"Worst Medical Scandal In History!" Michael Shellenberger | The Winston Marshall Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 мар 2024
- WPATH Files - “What we’re dealing with here is one of the worst medical mistreatment scandals in human history…. And maybe the worst”
Journalist Michael Shellenberger sits down with me to dive into the recently published WPATH files. What did Mia Hughes and the team at Environmental Progress discover in the leaked documents and videos from so-called "World Professional Association For Transgender Health"?
The truth about "gender-affirming care" finally exposed and the revelations of the report are horrific...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUDIO
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/3Ess...
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast...
Linktree: linktr.ee/winstonmarshall
FOR SHELLENBERGER : public.substack.com
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE:
If you're liking the show and want to stay updated, don't forget to subscribe to our RUclips channel! Simply hit the 'Subscribe' button below the video, and then click the bell icon to ensure you get all our notifications. Thanks for your support!
FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
Substack: www.winstonmarshall.co.uk/
X: / mrwinmarshall
Insta: / winstonmarshall
Linktree: linktr.ee/winstonmarshall
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/giulio-fazio/hig...
License code: XJHOA7GFA9DH5G25
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#wpath #wpathfiles #trans #gender #genderequality #genderdysphoria #medicine #transition #woke #corruption #abuse #twitter #detransition
Thanks for watching - if you want to support the show, so that I can bring on more great guests like Michael Shellenberger discussing important issues ignored by MSM, please remember to subscribe!
Thank you for the enlightening conversations.
Winston, I really expect someone of your calibre to include chapters so that viewers can see the specific topics covered and click on them at will. Please.............. please start putting in chapters.
Winston - I've been watching you since you were Spectator TV. Your new endeavor (yes, I'm just an American and spell endeavor without a u) promises to be a resounding success!
It has been so far.
Thank you for this! I was a tomboy and if I'd been born in 2000 or later, I would've been misdiagnosed as a trans boy. As a little girl, I even used to go to bed every night and pray I'd wake up in a boy's body.
Now, I'm grateful to have an intact woman's body, and I'm so worried for kids like I was, who just need time for their mental and emotional maturity to catch up to their physical maturity.
Thank you Winston for having these very important conversations. Your guests of late have been amazing. Well done 😊
I don’t say this lightly. All of those medical professionals belong in prison.
These are not physicians. They are conducting medical experimentation. They are in violation of their ethical oaths. That cannot be litigated. The US threw away it's moral foundation by valuing money through citizens united over human life. Every single human service profession needs to go before an ethical review board. Our policies at the federal level have succeeded in blurring boundaries between mental illness and a healthy health care system. This is human mutilation without ethics.
They are the reincarnation of Josef Mengele.
I am pretty sure that criminal law in many countries would easily make that possible if only the political will to procecute was there.The day will come.
Also watch. WHAT IS A WOMAN by Matt Walsh. It is eye opening.
No shit!
My own daughter called me a TERF when I tried to talk to her about trans ideology. She’s a child psychologist in the Bay Area, doctorate from San Francisco. The indoctrination runs deep.
Edit: thank you for all the feedback. For clarity, she called me a TERF when I was discussing trans women in female sports. She’s not involved in a gender clinic, nor has she referred any students for medicalization. My point was, this is hammered into university students, at least on the West Coast, as settled science, coming down from the medical world as proven facts. I do think she is starting to see the cracks, and I keep gently urging her to think more rationally about the entire ideology. She recently told me she realizes this is a social contagion.
Keep trying ❤ she needs you
I hope you get through to her at some time😢. Keep trying to send this sort of stuff to her!
If she's transing children, which she most likely is, there is no course correction. It is a cult. Research cult behavior for a broader understanding.
So sorry you have to go through this. Go softly with love.
this "leak" is 100% dishonest. Search "erin reed wpath files".
I've been preaching this for years. We will look back on trans surgery like we look back on lobotomies.
They’re doing lobotomies more than ever now. They call it ECT electro convulsive therapy. When l go to therapy (in a hospital) you can literally hear them doing it in the room next door. I asked about it and they said “sure if you want to sign up for that we can do it”. Yeah no thanks dr mengele. It’s horrible.
Worse. Were schools teaching normal children that lobotomies are a reasonable treatment to something that they are going through?
@@johnboylan3832 good point!
Right there with you!
@@johnboylan3832
- treating butchery and lies like reasonable care
- destroying language
- gaslighting on a societal level
- destroying children's framework of reality
- affirming delusions
There's probably more. It's waaaaaaaaaay worse than lobotomies ever were.
Our society is very, very sick. What we are accepting as normal behavior is so opposite of what is actually normal.
These so-called doctors and I say that lightly are just as criminal and butcher's as Joseph Mangala.
They need to be stopped
It is not a sign of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society.
@@marc-andrejobin7376
Precisely and for the last few months, I keep, repeating to myself and saying out, the exactly the same thing. 😊
This world, has gone mad; it's hard to find a good person, in this day and age.😢
@@dakota-rt8kd China's population is about to half over the next few decades and it has spent the decades since the one child policy bribing the rest of the world's leadership to ensure the same happens to the natural enemies of communism to keep its power somewhere relative during the collapse of Chinese civilization. We also know that our IQ has been declining since the 1850's and it'll cause the 1st world to collapse sometime soon regardless of China's departure and the sooner the someone starts talking about what we're doing about the world's nuclear weapons while we still have the intellect and time to do so, the better I will sleep at night knowing my stocks are taken care of.
Pathologising normalcy in order to normalise pathology.
At the Nuremberg Trials in 1947, seven doctors were hanged on the grounds that they had performed medical and surgical procedures on people who had not been in a position to give their *informed* consent.
I should have said *experimental* medical and surgical procedures.
In Australia, recently the supreme Court found that vax mandates were a human rights violation for this reason.
In Australia the supreme Court recently found that regarding jab mandates
My replies disappeared. It's a discussion they don't want
Be sure to read Peter Schweizer's new book, "Blood Money: Why the Powerful Turn a Blind Eye While China Kills America" to find out who's funding this trans-contagion.
We tried for years to get my daughter with severe endometriosis to be able to have a hysterectomy. By the time we found someone who would do the surgery she was 24 years old. She was just about bedridden by the time she had the surgery. No one would do the surgery because she might have wanted to have children. Now they are doing mastectomies and hysterectomies on physically healthy people. These so called medical people are the ones who are mentally ill.
Insanity. I'm sorry about your and your daughter's suffering. ❤
The courts in the 90s would not allow convicted rapists to be given what they called "chemical castration" (now known as puberty blockers) because it violated their civil rights
THIS! The same with women with PCOS or women with huge breasts causing back problems that simply want a reduction! It's a years-long fight to get insurance to pay.
It's about keeping sick people sick and making healthy people sick. Curing sick people isn't a priority anymore. Big pharma rules the whole industry as well as the trans ideology and the sicker people are, the more money they can make. 😕
Also the same with women either breast cancer or high risk for breast cancer.
I am pro LGBT, I am "anti affirming care". It's not affirming, it's saying there is something wrong with the child and convincing the child they are right.
Mutilation of a child's body or reproductive/hormones is the most disgusting practice. It makes me think of Dr Mengele.
"I am pro LGBT..." No, you're not.
I agree, I'm female and my padded bra is gender affirming.
I’m pro lesbian and gay, the rest is fantasy world, people with fetishisation. They need help not affirmation from the world that all is well. When are we all going to see and speak the truth. Stop allowing these activists to abuse the trans , queer and other minorities in the community . They are being used by a group of narcissistic people to justify their existence.
as we;ll as Dr Asperger.
The reason Mengele comes to mind is of the fact this whole situation mirrors the Nazi Aktion T4 program.
Thank God Alberta's government is banning this brutality against children.
Puberty blockers are now banned in the UK.
The only province with any common sense in Canada.
They haven’t done it yet. The secret “gender clinic” at the Stollery Children’s Hospital in Alberta still exists. The laws which allow men into women’s and girls washrooms and sports still exist. The public school lessons teaching children from kindergarten up that biology isn’t real and that there is no such thing as “boys and girls”, still exists.
These draconian changes to law were enacted in virtual secret and inspite of the UCP’s political speeches against trans ideology, they in fact have not repealed anything.
If I am wrong please let me know where I can find corrected legislation. Thanks.
💯Hapoy about Alberta. And New Brunswick I think.
100% of children can never give consent!
109% of the adults need mandatory therapy before considering . 2 years minimum.
Does matter if a child can give consent because it be illegal for a doctor to do. This is mad nazi scientist crap.
But enabling parents can!!!
Excellent point!
@@kennethmeeker6369 Trans children go through therapy as well.
Creating a group of people who will need medical care for the rest of their lives. Follow the money, it's always about the money.
The average trans worth $1.4M in their life time medical care. Follow the money.
"The love of money is the root of all evil"
it’s about money at best case scenario… it’s also sterilizing many people and getting rid of the “sexes” (aka humanity) is one step closer to transh umanist goals openly stated by elitists
@@lyndamassey3874there’s a lot of evils that don’t have anything to do with money… at best, this is about money from those at top In positions to push this
Agree. But frankly i think most will unalive themselves when they discover they were sold a lie at great personal and physical cost
Michael has uncovered another topic with horrendous consequences forcing atrocities on our children.
Thank you for being brave enough to make this information public
45 years ago, i managed a gender assignment clinic as part of my management portfolio at a major university teaching hospital. We only treated adults. They underwent extensive psychological evaluation and were expected to live full-time for at least a year before any surgery or drugs. Even with that level of careful evaluation it became clear that more harm than good was being done and our organization along with most other reputable ones discontinued this kind of treatment. Suddenly, one day this whole industry just popped up again, but in a more shady way.
Admitting that there is no way to get informed consent from a child, yet still going ahead with brutalizing their bodies is so disturbing.
Ya, can you imagine? You can't vote until your 18 or drink alcohol!
Exactly right; they cannot possibly know the long term effects. Even some adults have regrets after transitioning. Why has this all unfolded so quickly? It did occur in the past but was extremely rare; I asked a retired nurse about it and she said that... so what is going on now?
@@elizabethabbott2982 I mean.....people have always done evil things. It's nothing new. It is just "this" this time around. It will be something else in the future.
It’s like asking what gifts they want for the next 20 years, that would be ludicrous, but they aren’t harming their bodies, unlike the cult.
14:07 and 14:55 Eugenics
it's not "treatment" it's butchery, of the body, of language, of the soul itself.
It's the logical conclusion to how medicine has come along. Over riding nature's choice for being unable to have children, birth control, plastic surgery. It's the treating the body as if it's your machine you take in for maintenance.
Imagine convincing people to maim themselves. Insanity
well said
Hear! Hear!
👌
Thank you Winston for having Michael on! Thank you Michael for all of this research and the bravery to speak it out loud!! We must save our children from these butchers!!!
But remember, it's offensive to call these people groomers.
Absolutely sickening
Going through Menopause, I asked about HRT. My doctor would not do it, she said the risks were cancers, breast cancers, blood clots, DVT, Heart disease, severe mood swings, etc.. but let’s give it to young boys.
If you natural hormone replacement instead of the synthetic pharmaceutical hormones you won't have the problems but you have to have these mixed especially for you at a specialized pharmacy and they only recently started covering the hormones for me after l got mad that our ins was covering hormones for trans women but not for biological women.
Plus, it's mandatory to offer hormone medication to dysphoria patients, but, it can be a whole process for peri-menopausal women to get it covered by their insurance.
Yes, indeed. And even though it is relatively uncommon, men can get breast cancer. I am sure that breast cancer rates in males are going to rise because the estrogen does feed the cancer.
Horse estrogen has the risks. Look into BHT instead - bioidentical hormone replacement. May need to change doctors
How about we let nature take its course?
How in the hell can modern medicine promote the removal of healthy body parts, and the destruction of healthy hormonal systems as good medical practice. It's mind boggling.
Idealogical capture
Mastectomies have a similar history
It's woke
Because there's a huge amount of money in it and at the same time distracts people from actually major issues.
It's why we need salvation We have inherent evil.
As a young girl, i considered myself to be a tomboy. I played with all the boys in the neighborhood and identified with them. When I entered puberty, I was shocked that I was going to menstruate for years. It was painful and messy. But one of the issues I hated the most about being a woman was the power inequality. I was expected to be passive and to passively wait to be chosen by a man. I could not sexually approach men because I would be considered "loose" and "easy to get." I objected to the power inequalities between men and women. I didn't want children. Over time, I married and realized that I could surf, for example, something women didn't do. Later on I had children - two beautiful daughters. Life isn't perfect. We have to accept who we are and I accepted who I was and I did.
"Surf"? Puzzled.🤔
Tomboy are girls and perfectly normal. I seen mangotmer tomboy in comment fields mentioning to now be happily married. Just because a girl have some typically "boyish" interests do not make her a boy in a girls body.
This has gone well beyond ethics and is definitely criminal!
IM A 54 YEAR OLD LESBIAN AND A FEW YEARS AGO I THOUGHT OF TRANSITIONING BUT BEING A MATURE WOMAN I WAS INSIGHTFUL ENOUGH TO RESEARCH THE PROS AND CONS AND QUICKLY CHANGED MY MIND. THESE MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS SHOULD BE STRUCK OFF 😡👌!!!
Remember the Oxycotin crisis. That was a cautionary tale about what doctors will do for money
It’s not even possible. Were you going to change your skeleton too?
I have no issue with ADULTS doing things with informed consent, CHILDREN can’t consent to any of this madness
Can't say what should be done to them or you get kicked off the internet. I find myself thinking of what Clyde Shelton did to his family's killer and sent the tape to the DA(Law Abiding Citizen).😊
The hormones are very damaging in time and important nerves are cut. Chopping up someones arm for the fakest looking "dude" ever just seems like butchery at best and many regretters.
If your doctor says "you should do this or your child will harm themselves", leave that doctor that second.
yup, Emotional Blackmail. How the hell is a parent supposed to respond to that without looking like the bad guy, ya know?
Will harm himself, not themselves, unless the child is proven multi personality disordered.
@SKF358 Themselves includes FEMALES
Puberty is hard enough, these people, counselors and Drs messing around with children need to be charged!!
Puberty is a right of passage into adulthood, not a medical condition to $in on.
The fact that the President of WPATH is a trans identified male just says it all. The poacher turned gamekeeper 'guarding' the flock. How the NHS seeks guidance from activist organisations such as Stonewall and WPATH is mind blowing.
It is also the quack doctor in the Documentary "What is a Woman"
WPATH warpath? Yes, that is what they are on…
Because the decision makers at NHS belong to the same P-ring
Mind
Despressing
More like.
Not good.
😞
WPATH is well connected to a number of very wealthy people with an agenda at play. If this is ever broken open - if people in power are brave enough to do it - there’s going to be so many lawsuits and I hope some criminal charges pressed.
Instead of being called WPATH, should be called PSYCOPATH
My W(ar) against WPATH!
Wackopath
Best comment
There is a 40 page book online called "Brainwashing: A Synthesis of the Russian Textbook on Psychopolitics". It is a leaked document that explains a lot about the intentional inverting of the institutions of mental healing.
👍👍👍👍👍
Michael Shellenberger is brilliant, he understands and relates the facts fearlessly, thanks for an excellent interview, the best one I've seen concerning the trans issue.
If a 16 year old can't consent to have sex, how can he/she possibly consent to being mutilated?
good point
But that is the ultimate goal of this sick ideology: the elimination of the idea of consent. If you research, you will see that many gender activists are convicted pedophiles, many university professors that advocate for this also defend the idea of MAP (minor attracted person) etc. In California they recently approved a law that if you have sex with a minor that’s 10 years younger than you, that’s ok. It’s all connected, and it’s pure evil.
That’s the point. The people pushing this barbarism ultimately want to normalize that too. If a child can consent to this, then they can consent to that as well.
Thats one of the many goals!
I’ve read the files. One word kept coming to mind and that word is “chilling”. Shellenberger and the person who gave him the files are heroes. The decision to make the files public is on the one hand pure common sense, and on the other hand - given the times - a not-inconsequential act of bravery.
Mia Hughes assembled the report. @crymeariver. Many others have been trying to expose this for yrs and it has fallen on deaf ears.!!! This should be noted that many who come before Shellenberger have been sharing this info and been cancelled, lost positions of employment and been dismissed far before these files were shared. See all your right voter Podcaster platforms.
Hmm why cancel my reply?
Was it insensitive?
@@user-rv7ph1jl5ysomeone on another thread was saying their comments were disappearing on a completely different topic about mandates in 2021/22 if you know what I mean (don’t want to get this comment wiped)
@@LeeGee I don't believe so.. I was asking the poster to remember and note all of the women, journalists, people who have been cancelled, etc., and others that have been reporting on this way prior to Shellenberger getting involved. I think It's important to the naysayers to know the UK and Canada have been fighting to expose this for yrs., well before the USA has barely peeped about it. It's important to make the viewers aware that most people becoming aware right now are not far right supporters sans this one issue. @karadansky @sexmatters @redux
As a parent of a daughter who made a damn good effort in trying to transition at 13-15… it was hell. I NEVER allowed anything, not even a binder. On day one, ( 7 years ago), I found information that really questioned this rhetoric. I found a parents group on line, and thank god my husband was in line with me. She was the class ROGD girl. So many co morbidities, hospital stays, school refusal, friendships lost… hers and mine, school change, self harm, eating disorders, running away… etc etc. Too many therapists to count, too many meds to name. Tears shed… a seas worth. Self hatred… so deep. It took me 2 years to figure out a neuropsychologist evaluation might be needed. Diagnosis? Autism. She was 14, and her life turned around from there. She was relieved that there was an explanation for why she felt so off kilter.
Thank you for sharing your heartbreaking story. I'm so pleased you got through. You're one tough mum!! ❤️
Over indexing on being nice, as referenced in this discussion, can be the most destructive behavior women engage in. Often we trust professionals more than we should, who literally spend minutes with the child. Mothers are forever, good job Mom.
I'm glad you found a diagnosis for your daughter. They are not trying to find the root cause of this they just want to give out drugs and surgeries without proper diagnosis. It's being pushed in schools too so we have to look into every influence on the kids
Well done for caring enough to do the right thing gor your daughter.
A large portion of these girls that think that they are non-binary are actually autistic.
They’re still pushed into transition anyway
Because pushing HRT makes money
Surgeons are advertising their mastectomy surgeries on TikTok of all places
Gender, dysphoria is common in autistic boys and girls.
Sick world we live in! Pure 👿 Evil.
"Modifying sex traits does not modify sex." Should be obvious, but definitely needs to be said.
This is a crime against humanity.
Name “this”?
Fauci and Francis Collins opened the door and normalized it.
This report should be made mandatory reading for NHS Commissioners and MPs. Unbelievable, shocking and immoral- thank you so much for publishing this work Michael and Winston for platforming
Too much money and reputations to loose for that to happen ..
Well, all that money and their reputations ARE going to take a big hit anyway, so better sooner than later. AND the more money, the longer this goes on, the more to lose in paying out for irreversible damages done to human life.
Government funded in Canada 🇨🇦
Ffs
@@CuriouscatnapNot only that - when ppl with own interests (tim in health committees like WPATH with influence on WHO and DSMV) push for /demand procedures as standard „care“ and mandate a one fits all solution that is experimental, this happens!!
They already know and profit from it.
Yes, they will take care of it just like how they are attacking the damages from the Covid jab by walking out on every discussion.
I am a staunch conservative and I appreciate your stand on this as a moderate and former progressive. One thing that you may not be aware of is that parents who refuse to go along with transitioning their children, lose those kids to children's services with the State! I live in Oregon, a very blue State. But I know of another in Montana! Its in our schools and the teachers and school counselors purposely keep the child's confusion from the parents. It's criminal!
Michael Shellenberger is a national treasure.
Michael Schellenberger is a true American hero. He is a person of great intellect, courage, and moral character.
He also did a great job of holding his own against the host's political biases and keeping focus on the actual causes
Agreed!
Or at least he's a hateful transphobe with a malicious fundie agenda.
You're very familiar with Shellenberger then? Have you read the WPATH Files?
@@B99994 yes and yes, plus I watched the actual video of the doctors discussing how their patients didn't understand the full ramifications of the so-called gender affirming care they were receiving/were to receive.
I'm so glad that I wasn't brought up in this time. I was sexually abused as a very young child and wanted desperately to be a boy because, in my young mind, I believed that boys wouldn't be sexually abused. I was a tomboy with a very short haircut and a boyish manner. You can be sure that I would've been one of these confused, young people who believe that they were meant to be another sex...that God was wrong. Now, I'm happily married to a good man and have three daughters. I would never have had that opportunity had I been allowed to "change my sex" as a young person.
Pray for a son next.
@@GrzegorzDurda Ha. I'm long past a chance for that. I'll have to pray for a grandson. Only a granddaughter so far...
Thank GOD you were born before this madness
@@GrzegorzDurdaOr how about praying for a word where boys/men don't sexually abuse girls/women.
@GrzegorzDurda Or how about praying for a word where boys/men don't s*xu@lly @bu$e girls/women.
Thankyou for addressing this problem. I am disabled and am on the Autism spectrum. I called my state run health conglomerate after my Mom died because I wanted grief counseling. I had been there for assessment in the past.
I asked if they still had my record and they said yes.As we got talking, they began pressing me toward getting a sex change. I never brought it up, THEY did. This was while I had not yet been seen due to the pan demic. Over 5 hours of questions, they kept pointing out the option. When I flatly refused , she said "You should do it... you can't get pregnant" " Go for it, the taxpayers will pay for it!"...
( I had plenty of surgery due to my endometriosis... Hysterectomy was not fun).
I took this to their manager and got the run around.I wouldn't want Compass Health to treat my cat.
Next time I called, they had destroyed my record there.
Oh my god, I'm so sorry this happened to you, especially at a vulnerable time in your life, whilst grieving. Please report it to your local MP or any pertinent body that may take it further. It's unethical, coercive, manipulative, it goes against their code of conduct.
Horrific!!! Thank you for sharing.
Yikes!
This is basically a repeat of eugenics but almost even darker.
At the very least there needs to be a registry of medical professionals who participated in this. "Zero consequences" is not acceptable.
And pull their licenses.
Why is this happening??? How in the Hell can any Doctor go along with this ??? Why isn't anyone STOPPING THIS ??!! This is CRIMINAL
the thing is, a normal doctor will consider themselves a doctor first, then other things, those doing this are actually ideologues first, doctors second, they serve two masters, one that they love, the other that they use for furthering the first's agenda
Unfortunately the world is full of truly MADD scientists
Pray for Divine Discernment to recognize the secret servants of Satan, who have sold their souls for power and wealth.
"Ye shall know them by their fruits."
The Globalist Power-Elites' worldwide ORGANIZED CRIME SYNDICATE secretly call themselves the KINGDOM OF SATAN.
It’s because criminals aren’t being arrested or sued.
Money money money drugs surgeries I bet in the future we will see commercials on TV for lawyers saying if you were transitioned as a child to call
The worst part is that these physicians KNOW. EXACTLY. What they are doing. $$$
I think it’s more than money, there is a sexual perversion in all this, a level of paedophilia that involves sex organ mutation, the constant check ups… it’s so dark. The children, parents, doctors all obsessed with children’s sex organs and looking at them
Doctor take the Hypocratic Oath to "Do no harm" and to also "Perform No Unnecessary Surgery". Why is this being allowed? The AMA needs to be investigated & overhauled
Is that something that happens today?
Exactly!!!
Money, it's what makes the exception.
ALL CRIMINALS, EVERY SINGLE ONE.!!!
And I don't give a shift about being "political correct.
God, does not make mistakes!!!
It's, the decadence of a dying, World, morality". 😮🤔🤧 🙏💯✍️
The End Of Humanity 😮
What is wrong with the parents, no matter what a doctor is saying , the parents sign off on this. Agreeing to subject their child to lifelong medical treatment and life altering surgery is criminal. As a parent I’d be running the other way and fighting for my child’s health and life.
In some places, children are removed from their families by the State if the parents do anything other than affirm and allow.
The so called doctors tell the parents that the child will likely kill him/herself if the parents don’t agree to this regime. “Do you want a live ‘daughter’ or a dead son?” They put the parents in a terrible spot!
Truckers came out in their thousands to protest against mandatory vaccinations, how many people have come out to protest the barbarity of butchering innocent children. I find it disgusting that even today children don't matter.
Indeed some parents go along without questioning it, some sick parents even promote this shit, however there are parents who are blackmailed with the possibility of suicide of their children. Doctors and psychologists tell them if they do not affirm their children, they are at risk of suicide.
Why is Michael referring to Mark 'Marci' Bowers as a she? He is a man pretending to be a woman. Stop giving women's language away to men who have appropriated 'woman', it is disrespectful and insulting to women. These men are not any kind of woman.
He’s smart to do so. He’s trying to speak to people from a leftist angle. This is how the left demands people to be referred to. If he suddenly starts to behave like a Republican he’ll lose a lot of his audience and stop coming across as a reasonable intelligent person. Do you want to win this small battle, or do you want to win the war? You need to let him do his thing. You, who aren’t going on tour with your expertise on this subject, have the ability to say whatever you want.
He states that he supports gay and lesbian rights. The gray area is not easily navigated when you're not standing on one side or the other.
Yup. It’s kink. They effing get off dressing up in women’s clothes and the want to normalize a fetish for reasons I ca n only attribute to shame??? Pedophillia?? It DRESS UP FOR SEXUAL PLEASURE and the ones still pushing it I’ll bet they still have their junk
How about we all stop policing each other's language?
Because there are still monsters out there in govt, the CIA, the demonrat party, who run law enforcement and the govt. they incarcerate people and strip them of their licenses. Those people need to be charged with crimes.
The trans movement is an extension of the eugenics movement.
I’m sure Billy boy funds this as well the WEF ☠️ is they’re god
100% it absolutely is. Equity and inclusion in the UN Agenda 2030 involves this myth, plus the decriminalisation of incest and paedophilia and the root of this is depopulation through trauma and sterilisation resulting in reduced breeding...i kid you not
And it has deep roots in gnosticism, meaning it has powerful friends in high places.
@@johncaccioppo1142Sumerian Idolatry
Actually Satan is their God@@howardturner4382
Ray Bradbury, Rod Sterling, Alfred Hitchcock, and Edgar Allan Poe were never so filled with horror. Not even Stephen King. What a dreadful, dystopian prospect we have laid out before us. Heart breaking. Then again, we have Aldous Huxley and George Orwell, more to the point.
These people should be in jail. Do they even tell the patient that they be sterile...forever?
WPATH whistleblowers deserve much praise! My prediction is that most trans activists will keep denying reality. My hope is that parents will take in the new information and keep their children safe and healthy.
Yes, the whistleblowers deserve so much praise and admiration for their bravery, it can be so very risky to speak up. Hopefully, parents will access the truth in this video.
1000% when 90% of these folks are mentally ill I’m having a hard time listening to them, its like taking a heroin addicts advice on the benefits of heroin use
In California, children are being taken away from parents and placed in foster homes who agree with the school counselor to change the child's sex .
Myself and thousands of women have been screaming about this for years. YEARS! Thank you for speaking up because nobody was listening to women. Sincerely- thank you. I see a light ahead now.
Women's voices are often shut down or considered less important.This is true, but there are women out here.Fighting the good fight feminist non feminist women who understand that this is extremely important to our survival and inequality going forward.
@@roriemarie2968 Nonsense. Stop the victim propaganda. If anything women allowed this and affirmed and TRANSITIONED MOST KIDS.
@@GrzegorzDurdanope
Especially women don't listen to women
@@GrzegorzDurdaA handful of women not all women, that is equivant to saying all men are rapists because there are a few rapists.....dont treat people as an entity, there are women and men of all thoughts, persuasions, political and religeous beliefs
The people who undergo this type of surgery have no idea how much pain and suffering they will have to endure for the rest of their lives. It does NOT fix them.
which is why we must tell them asap
My neighbor and former classmate transitioned over the last 5 years. I see them outside of their parents house often, and they look SO sickly. Like its scary the difference. I really hope they are going to be okay and find some sort of recovery.
The sad reality is the damage has been done. They are going through an uphill battle aganist nature for the rest of their life. They have become statistics in this transgender human experiments with a redused lifespan.
The idea of having to keep an open wound open with 2 hrs of dilation each day sounds bloody excruciating!😨
it is just one of the shocking realities these post op. kids have to deal with. Another one is the inability of the neo vagina to eliminate the smell of expired semen and poo after sex.
what a nightmare.
That sounds like having labor dilation for 2 hrs everyday. 😮 that is horrible 😢
It's insane. I don't even feel like taking a shower some days. I can't imagine having to deal with something so intense and time consuming.
I first heard about this in a clip of that poor Jazz Jackson. Her mother is abusive af, I can't believe those channels are still doing "reality shows".
...they wish it was bloody.... and imo that alone says whether or not they are "real women".. can any natal females even imagine? guess we know who was buying all those overjoyed and smiling faces in the tampon commercials..
Huge respect, Winston. You've done the right thing - dangerous for your career & friendships, but the right thing to do.
the bigger danger would be to keep quiet about this evil monstrous behaviour
Thank you, Winston. Here in Canada public information regarding the dark side to trans 'treatments' is rarely mentioned.
My daughter was in the midst of mental health crises through the majority of her middle school and early high school years. She thought she wanted to become a boy and is a lesbian. She was dressing as a male and binding her breasts. While in a family therapy session, she called me out as an unsupportive mother, because at 14 years of age, I had not taken her a doctor to start the treatments for her to transition to a boy. I told her that she couldn’t even get out of the bed in the morning without crying and having a meltdown- there was no way I was taking her to start a sex change. I told her once she was mentally stable AND over 18 years of age, if she still wanted to be a male, I would support her 💯 and take her to any medical appointments and procedures. Until then, I would support her sexuality but would not condone medications or procedures. Within 3 months, she stopped binding her breasts and started dressing more feminine. She’s now 20, and has a steady boyfriend. She may consider herself bisexual (and that’s fine with me) but she’s currently in a heterosexual relationship. Thank God I had the common sense and fortitude to stand my ground and listen to my gut. Had I not and allowed the mutilation and hormones, her life would have been horrendous due to irreversible damage
Grateful to witness honest discussion calling out evil
I earned my doctorate and completed my hours for licensing years ago. I refuse to get licensed because the boards punish licensed psychologists who go against gender affirming care. That is why many psychologists are not coming out against gender ideology.
Doctors are gagged on vaksines.
You are brave❤❤❤
Again, criminal.
The radical center on this platform exposes what psychologists and psychotherapists are being taught in university. She has many good interviews with practitioners who do not want any part of this. Unfortunately she was in university and they blackballed her and disenrolled her so that she could not get a degree.
Every board is now like this including nursing. I am not aware of boards of social work. The psychology profession has overextended itself into legitimizing mental illness and predating the vulnerable.
Brilliant. Informative. Shocking. Disgusting. I'm reminded of a quote: " All that it takes for evil to flourish is for good men to stand by and do nothing."
Thank you, thank you. Thank you, for your work trying to protect children from evil.
Thé hypocrisie of it and double standard . When a 30 yrs old woman wants a sterilization bc she DOESNT want children, she has to go through rigorous and long winded psychological screening b4 they will perform this procedure. But they are quite happy doing this to a 10 yrs old with puberty blockers !!! Absolutely demented !! It’s bloody evil .
Thank you for this illuminating discussion. Slowly gaining the courage to discuss my concerns about these social issues with my left wing friends. Open discourse has been quashed.
Same here for me. But this is something I feel very strongly about and I will never stop!
My lesbian aunt recently had breast cancer and had to get one of her breasts removed, she had to beg the doctors to also remove the other breast that was healthy.
The doctors were suggesting things like prosthetics to conceal the missing breast, adamant that she could regret the decision to remove the other.
They only agreed to it because my aunt used to work at that hospital for years and knew the doctors personally.
How is this level of concern about even a potential regret completely absent here.
My aunt is almost 60, married to a woman thats even older than her and is very masculine anyways, yet the doctors still fought to convince her of the risks she was taking.
Comparatively here you have children with 0 life experience, a body that isnt even fully developed, multiple mental illnesses and a very confused sense of identity that is not in line with reality getting their breasts removed "just in case" and they can just "get them back later".
Very interesting and a very good point. Thank you.
My MIL also had bc, did have double mastectomy, after insisting she didn't want to risk getting bc again. Turns out she had the beginning of bc, a different type, in the "non-cancerous" breast. We were all relieved that she had decided for the double. Her age may have had something to do with the willingness to do the actual surgery, she was over 60.
24 U.S States and counting have passed laws saying you can not do these horrible things to children.
Praise God, we need to keep praying for common sense 🙏🏻❤️
26 states still doing it
@@robyn7287 We are moving in the right direction.
Cass Review out of UK helping to bring medical evidence
Thank God.
Thanks for giving Michael Shellenburger the space to, as Samuel Johnson would put it, 'unfold his legs have his talk _out.'_ In affording him the time and metaphorical leeway you drew him out extraordinarily well.
Not only was it illuminating, I also found it consoling.
Michael shellenberger has repeatedly impressed me as an honorable man. Is such a day of charlatans, much appreciated.
Not all people in a "caring" profession, are caring people.
Very few IME
How can a doctor do this to patients???!!!!
It is insane!!!!!!!!
they have thrown ethics out of the window they are evil monsters who are using permanent physical treatments to treat a mental disorder
They said “…joy in the moment…” as unbelievable as that sounds, that was one justification.
money
Yes. It's all about the money.
It has been common practice for student doctors to learn how to do pelvic exams by practicing on women who have been anesthetized for surgery, without their consent for quite some time. Women going in for random surgeries could have a line of interns lining up to penetrate them without them ever knowing about it. A large percentage of doctors SAed patients during their training, just because they were told to do so, so it's not surprising that that they would abuse patients in other ways when told that it's common practice.
Paid volunteers were always an option, but it was cheaper to do it to unconscious women without telling them. Their excuse for not getting permission beforehand was that they were afraid that the women would refuse. They didn't want them to have that option.
Only a few states have outlawed this practice.
So I don't find it surprising that doctors don't give a crap about ethics.
Wish we had this same energy for psychiatry. Psychiatrists have been abusing "patients" for decades with pseudoscientific "treatment" and society doesn't care. It's tragic.
Thank you for reporting on this huge issue. I pray that this is heard across the world and end this medical mistreatment altogether.
1.24 - WOW!! So the lack of mainstream media reporting on this is even more significant! What a disgrace
It's on mainstream media in the UK. Most newspapers, BBC, Sky, ITV and many more are showing it.
@@FemaleMatters oh wow ok, I've only seen it in some newspapers. What do you think of the reporting?
@@FemaleMatters where? Ive not seen it on those yet. they are silent as they are complicit
Women like myself, so called "Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminists" (that's how the trans ideologues refer to biological realists, fact based people like myself anyway) have been trying to get the mainstream to take this seriously for years. We've been silenced, threatened, no platformed, even questioned by police for "hate speech" over it. See people like Posie Parker (Kelly Jay Keen), Graham Linehan and J K Rowling amongst others.
I have not seen it in the US. They are again ignoring the glaringly obvious.
It's summarized in the released zoom call when the doctor asks (paraphrased) "How can I get informed consent from someone who hasn't even taken high school biology?
exactly...my youngest son is now 28 and Autistic.. children and adults with disabilites are so trusting and yet they do not completely get or understand the evils of this world. there is a special place in hell for those that mutilate a child...but to mutilate a disabled child....the anger I feel...they sicken me
Not all children take biology. Not all parents took biology. Do these doctors have kids of their own?
Nobody knew what trans was or is even now.
It should be made public and easily accessed on internet.
This is an ignorant comment about high school biology. They need to grow up themselves, and practise delayed gratification.
If they cannot practise delayed gratification then how will they ever help a child wait???
@@jayjaychadoy9226what?
I don’t think you understood the point of that statement which was rhetorical and wasn’t about the fact of taking biology classes. It’s about the level of understand a child does NOT have of biological systems and functions nor the life experience to make such decisions. It points to the fact that a child CANNOT - by nature of their age, naivety and lack of knowledge and experience - give informed consent. They are fundamentally INCAPABLE of consenting to such treatments and the full implications of going through it.
It's terrifying!!
2 very close friends who have been together since HS divorced over their daughter transitioning to a boy. The father agreed and paid for the process while the mom said No what happens in 10 years when he decides this wasn’t what he wanted he is 12. I think taking any kind of hormones and transitioning should be a decision only an adult makes and not a young child who isn’t even a teenager yet.
This has been one of the most intelligent podcast I have had the privilege of encountering in this current upside down and misguided time for humanity. Keep bringing more truth and put it out there!
The 'Emperor's New Clothes' analogy is actually more apt than is made clear here: in HC Andersen's fairy tale, the naked emperor pageants through the streets and when the little boy breaks the mob's mindless chorus of hurray, the emperor recognises he is naked, even if many in the crowd do not. But he decides to carry on regardless - adding that extra layer of truth-denying performativity we also see among the 'professionals' in WPATH.
Thanks for yet another superb episode of my favourite podcast, Winston!
The "Emperor's New Clothes" tale keeps popping up with the way things are going in society; it went back to the 14th century. Human nature apparently hasn't changed even though some may think themselves progressive, and even though we seem exceedingly slow to learn from history.
Just like Pallywood!
@@flamlingo3566What happened in 14th century Europe that people would want to deny? The decimation of a third of the population by the plague. Life was supposed to go on as normal, as if nothing had happened. Denial of reality, same as today. Morality has been cast aside, society is come unglued, but no, everything’s just fine.
Yes I have been using that exact analogy!
Actually, in real life, the little boy "disappeared". He was last seen leaving his house escorted by two burley men in black leather overcoats with wide brimmed hats pulled over their faces.
Any doctor that uses Emotional Blackmail, by saying things like “would you prefer to have a trans child at no child at all”, should be held accountable.
If a doctor says anything like that to a parent, the Doctor should immediately lose their license, due to malpractice!!!
It's really not a difficult decision, 😢
@@richardscathouse no it isn’t. They talk about children killing themselves if you don’t indulge their delusions, because they may end up killing themselves otherwise. However, the statistics actually show that there is zero difference in the suicide rate regardless. In fact child suicide was unheard of 50 years ago, when transgenderism was not even an idea. Therefore, don’t buy into this emotional blackmail nonsense!
In another you tube show a group worked to find who first listed the statistics that they're likely to commit suicude. They finally found the guy who admitted he made up the numbers as the ends justified the means. Its a lie. More likely to commit suicide after changes. This is why Switzerland shut it down.
It’s also not true.
Fact is sui**ide happens after the transition
Michael Shellenberger continues to impress me, specifically (and most importantly) with his honest and straightforward approach to the data with which he is confronted. This is truly the most valuable thing that we humans share with one another. Without this, humans promulgate chaos and progressive disorder that undermines any capacity for humans to live together. His journalistic integrity is matched by his capacity to choose the most important issues of our day and uncover the most indisputable facts swirling around these issues.
Kelly Jay Keen has been exposing this insanity for some time now. She is such a brave woman. A modern day hero! Hats off to her. And the more we expose this rubbish for the absolute gobbledegook crap it is the better.
Lets hold the professionals accountable and put them in jail for a minimum of 10 years. This crap would stop in a heartbeat.
Lifetime. All the victim have a lifetime to do as well
Today is everything normalised including social media.
If someone is medicating himself with alcohol or heroin, it´s considered as not normal,
Yet 2 billions people are daily medicating themselves with social media addiction
that creates much more dopamine in the brain than alcohol and it is more addictive than heroin.
it´s not more destructive than heroin but it can be if we don´t regulate it and do other stuff.
What batshit, raging transphobes are actually exposing is their raging, batshit transphobia.
I applaud Michael and his team on this fantastic exposé. WPATH has been a massive influence in Gender Ideology and its perverted destruction of vulnerable children and adults. It gives me hope we might put an end to this sickness 🎉
Until two days ago I’d never heard of them. So how come this is only coming out now.
How do they get off using the ‘World’???
Most people only know this stuff once their kids get sucked into the cult.
@@eleanorleech9869 yes
@@jayjaychadoy9226Because doctors from all over the (first) world contribute their (fake) knowledge/work to it. Doctors from all over the (first) world use its (crappy) standards.
Agreed, but he still refers to people like Marci Bowers as "she," which is a problem.
I had this conversation with mother, who was a nurse for 13 years in the army. She was a field medic. She was also a head nurse at the burn unit in San Antonio where they did experimental treatment for burns, and my wife who is now a nurse working at Walter Reed actively treating lots of these patients. After a brief 15 minute breakdown of the situation, my mother's conclusion was this is experimentation. My wife, who is treating these people actively had a much more compassionate response but clearly couldn't justify the concept of this being a reasonable medical procedure. In the respect of" I will do no harm quote or it's a more beneficial procedure than the repercussions. I think both of those are pretty standard in the medical field when evaluating a situation. I'm extremely grateful that such a amazing journalist and his team are covering this and I think it's one of, if not the most important things going on right now that needs to be shut down and people need to be held accountable.
any Doctor that did this in the USA should at the very least be sued into bankruptcy.
I'm sitting up here in Canada waiting for our public broadcaster to let us know about this. I feel I'll be waiting a while.
Central Bullshit Corporation.
Don't hold your breath (fellow Canuck here)
@@normanshadow1 I wrote to the CBC today and told them I've lost all trust in them for their silence on this. Maybe more people should do the same.
@@karenhunter3113Good idea, I will write to them too.
I'm a Canadian. Good luck. All MSM is now state media.
Why aren't these "professionals " losing their licenses?
Democrats are promoting this biden had one at the white house its their agenda
Because the whole system is corrupt
They are being ordered to comply or lose their livelihoods, credentials etc.
From a legal point of view, in virtually all countries with an established system of jurisprudence the concept of consent presupposes an age of mental maturity which must be attained before an individual's consent, informed or otherwise, can be legally recognized and acted upon. This should emphatically prohibit a minor child from consenting to the procedures under discussion here!
I think I should get a college credit for this. Seriously, we learn the art of critical thinking by watching discussions like this one.
After years of being de plat formed and disbelieved for calling out this madness, it is a tremendous relief to see Michael Shellenberger, a journalist of extremely rare caliber, taking on this topic. Thank you, Winston, for this incredible interview, and thanks to Michael Shellenberger for bravely shining a light on this horror.
as a physician i want to be able to say that i can’t rap my head around the idea of other physicians getting in bed with this terribleness. but after 40 yrs of practice i unfortunately can rap my head around it. and it has to be stopped. and, first things first, healthcare cannot remain a business. period.
100% Thank you for saying that.
Yes but what government can you trust to run it ? Many government departments and therefore governments are in collusion with these horrible policies and protocols
Touche!
*wrap
JUST WOW. You are an American Hero Michael…this is the most powerful interview I’ve heard of this topic and I am so grateful for your thoughtful, thorough and sensitive handling of this subject.
These procedures are equivalent to Chinese foot binding and lobotomies.
If anything is a crime against humanity, this is it!
This guy never stops impressing. Schellenberger has been at the forefront of so many important issues, sticking his neck out to inform people about countless uncomfortable and controversial topics... to the point of putting most current-era journalists to shame
My heart dropped when I was listening to the two surgeons who were operating on the tv trans child Jazz. They obviously did not have the slightest idea of what they were doing, one shockingly saying “WHY did you cut that!?” To the other during the awkward process. What made them think they could join mucus membrane to outer skin, move hair growing areas inside the body, and force blood circulation to service different areas than normal? The justice system cannot physically de-sexualize a r@pist, but they can do it to a confused child who has not yet had an org@sm or a baby.
Thanks Winston, discovered you recently from your Oxford debate. Hats off to you for your intelligence, courage and honesty. We need more people like you .
I’ve been saying this for a long time. In the next ten years, the flood gate of lawsuits against the trans medical industrial complex will make the lawsuits against big tobacco in the 1990s seem quaint. Every hospitals, clinics, doctors, surgeons, psychiatrists, universities, public and private schools, non profits, government agencies, activist groups, media outlets, governors, state government, local governments, local school boards and parents will be sued into oblivion. If I were a HS or college freshman right now, I’d study law. You’ll have a job for life.
The rise in maternal Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy is terrifying, and heartbreaking
What a great point!
This is exactly what I have been thinking especially in cases where the parents are utterly unable to accept their child is homosexual. I mean, if you believe your parents hate you, wouldn't you do ANYthing for their love. And isn't that just medical abuse of a child?
Also, I wonder if black/brown communities are more receptive to the parallel drawn to lobotomy bc these communities have been victimized in the name of medical research and progress?
It’s very prevalent among woke liberal women who are only too thrilled to have a trans child to embrace as a way to virtue signal and show how brave they are as a mother dedicated to the cause of trans rights.
Spot on.
Please keep in mind that schools call in child services when a kid speaks about changing gender. They’re then scheduled for mandatory therapy, then referred to a gender clinic. Parents are told “Would you rather have a son, then A dead daughter” The threat of removing the child from the home. Those gender ideologues have taken over school boards etc. Families have been destroyed because of this. Grateful for this to be exposed.
It's really sad that we're at a point where we have to say things like "going through puberty is a human right." So sad. This was a great interview, though.
Thank you for this much-needed discussion. Much appreciated.
Engaging in insurance fraud is how we destroy them.
Pointing OUT that they are engaging in Insurance Fraud is how we beat them.
Medical Malpractice premiums for Doctors doing this will become ASTRONOMICAL!
Yup. Insurance companies will be outraged for the wrong reasons 💰
Medical fraud and insurers forcing ratepayers to share the cost of elective procedures.
The WPATH Files needs to be a book so we can distribute it to every member of Congress.
Even members of Congress can read files. Plus, Abigail Shrier has written a book titled "Irreversible Damage" covering many of the same topics.
You can find the pdf online, as well as many great gender critical websites with loads of information.
I printed out the pdf in case the file gets taken down or corrupted.
They also tried to take consent from children in the covid vaccination programme x
Yes, as their end goal is no parental oversight.
It’s rebellion against our Creator. A move of Satan to destroy and mock God’s highest creation.