How trophy hunting works with Dr. Amir Khan
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2022
- Take action to end hunting trophy imports into the UK: bit.ly/3DTl7Nz
Animal lover Doctor Amir Khan joins HSI UK to look at how the cruel trophy hunting industry operates and why the proposed ban on hunting trophy imports is a vital step in protecting species under threat.
![MORTAL KOMBAT 1 - KOMBAT PACK 2 REVEAL TRAILER!! [REACTION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Mi2M58zEQVc/mqdefault.jpg)
Not Killed but Murdered
#Richard Johnson completely agree with you.
@@danieladipietro6341 this man is a fraud, a charlatan, a quack
peta supporter?
Killed buddy. Murder is a crime
Thank you so much to everyone who agreed/agrees that Trophy Hunting is more than wrong!
It is beyond my mind how these emotionless selfish monsters can still legally shot to such beautiful creatures only for fun and sick pleasure🤬
🤓🤓🤓🤓
They are not monsters
Repulsive. Serial killers keep trophy's.
This is disgusting them doing the trophy hunting why because they have so much money they don't know what to do with it so they go trophy hunting this has to stop the rich are not privileged
Pisses me off 😤🤬 murdered just to be a display on a wall or floor‼️For no good reason. This has to stop‼️
Indian wild animals are lucky...their lives also worth in India ..Mera bharat mahan ❣️
India is no different than the rest of the world. India has cruel sports like Jallikattu, animal slaughter for meat, dairy, and leather, and wildlife culling. All of humanity is messed up with the exception of a handful of people truly consistent to their morals who actually care about animals.
Disgusting, thank you for highlighting this.
Sou totalmente contra a caça.
It's all about the money and it probably will never stop... I was a child in the 60s and it was gorillas and elephants that were being hunted for trophies by wealthy people... we were always collecting money at our schools to help in this endeavor to keep the poachers out of areas all over the world-- probably others remember that-- teachers principals were telling us to bring money to school to donate to these countries that were having they're beautiful animals murdered by wealthy people.... Big Industry-- when will it ever stop-- just so disgusting but it still goes on-- thank you so much dr. For bringing this to light again-- I think so many people think this horrible practice has stopped...
So, what is the Humane Society doing about this?
Facts, so many people are always complaining about it but many of the complainers don’t do a thing for the animals. As well it is the humane society they are going to make it seem that all of it is bad.
I am pretty sure that trophy hunting funds around 90% of the money that goes into protecting these animals
Could you please share your sources ?
Maledetti 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😢😢😢😢😢😢💘🐾
I’ve heard stories about animal hunting. It’s so brutal! I hope it stops. ❤❤❤😢
i really like taxidermy but i completely don’t support killing the animals for that purpose alone. if they are killed for food, found naturally dead, etc, that’s okay. i like the idea of keeping part of the animal alive, having it be something beautiful even after death. but i 100% don’t like how (especially for large; endangered animals!) trophies are allowed to be traded after being made when killed for that purpose
Im.never proud of India. But in this condition am very very proud
I see nothing wrong with food hunting. My father would shoot a single deer for our family a year to subsidize enough food for all three of us and we would fish a lot.
Which.. is why they said trophy hunting lol. Did you watch the video?
Food hunting and trophy hunting are the same act with different end results. You don't have a survival necessity for meat consumption, few to nobody around the world actually does. People who live in wild settings with no access to crops have an excuse but hunting in general is strictly a business of entertainment for people who like the taste of animal meat or the thrill of killing. With the global availability of crops we have to make a moral choice to switch to them. I'm not saying animals don't die for crops, but crops are essential and taking defensive measures to protect them isn't remotely the same as going out of your way to trick, stalk, trap, and shoot an animal, which is a deliberate and premeditated act of violence.
Trophy hunting is disgusting and criminal!
Yes, I think it’s vulgar. In fact, I have a RUclips video that says James sparkman thinks. Trophy hunting is vulgar. You might wanna watch it and pass it on to people while you’re at it until I get 500 more views than I have right now please
also, @thehumanesocietyoftheunitedstates
please go help the animals warehoused at your manhattan, ny, location
Actually, I think this happens because less educations make people think that they are actually so grand and heroic for hunting those animals and showing that they are the boss.
Says someone who cannot even type in proper English. How ironic
A short way to say is
Kill one to save a dozen
Before any other discussion on trophy hunting one should understand that trophy hunting kills the animals with the best genetics in their prime, before passing on their genes. Trophy hunting destroys iconic species. Read more in the book The World As It Once Was, the best of its kind ever made.
No… it really doesn’t any more. Top males/females were once targeted by hunters but that is no longer the case. Herd and population control now govern how hunting is conducted with a keen eye on maintaining good genetics
@@michaelcook611 This is such a big lie. That is why there are zero elephants with big tusks left in most of the countries in Africa where trophy hunters still operate. On the Tanzanian side of the Kenyan border a 35 old big tusker was killed and trophy hunters lied that they killed only bulls after 50 years old.
@@megafaunaforever Old style, unrestricted, trophy hunting did wipe out most of the big “tuskers”, which is a great shame. However, game farms and conservancies who allow hunting today want to maintain top level genetics to make sure hunters and game viewers alike keep on coming back
@@michaelcook611 Some yes, some no. I know that for some antelopes and buffaloes they do take measures to keep superior genetics. But can you give me one single example where there are still "hundred pounders" in viable numbers managed by such a hunting conservancy?
@@megafaunaforever well there simply aren’t. And that is a massive shame. Don’t get me wrong I am a conservationist and want my great grand children to experience all the wild life this world has to offer. However, having lived in Africa with first hand experience of the legitimate and ethical hunting industry I can see how it benefits rural communities and the long term sustainability of many animals
People talk about African wildlife like we on an island we are the biggest continent in the world there is a sub species of giraffe in North Africa that has about 2000 left
But in Southern Africa we have a huge number of giraffes elephants and lions and if trophy hunting was to be stopped we would lose about 80 percent of our wildlife because without these animals having a worth from the hunters they would be worth the amount of meat you can get off that animal which is less than a 10th of what over seas clients pay
lol, just accept everything your told and don’t question it.
Will trophy hunters hunt their family or pet and hang on walls?. Disgusting human beings.
That's just about right ... unfortunately humans are the very worst 2 legged animal to ever walk this planet when everything is gone & the earth is reduced to a baron wasteland where money means absolutely or rather never has meant anything & if there are a few diseased humans left ...the most prized possessions will consist of finding tinned vegetables & or a stringy tomato plant .. don't say it can't happen humans have proven to be selfish ( I'm alright jack) types ever since they got spears, swords, crossbows, then guns in the hands to top it all we have overpopulated all corners of the earth & it just gets worse so it's a forgone conclusion that NO ONE LISTENS when wild animals then domestic animals " thinking about it dogs cats & other pets are on menus in restaurants in some places have diminished "Gone we will be hunting & eating each other!!💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
Nope, they would conveniently draw the line.
No more animal hunting please, I am an animal lover.🦁❤🇵🇷
hello fellow vegan
No
Elephants, Giraffes, and lions aren’t endangered…
Yeah,
Clear you haven’t done any research. The African Bush Elephant is currently listed as endangered, and Giraffes and lions are in steep decline.
🤔 Does nobody else find this off in some way? A lot of claims being made here, but literally nothing to back them up except other claims?? No data? Seriously? On the lighter side of criticism, having an aesthetic resemblance to many PragerU entries is... unfortunate, but probably effective.
Also, above all else, I can't imagine RUclips is a good place to look for social/political information. Bah.
You should be able to hunt animals that are common not lions or elephants
If there's no survival necessity for hunting, it shouldn't be done.
please be vegan. watch this documentary ⬆️ for a bit more about why
Be a vegetarian, like Hitler
No
Well none of this is true
People may not like it, but trophy hunting exists on a spectrum, with it overall covering over half of all wild land in southern Africa. A blanket ban will simply reduce wildlife's value in a part of the world where something without value quickly disappears. The biggest threats to wildlife are indeed snaring and charcoal production, not hunting. The most productive thing for the government to do would therefore be to engage with this and help encourage improved standards, not turn its back and walk away. The current blanket ban proposal is the worst of all worlds, and perhaps most awful of all, it's being doing with zero consultation with affected communities, who now are seeing the British take away access to what they see as their own natural resources - for the second time in a century. Because whilst the image of hunting is all big American game hunters shooting captive lions, the majority is very different - with a huge amount of community owned hunting areas. Seriously, the current proposals are set to cause more harm than good, and - and I speak to many many guides, conservation professionals, and communities about this - they have zero support among those who understand this area. Please, UK, think again and act with more wisdom.
This is not to say that some kind of ban wouldn't work, but it needs to be something that discerns the good/productive, from the bad/harmful. A 'smart ban' if you will. For example, one could ban the hunting of lions from jurisdictions that don't have increasing lion populations (up to a certain level - there has to be some consultation with rural communities that lose people & livestock to lion attacks), or ban elephant trophies, etc., but still import antelope trophies from countries that harvest game meat and that can demonstrate that the community has received XYZ% of the revenue. Nothing is perfect on this continent (or anywhere) - including mass tourism, which comes with its own impacts - but as always, knowledge and engagement are better than fire-and-forget moralising from a distance.
@John Shields, from where are you collecting your facts? From trophy hunters websites ?
The majority of these trophy hunters kill a lot of these wild animals in their young prime years that are unable to pass down genes.
The thousands of dollars they pay go in the pockets of corrupt govt/politicians in those African nations and to these wild conservation centers that support these ugly sports. The people and community don't even receive a dime or meat of the killed animals.
The trophy hunters, mostly americans, are a bunch of sociopaths that have no interest in conservation and only there to satisfy their lust for killing bigger flesh.
Your explanation is lame...
Goods production and expansion may be harmful to animals but they're not remotely an excuse to stack the list with deliberate and premeditated mass murder. There's no excuse for it.
It’s clear to me that your a bot, parroting all the same propaganda the hunting industry likes to.
Opinions and emotions are not facts and this is a propaganda video. I would never hunt an animal not even a pigeon, but trophy hunting is 1000% very, very beneficial to animal stocks, conservation and communities. Ban the TRADE, ok, poachers are scum. Before you listen to the nice man's sloowww voice know that the arguments made are weak and incomplete. The emotion, intent and love is very real.
lol, it’s clear your getting your information from one-sided sources.
Are you a bot, because this is all a myth.
The Dr sure is gullible if he believes anything the anti-brigade and the humane society actually say. It's always one-sided and such organisations never ever state the true facts or benefits hunting achieves. Conservation and hunting go hand in hand another (FACT!)
Hunting is the main enemy of conservation, that's a fact. You hunters don't even know the most primal things about any animal whatsoever, you just blow everything up and claim knowing how it works.
Brainwashed and stupid
Most species have been endangered due to this type of hunting lol! It hasn't conserved anything. Most of the wolves species are endangered everywhere
India and Nepal banned rhino hunting outright when there were only around 200 or so left from over-hunting, among other things, at the start of the twentieth century.
There’s now over 4,000 and rising, plus zero poaching in the species’ main strongholds, meanwhile Southern Africa’s having rhino poaching epidemics, especially where rhino hunting *is* allowed, and the total white rhino population crashed by 15% within the last couple years alone (FACT!!), and need I remind you about the whole Lemtongthai pseudo-hunting scandal involving underaged Asian prostitutes?
It’s really not that simple as you make it out to be.
@Brian Gupwell : trophy hunting is worst of all kind and does nothing to support conservation, by importing parts or bodies of wild animals and placing them on your walls or laying them on floors for fun, game and entertainment is not conservation rather promotion towards illegal trade and in a way more of poaching . Majority hunters are amateurs who don't even know how to hunt or shoot and would leave the wild animal wounded for hours that had to be shot again several times, the communities in Tanzania and Zimbabwe don't even receive a dime of food or money out of nonsense trophy hunting games played by hunters.
Countries like Costa Rica and India have made hunting a crime and illegal in their laws and yet their wildlife is thriving even without trophy hunters nonsense games for fun or sports at place, try look beyond western nations and that of Africa....
Loving animals is fine, but how do you conserve them? A number of these pictures come from South Africa, where farmers raise wild animals as a crop - selling them for live sales, hunting and meat. Over a million animals are shot every year, but more are born than harvested, so numbers keep going UP not down. The industry supports 100,000 jobs and produces more than 50,000 tons of venison per year. It is low-carbon, low fat, free range and low-water - perfect for poor marginal land. These are facts, not dreams.
To run this modern industry, farmers have re-wilded forty million acres of previous cattle ranches. Compare THAT to the Amazon. It is a huge conservation success, despite the propaganda of HSUS, a US organisation that has raked in $250million in assets from animal lovers. Should farmers kill all the animals and go back to cattle and goats? They have to make a living. And all of this is EXTRA to the 20-odd huge national parks like Kruger Park, where the tourists go to see animals, and where there is no hunting.
The only difference between a trophy animal and a meat animal is that someone takes the horns or skin home. They are all eaten or sold as medicines or parts. Its Africa - nothing goes to waste. Its modern farming.
The doctor is entitled to his beliefs, but he has been fed some pretty bald lies by animal rights fundamentalists. They don't conserve anything.
Trophy hunting is a atrocious act and having such gruesome people around is like feeding the devil.
John Nash: you're full of bullshit and your explanation is lame. I bet you are a white american trophy hunter yourself. You guys are as bad as poachers. You're doing no conservation apart from hanging or laying the wild in your home. You western trophy hunters are disgusting with your loophole values...
I'm glad in India atleast our wildlife is protected under wildlife protection act 1972, schedule 1, section 428 of indian constitution making it illegal to trade, torture, kill and hunt wild animals...sentencing upto 5 years in jail n fine...
Modern animal butchery and hunting is done strictly for pleasure, it's outdated and no longer a survival necessity. The people you blindly follow who make money off of these have every reason to spread propoganda about how shooting animals is actually good for them, not the non profit organization against animal cruelty who actually practice what they preach. You don't make money off of the blood of some individuals to help others. You're very clearly projecting as you need an excuse to justify your desire for blood sports. You help animals by preserving their lives by treating their injuries and diseases, and making efforts to protect them or by leaving them alone and not killing them to begin with, populating doesn't inherently help them, it makes more victims to be killed by future hunters and poachers. The excuse of giving people jobs is also not one to justify violence, child trafficking and drug dealing are jobs too. I won't be supporting these national parks if they're funded from the shed blood of millions of animals. Animals need to be preserved and left alone, not shot in mass numbers so that the money can go to populating other animals.
@@Hello-hz7gj Any form of animal cruelty should be considered that. It only exists cause people have always been selfish and bloodthirsty. We've spent generations building a superiority complex over animals.
@@sachinraghavan4556
Read my comment properly. First of all, man has been a hunter since before we were human - it is not "done for fun" - for some it is a way of life, for others a passion. Believe me, dying because of a modern hunting weapon is infinitely more humane that the agonising death of all wild animals in Africa.
40 million acres of private land in South Africa alone is filled with wild animals ranched for meat and hunting. Trophy or not, those animals are all meat, trophy animals included. The numbers are going up, not down, so it is simply not true to say the animals are endangered - ranchers can raise as many as you want. In the last thirty years, wild animals in South Africa have increased 20 fold. That huge industry is run by farmers, ranchers and the venison industry. Hunters buy their animals. Without hunting income, all those millions of animals might be replaced once again with cattle, as they were before the mid-20th century when there were few animals left outside the National Parks. 40 million acres of private hunting grounds also gives home to billions of plants, trees, animals, birds, reptiles and insects that are NOT hunted, and landowners protect their land from poachers. It would all be gone if the land was ploughed once more.
Across Southern Africa 1.3 million SqKms are supported by hunting concessions. There are not enough tourists to support all the National Parks now - how are you going to support that extra vast area? Talking and moaning about hunting certainly won't help.
This video is a clever propaganda video of HSUS. Dr Khan is a UK TV personality, not an ecologist. He doesn't have to live on $2 a day like many rural Africans so he can spout his well-fed ignorance of rural life or modern animal management.. HSUS/HSI makes $150 million a year selling this type of deception to gullible urban people and very little ends up conserving animals in Africa (google Humanewatch). The Kenyan speaker forgot to add that since they banned trophy hunting in Kenya, the country has lost 80% of it large wild animals (see Kenya Conservation Agencies). South Africa encourages private ownership and hunting and its wild animals have increased 20 fold - FACT. The Zimbabwe speaker quotes tourism around the big parks, forgetting two things - the people displaced by the parks and the fact that nearby locals live off tourists in a national tourist spot - elsewhere, there are no tourists to support patrols or feed people so without paid hunting (and the free meat from trophy hunts) they eat the wildlife (see CAMPFIRE project for hunting alternative).
The Giraffe expert forgot to add that of the nine species of giraffe, only the Souther giraffe, the one being trophy hunted, is doing well. some 26,000 exist and ranchers can raise more - at the moment only about 2% are hunted. They are not endangered.
Where hunting provides money and jobs, other land uses are prevented. It's that easy. Loving animals is not enough - they need practical help, not dreams.
My concern is for the wildlife and the rural people. Your concern is about your feelings. If you don't like hunting, don't go hunting. And I am not a hunter - my interest is rural economics and the hidden voice of Africa's rural people.
🙈 Ｐｒⓞм𝕠𝕤𝐌