News Today Debate | One Nation One Poll: Realistic Or Fanciful? | Rajdeep Sardesai | India Today

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 83

  • @strongsimba
    @strongsimba Месяц назад +9

    The ECI which cannot even hold 7 phases of LOKSABHA election with peace is dreaming of reaching the stars 😂😂😂
    Even they cannot hold MAHARASHTRA, JAMMU and KASHMIR together.
    Lets be realistic. Im not congress supporter

    • @pkmkb7412
      @pkmkb7412 Месяц назад

      Isn't it the same EC who conducted simultaneous elections in 1951-1967? Moreover, it's the EC itself who proposed this mechanism in the 1980s. Which was again reiterated by law commission and parliamentary committee on multiple occasions.

    • @kris9164
      @kris9164 Месяц назад

      ​@@pkmkb7412 Context matters. What was the voter count between 1951-67?
      Also, this is not a matter of logistics. It's about the hidden agenda to deflect attention from local issues

    • @lawrencekurbah
      @lawrencekurbah Месяц назад

      😊😊😊😊

  • @YouthIndiansTamil
    @YouthIndiansTamil Месяц назад +5

    Let see how will you bring this system in Tamil nadu .. First do the system with in one day election phase . It's Against for other political parties of democracy this path will change one two major political party in the country .. From south India I am against as voter ...

  • @VansNongbri
    @VansNongbri Месяц назад +11

    One nAtion one Election is a bad story.this Country is Democracy country.

    • @vishnu-uz3tn
      @vishnu-uz3tn Месяц назад

      shut up one election is good and bad for only khangress supporters

  • @sandipmishra8448
    @sandipmishra8448 Месяц назад +10

    This is good for country

    • @SKumar-kp7fq
      @SKumar-kp7fq Месяц назад +1

      Yeah states which contribute very little or nothing fiscally/intellectually to the growth of the nation all say that.

  • @subhash6670
    @subhash6670 Месяц назад +2

    we are already one nation. This is one more BJP election and public gimmick

  • @nandhinim2676
    @nandhinim2676 Месяц назад +11

    It will save tax payers money. Good.

    • @SKumar-kp7fq
      @SKumar-kp7fq Месяц назад +1

      i don't think so...Just a ruse to get BJP elected in places where it has least of chances like South India...

  • @emmanuelkrishnan3015
    @emmanuelkrishnan3015 Месяц назад +1

    Stop all this drama, let's have 5 percent GST for one nation.

  • @EdwardDSouza-e4c
    @EdwardDSouza-e4c Месяц назад +2

    ONOP is not practical and simply a waste of time.

  • @Aws1962
    @Aws1962 Месяц назад

    The question Ms.Superiya asked no one able to answer.
    Let say if the central govt collapsed in mid way after 2029, what will happen to the state assemblies?
    Should all state govts be dissolved in order to sync the next parliamentary election?

  • @ashwinkumar2244
    @ashwinkumar2244 Месяц назад +1

    Only news channel that's still neutral. If Modi is really interested in saving money, some one tell him to control corruption at political level, not write off thousands of crores loans, not reduce corporate taxes - out together many lakh of crores. Max he can save with ONOP is 5k crores, we tax payers can bear that.

  • @nehalmehta8124
    @nehalmehta8124 Месяц назад +1

    I don't understand Why congress has to oppose everything that is progressive and in the Interest of India AND COME OUT WITH ABSURD LOGIC THAT THEY CAN ONLY RELATE TO. Anyone who has a bit of commonsense would Agree and wonder why this took us so long to Execute as logically it would save us resources, effort and everyday there wont be elections. This is the only reason why people are leaving Congress as it is not able to Connect with YOUNG AND ASPIRATIONAL INDIA

    • @strongsimba
      @strongsimba Месяц назад

      An ECI which cannot hold MANIPUR ELECTION with just 24 lakh population in 1 day , hopes of conducting 28 states n 9 UTs.
      Im not congress supporter but lets be realistic. Andh bhak

    • @kris9164
      @kris9164 Месяц назад

      It takes more than a bit of commonsense to understand the problems with this ONOE approach, the hidden agenda of the BJP, and the way regional parties and smaller players will get marginalised.

  • @chethanpatwa8071
    @chethanpatwa8071 Месяц назад +1

    Just a few months ago Orrisa, Andhra Pradesh etc had election for both assembly & Parliament together. It was fine.
    Congress is the reason for disruption in cycle of simeltenous elections as it dissolved many assemblies which were ruled by its opponents

    • @strongsimba
      @strongsimba Месяц назад

      An ECI which cannot hold MANIPUR ELECTION with just 24 lakh population in 1 day , hopes of conducting 28 states n 9 UTs.
      Im not congress supporter but lets be realistic. Andh bhak

  • @shishupallodhi9430
    @shishupallodhi9430 Месяц назад

    हरियाणा की जनता भ्रमित नहीं होगी मोदी जी वोट तो ......को देगी ये ध्यान मोड़ने का प्रयास है.....

  • @mudukkurfarms3376
    @mudukkurfarms3376 Месяц назад

    Did Congress n Indra Gandhi had CONSENSUS to impose Emergency???

  • @rajeshx1983
    @rajeshx1983 Месяц назад +6

    First try to conduct election in one day through out India instead of phases🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @cricketforever1841
      @cricketforever1841 Месяц назад +3

      Mr genius, you are living in a country of 1.5 billion. Even uS don’t conduct election in one day. Jab nasha utar jaye tab baat kario.

    • @vidyadharnprabhu
      @vidyadharnprabhu Месяц назад

      ​@@cricketforever1841😂😂😂👌👌

    • @rajeshx1983
      @rajeshx1983 Месяц назад

      @@cricketforever1841 aray londe tum konse nashe me tho how india had voted elections 20 years before. Do research and comment🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @utkarshsingh8686
    @utkarshsingh8686 Месяц назад

    As a tax payer I am in support of this move by the government.....I want 5 years of peace and development instead of elections every month.....in all big democracies like USA....if they have simultaneous elections then why can't we?...no matter what congress is saying.... one nation one election is important for the country

    • @kris9164
      @kris9164 Месяц назад

      Only morons will not notice the fact that the USA has midterm elections and various local body elections at different times

  • @jvince3971
    @jvince3971 Месяц назад

    One Nation,one election one big golmaal 😁😀😃

  • @mudukkurfarms3376
    @mudukkurfarms3376 Месяц назад

    Congress talking ig Constitution...which amended for personal reasons

  • @mudukkurfarms3376
    @mudukkurfarms3376 Месяц назад

    The Opposition is opposing this to remain relevant till 2029...People will see through their games soon ..once the Govt throws it for public debate with clàrifications n justification..with facts n figures

  • @langshenk8426
    @langshenk8426 Месяц назад

    DMK made a good point.

  • @stanleyibkiss-vo2cl
    @stanleyibkiss-vo2cl Месяц назад

    Rajdeep you argue both sides but why do you have to say "there are those who say..." u say yourself yaar. U say it well

  • @RajeshR-sq7mh
    @RajeshR-sq7mh Месяц назад

    Politicians feel that Election is for Politicians(Political Parties) and not for people of Bharat. That is the reason why one nation and one election was not even attempted. Still there is opposition. Very sad.

  • @sanjibanroy-ev5sq
    @sanjibanroy-ev5sq Месяц назад

    The Union Cabinet on Wednesday approved the recommendations of the high-level committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind regarding “One Nation, One Election”; thus, ‘initiating the process for simultaneous polls across the country.’ With this, the BJP’s long-standing idea and manifesto promise of holding all elections simultaneously in the country gets a significant push.
    Earlier in March this year, the eight-member committee’s report suggested that Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections be held together, followed by local body polls within 100 days. However, it needs political consensus, followed by constitutional amendments to align Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections; along with, preparing a common electoral roll for all elections.
    Although, an exact timeline is not yet given, a Bill is likely to be brought in the upcoming Winter Session of Parliament.

  • @tapashsengupta-lu7st
    @tapashsengupta-lu7st Месяц назад

    It is NDA not Modi 3

  • @kris9164
    @kris9164 Месяц назад +1

    To all those who are blindly supporting the BJP for ONOE, if you guys had even an iota of common sense, you would instead question their agenda behind ONOE.
    When they have time and again destabilized govts by horse trading, and using ED and CBI, what outcome besides political gains and marginalizing opposition do you see with this move?
    Why have they not included provisions to implement the anti-defection law in spirit? Doesn't that explain it all?
    In our dysfunctional democracy, the only time a voter matters is election day and ONOE will take this away. The BJP knows it can't win state-level elections, where local issues become the focal point, as easily it wins the national election. Hence the plan to make elections more presidential style than they already are.

    • @subhashbalaji-pe8tg
      @subhashbalaji-pe8tg Месяц назад

      @kris9164 first you tell me what's is your bloody problem with you. R u khangress agent..

    • @kris9164
      @kris9164 Месяц назад

      @@subhashbalaji-pe8tg Is calling people with common sense congress agents your only job?

    • @subhashbalaji-pe8tg
      @subhashbalaji-pe8tg Месяц назад

      @@kris9164 you dont have common sense here and you are telling on me.

    • @subhashbalaji-pe8tg
      @subhashbalaji-pe8tg Месяц назад

      @@kris9164 see uneducated bruths like you doesn't know the reality. To get good leadership skills honesty hopes and trust is enough for a common. Modi ji is common man like us. If you have any problem with modi ji go and put case in Supreme Court. Just keep your bloody mouth shut and don't talk as if you came from directly heaven.

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 Месяц назад

    Bibah vs love.

  • @v.pummer5143
    @v.pummer5143 Месяц назад

    Wich election commissione state pols result un abil declared until week.

  • @arpitkumar9410
    @arpitkumar9410 Месяц назад

    👌

  • @prasathnarayanan3057
    @prasathnarayanan3057 Месяц назад +1

    Saravan tis is not ooooopi channel mind it😍

  • @arpitkumar9410
    @arpitkumar9410 Месяц назад

    👏

  • @k.r.seetharaman8855
    @k.r.seetharaman8855 Месяц назад

    ONOP has been done in 1952 /57/62.
    So its nothing new.
    If it had been done earlier,it can be done now and in future.
    So guys don't waste your time by listening to these bafoons

  • @tamoghnadas8581
    @tamoghnadas8581 Месяц назад

    7 phase mein ek loksabha krwate h aur chale 29 states ka eksath karwane
    Putin k sath jyada costi ka asar dikh rha h😂

  • @muktaashok7843
    @muktaashok7843 Месяц назад

    Not 29 states. Rajdeep

  • @pinkykonsam4169
    @pinkykonsam4169 Месяц назад

    How many money will save please someone tell me...

    • @shishupallodhi9430
      @shishupallodhi9430 Месяц назад

      वो अंबानी अडानी को देगा इसलिए नहीं बता रहा कोई

  • @ShubhamSinghBelhari
    @ShubhamSinghBelhari Месяц назад

    one nation one election is need of the hour.

  • @RanjanKumar-ei4xl
    @RanjanKumar-ei4xl Месяц назад

    Chhusia

  • @rajkothari7999
    @rajkothari7999 Месяц назад +1

    Mr Sardesai again shows his one sided views. What is right for the country? Politicians need to focus on their job . Costs?

  • @unkalpaddy16121
    @unkalpaddy16121 Месяц назад

    One Nation One Election is something everyone should work towards it and make it happen. Economic savings aside, even if it takes 6 months to finish the election, it leaves clear 4.5 years for the Govt machinery to work. At present, there is less than 100 days in a year when we are free from elections

  • @thankappangireesan6173
    @thankappangireesan6173 Месяц назад

    ONE NATION ONE ELECTION INTENTION IS GOOD FOR THE PEOPLE OF INDIA AND THEIR GROWTH. INDI COALITION PARTIES ARE TRYING TO UNDERMINING THE INDIA PROGRESS AND PROSPERITY.

  • @Kals1005
    @Kals1005 Месяц назад +4

    Supriya shrinate is always screaming pointlessly😂😂😂😂just following her master's footsteps

    • @arupksinha
      @arupksinha Месяц назад

      Congress had introduced one election system in 1951 to 1967. Now they oppose it. More elections, more loot and use of black money !

    • @Vijay-oz3sr
      @Vijay-oz3sr Месяц назад

      Totally agree with you, she's absolutely irritating to listen to 😂

    • @Rajesh_Chaudhry069
      @Rajesh_Chaudhry069 Месяц назад

      Thin woman is so shameless...it had no other work except abusing Modi .. such spokesperson s shouldn't be allowed to take part in debates.

    • @strongsimba
      @strongsimba Месяц назад

      An ECI which cannot hold MANIPUR ELECTION with just 24 lakh population in 1 day , hopes of conducting 28 states n 9 UTs.
      Im not congress supporter but lets be realistic. Andh bhak

  • @nigelgomez3705
    @nigelgomez3705 Месяц назад

    Rajdeep ultimately Modi ji is saab ka Baap. It will be passed. His name is Modi ji. Did'nt you Guy's see how Modi ji was elected for the Third Term as a P. M. Which he has created history. Congress are a Lost Party which will not see the day light of ruling till 2055.

    • @soundar4270
      @soundar4270 Месяц назад

      Yes. 2/3 MPs support will come from Pakistan , Srilanka, Nepal Parliament to pass 1 Nation 1 Poll in Indian Parliament

    • @rakee007rr
      @rakee007rr Месяц назад

      2/3 mps present and voting and among them 50% is enough. Please first read the constitution and understand the amendment procedure properly

    • @soundar4270
      @soundar4270 Месяц назад

      @ rakee007rr
      Feku mental. First You read constitution.
      NDA has already majority in both Houses.
      For making new Law, 50% simple majority is sufficient.
      For changing the Existing Law, 2/3 majority is required

    • @rakee007rr
      @rakee007rr Месяц назад

      @@soundar4270 boss dk... That's what I said. Educated fools. Try to understand what has been written. Then give reply...

  • @Vijay-oz3sr
    @Vijay-oz3sr Месяц назад +1

    All support for One nation one election

  • @sharanyanaidu8033
    @sharanyanaidu8033 Месяц назад +1

    It's realistic and administration will be more effective and economically less burden