Hindu Nationalism Could Breakup India but Ultimately People Will Resist Modi's Fascism-Arundhati Roy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- In a comprehensive interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Arundhati Roy says the present situation in the country is “extremely depressing” but she believes there are signs that the Indian people are climbing out of the hole they’ve fallen into. She said she has faith in the Indian people and believes the country will emerge out of the dark tunnel its presently within.
00:15 - 01:11 - Introduction
01:12 - 07:02 - Arundhati Roy on what has become of Indian democracy under Modi; the corporate-political nexus.
07:03 - 10:49 - Hindu majoritarianism in India and the role of the state machinery.
10:50 - 13:48 - The idea of a ‘Hindu nation’ threatens to break India apart.
13:49 - 17:22 - India’s (and the BJP’s) brutal treatment of minorities.
17:23 - 22:25 - Roy’s checklist on signs of fascism.
22:26 - 25:56 - ‘The people of the country are stopping India from becoming a fascist state.’
25:57 - 28:47 - Roy claims that the BJP losing the 2022 Uttar Pradesh election could be a dangerous prospect.
28:48 - 30:47 - The role of ‘liberals’ in facilitating fascism in India; how that has changed.
30:48 - 37:06 - Resonances of Nazi Germany can be seen in India today, but fascism will be failed experiment
37:07 - 41:46 - Fascism, fake news and falsified history
41:47 - 50:47 - The ongoing suppression of the narrative of Kashmir
50:48 - 52:42 - Is the picture of India improving?
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/sup...
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewir...
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewi...
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
Ma'am, your faith in some people has been realized.
Stay safe.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 she was helping terrorists in Kashmir . You are supporting terrorists ???
@@plmnjioqazzsw7962 please understand her family her hindu father divorced her Christian mother at young age
@@plmnjioqazzsw7962 terrorist is one who instills terror in others through violence. Seems like hindus are doing the same with dalits.
Not only is she one of the tallest intellectuals, she has such a beautiful and compassionate mind! Who else can otherwise write: 'To love and be loved. To never forget your own insignicance...To seek joy in the saddest places. To pursue beauty to its lair...To respect strength, never power...To never look away. And never, never to forget."
Her hatred for Hindus stems from the fact that her Bengali hindu father abandoned her keralite catholic mother. It forced her to go live with her mother in Kerala. I sympathize with her.
The fact that she can spew venom sitting in India illustrates India's tolerance. But my liberandos will disagree.
@@asheravi9328 Stop spamming over here and go to school.
#DumbAndDumber
@@asheravi9328 Islam itself is an ideology of hatreds. They even kill themselves by bombing , not even speaking about the infidels. Few days ago a Shia mosque was blown up in Pakistan this urban naxals are mute on these. Is RSS behind that too?
@@asheravi9328 Islam itself is an ideology of hatreds. They even kill themselves by bombing , not even speaking about the infidels. Few days ago a Shia mosque was blown up in Pakistan this urban naxals are mute on these. Is RSS behind that too?
benefits of Karan thappar's interviews:
1. you get to bulid vocabulary ....( cocophony is todays word )
2. you get to know whats happening in country
3. you can learn how to be a very good journalist- he does so much homework before every interview
4. you can watch an interview where in the end you dont wanna bang your head and abuse someone
5. Questions are sharp and incisive
6. He can make you drink water sometimes ...so all his panelist are in someway or the other be always worried whats he gonna shoot next .
7. when karan thappar is trying to drill into your answer ...panalists know that they are in trouble
8. even countrys smart lawyers sometimes get dumb stuck
And Dosti bani rahe
@@stillunknown5785 hahaha I'm reading your comment in Modi voice 😂😂
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
It's cacophony
@@sjraniga jali re jali kali mata ki kali kali gaand jali yay 😁
Thanks!
Thankyou 🎈
Arundhati Roy is a humble, nice and a gem..highly intellectual and respected.
--
My solute to her.
Lol 🤣
Someone asked me to tell a super joke and I forwarded your comment! What these are doing is called ‘Aranya Rudan’ 🤣
The tragedy is that only a very few public of India is able to understand the differences between democracy and fascism. The difference between a industrialist and a businessman. Jai Hind.
only librandus like you. hmm?
Modi was democratically elected,.... failing to understand this basic truth raises questions about your cognitive ability
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 yet we choosed a mass murderer thats the harsh truth we are becoming like Nazis
Between islamic science and real science
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 While it is true that depending on interpretation, Modi could be seen as democratically elected, do not forget the numerous accusations of malpractices against BJP. This combined with their influence over social and mainstream media and their use of religion in politics (which in itself is a violation of the code of conduct) may present a picture which is uglier than you think.
Corporates too are culprits for the horrific conditions the country are in today; may they rest in hell for eternity soon ; Adanis, Ambanis, Tatas and those who supported these fascists at any given point of time.
Corporates creates leadership, they funds advertisement , those advertisements are percolated to masses , masses dreams of illusion and delusion perceived thro advertisement.
What options do they have? Remember what happened to tanishq or Asian paints or Cadbury.
Corporates will work with any gvt. Companies cannot shut down just cz the leadership changed. Let's be reasonable here.
This is the best of all interviews of Karan because only Aurndatti Roy cud answer clearly all questions that Karan asked in her own words rather than just agreeing to what Karan wanted her to say. Hats off to Aurn datti Roy for be so open n Frank in sharing her views. ❤👍👌👏👏
I think I should have company of someone with intelligence like her
Brave lady , talk fearless truth 👍
👍🙏
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
Your reply " brave lady" is so true ...as anyone who speaks out against this snooping government is slapped with UAPA. Speaking the truth should not be considered as being brave ,like in the west ,our constitution guarantees freedom of expression....but sadly what you said is true.
yes true
Jail jaane vaali h beta ab yeh
Sweetness of her voice catches you the firsthand then you come to the beautiful words and then the meaning… she’s enchanting!! 🙏🏻
Really, True
So true..🌹🌸
Please convert to islam
@@tirthankarmandal1410 Ok
@Drac UU Ha ha ha… because yourself is a snake 😝
Beauty of democracy. You can endorse or oppose any political viewpoint as you choose. Currently people have chosen ,and if they wish change ,so be it. But the rule of law must persist.
Yes. If democracy is guarded people's will is the master. But that's where I start to get nervous. India's democracy has been weakening this decade. Independent institutions are being compromised, Government's political powers have increased exponentially so naturally, there is a question of whether India's democracy will remain in the first place or will it become a namesake democracy like Pakistan or Russia.
What if the people have become fools to not understand they have no control and have handed over their country to authoritarians.
@@mayavi93 When you think "people" have become fools and do not understand, the "people" you refer to is usually you yourself.
In democracy, any individual who thinks they know better than the billion other people in rest of the country is just being silly.
@@alcinnovations say this to the people who handed their country to authoritarians. You think PPL cant be brainwashed😂. Two word "Nazi", "Stalin".
Saying big words alone are not enough, think about what I said first. I didn't tell a single man's intelligence is more than a sane group's. But more than a group of brainwashed people.
@@mayavi93 Why do you consider yourself NOT brainwashed?
Great that Arundhati called out Karan when she was speaking about caste, Karan was trying his best to navigate out of that subject and was quite successful.
Dear Mr Thapar,
It was a pleasure listening to Ms. Roy but it was very disappointing the way you were conducting the interview. Miss Roy is an intellectual and when an intellectual is responding to a question, we should listen patiently and not rush in to counter her every word or sentence. To me it appeared as if you were in some sort of competition with her to prove yourself as a comparable. An honest truth is that you are just a journalist asking questions based on facts, and she was the one who was giving us some insight and wisdom based on her intellect. In your desperate quest to position yourself near her you have proved that you are a pseudo-intellectual. For future interviews please keep in mind that humility is a virtue.
I agree with you. I find him very irritating....
He went hard on her, drilled her...that's his job as a journo. Some other people do interviews that are soft core propaganda, scripted. At least there is no doubt that this is a real interview.
@@konchiwanamchoom5296 Its his job to question her to clarify her contradictory statements otherwise we could have you interviewer and lapping up everything she says
General p n thapar formula of 1962?😂
Oh I see😂
What a superb quote she mentioned "UP farmer said it perfectly - desh ko char log chalate hain, do bechte hain do khareedte hain charo Gujarat se hain" 😂 hahaha superb and bang on!
I am gujarati... Small business man in India and all over the world are also gujarati mam.... Is it bang on????
@@harshitdesai9631 Hi harshit, it is not about Gujarat or Gujaratis. It is infact indirectly hinting at the people who are buying and selling and ruling the country and hint is that they all four are from Gujarat. Waise. It is nothing to do with Gujarati people. Please don't take offense. I am from Bombay and I have grown up with Gujarati neighbours and colleagues. She is mentioning the place Gujarat as a hint to who those four people are.
@@nehaparkar some sources and how do you sell a country?
a country which thinks freebies as a real development, no wonder you think businessman are buying india, they have money so they are buying it otherwise people are just jealous of them
Learn about american billionaires, bill gates has bought majority lands in america, i don't see indians hating them instead we all know
Hypocrisy is an integral part of indians😂😂
@@shivam_nagar69 oh bhai..one means is means privatizing otherwise public sectors and the other is people of his preference for one person on the fore front (which will soon burst). Bahi why will anyone be jealous. If all are progressing and the country is progressing then why should anyone be jealous..but the point is that is not happening..the Rich are getting richer and poor are in a deep mess. Unemployment has been highest, crimes high, crimes against women high, social fabric ruptured at its highest..toh what progress are we talking about. Remove your rose colored glasses and see. Unless if you are an andh bhakt then all the best to you :)
@@harshitdesai9631 she is a commie from JNU what more can u expect from them?
I salute you that you uttered that Kashmiries want freedom.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
"अधर्म कितना भी बलवान क्यूँ न हो अंततः उसकी मृत्यु धर्म के हाथों ही होती है" यही सत्य है और यही स्वासत है यही सनातन है, आदि के साथ अंत भी जन्म लेता है
What a brilliant, fascinating woman Arundhati is. In 10:51, its amazing how eyes light up like fire! Incredible!!
Mr.Karan Thapar, even though I like your incisive questions, please have the patience to listen to answers to the questions which YOU have asked, without interrupting !!
Karan wants non stop criticism of BJP...if the guest deviates from that agenda for 1 second, he loses patience. It's annoying.
Mr Karan behave yourself
@@pcpolice2314 He Mr Karan is Quality journalist not Godi Modi Media owned by BJP
By watching him like that i accepted him the way he is. Now a days i dnt feel impatient to his interruption.. He is that so do we..
Karan seems to be trying a bit too hard to contradict her on many points, even though he would perfectly agree to most points she is making,
I think he was calmly picking holes in her logic. I may agree with the guests sentiments, but she did not explain herself well in this interview and he naturally gravitated to the lacunae in her thinking..
That is investigative journalism.
India getting disintegrated by religious chaos may be the ultimate interest of US politicians and of the Chinese. Therefore large amount of US moneys are liberally donated to the RSS subsidiaries working in various names in the US. Nobody know as to how such enormous moneys are transferred to India and used to suppress other religions and create a political and social Hindu majority.
@@9443141690 Can you cite a source to support your stance? I would really like to read about what you're saying
@@9443141690 RSS activists in UK and US are big donors but as far as I have been told some rival groups have compiled a register of key RSS activists, there will be something interstings to see.
The Congress created Dhirubhai Ambani and the BJP has gone for Gautam Adani. People carry illusion that they elect the PM. Harsh reality is dawning who selects that person.. Such a force could only be maintained by force.
@@specialrelativity8222
It converted an ordinary salesman into millionaire. Template is others to follow. Dhirubhai Ambani's sons have followed advice of their father literally. The Congress is now feeling high and dry.
@@specialrelativity8222 inc scams are much bigger
@Vijay Manjrekar
Be clear in thought. It is an Indian nation not of any particular religion. Please don't use Pakistani template here.
@Vijay Manjrekar 🤣😂 TheaRSSeHndtvAatnnkkkkwaaadiChhhhhhddzzzzzzzKaGbbbbbbrrrrrMtttttrrrrrrrAreAlreadyDoingItTheaRSSeAreRppppppppngDalitsOBCsTheAdanisAmbanisAreTakingAwayBillionsOfDollarsOfHindusAlreadyTheaRSSeIsAlreadyForcingHindusToCelebrateONLYthoseFestivalsLeadersWhoTheaRSSeWants😂🤣😂😂
@Vijay Manjrekar 😂🤣😂😂 CongratulationsToAllTheBhddddwaaadaaariNpunskTheaRSSeChhhhhdddddddzzzzzzzzWhoAreNotHumanButOnlyGbrrrrrrrMtttrtrrrrrrrrrr😂🤣🤣😂YouHaveAlreadyAchievedAllTheAboveObjrctives🤣😂🤣😂👏👏👏
Karan needs to stop interrupting. I can see how most Indians if not many will hate the truth of Arundhati - she is great and what you call an outstanding Indian
"Indian Army is Illegally occupying and oppressing the People of Kashmr and Arunachal Pradesh, Who demand Freedom from India"
- Arundhati Suzanna Roy
Kashmir is a legitimate dispute from the founding of India. It’s not like any other state. We have to accept that and find a solution while being clear it does not set a precedent for any other part of the country.
Before 2014 we use to get free flights, luxury hotels, perks and alcohol which is very democratic but now we are jobless.. 😂😂😂
Unity in diversity is what made India possible. People today are much more educated emotionally discerning to fall prey to divisive politics played around by all players. It's the compassion which has made India what it is.
There was never any unity among the masses. The unity of religions that you are talking about is a minority phenomenon. Most people from different religions don't want interference from others and want to live individually in peace. They just mind their own business
@@AnkitKumar-sn8hqyes I agree more with your comment.
Great soul struggling in narrow minded society under highly suffocating environment.
When is secularism coming in Pakistan?
Wire must arrange similar debates with CJI of SC OR HC by Mr Karan Thapar .
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Not possible?
I have always loved her opinionated interview. Loved the Way she said “ You promised you won’t interrupt “ to him.. yet he did.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
@Hearts N Eyes OpenWide Eyes OpenWide Let me deport you to Pakistan, then you will get the value of India when Muhammadans will treat you like that Lankan factory guy from Pakistan.
still Karan is one of finest.
@kb You said nothing different to what others have been saying for years. That is called extreme brahminical logic.
@kb You still don't understand. The anti muslim element make loader noise backed by their media and organisational structure.
You persecute them so much and when some of them retaliate you declare all of them terrorists. That is brahmanical logic. We think muslims in Inda are like a mountain between Brahmans and rest of us. You think one they are removed you can get to rest of us but be careful we are also ready and well organised.
Although I don't disagree with Ms. Roy, I as an Indian am really
Worried about what will happen in the near future. Arrogant leaders poor economy, unemployment, poverty etc etc.
Has destroyed this nation to a great extend.
@Vijay Manjrekar wow nice script .. !! Movie may act kon kar rah hai .. vivek Oberoi ya anupam kher .. produced by amabni and adani ..
Kuch sense k sath story likh lo be .. I mean seriously.. 5th std can come up with better story than this
@Vijay Manjrekar well anyone can write better than you..
If you had studied well, you wouldn't have to work for an IT cell .. 😉
In a world of blind people.. one eyed man was the God.. !!!
No worry, when you are thrown in the street you will realise ..
You get paid for this .. I don't
You people are beneath me and pure waste of time ..
After people dying left and right during covid ..people still for him .. should speak volume..
@Vijay Manjrekar well who raped dailt in unnao or in hatras .. or even asifa for that matter ..
I'm aganist violence of any sorts .. but for before asking me go ask bjp members, have any of them prisoned .. rather you took a support march .. shame on you ppl
The wire owner tweeted that south India should be cut off from India .
Just understand under which mindset this people are spreading propoganda.
BJP has enter karantaka, Pondicherry. In Andhra Pradesh BJP got big push in Municipal election.
This anti India gang is worried that TN and Kerala shouldn't unite with Hindu.
This is what their plan is which Rahul Gandhi was emphazing in the parliment.
This bullshit portal are advertising agency which promotes congress divide and rule policy in India
They will never report any story from Rajasthan or Punjab
They will only focus on UP
@@5Amandeep Thapar must be arrested for running anti India propaganda
Like it or not, Anundhati is bold and puts her point across. Her point about Kashmiris not wanting to join India gives me the chills
It’s a tragedy minority 10 percent of upper caste are ruling 70 percent of Dalit and backward community and keeping them under the umbrella of Hindutuva only for votes and power. This is why still Dalit and backward community are deliberately kept uneducated and economically dependent! Hope better sense prevail for the good of the nation.
Arundhati Roy is always forthright in her thought process, she is a beacon of hope and peace in the Difficult times we are passing through. She gives her views without hate and rancour, and gives the people of India a positive approach to follow to fight back against the fascist forces knocking on our society.
ARUNDHATI ROY YOU ROCK!!!!!!
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Tell me you are a communist without telling me you are a communist.
Tell me you're a isi-lamic t-err0-rist support without telling me you're isi-lamic t-err0-rist support.
Karan Sir, please talk about Sikhs too. We aren't happy either the way they are trying to dilute Sikhism.
Canada chale ja wahan gand mara ...
@@observerdownunder3999 tumhe sab se taklif kya he. BJP ke for me Muslim, sikh, dalit Christian khus kuin nahi he. Answer me
@@observerdownunder3999 that's your profession . Good for u . 😭💯
After Muslims & Christians you will be next. If you guys don't throw out of power then we are doomed.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Facts and logic clearly took a back seat in this interview
That’s the only thing that was consistent in this masterpiece- logic , facts and brilliance by a great human - Ms Roy
Andhbhakt
@@cHinduCrusher the issue is you cant even argue with these asses . These guys are deeply brainwashed . You cant do anything but watch these people bark
@@cHinduCrusherando n$mozi
@@Lavvonaffair Really? Did you even hear what she said at all?
Subcontinent didn’t learn from partition riots.I hope people of this region learn to live with harmony.
Pluralism is a blessing
❤️ 🇨🇦
Complete exchange of population is good solution
you can read all the violence in our religious texts. Think of the life under the kings and nawabs.
It’s a lot better than it used to be. Foreign fundamentalist religious ideologies have been trying to break India for 800 years now!
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Harmony kabhi bhi nhi thi. Sablog apne face pe mask lagaye the secularism ke name pe. Lekin itna fix hain ki ye country ab nhi tutne wali. Jinko pasand nhi hain rehna yha wo jayege apna boriya bistar utha kar, kyuki ye mitti hamari MAA hain lekin kuch logo ko bas ye geography dikhta hain. But haan is dharti ko MAA manne walo ka numbers jyada hain, isliye country to kabhi bhi nhi tutegi. Tutege log jinko is desh se pyar nhi hain aur mazboori me yha pe gujar basar kar rahe hain.
She said it...a true bengali and malayalee blend, you can imagine ..
Majoritarianism: What happens if we allow the majoritarianism of BJP's HINDUTVA to continue now. Afraid we may land up like Yugoslavia which got split into 6 Republics, independent Nations.
The six constituent republics are Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia.Yugoslavia disintegrated after a series of wars and conflicts (including genocide and ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims) between 1991 and 2001, which led to the killing of nearly two lakh people.
A Croatian woman said the reason for this breakup. “There were many reasons. But the main reason was the majoritarian mindset of Serbians. We in Croatia were not allowed to keep our Croatian identity, sing Croatian songs, celebrate Croatian festivals, and so on. We were simply asked to follow what Serbia decided.”
She cannot speak a WORD of Bengali , hated Hindu Bengali's all her life BUT still a blend :-)
@@Bandhu241 she never said against hinduism.
Divisions are happening across India now based on religion, caste, region more rapidly.... TV News Channels, Social media are igniting the divisions in most destructive way....
You are right. Media is adding ghee to the fire
Majoritarianism: What happens if we allow the majoritarianism of BJP's HINDUTVA to continue now. Afraid we may land up like Yugoslavia which got split into 6 Republics, independent Nations.
The six constituent republics are Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia.Yugoslavia disintegrated after a series of wars and conflicts (including genocide and ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims) between 1991 and 2001, which led to the killing of nearly two lakh people.
A Croatian woman said the reason for this breakup. “There were many reasons. But the main reason was the majoritarian mindset of Serbians. We in Croatia were not allowed to keep our Croatian identity, sing Croatian songs, celebrate Croatian festivals, and so on. We were simply asked to follow what Serbia decided.”
I read her book on Kashmir where she's trying to portray Indian army deployed in Kashmir as rapists. And being an offspring of a jawan and a communist, both the identity started conflicting each other, within me. 😢
Later on asking my father if it's true/not , he told it to be absolute crap. It's some ppl when bestowed with extra power like that of AFSPA becomes fearless from the consequences they might face on performing deeds which according to them is absolutely acceptable as they're the ones who're witnessing and sometimes bound to fight the biggest acts of bigot performed by the parliamentary body !
And there are some and not all army personnel are/were rapists and that too occurs as they're bound to distant from away from their partners
truth is modi again 2024 then 2029. Then yogi till next 25 years. Embarrass that. Sala ai duk kyu khaton nehi hota
Well put by Arundhati. She rightly flags even the army falling in Modi’s lap (without even a whimper).
Could u explain me how ?
@@chandrakanthveluri9860 watch the whole video
She explains clearly
@Vijay Manjrekar - Quite unnecessary and foolish.
@@chandrakanthveluri9860 Senior army officers today are today making political statements. Just 8 years back, they would’ve been packed for uttering even 5 words of the long, uncalled statements they are making today with total impunity.
Armed forces have very effectively been destroyed. And they lumped it.
@@AlokAsthana1954 Oh so u army officers should be mum coz it is the policy that was being maintained by the previous government. I don't think u have seen the interview of General Manekshaw. Kindly watch it and tell me if he was also wrong in opposing Indira Gandhi's orders in 1971.
EXACTLY. I have been saying this since forever.
Dictators never last in democracies.
On the contrary, democracies offer the best chance for a determined dictator. Hitler won elections.
Unlike Germany, India is having different languages and people so dictatorship can be in imagination for Modi ji
@@mohammedidrish8597 We will just keep our fingers crossed. Chauvinism is its own language.
Because of federal structure and segregation of culture and diversity in faith it seems very intricate to fall in the entanglement of dictatorships.
@@aminkapadvanji975 The main issue as I see it is the unwillingness of the "decent" individual to get into an actual fight. For example almost all of times I voted, I was "forced" to invalidate my vote as I knew that almost every candidate on the list was mostly a street thug turned electoral candidate. In the rare times when I saw a decent candidate and voted for him, he/she just lost. You might ask why I do not contest, but I hope you are not that naïve.
Only Arundhati Roy can ask Karan Thapar to “cool off” :) like that!
Correct 💯 m,am,, u r the inspiration for us to bring a change in modi ji '' reign,,. How long modi will frighten the common people,, people are disgusted with him,
Except wokes like you & people of books nobody else is frightened... Don't worry modi will back to power....these people are modern mir sadhiks of India...they have sold themselves to some masters..
@@dkmanju And you've sold yourself to Hindutva, no different than an IS recruit. You hate muslims, and all minorites, and its unfortunate because you may have been a good person. You unfortunately allowed Hindutva hate to become your master, instead of accepting true Hindu Civilizational values of Pluralism and accepting love to become a true Sanatani. Shame
Too much of interruptions by Thapar, when she's trying to make a point. Ease up man and remember that she's who we want to listen to.
The already forgotten issues which were hindrance to our development and progress have now been made to resurrect for the last ten years which is certainly going to harm our nation. The first movement of independence in 1857 and the struggle of independence later on had a very great role of both Hindus and Muslims. But now this unity which very essential for development is being targeted for votes by politicians. This is indeed worrisome.
Unity lol indian muslims protested and demanded Pakistan and Bangladesh as a muslim countries .now the India should be the country of hindus and we want Hindustara.
@@jrrj940 seems to be again a Muslim country will established. If you make hindu rastra
This threat of breaking up India will not work anymore. There is no Gandhi.
@@jrrj940 in your dreams.
I think this plea does not justify as in India though Muslims in India is a a minority comunity but still concentraed in big pockets like in Kashmir in UP CP and has the potential to be independent countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh. If two Muslim majority counties can be formed why not the third and fourth. Same is with Sikhs and others.
Your interview is very good, but Hindi speaking people do not know Karan Thapar and Arundhati Roy. It would be great if this interview is translated into Hindi.
please use google translations is possible
And also other languages like Tamil...
"Kashmir is not integral part of India" who said this ?
Who ever said that could probably be right ?
Ask to kashmiris
Someone whose middle name is Suzanne....masquerading as hindu but secretly dreaming of queen Victoria to rule Hindustan 😃
@@royandrews4980 Few activist and few sickulars with TV shows and news articles can keep shouting from roof tops, few UN resolutions will not help them. Hindus are awaken after 70 years of sick rules of Congress, Muslims pleasing party's are trying to prove they are Hindus. Lets see how much 'Free' left will offer for vote. Its Indians who will decide. Some Pakistan mullah by name Roy may keep crying!!
@@raeesasultana3236 Sure, India requests Kashmiri Muslims to leave country of infidels India and go to citadel of Islam Pakistan. OR any 57 peace loving rich countries! Just get out!
Ms Arundhati is the conscience keeper of the country. She rightly analyses the present scenarios of the country. We must listen to her
She is the breaker of the country and selective keep of conscience.
"We must listen to her" - You must. We mustn't.
In a democracy, we get rulers what we deserve.
And how did Syrians get ISIS and afghans get the Talebans?
@@varoonnone7159 He said 'In a democracy' ....Neither ISIS nor Taliban have come to power through the democratic process, I.e. through elections.
82 Average IQ ;-)
@@effervescentevanescenttran6331 60
@THE HINDU Of course it is but that's not the point here.
She predicted it correctly two years ago before 2024 elections that people will save India
Thanks wire for this fantastic interview with arundati roy
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Leftist Propaganda at its best. Hypocrites
Hats off to KT for asking the question about ethnic cleansing call to every single guest of him..
The wire owner tweeted that south India should be cut off from India .
Just understand under which mindset this people are spreading propoganda.
BJP has enter karantaka, Pondicherry. In Andhra Pradesh BJP got big push in Municipal election.
This anti India gang is worried that TN and Kerala shouldn't unite with Hindu.
This is what their plan is which Rahul Gandhi was emphazing in the parliment.
This bullshit portal are advertising agency which promotes congress divide and rule policy in India
They will never report any story from Rajasthan or Punjab
They will only focus on UP
Majoritarianism: What happens if we allow the majoritarianism of BJP's HINDUTVA to continue now. Afraid we may land up like Yugoslavia which got split into 6 Republics, independent Nations.
The six constituent republics are Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia.Yugoslavia disintegrated after a series of wars and conflicts (including genocide and ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims) between 1991 and 2001, which led to the killing of nearly two lakh people.
A Croatian woman said the reason for this breakup. “There were many reasons. But the main reason was the majoritarian mindset of Serbians. We in Croatia were not allowed to keep our Croatian identity, sing Croatian songs, celebrate Croatian festivals, and so on. We were simply asked to follow what Serbia decided.”
@@manchikantimurty7375 Well said
@@manchikantimurty7375 if leftist will live in india then it will happen
Ms. liberandu, urban naxal, tukde-tukde, anti-national, ghaddar. Thank You.
Good discussion. I would hope that the interviewer sort of simmers down and allow the interviewee to express and articulate in their own fashion.
Yes. The interviewer came off as a bit disturbing, distracting and obnoxious
Yes, I agree with your suggestion.
Yes karan is kind of obsessed about "paraphrasing'
I think the interviewer was keep on interrupting too much.
Correct
With all respect Mr. Karan why don’t you follow these steps
1. Pick your smartphone
2. Search fascism
3. READ
DO IT
Superb views on people's of India, the Great Arundhati Roy ji, well said, I want to read your book and very inspired by this interview Arundhati Roy ji, thanks very great.
Salute to the most versatile Arundhati Roy Madam.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Very candid and bold facts placed by madam for which throughout her life she struggled.
For the survival of democracy such voices needs to be strengthened
Madam is an anti Hindu brain washed has been who strives to remain in limelight at any cost. She is darling of Kashmiri Jihadists and that should tell you she really is.
Now India truly resisted fascism elements after this parliamentary election
Not in big way otherwise modi would be looking for other work
@@mossmm73 It has been resisted, not been
uprooted... It will be there as our country accepts all diverse beliefs.
Lol you think people voting in the lure of money and revival of caste politics is resisting fascism 😂
Both of this people have lost their own identity hence they see everything wrong in today's India.
Listening to two smart people conversation is like medicine to all the noise that is present in the Indian media..
Man things are not that easy..
India has adopted israel model...
Its not about hindu nationalism its a stategy....
She's smart. All right then. 🤡
@ping pong Coz they will be murdered if they do
@Karan good discussion. But please try to be a bit patient. Everyone is entitled to respond in their own elaborate, illustration providing, hypothesis etc. So please be cool. Keep your volume a bit balanced. Ok dude.
Same thoughts. I got a bit irritated by him.
To make these two serpents wriggle in the pain of Modi hatred , I will vote for BJP again😂
First time I heard to Arundhati Roy. How elegant her voice is!!! I fall in love with her voice....exciting to know more her writings n achievements!!!
my whole college life was spent abusing her. I was an idiot falling to whatsapp university. Sorry ArunDhati ji..
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
@@NativeVsColonial You are totally missing the big picture here.
@@iamfeign8498 Read the Qu'ran, to get the ideology.
Muhammadanism is a form of Arab Nationalism above all nationalities.
@@NativeVsColonial Missing the point again bruh. I think I am taking to a Parrot.
The realistic Arundhati&Karan interview
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
@@sjraniga We had, between 1998-2004 , seen party presidents , ministers accepting bribe on camera ,attack on Indian parliament y terrorists , visiting president of a neighbouring country insult Indians on India's soil , agricultural distress . if that regime had continued there would have been a civil war as seen in Gujarat in2002 . Besides , IPCL, Ashoka Hotels, BALCO, Hindustan ZInc , Centaur Hotels were gifted at a throw away price to cronies . The only difference isat that time there were many cronies and today only two or three
Jai Shree Ram
After Indhira Gandhi, i could have seen the same glazing face with sharp eyes such a gorgeous 😍 n stunning personality.
How can you compare with Indira, this lady looks devilish.
Brilliant what a brave intelligent lady
🙏🙏 excellent and objective analysis but we are very much apprehensive about your life and safety. ❤❤
Our Unity, the unity of fellow citizens is our biggest strength and literally no ideology howmuch Fascists, Racists, anti poor, divisive, deceptive, communal can destroyed us nor our our beloved country...
Our strength lies in our Unity in diversity, and that's the reason these forces are targeting, attacking and trying to destroy the social fabric, the bond between us by continously spreading lies and hatrate, fake narratives, Islamophobic contents and tries to frighten people, tries to divide people and exploit masses and Rule over them... But Now Public knows their real faces and their ajanda.
Communal virus is more dangerous than any other virus...
You agree with her views is a different matter but there's nothing 'objective' about Arundhati Roy and her views.
@@sagarsaxena6318
Let the public decide about her "objective" views, but the fact is the TRUTH what she said is undeniable if you only look at them without being biased and prejudice in your mind, if so, anyone can see what she is saying are facts...
Arundhati (Suzanne) Roy needs some serious servicing!
If Hindu nationalism can break up India, as is made out by Arundhati Roy, then what is her rationale when India got divided in 1947 when there was no NaMo/BJP/RSS? Wasn't India got divided in 1947 due to ambition of JL Nehru and MA Jinnah, both wanted to become PM possible only through division of India?
She said division again. It is growing in Maharashtra and south india. U northies not aware of it.
@@keralanaturelover196 Nice joke 😂😂
If Kerala has everything why are more than half the malayalees living outside Kerala ?!
BJP should organize lectures of Arundhati Roy in every part of India. BJP will automatically win, without any effort in 2024.
So true, Arunthathi Roy is enough to make BJP win not because people like BJP
@@nishanthramakrishnan3362 do you like bjp?
@@Karthickபரையர் I don’t like anyone. All politicians are bunch of thieves at the end of the day. So there’s nothing to like about them.
I love and support India, if anyone or party is inline with that agenda of developing and promoting India, I support them. I don’t mind India becoming like Singapore or Dubai - where you have better quality of life and development but some freedoms are compromised.
@@Karthickபரையர்non of your concern?? Well do you like congress 😂?
Mind Blowing Information.
Thank you Ms. Anudhathi Roy/ Mr. Thapar for high lighting to the Citizens of India.
Modi has been very efficient and successful in ensuring that Economy Progressed Downwards and Democratic stature of India.
Q
"Karan! Just cool off!". That's hilarious!
Every interviewee's inner voice.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
He too very gentlemen and he should be more smart to remove word from guest 🙏🏼
@@NativeVsColonial Funny that the only people that articulate this sentiment, are almost always Hindus. The Muslim never claims that he is disloyal to India, but the Hindu pre-empts this on his behalf. I wonder who the traitor is now?
@@Carnage1998tm Haha, Pakistan and Bangladesh were created by Hindus, also the state religion of Pakistan and Bangladesh is Hinduism 🤪
Muhammadans are the most loyal, this is why India in 1947 was divided on the basis of Hinduism. ☺
I am an admirer of Karan Thapar, BUT I was disappointed that Mr. Thapar WOULD NOT let Arundhati Roy talk about the Hindu Caste system ! Many " low Caste " Hindus left Hinduism to follow BUDDHA when Buddha walked the Earth . YES , contrary to the LIES of ABHIJIT CHAVDA the Caste system of India ( which is based on the lightness / darkness of a person`s skin ) pre-dates the Buddha !! The Caste system WAS NOT started by the Briish like CHAVDA outrageously claims !!
*Their mind is a master piece.. It is divided into left and right..In the left part nothing is right and in right part nothing is left*
👍👍😂😂
Hahahaha awesome!
👌👌👌
She replied rightly how can a person holding a constitutional position wearing a safron dress and if purda of muslim girls is against the uniform laws then how come the Sikhs are being allowed to wear Turbans and grow beard and hair in Army and their children in schools . Why purda is the target.
What is problem when owaisi mp of parilement wear beard and Islamic clothes what is problem for hindu believer pm modi
@@kr-us6ek But we will question when the children are denied their right to education as they are wearing hijab. And everyone knows which party ruling the state gov of Karnataka.
Salam Renowned scholar Professor Noam Chomsky on Thursday said that Islamophobia has taken a “most lethal form” in India, turning some 250 million Indian Muslims into a “persecuted minority”.
@@ajaykrishna4563 I was just going through the comment section I saw yours.. I really appreciate how you mentioned the term "children" not girls not Muslim... thanks for your unbiased response 👍🏿
@@ajaykrishna4563 they used to sit in the class without hijab for 18 months, suddenly they refused to remove hijab inside the class room, then other girls complained to school authority citing uniform rules, school authority tried their level best to fix issue but failed. Even other girls of the class revealing now that their entire attitude had changed since November as they started contacted CFI members. See their Twitter accounts you will get to know their hidden plan. You talk all thrash without knowing anything. I am from Karnataka too.
"Karan! You are really being ridiculous, sometimes!"
A vulture and a Hyenas sat down and had a discussion on how to get rid of the Lion to keep the forest safe.
Wonderful lady very brave and very intelligent outspoken gig respect great interview Mr thaper
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Aizaz she said few days ago....she said that PM should have compulsorily for 1 time only...will u agree with that....I dont agree...
Blabbering of a schizophrenic intellectual
Pakistan totally deserves her.... please take her
Please tell me what braveness she has shown ? Lol only thing she can do is abusing bjp because bjp is tolerant.
Repeal of farm laws should be treated as tactical retreat and not their defeat. No doubt the credit of that retreat goes to the stiff resistance put by farmers.
Brother they can't reintroduce the farm laws considering only two years are left for parliamententary election; they might reintroduce it after general election if they win it. I don't think they will do it even then after seeing the unrelentless resistance from farmers.
She is a Mighty Think Tank who had the Guts to speak.. God bless you madam
she is destructive women for India, Just send her to Pak
She does not believe God she believes only mecca brigade
I am with you bro
Karan’s cross examination of Ms. Arundhati Roy was quite effective. However, Ms. Roy is right that Mr. Modi has been intrinsically a fascist. Nevertheless, I salute Indian Opposition for making Mr. Modi kiss the Indian Constitution.
Indian media houses and business houses have been cravenly genuflecting before the brutal government and are worse than even East India Company, which , by all accounts , was not as brutal as the current Indian media houses and business houses. Indians may wistfully long for another spell of British like administration from whom many "Hindutvavadis" drew their pension and obtained their pardon
andhvirodhi spotted*
What is Mudaliar???? is it your doctorate??? Change must start from individuals...
Today its the Gujrat India Company, a few people from the same high caste running a brutal Raj.
Caste system need to be abolished.
@@numanunees2597
Italian Gandhi Company: ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
i was supporting equality casue .. but you have made me a hindu .. i now want hindu rashtra !!
U can try. Why not delaying. Ask modi to do in kerala bengal etc first.
Interesting to watch your pejorative talks with agreeable sighting-predictions by Mrs. Arundhati Roy. E,g. India slowly exhibiting/ moving toward Facism amidst people's oppositions.
Absolutely
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
I think India is in kind of a battle to understand it's position in the world and in its own place. India and majority of it's population is still living with a mindset of colonial veneration. They've been innately pulled into weakness of ignoring it's real potential she had for many centuries. Ms Roy, on the other hand, speaks of Yugoslavia and the Baltics as examples, but does not say anything about Scotland and Ireland at the cruel hands of the British. India must first take that into it's head to be out itself from the British disorder. Not only because Britain was it's worst enemy but also because it is India's enemy and practicing the same caste tactics on India itself in a funny way! Eg 2, Rishi Sunak was brought in as British PM for what? Who he was, what was his background in politics. So, these are tricks the Britain plays into the minds of people of India. I'm sorry, because I love your country as well as I feel pity for you guys. Thank you.
"Kashmir may not defeat India but it will consume india " how true is this that words are but vague shadows of the volumes we mean .
We will fight against Islamic extremism
That was the opinion of some extremist she quoted. I even forgot his or her name.
It is still consuming a lot out of rest of India and hopefully by implementation of
Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill of 2021, the valley will stand inclusive to its real ppl, the Pandits
Problem is Islam not kashmir when political Islam will be curtailed and law and order will be placed to check criminality by Islam everything will be OK.
I don’t agree with her. I however do agree to the point “Kashmir will consume India” but from a completely difficult perspective.
While 'Kashmir will consume india' is debatable , what is a proven fact is that 'kashmir has consumed pakistan' .
Great interview....
Love the way she has putted her views. So bold and courageous
Bold is a kind of Gold but a little may recognize it like you do it here. Congratulation!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
what's your IQ , haha
@@hindustai seriously, wasting money on education
@@dibbolistening depends on progress or backwards
After listening to this interview, Iam more confused than Karan Thapar who repeatedly claims he is confused.
We are a fascist state, we will become a fascist state, we may become a fascist state, we are on the way to becoming a fascist state, our chances of becoming a fascist state is receding, we may not become a fascist state, we will not become a fascist state because people of India will not allow it.
What is it madam?
Please decide before coming for an interview.
We should withdraw our army from the borders she says.
Which world is this lady living in?
The minute we do that, Pakistan will walk all over Kashmir, Siachen,Sir creek and God knows where else.
China which has already gobbled up Akshaychin and Tibet and within no time gobble up Arunachal pradesh, Sikkim, Nepal, Bhutan etc . They have referred to them as give fingers which is there to be taken.
In a dog eat dog world, she wants India to be a good boy and follow all the rules.
Modi's India may disintegrate in future in
future sometime
Arundhati roy's India will disintegrate tomorrow
No problem for her. She is rich and famous, will settle anywhere in the world.
What about us poor Indians?
This is the only place we have.
We cannot afford to be sheep among the wolves to be eaten again.
This country has been plundered repeatedly before.
I agree. She is living on her colonial entitelments she got when indiependent India was new and the masses did not know to speak english or become modernisesd. Now she has just lost here releveance as poeple ccan fend for themselves we dont need oxford dictorany to interpret the news and feed us as it used to be 30 - 50 years ago. though I hate it but I must agree social media has made them jobless and irrelevant
Good to see at least one beacon of intelligence in the comment section of this channel.
Mam your disclosure is really deep to the Indian root. Your foresight is sharp. Your hope in the people is encouraging. I admire your presentation. God bless you india.
Could you tell me why India broke up during Gandhi? Us waqt to RSS ka itna rutba nahi tha na hi BJP thi.
Bcuz Gandhi killed by ghodse
@@waymilky101 bhai Godshe killed him after partition... Ku6 study kr lia karo.
@@jhangirlone2401 Are bhai three dominions were created after breaking British India into three pieces. India, East Pakistan and West Pakistan.
Partation was the first and last solution tt that time.
But yes we inn1971 which party was in govt when Pakistan has been broken into two parts .
Which party created banladesh.
Every indian will never forget the symapathy of INC
And yes INDIA is incomplete without Congress and democracy
Well, there were many factors that led to it ..
To begin with india was not the complete india that we know today ..
India, when brits arrived was segregated in various princely states..
And at the time of independence, india still had many province that yet not had joined the Indian union..
Patel went and meet these leaders of province and asked them to join india and many joined india with various conditions..
That's the basic of india at the time of independence..
Muslim minority league was a part of Indian national congress and when the Muslim minority league weren't happy and doubted that they would be treated well and given equal rights ..
Mulism league request for a country of thier own and after many discussions it was agreed that they will be given tye current Pakistan and some money..
This is one of the many reason that lead to it
This is the same very reason India was broken in 1947 and now same mistake is being repeated and outcome won't be any different.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
@@NativeVsColonial Our leader Quaid E Azam Muhammad Ali jinnah once said to the Muslim of of india. You will spend your entire life to prove your loyalty to india but the hindus will never ever believe you". But you and hindus like you proved our leader words absolutely true. We are proud of our mother land pakistan thank you Jinnah. Looking forward for another Jinnah out of india.
@@MuhammadAdnan-sn1ct Don't act so naive, doing violence is in human nature but in Muhammadanism it is prescribed in its DNA, i.e. Qu'ran
Enmity, haterade towards non-Muhammadans:
🔹Qu'ran 3:28 "Let not believers take disbelievers as allies rather than believers. And whoever [of you] does that has nothing with Allah, except when taking precaution against them in prudence. And Allah warns you of Himself, and to Allah is the [final] destination."
🔹Qu'ran 3:151 "We will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve for what they have associated with Allah of which He had not sent down [any] authority. And their refuge will be the Fire, and wretched is the residence of the wrongdoers."
🔹Qu'ran 4:89 "They wish you would disbelieve as they disbelieved so you would be alike. So do not take from among them allies until they emigrate for the cause of Allah. But if they turn away, then seize them and kill them wherever you find them and take not from among them any ally or helper."
🔹Qu'ran 4:144 'O you who have believed, do not take the disbelievers as allies instead of the believers. Do you wish to give Allah against yourselves a clear case?"
🔹Qu'ran 8:39 "And fight them until there is no fitnah and [until] the religion, all of it, is for Allah. And if they cease - then indeed, Allah is Seeing of what they do."
🔹Qu'ran 8:55 "Indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are those who have disbelieved, and they will not [ever] believe."
🔹Qu'ran 8:59 "And let not those who disbelieve think they will escape. Indeed, they will not cause failure [to Allah]."
🔹Qu'ran 9:5 "And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful."
🔹Qu'ran 9:29 "Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled."
🔹Qu'ran 9:73 "O Prophet, carry out Jihād against the disbelievers and hypocrites, and be strict with them. And their abode is Jahannam (Hell), and it is an evil terminus."
🔹Qu'ran 9:123 "O you who believe, fight those disbelievers who are near you, and let them find severity in you. Know well that Allah is with the God-fearing.
🔹Qu'ran 98:6 "Indeed, they who disbelieved among the People of the Scripture and the polytheists will be in the fire of Hell, abiding eternally therein. Those are the worst of creatures."
Anything else, if you need more, check the Qu'ran.
@@NativeVsColonial ,you have no sense in what circumstances Almighty Allah instructed his Messenger but you have made up mind to prove it wrong however your generations will be wiped out of this world but you will get success.
@@NativeVsColonial u r misquoting the holy quran. Ignorant ppl like u might believe you but not those who has studied Quran and scholars like those who setting that interview. I am not surprised by your comment but fully understand that you are an agent of a godi media ran by RSS
The current dispensation, intoxicated in political power they have engineered to capture, is and will remain blind to the reality of India which is beyond their comprehension
That's where you are wrong. The current govt is way more connected to the ground realities than all you liberal elites, this is the main reason they win. Most problems in modern India exist bcz in 1947 Congress had a very fake idea of secular India. They imposed a western secular model on India when in reality the culture of Bharat has always been secular. You think India was built in 1947 but most India beleives in Bharat which has existed for thousands of years. You wanted to carve out a modern nation out of an ancient civilization, that's the main reason Congress has failed since 1970s. Imposed fake secularism, fake democracy when even Nehru was not an elected PM and there was only 1 major party for years after 1947. Fake history narrative was made to engineer the minds of the people and divide Hindus more into caste lines. Divide Hindus and join the minorities, that was the plan which blew away in such a short time. A strong nation cannot be built on a weak foundation as laid by the Congress. Modern education doesn't mean we should forget our history and culture. Mughals failed, British failed so how could congress win.
How prophetically accurate is the prediction of a far sighted creative soul! Thankfully the weather beaten masses have jumped to the rescue and relief of democracy under siege by the authoritarian Autocracy The historic mandate has delivered a fresh lease of life to our captive democracy with the opposition emerging with renewed Conviction, Confidence and Credibility with renewed moral authority to launch the missiles.
This makes me so pleased,and you have written it so well💕
Biggest opposition party having less than 100 seats is a historic mandate 🤦🏾👏🏽
"That is not even a question," only Arundhiti can say this to Thapar.
Only a jihadi k2a can believe this
Only a jihadi k2a can believe this
@@vasu7858 We can see who the terrorist in the comments is. Only a Bhagwa terrorist can say what you are saying
Millions people are those feeling future tensions but not speaking like These peoples. We should save our country and it's unity in diversity
Yupp..... let's just make half inheritance for divorced wives......
@martianspeaks they are propagandist....... just forget them...... let's take hindu muslim difference aside........the economic model wich bjp proposed will make india superpower in just few years......this government has shown so much confidence in youths........this will allow india to innovate for world........way batter than congress socialist policy were they just want to give everything for free...... support for poor to some degree is necessary but making youth depends of government jobs...... rather than doing industry job is just non sense.......we need more engineer innovating......
Best line ever, we were always brutal country......that's exactly what i was thinking when the related question was asked
True, but which country has not been brutal in one era or another?
Arvind I AM from Pakistan Don't Ever Give Up For Your Country Just Save Your Country From The Racist People India Have Genius People Like Arundati Roy So Please Keep It Up
@@truthandlie4806 you can have her and the anchor too . They don’t deserve to be india .
@@hameedjalal Hameed ,you nailed it !! 👌😂😁😁😁 Most countries have been 10 times more brutal than this country !!
We were brutal ??? To whom ??
This interview happened two years back abd karan thapar just said the same things a month ago. She was so clearly foreseeing the future.
All along Hindus lived along with Muslims. Muslims got all the benefits. Why they are not ready to have "equal" rights with Hindus? Why they want more rights than Hindus? And this Arundhati lady is saying that if you don't give Muslims more rights, the country will disintegrate and it will be broken. Why is she challenging that either Muslims will rule you or it will break?
She is one of the few who have been, since 90s, warning about the coming of age of today's religion inspired and dictatorial state
@@ajitnadgouda6079 You clearly have no idea about what's happening in the country.
She is saying "India is social contract between different ethnicities and not a nation".. That same language being spoken by none other than Rahul Gandhi.. Please be aware proud Indians🇮🇳
Absolutely similar language was also spoken by Ambedkar as he said 'India is not a nation, it is in the process of becoming one'.
All those social contracts must be respected....
@@stardust286ambedkar said India is a union of states with a quasi Federal system. That's very different from what Roy is saying.
She Arundati Roy is greatest journalist and favourite of all upressed people of india
You can never get tired of listening Arundhati Roy. She always speaks from the bottom of the heart.
Insightful interview...
People will redeem the County..
Signs of resistance visible and....
Yeah, right!
If one really wants to break up India, all they need to do is to produce a few more Arundhati Roys. No country needs enemies if they have "wellwishers" like Arundhati Roy.
Thats because u hv no critical thinking and no individuality and can only exist as puppet!
🤣🤣🤣
India is fast tracking under modi towards break 💔 up..
Did you thought that
Then you are consumed by masters ideology and have no free thought
@@h___p___2036 "Did" you "thought".??... What kind of uneducated language is that ?