Citroën C5 Aircross vs BMW X1 Comparison - French-German War | MotorBeam
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июл 2024
- In today's video, we compare the Citroën C5 Aircross and the BMW X1. Both the vehicles have a FWD layout, both have a 2.0-litre diesel engine and both come equipped with an 8-speed automatic and a host of other equipment. Which one out of these two makes more sense, we find out.
Join The FK-R tribe - www.fk-r.com
Become a #MotorBeamer: bit.ly/MotorBeamer and join the #MBSquad
Meet us - www.motorbeam.com/join-us/
Visit our website: www.motorbeam.com
Follow us on Instagram: / motorbeam
Like us on Facebook: / motorbeam
Follow us on Twitter: / motorbeam
0:00 Introduction
0:55 Exteriors
4:23 X1 Rear Seat
6:05 C5 Rear Seat
7:38 Boot Space
9:04 X1 Performance
11:37 X1 Ride Quality
13:24 C5 Performance
15:04 C5 Ride Quality
17:56 Bottle Holder Test
20:44 Verdict 
Авто/Мото
Hello #MotorBeamers, hope you enjoyed this video! Which comparo do you want to see next?
CELERIO VS TIAGO.
i20 vs polo
Citron c5 always French one is looking gorgeous👍
Nice and worthy comparison
C5 vs Countryman
This is the old motorbeam style. I don't like the new style of comparing on laptop. That's why the audience had decreased too. I hope motorbeam notices this
Have noted this feedback but sometimes it has to be done in the studio when all the cars or bikes needed for a comparo aren’t available on the same dates.
It still doesn't have a facelift model in India
We bought a X1 recently and omg. We tried driving the merc and Volvo but the punch and power that bmw gives is unmatched! Definitely sheer driving experience. But if ur looking for only pure luxury then merc is the way to go.
Adjust the front seats accordingly
15:34 The guys 5"5 and he has leg room of a Innovas 3rd row...
Also higher variants of the X1 gets a kick to open boot.
The X1 gets a 2L Turbo petrol with 220HP
Try Fortuner vs Mercedes GLA next time! They’re both blasts of their own segments and are cross priced as well!
Loude! Kuch bhi!
Good suggestion. Or should we do Fortuner vs A-Class Limo? SUV vs sedan comparo?
@@MotorBeam I guess the GLA would make a better choice as it’s also spacious enough to call it and compare it with a SUV like fortuner plus it’s a personal query as well, we’re a family of four plus a dog and we’re looking for a comfortable car and as we’re searching for it we’ve came around to a point where no channel whatsoever has covered anything like that mentioning “pet friendly” as also an aspect when considering the next “member” ( car ) to the family😊
@@iubxx Just get the Legender if you want to be tension free. Its way more reliable than Merc. It is way more spacious than GLA and you will have a cheap cost of ownership 👍😀
You can consider GLA if you want more features , Rich interiors etc.
🤣🤣3rd class cars
Citroen is doing it wright.
Those who buy an SUV like this usually want a nice comfortable ride, and Citroen nailed it!
Really tried hard to prove Citroen is better than X1....okay....
Because it is
BMW X1 is a luxury car in budget
While Citreon's is actually a high end BUDGET car. The customer who desires a BMW will never buy a Citroen.
X1 is not great. X5 is more features and comfortable
@@shiajinn2509 and customers who desire a Citroen will never buy a BMW. Its swings and roundabouts
Next time, include other ownership related metrics for comparison - not just the usual things like 0 - 100, leg room, mileage etc. Things that will make or break a buying decision are the following (Not all but a good starting list).
1. After Sales service
2. Number of service centers
3. Long term reliability of the brand - both locally as well as abroad (if a foreign brand)
4. Safety of local build - If CKD, global ratings may apply but if its locally manufactured - then it needs to have a GNCAP or something. Not "yet to be tested" rating
5. Long term commitment from brand (Chevy, Opel, Ford, Daewoo, Peugeot.....)
6. Resale value of product (Potential in this case - remember if the brand packs up, the resale of the car will become a mirage)
The asking price is quite steep - and its not a brand thats globally regarded as an aspirational brand nor are the audience for this car so experimental to buy even if its expensive.
why no one talks about xc40 its a brilliant entry level SUV from Volvo and better than X1, far far better than GLA and even better than Q3
Absolutely right bro..I am volvo fan..bt indian people never understand the value of of Volvo cars😞😞😞
Too boring to drive, drive it back to back with an X1 and you'll come to know
Cos it's Chinese owned: )
True
@@kostinarain7373 And not just that. A buyer looking at putting so much money on a car is looking at so much more. The lure of a german marque (BMW or Merc, lesser of Audi these days), bragging rights, safe bet with many BMWs and Merc around, service centers etc etc. A volvo might offer good creature comfort but that a merc does as well. And the cherry on top is that its a merc.
Very good efforts. Thanks.
I loved the comparison and the details discussed. Now, please pass the keys for my TVS XL CHAMP
I would say both the cars are waste at this price point 😀😀
KIA LELO 🤣🤣🤣
@@therainbowapple9321 Arun Panwar active in chat😂😂
xD
Tata harrier💪
Fantastic review .....Loved it
Very well seems a biased or a paid review for the non seller Citroen
Thank heavens for not involving the hyundai Tucson in this comparo.. Stay blessed😁
Motorbeam next video:
Maruti Celerio vs Lamborghini Urus
No, S-Presso
The last time French and Germans engaged in a war, it didn't go down well for France
Didn't go well for Germany either.
Would have loved to see comparison between C5 and Mini Countryman
C5 rear looks like mini clubman
Nice video
I have taken the test drive of C5 and it is much better than other nearby segments
C5 looks really ugly.
@vineet vishwakarma how's it ugly
or should it be hyundai kia who copies german cars 🤣
You guys done very well comparison 👏
German vs French War 😂
I thought dino’s vault is there in the thumbnail..
Make a comparison video for xuv 700 vs mg hector plus vs innova crysta
As soon as we get the 700 locally in Mumbai!
Something meaningful finally
Pls make video on Lexus es 300h.
Bmw 7 series and alto 800?
How about gloster?
We need comparison of jeep compass and x1
A Nice Sombu from Motorbeam
Plz make a video on Verna/creta/seltos 1.5ltr mpi petrol engine
Okay, let us try and source a car
@@MotorBeam plz include Astor also 😋
@@Asishh_ Haven't got the Astor locally yet
@@MotorBeam k😀
Why don't you mention the ground clearance? :/
C5 is overpriced, but it offer more comfort than the others,its suspension is fantastic.I personally loved the car.❣️(But my dads purse doesn't like the car🥲)
Dad's purse??!! You think it's funny?? And how is your purse looks??
@@manofsteel646 i mean he has no money to buy
Love the citroen
I thought Dino bhai was here 😄
Are you trolling somebody in the thumbnail..... That freeze shot
Citroen is luxury legend. ✌🏼😎
Arey wahh..what a comparison dude..
A 40lakh car which is only worth 20 lakh and a 50 Lakh BMW😂
A മലയാളീ हिनदी മേ സംസാർ കർ രഹാ है🌚😂
Wahh bhai moj kardi, മലയാളി പൊളിയാ 😌
@@noeljosegeorge pinnallah 🤠
Should have Compared with Tiguan allspace also
I taught it was a colab with dino bhai (@dino s vault) seeing the thumbnail 😆😄
Awesome video....this was what I was looking for long time...branded cars are just overrated...looking forward for more videos like this
Sir pin kardijiye famous hojaunga 🙂 👍
🔥🔥🔥
No one can beat the driving pleasure and power of X1
True, I also have an x1 and literally it's sick 😍
in it's segment only 🙏
Man C5 has a superior ride quality like it is sooo good. My parents had a choice between fortuner base variant and Citroen C5 we went for Citroen cause God this car is really good. Citroen has lived up to my mark also it has few features missing but tbh it's okay. The price also fits the car. the service center is soo good and it treats you well.. happy with C5.
Better buy jeep compass model S.. it has that premiumness, macho look, premium features and importantly proper 4*4 system with 10 to 15 lac lesser price
13:07 that is what BMW is about... You buy It for the fun of driving..
Sheer Driving Pleasure
- BMW 🔥
He said the x1 produces 400 Nm of torque. Is that correct?
Its high time that BMW needs to update X1 with fresh interior elements and few exterior changes… n again it will sell in good numbers…. Hopefully Soon…
As far as Citroen C5 Aircross in concerned, being a CBU it’s extremely expensive compared to what it offers so definitely not value for money specially for someone like me who change cars frequently (2-3 years)…
XUV700is much better value for product
All luxury brands have spoilt the bumper area of their cars.
How do they call these SUVs?
C5 is a good car but 8 lakh rs more ... The Gloster will be a better buy or even a fortuner for best bang for the money. The glosters ride is also good . Fortuner is Toyota , nothing to explain .
Holy duck...so much is not mentioned.. I own a BMW X1 2017 diesel, and test drove the C5...I can absolutely tell you...if you are an enthusiast, C5 is a waste.. secondly, braking is not as strong if you are driving on highways...there is ONLY ONE dealer of Citroen in the whole state of Gujarat...and absolutely no service centres anywhere but ahmedabad....and we all know what's road assistance like in India...the engine noise inside the cabin is too too high and disturbing when revving for a quick overtake..lastly the fit and finish of BMW is like wayyyy ahead of C5...no analog representation of dials...no electric adjustment for seats...we just can't compare them...
Coming to X1...very low under thigh support in back seat..not at all comfortable for long rides for 5...smaller size space saver spare wheel.. the factory fitted pirreli tyres RFT are the worst available in the market...they blow don't puncture..always opt for simple BS Turanza or similar tyres.
I thought it was dino bro on the left for an instant by seeing the thumbnai
Seriously ! Bottle holder space 🤷♂️
Biased Video or the promotion of Aircross
PLZ FOR
7 REASONS TO BUY *Mahindra XUV 700* not for *TATA Safari* or *Hyundai ALCAZAR*
And the bottle holder test you can see the biasing to promote a new coming brand 😂🤣
And at the end you'll say 11 lakhs cheaper 😂🤣
And why does that guy jumps in the thumbnail picture,
Poorly edited. Information shared is also not accurate
Sorry folks, how is missing rear middle seat arm rest not a deal breaker for a car of this price?
Nice ad
C5 air Ross is in the same category as X3/Q5/GLC
i bought the 2016F48, it has alot of problems till I drove for 5 years, Do not buy the X1, problems such as engine body clip on engine bay broke 3 times, gear changing module spoilt, hefty USD11000, twin turbo charger spoilt, another USD3000. battery changes 4 times USD500 each, the start/stop will not work properly,i its an indication. and other consumerbles. not really woth buy.
Most Detailed one.
Thumbnail pose is copied from Dino's vault 😂
If you don't mention
People would think these are hatchbacks or estate cars
They look nothing like an SUV
20 mins video?
What about after sales service...🤔
If buyer has 50 lakhs then, he/she should go for MG Gloster, as you get features and comfort of 1cr cars/suvs in it!!!!!
Citroen drives beautifully, almost like an Audi, but its seating comfort is very disappointing. Three prople sitting in the rear seats is a big joke!! Even one person cannot sit in comfort due to the poor seat design where you have to sit in an extreme corner only and your head is too close to the roof corners and the window glass. Only for this one reason I did not buy this car. Also the low hanging plastic apron with fake exhausts as rear bumper is a design howler. Also manual seat adjustment for the driver's seat is a super howler !!Citroen please do a course correction as otherwise this car is on par with Audi in driving comfort and driving dynamics, may be even slightly better. Please please I still want to buy it. And please have a service centre in Bhubaneswar . I am driving a q3 at present since the last 9 years. It still runs beautifully after 140000 kms. But I still want to change. Also the cost difference between the two Citroen variants is too high and seems unreasonable.
what is this bottle holder test. how is this relevant at all? that too with empty plastic bottles. matlab kuch bhi!!
Comparison is good for information but a buyer who is thinking of a bmw will always have the badge in mind. Also, BMW's are inherently reliable. With that perspective, X1 customer will 9 out of 10 times won't even bother about aircross
True
BMWs are inherently reliable money pits.
@@arunvignesh7015 i respectfully disagree
@@vivekgopinathan6960 You shall disagree sir but the simple truth is other than marketing crap, the word reliability and German cars is generally doesn't go hand in hand with eachother. These are unreliable expensive cars that are fun to drive and there's no question of that. The only word reliability can be associated with is probably Toyotas, Honda's and the Koreans to a certain extent.
@@arunvignesh7015 I owned a Fortuner, then an endeavour ... Just got a x3 30i & absolutely loving it. Buy thr service package & sorted. There are trade offs & I would choose bmw over any luxury brand or any brand
The day BMW started making FWD cars they lost their RWD only, fun to drive and easy to drift cars legacy.
Third class interior of Citroen
Mr. Biker, all 5 ft 6 inches of him needs to adjust the front seat to a realistic distance. Im 5'9 and I dont have any issues when someone my height is seated ahead of me. Also, stiffer the ride means more engaging the drive.
We wanted GLA instead of this old machine BM X1 🙄✌
Citroen against a BMW!!!😃
Love the C5!
MotorBeam is very unbiased and that's why I trust their feedback
Seriously🤣🤣
though this review sounds very biased 😂
Kya la bhai? Kuch bhi? Honda city and hyundai creta comparo dekh lo.... It is all bias and nothing else. Paisa bolta hai paisa. 😂😂
Poor review.. background music too loud and one reviewer dominating the other.
Bmw x1 is rear wheel i guess
How about 100mm more length with ventileted seats for half the price_ harrier❤
Better than German cars
Look at the leg room of citreon 😂 in 15:53 😂
Yeah.. these guys are doing a paid work for Citroen 😀
İ think C5 aircross better
That's the very purpose of this video
100% biased review....its clearly visible in the bottle test....the guys didn't even bothered trying to put two bottles in the rear door of x1.
And that dude saying when suspension is stiff he doesn't feel it like an suv...which world are you from bro....
Me can only afford spresso 🤣
Toyota Legender entered the chat!
Overpriced
@@sandy99797 nope
@@JOE-ob7ic every toyota is overpriced
@@sandy99797 yeah 😂
Paisa bolta hain 😂😂😂
Feels like a paid video from Citroen
XUV700 SABKA BAAP🙏🙏
Is this an advert for c5?
Paid comparison
its better to buy toyota and tune it to 1000hp
Why does this seem like a C5 advertisement more than a comparo lol. At least be unbiased if you're comparing. No wonder your viewership has gone down.
Why spend so much, buy creta!
Useless comparison. They tried really hard for Citroen c5 to win in every aspect. Felt as a paid video. The person sitting at back intentionally moved very hard while in bmw on bad patch. People purchasing bmw won’t even consider Citroen.
I drove both and C5 aircross is better in every way. German fans may not agree but that’s the truth. Actually C5 aircross is comparable with Range Rover in terms of comfort…
First comment ❤️
At least you could have tried to cover up. Everyone can see it’s a paid promotion and that’s not bad but at least don’t defame Bmw. And the money you took clearly shows by the hidden dislikes. More over C5 is not even close to Bmw in terms for its drive, interior looks, quality all around, badge value or after sales and dealership network where’s all that huh? It’s terrible to defame a good product buy taking money from the flop show Citroen.