it weird bc when reading Bluestar's Prophecy at the battle for Sunning Rocks your rooting for ThunderClan But in Crookedstar's Promise in the same battle, you root for RiverClan ahh perspective writing
This made me realize something I should have realized sooner. When Redtail died, and his body was brought into the camp, Bluestar received word of Oakheart's death as well as Redtail's, which meant that she was mourning her mate along with her deputy. Ah you Erins, you did it again!
I personally prefer Oakheart with green eyes, because it matches better with his pelt color. Also because I like the thought of Firestar looking like Oakheart, another reason Bluestar becomes close with him.
@@marijougonzalez8437 She actually did. Firestar reminds of Oakheart so much for Bluestar. Thats why she wanted to be his mentor and gave him "heart" as surffix.
SpottedwillowWH :)) Oakheart told Graypool to keep secret about those kits and pretended they're hers. Literally, Oakheart and Graypool are the only RiverClan members knew the kits were from ThunderClan and none of RiverClan members know anything about Bluestar or her kits. So, they didn't suspect and assumed they're Graypool's kits.
Aaaaahh, It's really cool to have the point of view of Oakheart. Everyone used Bluestar and aaaah I love to see videos with an original character, plus, with a beautiful style like yours! ^w^
I love the choice to make Crookedstar the Hamilton of this rather than give that to someone else, purely because the lyrics fit so damned well for him! No other cat that could have been chosen had as much to prove and as little to lose as Crookedstar, and I think that this PMV really benefits from showing the development of the relationship between the two brothers. I just love this so much oml.
@@steller_star He took care of RiverClan pretty well. Everything went downhill after he died lol. Bluestar was a worse leader than in her later years-- Imo only Firestar and Tallstar are better, one because he's the main character and the other because I'm biased
She's not the only one. Even one of the writers imagined him with green eyes but was corrected. Mistakes in the books also add to the confusion. In short she can do whatever the hell she likes.
Agreed. Honestly, if there's gonna be mistakes in the books, and even among the writers, then the fans kiiinda have free reign as far as minor design choices go.
His picture is in the Warriors Guide, but that's like a silhouette, so you can't see his eyes. All cats are originially born with blue eyes, but they change color as the cats grow.
The end made me tear up because you can see how much Oakheart longs to tell Bluestar the truth. That it wasn't his fault. That he'd never hurt her like that. But he can't tell her any of that and has to watch her pain and grief start to consume her. Her spiral down started with losing Redtail and only got worse with each lose after
Me and my choir friends literally were preforming songs during this unit, 3 of us in total. I would keep the beat by using the table as a drum and providing backup vocals, and the two other ones (who r boys) would sing
After I read Bluestar's Prophecy, I went back and read Into the Wild and it's a little disturbing that Tigerclaw was like, "I killed this guy", and Bluestar had to deal with the whole, "This dude murdered my ex-boyfriend" thing. It's actually quite heartbreaking.
I can't praise this enough. I've also lost count of how many times I have watched this. Point blank my favourite PMV i've seen so far. You fitted the lyrics so perfectly with Oakheart's story and the visuals are stunning! Otherwise too the PMV's of you guys are incredibly good and high quality!
Something I noticed: In the OG book, I think they didn’t know who the father of Bluestar’s kits would be yet, so she really was devastated to have lost an amazing friend. But now, I feel like everyone interprets her sadness as to Oakheart and not Redtail.
I interpret it as both. Shed of course be upset over Redtails death but shed also be extremely upset over the death of her mate and the father of her kits
if she was only pretending to be sad about Redtail's death when she was really sad about Oakheart's death, I would hate her with all my heart. Like bitch? your deputy just died, and instead of going there to mourn him, you are saddened by the death of your ex-boyfriend who (supposedly) killed your deputy????? WTF?
When I got older I started to realize how much terrible drama happens in the books. I mean deaths, betrayal, heartbreaks, hiding kits, power balances, discrimination, serial killers, revenge ect. I know our own cats have and had a lot of drama, but I'm so glad this was fiction This MAP is also one of my favorite and, although very sad, one of my favorite couples. The song also fits perfectly for Oakheart. And the cats look absolutely gorgeous
Maximus Gayus oml I cried. Oak heart is my second favorite charecter( sorreltail being the first) and this really relates to him. the animator thing person did a good job with dis
I've never realised how much this song relates to Oakheart.. (SPOILERS AHEAD!) (Theodosia writes me a letter Everyday. Keeping her bed warm while her Husband is away. He's on the British side of Georgia, he's trying to keep the colonies in line.) He longed to meet Bluestar every night after that one night when they meet each other and slept together. But Bluestar told him that they can't because they're in different clans. And it turns out, Bluestar was expecting kits. And since Thurshpelt had feelings for her, he had to pose to be the Father of the kits. In that way, Thrushpelt is Bluestars mate. "British side in Georgia" probably reference to Thunderclan and how he's trying to defend for it. (But he can keep all of Georgia, Theodosia she's mine.) Oakheart is still willing to wait for Bluestar, despite the clans had believed that Thrushpelt was the Father of his kits. (Love doesn't discriminate, between the sinner and the saints and it takes and it takes. But we keep loving anyways.) Oakheart knew that he had no chance with Bluestar because they were from different clans. Yet, they met up one night and after that, he waits for her by the Riverbank. (We laugh and we cry and we brake and we make our mistakes.) On that night, they laugh together, watch the stars together, they slept with each other, which ended up with Bluestar expecting his kits. (And if there's a reason I'm by her side when so many have tried.) Oakheart is still willing to wait for her. He even insisted that he join Thunderclan or she join Riverclan for the sake of their kits. (Then I'm willing to wait for it, I'm willing to wait for it.) Again, he waits for Bluestar by the riverbank each day. And now their kids too. (Death doesn't discriminate. Between the sinners and the saints and it takes and it takes and it takes. And we keep living anyway.) Mosskit died during the journey to bring the kits to Riverclan due to the cold. But after Bluestar returned to camp, she had to act as if she lost her kits and have to live on. And yeah, that's it! I really hope they make a book specifically for Oakheart. Please correct me if I'm wrong for the info above.
After that, I think it's about Oakheart trying to move on and forget Bluestar, but he still remembers her, with Crookedstar being a (thankfully) oblivious idiot and battling over Sunningrocks, and at the battle, he has to confront his past
I always wonder what happened if Bluestar fought in the battle with RiverClan too, and met Oakheart. I mean, everyone else would've been shocked to see that the leader of a Clan and the deputy of another one don't fight in a a battle and just stand and watch each other... Or so...
Never would happen though. Oakheart and Bluestar most likely avoided each other when in battle, if they ever fought in the same battles. They obviously would just take on the other cats around from their rivaling clans.
But what about when the rocks fell? Would she grieve him? Or what if he was on another cat and she was the only one that could help. Would she fight him?
I'm so glad I discovered this. This is absolutely beautiful. Like almost breathtaking. The Oakheart/Bluestar relationship was rushed and poorly handled in canon in my opinion, but you made it really enjoyable here. And the final battle, well, that was simply magical. I could really feel the thrill and adrenaline of the warriors as they went to fight, knowing they might not come back alive. All in all this was brilliant. Amazing job.
Jeromimo Yes of course Oakheart's entire life is part of the video, and the entire video was brilliant. I just found that the Oakheart + Bluestar moments caught my attention in particular just because I thought it had more impact here than it does in the books.
Elisa Wheeler I never agreed with the way the writers made Thistleclaw out to be a villain. He didn't kill his Clanmates or break the warrior code when he was alive so it didn't make much sense to portray him as a villain just because he didn't get along with one of the protagonists.
Oakheart is maybe now my first or second favorite, after seeing this and some other videos and thinking more of him and his life. They should make a special edition book about him, he deserves it. Everyone thinks of him as Crookedstar's brother, or Bluestar's mate, it's true, but they should think more of him. Even though Stonefur and Mistyfoot talk about how Oakheart faked Greypool was his mate, there should be special edition so we can see it through HIS eyes. I think the Erin Hunters should work on it.
This is in Oakhearts POV, and she wasn't ever that negligent to him, so not really. As they stated in the description, he had a separate upbringing, so had different views then Crookedstar, and the readers
A Tree Ok but Rainflower also got bullied as a kit and probably got traumatized and then bullied Stormkit . I am not defending her actions though she is horrible.
Same. I also fell into the DEH trash can and SU trash can after that. Edit: I fell into the heathers trash can too, and also (my favorite musical at the time) the Be More Chill trashcan.
Man, this is so nostalgic. I remember watching this seven years ago on my way down to Florida, where I was purposed to, and then eventually I got married, and now I have a 22 month old son like what ;;
I don't know how you guys do it, but I love it! You do such a fabulous job and I love the song! I never really thought about it from Oakheart's POV before. If you think about it, he's lost a lot too. Maybe even more than Bluestar. Yes, he does have his kids, but they don't know that he's their father! This really made me feel for him. Thanks for this beautiful piece of art!
Well, Ithink they do know that Oakheartis their father. Mistyfoot tells Fireheart that Oakheart her father. But since that was in Forest of Secrets, it might be considered outdated proof now, but...
No they knew Oakheart was their dad and thought Graypool was their mom. If you remember that scene in the beginning of Forest of Secrets it picks up where Blue drops her kits with Oak and then leaves and we see Oak taking them to RiverClan and giving them to Graypool
+Kiara SaysHi I think he's underestimated because not everyone has read the whole series, but in Into The Wild (which is where most people start) he's only mentioned at the beginning when he was killed, so he wasn't really noticed. It's a shame, I would have liked to see more of him, although he is from Riverclan and the main story generally follows Thunderclan cats, so he isn't one of the main ones. :/
In Bluestars prophecy, you see how great and understanding of a mate he is, in Crookedstar promise you see how great of a father he is, although he got into a fight with Crookedstar for being a bad father, I love his character development
So your channel just popped up in my recommended, and I remembered how much I used to love Warriors (I mean I still own every single book) but still, and this brought back such a huge flood of emotions and this just rekindled by love for it and fjhkjd it was so beautiful. All your videos are.
This is great! I feel like this also fits well with Crookedstar, particularly the "if there's a reason I'm still alive when everyone around me has died". The "my mother was a genius" can be justified by the fact that Crookedstar never really hated Rainflower and didn't really think poorly of her; he only wanted to earn her respect.
Can none of you read descriptions? This was from Oakheart's point of view, not Crookedstar's. The two brothers had very different opinions of their mother.
Can none of you read descriptions? This was from Oakheart's point of view, not Crookedstar's. The two brothers had very different opinions of their mother.
Ye they have small little boots Queens get Old grandma boots Warriors gets Cool leather shoes Medicine cats get’s Leather shoes to Same to apprentices And leaders get boots with jet packs so they Can fly
This makes me so sad!!! But in a good way, bringing back so many memories. But if there is a reason I still remember warriors, when so many I know have forgotten it, then I'm still gonna love warriors.
I don't like how the Erin's just make dumb decisions. "We need a character to die so Tigerclaw looks like a good guy? OAKHEART" "We don't have a power for Hollyleaf? LETS MAKE HER GO MISSING" "Dovewing is considered a marysue by half of the fandom? LETS MAKE HER HAVE A CLICHE FORBIDDEN LOVE AND HAVE HER KITS BE HALFCLAN AND SHE RUNS AWAY BECAUSE SHE'S SENSITIVE!!" Also, this work is amazing!
Also why the heck didn't they give Hollyleaf Dovewing's power, they said they didn't know a power for her, but they did know a power for Dovewing?? Someone explain-
@@eevtrap1027 i guess they didn't come up with a power for her in the time Harper Collins wanted, so they had to drag on the fucking thing for six more books. i kinda get it, but this Power of Three story just got bad with Omen of the Stars so yeeeaaaaa wasn't the best decision
I just love the story behind the map! like at 2:30 to 2:38 i get how he is worried about taking back sunning rocks.. Because Bluestar is Thunderclan, etc. Its just amazing and that just one part! (I just keep watching this XD)
RainTheKitten 125 Not really replace Cloudtail and Brightheart with Graystripe and Silverstream. Theodosia-Silverstream Burr-Graystripe Hamilton-Fireheart
I feel as though Swiftpaw should be Burr and Cloudtail is Theodosia's husband. It makes more sense, because Swiftpaw wanted Brightheart to be his mate, but he died. Cloudtail became Brightheart's mate, but Swiftpaw wants Brightheart to be with him in Starclan. Like how Burr wants Theodosia, but she's taken.
I love how at the part where leslie sings "death doesn't discriminate" Mosskit dies and when he says "everyone who loves me has died" It's like he's saying that bluefur didn't love him anymore.
EVERYONE GATHER YOUR TORCHES WE MUST BURN THE 10 DISLIKERS SCREEEEEEEEEEE Who Could Dislike This Beautiful Work Of Art- The Anatomy, The Shading, The Timing, The Lyrics, The Colour, The Accuracy, The Character Design, The Artists.. It's All Perfect. Great Job Noodlers, Your Art Has Caught My Attention. You Guys Are Now My Favorite Animators. Keep Up The Good Work! :)
I love this PMV so, so much! It's amazing and so well done. I love the art and the fact it's centered around a character that's usually just seen as 'that one cat that Bluestar loves' or 'brother of Crookedstar'.
I came by because I wanted to see this masterwork of an animation again and despite having watched this so many times before already, I cried like every time. this proves once more how great it is
You know, the ending scene kinda made me think. I bet that she (Bluestar) wasn’t just mourning the loss of her deputy, Redtail, but the loss of a cat she loved too.... And she went on believing that it was Oakheart who killed Redtail for so long
I love this video so much. God, the smooth transition, simply amazing art, and the way the pictures and story itself matches with the song, I can only describe it as extraordinary. I feel like you really took OakHearts view in BlueStars Prophecy to heart in this video. Everything seems to be 100% accurate. Especially BlueStars shoulder scar. I also love the character designs. It's amazing how you didn't consider the way CrookedStar thinks about his mother, but rather how OakHeart thinks about her. She may have been cruel to CrookedStar, but she really did care for OakHeart. How could he hate her? I watch this video at least once everyday because I just enjoy it so much. Bravo! I hope you find more inspiration for full length songs soon!
I really love this pmv! I'm usually not a fan of pmv's because they're just static pictures with words and my eyes are more attracted to the moving aspects but your pmv's definitely have moving aspects! Holy crap! Plus it's Oakheart which isn't an overused character so extra brownie points for that!
I have to say this is the most awesome PMV you have created and I love the views from everything. During this I felt the pain of Oakheart when he learned that Mosskit had died, the growing relationship between him, Stonefur, and Mistyfoot, the half-betrayal as he watches Bluestar lead her Clan, the shock of his brother Crookedstar's declaration of war over Sunningrocks, and the realization that he can't betray his Clan - despite of this. This PMV tugged endlessly at my heart strings so at the end I was crying. This was VERY well done and I am mad that people feel bad for Bluestar during this.
lol, I like how "What is it like in his shoes" is kinda like RAINFLOWER LOVED ME BUT MY BROTHER IS LEADER AND WAS ALONE XD I also like how Crookedstar is Hamilton
It’s cool to see oakheart’s perspective for once, he seems to think that Crookedstar thrives and pulls through, but he’s been effected by mapleshade his entire life, losing everyone he loves. Lovely map, creative and interesting great job
I really like Oakheart. And I'm very sad that he died already at the start of the book. Wonderfully you showed its history. Sorry for my English, but I'm Poland. :)
"My mother was a genius" No, your mother was an asshole. Seriously though, I was lowkey planning a Greystripe pmv with this song but I can totally see how it fits the (totally underrated) Oakheart as well! Good job picking that out! All of you did really well, this turned out great! I love the expressions and the editing and colouring was flawless! Congrats on finishing this and I can't wait to see more from you all!
@@wolflover324x9 That is one adorable Broken. You can tell as he has more grayish fur (From Yellowfang) And I think Raggedstar has more black, also I think he doesn’t have that many scars/he doesn’t have them in the same spots as the thing shows. I’m sorry for making you read this, or even writing this, just I study that stuff CLOSELY and I want to put it to use 😝
This is the video that got me to actually listen to the Hamilton soundtrack and made me watch Warriors MAPs which in turn got me reading Warriors again. Thank you so much! It’s the reason why Wait For It is my favourite song.
Omg the relationship between Crookedstar and oakheart was amazing especially when after breaking his jaw and seeing his reflection oakheart comforts him and sticks up for him when Rainflower neglects him amazing PMV
Oakheart is a great character in my opinion, I really wish we got to see more of him, I also really like how you made oakheart’s eyes the same as Crookedjaw’s as well as how you show oakheart loved his mother!
it weird bc when reading Bluestar's Prophecy at the battle for Sunning Rocks your rooting for ThunderClan
But in Crookedstar's Promise in the same battle, you root for RiverClan
ahh perspective writing
Ima wind clan person :p
It couldn't be any more obvious that it's ThunderClans, though.
Same, and when I read a Thunderclan book they become my favorite clan, then I read a Windclan book and they become my favorite clan, etc..
Lol
I like how in a nutshell they had a battle over a pile of rocks.
This made me realize something I should have realized sooner. When Redtail died, and his body was brought into the camp, Bluestar received word of Oakheart's death as well as Redtail's, which meant that she was mourning her mate along with her deputy. Ah you Erins, you did it again!
Mistystar suffered as much as Bluestar
@@sheeprose7383 because she won't FUCKING DIE
Fr this is so sad to think about
Don't forget, she thought OAKHEART did it, AND Oakheart was killed in the same report.
@@ParasaurPalThat just makes it even worse
Mapleshade: Trying _really_ hard to kill all of Appledusk"s descendants.
Mistystar, the immortal cat: *laughs evilly*
XD
This
She really is immortal, she has most of her lives, and she is the oldest cat known, SHE IS STILL ALIVE IN A VEIL OF SHADOWS!!!
Mistystar will live forever
Graystripe, too! He’s also immortal
Damn. As much as I wanted some way to find out how Bluestar felt after Oakhearts death, how did I not connect her grief for Redtail to Oakheart?
Fiyera what
Fiyera I love bluestar.
@@kayleeherbert8658 they meant that when bluestar was grieving over Redtail, she was also grieving over Oakheart, if not even more
Luisa Frugoli Probably more since she loves Oakheart.
I always connected it. I always thought while she was mourning Red Tail, she was also secretly mourning Oak Heart
FINALLY SOMEONE REMEMBERED BLUESTARS SHOULDER SCAR AAAAAA A A A A A A A
SHOULDER*
lol ikr
why she had scar?
Tigerclaw attacked her.
She had that scar before Tigerclaw attacked her
1:51 HE LOOKS SO ADORABLE OH MY GOODNESS
Captain wolf3 aww your right it is adorable
AYE, LIKE A LITTLE CUTE SOMETHING I CAN’T SAY ANY MORE OR I’LL CRY, HE’S SO CUTE.
Captain wolf3 yeah
Captain wolf3 _he do a happ_
That Cato is doing a happ
I personally prefer Oakheart with green eyes, because it matches better with his pelt color. Also because I like the thought of Firestar looking like Oakheart, another reason Bluestar becomes close with him.
I agree. It also matches his brother's eyes.
I like to think Bluestar gave Fireheart the ‘Heart’ suffix because of Oakheart
@@marijougonzalez8437 ooh I never thought of that
I like that theory. I have my own theory that might actually be true. She thought of fireheart like her own kit
@@marijougonzalez8437 She actually did. Firestar reminds of Oakheart so much for Bluestar. Thats why she wanted to be his mentor and gave him "heart" as surffix.
Ok, but seriously, how the hell did no one realize that the cats that share the same prefix and same coat colors were Bluestar's kits?
SpottedwillowWH because *thrushpelt* lol
SpottedwillowWH :)) Oakheart told Graypool to keep secret about those kits and pretended they're hers. Literally, Oakheart and Graypool are the only RiverClan members knew the kits were from ThunderClan and none of RiverClan members know anything about Bluestar or her kits. So, they didn't suspect and assumed they're Graypool's kits.
I KNOW RIGHT
I thought it was their Suffix? I assume you're talking about 'fur
The prefixes were not the same, and if you meant suffix, that could just be a coincidence, and Graypool had a similar pelt.
Aaaaahh, It's really cool to have the point of view of Oakheart. Everyone used Bluestar and aaaah I love to see videos with an original character, plus, with a beautiful style like yours! ^w^
agreed 😸😸
Your style isn't bad either. Koerenn
Anyone else think Bluestar looks like a riverclan cat?
@@Thegoldenbucket100 she does look like a riverclan cat tbh
I 100% agree
I love the choice to make Crookedstar the Hamilton of this rather than give that to someone else, purely because the lyrics fit so damned well for him!
No other cat that could have been chosen had as much to prove and as little to lose as Crookedstar, and I think that this PMV really benefits from showing the development of the relationship between the two brothers.
I just love this so much oml.
same this map is really great
People say Firestar, or Bluestar were the best leaders
*CROOKED STAR*
They were brothers?! Holy shit
@@steller_star He took care of RiverClan pretty well. Everything went downhill after he died lol. Bluestar was a worse leader than in her later years-- Imo only Firestar and Tallstar are better, one because he's the main character and the other because I'm biased
That moment when you realize that you always imagined Oakheart with green eyes but he actually has amber eyes.... sighs
She's not the only one. Even one of the writers imagined him with green eyes but was corrected. Mistakes in the books also add to the confusion. In short she can do whatever the hell she likes.
WAIT WHAT?!
Agreed. Honestly, if there's gonna be mistakes in the books, and even among the writers, then the fans kiiinda have free reign as far as minor design choices go.
His picture is in the Warriors Guide, but that's like a silhouette, so you can't see his eyes. All cats are originially born with blue eyes, but they change color as the cats grow.
Its like how all thought Nightcloud had green eyes and Breezepelt had amber eyes but they both have amber eyes
The end made me tear up because you can see how much Oakheart longs to tell Bluestar the truth. That it wasn't his fault. That he'd never hurt her like that. But he can't tell her any of that and has to watch her pain and grief start to consume her. Her spiral down started with losing Redtail and only got worse with each lose after
at least she learned the truth later
At least weknow thir happy in Starclan :)
What truth? I don't get it.
@@ameenatasleem8477 tigerclaw killed redtail and blamed it on oakheart
YOOOOOOOOOOO THIS WAS SUCH GOOD QUALITY YOOOOOOOOOOo A++
Didn't expect you to be here 🤔
I agree! I loved it! Plus, love your vids, ColaCat!
IF I can call you ColaCat xD
hi your pmv is amazing!!
CONGRATS ON THE MAPS! Gg
Alexander Meowington
Aaron Purr
Cat puns
Jaguarzk AJ 10/10 cat puns
X3 thx
Jaguarzk thank you for this
Why not Hamilmoew?
Jaguarzk omg those are so bad 😜
*my class mates presenting a speech of Alexander Hamilton*
Classmate: Arron Burr-
Me: *SIRRRRRR!!!*
lmao same
THAT DEPENDS WHOS ASKING
OH SURE, SIR
Same tho
Me and my choir friends literally were preforming songs during this unit, 3 of us in total. I would keep the beat by using the table as a drum and providing backup vocals, and the two other ones (who r boys) would sing
After I read Bluestar's Prophecy, I went back and read Into the Wild and it's a little disturbing that Tigerclaw was like, "I killed this guy", and Bluestar had to deal with the whole, "This dude murdered my ex-boyfriend" thing. It's actually quite heartbreaking.
And she thought that Oakheart killed her deputy! But he didn’t :(
1:07
"When they died they left no instructions just-"
*My headphones:* Low battery
now you know kids, they left low battery
XDDD
WHEN THEY DIED THEY LEFT NO INSTRUCTIONS JUST lOw BaTtErY!!!!!
POV: when your listing to Hamilton and your headphones decide to die at the worst possible moment💀...
I can't praise this enough. I've also lost count of how many times I have watched this. Point blank my favourite PMV i've seen so far. You fitted the lyrics so perfectly with Oakheart's story and the visuals are stunning! Otherwise too the PMV's of you guys are incredibly good and high quality!
Firri April exactly the same 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I watch this daily, so ya
#SAME I agree wholeheartedly with all of this. It's amazing and there are no words to describe just how amazing it is.
Hey I subbed to u a while ago
Ikr i criiii
Thunderclan: We own Sunningrocks!
Riverclan: No, WE own Sunningrocks!
Twolegs: *lemme introduce myself*
Something I noticed:
In the OG book, I think they didn’t know who the father of Bluestar’s kits would be yet, so she really was devastated to have lost an amazing friend. But now, I feel like everyone interprets her sadness as to Oakheart and not Redtail.
I interpret it as both. Shed of course be upset over Redtails death but shed also be extremely upset over the death of her mate and the father of her kits
@@mcytfan1415 And that her strongest warrior said
her own mate killed Redtail
if she was only pretending to be sad about Redtail's death when she was really sad about Oakheart's death, I would hate her with all my heart. Like bitch? your deputy just died, and instead of going there to mourn him, you are saddened by the death of your ex-boyfriend who (supposedly) killed your deputy????? WTF?
You know the drill
1. Oakheart
2. Shellheart
3. Crooked star
4. Maple shade
5. Bluestar
6. Redtail
7. Apple dusk
8. Mosskit
9. Stonefur
10. Mistyfoot
Hey, at least I didn’t get appledusk?
GOD I SWEAR I WONT KILL THOSE I HATE
well, I might ;)))))
I dunno how these work
BlueStar
Im not gonna like my jaw andnmouth are to perfect to be ruined
mistyfoot :D
IT WAS THIS VIDEO
WHO BROUGHT MY OBSESSION OVER HAMILTON
AND THEN OTHER MUSICALS
THIS VIDEO IS GUILTY OF EVERYTHING
AND I LOVE IT
OH MY GOD SAME !
Same m8
Same
Eesh this comment has 99 likes. Help
Saaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaame
When I got older I started to realize how much terrible drama happens in the books.
I mean deaths, betrayal, heartbreaks, hiding kits, power balances, discrimination, serial killers, revenge ect.
I know our own cats have and had a lot of drama, but I'm so glad this was fiction
This MAP is also one of my favorite and, although very sad, one of my favorite couples.
The song also fits perfectly for Oakheart. And the cats look absolutely gorgeous
Oakheart: mY mOtHeR wAs A *genius*
Crookedstar: ok sUrE
(I- thanks for the likes!^^")
more like:
*my mother was a bully*
@@lol42069. lol yeah
*sarcastic* Rainflower sure was a mother of a year!
How can she treat her kids like that.....
yep love this heheheh
suuuuure WhAtEvEr *BRO*
If you think about it Bluestar was mourning for her mate and her deputy at the same time.
Nightwing yeah she was
Oakheart she was mourning us LOL
Oakheart now she's in Starclan with us though!
I just realized that. That's so sad!!
Bailey Herbert yeah Bluestar had a tough life 🤧
YOU KNOW ITS GOOD WHEN IT MAKES YOU CRY
FEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELLLLLS
Max is Gay yay I almost did at the end.
This guy karate-chopped my feelings in videos
I was in class and had to try not to cry
Maximus Gayus oml
I cried. Oak heart is my second favorite charecter( sorreltail being the first)
and this really relates to him. the animator thing person did a good job with dis
I've never realised how much this song relates to Oakheart..
(SPOILERS AHEAD!)
(Theodosia writes me a letter Everyday. Keeping her bed warm while her Husband is away. He's on the British side of Georgia, he's trying to keep the colonies in line.)
He longed to meet Bluestar every night after that one night when they meet each other and slept together. But Bluestar told him that they can't because they're in different clans. And it turns out, Bluestar was expecting kits. And since Thurshpelt had feelings for her, he had to pose to be the Father of the kits. In that way, Thrushpelt is Bluestars mate. "British side in Georgia" probably reference to Thunderclan and how he's trying to defend for it.
(But he can keep all of Georgia, Theodosia she's mine.)
Oakheart is still willing to wait for Bluestar, despite the clans had believed that Thrushpelt was the Father of his kits.
(Love doesn't discriminate, between the sinner and the saints and it takes and it takes. But we keep loving anyways.)
Oakheart knew that he had no chance with Bluestar because they were from different clans. Yet, they met up one night and after that, he waits for her by the Riverbank.
(We laugh and we cry and we brake and we make our mistakes.)
On that night, they laugh together, watch the stars together, they slept with each other, which ended up with Bluestar expecting his kits.
(And if there's a reason I'm by her side when so many have tried.)
Oakheart is still willing to wait for her. He even insisted that he join Thunderclan or she join Riverclan for the sake of their kits.
(Then I'm willing to wait for it, I'm willing to wait for it.)
Again, he waits for Bluestar by the riverbank each day. And now their kids too.
(Death doesn't discriminate. Between the sinners and the saints and it takes and it takes and it takes. And we keep living anyway.)
Mosskit died during the journey to bring the kits to Riverclan due to the cold. But after Bluestar returned to camp, she had to act as if she lost her kits and have to live on.
And yeah, that's it! I really hope they make a book specifically for Oakheart. Please correct me if I'm wrong for the info above.
After that, I think it's about Oakheart trying to move on and forget Bluestar, but he still remembers her, with Crookedstar being a (thankfully) oblivious idiot and battling over Sunningrocks, and at the battle, he has to confront his past
єтєяиαl wow!
Pups?
You wrote pups instead of kits.........................
Father of the pups? *what?!*
"He has nothing to lose"
Bc he already lost everything that he loved.
Mate
Kits
Parents
Brother
Shall I continue? Lol
Also, 2:22 is amazing
and his life.
@@salami7031 that's dark
Yeah, Crookedstar was never going to have a good life...
I'm obsessed with this! :D
Your name seems familiar....
Same
Aren’t you a RUclipsr.....
same!
@@rori1381 hey, my pride ?
man i cant wait until your next pmv but *im willing to wait for it*
*Claps slowly*
XD
☺
I see what you did there lmao x"DD
yay XDD
THIS IS SO GOOD
+king skyless ikrrr
OMG RIGHT?
It's perfect! Just on beat exactly. The song is perfect for Oakheart.
Completely agree
IKR!!!!!
0:11 Me when I cant reach the cookie jar on the top shelf
1:27 Me when I finally get the cookie jar, but its empty
1:51 Me when i look behind me and there's a fresh batch of cookies just waiting for me
... same here.
LETS STACK UP TO REACH DOS COOKIES!!
FOR OAK`HEARTTTTTTT XD
I’m actually dying omg-
This is really good, everyone's talents really shined through! Love oakheart and his bro...... much......
Nifty-Senpai hewwo
I know om four years late but you do realise its a pmv? You said everyone's tailents...
@@mcytfan1415 read desc
@@kakaaw228 oh its by 2 people lol
"What is it like in his shoes" WHAT SHOES AM I MISSING SOMETHING
Kittykat Pikachu I read this just as that line sung out.
lmao
DID YOU NOT NOTICE THESE CATS HAVE FORMED THE TALENT OF WRITTEN LITERACY
He's the deputy
Kittykat Pikachu he means wait is it like to be him
I always wonder what happened if Bluestar fought in the battle with RiverClan too, and met Oakheart. I mean, everyone else would've been shocked to see that the leader of a Clan and the deputy of another one don't fight in a a battle and just stand and watch each other... Or so...
Never would happen though. Oakheart and Bluestar most likely avoided each other when in battle, if they ever fought in the same battles. They obviously would just take on the other cats around from their rivaling clans.
Kei i think you'll be right c:
But what about when the rocks fell? Would she grieve him? Or what if he was on another cat and she was the only one that could help. Would she fight him?
+strawberry queen We'll never know.
strawberry queen She would i guess
I think Bluestar always knew that Oakheart didnt kill Redtail.i think she just wanted to trust her warriors and didnt want to expose her secret.
I'm so glad I discovered this. This is absolutely beautiful. Like almost breathtaking. The Oakheart/Bluestar relationship was rushed and poorly handled in canon in my opinion, but you made it really enjoyable here. And the final battle, well, that was simply magical. I could really feel the thrill and adrenaline of the warriors as they went to fight, knowing they might not come back alive. All in all this was brilliant. Amazing job.
Jeromimo Yes of course Oakheart's entire life is part of the video, and the entire video was brilliant. I just found that the Oakheart + Bluestar moments caught my attention in particular just because I thought it had more impact here than it does in the books.
I love it too.
Ya I like Oakheart but I hate Bluestar she's cruel becuase she ran Thistleclaw out of starclan he was fine there
Elisa Wheeler I never agreed with the way the writers made Thistleclaw out to be a villain. He didn't kill his Clanmates or break the warrior code when he was alive so it didn't make much sense to portray him as a villain just because he didn't get along with one of the protagonists.
Elisa Wheeler Actually, the Erin's were just joking about that soo......
Oakheart is maybe now my first or second favorite, after seeing this and some other videos and thinking more of him and his life. They should make a special edition book about him, he deserves it. Everyone thinks of him as Crookedstar's brother, or Bluestar's mate, it's true, but they should think more of him. Even though Stonefur and Mistyfoot talk about how Oakheart faked Greypool was his mate, there should be special edition so we can see it through HIS eyes. I think the Erin Hunters should work on it.
I couldn't agree more! Now let's figure out how to contact them...
Ikr
i agree, instead of a super edition about a cat we've never heard of before (hawkwing's journey)
Exactly
Of course, the Erins would turn his book into "Crookedstar's Promise: Oakclaw's POV"
(I know I said Oakclaw, it's a joke)
Who else got introduced to Hamilton from this video :,)
Me
This was the first one I saw.
Partialy. My freinds already know and told me about it. But I never listened to any hamilton songs.
Yes. Me!
✋🏻
Wait for it is legit so accurate
Except
“My mother was a genius”
More like
“My mother was genius.....
AT NEGLECTION!”
This is in Oakhearts POV, and she wasn't ever that negligent to him, so not really.
As they stated in the description, he had a separate upbringing, so had different views then Crookedstar, and the readers
Yes. I'm salty about Her neglecting Crooked Star.
A Bush
This video was in Oakhearts perspective. He probably thought his mother was amazing!
Purrfessor Dumbledore It has been 10 months since I read Crookedstar’s promise and I’m still salty you cannot convince me otherwise
A Tree
Ok but Rainflower also got bullied as a kit and probably got traumatized and then bullied Stormkit . I am not defending her actions though she is horrible.
**climbs out of warriors trash, falls In Hamilton garbage bin** .......*sigh
I feel ya
*_ikr_*
Ikr
Same. I also fell into the DEH trash can and SU trash can after that.
Edit: I fell into the heathers trash can too, and also (my favorite musical at the time) the Be More Chill trashcan.
*Falls into Steven Universe trashcan*
I cried over this SO MANY TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!This is one of the most meaningful and sad relationships in warriors!
Hamilton+Warriors=
Life itself.
Btw, this is beautiful. Amazing job! :)
FangArt tbh NUUUUUU I DEFEND WARRIORS FROM THE HAMILTON FANDOM RRRREEEEEEEEEEE
but i must admit this is a good pmv n I love it ❤
Cinderleaf I’m in both fandoms tho...
FangArt that IS MY LIFE
Couldn't agree more.
I was on a Moonkitti livestream and more than half the comments were references to Hamilton. (Srsly, it was filled with comments such as "And Peggy")
Man, this is so nostalgic. I remember watching this seven years ago on my way down to Florida, where I was purposed to, and then eventually I got married, and now I have a 22 month old son like what ;;
I don't know how you guys do it, but I love it! You do such a fabulous job and I love the song! I never really thought about it from Oakheart's POV before. If you think about it, he's lost a lot too. Maybe even more than Bluestar. Yes, he does have his kids, but they don't know that he's their father! This really made me feel for him. Thanks for this beautiful piece of art!
Well, Ithink they do know that Oakheartis their father. Mistyfoot tells Fireheart that Oakheart her father. But since that was in Forest of Secrets, it might be considered outdated proof now, but...
Weegeepie 27 I meant she didn't know at the time.
Aspen Despain Yes, but she said this before she knew Bluestar was her mother.
Weegeepie 27 Really? I didn't remember that. Okay then.
No they knew Oakheart was their dad and thought Graypool was their mom. If you remember that scene in the beginning of Forest of Secrets it picks up where Blue drops her kits with Oak and then leaves and we see Oak taking them to RiverClan and giving them to Graypool
I love your skill at drawing cats
yeah, i agree! a lot of this art is like 7-8mo old now, and we have learned a lot in terms of compositions & art style!
Did anyone else besides me cry there ass off after they read blue stars prophecy?
Yurio Is Gay same
*_raises hand slowly as well_*
Furries Forever same
Snug Kit I did :'( (especially after Mosskit, Snowfur, and Morningflower died)
Raises hand slowly
That scene of the riverclan warriors emerging from the river gives me chills every time
!! This is rEALLY COOl! Everything is so well drawn - you guys obviously put a lot of heart into it ;u;
OMG FUNALLY SOMEONE DO AN AMV ABOUT OAKHEART, THANK YOU
+Caterina Luti
IKR!!!
I agree he is an underestimated character yet is really important (and handsome)
Yeah he really is an underestimated character. He's actually one of my favorites and I think it's sad he doesn't get appreciated more often.
+Kiara SaysHi I think he's underestimated because not everyone has read the whole series, but in Into The Wild (which is where most people start) he's only mentioned at the beginning when he was killed, so he wasn't really noticed. It's a shame, I would have liked to see more of him, although he is from Riverclan and the main story generally follows Thunderclan cats, so he isn't one of the main ones. :/
+Sabrina Richard
Oh my god, yus! I wish Oakheart joined ThunderClan :(
This Replay button is dead and my history is filled with Hamilton PMVs
Lps Tigerlily same lol
SAMEEEE
In Bluestars prophecy, you see how great and understanding of a mate he is, in Crookedstar promise you see how great of a father he is, although he got into a fight with Crookedstar for being a bad father, I love his character development
So your channel just popped up in my recommended, and I remembered how much I used to love Warriors (I mean I still own every single book) but still, and this brought back such a huge flood of emotions and this just rekindled by love for it and fjhkjd it was so beautiful. All your videos are.
This is great! I feel like this also fits well with Crookedstar, particularly the "if there's a reason I'm still alive when everyone around me has died". The "my mother was a genius" can be justified by the fact that Crookedstar never really hated Rainflower and didn't really think poorly of her; he only wanted to earn her respect.
"my mother was a genius"
HA
No she was an ass
+Emily Liston hole
I agree with both of you.
Can none of you read descriptions? This was from Oakheart's point of view, not Crookedstar's. The two brothers had very different opinions of their mother.
Can none of you read descriptions? This was from Oakheart's point of view, not Crookedstar's. The two brothers had very different opinions of their mother.
"What is it like in his shoes?"
CAT'S HAVE SHOES!!!???
@StarryVinegar *booties*
I think they are called booties, my cat wore them once and she was like a pregnant woman on Heroin
@@strawberrymilk5955 funny how u said it
Ye they have small little boots
Queens get Old grandma boots
Warriors gets Cool leather shoes
Medicine cats get’s Leather shoes to
Same to apprentices
And leaders get boots with jet packs so they Can fly
This makes me so sad!!! But in a good way, bringing back so many memories. But if there is a reason I still remember warriors, when so many I know have forgotten it, then I'm still gonna love warriors.
I really like how the Cats are drawn! (Editen because of much correction :T)
-I can't type for gods sake
Lolll why so much likes (330) =3
Fabulous Tessa *drawn
Fabulous Tessa I read, "I really like how cats are drowned!"
XD
Pokeminer AJ lol i didn't Day that mr. Pokeminer AJ
*Say
Fabulous Tessa I'm a girl. No need to apologize. It's fine.
I don't like how the Erin's just make dumb decisions.
"We need a character to die so Tigerclaw looks like a good guy? OAKHEART"
"We don't have a power for Hollyleaf? LETS MAKE HER GO MISSING"
"Dovewing is considered a marysue by half of the fandom? LETS MAKE HER HAVE A CLICHE FORBIDDEN LOVE AND HAVE HER KITS BE HALFCLAN AND SHE RUNS AWAY BECAUSE SHE'S SENSITIVE!!"
Also, this work is amazing!
We need a reason for thistleclaw to be in the df: SPOTTEDPAW WILL BE MOLESTED
Also why the heck didn't they give Hollyleaf Dovewing's power, they said they didn't know a power for her, but they did know a power for Dovewing?? Someone explain-
@@eevtrap1027 i guess they didn't come up with a power for her in the time Harper Collins wanted, so they had to drag on the fucking thing for six more books. i kinda get it, but this Power of Three story just got bad with Omen of the Stars so yeeeaaaaa wasn't the best decision
Mayachi making hawkfrost evil was also a bad decision!
Wow. This was moving. Hamilton and Warriors are two of my favorite things and mashing them together... wonderful. The ending really packed a punch.
I love this PMV because unlike some others i can tell who every character is and the song relates to them A*+++++
I just love the story behind the map! like at 2:30 to 2:38 i get how he is worried about taking back sunning rocks.. Because Bluestar is Thunderclan, etc. Its just amazing and that just one part! (I just keep watching this XD)
Koolibii A MAP is a Multi animator project,this my dear friend is a PMV
This song also kinda fits Cloudtail....
Cloudtail = Burr
Brightheart = Theodosia
Swiftpaw = Theodosia's husband
Firestar = Hamilton
RainTheKitten 125 I mean, not really....cloudtail didn't have much trouble getting brightheart, nor did firestar forbid it.
RainTheKitten 125 Not really replace Cloudtail and Brightheart with Graystripe and Silverstream.
Theodosia-Silverstream
Burr-Graystripe
Hamilton-Fireheart
I feel as though Swiftpaw should be Burr and Cloudtail is Theodosia's husband. It makes more sense, because Swiftpaw wanted Brightheart to be his mate, but he died. Cloudtail became Brightheart's mate, but Swiftpaw wants Brightheart to be with him in Starclan. Like how Burr wants Theodosia, but she's taken.
+ItsATabbyCat nuevarspana I agree.
Lol true!
I love how at the part where leslie sings "death doesn't discriminate" Mosskit dies and when he says "everyone who loves me has died" It's like he's saying that bluefur didn't love him anymore.
EVERYONE
GATHER YOUR TORCHES
WE MUST BURN THE 10 DISLIKERS
SCREEEEEEEEEEE
Who Could Dislike This Beautiful Work Of Art- The Anatomy, The Shading, The Timing, The Lyrics, The Colour, The Accuracy, The Character Design, The Artists.. It's All Perfect. Great Job Noodlers, Your Art Has Caught My Attention. You Guys Are Now My Favorite Animators. Keep Up The Good Work! :)
Don't do that... they just couldn't see anything well after replaying this 200 times, and click the dislike button.
they probably didn't mean to and just had their device upside down.😥😊
8 years later and this is still one of my favorite memories
I love this PMV so, so much! It's amazing and so well done. I love the art and the fact it's centered around a character that's usually just seen as 'that one cat that Bluestar loves' or 'brother of Crookedstar'.
I came by because I wanted to see this masterwork of an animation again and despite having watched this so many times before already, I cried like every time. this proves once more how great it is
You know, the ending scene kinda made me think.
I bet that she (Bluestar) wasn’t just mourning the loss of her deputy, Redtail, but the loss of a cat she loved too....
And she went on believing that it was Oakheart who killed Redtail for so long
This play/musical was absolutely outstanding. I'm so happy people are using the songs from it in Warriors animations.
I love this video so much. God, the smooth transition, simply amazing art, and the way the pictures and story itself matches with the song, I can only describe it as extraordinary. I feel like you really took OakHearts view in BlueStars Prophecy to heart in this video. Everything seems to be 100% accurate. Especially BlueStars shoulder scar. I also love the character designs. It's amazing how you didn't consider the way CrookedStar thinks about his mother, but rather how OakHeart thinks about her. She may have been cruel to CrookedStar, but she really did care for OakHeart. How could he hate her? I watch this video at least once everyday because I just enjoy it so much. Bravo! I hope you find more inspiration for full length songs soon!
I love the emotion conveyed at 1:13. What a heartbreaking scene.
I really love this pmv! I'm usually not a fan of pmv's because they're just static pictures with words and my eyes are more attracted to the moving aspects but your pmv's definitely have moving aspects! Holy crap! Plus it's Oakheart which isn't an overused character so extra brownie points for that!
HELLO, new favorite warriors pmv! this is fantastic and dynamic and does oakheart's character so much more justice than the books ever did! :"0
This is the video that got me into Hamilton. I thank you so much for playing such a major role in my life.
I still get goosebumps after all this time.. thank you for this masterpiece. ❤
Warriors will never escape Hamilton Hell.
TragicUnity
Hell no
Hamilton HEAVEN
Oakheart's Bby X3 great name
YO THANKYOU THANKYOU Meowcakeplays :3
TragicUnity hell? its hamilheaven
This song is perfect for Oakbae and Bluestar!I hit the replay button so many times.
I can't explain how much I love this MAP
not a MAP, but thank you!
+Noodlers you made this?! On your own?!
'Noodlers' is a multi-person channel. Multiple people animate these, this PMV in particular was made by climbtothestars and hoxau
+Inkythewolfgirl oh, ok.
❤❤❤❤
I have to say this is the most awesome PMV you have created and I love the views from everything. During this I felt the pain of Oakheart when he learned that Mosskit had died, the growing relationship between him, Stonefur, and Mistyfoot, the half-betrayal as he watches Bluestar lead her Clan, the shock of his brother Crookedstar's declaration of war over Sunningrocks, and the realization that he can't betray his Clan - despite of this. This PMV tugged endlessly at my heart strings so at the end I was crying. This was VERY well done and I am mad that people feel bad for Bluestar during this.
0:19 KEEPIG
@@xx_azura_xx8899 I realized, too.
lol, I like how "What is it like in his shoes" is kinda like RAINFLOWER LOVED ME BUT MY BROTHER IS LEADER AND WAS ALONE XD
I also like how Crookedstar is Hamilton
im addicted. Ive watched this video maybe 20 times the last 3 days
same XD
Same!
same
same
R WE LL SURE WERE NOT THE SAME?! XD
It’s cool to see oakheart’s perspective for once, he seems to think that Crookedstar thrives and pulls through, but he’s been effected by mapleshade his entire life, losing everyone he loves. Lovely map, creative and interesting great job
I really like Oakheart. And I'm very sad that he died already at the start of the book. Wonderfully you showed its history. Sorry for my English, but I'm Poland. :)
"My mother was a genius"
No, your mother was an asshole.
Seriously though, I was lowkey planning a Greystripe pmv with this song but I can totally see how it fits the (totally underrated) Oakheart as well!
Good job picking that out!
All of you did really well, this turned out great! I love the expressions and the editing and colouring was flawless! Congrats on finishing this and I can't wait to see more from you all!
Being a genius is not the same
1:24 Why do you draw Brokenstar so adorably I wanna keep him now
Actually that might be Raggedstar? Hmm
HMmMMMM LiKe sAmE-
He is adorable, if it is not Raggedstar
@@wolflover324x9 That is one adorable Broken. You can tell as he has more grayish fur (From Yellowfang) And I think Raggedstar has more black, also I think he doesn’t have that many scars/he doesn’t have them in the same spots as the thing shows. I’m sorry for making you read this, or even writing this, just I study that stuff CLOSELY and I want to put it to use 😝
So happy this is back! It's what originally got me into Hamilton and what made me finally take the plunge into reading warriors. Thank you!!
lol oak actuAlly looks good with greeeeeeen eyes e3e
wait.... so you love Kpop, Hamilton, and Warriors? Maybe even Ryan higa?
If so we'd be twins.
not ryan higa but ham ham warriors and kpop yass
ahhh this is so beautiful
IM WATCHING THIS NON-STOP
ayeeee
Agreed!
yep
Same
Frosty lol i see what you did there!
This is the video that got me to actually listen to the Hamilton soundtrack and made me watch Warriors MAPs which in turn got me reading Warriors again. Thank you so much! It’s the reason why Wait For It is my favourite song.
Omg the relationship between Crookedstar and oakheart was amazing especially when after breaking his jaw and seeing his reflection oakheart comforts him and sticks up for him when Rainflower neglects him amazing PMV
Oakheart was such a great guy. *Muffled sobbing in the background*
I love the originality in this! Not often you find a PMV/AMV about Oakheart of all cats
***** Ikr? I mean, I know he isn't in the books much but neither was Scourge and Scourge gets more attention
+AlphaWolfDrummer I KNOW! he deserved MORE
Read CrookedStar's Promise and BlueStar's Prophecy, Oak Is in those books. As for Scourge he has his own Manga/Book
+Mangle The Pirate Fox
*isn't in the books much
He was mentioned a couple of times in TPB and in some chapters of Bluestar's Prophecy.
I can’t stop replaying this
oooo this gave me shivers
this was so well done!
Oakheart: My mother was a genius.
Me: Actually, she was the worst mother in all of Warriors.
Read the description
WERE DO U GET THESE ONGS I LOVE THEM
+Acadia cat what...
i love these song i RElisten to them every day!
Hamilton Musical
thx!
Acadia cat ikr
Oakheart is a great character in my opinion, I really wish we got to see more of him, I also really like how you made oakheart’s eyes the same as Crookedjaw’s as well as how you show oakheart loved his mother!