There is a difrence between easing suffering in a physical way by providing relief services in the way of resources and medical care. To remove the emotional trauma or "negative emotions" is a far more delicate process and is a sign that she does not understand the value of pain. Pain helps us remember but also to learn and to grow. With good council, trauma can be eased, but the memory lingers. While I can understand the intent, the willful disregard of the outcome is the final nail in the coffin. She removed the ability to feel anything, and that is the problem.
Isidora had good intentions but her desire to heal her father consumed her - no different than how Anakin’s fear of losing his wife led him to become Darth Vader. It’s natural to want to help someone who is suffering and the fact is her father was clearly consumed by his grief already at this point. It’s been how many years since her brother died and rather than trying to be a good father to his remaining child, he is wallowing in grief for the loss of another child. This could also be a bit of an insight as to why Isidora is obsessed with taking away her father’s pain, maybe she believes that the loss of the grief for her brother will make her father love her again, a love that she’s probably been without since her brother died. It is not the responsibility of the child to make the parent happy. The parent has a responsibility to the child, and while the loss of one child is understandable, it is no excuse to stop being a loving, caring parent to the other child who still lives.
Isadora and the Keepers both had points. It's really a missed opportunity thst you can't meet in the middle to try and find a balance between locking knowledge away and falling to it.
Isidora was corrupted by the Ancient Magic. It is heavily implied that Ancient Magic, especially when combined with extracted emotion, is a corrupting influence. We do not see Rackham use raw Ancient Magic, and if the main character decides to absorb Ancient Magic at the end of the game, they are changed by it.
Isadora was a villain who didn't know she was a villain. Pain is part of being human. If you can't feel pain, you are dead inside. She needed a session with a muggle therapist.
Love this video! I believe she started out with good intentions, but the keeper's should have told her 'With great power, comes great responsibility'. The problem I believe is that Isidora didn't understand that, emotional pain is different to a physical one, though both can intertwine with how it makes you 'feel' as a whole. Removing a pain or any negative emotion ; removes a part of what makes you human. Her father was in some sort of deep, grieving depression and maybe he felt as though he failed as a father. It has never been stated mind, when her brother passed away, or from what I have played multiple times. If we are assuming he passed not long after the events of the keepers, then how did Isidora survive, if her father had 'given up' ; so to speak? Or did his pass away not long after she started at Hogwarts? Was her brother the favourite out of the two? I few questions I still ask. Long and short; is she a villain? Jury has come back with a yes for me, good intentions or not. The magic was still unknown, but powerful.
That was a great video. I actually really liked Isadora. She had her bad points but then agains so did the keepers themselves. You are a great story teller. Please do more Hogwarts legacy lore videos.
She had good intentions at the start but later she was doing it for power cuz she realized that by inhaling the Emotions she would increase her power
Isidora was more of a well intentioned villain. She meant well, she wanted to help, but she went off the rails and lost herself in her grief.
There is a difrence between easing suffering in a physical way by providing relief services in the way of resources and medical care. To remove the emotional trauma or "negative emotions" is a far more delicate process and is a sign that she does not understand the value of pain. Pain helps us remember but also to learn and to grow. With good council, trauma can be eased, but the memory lingers. While I can understand the intent, the willful disregard of the outcome is the final nail in the coffin. She removed the ability to feel anything, and that is the problem.
Isidora had good intentions but her desire to heal her father consumed her - no different than how Anakin’s fear of losing his wife led him to become Darth Vader. It’s natural to want to help someone who is suffering and the fact is her father was clearly consumed by his grief already at this point. It’s been how many years since her brother died and rather than trying to be a good father to his remaining child, he is wallowing in grief for the loss of another child. This could also be a bit of an insight as to why Isidora is obsessed with taking away her father’s pain, maybe she believes that the loss of the grief for her brother will make her father love her again, a love that she’s probably been without since her brother died. It is not the responsibility of the child to make the parent happy. The parent has a responsibility to the child, and while the loss of one child is understandable, it is no excuse to stop being a loving, caring parent to the other child who still lives.
Isadora and the Keepers both had points. It's really a missed opportunity thst you can't meet in the middle to try and find a balance between locking knowledge away and falling to it.
Great one bro
Isidora was corrupted by the Ancient Magic. It is heavily implied that Ancient Magic, especially when combined with extracted emotion, is a corrupting influence. We do not see Rackham use raw Ancient Magic, and if the main character decides to absorb Ancient Magic at the end of the game, they are changed by it.
Isadora was a villain who didn't know she was a villain. Pain is part of being human. If you can't feel pain, you are dead inside. She needed a session with a muggle therapist.
The road to corruption is paved with good intentions.
This was a really great video. I actually really enjoy it ❤
I enjoyed this ❤ wonderful job
Love this video! I believe she started out with good intentions, but the keeper's should have told her 'With great power, comes great responsibility'. The problem I believe is that Isidora didn't understand that, emotional pain is different to a physical one, though both can intertwine with how it makes you 'feel' as a whole. Removing a pain or any negative emotion ; removes a part of what makes you human. Her father was in some sort of deep, grieving depression and maybe he felt as though he failed as a father. It has never been stated mind, when her brother passed away, or from what I have played multiple times. If we are assuming he passed not long after the events of the keepers, then how did Isidora survive, if her father had 'given up' ; so to speak? Or did his pass away not long after she started at Hogwarts? Was her brother the favourite out of the two? I few questions I still ask.
Long and short; is she a villain? Jury has come back with a yes for me, good intentions or not. The magic was still unknown, but powerful.
Very nice character analysis.
That was a great video. I actually really liked Isadora. She had her bad points but then agains so did the keepers themselves. You are a great story teller. Please do more Hogwarts legacy lore videos.
Isidora is muggleborn so her brother and father are muggles
Really? I didn't see anything in my research that she was muggle born but I will definitely look into it for further videos.
Nope. She is Half-Blood
I've played the game once all the way through, and a couple times part way. What Isadora did, I believe was at best unethical, at worst sinister.
I played this game a bit never finished it
You should, it's really good.
Destruction makes the best villain 😅
Interesting story.
Really enjoyed hogwarts
She is bad as feelings makes us human
Good theory! It's a shame that this game will get the noms and my beloved Black Myth: Wukong gets wrongfully snubbed.
I have been meaning to play Black Myth: Wukong also. The game looks amazing. I might do some Lore content on it as well.