Chinese sniper vs. American sniper during the Korean War (1952)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 дек 2022
- Snipers (2022) - Based on a true story during the Korean war. The story of sharpshooter Zhang Taofang, a young army recruit who at age 22 sets a record during the Korean War by reportedly killing or wounding 214 American soldiers with 435 shots in just 32 days.
You only got one chance to face enemy snipers on the battlefield, one shot, one chance, you miss, you die. 
Развлечения
I didn't even realise it's 50 minutes before i click that video
I didn’t even realize it was 50 minutes until your comment popped up as the top comment just now…
Same I thought this was just a movie clip
The chinese have a passion for everything long and big. Well, you understand why...
@@NineNineSevenTurbosame lol xd
Well, China doesn't believe in copywrite so it'd be hypocritical to issue a strike against this vid.
Lmao, every Chinese kill shot is a headshot like they're using an aimbot from battlefield or Cod.
More like Sniper Elite 4🤣
its called the chinese **GRIM REAPER** FOR A GODDAMN REASON BRUH
Heh, because they are the main character of the movie.
Just like every other american movie you see.
@@yalmazkhan2974 Really? There was one scene in Saving private Ryan, but it was just that, one scene, not every single shot.
Now let's be real, everyone talks about Holly wood movies being just as bad, but let's have some examples:
Platoon (movie about a young soldier torn between good and evil representations)
Full metal Jacket (movie about the brutality from basic training to war)
Apocalypse Now (the madness of man in war)
The Thin red Line (juxtaposing war and nature and the cruelty of both)
Flags of our fathers shortly followed by Iwo Jima (the latter of which did a fantastic job of presenting the war from the Japanese side).
Now there's only been one Chinese movie I've ever known to delve deep into the cruelty of war and the evils inflicted upon civilians from BOTH sides, a movie called "On devil's doorstep" wouldn't know what the Chinese translation would be though. Both the Chinese communists, nationalists and Japanese were not presented in a particularly humanising light, but it's one of the best war movies I've ever seen. Unfortunately the director paid the price for that and was hounded and persecuted by the CCCP for making that movie. That was back when the Chinese had even an ounce of freedom to express themselves, compared to now when making a movie like that would be impossible.
But hey, at least this movie is better than most of the crap that comes out of Russia about war I'll grant you that, however the Soviets did produce some good war movies, like come and see.
I like how every American is from South. Guess the southern accent covers up the Russian accent better.
They sound more British than southern
Well,
Similarly, when we see any Indians (I mean Indians from "India" not the "Native Americans") in a Hollywood movies or even a TV series, those are inherently from Southern India and mostly dark skinned (I mean much darker than an average Indian)... go figure...lol
So after decades of enduring cheesy, one-sided hollywood war movies like Fury we can finally endure cheesy, one-sided war movies from other nations.
you mad bro
its not even one sided
@@zachdaniels5626 just tired and bored
This movie is still unrealistic as Fury. But you know, you are right. American people have a whole Hollywood, Russians have their unrealistic movies, Chinese also have. Fair enough, I guess.
Nobody needs a realistic movie because it won't romanticise war. People wanna see heroes who are in fact such a bustards. For example, in Japan such figure as Siro Isii is a hero. And there's no matter what kind of terrifying bs he did, for he's country he is a hero.
Most realistic war movie I've seen is German "Stalingrad" movie. It showed the bloody mess, terrible things, and hopelessness. War never should be romantic. But as I said earlier, people need a fcn fairy tale with good ending.
@@username_2667
I am Japanese. I don't think many Japanese people view Shiro Ishii as a hero.
I don't know which country you are from, but it's a little sad that you have such an image of today's Japanese people.
It makes no sense not to use available support from artillery. That's an awful lot of snipers in one area.
Also rifle grenades or mortars.
Yes, but then the movie would just be wheeee...kaboom. The End.
@@HO-bndklmaaoooo
@@gareginasatryan6761 imagine the US snipers set their trap at night, when the chinese forces have to fight without visibility.
Watch the whole movie before any comments, please.
This film was pretty far from the actual events that took place, but they did put a lot of effort into making this look pretty good.
This is the comment make sense here! Yeah, it is a movie, not a documentary!👍
A good movie, better than any documentary.
@@Gamer-Sam no no, it is a peice of propaganda produced by the ccp to make them look like heros
The truth died the day they started to film. This movie was funded by the Chinese Communist Government and was made for propaganda purposes.
I'm genuinely impressed by how they humanized the American soldiers. I wish more of our war movies did the same instead of depicting enemy soldiers as zombies in uniform.
From a Japanese perspective, what are the problems with this movie?
#1: There is no scene where the Chinese soldiers reflect bullets, even though their bodies are made of steel from kung fu.
#2: There is no scene where the American soldier learns karate from a karate master at the Japanese base.
#3: There is no scene where the two men engage in an aerial hand-to-hand combat using kung fu and karate.
yeah fr, they should add that, they should also add drugs and lean,
Sounds like you haven't seen the sequel, "Sniper II: Revenge of Kung Furious". Its all that & more 👌
im chinese but idk about that one. ive read all the chinese history books and I didn't see nothing about karate and kung fu. ur probably talking about another scene
Why not a unicorn and a flying tiger ?
Don't be silly tigers are a made up creature 😂
I learned that US troops were apparently, emotionally volatile & communicated exclusively in southern accents & growling. How they managed to compete against such a calm, pragmatic adversary will forever be a mystery 🤷
I highly doubt any of these guys are American. Have to find to many willing to prostitute themselves for chinese lies.
izzaso ??
To be fair - we women do notice you men tend to fall back on primitive sounds/grunts while concentrating.
@@KathrynsWorldWildfireTracking That's just when we have a tough task, so we concentrate on channeling our internal spirit animal. Its normal man stuff.
Who seemingly rolled a ton and could fire from iron sights like a Russian with aim bot in COD... What a totally load of bullshit. Hey man drink the coolaid because you idiots haven't fought a single real war since this conflict and not a single one of your leaders has seen combat in your lifetime.
No kitchen utensils were harmed in the making of this movie. 😊
That's the BEST ONE of all these comments!
I seen a hole in the spoon, your not foolin nobody.
Of coz there were !! U think the kitchen utensils used here were CGI ??! 😓
@@leadsolo2751it A DAM JOKE DUDE
U got a hole in your right spoon!
my great uncle died on the same year in 1952 he was in the US Army during that time in the Korean War he was a PFC and he smothered his body when the enemy soldier threw a grenade into his trench he shoved his buddy and he shouted a warning to his other buddy by the time he was on the grenade and it detonated he was badly wounded both of his buddies carried him to nearest aid station by the medics were getting ready to bandage him up but he died in early morning hours of 11/30/1952 he passed away from his wounds his buddies told the commander to put my great uncle in for the Medal of Honor in 1954 two years later he was awarded the Medal of Honor posthumously. Charles George (1932-1952)
Medal of Honor Recipient
@@bunnyfuzzamen my great uncle saved his friends from a grenade
@@jamesgeorge960 Must have been a hell of a guy. But what a waste, he never should have been there, the USA should never have been there and the same mistakes continue to happen over and over. "Ours is not to wonder why, ours but to do or die". It's time the people of the USA started questioning the WHY!
@@ELLISRUGER8 Did RVN, '66-'67, you've got that right.
Did he have time though to wave the flag and tell the tale of the greatest nation in the world and freedom and democracy and all that stuff?
❤I am a South Korean born after the war and am very sorry to hear that.
US Soldiers KIA(1950.6.25~1953.7.27) is 36,574.
All the Heros didn't die and are not at the Graves.
They still live at South Korean people's mind and heart.
Wouldnt be a Chinese fillm without the fanatical yelling.
No really, some parts are really how Sichuan people talk in dialect
crazy how the Chinese snipers keep revealing its position thru audio cues (shouting) and still manage to spot and points its fellow men
Chinese: Use that new spoon trick I taught you
US : That old trick...you gotta be kidding me....
“That old trick” still shoots the spoon🤦🏽♂️
"That old trick, I always fall for it!" "Well, here I go again!"
Yup, pretty stupid for a “skilled” sniper.
The script called for it though.
Yeah. This is the dumbest fvking movie ever made 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I mean if he didn't shoot the spoon then they would've seen their flashes. I'm not sure you guys understand the "trick" in this scene.
The spoon was to act as a mirror, allowing them to see without getting shot. Shooting the spoon removed their ability to see, but the script called for them figuring out the positions anyways. You did not understand what the purpose of the spoon was.
Impressive how they try to make the us look both cool and weak at the same time
"We wiped out what, 20% of the North Korean population?" - General Curtis Lemay
Weak? I think not. If anything, the portrayal of US soldiers is weird. Something off about it all. I suspect this is an AI movie.
Maybe you are.
@@rjpx947 or a chinese funded movie
There is much respect for our capabilities
Zhang Taofang was the People’s Army’s top Korean War sniper, and it’s claimed he killed or wounded 214 “American enemies” in 32 days, firing only 432 shots. Assuming eight-hour shooting days, this means Taofang inflicted one American casualty every 63 minutes, every day, for four weeks-and expended only two rounds per hit-a statistic that is difficult to believe. Very Difficult.
All while using iron sights lol.
Largely because he is one of dozens of fake heros invented for the propaganda reels.
Right, and King Ill Sung shat gold, Kim Jung Il invented Hamburgers but never needed to eat because he drew energy from the sun, and Kim Jong-Un flies around on a magic donkey at night.
@@JESantaMaria Don't forget the incredible golfing abilities of Kim Jong-il, father of current supreme leader Kim Jong-un, allegedly carded a 38-under-par round of 34 at the course, with 11 holes in one - in his very first round of golf. LOL.
This might be true. In that war, casualties underbus regime side is morenthan 20x than chinese side.
I didn't even realise I was here for a whole movie.. this was AMAZING! So much drama, realism, emotions - this was BRILLIANT!
As corny as it is you gotta hand it to them for humanizing the Americans.
Something you wouldn't see in american movies
lol did they?
@@JsJdvyeah when you do you get accused of being a nazi.
@@JsJdv Suuuure
That could never happen in a hollowood film.
Even in propaganda, us army look so cool.
Really, nothing in the last 50 years didn't make you realise this?
yes, like 'Ze-Germans' in US movies.
Remember Vietnam, Afghanistan 😂
Skipper...I belive is a nautical term...i.e...navy or matines..
@@syedys. the outpost and we were soldiers are pretty cool movies idk what ur on about
Why is there always a flash from the rifle scope? The British in the napoleonic war had figured out how to prevent flashes from telescopes. Why would the snipers in the Korean war not know those tricks?
On a dark cloudy day lol
@@JESantaMaria There is that.
And it flashes with the sun BEHIND the position of the american sniper in the first scene. Watch the shadows ... ;-)
@@ralfbuhr8091 It's basically bollywood.
Cause they couldn't google "How did the British in the napoleonic war prevent flashes from scopes"
I'm not sure how this is considered propaganda. Just because the protagonists were Chinese and the antagonists were American doesn't mean Pro-China, Anti-US. It's a different perspective. Like All Quiet on the Western Front, a movie with a German perspective of the war, but that is far from propaganda.
Pretty much how the US media works, if you side with X you are called a propaganda consumer, and when it's the other way around they call you anti-patriotic 🤷
very true
Except the outrageous story about Chinese soldiers fighting unwinnable odds
@@danehampe2972 how about outrageous stories about American soldiers fighting unwinnable odds?
Do you trust the Chinese?
The part with the american soldiers speaking any understandable chinese is the least realistic part.
Not entirely.
yeah the most unbelievable part is americans being competent
It was actually comprehensible too 💀
Probably because they hired Foreigners in China
The least realistic part for me was how the Chinese were capable of putting out all those between the eye headshots. Especially considering they were all armed with regular basic issue bolt action rifles with open iron sights. Bullshit!!
@skop3609 Well they were competent enough to wage war against Imperial Germany, Nazi Germany, Imperial Japan, and North Korea + China. Almost all of which was concluded within 10 years.
That "spoon", must be for a company sized pot of rice.
Yep, rice is more healthy than hambergers or chocolate, see how many fat Yankees nowadays🤣
@@Gamer-Sam nuh uh dumass
@@Gamer-Sam China is now facing this same obesity problem as well. Its a side effect of industrialized food supply providing lots of cheap food.
@@VincentNajger1 Funny, a large portion of China is still starving 😂
how many chinesse is fat and how many americans are fat, now judge rice is good or not?
Never underestimate Chinese cooking utensils. It is their secret deadly weapons
Already know snipers aiming at them but still stand up??
Rip logic....
He know they only 2
When they got to tank he saw him
There a lot of things in this movie that don’t make sense. Why didn’t the Americans call for fire support when things started going badly? Why did Jack fear a court marshall when he committed no crime nor did he disobey orders? Why did Jack, who seems to be a veteran, fall for an old trick though he knew the trick and revealed his position? Some of the actions taken were just silly.
Despite these problems, I would say this is a watchable film. I wouldn’t get it on Blu-ray, but I appreciate the exposure to Chinese media. Thanks for uploading this.
bru what doesn't makes sense is a sniper shooting a rope hundreds of meters away 3 times
It's a chinese propaganda movie I believe so the Americans have to seem dumb
It was writen by the CCP
From what I remember Jacks group of snipers are actually mercs specifically hired by the army to take out the chinese sniper squad, primarly the leader. After capturing and placing the chinese intelligence officer they still couldnt find where he placed his detailed plans, thus made an ambush with the secondary goal of taking out the CN sniper squad out. Since they were hired they couldnt break the contract w/out fear of a court marshal and disobeying orders by retreating.
Finally jack fell for the spoon trick since it acts as a mirror, when the final member was waving it around jack thought he was using his arm to wave it and try to gather intel of where jacks position underneath the tank is. If Jack didnt shoot it then eventually the CN sniper would spot him leading to both their locations being compromised making the fight more even when before it was in Jacks advantage (since he had set up a decoy body in a more obvious spot thus making that to be seen first)
What is surprising however is the fact that the final CN sniper instead tied it around his shoe and was not relying on the spoon as a way to gather intel, and instead was using it as a decoy to bait Jacks fire so he could return fire. Jack didnt expect this because he would first think that the CN sniper is using his arm to wave it around thus he got outplayed, and when Jack fired the CN sniper returned fire to where he saw the muzzle flash, leading to Jacks demise
Overall jack got outplayed and was sloppy, likely a result of all his groups death at near impossible/unlikely shots and angles, which both teams made (from the first shot after the ambush and from the leaders "impossible" shots which were a result of good tactics and the enemy being outplayed)
My personal favorite tactic has to be, setting up a sniper aiming for a specific location you will bait the enemy to, start firing one bullet at the enemy position and roll down the hill to that sniper, since the enemy is conditioned to think there is only one person they will peek, fire, and then continue moving after each bullet from your side. Once you reach the 2nd location, continue the one bullet pattern but when the enemy peeks they wont expect that there would be two people instead of one
@@chadliu5005 Thanks for the added context.
No one ever woke up in a fight smd thought they were the bad guys.
You just do your best.
wat is that supposed to mean
@@frankyfeuilles3511 it means those who fight - both sides - do not see themselves as evil. Those recriminations may come later. But you don't wake up like some cartoon villain and say your the Army of evil.
"War means fighting. Fighting means killing."
maybe not "the bad guys", but "the worse guys" for sure. Just think of some bloke walking through a village and seeing a bunch of dead civilians, killed by artillery or bombs. The babies and so on.
Even dead soldiers. Look up "George S. Patton slapping incidents". Random Wiki result while trying to find a quote about how how soldiers fight to protect their comrades and to prove themselves and how after months they can lose their motivation, I found in Shell shock article,
_In total, 266 British soldiers were executed for "Desertion", 18 for "Cowardice", 7 for "Quitting a post without authority", 5 for "Disobedience to a lawful command", and 2 for "Casting away arms"._
That's in WWI, the war where the British and German soldiers had a Christmas truce to play football, and which originated this anecdote:
_I was having tea with A Company when we heard a lot of shouting and went out to investigate. We found our men and the Germans standing on their respective parapets. Suddenly a salvo arrived but did no damage. Naturally both sides got down and our men started swearing at the Germans, when all at once a brave German got onto his parapet and shouted out: “We are very sorry about that; we hope no one was hurt. It is not our fault. It is that damned Prussian artillery.”_
Soldiers don't have to think their enemy is the "bad guys", and if you accept that, you can see how a soldier can think their own side is worse. Even if they would be punished, perhaps executed, for taking any action based on that conclusion.
@@craykard8325Next you gonna tell them the Germans and Japanese thought themselves to be fighting for a righteous cause. That would possibly be too much to take in for a single day.
from the chinese pov, they were just giving their borders strategic depth, like israel does with the west bank. America sure as hell wouldn't let the soviet union roll up mexico and station right across from the rio grande
Chinese Spring Offensive Casualties by Nation
US: ~1200
AU/NZ: 34
UK: 141
CAN: 12
BE: 12
PH: 16
ROK:UNK
CN: 85k-90K (Chinese sources)
CN+DPRK 110k-160,609 (UN estimates)
And this is story about how all American soldiers end up in foreign missions (UA, Syria, Afganistan, Iraq, ...).
LOL Chicom propaganda film to make themselves look like the good guys.
Everyone is the good guy in their own story. The UN police action had no good or bad guys, just winner and losers. Which, no one really did either if you look beyond body counts. The winner might be Pandaland, but that is only because so many undesirables/future political threats were removed by placing them into the Volunteer Army.
Right and your movies are not propaganda?
oh you think the americans are the good guys everywhere in the world?
@@AZNinsomnia02 Do you know how you live in a good/free country? Try criticizing the government or the leader. If you get sent to prison, chances are, you live in a shithole and you don't even know it.
NEW FLASH - Every country produces propaganda to make themselves look like the good guys.
Nobody is ever the bad guy in the films they make about themselves. They might make out that some of their own were incompetent, but that's only to make the hero even more heroic.
Hollywood in particular has a long, long, long history of doing propaganda where America saves the world or where the white American settler was the innocent one rather than the invader who slaughtered the natives. British cinema is not much better. I'm Australian and our movies about war are no better.
This movie looks cool other than the Americans being generally too old for military men. Most guys are under 30.
Their uniforms are also way too clean
😂😂😂😂😂. Dude, you need to raise your standards 😂😂😂😂😂. This is the biggest pos movie ever filmed 😂
You misunderstand. The large doses of stress tends to age young men and a month of not shaving doesn't help any.
@@smyers820gm Prove it.
@@smyers820gmwell, in every Segal movie ever made, In slow mo scenes the bullets leaving guns are always full cartridges leaving the gun. In this movie it isn't. If you can get over yourself. This movie is not bad. Acting isn't bad either. They also didn't make the Americans classic bad guy goon squad.
The US military in this movie is a cartoon😂😂
Ofc its chinese directors and chinese film so its gonna be like that. I mean its kinda also the same the other way around
As they are in real life, the US made one-sided stupid funny movies for decades now and this is just the Chinese equivalent same way you watch Top gun they're probably watching this😂
No matter how hilarious it may seem to us it's basically the same thing
US military is always a cartoon.
They are heros front of un armed civilians. Thats why their socalled military harwares are failing one by one in Ukraine
in reality also same🤣🤣,we saw american army running in afghanisthan to escape from afghan people🤣🤣
@@sankisets2368 Don’t be such a retard. There’s a difference between military victories and nation building. Americans won the war militarily, but lost the nation building aspect. Same with Iraq. But don’t underestimate the American military just because they didn’t win hearts and minds.
15:42 - Brilliant filmed in the style Sergei Bondarchuk perfected in his _War & Peace._ (Soviet incredible masterpiece of 100,000 extras.)
He got the over-the-trench shots with cameras on wires, in between poles. Crew hand-cranked the cams across, trying to be smooth as possible. Amazing to see this re-created here, same way i'm sure - but also, with steady-cam hand shots too, ground level. Sergei had to use railcars in the trenches.
Sound fx - on point too! I have crappy headphones, and I feel like I'm suddenly wearing a $500 set. Incredible.
See War of Arrows, and of course, the Soviet War and Peace, if you like this.
as terrible as former and current governments are. We must not forget each man is their own; who seeks what most other men want. Joy and happiness. Regardless of the land they were born on. Humanization of an adversary is only evil to those who abandon peace.
Agree! North Korean started the war btw.
yeah, i agree
@@Gamer-Samyeah but not their population nor soldiers. Although they are the ones who fight and effectively kill, they would not need if they weren’t ordered to
@@Gamer-Sam There was provocation from both sides, if the DPRK didn't strike the South Koreans would've. It's really quite foolish to depict this conflict as Aggressor vs Victim, especially considering the horrific amount of atrocities committed by the Republic of Korea.
@@Gamer-Sam coming from an american, they didnt lol, it was a cover up, the US invaded first
I'm surprised that they didn't show him taking 5,6 or 7 seven rounds to his body and still walking out like a super-hero, or like so many other "Gung-fu" movies, flying across the tops of trees...they could have done greater justice to the "true story" by sticking to what really happened instead of the "Matrix" scenes.
Its a film, what about Top Gun etc etc etc all bullshit
I like how badly this triggers Americans, despite the Korean War being one of a few examples where their Army and leaders were on the wrong side of history. It's okay to be disgusted by the actions of the political class and military--they're not direct extensions of your identity, kids.
In this war, Chinese soldiers died for their Chairman Mao Zedong and North Korea's leader Kim Il-sung, while American soldiers sacrificed themselves for democracy and freedom.
bullshit!
@@yodaichi888 Mind elaborating?
Shut up
That's a very questionable interpretation of an imperialistic af war.
The only time that the USA hasn't been a belligerent in a war was WW2...which they joined heinously late and still managed to uselessly war-crime the Japanese(read: deliberately killing noncombatants) in retaliation for a military installation(read: largely combatants and military personnel) being attacked. Way to consistently be monsters, US military-industrial complex.
"and children, this is how the PLA liberate Korea from the the evil americans nazis ..." Its like whatching and inverse ww2 Hollywood film...
Wait, hold on, hold on....🤣 it's not "evil American Nazis" it's "Evil imperialism American". Nazi was from Germany. read more book before any comment here would ya? it's kinda embarrassing 🤣
@@Gamer-SamI may be wrong but the guy is making a reference of the US vs evil nazi movies. And thosse movies kinda full of propagandas and unrealistic. And in this movie you can see china is doing the same thing
@@Gamer-Sam in some asian, african, middle east, and american (continet) countries , the star and stripes have the same value to a swastika. Too many US war crimes in the world, too many bombing campaing against civilian population, too many Linebackers , Red thunders.
You should read a book o better: EXPLORE THE WORLD. Nobody likes you...
@@Gamer-Samwhere are you even from tf
@@Gamer-Sam Nazi was German from Germany.
It was GERMAN.
I like this film a lot, portraying how both sides committed war crimes of some way shape or form. The Chinese by faking a surrender, the Americans by killing wounded combatants
Odwróćmy role.. i jak to wtedy wygląda?
@@tomaszkluska6419 Pierwsza rzecz ta osoba ciebie nie zrozumie jak będziesz pisał po polsku, druga rzecz ty pierdolony ułomie co to wgl ma znaczyć??? obydwie rzeczy to zbrodnie wojenne, gdybyś "odwrócił role" to dosłownie NIC by się nie zmieniło
Here is a movie fact:
When it is released from a certain country, the country it released in, is most likely to survive.
Here is an example:
If it released from america then it is most likely that the American characters would survive.
100 years ago: Worse war
2024: some countries still fighting
skipper us is 250 years old and started around 300 wars.
Un-Fun Fact: The war in this film - is still going. There's a Ceasefire with N. Korea. Not an armistice! The Korean War, never ended.
S. Korea, America, and allies such as Japan - are still ready to resume the fighting at a moment's notice.
It's also why we can't sign the anti-land mine legislation yet. It's the only thing that stops N. Korea's massive amounts of troops, from flooding across the border in a tidal wave.
The reason N Korea is impoverished - they keep a more than million-man army, at the ready to deploy. Thus, the people suffer. The people's needs, are cut for the military's.
Chinese War propaganda tries not to make America look badass (impossible challenge!!)
Actually a lot of their war movies make GI's out to be extremely dangerous and well trained. its what makes their heroes all the cooler when they triumph over a competent and deadly foe.
This movie kind of purposefully makes the Americans look badass though
Every us war movies also propaganda too not different from Chinese one
@@Roamingeast Tipic
Ever heard of Rambo?
I laughed at the first headshot when he passed the Medkit😂
wow such badass
That acting is on point, on point to be the worst I have seen thus far.
Bro got hit by .30 cal and still walking fine.
.30 cal
There were no 50 cal at this age, Smartass
This is just so stupid, who'd put this many snipers in one go?
Butt hurt huh🤣
@@Gamer-Sam No sane commander would put that many snipers in one concentrated area. also what is with your comment?
Ugh... your replies to comments are insufferable. OP is making a tactical observation that you would never have this many snipers in one location. Maybe if you pulled your head from your ass you would know that.
They were meant to make the commander look insane
They really do , if necessary. Hundreds of snipers was taken part even in the battle of stalingrad and Moscow war and liberation of France after D day land .
The producers screwed up in making this movie if theyre after historical accuracy. At time index 40:38 it shows the loader reloading the browning GPMG coax with soviet linked 7.62 x 54 R, not the ball, caliber 30 of 1906 (30-06). Also the rounds are copper washed, a dead give away, typical of soviet era ammunition.
Really?! Dude..🤣 I got nothing to say, but I respect your comment here.
That's the least important accuracy!
Its very very important.
Ale faktycznie podziwiam Twoją wiedzę :)
@@Gamer-Sam "Respect your comment here", but you're salty at people not being favorable to the video LOL. Whatever you say, wumao troll.
you should feel lucky that they didn't get a t-34 cosplaying everything lmao
This is the army that used human wave attacks, allowing thousands of their own men (who were mostly former Chang soldiers they wanted to thin out anyway), and here they are spending vast amounts of time to rescue a couple dudes. Its all very silly.
Chinese propaganda video lmao
Yep, I don't think it's fooling many people (other than Chinese) thankfully
@@doozledorf7036 Yes it is propaganda, but you forgot... You are the minority not the Chinese. Most people on this earth are fundamentally non western. You should stop living inside your bubble because the world is a giant place full of people who do not share your views.
And if you think that American cinema doesn't produce propaganda about geopolitics, then you are simply delusional.
Fact read your historians..
I mean, still way better than Fury, Enemy at the gates or other western propaganda bullshit that makes zero sence 🤷♂️
@@doozledorf7036 1000 times better than the modern Hollywood crap
I'd like to thank great leader xi for not making projectiles as full cartridges in slow mo scenes.
Było tak w jakimś filmie?
Nie wierzę...
kitai pidaras
@@Syaralayu :D
The technical advice on this was pure A55
What?
@@Gamer-Sam Bro doesn't know 😭
@@Gamer-Sam You don't know what TECHNICAL ADVICE IS?
bro was like... ok I'm a good sniper, let me go and clogged up in a tank.....
Of course they would use non Americans to play the Americans.
It's hard to get American actors for stuff like this. English actors are more available. At least they still used English speakers.
@@maplemaple1439 yeah and they all talk like the Van der linde gang
I thought they sounded pretty good. I've heard Nicole Kidman and other nonAmerican actors slip in their native dialect every once in a while.
lol not far from the Americans then. The Americans used random African actors in Black Hawk Down, a movie based in Somalia, instead of actual Somalis and not a single Somali actually acted in that movie. In Man in the High Castle, they hired people from South East Asia to portray the Japanese.
@@guardiadecivil6777 why "not far from Americans"? Everyone uses actors to act. But there are many more American actors available, in general.
That tank was an actual boss battle 💀💀
bro learned the attack patterns 💀💀💀
the tank is disabled because artillery
Who tf is going over to China to help them make propaganda movies 😂
Anyone who wants the money and not give a single flying fuck about their propaganda
Yankee got sour that I can tell. Unfortunately, China doesn't make good propaganda as Hollywood, yankee got brain washed so bad that so easy get sour.over a movie clip?.🤣🤣
Same type of people that goes to Hollywood to help them make their propaganda movies. I think they might been called actors or something like that...
@@Gamer-Sam Looking at how the side that China backed in the Korean war vs the side we backed ended up.. ya you're not looking so good here.
@@Gamer-Sam You keep saying yankee like we find it offensive lol. 🤐
I love watching long videos like these it makes me feel like i'm in a movie theatre
You know how far this is from reality because those poor bloody Chinese cannon fodder are wearing shoes and cold weather gear, aren't half frozen and aren't almost dead from starvation. The rate at which the Chinese commanders threw their soldiers lives away was disgusting and criminal. There are some great old docs about the Korean war and battles like Chosin Reservoir here on youtube. If you want to see what really happened and what Chinese soldiers really looked like and what they were equipped with, look some of those old documentaries up. If you are Chinese and have never been shown the truth, you should watch them. Its beyond awful what the average Chinese soldier had to endure. Its why millions of them never got to go home. The incompetence of the Chinese mid command is shocking. A good example is a vid called 'How an entire army froze in place - Forgotten History'.
The chinese cannon fodders are captured nationalist party soldiers, they also no any gun charge to the front line.
Dude this movie story was in 1952, not 1950 -1951, Please read more before any comments, this is embarrassing 🤣
@@Gamer-Sam Dude. Stop being cringe. The only embarrassing thing is that you seem to think this Korean War movie is anything but propaganda. All you know about the Korean War is a very skewed CCP version. You should be angry at how the Chinese commanders wasted countless soldiers lives with wasteful tactics. There's lots of unbiased documentaries with real footage that just tell it how it happened. Use the freedom of information we enjoy to really find out for yourself.
And really look up a vid here on youtube called 'How an entire army froze in place - Forgotten History'. That's just one example of the incompetence of the North Korean and Chinese leaders, from the Chosin Reservoir battle. There's lots of examples of insane human wave attacks and worse. There are lots of interviews with old veterans that tell exactly what the war and the fighting and the conditions were like. Its a rabbit hole that will shock you, and hopefully wake you up, if you decide to go down it. That war was terrible for all sides and its disturbing to see how rabidly fanatical, nationalistic and jingoistic some Chinese still get about an awful war fought 70 years ago that nobody won and that had very little purpose in the long run.
Also, this is the Free World. I assume it was you, or someone on this channel, that reported my above comment for some reason. You can't make a false 'hate speech' or whatever report, just because you don't like what a person has to say. It's called 'free speech'. Making false 'hate speech' reports is s quick way to get booted from the platform. That's what the 'like' and 'dislike' buttons are supposed to be for.
@@Gamer-Sam All this talk about "Pissing off Yankees", and yet, from someone who's an Asian American, are from a very small minority of people who say stuff like this, that in itself, is embarrassing. No offense.
@@Gamer-Samyes, you are an embarrassment..
"Real" story from north korean propaganda ministry... Sure.
He propably existed and shot 20-30 men in that month, propaganda just added aditional number at the end.
The weapon the korean sniper is using wouldn't be a sniper rifle. That's an M44, the short carbine version of a 91/30 mosin
So this is where all our M1D rifles went :D how'd they end up with so many?
I smell propaganda.
OP is responding in chinese, so...
I guess you've never seen any Hollywood movie ever.
@@justatiger6268 right?
@@justatiger6268 Lolz
@@justatiger6268 Holloywood movies are suuuper factual - for sure 🤡
ESPECIALLY when it's about the US at war 🤠
Just remember the battle of yultong, American officer says "there are so many rags on the field"
Filipino Soldier "No sir they are dead bodies"
Why Philippines did not develop and prosper while enjoying close relations with the US?
@@silverianjannvs5315 i think you already know the answer
@@silverianjannvs5315 America killed one million Filipinos.
@@silverianjannvs5315 LOL ahhh you commies are so boring, Living standards have been rising year on year in the Philippines, try googling it China shill.
@@vladyMarcusLL the answer is you're wrong and a vatnik orc slime. try looking up the states, things are better in Philippines than ever.
This isnt any worse than an american war movie lol
Eh, wouldn’t put it up to Fury’s standards.
Everyone's a sniper until the artillery makes itself felt.
sacha baron cohens service in Korea.
See yourself the way Chinese propaganda sees the US Army
which is true
@@gobblelevclass3nuclearsubm393what the way the Chinese see americas military?
first half was fine, but then it goes cartoon style
The most plot armour I have seen
And then the artillery dropped, and the airstrikes, and tanks, and ten more infantry divisions.
Based on a 'true' story. Calling bullshit on this one
Yeah? Maybe you should read some history book or just Google Korean War before comment here, you are only embarrassing yourself and this make your comments Sounds "Bullshit".🤣 Sorry if is true story hurt your ego feeling, please, please do some homework before any comments here. Piece of advice: Google Chinese Korean War Sniper " Zhang taofang", People now days are so lazy even do any research no more 🤣🤣 Show some respect to history would ya?
@Gamer-Sam
Unlike you, I actually did my research prior to posting here 'bud'. The issues with Chinese movies that covered the Korean War is that they spun it to their own narrative, to the point that you call it fantasy.
I am well aware of the sniper that this movie follows but another issue is that no one actually confirmed that he made 216 kills, so that put his bias to the like of Chris Kyle and knowing the Chinese government, they would likely propagandize the event and say "Yup, it happened. Even tho we didn't confirmed it."
I would call this movie "loosely based" because you can clearly see they taken creative accounts in the event by putting it in a burlap sack then proceed to beat the shit out of it.
I wouldn't show any respect to the movie that doesn't respect history much like I wouldn't respect you for embarrassing yourself here
@@blazingangel5463 It's ok bud, it's " the forgotten war" something needs to be "forgotten" 🤣 you keep living in the dream pal, don't forget your "Bullshit" btw.
@@Gamer-Sam Nah. I'll just forget I had this conversation with you since I couldn't comprehend the nonsense you're spewing from that trash mouth of yours. Good day to you
Go watch private Ryan to drink your own propaganda then
It’s pretty sad if this movie sided with Americans then almost all of these comments wouldn’t be here, honestly depressing.
Thisss
Only americans win wars right?
That’s because siding with the communists is disgusting, especially since North Korea invaded first. Which, by the way, is so typical of CCP! I’m Chinese so I know, but Chinese people tend to think of the Korea war as a war between China and the US and rarely focus on North vs South Korea, which is the real focus. It’s so retarded to me, because they look down on their own allies, the North Koreans, so much they barely feature in this fucking movie!
It got 1 out of 10 for realism and I think I’m being generous. In the opening scene every sniper has a different scope and reticle and no spotters? No attempts to flank, no mortars and attacking in the middle of the day on open ground? US had at least 1 machine gun but used once to hit primer on unexploded shell? Snipers can get hold of and drive a tank but no crew? It was silly beyond belief but that’s North Korea to this day. Nutville.
That is definitely a Chinese propaganda movie.But not a bad one.Americans worked that hold and the chinese weren't that young
Good, somebody needs to balance out all the american propaganda movies (so basically every single hollywood movie that shows the us army) that are out there.
@@abeedhal6519 You should go hunt down the Russian WWII movies! A bunch of great ones! History makes it seem US was the big winner in Europe! Wrong!
@@roseanneroseannadanna9651 Russia only was able to keep fighting the Nazis because the Americans supplied them with the newest Surplus???
Yeah, my grandpas fought the Chinese during the Korean war. One fought from the Incheon Landing all the way until the end then moved on to fight during all of Vietnam. He didn't talk about war to me at all. My other grandpa saw action towards the end of the fighting in the Korean war. He talked about things only a few times so I listened intently. He spoke with admiration for the enemy so they had his respect and that made me listen all the more. What I find difficult to believe is how Chinese troop in this movie up until I stopped watching, was armed and healthy. They were excellent with mortor fire. However, the bulk of the Chinese were so ill equipped that they gave them cut-outs and painted them to look like riffles. A common tactic is that they would give them opium and beat drums. Then, they would conduct mass raids to try and overrun US and ROK positions. Then the BAR men would mow them down like grass. Then, the Chinese mortor men would zero in on the US Infantry BAR guy's location to try and take him out. They would walk forward mortors and zero in by the third round, they didn't care if they blew their own men apart as Communists care little for the lives' of others then and even now--look at all of the escalator, factory malfunction, elevator, and death by negligent driving videos. So, by the 2nd round the US Infantry squad would move to a new firing position and start massacring the drugged up Chinese men running at them again (with fake riffles and sharpened sticks). The war was brutal and in fact, the Chinese and DPRK troops became so ill-equipped that they started publishing propaganda saying, "Americans are afraid of Hand-to-Hand combat that is why they shoot so many of us" as opposed to Communism just sucking and resulting in no money or care to equip troops due to the "Wealth and life for me not for thee" mentality. This propaganda worked in the Chinese and DPRK demise though. It lead to the legendary Lewis Millet creating Bayonet Hill. Millet went on to keep leading men on Bayonet charges massacring countless numbers of Chinese and DPRK troops. So, there is anecdotal evidence as well as historical evidence for you.
That rolling move. Works every time.
Almost as good as John Wick 🤣
Not a hope in hell would a real sniper stand up and the other guy get him with one hand on the rifle.......
A real sniper never fires repeated shots from the same position.
There is so much wrong with this film, trained soldiers would not act the ways shown.
snipers inside a tank? well, known propaganda, but take care about some topics
Impossible, Chinese would never have been able to shoot that good with eyes like that and be bad at driving cars at the same time? Definitely fairytale
Dafuq?
Lmfao
Don't under estimate Asian
dont forget, what you have on your home, it made by Chinesse :)
Guys this is obviously a joke, but still, they wouldn’t actually be able to shoot that accurately considering how they are shooting in this propaganda film.
The Chinese government showed an alarming eagerness to sacrifice soldiers during this conflict… there are stories from American machine gunners where they witnessed hundreds of Chinese soldiers charging their positions head on, only for them to be cut down. “The bloodshed was on a level I had never seen before, as the sun rose we saw a mountain of bodies and yet they still continued to charge.”
Who made the american's text for this shit? 💀
The same office that approves their text for everything they even reused lines from Wolf Warrior.
Thanks to the camera man for surviving 😂
It’s a movie. American does this stuff too.
But the idea of US soldiers being bad in this way and not knowing tricks when they see them is quite ridiculous.
That commanding officer character is a general Patton joke.
US officers would not display their rank on the front of their helmets so as to not make themselves targets. They would be on the back of their helmets. Most people shot do not bleed out of their mouths. Chinese enlisted men would not use these tactics just to be slaughtered.
After getting the last sniper he stand triumphant over his enemy, and then dies emotionally after do to starvation, blood loss plus hypothermia oh yah and the 3 divisions of angry marines with armor, air and artillery support.
The anger marines? I dont even think the marines knew what was going on in the end. If they did, they'd have heard all the gun fire and head over to check it out.
Besides, it was the army that was there not the marines
This comment and its replies seem oddly familiar and it scares me.
I mean it was meant to be a bit of a juke but it seams like people are taking it far too seriously
@@Kingtiger21 Jukes are taken seriously, by some people.
Battle of Triangle hill, US KIA - 365 from 14 October - 25 November 1952. Zhang arrived on 11 January 1953, there is not even an records of a battle for the next 32 days from the UN side. Roughly 2/3 of the KIA of a 42 day UN attack, you would think they would make a note of this battle? China too busy making up heros who burn to death rather than scream, or study chairman mao with a flashlight with the lights on.
They were debating on what's better, Ramen Or Mac N Cheese, that's why they were fighting
A real sniper doesn't stay in one location after it shoots it relocates to another position..and theirs too many snipers in one area...snipers are like leopards, they hunt alone...
not really snipers are usually in teams of 2 one shooter and one spotter soo... you're wrong on this one.
Chicom was only good at human wave attacks.
I have to say, all I know is this movie does pissed a lot of Yankees... 🤣 drama, drama, glass heart is easy to break, didn't know that Yankees nowdays are so senstive, like a little girl.
@@Gamer-Sam Are you the Asian equivalent of Trump?
Nope, just trying show a little respect to history, and history ain't fantasy world, that's the fact some people refuse to accept. Piece of advice, please please please read some history book or at least Google Korean War before leave any ignorant comments in here would ya?, don't you feel kinda embarrassing yourself? 🤣
@@Gamer-Sam it is hard to have respect for the North Korean side in this conflict, when their military still drives in coal-trucks and their airforce still uses Mig15s.....yea the same planes like in this war.....at this point, we have to congrat them to keep them in condition as history pieces even today. Would be funny if not 25 million people have to suffer for this clown-show.
214 kills in 32 days wonderman is just a propaganda-claim, like soviet snipers, while in reality most of them were slaughtered like regular soldiers in idiot operations, because the soviets never created a real sniper unit for sniping, they were always only inf. support and wer eonly intended to support infantry operation. Russian armies had always the problem to organize their large armies and the Chinese army had the same problem even worse over the whole civilwar or war against Japan and still in the Korean war.
Some rare exceptions happen, when an actual good hunter appears on the battle and Taofang was a good hunter, but he was just similar to Robertson or other actual snipers and the fact, that Taofang was later forced into a Mig15 and than later shovelled into the air defence, just shows, that his actual sniper-talent was never used, he lacked in talent as a pilot, but was forced into it for propaganda and the lack of his use as a sniper in this war hints, that these claims were not real, but propaganda.
On the other side you have Hathcock, who has formed structures for the marines, that created tons of effective snipers in vietnam and he was put into this position after his talent was recognized by the US army in Korea....this happens with real talents.
And just on a sidenote, the best snipers were the Germans....in WW1....because they were specific recruited from the traditional local hunting clubs in every village in germany, who started these clubs, when crossbows were the hunting standard, they were the first professional sniper org. in an army and the scopes of the german army had the best glass, normally used for microscopes, because in Germany we have a really pure sand-source for the biggest medical glass production to this day. wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b8/German_sniper_team.jpg/1024px-German_sniper_team.jpg these guys were killers, only some units got actual payments for confirmed kills, so they were strict about it and there were quite a few snipers, who hit the 200 confirmed kills mark...and most of them didn't served over the whole war. Some snipers have stopped storm-attacks by themself....Mühlberger, just a particular fast shooter and former illegal hunter, killed 50 guys in a single attack and in the next attack again 25 guys on the same day...and he was at the front for a whole year. We dont know his kill-count.......we only know about him, because he had these 75 confirmed kills on one sole day.
And there were in every conflict tons of these unnamed soldiers, who killed a lot of people and would have rather killed themself than ask for praises for his actions. My own grandgranduncle served on the eastern front in WW2 as a sniper....but as a sniper on a munition train, so he never got a confirmed kill and never killed a soldier....only belorussian partisans, who tried to kill him at the same time...and a lot of these partisans were probably kids....accomplishment? pride? cool? It is killing. Hate it. The sane snipers hated their job and didn't wanted to get recognised about it, like Robertson, who never revealed his kill-count.
@@Gamer-Sam The Yanks are being pussified at school. Just take a look at their woke military recruitment video. An embarrassment for a such great nation.
Chinese shoter is like rajnikant, shooting the voice and recognizing the direction from which the bullet is coming
I aint even mad they made us look scary as fuck. Period accurate rifles, sights everything. China can have their exaggerated prop movies as long as its entertaining,
1952년 한국전쟁의 미군을 마치 수년전인 1942년 2차 대전 당시 독일군 같이 표현했군
That's real
ALL wars are banksters wars.
*Americans grow up with guns and do a lot of hunting at a young age. One advantage of THE RIGHT TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS!.*
First, where's the rest of the flick? Carlos Hathcock made a kill shot through a scope one time and now every sniper movie made has to try to do the same. This is one of the worst as it's clear that the kill shot was off angle. This is completely impossible and makes this more of a comedy than anything else.
how the heck, this went in every "play next" while I'm just playing Australian songs.
🤣 Sorry to hear that
I mean not accurate where’s the scene where the Chinese throw wave after wave of undertrained ill equipped conscripts into American machine gun fire
This is not one of your Hollywood bullshit
@@Niektolentak That is what the Chinese did, many of these guys were Nationalists who had been left behind and forced into the war to prove their new loyalty. They were so poorly equipped, you would not believe it if i told you little pink.
When the american said " I win" at the end already knew the Chinese sniper is gonna win😂😂😂😂
A film about ordinary working folk killing each other, for the man.
...and they lived in poverty ever after. The End.📙
As opposed to a Yank with cancer who can't afford health insurance.
Best comment.
Couldn't they be allowed to make that decision for themselves? Who the fuck are the Yanks to tell everyone how to live. Who are they to impose their values of greed on others.
Chinese sniper vs. American sniper Korean War MOVIE error' M1903 Springfield Sniper Rifle M1C M1D Sniper Rifle Garland Used in real life🤬
I'd have more of a problem with the model 70 Winchester. I know they were in Vietnam, but Korea? The Marines were still using 1903's, so at least they were in theater. Not the 03A4, the one with the Unertel scope.
during the korean war filipino soldiers defeated 40,000 chinese military...