
      In our language we call this Ahankar that you becomes the slave of your intellect.
      For example if you look into a debate between two people in a public place, you will see they both are right and wrong at the same time but far from the truth.

    • @HeresMyView
      @HeresMyView 2 года назад +1

      Trained in Harvard, taught at Harvard, and have American mentality towards India. That's why India can never get out of the west control, especially US. He should learn to apply the knowledge to help India NOT to be under American hegemony. Instead, he imported American mentality n policies to undermine India, always thinking the west is superior to India. Sad for India.

  • @ranenbhattacharyya136
    @ranenbhattacharyya136 2 года назад +11

    Utterly wonderful intelligent fearless Indian !

  • @thomashom7514
    @thomashom7514 2 года назад +6

    India needs a reality check. India is not the least comparable with China in all aspects. The old expression “talk is cheap” applies here.

    • @limkheakwei4412
      @limkheakwei4412 2 года назад

      Yeah talking through his arse

    • @ParkerAt941
      @ParkerAt941 2 года назад +2

      Indians majority believes "talk" is their super softpower, and obsessed with its huge "success".

  • @sureshparikh1808
    @sureshparikh1808 2 года назад +13

    You have a simplistic view of the Russian action. You do not investigate the long history of goading Russia. There may be an US agenda to topple Putin, who was forced to act when the Ukrainian option of not joining NATO or being a buffer state no longer exists, when Ukrainian armed forces are already integrated into the NATO command structure.

  • @sbs5408
    @sbs5408 2 года назад +50

    I admire his courage, knowledge and perseverance. But he is wrong on Ukraine. India did the right thing by abstaining. We cannot kowtow US and western powers on this matter.

    • @bullsbears2600
      @bullsbears2600 2 года назад +2

      Don't be surprised .
      They never thought of us more then their slaves.
      They always act hypocryticaly when it's about any eastern country. Infact people deserve , we should have learnt a lesson by now, but nevermind we will learn it one day and will be able to recognise the enemy in the mask of friend.
      Just think ones what the west has ever given to India? Money ? Power? Respect? I would say nothing , they gave us nothing . They are investing money in our country which they stole from India itself they took 45trillions of euros from India which is even more then European countries and USA's total GDP combined at current date. Infact when British came to India , Churchill used to call us black dogs,niggers. They even destroyed our educational system, to break the backbone of Indian civilization. So my dear friends they don't deserve any soft corner in our hearts. India with USA is same as locking a person with a poisonous snake in a room. And about the China and India it's better not to have any conflict just because of US . It's just USA's another plan to make it's hegemony in this 21st century, they want the two developing worlds to fight and eventually get ourselves economy bleeding. And then a new crisis will happen in both of us countries. And USA hegemony lives.

    • @minimeguju6868
      @minimeguju6868 2 года назад

      He is a lose cannon

    • @sbs5408
      @sbs5408 2 года назад +1

      @@wretchedsoullikemine It’s a war. During such stressful times people can lose their minds. Some Ukrainians may be angry that India didn’t vote in their favour at UN. In the past Ukraine voiced against India on Kashmir. It is a question of own priorities and compulsions. India did it buckle under western influence.

    • @HeresMyView
      @HeresMyView 2 года назад +3

      @@bullsbears2600 , you're so right. Spot on.👍👍
      India is never an equal partner to any western countries. India is a junior partner, not Russia. Britain looted India n left a legacy of poverty, economic shambles, divided people, high illiteracy, and cultural destructions. Why is this not a lesson learn from hundreds of yrs of humiliations? Just bcos he went to Harvard, indoctrinated to believe that India is inferior n the west is always superior, gives a strong indication that he had not REALLY learn anything valuable. Instead, he strongly advocated that the western ideology must be followed to develop India. That is a vicious cycle of disaster for India. India needs to be really independent n develop her own economic policies based on Indian culture n characteristics. Does he not know this century belongs to the Asian global economic powerhouse. The west is in decline.
      In fact, Harvard University is not all that esteem. The education scandal in US revealed that the rich, famous n powerful use their influence to gain admission into Harvard for their kids. It has NOTHING to do with intelligence or well educated admissions. So, do not always think Harvard is at the top. Work with Harvard trained employees, know a few Harvard graduates and mixed with a few Harvard students like I do, n you will realize that it is NOT what it seems.

    • @askme9572
      @askme9572 2 года назад

      @@bullsbears2600 Indian Cvilization : Sathi Partha , Castism , Religious Superstitions , Un-scientific temperament , Cock and Bull religious stories .
      It is good that first Mughals came ,unified and ruled India and then British came and ruled India .British also unified India .
      If they had not ruled over India , we would have 25 contries in Indian sub-continent today .
      Today we have only 3countries : BanglaDesh , India and Pakistan in Indian sub-continent .
      India has achieved some progress ,at least ,inspite of the fact that Indians have been very ignorant people on earth and fighting for their religions and castes .
      Unfortunately , religion and caste war is still going on .
      Zero civilization , India had !

  • @balun872
    @balun872 2 года назад +20

    About the heading....
    Fortunately SS is not the PM of India:
    He would be the Zelenski of India.

  • @fundaclear5398
    @fundaclear5398 2 года назад +16

    Genius having a hidden agenda.

  • @goldentunes1218
    @goldentunes1218 2 года назад +7

    Dear Dr Swamy, I was a Swamy bhakt till recently. I believe PM Modi has lost a great counsel like you for no valid reason.. Your knowledge is amazing...youcare a powerful Sanatani. You are a great warrior against corruption...
    Yet your ambition at this age for power has dis appointed me.
    Now all Hindu minds should forget differences and fight common enemy .. Here you are... Joining the defeated troop of LKA, Y SINHA, Shatru etc. What purpose?
    So now i cancell my swamy bhat club membership. May you live healthy and happy🙏🏿🌹

    • @chilpeeps
      @chilpeeps 2 года назад

      You are emotional fool then his son in law is also a Muslim and his daughter is anti india propagandists I don’t like bjp and I do like his views on economy but it doesn’t make him saint or a well wisher just research before worshipping someone specifically people like him.

  • @rexgomes916
    @rexgomes916 2 года назад +35

    How can someone be so blunt n brave in a acting party .
    Education is so important today's India

  • @SSC_BOOK
    @SSC_BOOK 2 года назад +9

    He is always High!!!👍

  • @a_son8549
    @a_son8549 2 года назад +62

    Though I respect Subramanian for his sharp intellect on occasions, it's time for India to stop having wet dreams about war, not with China, nor with Pakistan. What good does it bring, except maybe momentary satisfaction to the politicians' ego, and that at the cost of the common men's lives. India should stay focused on being an economic and educational powerhouse.

    • @nothingabsolute6302
      @nothingabsolute6302 2 года назад +5

      And keep on losing parts of our land from time to time.
      So let's stick to "koi aya nahi" line! Great..

    • @prasadscarlet3712
      @prasadscarlet3712 2 года назад +4

      He is not suggesting we should invade china like Russians are invading Ukraine. He saying we should defend our land when china occupies 4000 sq km of our territory and we should. What's the point of having a large army and what's the point in spending billions of dollars out of taxpayers money for buying arms and ammunition from other countries...
      You can be economic and educational powerhouse and all that, but if you are lethargic in defending your land, history will repeat.

    • @vipinvijay4449
      @vipinvijay4449 2 года назад +1

      If india and china goes for war.who will benifit it..."US":Whose NATION bUILDING WILL HAPPEN ONCE THEIR COMPETITORS ARE DONE.SAME LIKE WORLDWAR FIGHT BETWEEN RUSSIA AND GERMANY.WHO arised as super power-US.Let US AND China fight it out.we have to concentrate on our internal matters till 2030s which is enough a time for india to do marvellous progrees s given a stable govt in centre. AND UP

    • @aquarius4562
      @aquarius4562 2 года назад +2

      @@prasadscarlet3712 ....
      Someone should slap Big mouthy Subramanian with facts Check.

    • @Lucas-ix8bg
      @Lucas-ix8bg 2 года назад +4

      We have to grow economically strong. China kept a low profile before the US. China kept on saying that it can't compare/compete with US military power until one day they challenged US hegemony when they had become strong. Economically more stronger means war is already won against adversaries.

  • @SherSingh-vf3eb
    @SherSingh-vf3eb 2 года назад +10

    Mr subramaniam world stage is not like india where your baseless thoughts will be given respect because you belong to brahmin caste. Now comes the question india alone is capable enough of defeating china on these kind of conclave you should have proper data according to recent research china has world largest navies in terms of no vessels. China can design his own fighter jets but india have to wait for russia or American engine to take off his fighter jets. Do understand this facts. India doesn't have its own defense manufacturing industry.

    • @angeldust4224
      @angeldust4224 2 года назад

      No country fights wars on its own! Small conflicts are a different issue.

    • @beastmode6225
      @beastmode6225 2 года назад

      Majority of Indias firepower and military equipment comes from Russia . Russia and China have a very very close pact. Russia would cut India off from weapons and supplies to stay neutral and not go against China and China would win a war

  • @palanichamyperumal2637
    @palanichamyperumal2637 2 года назад +60

    In the case of Ukraine this man's points are not correct because Russians are now more concerned with their country's security and they want that those Ukraine Government must respect the old treaty which was made earlier when USSR was heeding Ukraine as an independent state...! Moreover Kiev is very near to Moscow also !!...

    • @ymantu
      @ymantu 2 года назад

      I think over Chinese are playing the main game behind the curtain.

    • @temporarypassenger518
      @temporarypassenger518 2 года назад +1

      I agree

  • @hardik373
    @hardik373 2 года назад +6

    Sir, you are not solitary!
    A lot of people KNOW who's behind what and who's getting the credit. Even in a democracy, the quality of followers over the quantity often holds a significant relevance 👍

  • @arunjetli7909
    @arunjetli7909 2 года назад +25

    Agree with him mostly but he is ignoring history and says nothing about the provocation from NATO. How convenient Dr. Swamy rely on Aristotelian reason based on abstraction typical of western epistemology .I don’t know enough about economic engine to have an opinion .

  • @liewjames2852
    @liewjames2852 2 года назад +13

    India is so very obsessed with defeating China always keeping an eye on China. Talking loudly to itself dreaming, posturing, speculating, chest-thumping and making boasts and threats of all kinds but yet still a pipedream or a mountain too high to scale. Don't just keep boastIng about your Agni and Brahmos or Tejas. Start lifting standards of public hygiene and health care for the poor majority.

    • @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos
      @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos 2 года назад +1

      out of millions of videos and political discussions published every month in india wumao chainese comes on a discussion between two indians for an indian audience about one of our neighbouring countries which we share a 1000km border with and says InDiAns AlWaYs TaLkInG AbOuT ChInA nobody gives a shit about chaina but our national security threat posed by china is a major issue so we talk about it , if anyone has a problem they can F off

    • @chilpeeps
      @chilpeeps 2 года назад

      I really think rice bag always cry without researching their own china is better because it’s don’t give a f about its ruler public they live like cave mens the same china still usages the forced labourers before making such a judgements you should research more atleast travel there first and research your own

    • @thomashom7514
      @thomashom7514 2 года назад

      @@chilpeeps Jesus, use clear and correct English and grammar to make you understood. What are you trying to say?

    • @dsrvarat
      @dsrvarat 2 года назад

      China cant even to defeat Taiwan and how to going to defeat India. China knew India very much stronger with western technology, china technology merely scrap iron ... infrerior quality of defence equipment.

    • @thomashom7514
      @thomashom7514 2 года назад

      @@dsrvarat India better produce more toilets and indoor plumbing for it’s people. Piles of shit are everywhere and then your holy cows eat it. How is India going to fight China? It can’t produce it’s own high speed trains and it’s infrastructure is a mess. The Indians only talks of what will happen but nothing gets done. 🤷🏿

  • @Unknown.man_209
    @Unknown.man_209 2 года назад +123

    He should understand that being a rebel doesn't work when international matter is concerned.
    I agree with all the things he said but disagree with the Ukraine issue ...

    • @PHOENIX-ff5fl
      @PHOENIX-ff5fl 2 года назад +8

      thike koisa....i too agree with him for every causes except the ukraine issue....because still our 70% of military parts comes from russia...and russia act as our representative in UN many times ( recent eg. using veto for the kashmir issue). So until we get veto power n fully indigenized our military equipments we r dependent on russia. kin2 Dr swamy logat koi besi flow gusi jai ketiaba

    • @bullsbears2600
      @bullsbears2600 2 года назад +7

      Yeah same. Ukraine was the one of them who proposed bill against India in 1998 after the pokhran test. And don't forget the European states position during the America's invasion on Afghanistan. Aghani's weren't human's? So Russia - Ukraine war isn't about russia's power show, it happened just because US wants no one else in this world to overcome them and make their hegemony worthless. US did it in purpose to damage their number one enemy since the cold war Era 'russia'.

    • @balapillai
      @balapillai 2 года назад

      @@bullsbears2600 : Continuation of the mayhem US’s Hillary Clinton started in Syria?

    • @bullsbears2600
      @bullsbears2600 2 года назад

      @@balapillai yes I think so.
      And ofcourse they don't care about anyone like China. China driven by money, US driver by power. None of them care about anyone or anything else.

    • @divakars2360
      @divakars2360 2 года назад

      True

  • @p.k.malhotra9522
    @p.k.malhotra9522 2 года назад +13

    Age is catching up with Dr Swami. He is more and more indulging in self praise. Sathia Raha hai.

    • @gauravgupta4543
      @gauravgupta4543 2 года назад

      Bhootni ke aukaat mein rah kar bol.....akal seekh le

  • @bosnbruce5837
    @bosnbruce5837 2 года назад +14

    LOL what was that at the end about wanting to singlehandedly "defeat China in a war"?
    Was that said in order to please the audience or is he not all right in the head?

    • @thomashom7514
      @thomashom7514 2 года назад +1

      Swamy is playing to the audience just like a politician. Trump does the same. Who is most unbelievable?

    • @kyb2027
      @kyb2027 2 года назад

      Because when war start he doesn't have to go on ground lol. So easy for him just say we will destroy china singlehandedly and put sigma rule music and Indian audience will jump like bhakt

  • @rmnair90
    @rmnair90 2 года назад +18

    Re: Literate south, Illiterate North, and 1977 elections
    Sir Mrs Gandhi lost the North because in the North Nasbandi was implemented with great "enthusiasm". In the south it was not so. Then there were the police excesses. The south had hardly any. That was to be expected. JPs movement was largely confined to the hindi- heartland.

  • @chanchal9435
    @chanchal9435 2 года назад +2

    Wah Swamy ji wah! Only true deshbhakt leader in today's time when rest are just political party bhakts. It's always a pleasure listening you.

  • @engsudatta276
    @engsudatta276 2 года назад +32

    The statement that Chinese culture was Indianised was an exeggeration. It was only in the religious thought, especially in Buddhism that Indian influence was felt. But even this aspect of Buddhism was sinicised and became Zen Buddhism. In other words, the Indian influence in Chinese religious thoughts had receded over the centuries, much less in Chinese culture.
    Let this Swami be India-megalomania and talk big about India's might. There are many areas that India has to improve on before it can catch up with China, let alone superseding it.

    • @victorbaptistrodrigues3350
      @victorbaptistrodrigues3350 2 года назад +1

      China is frightend n aware to fight inbraveness in all of Asia

    • @engsudatta276
      @engsudatta276 2 года назад +3

      @@victorbaptistrodrigues3350 In no way is China afraid to protect its territory, like Taiwan and in Tibet, which is alteady part of China since the Mongol Yuan Dynasty.

    • @Ashi_Cooks
      @Ashi_Cooks 2 года назад +1

      Lol chinese people are suffering they dont have access to internet if they try to tell anyone they are suffering from proverty and hunger you will be imprisoned in Chinese Nazi concentration camp

    • @gurindersingh8109
      @gurindersingh8109 2 года назад +2

      Sikhs under the Sarkar e Khalsa defeated China in Tibet but hindus of hindus rashtar can't last a week on battlefield against China

    • @apurvabhusari2049
      @apurvabhusari2049 2 года назад +2

      @@gurindersingh8109 says who sikhs themselves have hindu lineage. infact everyone in indian subcontinent has hindu ancestry. Sikhs are not different . So stop bring pride of only being sikh . Keep pride on being indian as it is what india requires not division. Just learn something from history.

  • @satyanarayanak6047
    @satyanarayanak6047 2 года назад +62

    I wish this man long life, so that many more conflicts will resolve.

    • @aniruddhachakrabarti6497
      @aniruddhachakrabarti6497 2 года назад

      He should not have left Harvard .had he not then he might have won a Nobel Prize for economics.

  • @manoharpatil6795
    @manoharpatil6795 2 года назад +14

    Apart from political differences in BJP we must appreciate Mr Swami has a credit for Shri Ramlala temple in Ayodhya. He is doing further efforts for Kashi and Mathura temples. to be freed from present condition clutches of muslim encroachment. Jai shree Ram. 🌹❤️

    • @jagmohanbedi5857
      @jagmohanbedi5857 2 года назад

      Have look at hospitals and dispensaries (the temples of mankind) they are empty and they want to cure ur (mental illness) by temple-mosque issues. Devilish

    • @logingoogly
      @logingoogly 2 года назад

      @@jagmohanbedi5857 Don't oppse if we try to correct wrong doings or henious crimes of past ofcourse through legal course. Concerns with medical infrastructure is different issue & must be taken care of.

  • @prakku
    @prakku 2 года назад +37

    Age is catching up with Swami. Boasting apart, he repeats himself

  • @lalitgupta689
    @lalitgupta689 2 года назад +12

    Please don't get fooled by his oration skills. That's all he is good at. He swings to RSS and hindutva as per his convience, then swings back to Antonia Maino's team when it's convenient for him. He is one of the few responsible for Atalji's govt to collapse. It's good that current BJP leadership remembers their history and keeps a fair distance from him.

    • @sumansatan1669
      @sumansatan1669 2 года назад

      He is a loose cannon but a great propounder of Hindu faith.

    • @TOD75
      @TOD75 2 года назад

      💯 Truth, You're Correct, he's poisoning people's mind.

  • @gdydbjsiuxvsnsjdx
    @gdydbjsiuxvsnsjdx 2 года назад +8

    Swamy has lost it these days..

    • @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos
      @JustAPokemonCommentingOnVideos 2 года назад

      he lost it 10 years ago ; he is just a malfunctioning missile that can strike anybody now that is why modi does not want him in cabinet ; oppose him and then he will threaten court cases against you

  • @donaldtrumpjunior2938
    @donaldtrumpjunior2938 2 года назад +17

    He is India's zelensky....in no way we can defeat China at the moment

    • @monty1156
      @monty1156 2 года назад

      Not day Never.

    • @manikanta8592
      @manikanta8592 2 года назад

      USA defeated by vietnam bro

    • @donaldtrumpjunior2938
      @donaldtrumpjunior2938 2 года назад +1

      @@manikanta8592 with the help from Russia bro...and we can't compare veitnamese jungle tactics to that of our army ...huge different...the Veitnamese can even eat snakes,wild boar, to stay alive,but we can't...

    • @beastmode6225
      @beastmode6225 2 года назад

      @@manikanta8592 china was also defeated by Vietnam in the 70s wars snd Soviet Union failed invasion of Afghanistan with help of other super powers there is always a country behind the curtain

    • @good_man4083
      @good_man4083 2 года назад

      @@beastmode6225 the other around China did defeat Vietnam

  • @kumarsathyanesan2488
    @kumarsathyanesan2488 2 года назад +3

    Wishful thinking. Courage and foolishness are the two sides of a coin. If you win you are courageous, but if you lose you were foolish.

  • @MrBindia
    @MrBindia 2 года назад +40

    He gets offended when any one criticise him . On issue of Ukraine he is completely wrong. He is showing his pro American stance. Besides that people know how he messed up Ram Mandir case . He is desperate for credit

    • @thelayman6189
      @thelayman6189 2 года назад +6

      How did he mess up the Rammandir case .. i would like to know. He seems to have support when he claims he was the one who solved it ...

    • @yogendranbaptist3300
      @yogendranbaptist3300 2 года назад +2

      Mr. S. Swamy is tired and lost all of his credibility! better he should stay in a retirement home and only pray to God till his death! That way he can help all the Indians.

    • @user-ge3je1oi8r
      @user-ge3je1oi8r 2 года назад +3

      How did he mess up?

  • @shankarcg786
    @shankarcg786 2 года назад +15

    Had he been made FM he would not have talked about shastrarth or debate I can understand his pain feelings because his knowledge of economics from Harvard is wasted 🙏

    • @debrajbasu2060
      @debrajbasu2060 2 года назад +1

      I m really surprised that you know so much about him!!! Is he you cuisine brother or material uncle???

    • @shankarcg786
      @shankarcg786 2 года назад +4

      @@debrajbasu2060 it's seems your are quite impressed by his speech which I am not he has been peddling the narrative that he has all the brain which no one has for last several years and I am fed up of it because has nothing new to say 😂

    • @parthapratimghosh3205
      @parthapratimghosh3205 2 года назад +1

      @@shankarcg786 maybe he's saying nothing new but what he is saying is not useless. You know that very well.

    • @debrajbasu2060
      @debrajbasu2060 2 года назад

      @@shankarcg786 Now, the real problem of yours seems surfacing, you believe you have more intelligence than him or you could say something more useful to than him!!! Please go and have a debate with him, what stops you, we have a pure democracy !!! 😄😜

    • @shankarcg786
      @shankarcg786 2 года назад +2

      @@debrajbasu2060 my point is simple Mr swami is a shrewd political man, if he was made a minister with a powerful portfolio then he will not utter a words against the ruling dispensation eg in all his interview he praises the late pm chandrasekara (who of course was a honest man) because swami was made the minister and his opinion mattered whereas in the present regime it seems he is not taken seriously in bjp meetings that's why he vents out his frustration or criticism which is selective otherwise I have nothing against Mr Swami who has brains.

  • @prasadhonnavara875
    @prasadhonnavara875 2 года назад +8

    Good interview.dr swamy is at his best here.

  • @VidyaSimran
    @VidyaSimran 2 года назад +5

    True.

  • @LifeizSimple
    @LifeizSimple 2 года назад +9

    Criticising the wrong within a party is needed. That's real democracy.
    I don't agree with Sanskrit thing and Puranas. Follow the culture of the land.
    China should be dealt with. Big bully. But without any bloodshed.

  • @chandrasekaranhkrishnamoor7751
    @chandrasekaranhkrishnamoor7751 2 года назад +3

    Upright man with wisdom. Jaihind

  • @sureshlagvankar2977
    @sureshlagvankar2977 2 года назад +2

    Nice to hear that Shri Swami was trained at Rajkumari Amrit Kaur Coaching for swimming.
    I too got trained with same coaching scheme for Table Tennis at Vllabhbhai Patel Stadium, Worli, Mumbai ! 😍

  • @VENKATRAMAN-mb2sz
    @VENKATRAMAN-mb2sz 2 года назад +6

    M r.Swamy did his education in English Medium School , did his research in HARWARD,
    GOT all the benefits. all in english not in any of our Indian languages ()including the GREAT
    SANSCRIT. ). NOW he advises others to persue their studies in Sanscrit. what A true Indian
    Indian politician. Real Hindu.!
    a. Venkatraman.

    • @sumansatan1669
      @sumansatan1669 2 года назад

      But he is still faithful to his faith and culture, unlike the pseudo liberals.

  • @dineshsivasankaran6157
    @dineshsivasankaran6157 2 года назад +4

    The man has lot of guts. He has gained all through his career. Nothing to loose and no regrets, watching on his conversation. The remaining part of the life is like let us see what is the next big challenge. Thanking the channel ✌

    • @abhishekchaudhary2639
      @abhishekchaudhary2639 2 года назад

      He is such a great ash hole that know one takes him seriously. He was begging Modi to make him finance minister but fake degree Modi kicked him aside.

    • @user-ij1wp7op2f
      @user-ij1wp7op2f 10 месяцев назад

      Such people are everywhere incl. in China, with guts to talk big showing their so called patriotism, but in fact helps nothing,

  • @ravimalhotra337
    @ravimalhotra337 2 года назад +17

    I like subramanium swami, he should stay in bjp forever becoz such person is needed in bjp for such argument for improvement

    • @ruhulchowdhury8032
      @ruhulchowdhury8032 2 года назад +2

      India can defeat China in movies only. Dr Subramanian and his cronies can keep dreaming !!! In reality it will be a disastrous defeat for India.

    • @ravimalhotra337
      @ravimalhotra337 2 года назад +3

      @@ruhulchowdhury8032 Defeat for India???? O come'on talk sense. No individual nuclear country can be defeated. If war happens (God Forbids) it will be disastrous for the mankind. Both China and India will totally be a barren land for millions of years. The rest countries will suffer tremendous due to radiation and impact of nuclear arsenal. Remember China has the highest of nuclear bomb so lots of radiation from it will erupt from it. I need not teach you the effect of radiation from hydrogen bomb, nuclear bomb, atom bomb. And obviously the extra effect of biological and chemical bombs kept for use. Those too will have impact. The globe is gone. Its even very scary to think of dear.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @pankajdalal666
    @pankajdalal666 2 года назад +3

    Brave💪 honest legend dr. Swami on his words.

  • @Jeetu0301
    @Jeetu0301 2 года назад +21

    Well he is right unless we don't boast more and focus on the progress.

  • @achutanandaBehera1993
    @achutanandaBehera1993 2 года назад +2

    Love you Swami ji

  • @Anil-md7ki
    @Anil-md7ki 2 года назад +2

    Agree with Swami ji on everything.

  • @nplm947
    @nplm947 2 года назад +3

    Anyone leader who talks of war should be condemned....SSwamy is a spent force and struggling hard to come to lime light after passing 80+

  • @prasadgolatkar7961
    @prasadgolatkar7961 10 месяцев назад +1

    Swamiji, you are blessed always with regards, doing to protect our ancestors sanathan culture,

  • @pilakkilummer9569
    @pilakkilummer9569 2 года назад +3

    Mr Subramanayaswamy tweeted in 2014 “ In my personal capacity I declare that our Prime Minister Mr Narendramofi has transformed to Brahmin as he inherit and exhibit Brahminical Qualities “

    • @mercedesbenz3751
      @mercedesbenz3751 2 года назад

      Don't you know a person could change his varna as per his Karma and Gunas? Narendra Modi qualifies as all of the varnas.

  • @dipakbose2677
    @dipakbose2677 2 года назад +1

    Kautilya said that ignoring the power of an enemy country is very stupid.

  • @Rahul-vp7sj
    @Rahul-vp7sj 2 года назад +13

    Swami ji is a great human great politician

  • @ksouda5415
    @ksouda5415 2 года назад +3

    Sadness is our Swami is getting old😐😐

  • @yokesh_765
    @yokesh_765 2 года назад +24

    He is one of the genius we have with us.

    • @arunjetli7909
      @arunjetli7909 2 года назад

      I like hi as well but he us still stuck in Aristotelian western paradigm he ignores reality such as posturing by countries as a policy I don’t mind his big ego as he has qualifications but not in epistemology theory of knowledge he has to prove that tjr Ukraine war is about democraccy

    • @dr.mohammadamin5995
      @dr.mohammadamin5995 Год назад

      Birth based caste is rubbish - it is utter nonsense so long as people are stbborn in isolating low caste hindus from temples and social interactions.. Swami will do well in fighting this on Ghandian lines oterwise it is nothing but empty slogan of highly ambitious poltician.

  • @parthapratimghosh3205
    @parthapratimghosh3205 2 года назад +4

    I don't know why this government is doing nothing to change the history curriculum. If the thought doesn't change then what's going to be changed??

  • @dipakbose2677
    @dipakbose2677 2 года назад +1

    He could not prove that Mahalanobis was wrong on any of his theories.

  • @nimmwinnei6488
    @nimmwinnei6488 2 года назад +3

    sanskrit+30,iyer+30,ramanujan+30,kumbakonam,+30,poonul+30,pusari+30,thanking you MOIDIPS NIMMWINNEI

  • @vishnmohan
    @vishnmohan 2 года назад +3

    Mr Swamy may be a honourable patriotic person, no doubt, but he thinks of himself as intelligent,that’s true but his ability to cope with people is not very good,on the contrary Modi has some ability to run a party and make people to follow himself. That is the most amazing things for a PM to run a country like India against all odds. I think that’s is the reason Modi didn’t make him as FM,but swamy has the guts to say anything,what is right. So we must appreciate both Mr Modi and Swamy.

    • @thomashom7514
      @thomashom7514 2 года назад

      Swamy is the Mao Tsetung of India, an educated theorist but not pragmatic like Deng Xiaoping. He is also arrogant with every sentence starting with “I”.

  • @gabrielsomething8683
    @gabrielsomething8683 2 года назад +11

    Here is the biggest problem. Religion should not be in the law. The law should defend the right to believe but not enforce beliefs. Any country who has beliefs in their laws has failed is poor, has difficulties growing.

    • @air99i
      @air99i 2 года назад +1

      It's the game of conversion that's imposed such a law.
      If religion is forced through lies & deception, there has to be a law that protects the individuals from manipulation.

    • @thomashom7514
      @thomashom7514 2 года назад

      Separation of church and State like America.

  • @wecare838
    @wecare838 2 года назад +19

    *This conflict should teach the world the importance of peace. Our future is always uncertain if we dont have good relation with our neighbours. We can only grow if there is peace in asia. And that can only happen if China and India resolve their differences through dialogue and atleast try to work together. Peace is the only way forward💛.*

  • @muralichundi
    @muralichundi 2 года назад +1

    Must appreciate his guts

  • @kumarasamypinnapala7848
    @kumarasamypinnapala7848 2 года назад +11

    Hat's off Dr Swamy ji jai Bharat matha ki jai Shree ram vettri Vel Veera Vel valzga thamizagam jai hind 👏👏👏👏👏🙏

  • @gopalkolandavelu5575
    @gopalkolandavelu5575 2 года назад +1

    Doctor Sir, I still cannot get over one fact. A skirmish was going on in Ladakh and our soldiers lives were lost. While at the same time our leaders were having tee a tee with the chinees President and his entourage. How can this actions of our leaders be explained.

  • @kumudhanandbeml8582
    @kumudhanandbeml8582 2 года назад +7

    He is gem of the genius, a society think tank, who cemented many things through legal fight.... Pride of indian 🇮🇳politics....

  • @sn59826
    @sn59826 2 года назад

    Many of his arguments are compelling!

  • @sangameshj8319
    @sangameshj8319 2 года назад +1

    A team headed by Swamiji sir should be a advisor to the PMO to address and access the performance as an auditor...🙏🙏

  • @chandrur6810
    @chandrur6810 2 года назад +1

    This is a SAMPLE
    OF - DOUBLE STANDARD. *
    CATCH ON
    CHEERS. "

  • @vikramrahulsingh
    @vikramrahulsingh 2 года назад

    Well spoken Mr. Swamy!

  • @suchetadas4375
    @suchetadas4375 2 года назад

    Thanks .Desh hai to hum hai .

  • @highlightchannel2986
    @highlightchannel2986 2 года назад +3

    Only kakki nikar is enough to fight to chaina😂

  • @air99i
    @air99i 2 года назад +4

    Now is the time if any to double up spending on defense using Artificial Intelligence and robotics to keep up with the competition.
    The world is divided as demonstrated due to recent events.
    India has to be completely "self reliant"

    • @HarshvardhanKanthode
      @HarshvardhanKanthode 2 года назад +1

      I studies robotics in my undergrad let me tell you AI and Robotics are far from what you see in the movies. Another decade of research and computing power is needed to make headway in top grade defence solution s

  • @karthikpolasani3038
    @karthikpolasani3038 2 года назад +1

    I dont know wonderful friend but he is definitely a person who shouldn't be messed with.

  • @dipakbose2677
    @dipakbose2677 2 года назад +1

    Among the Maharajaras those who opposed the British also vanished .

  • @nanditade2351
    @nanditade2351 2 года назад

    Exceptional chat show definitely on information and news

  • @BrassBalls20071
    @BrassBalls20071 2 года назад +6

    But surely not under the BJP-RSS goon raj.

  • @etroll6451
    @etroll6451 2 года назад

    Swamiji resonates, you don't win without fighting.

  • @sumitrabrahma4466
    @sumitrabrahma4466 2 года назад +1

    🙏 swamiji

  • @knd3155
    @knd3155 2 года назад +8

    How funny what a jokes 😂😂😂😂

  • @harryzhang3111
    @harryzhang3111 2 года назад +1

    Is this the same guy who predicted that India will overtake China's GDP in 2025?

    • @hfur7758
      @hfur7758 2 года назад

      2025 he didn't He meant China 2069🍒

    • @harryzhang3111
      @harryzhang3111 2 года назад

      @@hfur7758 I watched him telling this in another youtube. May be not 2025 but 2027. I was wrong when I said 2025. Nevertheless, it is almost impossible to achieve. Having a target is good but the target has to be realistic.

    • @hfur7758
      @hfur7758 2 года назад

      @@harryzhang3111 Absolutely Right. Keep well Godbless 🍓.

  • @AJAYSINGH-ns1vv
    @AJAYSINGH-ns1vv Год назад

    Swamiji is living legend. Love from bharat madhyapradesh.

  • @silent_traveller7
    @silent_traveller7 2 года назад +1

    As always speaking for the Americans.

  • @desicat3563
    @desicat3563 Год назад

    Subramanian Swamy is so knowledgeable and has so much info to share on politics of Nehru-Indira era .
    Immense respect for him.

  • @pankajkamat9689
    @pankajkamat9689 2 года назад

    Very true

  • @siddharthsatapathy2493
    @siddharthsatapathy2493 2 года назад +1

    i want Swamy to be President of india

  • @harshavardhan730
    @harshavardhan730 2 года назад

    No matter what people say today , Dr Swamy’s contribution to the country will remain unparalleled .Though not getting what he deserves has turned me him bitter that doesn’t make him less of a patriot he is , his patriotism is unparalleled , it has been people’s tendency to dispose off great men and women as per their convenience ,those who are pointing fingers on Dr Swamy today , I can vouch ,have not a percentile of his merit -politically, intellectually,academically. He remains as one of the finest leaders this country has produced.

  • @paulramrattan8278
    @paulramrattan8278 2 года назад +2

    I'm Guyanese of Indian Origin and I love to listen to Professor Swamy Ji

  • @ramachandara2830
    @ramachandara2830 2 года назад +3

    Subramania Swamy knows the answer to the Chinese occupation of Indian territory.
    Indians in general are good talkers and negotiators, while the Chinese are the opposite, the will only bow down to power. To get the Chinese occupied territory, no amount of talking will help. India has to show it muscle power, even if it is not real. Chinese will run if they convinced that India has the power.

    • @jdjssd.n.jsjssjs8951
      @jdjssd.n.jsjssjs8951 2 года назад

      If the Chinese are stupid, their economy will not be five times that of India. The stronger the economy, the stronger the military. China can hold it's breath under water much longer than India.

  • @rtanwar6976
    @rtanwar6976 2 года назад +1

    Sher E Bharat Sri Swami ji...Jai Hind 🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🦚👍

  • @mathragovender1989
    @mathragovender1989 11 месяцев назад

    Subramanian Swamy Sir, i didn't know you till this moment. I am moved by your words of wisdom and your dedication to Bharat. I sincerely feel you should be by Modi's side constantly. Please guide the ignorant people of Bharat.

  • @ymantu
    @ymantu 2 года назад

    I love you Swami

  • @bhawnasinha4693
    @bhawnasinha4693 2 года назад

    This is reality👍😀

  • @omprakashmahara
    @omprakashmahara 2 года назад

    The interviewer should ask what about nuclear arsenal thy have build up if used in war , who will win?

  • @nothingabsolute6302
    @nothingabsolute6302 2 года назад +1

    There wasn't and there wouldn't be another Dr.Subrahmanian Swamy!

  • @CJ-Fortes_Atque_Fidelis
    @CJ-Fortes_Atque_Fidelis 2 года назад +1

    'Birth based caste is rubbish', my respect to Dr Swamy

  • @shankarsharan1362
    @shankarsharan1362 2 года назад

    Great!

  • @stephentan6995
    @stephentan6995 2 года назад +7

    India talks big but acts small. China acts quietly but effectively. Just look at their economies: India is at least 50 yrs behind China, i. e. if they can put their words into action.

    • @fasttube1948
      @fasttube1948 2 года назад +1

      After ww3 there won't be West or China so good not to be like China or west

    • @spranavshanker
      @spranavshanker 2 года назад

      Being an Indian, I agree with you. Things are changing for better.

    • @vijayanand1997
      @vijayanand1997 2 года назад

      Just because something happens fast doesnt mean it's good... We need inclusive growth.. Slowly and steadily moving towards it

    • @psvasu23
      @psvasu23 2 года назад

      In China, you have everything maybe...but not your voice. Government can randomly put anyone in jail or a quarantine centre !!! you think that you have a great country!!

  • @nanusk991
    @nanusk991 2 года назад +2

    If you think he irrational, then have a look at his work. Don't worry about his words.

  • @dasgupta9288
    @dasgupta9288 2 года назад +1

    In 1962, Nehru was surrounded by many such experts.

  • @thommantelokam2956
    @thommantelokam2956 2 года назад +1

    Thanks to Swami, China builds Naval Port in Colombo, close to international ship routs. This ‘agent’ prevented Sethusamudram project on false mythology & beliefs. He met Bhindranwala and was a sympathizer.