We shouldn't need to ask for permission to begin with! if England wanted to leave they would without even thinking about consulting Scotland, it's basically just a huge hypocrisy.
@@kraevous What Neutral Country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is as it states, a United Kingdom and funny enough Scotland is not mentioned in the title as Scotland is not a Country as defined in international law but just a part of the UK and is no more important than the big Metropolitan County Councils in England, and England is not a Country with no separate Government and again is a part of the United Kingdom, the whole country is run by the Government of the United Kingdom.
@@DiscreetPete5050 55% against Independence, 45% for independence with an 85% voter turnout. 45% in not a small minority, and after the actions of the mismanaged UK Gov't, they are completely in the right to want to try again. Global politics are rapidly changing, and the UK splitting up would be beneficial for all parties. Smaller countries are easier, and cheaper to manage.
@@stephanblack4558 you are not even british, british don't need your opinion, british gave you an independence and made your country and now you people are trying to break britain?
I believe Hawaii and Alaska should become Independent from the USA, Mate you do not know anything about the United Kingdom and sorry to disappoint you Scotland will not get independence.
@@thesealord4693 Texas cannot secede from the Union because that ship sailed ever since THEY LOST THE CIVIL WAR. If anyone in Texas tries to push for independence for real, they will be imprisoned. That is why politicians only talk about it but they never, ever care to actually carry it out. Even Conservative Supreme Court justice, Antonin Scalia, shot down the possibility of Texas gaining ever independence. Not seeing a legal way how that could ever be accomplished. In fact, anyone trying to destroy the Union would be arrested. I dare any politician in Texas to even try it. They don't have the balls.
Not realy, as the majority of Scottish people do not want independence, before making silly comments you need to live in the UK and understand what hand feeds Scotland, and it is the UK Government.
@@DiskusGames so what ? why should one part of a country get a vote to leave? does the shetland islands get to vote on independence and take all their massive oil and gas reserves with them ?? exactly it’s silly
The UK is the ""UNION" and Scotland is not run by " ENGLAND", England has no Government but is run by large County Councils answerable to the United Kingdom Government, Scotland like England, Wales and Northern Ireland is run by the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland do your research mate.
@@peterwilliamallen1063 the united kingdom government is run by the english so scotland does answer to england. they cant even hold their own referendum
No means no and you can whinge for the rest of your sad lives independence is gone forever, Jimmy krankie can't sort your drugs problem out never mind independence the latest poll is 57 v 42 against independence, krankie will resign soon then Scotland can move on.
@rationalsikh6950 the chances of Scotland leaving the UK have gone forever I,m afraid its just Jimmy krankie,s pipe dream as Scotland can't survive without Westminster and she needs to get her act together and pay back the millions she's taken from the Scottish tax payers and the eu have all told her that Scotland would never get back into the eu because their mounting debt and biggest drug problem in Europe so the best option for the Scottish people would be to jail sturgeon and get a party in who can sort the massive problem she's created.just check out Andrew Neil,s interviews with her it was a total car crash as he ripped her to shreds with his questions, she had no answers ,honestly take a look well worth it.
My Grandmother came to Canada from Scotland in 1908. Until now, I've always been proud of my Scottish heritage. But Scotland has become way too woke. Far-Left politicians have ruined it.
Freedom? Don't they already have freedom? What more freedom can they have? Separating from the UK is different than getting freedom. If they were being oppressed like in China I can see a call for freedom but they are not.
@@ariesrcn Are you serious? For a start well won't be paying towards this 'union', and a bonus is we will have full control over our laws unlike now where a foreign government gets to tell us what laws we are "allowed" powers to. Obviously this has never once happened the other way around though, there would be an uproar if that ever happened...
@@toolbaggers Ukraine also is under constant bombardment of missiles and drones, last I checked Scotland is not under attack. But lets break this down farther, why stop at Scotland being separate and separate it into clans again. Where each clan have their own lands and laws.
Come on Scotland, home of the world's strongest bravest men. Take what's yours! You won't get what you deserve by tiptoeing around and asking politely.
Anne here's a test of your sincerity: instead of just inciting other people to violence, are you willing: 1) To join a female fighting unit and sacrifice your life for the cause? 2) Or alternatively, offer up your money so that the Natsis can do more than what the rules of polite democracy allow?
Also, a woman's fight is closer to home. We wouldn't "need" 500k economic migrants every year if so-called "old stock Canadians" were having bigger families -- and younger than they are -- maybe one day we won't be squashed under central banks usury and be able to achieve what our grandparents and parents took for granted.
@@augustopinochet1670 leave politics to grown ups ha! What a joke Scotland doesn't need any bureaucrats from different countries telling them what they can and can't do. With funny remarks like that you must be a real clown. Plus it certainly doesn't take a grown up to try and lie, cheat and steal if anything it's pretty childish actually.
@@augustopinochet1670 Politics are for evil shallow ignorant worldly busy bodies who love drama. You couldnt even tolerate this dudes small joke. Putrid human being.
Speaking as a Scot and long time independence supporter I disagree with your opinion that the Royal family is “demonic”. The Royal family has supported Scotland in many ways and there is no reason to link the monarchy with independence.
@@alasdairblack393 i am from nova scotia our which is new scotland and I have much proof in our counrty the royal family did murder and theif of people land and their genocide continues in our lands through the courts run crown everything you are not seeing our perspective and if you look it up you can easily see the murders and genocide and it contines
@@alasdairblack393 our coat of arms is the lion and unicorn the unicorn is from new scotland and they removed it from most everything and hide the history and reason why but it is to do with the powerful magic that came here from scotland even in university the "crown illumi and cults which there are many the removal of the unicorn goes deep and the royal families run human trafficking genocide through many avenues i only love the fun of it and lady diana i love her and i undersstand we are grown to worship her but sadly their crimes have been proven in many places simple as that
@@NoName-hg6cc just because you think they are doesn't mean they are. They are not. clearly you don't know what a colony is. Anyway, it was Scotland's king that became the king of England as well. So if anything England is a colony of Scotland going by your distorted logic
@@ironblu4110 Just because you deny it it doesn't mean it's true. If you studied you'd know theyare colonies That king moved to London, which lord today over Wales, Scotland and NI
@@NoName-hg6cc they are literally not colonies. Stop being a troll. NI voted to remain in the union. You seem like a person who blamed England for all the world's problems rather than take responsibility yourself.
I am American, so maybe i am a bit biased, but YES!!! Scotland should declare independence! I can't speak for all Americans, but i would support you guys 😃 Any population that votes to leave whatever authority they are governed by should have the right to leave, thats how democracy and voting works. If you all want to leave the United Kingdom you have every right to do that. Wish you the best 🤗
@michelhebert1099 Not really. Long term, it is the US south that is currently keeping the USA from immediately diving off the deep end into SJW leftism.
@@doger6531 Sorry Doger, no one cried when India and Pakistan went Independent as they were a Victorian drain on our Economy and were a separate Continent of no use to Great Britain. Scotland is totally different it is not a separate continent but is an integral part of the United Kingdom and has been for 100's of years, and NO it will not get it's independence, do you not watch any news or read papers, this debate was put to both the UK supreme Court and the Scottish Advocate Court, both the highest courts in the UK and Scotland for the Independence question to be judged on whether the Scottish Devolved Government had the right to call an election with out the UK Governments permission, the case took 6 weeks to go over and the result was that as Scotland is not in a conflict with England ie at War, and is being treated adequately and is not an independent state under UK rule, the Scottish devolved Government CAN not have an Independent Vote or become Independent until the ruling government of said Country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, Westminster gives it's consent to such a referendum. This was verified and agreed to by the Scottish Advocate Court and it was stated that the Devolved Government of Scotland has only jurisdiction to govern what goes on in Scotland and has no political power to decide anything international to do with Scotland as those decisions can only be made by the UK Government alone, so NO Scotland will not become independent unless the UK Government allows it, and two of the most influential and powerful millionaire brothers in Scotland have warned Nicoler Sturgeon tho give up on the Independence thing and concentrate on running Scotland.
@@doger6531 Nope, no Brits Cried and try googling about Winston Churchill and India and you will find that he was all for helping an Independent India out,
@@RJ-wc4nn Yeah not at all, it is not up to the people it is up to the Government of the UK that has been paying Scotland millions of pounds in hand outs and devolution was not for independence but so Scotland could be run from Scotland instead of London plus there are more people in Scotland believe it or not that do not want independence than want it, so how are you going to afford your health care under independence as the Scottish NHS will finish and in the Republic of Ireland it cost 300 euros just to see your Doctor.
@@DiscreetPete5050 Hi bud, I’m Scottish too, but raised in Canada. I’d argue that if brexit had been voted on first, than Scotland would be independent now.
I do understand holding a referendum every 10 years to see if you still want to stay in a country is not cheap. But since it was held they left the EU which is a big change.
Keep Fighting Scotland 🏴!!! No Retreat No 👎 Surrender Fight Fight for your Freedom. I can’t believe you guys are still kept captive by the English as if it was still the Medieval Times 😏It is not those days anymore it’s 2023.
@@thepatriot4076 mate that was literally just the beginning. After America the Brits were free to set it's eyes on India and the rest of Asia. Get your history right please
@@thepatriot4076 I guess actually collapsed in 1947 after India get independence.The King or Queen never have an official name of British emperor or empress but an Indian one
I don't know where you get your information from, but Canada is an Independent Country it's only connection with the UK now is it's membership of the Commonwealth of Nations who's head is King Charles 3rd
It was same for Ireland but then things turn other way around when people realize that hegemony is in place not a democracy. If they want independency, they will get one, is not about stereotype separatism but something Human beings are submitted by belonging to different tribes!
I have Scottish ancestry, in 1776 America gained their independence from England, I'm here in the US cheering for Scotland, dont ask their permission, take your freedom
@@ironblu4110 Its a comment under a RUclips video, I will continue to say what I want, "please stay out of it" pretty sure your not my father random person on the internet
@@AmericanWireman It really bugs me when Americans say they have UK ancestry and are therefore entitled to interfere with quite complicated and nuanced political issues like this. Because normally the ancestry is a least 100-200 years ago. Have you visited or lived in the UK before?
@MsMissy It will, and so will North Ireland get her freedom. Soon UK will be a past tense with only Englandistan left. You know what? London probally will have a new name: NewMumbai 🙃
@@DiscreetPete5050 It's been 10 years and this was before Brexit. Also please learn to speak for yourself, only statistics and the referenda can speak for the majority.
I agree, I pray for the UK to get better as a whole in the upcoming years, if we don't rejoin the EU I'd be surprised but as long as we rejoin the EU at some point I'm happy staying in the UK. It just wouldn't be the same if Scotland left. There isn't really a good plan for independence anyway at the moment and it would literally be a gamble so it's no even worth it unless Scotland wants Brexit the sequel.
When in the course of human events. It becomes necessary to dissolve the the political bands which have connected them with another and to Assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the laws of nature and of nature's God entitle them a face respect to the opinions of the mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.
The SNP don`t do maths. England`s population is over ten times that of Scotland. This they think is undemocratic. Imagine their surprise when they find out that the EU has an even larger population.
@@DiscreetPete5050 I'm from Scotland also and no we want to leave hence why we keep voting SNP and unionists fail even when they all work together and vote Tory 😏
Scotland must fight for it's freedom against the tyranny of the crown and it's lackeys. If the people want it they'll have to work for it just as the other colonies did in the past!
in 1707, England agreed to give Scotland money to pay off its debts, and both countries' parliaments passed the Acts of Union to become one nation..they wasn't forced like people think 😄
So UK is cool to separate from the EU but not cool for Scotland to get out of the UK?
Oil...
Yep. That's it. It's not a union at all. It's an ownership.
It's a federation
YES, not so much the mother of all parliaments eh
@@niklasvilhelm7247 the UK isn't a federation 😂
If the Scottish people want independence they should be allowed to vote for it.
We shouldn't need to ask for permission to begin with! if England wanted to leave they would without even thinking about consulting Scotland, it's basically just a huge hypocrisy.
They voted to stay in 2014.
@@elaineg5301 because uk was a part of EU back then
@@elaineg5301 Because they were lied to, told that the only way to stay in the EU was to remain in the UK.
@@elaineg5301 What About Todya Duffar Live in Today
The UK is a sinking ship
@msmissy6888 lol You're hotels are filled with barbarians, you cant deport grapists and murderers and have no control over your borders....
Yes, it sunk, very irrelevant. Yery ripe.
@MsMissy you're everywhere in these comments. It gives insecure.
@MsMissy Get a grip on yourself already...
@MsMissy You clearly haven't; get a grip on yourself already...
Full Support to Scotland 🇨🇭🤝🏴
Well it wont be getting Independence full stop.
Support for break up you to four 😍
@@armanamini2133 well sorry it ain't happening
So much for a neutral country 😂
@@kraevous What Neutral Country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is as it states, a United Kingdom and funny enough Scotland is not mentioned in the title as Scotland is not a Country as defined in international law but just a part of the UK and is no more important than the big Metropolitan County Councils in England, and England is not a Country with no separate Government and again is a part of the United Kingdom, the whole country is run by the Government of the United Kingdom.
Denied? What happens to democracy? US and the rest of Europe should support Scotland independence.
There was about 8 countries in the Europe out on a march that night too to support Scotland
How?
And what about Catalonia 💀💀
Nothing to do with the US or the rest of Europe. Its for UK courts to decide.
@@jackd9928This is meant to be a voluntary union
Scotland is fighting for freedom from England for centuries .
It is just about the time , they get it.
They should just say "F" the UK; I would...
@@DiscreetPete5050 Just like the "majority" voted for the Canadian PM?
@@hairydude4020 Don’t like democracy, no problem there are plenty of countries you can go to if you don’t want freedom or a voice.
there is NO freedom in its proper context when man is Godless- NOT godless- himSELF
@@jcr-studiosThe government wasn't elected by the majority of eligible canadians; you do understand what a "democracy" is, don't you?
Scotland can't hold an independence referendum but the UK Conservatives can tank the economy and shift through multiple PM's in less than 6 months.
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@DiscreetPete5050 55% against Independence, 45% for independence with an 85% voter turnout. 45% in not a small minority, and after the actions of the mismanaged UK Gov't, they are completely in the right to want to try again. Global politics are rapidly changing, and the UK splitting up would be beneficial for all parties. Smaller countries are easier, and cheaper to manage.
@@DiscreetPete5050 you are correct, thank you.
@@stephanblack4558 Geo doesn't even have a point...
@@stephanblack4558 you are not even british, british don't need your opinion, british gave you an independence and made your country and now you people are trying to break britain?
Full Support to Scotland from USA 🇺🇸
Texas independence ✊
I believe Hawaii and Alaska should become Independent from the USA, Mate you do not know anything about the United Kingdom and sorry to disappoint you Scotland will not get independence.
@@thesealord4693 Texas cannot secede from the Union because that ship sailed ever since THEY LOST THE CIVIL WAR.
If anyone in Texas tries to push for independence for real, they will be imprisoned. That is why politicians only talk about it but they never, ever care to actually carry it out.
Even Conservative Supreme Court justice, Antonin Scalia, shot down the possibility of Texas gaining ever independence. Not seeing a legal way how that could ever be accomplished.
In fact, anyone trying to destroy the Union would be arrested. I dare any politician in Texas to even try it. They don't have the balls.
….From the country which doesn’t allow it’s states to leave there union.
Yes love from India also, Scotland should get independence from UK like Britain divided india 70 years before .
Are you serious!? You need permission 😆 Mr Wallace would not stand. He'd be yelling Freeeeeeeeedoooooooooom!
This is what Ukraine is also fighting for right now. FREEDOM from a BULLY neighbour!!!
Send Javelin missiles and HIMARS to Scotland!!! F U Charles!!!!
If only it was funny.
@@casperwallace9685 funny to me
Support to Scotland from China.
there must be some English come to talk about the prejudice of China politics.
Support to Hong Kong from The UK
this would be funny if it were not so tragic, a dying empire attempts to hold onto its possessions
This
Scotland was a very active participant of the empire and also voted no to independence once already...
Do as you wish Scotland 🏴🆓
if anything this court ruling will have the effect of pushing more scottish people to support independence, it's really a gift for the nationalists
Up to 56% all ready
already voted, can’t have a vote every 8 years
@@Armed-Forever And why not? Circumstances have changed a lot since 2014.
Not realy, as the majority of Scottish people do not want independence, before making silly comments you need to live in the UK and understand what hand feeds Scotland, and it is the UK Government.
@@DiskusGames so what ? why should one part of a country get a vote to leave? does the shetland islands get to vote on independence and take all their massive oil and gas reserves with them ?? exactly it’s silly
freedom!
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
Sour grapes lmao
@@DiscreetPete5050 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 yeah
Colonies of Britain.
The UK is not a "union". Scotland is basically run by another country, England. How can a proud(?) nation accept this?
You get thats why its driving for independence means.... its not accepting it. right.
The UK is the ""UNION" and Scotland is not run by " ENGLAND", England has no Government but is run by large County Councils answerable to the United Kingdom Government, Scotland like England, Wales and Northern Ireland is run by the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland do your research mate.
@@peterwilliamallen1063 the united kingdom government is run by the english so scotland does answer to england. they cant even hold their own referendum
Just like California in America right 💀💀💀
Keep going my Scottish brothers and sisters. Fight for the freedom you deserve. We will not be silenced.
Québec too
No means no and you can whinge for the rest of your sad lives independence is gone forever, Jimmy krankie can't sort your drugs problem out never mind independence the latest poll is 57 v 42 against independence, krankie will resign soon then Scotland can move on.
@@dominichall5326
Scotland will leave uk, it’s bound to happen. Brexit slaughtered UK
@rationalsikh6950 the chances of Scotland leaving the UK have gone forever I,m afraid its just Jimmy krankie,s pipe dream as Scotland can't survive without Westminster and she needs to get her act together and pay back the millions she's taken from the Scottish tax payers and the eu have all told her that Scotland would never get back into the eu because their mounting debt and biggest drug problem in Europe so the best option for the Scottish people would be to jail sturgeon and get a party in who can sort the massive problem she's created.just check out Andrew Neil,s interviews with her it was a total car crash as he ripped her to shreds with his questions, she had no answers ,honestly take a look well worth it.
@@yannislaurin5438no
Free Scotland
Free Wales
Free Northern ireland
End England's tyrannical rule!
I agree. England is true evil.
Clearly you don't understand how the UK works. You just fall back on the age old excuse of blaming England for all your problems
You forget about Cornwall they where a nation once or do you not actually care
@@dyhale I didn't forget. I just don't see the relevance. If you go back far enough I could talk about Mercia and Northumbria etc
The fact that this is still a thing is unbelievable...21 century colonialism
Scotland should just do as it pleases...
@@hairydude4020 William Wallace is dead.
@@nomorewar4189 What are you yammering on about?
@@hairydude4020 use your brain - that should help - maybe not in your case.
@@nomorewar4189 Says the one yammering on about William Wallace...
Proud to be part Scottish
My Grandmother came to Canada from Scotland in 1908.
Until now, I've always been proud of my Scottish heritage.
But Scotland has become way too woke. Far-Left politicians have ruined it.
Go Scotland go ! Go get your freedom at long last!
Freedom? Don't they already have freedom? What more freedom can they have? Separating from the UK is different than getting freedom. If they were being oppressed like in China I can see a call for freedom but they are not.
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
This is what Ukraine is also fighting for right now. FREEDOM from a BULLY neighbour!!!
Send Javelin missiles and HIMARS to Scotland!!! F U Charles!!!!
@@ariesrcn Are you serious? For a start well won't be paying towards this 'union', and a bonus is we will have full control over our laws unlike now where a foreign government gets to tell us what laws we are "allowed" powers to. Obviously this has never once happened the other way around though, there would be an uproar if that ever happened...
@@toolbaggers Ukraine also is under constant bombardment of missiles and drones, last I checked Scotland is not under attack. But lets break this down farther, why stop at Scotland being separate and separate it into clans again. Where each clan have their own lands and laws.
Come on Scotland, home of the world's strongest bravest men. Take what's yours! You won't get what you deserve by tiptoeing around and asking politely.
Anne here's a test of your sincerity: instead of just inciting other people to violence, are you willing:
1) To join a female fighting unit and sacrifice your life for the cause?
2) Or alternatively, offer up your money so that the Natsis can do more than what the rules of polite democracy allow?
@@Jon.Morimoto 😉 Scottish women are strong AF too.
@@anneonnamouse5496 Weak. My questions were specific and clear. Your refusal to answer says everything about your character.
@@Jon.Morimoto nice try, CSIS. You think I'd admit to anything incriminating? They aren't paying you high enough.
Also, a woman's fight is closer to home. We wouldn't "need" 500k economic migrants every year if so-called "old stock Canadians" were having bigger families -- and younger than they are -- maybe one day we won't be squashed under central banks usury and be able to achieve what our grandparents and parents took for granted.
Free scotland free Falkland Island
FREEDOM! Best wishes Scotland. Get in touch with your inner William Wallace's and find your independence.
Go watch movies and leave politics to the grown ups.
@@augustopinochet1670 leave politics to grown ups ha! What a joke Scotland doesn't need any bureaucrats from different countries telling them what they can and can't do. With funny remarks like that you must be a real clown. Plus it certainly doesn't take a grown up to try and lie, cheat and steal if anything it's pretty childish actually.
@@augustopinochet1670 Politics are for evil shallow ignorant worldly busy bodies who love drama. You couldnt even tolerate this dudes small joke. Putrid human being.
LOL!
Sturgeon: Independence
Also Sturgeon: Let's join thr EUSSR.
@@augustopinochet1670 Time to pull your head out from wherever it is you have it stuck...
I support Scotland
My family will do a freedom tour in Scotland if they get to do a referendum! Support Scotland independence.
No
@@ironblu4110 Unless Scotland is a dictatorship and you are the king, you can not say no.
@@watchman835 maybe I am the king
@@ironblu4110 Make up your mind before you talk again.
Why care what the UK court says...
@@DiscreetPete5050 This changes nothing that I've stated...
@@hairydude4020 It’s a bot
Love how politicians are talking about consent... I certainly didn't get to uphold my consent on a certain something.
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
Always has to be that person to make a comparison to something that has nothing to do with the topic.
@@Gaetano.94 Does it hurt your feelings or something?
@@DiscreetPete5050 so you haven't been around for the fallout of the referendum?
A lot has changed the last 8 years, you are against democracy
@@neil6104 Scots are British lol
Those who make peaceful revolution impossible, make violent revolution inevitable.
they voted already
@@Armed-Forever under false promises.
Independence for Scotland break from demonic royal family and being the unicorn back long live Scotland!
Speaking as a Scot and long time independence supporter I disagree with your opinion that the Royal family is “demonic”. The Royal family has supported Scotland in many ways and there is no reason to link the monarchy with independence.
@@alasdairblack393 The "royal" bloodline should have been ended ages ago...
@@alasdairblack393 i am from nova scotia our which is new scotland and I have much proof in our counrty the royal family did murder and theif of people land and their genocide continues in our lands through the courts run crown everything you are not seeing our perspective and if you look it up you can easily see the murders and genocide and it contines
@@alasdairblack393 our coat of arms is the lion and unicorn the unicorn is from new scotland and they removed it from most everything and hide the history and reason why but it is to do with the powerful magic that came here from scotland even in university the "crown illumi and cults which there are many the removal of the unicorn goes deep and the royal families run human trafficking genocide through many avenues i only love the fun of it and lady diana i love her and i undersstand we are grown to worship her but sadly their crimes have been proven in many places simple as that
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
Brexit was a piece of arrogant idiocy.
Just like the West and canada
@@yannislaurin5438 Yours is a typically mindless retort specialised in by the Kremlin propaganda aparatus.
@@oraclex2976 Lol no it's just true
England doesn't want to let the first and now last colonies (Scotland, Wales, NI) go
Wrong because they are not colonies
@@ironblu4110 They are
@@NoName-hg6cc just because you think they are doesn't mean they are. They are not. clearly you don't know what a colony is. Anyway, it was Scotland's king that became the king of England as well. So if anything England is a colony of Scotland going by your distorted logic
@@ironblu4110 Just because you deny it it doesn't mean it's true. If you studied you'd know theyare colonies
That king moved to London, which lord today over Wales, Scotland and NI
@@NoName-hg6cc they are literally not colonies. Stop being a troll. NI voted to remain in the union. You seem like a person who blamed England for all the world's problems rather than take responsibility yourself.
scotland should get their freedom👍
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@DiscreetPete5050 Now today is 2022
I am American, so maybe i am a bit biased, but YES!!! Scotland should declare independence!
I can't speak for all Americans, but i would support you guys 😃
Any population that votes to leave whatever authority they are governed by should have the right to leave, thats how democracy and voting works. If you all want to leave the United Kingdom you have every right to do that.
Wish you the best 🤗
I support Scotland 100%
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@DiscreetPete5050 Don’t you believe that maybe after Brexit things have changed?
I don't support it as a Scottish
We support independent Scotland
No country can forbid a territory from being independent if that's what they want. The U.S. didn't ask permission to England.
We should avoid paying tax just like the Americans
Uh yes they can. The US prohibited its southern states from leaving. The UK can do the same with Scotland.
@@FinalLugiaGuardian And look at the mess it created.
@michelhebert1099 Not really. Long term, it is the US south that is currently keeping the USA from immediately diving off the deep end into SJW leftism.
What's the difference from Ukraine . Oh yeh Scotland isn.t the most corrup- country on Earth !
free Scotland, love from India.
Well sorry to disappoint you, Scotland aint getting Independence.Greetings from the UK
@@peterwilliamallen1063They will one day and you Brit’s will cry just like you did when India got independence lol
@@doger6531 Sorry Doger, no one cried when India and Pakistan went Independent as they were a Victorian drain on our Economy and were a separate Continent of no use to Great Britain. Scotland is totally different it is not a separate continent but is an integral part of the United Kingdom and has been for 100's of years, and NO it will not get it's independence, do you not watch any news or read papers, this debate was put to both the UK supreme Court and the Scottish Advocate Court, both the highest courts in the UK and Scotland for the Independence question to be judged on whether the Scottish Devolved Government had the right to call an election with out the UK Governments permission, the case took 6 weeks to go over and the result was that as Scotland is not in a conflict with England ie at War, and is being treated adequately and is not an independent state under UK rule, the Scottish devolved Government CAN not have an Independent Vote or become Independent until the ruling government of said Country, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, Westminster gives it's consent to such a referendum. This was verified and agreed to by the Scottish Advocate Court and it was stated that the Devolved Government of Scotland has only jurisdiction to govern what goes on in Scotland and has no political power to decide anything international to do with Scotland as those decisions can only be made by the UK Government alone, so NO Scotland will not become independent unless the UK Government allows it, and two of the most influential and powerful millionaire brothers in Scotland have warned Nicoler Sturgeon tho give up on the Independence thing and concentrate on running Scotland.
@@peterwilliamallen1063 Nah Winston Churchill was a Brit and he totally was crazy about making sure India stayed so yes a lot of you Brit’s did cry
@@doger6531 Nope, no Brits Cried and try googling about Winston Churchill and India and you will find that he was all for helping an Independent India out,
Full support to Scotland from India 🙏🙏
Well they are not getting Independance.
@@peterwilliamallen1063 yeah not for now but people will fight and will get it for sure soon.
@@RJ-wc4nn Yeah not at all, it is not up to the people it is up to the Government of the UK that has been paying Scotland millions of pounds in hand outs and devolution was not for independence but so Scotland could be run from Scotland instead of London plus there are more people in Scotland believe it or not that do not want independence than want it, so how are you going to afford your health care under independence as the Scottish NHS will finish and in the Republic of Ireland it cost 300 euros just to see your Doctor.
@@peterwilliamallen1063thanks once again to our expert on the plight of scottish independence- mr Peter William Allen
Not a union of equal nations then.
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@DiscreetPete5050 Hi bud, I’m Scottish too, but raised in Canada.
I’d argue that if brexit had been voted on first, than Scotland would be independent now.
We will never give up the fight.
The fight to tear the UK apart and rip it to shreds? Wow
@@ironblu4110 sounds like a dream ngl
@@ironblu4110 perhaps
Freedom!
support to Scotland from China。
They are a people with their own unique history and culture. They’re already their own country, no excuse to deny them independence.
I do understand holding a referendum every 10 years to see if you still want to stay in a country is not cheap. But since it was held they left the EU which is a big change.
Seriously? If Scotland was independent, they would fall.
@@kingbilly38 Do you typically just make things up?
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@kingbilly38 Rangers supporter scared of losing the union flag, no?
Freedom!!!
They should separate just because of that!
Just hold the referendum anyway. What are they gonna do?
Full Support Scotland idenpedence and freedom from Serbia!!!
🇷🇸🤝🏻🏴
🇷🇸💙🇷🇸
Com on Scotland
Keep Fighting Scotland 🏴!!! No Retreat No 👎 Surrender Fight Fight for your Freedom. I can’t believe you guys are still kept captive by the English as if it was still the Medieval Times 😏It is not those days anymore it’s 2023.
Scotland would get independence from UK, love from India
🤣🤣🤣🤣
.... and then people wonder why they'd want independence. What a joke.
Freedom !!! I will climax if Scotland got its independence.
No climax for you then because Scotland is staying in the UK.
Please stay with uk
Will support Scotland.....Go for Freedom and a better economic reality with Independence from England.
Keep fighting for independence..
Good.
Scotland should just tell the uk to "F" off...
Take your independence Scotland… don’t ask… just take it!
The British empire is done😂
The empire died in 1776 when France and the American colonist sent the red coats back to little England
@@thepatriot4076 mate that was literally just the beginning. After America the Brits were free to set it's eyes on India and the rest of Asia. Get your history right please
@@thepatriot4076 I guess actually collapsed in 1947 after India get independence.The King or Queen never have an official name of British emperor or empress but an Indian one
Give them their independence!
Not really independence if there going to join the eu after leaving
Love the idea hope Scotland gets what they truly desire Canada is trying to go for full Independence since the queen passing
What are you talking about?
Canada has be hijacked by Trudeau and the WEF🙄
I don't know where you get your information from, but Canada is an Independent Country it's only connection with the UK now is it's membership of the Commonwealth of Nations who's head is King Charles 3rd
Do you support Quebec？
@@linderoes7832 Quebec will not become independent of Canada for the same reason Scotland will not become independent of the UK.
Good, dissolve even the Scottish parliament
Free Scotland
If Scotland became independent would it be a republic or would they have their own royalty?
Republic, unless they choose a new monarch
Scotland is not big on Royalty, they like Scotland as a holiday home. We might let them come up...its up for discussion.
Were holding a raffle thing we.just pick anyone who's Scottish,
No scottish and English crowns have caused so much misery and division through class scotland must be wise in the future
The tendency is separation and that will be achieved naturally if no allowed
It was same for Ireland but then things turn other way around when people realize that hegemony is in place not a democracy. If they want independency, they will get one, is not about stereotype separatism but something Human beings are submitted by belonging to different tribes!
This is what Ukraine is also fighting for right now. FREEDOM from a BULLY neighbour!!!
Send Javelin missiles and HIMARS to Scotland!!! F U Charles!!!!
Thats your problem! Don't ask!
I have Scottish ancestry, in 1776 America gained their independence from England, I'm here in the US cheering for Scotland, dont ask their permission, take your freedom
Stay out of it please
And the US gained independence from the British empire, NOT England
@@ironblu4110 Its a comment under a RUclips video, I will continue to say what I want, "please stay out of it" pretty sure your not my father random person on the internet
How do you view Hawaii and Puerto Rico？
@@AmericanWireman It really bugs me when Americans say they have UK ancestry and are therefore entitled to interfere with quite complicated and nuanced political issues like this. Because normally the ancestry is a least 100-200 years ago. Have you visited or lived in the UK before?
they must vote no
Liberty and Independence.
People keep talking as if England invaded Scotland. No, Scotland invaded England.
LOL what? You mean briefly in retaliation?
No the Scots repeatedly invaded England and finally succeeded in taking the crown. England did not colonise scotland.@@hmu05366
I am William Wallace and I say to my countrymen “Freedom”!!!
Independence for Scotland no uk I don’t care
‘FREEDOM!’…..
🏴 + NS, send boats ⚔
This is going to backfire.
@MsMissy It will, and so will North Ireland get her freedom. Soon UK will be a past tense with only Englandistan left. You know what? London probally will have a new name: NewMumbai 🙃
@MsMissy It will if the people decide to make it; you appear extremely naive...
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
after all this time, the people still stand!
Independence is not won in court!
Uh-oh UK's in (trouble) now!
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
Iam Scottish I hate independence 🤮🤮🤮🤮
WE WANT FREEDOM FROM UK..
Scotland should be sovereign and NI reunited with Ireland. Fullstop.
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
@@DiscreetPete5050 It's been 10 years and this was before Brexit. Also please learn to speak for yourself, only statistics and the referenda can speak for the majority.
@@DiscreetPete5050 You have not kept up with the news then, SNP have been voted in the last 10 elections. Do please read more.
No.
Full stop.
Great news 👏
if the one in 2014 NO . was dismissed by us true patriots of SCOTLAND why should a YES be any different?
The United Kingdom should stick together, perhaps Northern Ireland should gain independence but as a Scottish citizen I wish not for such separation.
I agree, I pray for the UK to get better as a whole in the upcoming years, if we don't rejoin the EU I'd be surprised but as long as we rejoin the EU at some point I'm happy staying in the UK. It just wouldn't be the same if Scotland left. There isn't really a good plan for independence anyway at the moment and it would literally be a gamble so it's no even worth it unless Scotland wants Brexit the sequel.
@bhanksshuggy5158 The UK is not rejoining The European Union. and Scotland is not leaving the UK.
Those were once in a generation referendums.
Scotland must stop asking permission, They are not our master's, If it is good enough for NI them Scotland be part of the EU can Join too.
They can't stop Scotland, poms need to but out,there are loop holes.
Shame England, shame Charles, shame...
Agreed the monarchy is a joke
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
I mean with brexit, they should be allowed to vote if they want to be in the uk or independent.
most in england are ok with them leaving so not sure why it should be a big deal.
are you the same Charlie who is telling the similar things about Quebec leaving Chinada?
@@motorola9374 that would be my grandma
and yet, it is. They even tried to love bomb us in 2014...
When in the course of human events. It becomes necessary to dissolve the the political bands which have connected them with another and to
Assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the laws of nature and of nature's God entitle them a face respect to the opinions of the mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.
God speed on your path to self government and freedom
We already did this. its called canada. lets dew it again lads
If Scotland goes independent in the UK will become more weaker than already is 😑
Don’t go down the road of Never-endums. 🇨🇦
The SNP don`t do maths. England`s population is over ten times that of Scotland. This they think is undemocratic. Imagine their surprise when they find out that the EU has an even larger population.
The SNP are basicly all hypocrites.
In uk they have no say. In EU they will
Cut them free, rebuild Hadrians Wall, we don't care!!! Ban wee Jimmy cranky from crossing the border 🤣
Hadrian's wall is in England dummy
@@DiscreetPete5050 I'm from Scotland also and no we want to leave hence why we keep voting SNP and unionists fail even when they all work together and vote Tory 😏
@@DiscreetPete5050 So?
You act like this is some sort of insult, but thats what we want
Scotland must fight for it's freedom against the tyranny of the crown and it's lackeys.
If the people want it they'll have to work for it just as the other colonies did in the past!
in 1707, England agreed to give Scotland money to pay off its debts, and both countries' parliaments passed the Acts of Union to become one nation..they wasn't forced like people think 😄
Not a good idea Scotland …….. I was born under a Union Jack!
Uuuu, UK is not strongest country
How many years has Scotland been trying to become independent? 300?
they tried in 2016 but failed because most of them voted to remain part of britain
@@MrSartorius1 Because we were told lies about Brexit
@@MrSartorius1 2014
Scots didn't get a vote which dragged them into this Union.