They never carried on without Ian, they shouldn't have carried on when Gillian left and they most definitely shouldn't still be going without Hooky. I'd love to go and see them again, they're my favourite band, but if it ain't the original lineup it ain't New Order in my opinion.
shame on you, all the people who didn't like Bernard singing Joy Division Songs. I just read it 1Millon times in the coments and i am so damn bored of it! Ian Curtis is dead. we miss the singer he was, but he is dead, and Joy Division (now New Order) is STILL (hope you get the joke and spin the record STILL on your turntable, like I did) around and play those songs! why the face! I'm happy! And yes, Bernard is no good singer. But who cares, its Joy Division. Yes Hooky is gone, miss him like Ian :)
Not really a cover because there the original members of joy division so it's there song but obviously because the lead singer died someone else has to sing It
They did get new "life" into Love Will Tear Us Apart by changing the key to fit Bernards vocals better. Here it just doesn't work. His vocals just sound like he has no emotion behind it. My favorite Joy Division song here. It's nice they want to play it but it has to sound like he means it.
Cortana no he left, tried to sue them after they continued without him, and started his own band and literally said he made it his goal to screw over new order now hahaha I wish they would settle things out at this point in their lives but no :-/
@@RafaelRamone1990 I wish Hookie would reunite with them.Although I love the Light,and have seen them play both times they came to New Orleans.I am still waiting for New Order to come here.
feels like he's phoning it in on stage and the bassist looks like such a poser. no way i'd pay for this, would rather watch old youtube clips w/ Hooky in the band for free
Bernard Sumner doing this version of disorder is bad compared to Ian Curtis. Obviously Ian isn't around anymore but this version just doesn't live up to Joy Division classic.
Cudos to Stephen Morris for still be able to keep the insane tempo on the drums.
ikr
it’s way slower here
What do you call a drummer in a 3 piece suit?
Defendant.
a funny joke I just remembered.
@@loopedmess i don't get it
Ian Curtis i miss you
me to
Br por aqui?
Oh
Opa
So do I
*We
Rip ian curtis (1956-1980)
Ava
Just so bloody good.
Ian Curtis i miss you
Steve's Drumming is amazing on this. Watching back for the first time in while!
Disorder was simple yet complex..
Jack's Film Orchard Simplicity in its most complicated state🎵🎶
So so deep and atmospheric
The lyrics are so complex. Like tong twisters
This man is a drum MACHINE!!!
One of the most influential rock song ever!
Incredible job! Bernard's voice sounds fantastic on this and that guitar! They should play this song more often.
It’s not the same without Hooky
Was just thinking that while watching this.
Course it fucking ain't he was the heart (and soul)(sic) of the band the engine room so to speak
not the same without Ian either
They never carried on without Ian, they shouldn't have carried on when Gillian left and they most definitely shouldn't still be going without Hooky. I'd love to go and see them again, they're my favourite band, but if it ain't the original lineup it ain't New Order in my opinion.
Not the same with Ian, but a good ode to him, we miss him.
I was there! Goose bumps.
Belter of a gig that!
polewka123 somewhere near the back.
@@magiccat4316 I was...well...where I filmed it from.
An amazing gig.
shame on you, all the people who didn't like Bernard singing Joy Division Songs. I just read it 1Millon times in the coments and i am so damn bored of it! Ian Curtis is dead. we miss the singer he was, but he is dead, and Joy Division (now New Order) is STILL (hope you get the joke and spin the record STILL on your turntable, like I did) around and play those songs! why the face! I'm happy! And yes, Bernard is no good singer. But who cares, its Joy Division.
Yes Hooky is gone, miss him like Ian :)
I love Bernard singing it! Shame on ya’ll if you don’t like it. Look I loved Ian too, but to say Bernard was not good.., man that’s just wrong.
They need Peter dude. Not the same energy without him running the show lol
They still ROCK!!!
Gillian looked great there .Great airplaying.😁
bass player always looks like a fan who got invited onstage to play
my favorite Joy Division song
Stephen Morris is a machine on the
drums.🤟🏼
Absolutely is ❤
Ian curtis for ever ❤
Nailed the Baritone!!!!
Great cover🎵
Man...
Not really a cover because there the original members of joy division so it's there song but obviously because the lead singer died someone else has to sing It
Amazing
Sounds great
It's just not the same without Ian.
Alex Thorne i bet they'd agree with you dude.
Ian's voice is much better and his ability to convey emotion through it can't be matched.
jplb96 exactly
Alex Thorne Or Peter.
I came to watch again
Superb gig and great to see this live. Did you go?
polewka123 no. if i was there i will be bathed in tears til now
Step is the same good as 20 years old doing the song!
They did get new "life" into Love Will Tear Us Apart by changing the key to fit Bernards vocals better. Here it just doesn't work. His vocals just sound like he has no emotion behind it.
My favorite Joy Division song here. It's nice they want to play it but it has to sound like he means it.
i think he was trying to mimick ians voice which was emotionless
Channeling Ian !!!
cool
а то, Миша
Ian legrand
Hooky
Bernard should leave the Joy Division tribute to Hooky. #TeamHooky
Agreed
Well said
Where's Hooky?
Cortana no he left, tried to sue them after they continued without him, and started his own band and literally said he made it his goal to screw over new order now hahaha I wish they would settle things out at this point in their lives but no :-/
No offense or anything, but I am still amazed how people haven't noticed that Hooky left. It happened 10 YEARS ago, so it's not that recent anymore.
Ignorance stopped amazing me 10 years ago.
What is Gillian doing during the song?
Hooky does this much better
Robert Brown theres like a whole part of this that hooky does that they didn't play
Hell no, Ian is much better
I still prefer Peter Hook playing this song than Bernard Summer. But of course, nothing compares to Ian.
@@RafaelRamone1990 I wish Hookie would reunite with them.Although I love the Light,and have seen them play both times they came to New Orleans.I am still waiting for New Order to come here.
Disorder need Ian Curtis whatever the version !
So sad!...
Post punk =3
Bernard sounds gutless and weak singing the parts of JD songs where Ian would go psycho and belt it out
I think it would be better not to play this song, but the performance is good
Hmmmm...Barney couldn't sing JD songs.
feels like he's phoning it in on stage
and the bassist looks like such a poser. no way i'd pay for this, would rather watch old youtube clips w/ Hooky in the band for free
Live in Finsbury park is my ABSOLUTE favorite. 2002. DEFINITELY CHECK IT OUT!
Bernard Sumner doing this version of disorder is bad compared to Ian Curtis. Obviously Ian isn't around anymore but this version just doesn't live up to Joy Division classic.