Thank you for watching and supporting me! Here is the second part where I answer your questions about my life in Georgia and some future plans: ruclips.net/video/BxqPx9gk_-w/видео.htmlsi=-lhNPrMbVZp6swQQ
Don't return to Russia until Putin is gone. The Soviet Union has been reborn under the leadership of General Secretary Putin. Any who leave Russia, in Putin's eyes, are traitors to the Motherland for leaving her, especially in the middle of a "special military operation." And Putin does not forgive or forget traitors.
I feel sorry for you and your family if you think Russia is the bad guy here and the West is innocent. The very fact that you think the war started in 22 tells me that you are absolutely clueless and your advice for other people not to believe the Russian propaganda. If propaganda were a competition, the West would be world champions and Russia wouldn't even make it to the finish line. Greetings from Germany, who also lived in Russia. Do you think we can say anything against the government here without consequences? if so, you are actually clueless.
@NatashasAdventures You are doing very well indeed, for your audience of imbeciles and degenerates, who think they can hurt Putin and the Russians, despite what has been proven for thousands of years and the biggest and most powerful assembled armies in history have failed, but keep going anyway, Putin described you well "MORONIES" 😉😆 Какое удовольствие, какой успех и достижение с твоей стороны и просто чтобы человек тобой восхищался😄
You are young and beautiful and the worst tragedy that could very well happen if you returned to Russia is to fall in love and then lose who you have fallen in love with to Putin's ambitions for an evil empire and war . Make a life out of the country and find your future , your family will have unconditional love and will support your decision and future.
I know what it is to be "home sick." It is better to be free and alive. Take the advice of an old man. You are young and adaptable, but be happy and safe. That is the best life.
@@checkfactschecking I have seen her previous videos from Russia and she was traveling all over the place. Such things can be done only by free man, correct me if I am wrong.
56 year old veteran combat medic. If you are safe, chill. Do you. It’s funny how fast things can change. Not always bad too. Keep busy and smile. Nothing lasts forever. You are young 20 years from now you will still be you. Patients is a virtue. Get a small dog. Love looking in on you from time to time. Stay safe.
One of the things I wonder about is, what will become of the veterans with profound injuries? After World War 2 Stalin created an entire system of hospices, mostly in Siberia, for their "Samovar People", Russian war veterans who had profound or visible injuries. Stalin did this for two reasons: humanity & duty for these veterans, & to remove them from the sight of Russian society. The chance of them becoming their own political force & lobbying for changes was a chance Stalin could not take, but he also could not kill them as he usually did, & at that point in post-War Russia the Samovar People weren't seeming to be interested in Russian politics yet. He didn't need them killed, only moved. Those hospices varied in their conditions & services. Some were legitimately good homes for these people, mostly men but a few women as well. Some were less nice. Some were terrible. They made the greatest of sacrifices for their Country. They deserved for their stories to be told wider than theirs were. And this War will definitely see men & some women with the same profound & visible injuries. How other Russians treat them in the future will be a crucial indicator of Russian civil society's own health & wellness.
Dont be a-fool. Have you not noticed that there are no pro-Russian comments in main thread, only in answers? What, people from Russia only know how to answer someones comments but are unable to post their own? This is purest, well-censored, cope-prpgnda for audience such as you. Russians have it good, ulike you. Afordable living, no homeles, no crime, no gangs, no gmo, breathtaking cities and infrastructure..
@@stix2youam from ex Yugoslavia, let me tell you what west and pro-western traitors have in plan for Russia. Same as we got, deindustrialisation plummeting standard and servitude. Stop pretending you are the good guys. I have visited both Russia, Ukraine and all western countries. In Russia, only danger are courious squirels in parks, while in west one needs bodyguards from all the gangs, criminals, homeles. In pro western noble Ukraine i have witnesed such moral decay i heve not seen anywhere in world. Noble, resilient my-a$$. Nothing but cnon-foder-servants. Same as what you plan for Russia..
@@CoffeeAndPaul who is a target for this nonsese? Russians know their history and love Stalin. Is this diabolical distorsion for yr public? To make them-hate-RU even more? I see you repeat this coment many times while my are deletwd by this nice girl in acordance with freedom of speach.
@@CoffeeAndPaul Stalin put many of the forcibly repatriated Russians who had fled to Western zones in post war Germany & Russian veterans straight to Siberian Labor camps, not hospices!! It was only after 1956 that Khrushchev, after denouncing Stalin's policies, permitted the inmates to live in the civilian towns near the camps. They were NOT permitted to return to the regions that they had lived in pre- 1940...Stalin didn't have to shoot or gas the returnees. He let the harsh conditions & lack of adequate care do it for him!!
My short Question, WHY??? Why draws "you" back. Remember your exit interview at the airport. Look at some of the troll comments below. I agree with you, they could easily be waiting for you with a case (instead of a guy who traveled a long way).
It is nice to hear about Russia from the perspective of a smart unbiased young woman, we don't hear from the media, your English is great also, subbed.
@@bryanemmel6516 Don't be a fool. I learnt this from advice on a Russian YT channel, ,(Agent Nesty. My R u ssian Train trip went completely wrong, 14 mins in) You don't understand what a democracy is.
Don't return to Russia voluntarily. Georgia is at least *one step removed* from being under his thumb. While some Georgians hate what Russia did and you catch the flaks from that (just from speaking and looking like Russian,) you should always keep in mind that you are actually closer to them politically in terms of being somewhat of an escapee from Russia. My parental family's new abode in British Hong Kong (after sneaking into it) was dominated by the Cantonese. They had the saying that olden time's Beijing's Emperor banned them from calling cucumbers 黃瓜 so they had to call cucumbers 青瓜. They said: 『山高皇帝遠。』"The mountains [separating them from Beijing] are high and the emperor is far away."
I love that little pigeon. Hardy birds that can weather storms just like you. You're old enough to appreciate what Russia is doing wrong but young enough to outlast this storm and help in its recovery. I'm 65 and may not see the bright future of Russia but you will. Find happiness where you can for now.
Right idea, but I don't expect there will be a "bright future" in russia until she is our age or older. It is going to take "guidance" and at least a couple of generations to clear out the brain washing putler has done, Her grandchildren MAY have a "bright future" in russia, but not likely sooner.
but its must be someting one - or too young, or old enougth. If you too young its adults business, if you old enought - you must take responsability for your decision
I am from ex Yugoslavia, let me tell you what west and pro-western traitors have in plan for Russia. Same as we got, deindustrialisation plummeting standard and servitude. Stop pretending you are the good guys. I have visited both Russia, Ukraine and all western countries. In Russia, only danger are courious squirels in parks, while in west one needs bodyguards from all the gangs, criminals, homeles. In pro western noble Ukraine i have witnesed such moral decay i heve not seen anywhere in world. Noble, resilient my-a$$. Nothing but c4non-foder-servants. Exactly as what you plan for Russia.
Thank you for answering all of those questions, especially where you mention losing your friend- I'm sure making the decision to talk about that was a hard one. I hope you remain safe and untouched by the commissars in Russia who would seek to do you harm.
It'S not even an attractive country - spending 2 years in Russsia , I'd say the cities are often ugly / miserable ... Housing is horrible ... most people DON'T have a dacha or a garden . In many respects , quality of life is very low and life is unpleasant compared to Europe and the civilised countries .( Weather is dreadful AND EXTREMELY DEPRESSING )
Hi, I'm from Finland and I'm saddened by what Putin has done to Russia. I worked in a factory here for 20 years, and I cooperated daily with Russian truck drivers, I loaded their cars. I like them a lot, we always had fun working together. My heart is sad when Russia has such a leader that it affects all of our lives, Russians first of course. I know many Russians and I have nothing bad to say about them. I hope that one day we can work together again and laugh at life.
Thank you for answering so many questions. I appreciate the perspective of someone like yourself in a world of talking heads. Greetings from Minnesota.
If you knew the state of Russia when Putin took over you would now see him as a savior. What do you think filled the void between the collapse and Putin taking over.. The International Red Cross?? Or the barbarian?
Nations outside of Russia aren't free. Even Canada has censored all free speech and even access to the news. People outside of Russia are homeless slaves that live in poverty. They learn to be happy to own nothing...
Telling the truth is irreplaceable. There can be no peace without it. Thank you for showing that a few honest words can shatter a billion lies and rantings. Thank you for the peace you offer. I wish you, your family and your country all the joy it is still possible to cultivate after the storm.
Natasha, thank you so much for this. I liked it so much. You said it was hard. I hope you will find the strength to do the next two. Here is my hope and care for your safety and that of your family and friends back home. Thank you again.
I think there is another reason why countries bordering Russia do not want to accept Russian immigrants. Both now and in the past, Russia (I mean authoritarian leaders) has used the fact that there is a Russian minority in a country as a justification for invasion. And AFAIK there have also been cases where Russians, for example in the Baltic states or Germany, have organised demonstrations in support of Putin.
You so dumb. If That is the case than nobody should allow Germans in because they started 2 world wars or dont allow Georgians in because Stalin was Georgian and killed over 25 million soviet Citzenz.
dude.. she is a troll lol.. she has no opinions 🤣 weak paid troll.... she has no dignity.... she has nothing to do in Russia.. Russians don't give a damn about her :)
She's more safe in Russia... nothing happens to anyone there's thousands of critics all over Russian Social media, you are been fed lies so she can earn more money through RUclips who has demonatized RUclips in Russia... this "depressing " woman is playing on you russophobic feelings to earn money 😂.. I live in Moscow, CNN has their offices here, they spread their propaganda here but remains safe, it's because we see right through it, here's thousands of US expats just in Moscow alone 90% wants Russian citizenship that tells you alot!!!
Been a couple of years since I watched your content. I find your vlogs very informative, I only put them on the back burner for a wee bit, and it’s ended up being a couple of years. Glad I found you again.
No, realistically it's not safe for dissidents to live in Russia. Come to the Netherlands. Everybody speaks English, there's a good immigration policy for refugees, and plenty of jobs.
It's extremely difficult for Russians to move to any country in Europe. Roman (YT channel "NFKRZ") had to go Serbia twice to apply for visa to Portugal.
Years ago I asked if you could always say "pakka pakka" at the end of your videos, and now every time you say it, I think I had something to do with it. I love you and will always love you. Big support from Pittsburgh, USA.
Sorry that you are separated from your family. This may not be forever. It was nice to see you and your mascot pigeon doing a Q&A again. Stay true and stay safe. It’s always good to know you’re doing well.’ Condolences to the loss of your friend. No life lost in a war is beneficial to the outcome.
You are brave and strong and have endured a great deal of hardship and stress. There will be more, but you can handle it! Thank you for your continued videos.
Thank you very much for opening up to these personal questions about your point of view, your struggle with the given situation as an emigrant in the diaspora. My condolences for the loss of your schoolmate and childhood friend. War always takes lives, and every casualty is a victim to the people in power who forced them to engage in war. I hope you have the strength to get through this hard times and that your wish to return to a new democratic Russia will happen someday soon. Keep sane and engage yourself in meaningful projects. Your voice matters, you matter, and you are needed for taking part in the reconstruction of Russia after the war. I am looking forward to the upcoming two videos of yours.
*Dude... if you understood what kind of crap you're talking about, you'd probably be ashamed. First of all, in Russia, prostitutes, homosexuals and lesbians will never rule the country. We Russians know very well what kind of poverty and collapse they brought the country to in the 90s of the last century!*
Thank you Natascha, this was a very good and interesting video. Sorry for your loss, for your friend and your country. Keep strong, doing what is good and be free. Greetings from the Netherlands ❤
I remember Ukraine Spy cheif was smiling alot when Navalny died, he was happy like he was when the mocow terror attack happend, and it happend right before the election, meaning it was meant to make Putin look bad... There is a pretty big chance that CIA together with Ukraine was behind it, and it looked like Russia revenged it straight after.
A great q&a, thanks. I find your answers and the perspective very interesting. I'm sorry that you feel sad when people ask about your relationship with your family. You are not alone, there are many who do not have close relationships. I understand as I found it difficult to have a close relationship with my family due to their fundamentalist religious beliefs and personality differences. I also know what it is like to be separated from family as my daughter works in China. In some ways, not being close makes it easier when you are separated. Take care and keep your chin up.
Hi Natasha, So sorry to hear about your childhood friend. May he rest in peace. I ABSOLUTELY love this Q&A and your honesty in answering these questions. I think you are really brave and wish you the best! Take care. Anthony
Yeah, I am so sorry for the childhood friend, too, especially for the widow he left behind. I'm not particularly emotional about people "winking out" because I'd moved so many times already so I became somewhat numbed.
Natasha I’m also from the same community as you. Please do not go back to Russia . Your life is precious. You are young . The world can change in 5-10-20 more years. All we have is the present and it’s in the present we make the decisions that will affect our future . Please focus on this last part of the sentence . Sending ❤
I am very amazed at your extensive language skill as a non-native speaker. 2nd, your ideas are clear and well stated. Continue to improve and your life will continue to improve.
I am happy that your time at the University of Minnesota was a positive experience. I currently live in Edina, MN, which is a southern suburb of Minneapolis. I don't know why, but there are a lot of Russian people living in this area now. If I walk around the lakes or go to the local farmer's market, I will inevitably hear people speaking Russian.
I really liked this video, it's so nice how you have approached those questions, I feel you more mature and relaxed. Good work Natasha I wish you all the best
I hope you are happy Natasha :) I have seen a few of your videoes, and its always interesting to hear your take on things :) Much love and respect to you from Denmark
If the Russia police is aware of you, they probably googled you as well and found your channel. I would say Russia is not big enough for you and Putin to live in. So as long as he is in charge and this war continues, I would not even think about returning.
@@barreloffun10 all wars, especially those initiated by the USA, are acts of aggression and indeed smell foul. So if you blaming one warring nation, blame them all!
Good to hear your parents know that you are safe. I’m a longtime subscriber to your channel and I liked the tour you once gave of your home and garden in, I think it was Spassk-Dalniy. And your dog Barni when you where showing your potato plants. i understand how relationships with can be complicated and wish you all the best.
Yeah! I remember that tour too. And the fishing trip with the parents. And the students dorm in Chabarovsk. It breaks my heart to think about not being able to go back to where one's roots are. I know that feeling myself. It's the worst when you have to flee or emigrate your home. I hope that all refugees worldwide may one day be able to return safely to their homes.
You make the strongest case against authoritarianism and dictatorships, showing how one single person can adversely alter the lives of so many people. I admire your courage to stick to your principles; unlike so many politicians, sycophants, bureaucrats and enablers who make this world a troubled place.
hahah authoritarianism and dictatorships 🤣 dude wake up.. she is just a troll... a weak paid troll with no dignity !!... what a clown you and her are... that's sick
@@ettoreatalan8303 I don't know who you think made that assumption. Perhaps you didn't read the last phrase in my comment, or didn't understand it. However, Putin has tremendous power and he could stop the war in Ukraine right now if he wanted to.
I understand wanting to live in one's own country. I hope things will change in Russia, so you can return. But if not, I wish you the best wherever you decide to live. Canada seems like a good country to live in.🦋
Hi Natasha. I am always so impressed with your thoughtful presentation, perspective, and insights to the situation and questions. As an US ex-pat currently in Europe I am increasingly concerned with the direction my birth country seems to be moving in. From the heart, I wish you all the best and keep giving us your (as best you can) unfiltered view.
I am also concerned about direction USA is moving, but this is about at ferocious dictatorship that kills people like ants. Do not compare Russia fascist regime with USA. They are too far apart.
Do NOT return to Russia now. I would go even further. Do NOT stay in Georgia. Try to get to the EU. It is hard, but other Russian refugees did it too. Do it with some haste. The window is closing.
@@JFJ12 dankjewel. I just saw prices for eggs today 5eur for 10...come to EU, such great economy 😅😅😅 noone can buy a house while in Russia families thrive😅 COME TO THE NETHERLANDS 😂😂
Natasha, I consider you one of my personal heroes! You are a brave young woman with a wisdom beyond your youthful years! Please keep doing what you do! 🙂
I found your honest answers refreshing! You obviously want to live your life in a country where you’re free to speak your thoughts without repercussions. I live in Mexico and find your reasons for leaving your country very interesting, but I too would leave for these reasons. I hope that you will settle down someplace where you can live your life fully and freely. Sorry to hear about your childhood friend. This happens during war,and hearing how his family reacted to your comments makes me sad that fear is so pervasive in Russia!
Hi Natasha, thank you for recording this Q&A. It must have been very difficult and I think you have given really well thought out answers. My condolences about your childhood friend. It must be so surreal to think of that. I'm also very sorry to hear that a close relationship with your family is not possible at the moment. I can only imagine what you have been experiencing in recent years, planning to leave your country, escaping, establishing a new life, thinking about your future amidst all the uncertainty. I think you have done fantastically. You have a cool head on your shoulders, critical thinking, resources compare to many others, and most importantly, you are at the right age. You are not too young to not be able to form your own opinions, you are not too old to be tied down by other life commitments. You are young, adaptable, resilient, healthy, and courageous. Home is where you are. Have hope that at the end of the darkest tunnel, there will be light
It's a strange thing, but I guess entirely natural to care for people, especially good natured people like natasha. It would be nice to see natasha go home to her family but I would worry a great deal for honestly outspoken people like her in that situation.
What I sincerely admire in your adventure is you accepting the conflict, that is your love towards what is true and cherishable in your homeland, on the other hand non-compromisingly rejecting the evils of it. And what I wish for you? That one day, you might enter the country of your true desire. Пока пока!
Most of the answered questions are questions made by Russian or other trolls. It's easy to spot them beacuse they use terms like "Feminazi" as if that is a real thing. I praise your patience in answering all of them honestly and truthfully and that behaviour is what have gave this channel so much popularity.
I hope one day Russia will be a place where you able to return to and feel safe and able to fully express yourself however you so wish. Until that day whichever country you choose to reside in will be that country's gain and Russia's loss. Stay safe!
As I understand it, international students in Russia are being told they need to enlist or they will lose their visas. So no, unless you have a death wish do not go to Russia from Bangladesh or Africa to study.
Stay positive and stay respectful. You are young and intelligent. I like that you have worked for what you have. It sounds like you have possibilities in Georgia, in the US, and Russia will recover-it always does. Respect the Army, they did not choose their situation. Your Russian culture is an asset. I keep in touch with Russian family/friends and list my accomplishments on my resume. They distinguish me from other people. I can see you work hard and should have a good resume.
Thanks Natasha. You are a very intelligent young woman. I know I am stating the obvious, but, if the police were collecting information about you, it is not safe. Anything can be written in a file or in a witness statement or complaint to be signed by an informer or someone vulnerable to police pressure.Family relationships go through ups and downs so perhaps your situation will improve in the future.
Considering that she is saying bullshit about Russian army and at the same time planning to return she is not intelligent at all. And also, she said now 'If Putin wins'. Lol it is not even a question for intelligent people. The questions are 'When he will win'. And 'What happens next'.
Privet, Natasha! Hello to all Natasha's friends! I have avoided social media, because being anonymous make them behave so rudely. However, I was thinking about you recently, wondering if you are alright. So, I was happy to see this video. Your hair has grown since I watched saw your videos last time. So, months have passed. I understand your life is hard now, and I can see it in your face. Outlooks is probably not the most important thing for you. But in few years, a curious and funny young girl has turned both clever world class journalist and seemingly tired adult woman. I am thinking about what to say after all. Understandably, your videos have been serious for a long time. And I know my interpretations of your situation cannot be precise. You are doing great work and speak on behalf of maybe millions! It is important and maybe motivates you. But I wish there are also happier days in your sight!
always keep in mind that wars often, if not always not what we think. One side could look bad, and actually be the good guy and viserversa. It is always good to just keep an open mind, as the truth always will surface later in time. Just keep moving forward and live your best life.
@@nozhki-busha I'm coping very well thanks very much. Russia & the rest of the world are getting stronger as the Western world rots under the weight of its own corruption & propaganda 👍🏿
@nozhki-busha She should definitely go to UK and enjoy your amazing country and stay there too😂 land of great opportunities😂 great housing especially 🤡 low inflation, all politicians are very honest, no corruption 😂 just amazing life, go!!
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for watching and supporting me! Here is the second part where I answer your questions about my life in Georgia and some future plans: ruclips.net/video/BxqPx9gk_-w/видео.htmlsi=-lhNPrMbVZp6swQQ
Don't return to Russia until Putin is gone. The Soviet Union has been reborn under the leadership of General Secretary Putin. Any who leave Russia, in Putin's eyes, are traitors to the Motherland for leaving her, especially in the middle of a "special military operation." And Putin does not forgive or forget traitors.
I feel sorry for you and your family if you think Russia is the bad guy here and the West is innocent. The very fact that you think the war started in 22 tells me that you are absolutely clueless and your advice for other people not to believe the Russian propaganda. If propaganda were a competition, the West would be world champions and Russia wouldn't even make it to the finish line. Greetings from Germany, who also lived in Russia. Do you think we can say anything against the government here without consequences? if so, you are actually clueless.
@NatashasAdventures You are doing very well indeed, for your audience of imbeciles and degenerates, who think they can hurt Putin and the Russians, despite what has been proven for thousands of years and the biggest and most powerful assembled armies in history have failed, but keep going anyway, Putin described you well "MORONIES" 😉😆 Какое удовольствие, какой успех и достижение с твоей стороны и просто чтобы человек тобой восхищался😄
You are young and beautiful and the worst tragedy that could very well happen if you returned to Russia is to fall in love and then lose who you have fallen in love with to Putin's ambitions for an evil empire and war . Make a life out of the country and find your future , your family will have unconditional love and will support your decision and future.
Don’t go back, it’s too risky. You have a lot of viewers, I’m sure some can help you find solutions.
I know what it is to be "home sick." It is better to be free and alive. Take the advice of an old man. You are young and adaptable, but be happy and safe. That is the best life.
She was free in Russia as well she just doesn't know it yet.
@@_TheMax_ You are lying and/or in denial.
@@checkfactschecking I have seen her previous videos from Russia and she was traveling all over the place. Such things can be done only by free man, correct me if I am wrong.
@@_TheMax_ You are wrong. Things have changed in Russia and no one gets to travel freely.
@@_TheMax_ Ask this question to the families of those who mysteriously died
56 year old veteran combat medic. If you are safe, chill. Do you. It’s funny how fast things can change. Not always bad too. Keep busy and smile. Nothing lasts forever. You are young 20 years from now you will still be you. Patients is a virtue. Get a small dog. Love looking in on you from time to time. Stay safe.
One of the things I wonder about is, what will become of the veterans with profound injuries?
After World War 2 Stalin created an entire system of hospices, mostly in Siberia, for their "Samovar People", Russian war veterans who had profound or visible injuries.
Stalin did this for two reasons: humanity & duty for these veterans, & to remove them from the sight of Russian society. The chance of them becoming their own political force & lobbying for changes was a chance Stalin could not take, but he also could not kill them as he usually did, & at that point in post-War Russia the Samovar People weren't seeming to be interested in Russian politics yet. He didn't need them killed, only moved.
Those hospices varied in their conditions & services. Some were legitimately good homes for these people, mostly men but a few women as well. Some were less nice. Some were terrible.
They made the greatest of sacrifices for their Country. They deserved for their stories to be told wider than theirs were.
And this War will definitely see men & some women with the same profound & visible injuries. How other Russians treat them in the future will be a crucial indicator of Russian civil society's own health & wellness.
Dont be a-fool. Have you not noticed that there are no pro-Russian comments in main thread, only in answers?
What, people from Russia only know how to answer someones comments but are unable to post their own?
This is purest, well-censored, cope-prpgnda for audience such as you. Russians have it good, ulike you. Afordable living, no homeles, no crime, no gangs, no gmo, breathtaking cities and infrastructure..
@@stix2youam from ex Yugoslavia, let me tell you what west and pro-western traitors have in plan for Russia. Same as we got, deindustrialisation plummeting standard and servitude. Stop pretending you are the good guys. I have visited both Russia, Ukraine and all western countries. In Russia, only danger are courious squirels in parks, while in west one needs bodyguards from all the gangs, criminals, homeles. In pro western noble Ukraine i have witnesed such moral decay i heve not seen anywhere in world. Noble, resilient my-a$$. Nothing but cnon-foder-servants. Same as what you plan for Russia..
@@CoffeeAndPaul who is a target for this nonsese? Russians know their history and love Stalin. Is this diabolical distorsion for yr public? To make them-hate-RU even more? I see you repeat this coment many times while my are deletwd by this nice girl in acordance with freedom of speach.
@@CoffeeAndPaul Stalin put many of the forcibly repatriated Russians who had fled to Western zones in post war Germany & Russian veterans straight to Siberian Labor camps, not hospices!! It was only after 1956 that Khrushchev, after denouncing Stalin's policies, permitted the inmates to live in the civilian towns near the camps. They were NOT permitted to return to the regions that they had lived in pre- 1940...Stalin didn't have to shoot or gas the returnees. He let the harsh conditions & lack of adequate care do it for him!!
Thank you for being so open, honest, and human.
Thanks! I love your videos! Keep them coming.
Thank you for this video - I found it very informative but also very moving. I'm so sorry to hear about your friend.
La Paz de Cristo 🙏🙌
Merci!
Returning? Short answer: NO.
Long answer: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO !
My short Question, WHY???
Why draws "you" back. Remember your exit interview at the airport. Look at some of the troll comments below. I agree with you, they could easily be waiting for you with a case (instead of a guy who traveled a long way).
Obvious answer
The Russian government is not concerned with 20 something yr old nobodies with RUclips channels lol 🙄🤦♂️😂
@@js70371 One "nobody" has to serve more than a decade in jail just for having changed 7 price tags in a supermarket with anti-war slogans...
It is nice to hear about Russia from the perspective of a smart unbiased young woman, we don't hear from the media, your English is great also, subbed.
Hang in there! Greetings from Germany ❤
😂 Obviously another 🐑 from the West of Germany.
How's your gas prices since the US blew up your gas lines to Russia??? 🐑
Get lost.@@pessi6185
I will pray for Germany 😂 Russia will be fine
Germany now🏳️🌈
Do not return. People who speak out can disappear. Not worth it.
I think you are talking about the U.S.
@@bryanemmel6516in US A case is people who have problems with Clintons they"desappear"...
@@bryanemmel6516 Don't be a fool. I learnt this from advice on a Russian YT channel, ,(Agent Nesty. My R u ssian Train trip went completely wrong, 14 mins in) You don't understand what a democracy is.
Don't return to Russia voluntarily. Georgia is at least *one step removed* from being under his thumb. While some Georgians hate what Russia did and you catch the flaks from that (just from speaking and looking like Russian,) you should always keep in mind that you are actually closer to them politically in terms of being somewhat of an escapee from Russia.
My parental family's new abode in British Hong Kong (after sneaking into it) was dominated by the Cantonese. They had the saying that olden time's Beijing's Emperor banned them from calling cucumbers 黃瓜 so they had to call cucumbers 青瓜. They said: 『山高皇帝遠。』"The mountains [separating them from Beijing] are high and the emperor is far away."
It's not gonna happen. Natasha is not suicidal 😅
I love that little pigeon. Hardy birds that can weather storms just like you. You're old enough to appreciate what Russia is doing wrong but young enough to outlast this storm and help in its recovery. I'm 65 and may not see the bright future of Russia but you will. Find happiness where you can for now.
and the monstera!
Right idea, but I don't expect there will be a "bright future" in russia until she is our age or older. It is going to take "guidance" and at least a couple of generations to clear out the brain washing putler has done, Her grandchildren MAY have a "bright future" in russia, but not likely sooner.
As long as the feudal serf system is allowed to remain there is no bright future.
but its must be someting one - or too young, or old enougth. If you too young its adults business, if you old enought - you must take responsability for your decision
I am from ex Yugoslavia, let me tell you what west and pro-western traitors have in plan for Russia. Same as we got, deindustrialisation plummeting standard and servitude. Stop pretending you are the good guys. I have visited both Russia, Ukraine and all western countries. In Russia, only danger are courious squirels in parks, while in west one needs bodyguards from all the gangs, criminals, homeles. In pro western noble Ukraine i have witnesed such moral decay i heve not seen anywhere in world. Noble, resilient my-a$$. Nothing but c4non-foder-servants. Exactly as what you plan for Russia.
Thank you for answering all of those questions, especially where you mention losing your friend- I'm sure making the decision to talk about that was a hard one.
I hope you remain safe and untouched by the commissars in Russia who would seek to do you harm.
Díky!
I hope you are looking after yourself and many thanks for the life choices you have taken in adopting a moral stance. Thank you Natasha
What is the moral stance?
Please don't even think about returning to Russia. The thought makes me nervous.
I agree with you.
There's more chance of me winning a beauty contest 😂
It'S not even an attractive country - spending 2 years in Russsia , I'd say the cities are often ugly / miserable ... Housing is horrible ... most people DON'T have a dacha or a garden . In many respects , quality of life is very low and life is unpleasant compared to Europe and the civilised countries .( Weather is dreadful AND EXTREMELY DEPRESSING )
@@barbarcreighton6726 ukie stop pretending
Russia is awesome...
Thanks. It seems to me that you are guided by your principals even when it is difficult. Your work is valuable and probably helps to inspire change.
I'm glad to see you are still doing well Natasha. Hang in there and keep going on your journey! Never give up!
Interesting Q&A, much appreciated! Some of the questions were very good, while others were not worthy of a response. Your patience is admirable!
Hi, I'm from Finland and I'm saddened by what Putin has done to Russia. I worked in a factory here for 20 years, and I cooperated daily with Russian truck drivers, I loaded their cars. I like them a lot, we always had fun working together. My heart is sad when Russia has such a leader that it affects all of our lives, Russians first of course. I know many Russians and I have nothing bad to say about them. I hope that one day we can work together again and laugh at life.
Yes, my Georgian friends love Russians ... but HATE the government.
Oh yeah...surely Russians prefer drunk Yeltsin again...right?
Oh by the way, you live in a NATO country now and NATO exists for the sole purpose being a client market for U.S. made weapons.
Thank you for answering so many questions. I appreciate the perspective of someone like yourself in a world of talking heads. Greetings from Minnesota.
If you knew the state of Russia when Putin took over you would now see him as a savior.
What do you think filled the void between the collapse and Putin taking over..
The International Red Cross?? Or the barbarian?
I strongly recommend you make a life for outside of Russia. You have your whole life ahead of you. Live it free!
She is still trying to get refugee status. She wants to live free at the costs of others. No even her parents support her anymore.
Nations outside of Russia aren't free. Even Canada has censored all free speech and even access to the news. People outside of Russia are homeless slaves that live in poverty. They learn to be happy to own nothing...
@Booz2020 Free Pakistan!
Telling the truth is irreplaceable. There can be no peace without it. Thank you for showing that a few honest words can shatter a billion lies and rantings. Thank you for the peace you offer. I wish you, your family and your country all the joy it is still possible to cultivate after the storm.
Natasha, You are just the BEST !!! Love your truthful and thoughtful videos.
Natasha, thank you so much for this. I liked it so much. You said it was hard. I hope you will find the strength to do the next two. Here is my hope and care for your safety and that of your family and friends back home. Thank you again.
A moving Q&A. Very sorry to hear about your friend, Natasha. So much respect for you. Stay safe and strong out there.
I think there is another reason why countries bordering Russia do not want to accept Russian immigrants. Both now and in the past, Russia (I mean authoritarian leaders) has used the fact that there is a Russian minority in a country as a justification for invasion. And AFAIK there have also been cases where Russians, for example in the Baltic states or Germany, have organised demonstrations in support of Putin.
I think the reason is different.Probably that pressure is being forced on the civilian population to change the system.But your reason is also true
British did the same to Ireland. Many countries use that pretext (settler colonisation)
You so dumb. If That is the case than nobody should allow Germans in because they started 2 world wars or dont allow Georgians in because Stalin was Georgian and killed over 25 million soviet Citzenz.
Yes. Mariupol was flattened because it was Russified in the past.
Is it a joke? Russia is the largest country in the world and less than 150 millions people, then Russian claims there are not enough space to live?
Good to hear from you Natasha. So sorry to learn about your childhood friend. Stay strong and best of luck to you!
You're super brave Natasha and I know it must be hard. Keep it up, I wish you to be happy and safe and be able to realize your goals ❤
Please stay safe. I value your opinions and support your efforts...
dude.. she is a troll lol.. she has no opinions 🤣 weak paid troll.... she has no dignity.... she has nothing to do in Russia.. Russians don't give a damn about her :)
She's more safe in Russia... nothing happens to anyone there's thousands of critics all over Russian Social media, you are been fed lies so she can earn more money through RUclips who has demonatized RUclips in Russia... this "depressing " woman is playing on you russophobic feelings to earn money 😂.. I live in Moscow, CNN has their offices here, they spread their propaganda here but remains safe, it's because we see right through it, here's thousands of US expats just in Moscow alone 90% wants Russian citizenship that tells you alot!!!
So you value opinions over facts ??
Evidenced based facts are reality not opinions!
she's paid by CIA and Soros
Been a couple of years since I watched your content. I find your vlogs very informative, I only put them on the back burner for a wee bit, and it’s ended up being a couple of years. Glad I found you again.
No, realistically it's not safe for dissidents to live in Russia.
Come to the Netherlands. Everybody speaks English, there's a good immigration policy for refugees, and plenty of jobs.
Good country 🇳🇱 people are very nice too
She Should Move To Germany Too or Sweden..
@@fabricio4794Swedes aren’t very keen on Russians.
The reason she's in Georgia is because it's one of the few places she can reach with a Russian passport.
It's extremely difficult for Russians to move to any country in Europe. Roman (YT channel "NFKRZ") had to go Serbia twice to apply for visa to Portugal.
Natasha - you are so incredible. I love and appreciate you.
Years ago I asked if you could always say "pakka pakka" at the end of your videos, and now every time you say it, I think I had something to do with it. I love you and will always love you. Big support from Pittsburgh, USA.
Sorry that you are separated from your family. This may not be forever. It was nice to see you and your mascot pigeon doing a Q&A again. Stay true and stay safe. It’s always good to know you’re doing well.’
Condolences to the loss of your friend. No life lost in a war is beneficial to the outcome.
You are brave and strong and have endured a great deal of hardship and stress. There will be more, but you can handle it! Thank you for your continued videos.
Thank you very much for opening up to these personal questions about your point of view, your struggle with the given situation as an emigrant in the diaspora. My condolences for the loss of your schoolmate and childhood friend. War always takes lives, and every casualty is a victim to the people in power who forced them to engage in war. I hope you have the strength to get through this hard times and that your wish to return to a new democratic Russia will happen someday soon.
Keep sane and engage yourself in meaningful projects. Your voice matters, you matter, and you are needed for taking part in the reconstruction of Russia after the war.
I am looking forward to the upcoming two videos of yours.
*Dude... if you understood what kind of crap you're talking about, you'd probably be ashamed. First of all, in Russia, prostitutes, homosexuals and lesbians will never rule the country. We Russians know very well what kind of poverty and collapse they brought the country to in the 90s of the last century!*
Kiitos!
Thank you Natascha, this was a very good and interesting video. Sorry for your loss, for your friend and your country. Keep strong, doing what is good and be free. Greetings from the Netherlands ❤
An extremely brave, articulate, knowledgeable, funny and intelligent human being.
Remember Navalny before returning to Russia 😢
Who care navalny
@@carlos.gomez2023in English please.
Another CIA stooge
I remember Ukraine Spy cheif was smiling alot when Navalny died, he was happy like he was when the mocow terror attack happend, and it happend right before the election, meaning it was meant to make Putin look bad... There is a pretty big chance that CIA together with Ukraine was behind it, and it looked like Russia revenged it straight after.
Russia is a very dangerous place for people who speak the truth right now.
A great q&a, thanks. I find your answers and the perspective very interesting. I'm sorry that you feel sad when people ask about your relationship with your family. You are not alone, there are many who do not have close relationships. I understand as I found it difficult to have a close relationship with my family due to their fundamentalist religious beliefs and personality differences. I also know what it is like to be separated from family as my daughter works in China. In some ways, not being close makes it easier when you are separated. Take care and keep your chin up.
Thanks
Hi Natasha,
So sorry to hear about your childhood friend. May he rest in peace.
I ABSOLUTELY love this Q&A and your honesty in answering these questions.
I think you are really brave and wish you the best!
Take care.
Anthony
Yeah, I am so sorry for the childhood friend, too, especially for the widow he left behind. I'm not particularly emotional about people "winking out" because I'd moved so many times already so I became somewhat numbed.
Thank you for educating us, you are a brave woman.
Very interesting and informative, Natasha. Thank you for this video and I look forward to the next uploads.
Natasha I’m also from the same community as you. Please do not go back to Russia .
Your life is precious. You are young .
The world can change in 5-10-20 more years. All we have is the present and it’s in the present we make the decisions that will affect our future .
Please focus on this last part of the sentence . Sending ❤
Wow, that was a very good video, very informative.
Thanks for the update Natasha, and keep up your good works.
Thank you Natasha! Always a great pleasure to get an update from you!
I am very amazed at your extensive language skill as a non-native speaker. 2nd, your ideas are clear and well stated. Continue to improve and your life will continue to improve.
YOU are so fortunate that you are figuring out how t to follow your own compass. Best from New Zealand .
I am happy that your time at the University of Minnesota was a positive experience. I currently live in Edina, MN, which is a southern suburb of Minneapolis. I don't know why, but there are a lot of Russian people living in this area now. If I walk around the lakes or go to the local farmer's market, I will inevitably hear people speaking Russian.
These are Ukrainians. They speak Russian between themselves cus Russian is their mother tongue. Same here where I live.
Very interesting Natasha, to hear a normal person speaking of this difficult situation.
Sorry about your friend. Hope to see you again soon.
Thank you so much for your video and your open perspective on things. It certainly is no easy time for you. Best from Germany
Proud of you, (young lady). Love watching your videos which show me other places without fake news and BS. Good luck in the future !
I really liked this video, it's so nice how you have approached those questions, I feel you more mature and relaxed. Good work Natasha I wish you all the best
I really liked this video. You gave us a complete and honest picture of current political and social status and your feelings about them. Thank you.
Thankyou for answering so many difficult questions. I am looking forward to your next video. Be safe.
I hope you are happy Natasha :) I have seen a few of your videoes, and its always interesting to hear your take on things :) Much love and respect to you from Denmark
Grazie.
If the Russia police is aware of you, they probably googled you as well and found your channel. I would say Russia is not big enough for you and Putin to live in. So as long as he is in charge and this war continues, I would not even think about returning.
There is no war, only an SMO.
@@robertholland7558Riiiiiigghht
@@robertholland7558 A Russian war of aggression, by any other name, would smell as foul.
@@barreloffun10 all wars, especially those initiated by the USA, are acts of aggression and indeed smell foul. So if you blaming one warring nation, blame them all!
Yeah, of course the police have nothing more to do to catch some blogger
Good to hear your parents know that you are safe.
I’m a longtime subscriber to your channel and I liked the tour you once gave of your home and garden in, I think it was Spassk-Dalniy. And your dog Barni when you where showing your potato plants.
i understand how relationships with can be complicated and wish you all the best.
Yeah! I remember that tour too. And the fishing trip with the parents. And the students dorm in Chabarovsk. It breaks my heart to think about not being able to go back to where one's roots are. I know that feeling myself. It's the worst when you have to flee or emigrate your home. I hope that all refugees worldwide may one day be able to return safely to their homes.
I can't imagine being in your situation and don't know enough to advise you what to do, or where to go - but stay safe, Natasha. You deserve it. 🙏
Stay brave!
I'm glad you got out and that you are safe. Maybe someday things will change. Let's hope so.
Natasha, you are brave, intelligent, and independent thinking. Always support you from China! Real Russian will proud of you!
No
@@caiolima1-s9c No what?
@@caiolima1-s9c no brain? Sorry to hear that, dude
@@HaleG9 fds
@@caiolima1-s9c Kremlin-🤡
You make the strongest case against authoritarianism and dictatorships, showing how one single person can adversely alter the lives of so many people. I admire your courage to stick to your principles; unlike so many politicians, sycophants, bureaucrats and enablers who make this world a troubled place.
hahah authoritarianism and dictatorships 🤣 dude wake up.. she is just a troll... a weak paid troll with no dignity !!... what a clown you and her are... that's sick
The assumption that only one single person is to blame is naive.
@@ettoreatalan8303 I don't know who you think made that assumption. Perhaps you didn't read the last phrase in my comment, or didn't understand it. However, Putin has tremendous power and he could stop the war in Ukraine right now if he wanted to.
@@daviddb4858 Quote: “...showing how *one single person* can adversely alter the lives of so many people.”
I live in the UK, and we have a Prime Minister who married into the Oligarch Class and was not elected.....
I understand wanting to live in one's own country. I hope things will change in Russia, so you can return. But if not, I wish you the best wherever you decide to live. Canada seems like a good country to live in.🦋
Thanks!
Hi Natasha. I am always so impressed with your thoughtful presentation, perspective, and insights to the situation and questions. As an US ex-pat currently in Europe I am increasingly concerned with the direction my birth country seems to be moving in. From the heart, I wish you all the best and keep giving us your (as best you can) unfiltered view.
I am also concerned about direction USA is moving, but this is about at ferocious dictatorship that kills people like ants. Do not compare Russia fascist regime with USA. They are too far apart.
Love your answers. Love how you feel about the problems you face.
I missed the pigeon so much. :) Stay strong.
Do NOT return to Russia now. I would go even further. Do NOT stay in Georgia. Try to get to the EU. It is hard, but other Russian refugees did it too. Do it with some haste. The window is closing.
The EU Will seize to exist.
The cracks are clearly visible already.
@@JFJ12 dankjewel. I just saw prices for eggs today 5eur for 10...come to EU, such great economy 😅😅😅 noone can buy a house while in Russia families thrive😅 COME TO THE NETHERLANDS 😂😂
@thomasov2004 😂 aahhha exactly what I thought when I moved there😂 2024 moving to Hungary...
Georgia does not seem safe anymore. Perhaps Serbia.
@thomasov2004 you eat tulip’s???
Thank you so very much for sharing this video. You are very brave and we do appreciate your honest opinion
Many thanks, Natasha! Sending love and respect.
Natasha, I consider you one of my personal heroes! You are a brave young woman with a wisdom beyond your youthful years! Please keep doing what you do! 🙂
I found your honest answers refreshing! You obviously want to live your life in a country where you’re free to speak your thoughts without repercussions. I live in Mexico and find your reasons for leaving your country very interesting, but I too would leave for these reasons. I hope that you will settle down someplace where you can live your life fully and freely. Sorry to hear about your childhood friend. This happens during war,and hearing how his family reacted to your comments makes me sad that fear is so pervasive in Russia!
It is good to hear from you and that you can answer the questions we have❤. Sorry about your friend who died.😢
Hi Natasha, thank you for recording this Q&A. It must have been very difficult and I think you have given really well thought out answers. My condolences about your childhood friend. It must be so surreal to think of that. I'm also very sorry to hear that a close relationship with your family is not possible at the moment. I can only imagine what you have been experiencing in recent years, planning to leave your country, escaping, establishing a new life, thinking about your future amidst all the uncertainty. I think you have done fantastically. You have a cool head on your shoulders, critical thinking, resources compare to many others, and most importantly, you are at the right age. You are not too young to not be able to form your own opinions, you are not too old to be tied down by other life commitments. You are young, adaptable, resilient, healthy, and courageous. Home is where you are. Have hope that at the end of the darkest tunnel, there will be light
Thank you, Natasha. Your honesty and bravery is inspirational. :))
delusional
@@VictoriaPobieda Vatnik
@@spervuurproduksies NAF0 shillbots will seethe and rage
I wanted to visit Russia someday but I won't set foot there until a drastic change of government.
Has there ever been a positive in Russia after any drastic change of government, far-left or right leaning?
The current Russian government is mild compared to the days I travelled there way back in the 70’s. PS in those days there was no Ukraine.
@UCpfg7LMb-iO7HZi0aPudyYgOf course there was Ukraine. 😂😂😂 It was a constituent republic of the U.S.S.R.
@@robertholland7558 This is as stupid as saying "there's no Texas under current USA"
never come to russia, russians respect Putin
We love you Natasha! ❤ The world loves you!
It's a strange thing, but I guess entirely natural to care for people, especially good natured people like natasha. It would be nice to see natasha go home to her family but I would worry a great deal for honestly outspoken people like her in that situation.
Be happy and safe young lady. Thanks for the interesting video.
good vid, keep up the good work and stay safe always!
You did a wonderful job Natasha! 👍
What I sincerely admire in your adventure is you accepting the conflict, that is your love towards what is true and cherishable in your homeland, on the other hand non-compromisingly rejecting the evils of it.
And what I wish for you? That one day, you might enter the country of your true desire.
Пока пока!
Most of the answered questions are questions made by Russian or other trolls. It's easy to spot them beacuse they use terms like "Feminazi" as if that is a real thing. I praise your patience in answering all of them honestly and truthfully and that behaviour is what have gave this channel so much popularity.
100% agree - that term was a dead giveaway. I'd tell them to stop being so obvious, but they just can't help themselves...
it is not a real term? the phenomenon exists, why the term should not?
@@beibotanov LOL
Best wishes to you. I hope your country becomes safe again for all its people.
I'm so sorry to hear about the passing of your friend 🫂. Please stay safe.
-- YaY --
Pigeon
is here today ! Oh and I always enjoy your points of view and humour.
Thank you for continuing to share like this, Natasha.
I hope one day Russia will be a place where you able to return to and feel safe and able to fully express yourself however you so wish. Until that day whichever country you choose to reside in will be that country's gain and Russia's loss. Stay safe!
At the rate she is going she will never be able to return. This is because Russia is fighting nazis in Ukraine and they both have a history.
Poor girl. Stay strong 💪
Thanks for your RUclips work! It’s very informative!
As I understand it, international students in Russia are being told they need to enlist or they will lose their visas. So no, unless you have a death wish do not go to Russia from Bangladesh or Africa to study.
Stay positive and stay respectful. You are young and intelligent. I like that you have worked for what you have. It sounds like you have possibilities in Georgia, in the US, and Russia will recover-it always does. Respect the Army, they did not choose their situation. Your Russian culture is an asset. I keep in touch with Russian family/friends and list my accomplishments on my resume. They distinguish me from other people. I can see you work hard and should have a good resume.
Thanks Natasha. You are a very intelligent young woman. I know I am stating the obvious, but, if the police were collecting information about you, it is not safe. Anything can be written in a file or in a witness statement or complaint to be signed by an informer or someone vulnerable to police pressure.Family relationships go through ups and downs so perhaps your situation will improve in the future.
Considering that she is saying bullshit about Russian army and at the same time planning to return she is not intelligent at all. And also, she said now 'If Putin wins'. Lol it is not even a question for intelligent people. The questions are 'When he will win'. And 'What happens next'.
Privet, Natasha! Hello to all Natasha's friends!
I have avoided social media, because being anonymous make them behave so rudely. However, I was thinking about you recently, wondering if you are alright. So, I was happy to see this video.
Your hair has grown since I watched saw your videos last time. So, months have passed. I understand your life is hard now, and I can see it in your face. Outlooks is probably not the most important thing for you. But in few years, a curious and funny young girl has turned both clever world class journalist and seemingly tired adult woman.
I am thinking about what to say after all. Understandably, your videos have been serious for a long time. And I know my interpretations of your situation cannot be precise. You are doing great work and speak on behalf of maybe millions! It is important and maybe motivates you. But I wish there are also happier days in your sight!
I hope this helps.
always keep in mind that wars often, if not always not what we think. One side could look bad, and actually be the good guy and viserversa. It is always good to just keep an open mind, as the truth always will surface later in time. Just keep moving forward and live your best life.
Hi Natasha, please please stay safe. You are an example to us all! (UK)
🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@pessi6185 cope more vatnik
@@nozhki-busha
I'm coping very well thanks very much.
Russia & the rest of the world are getting stronger as the Western world rots under the weight of its own corruption & propaganda 👍🏿
@nozhki-busha She should definitely go to UK and enjoy your amazing country and stay there too😂 land of great opportunities😂 great housing especially 🤡 low inflation, all politicians are very honest, no corruption 😂 just amazing life, go!!
take her to the UK, we don't want her in Russia