Planchet Flaws, Altered Surfaces, Scratches & Environmental Damage on Coins - PCGS No Grades: Part 2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- PCGS explains four additional problem coins in part two of the "No Grade" Grading 103 webcast series Planchet Flaws, Altered Surfaces, Scratches and Environmental Damages that can cause a coin not to be graded by PCGS. Note that these coins can still be holdered by PCGS as "Genuine."
PCGS Official Site: www.PCGS.com
PCGS Facebook: / pcgscoins
PCGS Instagram: / pcgscoin
PCGS Twitter: / pcgscoin 
Хобби
My biggest issue is with the standards on certain toning not being fit for a grade. Saying it's not a good looking coin... isn't that subjective? I liked the way that Stone Mountain half looked.
Excellent presentation. Thanks for sharing!
I think some of the environmental damage looks cool
Are planchet flaws not just another type of error?
A couple of attribution errors in diagnostics but an OK video.
Thank you so much for the info
Can't see a close up of coins.
The scratched liberty hear the end is struck on a FUGIO. No big deal.
so they pay you to grade their coin...you dont grade it , keep the money and send the coin back...try that in front of me. if you see a problem with the coin then deduct from the grade , but it should get a grade....grading companies are killing the hobby
Wow good info ..just disappointed i thought some of my "error" coins i thought were unique may as well not even be able to be graded if i sent them in:-(
I also have a 1907 Liberty V nickel Perfect Details nice strike I see no wear on it anywhere. but it does not have the nickel plating, copper? The same with a 1990 Lincoln penny no copper nice strike on either side looks like the 43 zinc penny completely clean no spots of copper the little Groove around the rim maybe a flake or so with a magnifying glass sharp detail any advice? thank you.
I have an Queen elizabeth 1812 war coin and it has a slight burn and a few dents help ples :(
I have a question. I can't seem to get a straight answer from anyone, and few people agree either way.
I've read that a die clash coin is considered an error. I read in the same article that the damage done at the mint doesn't count against the grade, as that's determined by signs of circulation.
I ask, as I have inherited a 70yr long collection of die clash, variety and error coins, and my favorite coin is a little appreciated 1968 Roosevelt Dime w/ Die Clash. Not only is Roosevelt clearly on the reverse, and on the Obverse Roosevelt has two separate and complete ears, but the best part is, it has full bands, is toned beautifully, and even the tiniest of die scratches are still tall and sharp. One look at the rim tells the story, and I'd like to know if things like that should be submitted for grading, but keep in mind, I have well over 1500 error and variety coins dating from 1910
Hi Bill, you might find this article helpful in defining die clashes www.pcgs.com/news/from-the-pcgs-grading-room. It is correct to say that clash marks are not at all detrimental to the grade.
@@PCGScoin Thank You! Great reading! I know Roosevelt Dimes aren't the most popular, but there are a few dedicated collectors, and some of the coins I have, have been given hilarious names that absolutely fit ... But what gives me the most pleasure is trying to find actual PMD ...🤣 It's definitely entertaining as you spin the coin, and watch it transform like a kaleidescope 👍🤣
@@PCGScoin Oh ... I posted a video of a 1964 Washington Quarter with what appeared to be The Ring Of Death ☠️
Upon closer inspection, I realized that it was actually mint damage, and then I found two more.
Apparently, if the "ring" stays along the collar, it's the ring of death, but if the ring dives down across the top of Washington's skull, it's a pattern created by a die clash or a partial strike where the coin receives a second partial strike, and the collar cuts a groove in the die, but that's just my theory.
🤝📈
But I just saw a graded coin on eBay yesterday that had a plugged hole. It was an old capped bust dime. Why was that graded?
I see gold coins from the Brother Jonathan shipwreck with numerical grades from PCGS: please explain.
NGC Grading Standards for Shipwreck Effect Designated Coins
SHIPWRECK EFFECT A - A coin exhibiting minimal surface disturbance from saltwater exposure, and exhibiting superior eye appeal for a shipwreck artifact;
SHIPWRECK EFFECT B - A coin showing evidence of light surface disturbance from immersion in saltwater. May have some areas of moderate disturbance, not affecting central design elements. Coin possesses above-average eye appeal for shipwreck recovery coin;
SHIPWRECK EFFECT C - A coin displaying moderate disturbance to its surface from exposure to saltwater, while possessing at least average eye appeal for a recovery specimen. Accurate attribution and identification is not hindered by any surface impairment;
SHIPWRECK EFFECT - Portions of the coin exhibit heavy to severe disturbance from saltwater exposure, with metal loss affecting the design. While accurate identification and attribution may be possible, it is no longer possible to draw conclusive determinations about the coin’s surface prior to saltwater exposure.
Any are environmental damage of some sort.
I have an 1853 half dime arrows it's real thick like a proof coin would be, and I was wondering how do you tell if it's a proof coin? thank you,. wondering if you could help?. I look 4 the mint mark I'm not even sure they had 1 could not find it thank you again.
Tammy Dalton: Take it to a coin dealer or a coin show and ask ask for advice. Also a great idea is to find a coin club in your area.
By these rules ancient coins would never graded.
Chris Garner Hence ancient coins don’t use normal numerical grades they have there own grading standards
Exactly my same thinking, but someone replied to you giving some important detail on ancient coins differfent grading.
that's because they have a more historical value... especially if it can be tied to a world event like a cache of war funds/loot!
Ancients are graded totally different i believe
I have a penny and nickel dime and quarter they all have scratches same kind I heard they were made by the finger feeders and all these videos here on RUclips I only seen one
I have some scratches on some of my coins :(
Your video is very informative I really appreciate your help. Where you ever a professor?
Honestly if you just graded it ms 64 scratched instead of ms details . Youd ruin fewer days and keep your reputation. I dont understand
In Canada today, some anti-monarchists still scratch the obverse of the coin....
DO YOU STILL HAVE THE 1942 S NICKEL? I'M INERESTED IN BUYING IT. HOW MUCH? I COLLECT NICKELS AND PENNYS MORE THAN ANY OTHER COINS
Lol they grade other people's coins. They probably never owned that coin.
i have a beauty 42 nickel blow your socks off Honestly
"the old 2X2 days"? Do people not use 2X2s anymore? What do they use instead?.... And who the heck would buy a coin, "sight unseen" these days???
I recently bought a PCGS coin PCGS AU Detail Genuine Environmental Damage. looked good to me...im happy wish I knew where it was on the AU spectrum though (40603721) It will go in my box and maybe in 50 years or so my kids might like one of their dad's odd coin purchases :)
Seems like PCGS has a long list of reasons to not do their job.
True.
John Burgess
What are you talking about???? That is them doing their job
Sparky Jones: They have a reputation to uphold and they set their standards. You could try a different grader...
I think they're too picky too, some of those "damaged" surfaces don't look that bad to me, most coins were circulated like they were meant to be, cut 'em some slack! You could still grade them like ANACS does.
grade your coin with ngc is better than pcgs ngc seem to give higher grade than bull shit pcgs