Superb Even people is costal area are afraid of doing this business because of risk involved Doing it far away from coast is very courageous. 👏🏼👏🏼 Best of luck to all farmers
True, are you sure there is Saline water in Punjab like this guy claims? Remember, Punjab is 1000s of miles away from any sea, so it cannot have salt water source. Of course there are ways to harvest Fresh water shrimps. I think these people are doing mischief, one of the bad thing about this is due to salt water seepage, the farm near them also will have problems and then the farmer has no option but to sell land to these people
No offense but Our Punjabi brothers have a very different way thinking , they can be very regressive and barbaric at times most of them clearly lack a logical way to interpret things and don't think about the future consequences at all Trying to reason with them is akin to bashing your head on a wall. What these guys are doing is extremely stupid .
@@trivialthings SALT cannot be simply created, there have been areas in other areas of country which are thousands of miles from sea but the land is never SALTY. how does the salt come there? These areas are supplied by Fresh water from North (Indus/Saptsindhu) what are the chemical changes that makes land that is fertile, have salinity? Due to farming Mexican rice? REALLY? If you see with the flying drone shot, some farms are dried and "Salty" and next to it there is farm that is lush green with rice crop? how exactly? There is mischief, that someone is doing because they want to try and so Shrimp farming etc, this is deliberate mischief. YES due to over exploitation the land can lose its fertility, but does not make it Saline when there is no source for Saline water for 1000s of miles, but yes, they can get Rock salt just off the border.
Turning an adversity into benefit, wonderful creativity. There is a unique variety of rice in Kerala that grows in partly saline water, called Pokkali. Would that also be helpful in this situation? Perhaps they can try it out and check.
8:44: Thailand: "This is exactly what we are doing here. Instead of growing the world famous Hom Mali Jasmine Rice we now dig holes and put salt and poisons into them. And some shrimps."
How will they fill the land in future?? Now a day aquaculture is so popular, I think in the coming future we have to depend only on fish. They could try to regenerate the land for agriculture not for aquaculture... BTW thanks to eco India.. love it
As long as the ponds are cleaned regularly it is fine, or else the fish will be very dangerous for consumption . But these guys are right when they are not encouraging addition of salt or increasing salinity.
Recent report, 16 district in punjab have uranium poisoning in their groundwater now, thanks to excessive misuse of water on foreign crops both wheat and rice.
Our governments spend zero on research and development as compared to Israel. We should invite top researchers from outside India atleast for case study and help us in this.
Extremely misguiding narration... this is not overexploitation of ground water. But rather water logging due to seeping up of surface water near major irrigation canals built on Sutlej. Totally different hydrological phenomenon.
Maybe even make organic fish feed from food waste, I once did it with banana peel, carrot and egg shell-then dried in an oven to make it flaky and swordtails ate it up.
In the late 80s & 90s Ecuador converted fertile land for shrimp farming today the land is barren. So its not unknown that onland shrimo farming devastates the land. Once cow urine &manure dead leaves green waste made up the fertilizer. Then came chemicals. No we return to natural & are paying for it. Hope lessons learnt.
The video is excellent, however why on earth could the narrator or the audio editing team not fix the microphone. So muffled and very unpleasant to listen to! such a shame.
This is the result of aggressive farming practices in Punjab. Most of Punjab is arid land, rice is extremely water intensive and should not have been cultivated there.
Many parts of Maharashtra farmlands have been destroyed by "salting" issue from over usage of subsidized/free govt chemical fertilizer. These lands have become useless and usually sold to real estate agents who build ugly buildings over it and contribute to the already ugly landscape.
@@pretham2228 well, adani bought their wheat, often paying more than MSP. So yes, Adani did help. But farmers from showed many a times how ungrateful they are. They burn stubble every year causing massive pollution, and nobody is even allowed to talk about that. And you are dragging Adani in this because it's just became fashionable, you ignorant halfwit.
Mark my words and put it in your house. Private companies is cancer for farmers. It may be good for you and cancer to farmers. If it is helpful US farmers would have been rich.
Punjabis/Khalistanis need to stop blaming central government & need to start holding their state governments responsible. The current CM of Punjab is a drunk mad man.
Debt on pb 2007 - 50,000/- Cr 2017 - 1,82,000/- Cr 2022 - 2,85,000/- Cr Govt. 2007- 2017 ( badal + BJP) Centre - 2014-2017 (BJP ) Captain is 2 time CM 2002-2007 2017-2022 Now he is in BJP Bjp +badal+ captain + unke kutte ruled Punjab from 1997-2022 =25 years Ab bosdivalo so jao kitna lootoge Punjab ko
Do Punjabis even know what shrimp is? I am in a food group with a huge number of people. Whenever someone posts shrimp, north indian people ask what it is. They are always surprised and call it an insect
Punjab's average rainfall for period July-Sept is about 300 mm,must not rainwater harvesting be carried out totally in these shrimp ponds? Lack of will?? whimpering about water salinity by agriculturists had been recorded since 70s.... that too in research papers.
If govt need to help in setting up the shrimp farm then they should also tax those farmers later to recover the money. It should not be just take This money and all future profits are yours.. No no. No.
it's going to have a very bad effect in the environment in few years. what do they do with the stagnant water ? just throw it in the nala ? shrimps needs constant fresh saline water for proper growth. it will lead to more water scarcity n damage
imagine all the tourism khalistan state would get from neighbouring countries and good relations, wow wow go for indendence punjab india, its good option
@@ashish282 data is not available real as most surveys consider eggs to be vegeterian as well but if u just go by the sheer amount of poultry reared u will find what I am saying to be true the data available might be true for older generations but the current population most of punjabis even in delhi and other states are non vegeterian
Superb
Even people is costal area are afraid of doing this business because of risk involved
Doing it far away from coast is very courageous. 👏🏼👏🏼
Best of luck to all farmers
not much of option left ,, fish + shrimp+ compost farming are only few methods to create a better livelyhood in punjab for a debt riden farmer
you can also do pearl farming along with shrimp farming which is very profitable.
True, are you sure there is Saline water in Punjab like this guy claims? Remember, Punjab is 1000s of miles away from any sea, so it cannot have salt water source.
Of course there are ways to harvest Fresh water shrimps. I think these people are doing mischief, one of the bad thing about this is due to salt water seepage, the farm near them also will have problems and then the farmer has no option but to sell land to these people
No offense but Our Punjabi brothers have a very different way thinking , they can be very regressive and barbaric at times most of them clearly lack a logical way to interpret things and don't think about the future consequences at all
Trying to reason with them is akin to bashing your head on a wall.
What these guys are doing is extremely stupid .
@@sachinmesta4238 there was sea once in this tegion(himalyan and himalayan foothills). I have studied in it in ancient geography
This is the power of research and knowledge. Hats off
How
Thats total lack of common sense
@@sachinmesta4238 what do you mean
@@trivialthings SALT cannot be simply created, there have been areas in other areas of country which are thousands of miles from sea but the land is never SALTY. how does the salt come there? These areas are supplied by Fresh water from North (Indus/Saptsindhu) what are the chemical changes that makes land that is fertile, have salinity? Due to farming Mexican rice? REALLY?
If you see with the flying drone shot, some farms are dried and "Salty" and next to it there is farm that is lush green with rice crop? how exactly? There is mischief, that someone is doing because they want to try and so Shrimp farming etc, this is deliberate mischief. YES due to over exploitation the land can lose its fertility, but does not make it Saline when there is no source for Saline water for 1000s of miles, but yes, they can get Rock salt just off the border.
Intelligent use of music to show the positive side of an ecological nightmare in punjab.
Turning an adversity into benefit, wonderful creativity. There is a unique variety of rice in Kerala that grows in partly saline water, called Pokkali. Would that also be helpful in this situation? Perhaps they can try it out and check.
Rice is naturally a water-intensive crop, unfortunately.
Even though, he does not recommend adding salt, farmers would end up adding salt in other areas , there by contaminating adjacent areas.
It takes quite an effort to spin shrimp farming as eco friendly! Punjab lazy farmers are powerful!
@@fieryshadow123 Destroying the fields of Punjab is a good way of turning india to poverty and hunger.
If that is the aim, this is a good step.
Wonderful story, well told. Kudos.
8:44: Thailand: "This is exactly what we are doing here. Instead of growing the world famous Hom Mali Jasmine Rice we now dig holes and put salt and poisons into them. And some shrimps."
That's also the same in Andhra pradesh. Fertile paddy lands are being converted into salt mines.
Why poison?
@@introtwerp Chemicals, Antibiotics, ... I'm too lazy to look it up ....
We all hope it doesn't turn disastrous 👍🏼
Hope is what keeps us alive. Thank you so much for the wonderful piece
How will they fill the land in future?? Now a day aquaculture is so popular, I think in the coming future we have to depend only on fish. They could try to regenerate the land for agriculture not for aquaculture...
BTW thanks to eco India.. love it
Why? Shrimps are way better than ghass pus. Protein👍
Yes they are going to have another disaster until they reverse this and reclaim agricultural land with organic farming, desi seeds and desi cows
Hats off to our enterprising farmers.
In Southeast Asia, there are inland lobster farms. The return is more lucrative.
Lobster as a delicacy has use in Asian Dishes ....
American, European palates have shrimps much more
Not possible in Punjab
Dr Prabjeet Singh a great Asset to Aquaculture in India !!
this is such a good example to quote in upsc answer.
Wonderful! Splendid!
Amazing, well researched
This is wonderful.
Send the whole batch of shrimps 🦐 to Bengal. We Bengalis are fond of (almost crazy for) seafood. And here the price of shrimp is 400-450/kg.
Nahh Delhi has huge demand at high end restaurants
In punjab hardly any1 eat this
As long as the ponds are cleaned regularly it is fine, or else the fish will be very dangerous for consumption . But these guys are right when they are not encouraging addition of salt or increasing salinity.
Good report
very smart idea!!!!
Recent report, 16 district in punjab have uranium poisoning in their groundwater now, thanks to excessive misuse of water on foreign crops both wheat and rice.
dark side of green revolution and corrupt politicans
Amazing.👏🏼
As usual excellent video
Coastline main loss hota hain public ko , waha kya baat hain Punjab salute
Perfect example of making lemonade when thrown lemons
Good information.
Our governments spend zero on research and development as compared to Israel.
We should invite top researchers from outside India atleast for case study and help us in this.
The politicians are alive to loot the public, they don't have time to think for the public
but goverment busy doing muslim hindu sikh
Nce work jessica n noo bro🥰
request you to use a good microphone and a De-esser!! Good info, but the sound was definity recorded from a iPhone wired earphones!!
PLEASE, BRING BACK "YOUR MORNING FIX" 🙏
Uniquely India
ਧਰਤੀ ਦੇ ਵਿੱਚ ਪੈ ਗਿਆ ਸ਼ੋਰਾ,ਝੀਂਗਾ ਪਾਲੋ ਛੱਡੋ ਝੋਰਾ।
ਜਿੰਦਗੀ ਦੇ ਆਓ ਬਦਲੋ ਰੰਗ,ਸਾਂਝ ਪਾਓ ਗਡਵਾਸੂ ਸੰਗ।
Y’all need captions and voice over is very low quality and the audio quality is inconsistent throughout
This place is like 5 km from my home, its funny to see home town randomly online 😅
Good work ,u can explore pokkali rice along with the shrimp culture.
Our HERO 👍
Extremely misguiding narration... this is not overexploitation of ground water. But rather water logging due to seeping up of surface water near major irrigation canals built on Sutlej. Totally different hydrological phenomenon.
They can focus on Fishes too .....
Maybe even make organic fish feed from food waste, I once did it with banana peel, carrot and egg shell-then dried in an oven to make it flaky and swordtails ate it up.
@@hunterhq295 👏
more saline fishes should be introduced. Which will fetch higher productivity and thus higher income for farmers.
This will have devastating outcomes. This will cause people to making their lands salty on purpose
10:57 Lmao dude casually dropping the fact that he owns 40 acres😂😂😂
Can’t he own ?
@@tarunjassal9338 of course he can, he seems to complain about stuff as he is sooooo poor.
@@tarunjassal9338 no land ceiling act in Punjab ?
@@TalwinderDhillonTravels see these people are farmers, if they don't utilise the land to generate income, the land is hardly of any use to them.
The background narration's sound quality should be improved
Punjab is not granary of India for past 40 years.
Andhra, Bengal, UP are much ahead
I heard in Assam Punjab was sending fishes to Assam's market.
In the late 80s & 90s Ecuador converted fertile land for shrimp farming today the land is barren.
So its not unknown that onland shrimo farming devastates the land.
Once cow urine &manure dead leaves green waste made up the fertilizer. Then came chemicals. No we return to natural & are paying for it. Hope lessons learnt.
They can now ask for MSP on Zinga as well
The video is excellent, however why on earth could the narrator or the audio editing team not fix the microphone. So muffled and very unpleasant to listen to! such a shame.
if punjab under india cant grow crops under salinity issues, go for independence, you have my full backing
rainwater harvesting and soil less farming may be the way to go.
This is the result of aggressive farming practices in Punjab. Most of Punjab is arid land, rice is extremely water intensive and should not have been cultivated there.
In Andhra after shrimp farming the land turns un fertile for future farming.
I love the video but the audio is very bad, can u please improve it?
Many parts of Maharashtra farmlands have been destroyed by "salting" issue from over usage of subsidized/free govt chemical fertilizer. These lands have become useless and usually sold to real estate agents who build ugly buildings over it and contribute to the already ugly landscape.
Well in all fairness, government did try to help you out, but many people thought protesting for months on the Tikri border was a better alternative
Adani tried to 'help' these farmers... lol 🤣
@@pretham2228 hahaha some people like yourself are so delusional!
@@pretham2228 well, adani bought their wheat, often paying more than MSP. So yes, Adani did help. But farmers from showed many a times how ungrateful they are. They burn stubble every year causing massive pollution, and nobody is even allowed to talk about that. And you are dragging Adani in this because it's just became fashionable, you ignorant halfwit.
Mark my words and put it in your house. Private companies is cancer for farmers. It may be good for you and cancer to farmers. If it is helpful US farmers would have been rich.
@gobindsingh I am a farmer, and you can pay a visit to my farm to know what we are going through
Greed of the Old generation did this, Pumping groundwater, and heavy use of Pesticides.
what happens when the salinity of the land increases beyond the levels tolerable to shrimps?
are we going to eat wheat or shrimp only?
you cant afford shrimps
That artificial, chemical, green revolution destroyed farming brought by ms Srinivasan who was not a farmer
What are your doing?
How much money did it cost
Look at how small that shrimp is?
why can't the land be used to produce salt?
💚
#SavePanjaabWaters
Punjabis/Khalistanis need to stop blaming central government & need to start holding their state governments responsible. The current CM of Punjab is a drunk mad man.
Debt on pb
2007 - 50,000/- Cr
2017 - 1,82,000/- Cr
2022 - 2,85,000/- Cr
Govt. 2007- 2017 ( badal + BJP)
Centre - 2014-2017 (BJP )
Captain is 2 time CM
2002-2007
2017-2022
Now he is in BJP
Bjp +badal+ captain + unke kutte ruled Punjab from 1997-2022 =25 years
Ab bosdivalo so jao kitna lootoge Punjab ko
Where this salt leeching has come from? This is the problem of coastal area, but Punjab?
Water on land for growing rice-> evaporation-> water dries -> salt is left on land
Every other mic in the video is better than the narrator's mic.
We dont had anything in our area still we produced shubhman gill
These shrimps speak Punjabi and do Bhangra in Bollywood Punjabi songs
Do Punjabis even know what shrimp is? I am in a food group with a huge number of people. Whenever someone posts shrimp, north indian people ask what it is. They are always surprised and call it an insect
It's a arthropod
Crustacea
Ask them to grow jojoba plant which is tolerant to saline water and much much more rewarding thru jojoba oil produce.
Punjab's average rainfall for period July-Sept is about 300 mm,must not rainwater harvesting be carried out totally in these shrimp ponds? Lack of will?? whimpering about water salinity by agriculturists had been recorded since 70s.... that too in research papers.
Why Villages In India are still neglected for education, transportation and other basic amenities.?
But i need somebody to clearly tell me how the lands gives out salt and become barren like this?
👍👍👍
If govt need to help in setting up the shrimp farm then they should also tax those farmers later to recover the money. It should not be just take This money and all future profits are yours.. No no. No.
Pls get a better mic 😊
its quite a complicated isue. the solution isn't simple. punjab government needs to ivnest in research to get the right solution
Freshwater 🦐 shrimps
How the heck can be Naturally saline water in Punjab? there cannot be, Punjab is thousands of miles away from the sea.
1.51 lakh ha of land of Punjab is affected by dual prob of salinity and water logging.
it's going to have a very bad effect in the environment in few years. what do they do with the stagnant water ? just throw it in the nala ? shrimps needs constant fresh saline water for proper growth. it will lead to more water scarcity n damage
can be used as fertilizer
When you listen congress leaders rather than your cultur and comunity... you die like this..
power of education crisis into opportunity
PMMSY SCHEME HELPS FARMERS TO RAISE FUNDS IF U HAVE LAND
FARMERS PLEASE CONTACT UR STATE FISHERIES DEPARTMENT .
Don't think its easy to do shrimp culture, it's always a gambling game, hope eco india tell the other side also
imagine all the tourism khalistan state would get from neighbouring countries and good relations, wow wow go for indendence punjab india, its good option
Use better mic
Watch billions in change 1@2
rice should not had been grown in punjab in first place. its a crop of terai region not punjab.
Green revolution destroyed my punjab
These were the loudest opposers of Farm Laws. They will suffer now.
So Sadhguru was right after all
Lol he is a scamster be aware! but soil is degrading!
Punjab is responsible for his own fall, taking out ground water with tax payers free electricity....
This is stupid. This precious agricultural land is being destroyed .
Watch it again.
The land is already unusable for agriculture (due to previous mistakes), so this is a feasible option.
Saline water saline soil no other option
*ONLY BJP CAN HELP*
Go vegan,
Punjab have higher number of vegetarians, it's shame that this has introduced
dont force your views and ewating habits on others.
Dude which land u in? Chicken and murga are also consumed heavily there that is not vegan either
@@futureprenur9594 please show what percentage of people are vegetarians in Punjab...?
Talk on data not in the air
@@kkdias9924 how am I forcing my views?
@@ashish282 data is not available real as most surveys consider eggs to be vegeterian as well but if u just go by the sheer amount of poultry reared u will find what I am saying to be true the data available might be true for older generations but the current population most of punjabis even in delhi and other states are non vegeterian
Khalistan zindabad
Lol😂
Good morning sirs I'm a punjabi brine shrimp
Pakistani / Chinese channel
Great#sonubhatiofficial
Great#sonubhatiofficial