10 Mistakes You Missed In Encanto
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2024
- Well, Disney has done it for the 60th time. They’ve put out another animated musical that will infect all your karaoke nights and gatherings around pianos with a charming story about family with catchy songs. This time it’s an entirely inhouse story of the Family Madrigal and their magic enchantment that not only protects their village from the outside world but also gives the Family Madrigal special magical powers. Well, except for the central character Mirabel. It’s a heartfelt story that explores the complexity of family relations, the things we hide, and the things we don’t see in our family members and the weight that these things can create for family members. And of course a lyric book from Lin Manual Miranda to round things out. But while the movie is incredibly charming and the story affecting…I wasn’t crying, you were…there are some things that don’t quite add up once the overture fades and the tissues are dispensed. It turns out that one of the reasons to not talk about Bruno is that some things about the family’s erstwhile prognosticator don’t quite add up. That doesn’t even touch on the complicated relationship between Abuela and Mirabel, and why won’t Casita at least give Mirabel her own non-magic room instead of making her stay in the nursery? Let’s look at some of the big questions from Disney’s big 6-0. What did you think didn’t make sense? Let us know in the comments and be sure to like and subscribe for the latest videos in your inbox.
Subscribe: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Screenrant
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:46 Why doesn’t Mirabel get a room?
1:56 Speaking of rooms, how did Mirabel get out of Brunos?
3:21 Maybe we should talk about Bruno…
4:52 What’s that jaguar eating?
5:45 Dolores blabs but keeps Bruno’s secret?
6:39 What was up with that toucan?
7:24 Let’s talk a little more about Bruno…
8:01 Did Bruno really never find out how deep the misty pit was?
8:51 What caused Abuela’s change of heart?
10:05 Disney’s oopsie
Check out Screen Rant’s official TikTok!
/ screenrant
Our Social Media:
/ screenrant
/ screenrant
/ screen-rant
Our Website:
screenrant.com/
Written by: Ryan Carbrey
Narrated by: Justin Freitas @JustinFreitasVO
Edited by: Joe Criscitello @OfficialJoeyC_
For copyright matters please contact us at: legal@valnetinc.com 
Кино
Do you think Encanto is the beginning of a string of future Disney classics?
Hell yeah! It includes more relatable messages, like being under pressure and living in a somewhat toxic family. If it doesn't go down in history, then I'm gonna be shocked.
Not really. It was fine, but I just saw it as a lesser Coco. It probably deserves a second watch, but right now I'd say it's probably Disney's worst since Meet the Robinsons, which isn't a bad thing. I love Meet the Robinsons.
No. Watched it and absolutely hated it. Only the ending was somewhat decent. Mediocre plot, cliche characters and a song every five minutes. Two thumbs down!
@@alyssamorgan747 That's interesting. The ending was the only part I didn't like. Not the ending itself, just the fact that there was no climax. That really bothered me.
yes
Apparently another mistake Disney made was that they focused on making Isabela merchandise for girls and turns out the little girls actually wanted Luisa merchandise 😂😂😂
I love Luisa ❤️
theres no messy isabella too.
I'm in my 30s and would rather have Louisa merch by far
I relate far more to Luisa and would like some Luisa merch myself, and im twenty.
I kind of figured she didn’t say anything about Bruno being in the house because the movie made it painfully clear that they don’t talk about him.
Then why couldn't she keep from talking about his proficiency during the engagement
At one point I’m pretty sure she says “it’s like I hear him now.” Because she probably did hear him.
@@mktrill Because that secret kinda... you know... is about how the miracle is dying and they are all fucked.
@@Kikiricki11 she should have been known that since abuela's prayer in the balcony to abuelo Pedro she admitted the magic was fading
@@mktrill tbh they bring him up from time to time. Mirabel does in the opening song and her mom does when she’s trying to caution her about losing her way in the family. Obviously they sing a whole ass song about him but up until that point everything was fine with the magic. I think the entire point of the not talking about Bruno policy is to ignore his existence so even if she would have spoken up before I don’t think anyone would have behaved differently.
In "We don't Talk about Bruno" song it's amazing because Delores does not talk about Bruno in past tense like the others because she knows he is still around
Nice point of view
yeah. I just like the song. I don't really find any deep meaning in the lyrics personally.
Dolores**
But there are other characters that do to
Camilo does that
6:39 - The Tucan went back and talked to Antonio. That's why later on, Antonio follows and ends up in Bruno's room with them all. At least that's what I got out of it.
Maybe, we know that the rats are the ones that told him abt bruno still being there
In the movie he does say “the rats told me everything” so…
What gets me about that is in “all of you” antonio is singing “thats bruno?” As if they never met and he wasn’t in his room earlier that day
@@aniyahscott2344 if you watch the movie with subtitles it’s actually a question not a statement
@@susannazvara4915 Wait, I never realized that! How could he not know that that’s Bruno then??
Surface Pressure was my fave tbh. It immediately felt like a Lin song through and through. It's still stuck in my head!
You see, Screenrant, there's a thing called willing suspension of disbelief. As Ryan George puts it, audiences will put up with mildly contrived events "so the movie can happen". As an example, the version of the movie where no one talks about Bruno after his departure, so there's conflict in the movie, is more interesting than the version where everyone's open about it
Here's one probably no one caught-
It's been confirmed by the encanto creators that dolores's room has soundproofing, so she can actually relax. But at the end during "All of You", she sings to Mariano about how she knows he writes poetry when he goes to sleep. So do they just have like... REALLY different bedtimes?
Maybe she listens deliberately.
Yet she heard Luisa's eye twitching all night
She probably sits on the balcony at night specifically to listen to him
Her room probably has a window. Plus there is a balcony outside of Dolores' room.
@@Quetzal00358 This was in reference to the rest of the party following Mirabel talking about the foundation, not when they went to bed.
I know no one is even going to read or respond to my comment, since it is not short or phrased like a meme, but:
I think an alternative interpretation of the primary struggle that makes more sense is that it was not the stress on the family's emotions that was killing the magic. It was that it was being EXHAUSTED, with the Magic being relied upon to do EVERYTHING, while the Family and Townsfolk were not contributing enough of THEMSELVES to replenish it. The candle did not give her powers, because it sensed it needed HER to give it power back in return, and that she was strong enough to do it.
The Magic did not return until not only the Family, but the whole COMMUNITY gave of themselves to rebuild and replenish the generosity and good will needed to replenish three generations worth of using the magic to solve EVERYTHING without giving from the parts of themselves that did not come from the candle.
When the house was rebuilt by hand, the goodwill of the whole town recharged the magic.
That Is how I saw it, anyway.
My theory is kind of similar! I interpreted it as a sort of protection of the family, since it was abuelito's sacrifice that created the encanto. As the family as splitting apart (rather than being a cohesive unit, which meant having the freedom to be themselves and give back to the family unit in their own unique ways), the encanto was getting stretched thin.
Yay
I don’t think Screen Rant understands the meaning of the word “mistake”
Fr
Encanto pitch meeting?
Screenwriter: She has to hug her sister to save the miracle.
Producer: It must be hard to get her sister, who hates her, to hug her.
Screenwriter: Actually it'll be super easy. Barely an inconvenience
Producer: Oh really?
Screenwriter: Yeah she just insults her and calls her selfish, leading her to sing a song and hugging her at the end
Screenwriter: Then in the last song Dolores says she always heard Bruno and knew he didn't leave
Producer: She knew the man that everyone was scared of and didn't talk about was there for 15 years and she didn't say anything?
Screenwriter: Yeah yeah yeah
Producer: Why?
Screenwriter: I DON'T KNOW
Screenwriter: So what'd you think?
Producer: Sounds good but I wanna know about the soundtrack. We are Disney and are known for good music in our movies
Screenwriter: Oh yeah it'll be good
Producer: Really?
Screenwriter: Yeah. I mean it won't be anything groundbreaking
**Cuts to article about how We Don't Talk About Bruno topped Let it Go in the charts**
That seems so accurate I am actually expecting it to be said.
Lol
Ooh not talking about long-lost brothers in walls is TIGHT!
Hugging her sister to save the miracle is *TIGHT*
I’m gonna need you to get all the way off my back about that…. 🤣😂🤣😂🤣
The only mistake was me hitting play on this video. How the hell is Mirabelle not getting a room a mistake? It's the inciting incident. Stick to letting Ryan do Pitch Meetings.
That's being moved to its own channel.
Mirabel's door was on the wrong side of the house. When Alma reacts to the door disappearing and the candle flickering, you can see the portraits of everyone's gift ceremony behind her. That's between Abuela's door and *Pepa's* room, so Mirabel's door was on Pepa's side of the house and not Julieta's. The door that disappeared on Mirabel is in the exact same spot as the door that opens for Antonio. On the other side, where Mirabel's door *should* be, next to Luisa's door...is the painting that leads to Bruno's hideout.
I think I saw the painting right next to Dolores' room
Bruno doesn't have to do the ritual, it just helps with anxiety
Are we gonna talk about how most of these werent mistakes, but just gaps in writing and overlooked logic
gaps in writing and logic in your story are mistakes
@@InnerAtanih Logic, yeah, but the gaps in writing were probably due to the bloated run time(even though they probably couldve been worked on making the other mini songs better💀)
@@TLEvilMel I agree, though it’s all sort of a a cohesive story and missing either or is a mistake for the story. I found the music anywhere from forgettable to mediocre outside of Bruno’s song and the movie itself to be formulaic and . It seems like social media and headcanons from the fandom is the only thing holding this movie together lol
Or they weren't gaps at all, and in a couple cases either pretty obvious, or taking something intended strictly for humor (the toucan in Bruno's room) as a serious plot element?
@@InnerAtanih I'll agree to disagree.
I almost can’t forgive that Hamilton reference Lucky for you I have half the soundtrack memorized
amateur /j
I have the entire soundtrack memorized lmao-
@@coyotix what I'm saying is half the soundtrack was appealing to me cuz why bother knowing all the songs if I only like half of them
@@madambutterfly1997 that’s true
Even though I didn’t memorize it I recognize most of the songs within the first 10-20 seconds of them playing
Those are rookie numbers. You gotta pump those numbers up!
07:45 Well, it's kinda the same with Mirabel's mother Julieta, she needs different ingredients and to actually MAKE the food to heal people. She can't just pick a strawberry, stuff it into someone's mouth and that's that.
Numbers 1 and 9 are not mistakes. They are reflections on the culture that the movie is based on.
1 = Mirabel doesn't get her own room because failing to gain powers meant that she had not come of age. It doesn't matter how old Mirabel becomes. Without completing the... let's say... "maturity ritual"... Mirabel would never get her own room unless she were to marry. If she had lived past her 50s and never married, she would likely still be living in the nursery. It is very possible that she may still be in the nursery of the reconstructed Casita.
2 = Elders are held in much higher regard in that culture, especially an elder that is the leader of the family. It is extremely inappropriate for children, grandchildren, and descendants to yell at the elders of the community. Not even Abuela's grown children would openly bark defiance at her.
For Mirabel to be verbally aggressive to Abuela and running away from the family AS WELL AS the conflict destroying what Abuela obsessively feared losing would make Abuela reflect and reconsider the choices she has made.
i’m seriously living for this Joey C guys editing
Bruno probably didn’t know the pit wasn’t botomless because it might have broken when the cracks were being formed.
Good point. Plus he does spend a lot of his time behind the kitchen walls specifically.
When I still thought the movie had a traditional villain I was sure that Toucan was some sort of shape-shifting wizard not to be trusted.
He only answered to Antonio, like the eels to Ursula, Iago to Jafar, the crow to maleficent... I'm onto you Antonio...
@@mktrill creep
@@cheese-nipples-1728 oh snap lol outocorrect I ment onto not into
Delores absolutely told someone, but she was 11 when he left & the family was stressed about Mirabel so I expect she was ignored or Abuela threatened her. Or Bruno bribed her with rat telenovelas.
Camillo overheard her talk about Bruno & rats & his kid brain created a monster.
No, I have absolutely not spent too much time thinking about this movie
I assumed Luisa overheard "the adults" talking about Bruno and his lost prophecy, back when she was a kid, shortly after he disappeared (and not a recent thing).
Here's one. Pedro was killed while the refugees were running away from the 1000 day war, which ended in 1902. They've been completely cut off from the rest of the world since then for 50 years (Alma's triplets are 50).
So given that, how does Bruno know about television? Yeah, you could chalk it up to the visions, but Mirabel seems to comprehend it.
whoever this JoeyC guy is does one hell of a job editing
"So what does the panther eat?"
We don't talk about the chicken.
One thing I always wondered was how Antonio managed to get into Bruno's hidden room without falling into the chasm or having some difficulty getting the rest of the animals in
Love this movie
The editor's Chris Farley references are great 🤣🤣
8:37 “Bruno returns to save her niece”
Camilo is only slightly older than Mirabel, less than 6 months, but she doesn't know who Bruno is at all because he left after making the prediction, so how does Camilo know exactly what he looks like? Can he perfectly copy and exaggerate from just his door portrait and family tree? Abuela would have hidden all photos of him so Camilo wouldn't have seen those.
I mean there was a image of Bruno on his door, so Camilo may have copy that and exaggerated some feature.
Consider for a moment that it’s Felix who is the first to tell Mirabel about Bruno, and then even Pepa does, and then Dolores who tells the most about him. It seems that side of the family has less issue with gossip.
there’s the pic of him on his door, and there’s the painting of the whole family we see in the beginning
He also “remembered” him being 7 feet tall so clearly his memory isn’t awesome
@@courtney-ray ...But to a little kid someone 5'10" would look Huge! 😂
I like the guy at the end, he did a bang up job xoxo.
I feel like a mistake that a lot of people missed in Encanto was Antonio's door.
As it shows all the other doors, it shows the children as young adults. Even Bruno, who is middle-aged, is shown as a young man on his door.
On Antonio's door, it shows a little boy.
Maybe Antonio has a second gift of immortality, or it's an actual mistake.
It’s not that Dolores is terrible at keeping secrets, her job is to relay everything she hears to the family.
Abuela was never told about the vision, so there was no reason for her to know that Mirabel would be the possible "downfall" of the family until the dinner scene. Which means she treated her badly for not having powers not a prediction.
But for her, Mirabel not having powers was a sign that the miracle was fading. She was projecting her fear unto Mirabel and resented her for it.
@@ttisol That is true, but it doesn't change anything
Thanks mom, but my sister is juggling a FRICKIN' CHURCH!
Bruno’s power is being misunderstood. His prophecies are like sand, and can change. Like sand, when exposed to intense pressure, it solidifies and turns to glass. This is why all the prophecies go wrong, abuella putting too much pressure on Bruno. Mirabels prophecy he stops letting the pressure to protect her, which is why it isn’t set
This is such a reach
All his predictions came true, none changed
Luisa said she heard the adults taking BEFORE Bruno left... meaning she was a kid... they werent talking the same night.
mistake
noun.
An action, decision, or judgment that produces an unwanted or unintentional result.
Here's the definition of mistake, because you apparently don't know it.
Is Ryan going to come back for any more pitch meetings?
The fish lady turned into Dolores during We Don't Talk About Bruno
it's really annoying overtime i get a notification and get excited but then it's some random thing like this instead of pitch meeting which all it matters!
i feel like dolores tried to tell everyone but just got shut down by abuela and thats why she forbid them to talk about bruno also i think ive read somewhere that bruno can do everything without any preparations but its very hard to do and drains alot of his energy making him fall asleep
I didn’t think much of Alma. She had a condescending attitude towards Mirabel for not getting a blessing and she should have been more understanding of how it made Mirabel feel inadequate. She meant well but she could have done better. She didn’t even bother to work with Mirabel to see how she could be useful
Bruno looks hilarious whit a bucket on hes head
Bruno can look into the future anytime, anyway, anywhere. It's just super mentally taxing.
Exactly... Why 2 caterpillars? I mean... Surface pressure is just so emotional!
BRUNOS POWER IS ACTING FOR THE LAST TIME
@ScreenRant as far as the carnivore thing. There is a scene where Antonio tells the leopard to not eat some rats.
The clip of the sulking jaguar was in the video briefly when they talked about the big cat's diet.
Anyone wondering how the room of the lady with the cloud on her head will be like😂
Yea and I also wonder how poor Felix could sleep in it too. Pepa gets a random nightmare and it starts raining on them 😂
''Camilo fix your face!'''
I have been waiting for a video like this for SO LONG it made me cry to see it.
In the song we don’t talk about Bruno. When Mirabel is putting the prophecy together at a table and everyone is dancing around her, The lady with a fish end up turning into Delores when she goes off screen. Right after 4:18 but right after the clip cuts off.
That was on purpose, you can see it in the planning for the scene on RUclips :)
I noticed that. There doesn't seem to be any reason for the switch
Narrative of Self is the result of a feedback loop between “Separate Self” & Cosmos 🎈
I'm sorry, but, "Dolores is terrible at keeping secrets" is not true. Do you want to hear some secrets she kept?
1. Bruno in the house.
2. Isabela crying herself to sleep.
3. Her love for Mariano (aka Isabella's fiance).
And probably a lot of others, please, don't judge her.
Omg I never thought about this till this exact moment, the reason she told everyone about the secret during the proposal, was literally to ruin the proposal, seeing as how she wanted mariano to herself... Not because she couldn't keep a secret
But how could she keep such big secrets like Isabela's rejection for Mariano to herself
But about that Bruno one, she did discreetly talk about him during We Don't Talk About Bruno
She even says "I can hear him now" referring to Bruno
And she sings her verse of the song in present tense implying that Bruno IS in fact still here
@@mktrill that's very logical! I hadn't thought of that... 😅
@@pratibhaaa7265 I agree!
And I also agree with @mktrill's idea
She wanted to ruin the proposal
And everyone blamed Mirabel for it
I think you might have forgotten one. How did Augustin heal himself in the song All of you? His face went from swollen to cured in 2️⃣ lines all without Julieta's healing food.
His face is still swollen when the towns people come and help. It’s only when they’ve done a lot of rebuilding that we see his face healed.
@@marianap7015 also, the food only quickens the process... allergies arent a permanent condition. Heck, her portion of the song even says 'are remedies for real' meaning even without her powers, she knows first aid
@@aoinatafanboy84 True. Also, after the house collapses all around Mirabel, Julieta tells her to wait and then goes and gets a bottle with some liquid in it. Probably some medicine or something.
@@marianap7015 yeah, this video just irks me because for 'things people missed' the narrator missed even MORE stuff.
@@aoinatafanboy84 yes I found actual stuff that was missed by reading the comments lol
10:40 Surface Pressure is my favorite too but does no one talk about “What Else Can I Do” its the 3rd best in my opinion
Guess what the entire song is about bruno so they do talk about bruno
In regards to the misty pit, I reckon that the pit was a lot deeper but casita made it safe once Mirabel was in danger.
Bruno is her son. So wouldn't be "another grandchild"
What happened with the Pitch Meetings?
Whoops!
There are more mistakes in this video than the movie. For one, Dos Oruguitas was submitted because it is symbolic of the entire film and not just about the journey of a single character. Lin Manuel has spoken about this in interviews and said that while they're very proud of Bruno's success, Dos Oruguitas was always going to be their submission. Disney stopped submitting multiple songs from the same film ages ago in order not to split votes.
We don't know that Casita is actually in control of the magic, rather than just a product of it.
I also wondered how Mirabel got back from Bruno’s tower.
I always assumed the sand carried get over the pit
Actually, she doesn’t keep the secret because in We Don’t Talk About Bruno, she says, “I can always hear sort of muttering and mumbling” so Ashe tells Mirabel, which is actually ANOTHER mistake because when she finally meets Bruno, she was confused. She says “so you never left?” Or something like that.
I aggree with dos oruguitas being the one for the oscars.
damn i really that was the last you missed in encanto
Where is pitch meeting? I’m thinking about rioting because we haven’t seen a new one in 3 weeks.
Amazing 💚🔥🏆
Sorry but no
I believe that Mirabel didn't get a door because she will get Abuela's room when she passes. And Mirabel didn't get a power because she's supposed to take over for Abuela, who also doesn't have a gift. Idk if that's what they were going for but that's the only explanation that makes sense. She has everybody's best interest at heart and the miracle knew that she would make a great leader.
People always over think these movies but that's part of the fun,I believe killing Merabel's spirit was killing the magic because she is Hope, Inspiration,and Growth for the family without her their is no gifts.
I loved this movie. I've enjoyed watching it several times and related to the pressure to be strong and to be perfect, and without achieving certain goals, like having children ofy own, I felt like I was stuck in the nursery.
As for mistakes. I thought the timeline was a little odd. I didn't think the triplets seemed like 50 year olds. I also noticed Mirabel's shoes. When Mirabel dresses, her simple espadrilles slide onto her feet, but throughout the movie when you see her at a distance, her shoes have ankle straps or ties.
The line ‘he’s here’ that’s heard near the end of the Bruno song reminds me of the way ‘they’re here’ is said in Poltergeist. They didn’t mean the boyfriend was here for dinner, they meant Bruno’s presence is. And they were right.
Also wait, Mirabel is second youngest? I thought Camilo was younger, how old is Mirabel?
Who else has their favourite character as Bruno
Delores kept Bruno's secret because Bruno is an Elder (remember Delores was 9 when Bruno left, and if an adult wants to leave, it isn't a 9 year old's place to disagree with them), and it wasn't harming the Family to keep it (after all, everyone made it pretty clear that Bruno's predictions were not wanted.) On the other hand, Delores is an adult by the time she heard Mirabel's secret about Bruno's vision, so she can decide as an adult whether that secret was important to tell the family, and on top of that, she sees that secret as something that can destroy the family, which she know is something that Abuela is particularly afraid of.
Dolores also wanna ruin Mariano's proposal cos... She likes him.
Who is on the balcony when Delores is singing we don’t talk about Bruno. I see a shadow.
The reason the toucan was in the scene with maribel is to play off every cliche of a Princess owning a pet that they can only understand or the pet that is with them throughout the film as like a sidekick they did it as a reference sort of
Did you know that Mirabelle doesn’t get her gift because after touching the candle she rubbed her hands on her shirt and casita did not recognize it because of that
Did anyone else notice that the miracle created Casita right where Abelo Pedro dies but later Mirabel has to run away from the Casita to get there????? Please help I can’t stop thinking about this
@@marianap7015 ahh thank you thank you! Ok I can officially sleep tonight!
@@sugarsweetsadie1026 So I had to rewatch it (even though I have multiple time by now😂) and I gotta say my answer was partially right and I’d like to clarify. For the purpose of making a short visual for the story at the beginning, Abuela is shown standing next to the river a few feet away from Pedro when we are told he was “lost.” Then without her really walking anywhere, the mountains grow and and Casita comes to live and she is nowhere near the river. Then during “Dos Oruguitas,” when they’re aggressors are getting closer, everyone runs away from the river and Pedro goes back. Then when the mountains are growing Abuela could see the River from far away suggesting she watched him get killed from a longer distance than shown at the beginning. So either way they didn’t get their miracle nor Casita right at the location where Pedro was killed so I think we are good on that part😊
@@marianap7015 0.o Thanks! That was really helpful!
a mistake you missed is when Dolores turned into fish lady
I think that the most obvious mistake was the thing about last song of the movie. They rebuilt the house, the time of course goes by, the father of Mirabel is healing from the bees, BUT Miranda still has the white plaster on his nose from the Isabella’ s flower bite! How many… months has that plaster?? The right would be that Miranda has a remaining mark from that bite instead of the same plaster!!
I want to know how Abuela knew that each kid was going to get a gift and at what age that would happen? Was the first one a surprise and an accident? Do the doors just appear one day?
Those weren't mistakes. Most of these were simple plot holes and the rest were explained easily enough if you paid enough attention. Just reaching for content.
‘Simple’ Plot holes
Yeah, so I think Dolores actually didn’t necessarily keep the secret: like from time to time she would mention: “hey, you know, Tio Bruno is…” and the rest of the family would be like: “we don’t talk about Bruno!” So she just gave up and stopped mentioning Bruno at some point 🤷♀️
Oh goodness... Mirabel is 15... Bruno was in hiding SINCE she turned 10... He couldnt know about it for 10 years when he left his tower after 5..
Uh,no. Bruno went into hiding since she was 5,not 10. The madrigals get their powers when they turn 5 years old.
@@cbfranco3307 ah, I thought it was 10 lol. That one I will take credit for
My take is that the Encanto (the area within the protective high mountains) is Abuela’s “room”, because when Mirabel looks into the one with the candle at the window, it’s just a regular room, like Mirabel’s. That said, Mirabel’s gift is her transformative ability, like a cocoon turning a caterpillar into a butterfly. The cracks in Casita began because of Mirabel’s inability to use her gift because Abuela constrains her in order to keep things in her own ways. The finale is literally Mirabel saying they need a new foundation. She is a sort of successor to Abuela.
The biggest mistake for me is the timeline for Bruno. In 'We don't talk about Bruno' Pepa is signing about her wedding day being ruined. I can only assume Pepa did not have the children at this point, and years later he is still amongst the family and having visions and doesn't leave until Mirabel is 5, and we know both Camillo and Delores are older than Mirabel... so for almost a decade Bruno couldn't have said 'it wasn't a prophecy I could just see you were sweatin' and calm that whole thing down??? The song makes it sound like he was immediately shunned after the wedding but he was around for at least 10 more years as Delores is about 5 years older than Mirabel is.
Casita is a sentient magical house, why is the magic only present on the surface-space? you'd think a magical house won't need a crawl space that looks about as decrepit as any other crawl space, so if the Casita can create a room that looks bigger on the inside, why didn't it give Bruno that luxury of making his crawl space much nicer or larger.
The first time I watched it, I had no idea that there was tension between Mirabel and Isabela, the second time I watched it, I did hear it in 1 Line in the song We Don't Talk About Bruno. However I have to watch it again, because other than being a convenient false reward for the plot, I didn't really see it. I think another mistake was not making this clearer in the script and animation.
The way Isabela flipped her hair at Mirabel early on in the movie, giving her a piece of sisterly "advice" by telling her to be helpful when Mirabel is literally carrying a big basket full of things is definitely a clear first indication of their tense relationship, and also how Mirabel tells her mom how Isabela never has a bad hair day is another indication of how she sees her sister. And not to mention the annoyed look on Mirabel's face when she sees Isabela descend on the swing as she sings her part in "We Don't Talk About Bruno" says it all about how she's fed up with her seemingly perfect sister. Also, there's Isabela shouting "I hate you!" at Mirabel after the dinner with Mariano was ruined because Dolores told everyone around the table about Mirabel's fate and the potential danger it could put Casita in. It isn't until "What Else Can I Do" when Mirabel reluctantly hopes to get a hug from Isabela in order to save the magic of Casita, that's also when she sees what Isabela truly struggles with and she gets a whole new respect for her.
Yeah the character relations are so flippant and fleeting
I take it you don't have siblings. The microaggressions in sibling dynamics are super obvious when you're in them LOL
@@ranuncudahlia I do have siblings, two older brothers and a younger sister and yes, I know exactly what you mean. I love my siblings but we don't always see eye to eye on different things. And the age/power hierachy is definitely present in my family. I relate to the dynamics between Mirabel and Isabela a lot because my brother and I are a lot like that.
That's crazy! Pressure and We don't talk about Bruno are the best!
Sorry but no
My favorite part is when mirabel meet bruno ok I mean oscar
I don't think most of these were mistakes. Colombian children do drink coffee though.
WE WANT ANOTHER ENCANTO OF WHAT HAPPENS AFTER
WHEN DO WE WANT IT
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW
At the end of Encanto it is possible that it's connected to frozen when Bruno says let it go
Why does everyone say abuela is pouring pressure on the family, I think the family is pouring the pressure on themselves, the only time she is forcing anyone to do anything is when she (wrongfully) thinks Maribel is running everyone's powers... Name a scene where abuela forces anyone to do anything...
Everyone at my school keeps singing Encanto songs alllllllll of the time!
I'm one who often finds annoying inconsistencies in films but have to disagree with some of these. The one regarding Bruno not knowing how deep the pit is could be as simple as it's a new hole created by the deteriorating casita. And when Delores says 'I can hear him now' she's referring to Mariano the 'love of her life' Bruno prophesies will be betrothed to another (ie Isabel).
My biggest gripe with this film is that Mirabel wears glasses and isn't healed by her mum. I know they say it's because it's not seen as an injury/disability but imagine if a character was in a wheelchair and hadn't been healed. While I, a disabled person who uses a wheelchair, would love this, there would be uproar from most of the population as to why the magic didn't heal that person. Don't get me wrong, I think it's great they have the main character wearing glasses, I just think with the chosen magical abilities it was maybe the wrong film to do this. I still wait the day we get a main character with a disability who isn't either the villain or the saint, but I'm not holding my breath (I mean, it took this long to have someone with glasses?).
With the glasses, I think it’s simply that Mirabel is perfect just the way she is, glasses and all, to her mum. Her mum has to choose to make a recipe specifically to heal a specific thing so she wouldn’t make a recipe to heal something that she sees as just a trait of her child.
I agree with you that it would be amazing some day to have a disabled character, especially if the disability was not made a big deal but was just part of who the character was, no big ‘overcoming adversity’ story or anything. As disabled people, we so rarely get to see ourselves represented in stories and on screen unless it’s part of some pity party, moral story, or ‘inspiration p*rn’.
@@gabeangel8104 Yeah it seems disabled people are either saints or villains with no inbetween. And I agree that she's perfect just the way she is, but I also know that if someone was born without a limb everyone would have an issue with the magic not healing them (despite bad eye sight being just as disabling without the use of glasses). Not sure her mum cooks for specific injuries/sickness as in the Madrigal Family song she just has a plate of food and gives one to each person in the queue.
Her mum's food does heal her from a cut. Maybe she can heal aquired injuries and illnesses, but not genetic or congenital ones. I do wish they'd cleared that up with a line or two of dialogue, though.
How did Brono patch the house so fast when it first cracked ?
The magic started being affected after Mirabel didn’t get her gift. At Antonio’s party Abuela treats Mirabel like a complete liar yet that same night she prays they don’t loose their Miracle. As the protector of the candle, Abuela knew that there was something wrong all along and thought having a stronger grip on the family would somehow save it. My guess is that the cracking had been going on for years but never as visibly to everyone else like the night Mirabel first noticed it. This is because the tensions between some members of the family were only getting stronger during the time the movie takes place. Only Bruno would’ve noticed the cracks because they starter with the house’s foundation like problems with the family had to do with their foundation as a family. That’s why in the song at the ending they talked about having a “new foundation” even if it’s not perfect (referring to the house and themselves).
Lil' nitpicky, but I understand. But Dolores didn't hear them speaking about that future because they weren't talking about it THAT night. Meanwhile, Luisa and her twitch started "crack night". Now Abuelita and her PRAYER that might... Wait, no. Dolores' room had to be soundproof for her to even sleep at night. Yeah, so NO. Also Dolores has some clues about Bruno, but I'm sure Mari-chan filled in ALL those gaps.
Not nitpicky at all. Luisa clearly said 'once' implying she overheard them after Mirabelle was meant to get her door. It happened years before.
if i was born and every cousin i had got a superpower except me i would be depressed how is she not depressed
She is sad deep down but supresses all her negative feelings (e.g. avoiding to talk about herself and instead focusing on her family in the beginning) until she is excluded from the family picture after Antonio received his gift. She then sings about it (starting with how she is okay to stand aside so her family can shine untiö eventually admitting that no, she is not fine).