Considering the pinnacle of art that Bo Burnham's "Inside" and the movie "Jaggi" holds in my own experience, and now seeing Dostoevsky's Demons being compared to those, makes me want to read it so much. But my reading self has been comatose for a while. Hopefully, he will come back to life soon. 😔🤞
I am a librarian at one of the best library in Aisa. I see your videos and also we take your recommendations seriously and use those in book of the week❤
Roskolnikov is probably one of the best sociopathic character written ever….deotovesky just dives deep in the mind of how people think.its sad he didn’t get recognition when he was alive
Have read it. Such a massive work by Dostoevsky. He completely dives into the human psychology and presents every tiniest thing. Also his "Notes from underground".
last year, I picked crime and punishment and I remember how tormented I was while reading about raskolnikov. Could'nt read more than 15 pages a day coz it would all get pretty heavy, needless to say the storyline wouldn't move an inch but that was okay to me. At last I was quite pissed by the character that I made it a point to only read the last few pages in internet summary... kinda to show my anguish to dostoevsky, I was pissed at him and his genius that I couldn't read him anymore. I don't even remember much of the book, I only remember I was pissed and tired and my brains were palpitating.. made a pact after that, only one dostoevsky a year, Or else I'll be the depressed-ass Rodya.
Why are Indians so obsessed with Dostoevsky, Kafka. I've tried reading both(Notes from Underground and metamorphosis) and found they induce claustrophobia (I already have some anxiety issues). Though I read a lot(e.g Moby Dick, Jon Krakauer and much more and is proud member of two book clubs in Jaipur). If one starts suffering from mild Agoraphobia, one should know where to look. The future may be uncertain(Jobs, Marriage, Children, Misogyny and more) and confusing but do Dostoevsky has a cure.
It is the most sarcastic of all Dostoevsky's books 😇Right from the first page, that character Verkhovensky senior, who was once a revolutionary and lives off that fact for the rest of his life - it is just too much. But it is also distinctly anti-Communist, more than 50 years before the Russian revolution, Dostoevsky saw through Communism, knew it would be a disaster....
Got this recommendation from couple of folks and thinking of starting it. One of the reasons why I had been avoiding Russian classics (and for that matter any foreign author) is because of the translation. I find it almost impossible to believe that the works narrated in a language retain their complete essence when translated to English. So comes the second question of, translator, because you have to admit, a book becomes as good as its translator and not the author. So that being said, now that I have decided to give it a try, which of the below translators would you recommend. • Demons (Penguin Classics, 2008). Translated by Robert A. Maguire • Demons (Vintage, 1995). Translated by Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky. • Demons (Penguin Classic, 2001). Translated by Garnett Constance.
uhm, okay kitaabi cabins you got me there, I must return to the bookstore and buy another book. and fill it with annotations. esp, Dostoevsky. wish me luck.
but why to appreciate ? just get some knowledge and leave. low testoseterone buddy. dont be desparate for it. people like us represent men community which doesnt win medals and trophies in sports, no big tech companies in india. instead we do this 2nd aaj kal kitabo me b soft porn bech rhe h sb romanticism k naam pe. non fiction pdho itne he staunch book reader ho toh.
The RUclips algorithm has become invasive, i have only ordered the book "crime and punishment" except that i have not even typed the word crime and punishment on my phone together but somehow out of nowhere this video popped up on top of the home tab of youtube. I don't know how to react to this kind of sorcery. 😶
I dont like to read books 📚 , mujhe kabhi pasand nahi thi books padhna. But mai videos k form me chijeo ko dekhna and sunna pasand karta hu , chahe vo 10hours ki bhi kyu na ho. Kya aisa koi plateform hai jaha books ko videos /stories k form me present kiya jata ho?
Heyy, I am also reading Demons and honestly this book is so dense sometimes and still it manages to strike something in the back of my little brain. next I want to read the mammoth by FD…The Brothers Karamazov. Could you please please make a video about how to read it specially as a non-christian Indian?
I’m about to start my journey with Dostoevsky and would love some guidance on the best reading order. Could you recommend a sequence to fully appreciate his works, from early novels to his most renowned masterpieces? Thanks in advance!
If you have enjoyed this, try insulted and humiliated or The Idiot, and when you're done with these two, do a Notes from the underground 🤘 Just one thing against the guy, if only he could have had lesser number of characters and maybe a little simpler and not similar sounding names of characters
I have just one question, how should a person read Dostoevsky. I tried "Crime & Punishment" but i didn't able to catch the essence of the book. Probably read 30 pages and discouraged. So my question is how should someone start reading him and understand what is he trying to convey?
I'm not a book reader at all and cp was my first ish book and i found that I had it easier cuz I had the pavear translation of the book, if possible you might want to switch. It was the best book for me. Tho the writing style is pretty confusing since it isn't mentioned who is speaking Many times
Read at your own risk guys, this books are not for everybody, i am not saying you got less cerebrum but a book should be enjoyed if it becomes a memory hogg leave it, there are so many books and so less time to read.
Thank you kitabi cabins.😊 I request here all to read books of ACHARYA PRASHANT, your life will change.Some recommendations: 1)Infinite potential-ACHARYA PRASHANT💪 2)Women's revolution-ACHARYA PRASHANT 📚 3)Climate change -ACHARYA PRASHANT🌍
I find that the people who go deep in literature, have multiple brain in one And they end up bieng more complex...This was just my thoughts please don't take it the other way
I had a youtube channel two years ago. I used to post my literary explorations and insights in form of videos just like you. I don't why, no one really supported me, no comments no engagment, even the readers were not watching or even sharing me their thoughts about what should I change to improve. Then as I turned 19, I realized, Reading books and changing my own life is a better approach then making it a fashion show on youtube. Thus, I deleted my channel, now I spend hours reading novels and philosophy. But recently, I created a phony YT account, I used Female AI voice and BOOOMMMMM. It has a pretty good reach, and it also got monetized recently. I guess, I now know what is selling and what not.
Hey ! I read Crime and Punishment and The Idiot last year and I loved it. I kinda fell into a reading slump for almost 1.5 month but I later recovered. Also I am currently 50 pages away from completing The Brothers Karamazov which is another thick brick by Dostoevsky. Loving it so much. I also saw White Nights trending on bookstagram and I read it but what I felt reading his other (thicker) books was somewhat missing in it. I read Notes from Underground and The Meek One by him in 2022 and those were also nice and beginner friendly. You may also pick up books by Leo Tolstoy if you're loving reading Dostoevsky. 😊
why this channel doesnt promote indian ancient novels like mahabharata critical edition, original valmiki ramayan, and many other versions of ramayan, books of kabir , ramcharitmanas, tamil literature like alai osai , Kalidasa literature which is placed equal to shakespeare, and many others. I think We should also know about us and include western or russian philosphy . They promote their books, we read them and praise them but we fail to recognize our own. i think we are still enslaved by them.
Well for starters its her channel and she gets to decide what books to promote and which topics to discuss on. You are welcomed to subscribed those channels which talks about our culture and books. There is nothing wrong in reading books apart from our culture, yeh enslaved wala mindset nikaldo bhaisahab, grow up
@@chaitanyagawade9663 grow up ? maine mna nahi kra nh dhyn se pdhgle growm k chode. bhr wale b apni he literature pdte h na k asia . uske bd vo asia chinese russian pe jate j h grow up hone ki zaroort tereko h mereko ni. khol le ankhein ache se apni or diaper dhole jake
![Megan Thee Stallion - Mamushi (Remix) [feat. TWICE] [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5c0_u9PsrsQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Considering the pinnacle of art that Bo Burnham's "Inside" and the movie "Jaggi" holds in my own experience, and now seeing Dostoevsky's Demons being compared to those, makes me want to read it so much. But my reading self has been comatose for a while. Hopefully, he will come back to life soon. 😔🤞
I am a librarian at one of the best library in Aisa. I see your videos and also we take your recommendations seriously and use those in book of the week❤
Charu Ji, you're that melancholia in my life which brings me the ultimate bliss.
Okayyy!! And a tour of your books behind you, please.
Roskolnikov is probably one of the best sociopathic character written ever….deotovesky just dives deep in the mind of how people think.its sad he didn’t get recognition when he was alive
Have read it. Such a massive work by Dostoevsky. He completely dives into the human psychology and presents every tiniest thing.
Also his "Notes from underground".
We love you madam.
You calm style of talking about books in depth is wonderful.
last year, I picked crime and punishment and I remember how tormented I was while reading about raskolnikov. Could'nt read more than 15 pages a day coz it would all get pretty heavy, needless to say the storyline wouldn't move an inch but that was okay to me. At last I was quite pissed by the character that I made it a point to only read the last few pages in internet summary... kinda to show my anguish to dostoevsky, I was pissed at him and his genius that I couldn't read him anymore. I don't even remember much of the book, I only remember I was pissed and tired and my brains were palpitating.. made a pact after that, only one dostoevsky a year, Or else I'll be the depressed-ass Rodya.
I kinda feel same, i only read 45 pages & i thought is not the right time so i will try it some years later after reading some other classic's
The narrative becomes so dense that the impact of the previous scene is quickly lost, leaving the reader frustrated as hopes and expectations dwindle
This girl's personality is as mesmerising as the book she is talking about, or more....
Glad someone is talking about Demons... Missed by many, but one of his most powerful works.
Watching Inside by Bo Burnham. Thank you for introducing that special to us and I will also be watching Jaggi afterwards.
I like Charu's recommendations
Incredible Charu ❤😍👏🏻👏🏻
Dont read books for fun,read to learn.Read books which can impact you
Why are Indians so obsessed with Dostoevsky, Kafka. I've tried reading both(Notes from Underground and metamorphosis) and found they induce claustrophobia (I already have some anxiety issues). Though I read a lot(e.g Moby Dick, Jon Krakauer and much more and is proud member of two book clubs in Jaipur). If one starts suffering from mild Agoraphobia, one should know where to look. The future may be uncertain(Jobs, Marriage, Children, Misogyny and more) and confusing but do Dostoevsky has a cure.
Nice high quality content. I really like young kids are independent thinkers now days. Proud.
It is the most sarcastic of all Dostoevsky's books 😇Right from the first page, that character Verkhovensky senior, who was once a revolutionary and lives off that fact for the rest of his life - it is just too much. But it is also distinctly anti-Communist, more than 50 years before the Russian revolution, Dostoevsky saw through Communism, knew it would be a disaster....
Got this recommendation from couple of folks and thinking of starting it. One of the reasons why I had been avoiding Russian classics (and for that matter any foreign author) is because of the translation. I find it almost impossible to believe that the works narrated in a language retain their complete essence when translated to English. So comes the second question of, translator, because you have to admit, a book becomes as good as its translator and not the author. So that being said, now that I have decided to give it a try, which of the below translators would you recommend.
• Demons (Penguin Classics, 2008). Translated by Robert A. Maguire
• Demons (Vintage, 1995). Translated by Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky.
• Demons (Penguin Classic, 2001). Translated by Garnett Constance.
Charuuu is backkkk
she's also a founding member right ??
@@roopraj859of kitabi cabins? I thought it's her channel only
@@doofus8 no it belongs to chalchitratalks (totally worth subscribing)
@@roopraj859 cool ... I'll check out their work
@@doofus8 their shorts are great they recommend stuffs
I had just started crime and punishment. 2nd chapter is soo boring in but after 15 boring pages something start which takes a whole dark turn❤
the degree of articulation.. damn
charu, I love your brain
Currently m reading beyond good and evil❤
I LOVE HER SO MUCH I’m literally Adding demons to cart right now I MEANNNNN❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Appreciated ur choice of the books
uhm, okay kitaabi cabins you got me there, I must return to the bookstore and buy another book. and fill it with annotations. esp, Dostoevsky. wish me luck.
Another charu's recommendation LESGO 🚀
Where can I get the audio book for this
Hey Charu ❤😊
if queen say so, we will read it
😂😂😂😂
but why to appreciate ? just get some knowledge and leave.
low testoseterone buddy.
dont be desparate for it.
people like us represent men community which doesnt win medals and trophies in sports, no big tech companies in india. instead we do this
2nd aaj kal kitabo me b soft porn bech rhe h sb romanticism k naam pe.
non fiction pdho itne he staunch book reader ho toh.
@@ishaanrohmetra3447apna comment dekh lo on video "Classic literature for beginners #6" 😂😂
Cringe
Hardly a day passes by without men being simps and displaying pick me behaviour in the comment sections.
Here to see the review but can't help but notice the comment section. WTF is wrong with us?
i appreciate u for giving honest review of white nights .. it was bit cringy 😅
Lovee it!♥️✨
Wow! Great use of Tarkovosky's films' clips in the background, much appreciated. Keep up the good work.
I have become a fan of your voice..!!! 😊
Hardly a day passes by without men being simps and displaying pick me behaviour in the comment sections.
everybody just recommends books, but nobody ever gifts books 😭
Yesss
Using tarkovsky's films as a background while talking about dostoevsky is so legit
Can you check out *Living at the source* .
There was a viral image of *Chris Gayle* having this book.
The RUclips algorithm has become invasive, i have only ordered the book "crime and punishment" except that i have not even typed the word crime and punishment on my phone together but somehow out of nowhere this video popped up on top of the home tab of youtube. I don't know how to react to this kind of sorcery. 😶
Kuchh samjha nahi but somehow the video was calming lmao ?
U need therapy
After watching u talk about deotovesky I am feeling like that Lego meme 😂
Read bardo thodol by Padmasambhava
Where were you able to get access to Amit Dutta discography?
ma'am read A confession by Tolstoy 🙏🙏
I dont like to read books 📚 , mujhe kabhi pasand nahi thi books padhna. But mai videos k form me chijeo ko dekhna and sunna pasand karta hu , chahe vo 10hours ki bhi kyu na ho. Kya aisa koi plateform hai jaha books ko videos /stories k form me present kiya jata ho?
audiobooks???
what translation would you recommend for both the crime and punishment, the brothers karmazov. some modern translations maybe or your favourite ones?
Well if she says now i gotta read
Heyy, I am also reading Demons and honestly this book is so dense sometimes and still it manages to strike something in the back of my little brain.
next I want to read the mammoth by FD…The Brothers Karamazov. Could you please please make a video about how to read it specially as a non-christian Indian?
Do you hear Beghum Akhtar?
Please give a sequence of books in whivh a beginner should read
Take a book read it .
Done
I read White Nights and ironically got friendzoned after few days 😭
I’m about to start my journey with Dostoevsky and would love some guidance on the best reading order. Could you recommend a sequence to fully appreciate his works, from early novels to his most renowned masterpieces? Thanks in advance!
Is Demons and Possessed same
Can we get audio book for this
well one definitely needs balls to talk about Dostoevsky and his philosophy. And you obviously have .
charu do a bookself tour pls
please make a reading order of dotoevsky🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Can you please do a order of how to read dostoevsky books
You should watch/read Attack on Titan.
If you have enjoyed this, try insulted and humiliated or The Idiot, and when you're done with these two, do a Notes from the underground 🤘
Just one thing against the guy, if only he could have had lesser number of characters and maybe a little simpler and not similar sounding names of characters
Please show the book collection of your
Book tour❤
Which translation of demons is it?
I have just one question, how should a person read Dostoevsky. I tried "Crime & Punishment" but i didn't able to catch the essence of the book. Probably read 30 pages and discouraged. So my question is how should someone start reading him and understand what is he trying to convey?
I'm not a book reader at all and cp was my first ish book and i found that I had it easier cuz I had the pavear translation of the book, if possible you might want to switch. It was the best book for me. Tho the writing style is pretty confusing since it isn't mentioned who is speaking Many times
If u drop a book by just 30 pages.
Man no one can encourage you to anything
I am in love with you❤
Dostoyvekey brother karmazov
Is greatest fiction book ever written
Whats the best book to start Dostovesky ?
Crime and punishment
Read at your own risk guys, this books are not for everybody, i am not saying you got less cerebrum but a book should be enjoyed if it becomes a memory hogg leave it, there are so many books and so less time to read.
BEST
can anyone tell me about some indian website to buy afffordable books
Thank you kitabi cabins.😊 I request here all to read books of ACHARYA PRASHANT, your life will change.Some recommendations:
1)Infinite potential-ACHARYA PRASHANT💪
2)Women's revolution-ACHARYA PRASHANT 📚
3)Climate change -ACHARYA PRASHANT🌍
Yes
"मूर्ख चाहे पूरी लाइब्रेरी उठाए घूमे, वह फिर भी मूर्ख ही रहेगा। ज्ञान का सार समझना जरूरी है, सिर्फ किताबें रखना नहीं।"
Sun to my worm
Makeup looking good
Brother karamazov
Lol who reads quacks like osho?
I find that the people who go deep in literature, have multiple brain in one
And they end up bieng more complex...This was just my thoughts please don't take it the other way
True! I read daily & I feel one needs to be mentally strong to read so that one can enhance one's character instead of making it complex.
I am reading The India Way lekin mujhe kuch samjh nhi aa rha. *Crying emoji*
I had a youtube channel two years ago. I used to post my literary explorations and insights in form of videos just like you. I don't why, no one really supported me, no comments no engagment, even the readers were not watching or even sharing me their thoughts about what should I change to improve. Then as I turned 19, I realized, Reading books and changing my own life is a better approach then making it a fashion show on youtube. Thus, I deleted my channel, now I spend hours reading novels and philosophy. But recently, I created a phony YT account, I used Female AI voice and BOOOMMMMM. It has a pretty good reach, and it also got monetized recently. I guess, I now know what is selling and what not.
Be a dhrista
Hero
Crime and Punishment got me into reading.
🖤🖤🖤
Hey ! I read Crime and Punishment and The Idiot last year and I loved it. I kinda fell into a reading slump for almost 1.5 month but I later recovered. Also I am currently 50 pages away from completing The Brothers Karamazov which is another thick brick by Dostoevsky. Loving it so much. I also saw White Nights trending on bookstagram and I read it but what I felt reading his other (thicker) books was somewhat missing in it. I read Notes from Underground and The Meek One by him in 2022 and those were also nice and beginner friendly. You may also pick up books by Leo Tolstoy if you're loving reading Dostoevsky. 😊
Perfect girl doesn't exi...😮😮😮
A beautiful gorgeous girl reading Dostoevsky is a rare sight.
Nothing could be more poetic than accompanying Dostoeyvsky's quotes with Tarkovsky's images.... 😌
Really liked the edit choice behind this....
Take off your glasses, so that I can read your eyes...
girls who read dostoesky ... runn 😂😂
Why reason
@@RishabhVirmani they don't save screenshot only bro they know your next move also
hi crush
aap bolo, aur hum napadhe, kaise ho sakta hai🤪
Hey hey booooooooyyyyyyyyyyy😂!
why this channel doesnt promote indian ancient novels like mahabharata critical edition, original valmiki ramayan, and many other versions of ramayan, books of kabir , ramcharitmanas, tamil literature like alai osai , Kalidasa literature which is placed equal to shakespeare, and many others.
I think We should also know about us and include western or russian philosphy .
They promote their books, we read them and praise them but we fail to recognize our own.
i think we are still enslaved by them.
Well for starters its her channel and she gets to decide what books to promote and which topics to discuss on. You are welcomed to subscribed those channels which talks about our culture and books. There is nothing wrong in reading books apart from our culture, yeh enslaved wala mindset nikaldo bhaisahab, grow up
@@chaitanyagawade9663 grow up ?
maine mna nahi kra nh dhyn se pdhgle
growm k chode.
bhr wale b apni he literature pdte h na k asia .
uske bd vo asia chinese russian pe jate j h
grow up hone ki zaroort tereko h mereko ni.
khol le ankhein ache se apni or diaper dhole jake