Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! Makita Gold: amzn.to/3Fxu8Mn Dewalt: amzn.to/3AfYYVU TEMO: amzn.to/3uTgder Milwaukee: amzn.to/3aalG6X ARES: amzn.to/3AeD1pV Neiko: amzn.to/36dQLFQ Irwin: amzn.to/3lfgQIN Ryobi: amzn.to/3fMkRDr Hart: amzn.to/3DektYY Makita: amzn.to/33qGVPf
Do I have an impact driver? No. Do I need an adapter? No. Will the outcome of this video directly benefit me? No. Will I watch the entire thing with great interest? Of course!
I’m from Canada do you Americans get the craftsman line in the USA I’d like to see them tested you can get the drill and driver for 100 cdn on sale regularly. It’s a great budget set I also have dewalt tools and the craftsman stuff isn’t that much worse.
I don't use all that stuff either But the videos about undercoating or anti-seize got me thinking. However, I don't even get most of these Products on the European market. But I can compare. FuidFilm for Example has Products that perform like Cosmoline Rp and meets the same military standardization. You learn what to watch for 😁
Same, recently when I had to buy some (emergency situation) Radiator Stop Leak, I searched and didn't see any videos from PF, I was legitimately uncertain about buying any of them. lol
All the impact adapters that broke in the small cross area are breaking safely. Rather than twisting and possibly throwing chips, they break quickly and reliably, without shrapnel.
That may be the case but it’s ironic that most of them are the bigger brands who had that but along with that claimed the biggest breaking strengths…. This is why people like him are vital, don’t believe the hype that big brands claim, save your money when you can and buy the tool for its quality, not it’s name
My dad isn't an technology guy, doesn't even have an email address. But I told him about your channel and now he's a youtube addict for your channel and won't get off their computer. He loves working in the shop and can't get enough. Great video!
you'll first have to form a committee, then have a meeting, then form a group to oversee the committee, then the group will have to have a meeting, then the board will need to approve the committee, then have a meeting about the group, then maybe you can present to the board so they can have another meeting.......in between golfing that is.
I have no idea how, but I think I've just chain watched this guy for like 3 hours... Learnt lots, but not sure where the time went haha. RUclips is a strange beast.
It's not just RUclips, as many RUclips channels' content varies from person to person. PF content is legitimately no exception and is highly useful with testing, legitimate data, and time efficiency of each video he puts out. He dedicated his channel from experience and whatever gets him started from his heart, he'll put it out there. He saved a lot of industrial workers time so that they can get the best tools to work with by the various tests and various tools that PF utilized with in comparison to each brand. If it wasn't for this channel, I would somewhat be buying the average tools and others, but I seek for the best tools.
My understanding is the impact bits with “torsion zones” are designed for the bit to last longer in its useful life span. Meaning when you’re using the bit to fasten nuts/bolts, or remove them, the bits don’t undergo this kind of extended even torque you see in the video, rather they experience momentary shock force, that drops of rapidly. Those torsion zones are there so that the bits don’t twist over time or multiple uses, but are rather designed to absorb the momentary shock and snap back into original shape. They’re not designed for high constant torque applications, but rather many, many, many smaller momentary shock torque hits. So like if your driving a million deck screws - that’s where these bits shine, they will survive longer without twisting over time.
I very highly agree. I want speed insert, good fitment, drive speed and balance. On the back end good edge retention always makes a big deal. It is very interesting that he's testing them in inverse which is probably the best way to save 1,000,000 hours... I think objectively this video is just a steel composition comparison for nightmare testing. I think he's actually peering pretty deep here.
@@Ihavetopoop718 i agree with most of his testing methodology. In particular the tests involving bit edge retention and head strength over use/time. My only complaint is regarding the claim that the bits with "torque zones" are compositionally weaker under constant high torque application. That part the bits with torque zones are not designed for, they're designed as a system to survive longer the repeated hammer hits from hammer drivers as you're putting in lots of repeated screws (like deck screws) with lots of small momentary repeated torque blows from the hammer mechanism, acting like a spring and snapping back slightly after each hit - thereby not putting in a permanent twist to the bit, and protecting the head and teeth (Phillips, Torx, etc.) from damage. They're not designed for high torque applications like bolts that needs to be torqued to 150Lbs with a slow turn of a torque wrench or even an Impact Wrench...in this case obviously the thicker the better.
Well you have to admit testing these to the point of failure does give you some indication as to overall durability. Just look at how the DeWalt ran away with the title in the test which counts most... For use with impact tools that generate less than 2000 inch pounds... Which is coincidentally where the bit snapped.
@@ConcernedCitizenPPCA I agree...I grabbed some of those just to have. But still, there's a reason they design them with these torque zones, and its not for ultimate steady state torque strength, but rather repeated multi-use. So would be interesting to see them tested against each other within those parameters.
I picked up the DeWalt brand adapters on a whim, then watched this video with fingers crossed, and low and behold, luck was on my side! Thanks for the in-depth reviews, you are the man!
I really appreciate the fact you buy all these products. I love how fair you make all these test. You should start including the comments where people make suggestions that you pick.
Not here for shout outs. Only one guy deserves a pat on the back and it's the creator of the channel. I just want to see his work. The comment section is active enough.
Thank you very much! Trust me, manufacturers do watch the videos and most of them appreciate the unbiased reviews. I've had offers for contract work testing products for major brands but have declined all offers. Thanks again
@@ProjectFarm I was always curious if you had feedback from manufacturers because of your videos. Thanks for staying unbias. It makes me questions what level of testing takes place from manufacturers of their parts in the first place... Granted not everyone is trying to be the best product on the shelf, but trying to be the best product at the best price for how it will be used is important for people to remember too.
I work in mechanical construction and we always use Milwaukee adapters and we go through multiple a month. One of the most useful videos I've seen in a fair while, safe to say we will deffinatly be picking up a different brand next time, thanks a lot and always love your content.
@@probablynotwearingpants6228 I think they do. Pretty much all companies that produce or sell consumer products have Instagram and/or Facebook pages. That means they have a person or team responsible for their social media presence which involves monitoring as much as it does content creation.
@@MikeCookie1973 I know they have marketing, tech, social media and whatnot but i imagine somewhere there's a person solely devoted to finding any little mention of that company whether it be on youtube or some strange foreign language forum in another country. I guess like a forensic investigator for the internet.
@@ProjectFarm Thank you for saving consumers so much time and money so we don’t have to figure out the best on our own! I would love to see an episode on ratcheting wrenches when possible
Yep the Gen 1 Milwaukee socket adapters were stronger and built more like the Dealt he tested. The shock zone is a gimmick to sell more bits but its catching up to all these manufacturers nobody will buy them before to long.
Bro you saved me money lol. I upgraded to a brushless dewalt and broke a ryobi adapter and another no brand one qnd then ended up ordering the makita and so far so good
@@replynotificationsdisabled No, the point isn't usually to break them, but if you're going to buy one, wouldn't you want to know that you are buying the one that won't let you down if you're working late at night fixing something and it just happens to be the tool you have, or the tool that fits in a tight spot, and if you break it while working you can't just go get another one. I like to buy tools that last, like I like to buy cars that won't leave me stranded on the side of the road 20 miles from civilization.
Thank you for including Ryobi! It's such a common and popular brand for average consumers and hobbyists like myself. I'm sure a LOT of viewers are thankful to see the brand represented
Spot on comment; very clever testing methodology. And making sure the threads were properly lubed controls a key error variable. PF really is the gold standard for grass-root RUclips product evaluation content. And especially, NO SPONSORSHIP. Can you imagine how much he has been tempted?! Please, stay true to your principles and never cross the line! Don't even look over the edge. There are enough people out here that value your purity to keep your channel healthy. We will endure the non-related ads so you get eyeballs (and good rates) because we recognize your commitment.
I've always been concerned with those impact absorption areas on these various companies impact adapters and bits and this test proved why! It makes some pretty rudimentary sense that less material provides less stability.
See? Smart ppl live in Indonesia! While I already know thats true, I can only currently confirm this bcuz this lovely person knows where to get their unbiased consumer reviews. Greetings from USA, friend! U clearly have impeccable taste😊👍
@@deelanders6132 i literally watching this channel, when pf just testing the mower engine thing, First PF video that i watch is what happen if you put dirt on engine....
Thanks for another super useful comparison. I picked up a Snap-on 1/2" to 3/8" adapter, after my Craftsman twisted off, due to their superior image. While it did not twist off, the square section is now loose in the socket part. These adapters are often useful when a deep socket is needed and it would be nice to know which work well.
I find myself rooting for the tools I have in my garage when you are testing on the channel... love the content, please keep videos coming, fair testing of well known brands helps when trying DIY! Thank you
Hey I just wanna say that we really appreciate everything you do. You make it easy for not only the average weekend warrior taking on home/car projects but also for everyday professionals who work day to day with the same tools/equipment you test to make sound decisions. I've been watching and following along for about 3 years and it's always been quality content.
Sir hands down this is for me the Best go to channel for reference to see tested things, And my hats of to you for your help, hard work, and care, I will always recommend the channel to all those who are interested. Keep well my prayers for all in these troubled times, bless.
@@ProjectFarm , I think that's a Great idea. I have always wondered about those. While set up for such a test, maybe a test for impact extensions designed for transmitting FULL torque. I've never had much luck with an extension on an impact.
Perfect idea! Always curious to know if it's the appropriate torque after putting a customers wheel on with one. So they're able to get the wheel off on the side of the road without struggling.
I have the dewalt impact adapter and feel confident to be aggressive with them after this review. Thanks for making these great videos!!! Very very informative and helpful when deciding what is sufficient for the price range or if you need maximum performance. Your channel is awesome man 👏
Fascinating video, and great testing. I notice that several of the adaptors broke where the size was stamped into the metal - see 1:45 or 3:27, for example. That's exactly what I'd expect for a brittle fracture like this; any notch will weaken the metal and provide a ready initiation site for the fracture. If that's a more general observation, it might suggest tools with printed sizes are stronger.
@CORNER MARKET PLACE While true, indestructible products aren't as profitable. Generally, high-volume mid- to low-quality companies will buy out the highest-quality companies and intentionally weaken QC and tooling. If not, they re-engineer the product or manufacturing to push the final product to its limit, though this technique is mostly seen in tech products. Another technique is to directly weaken the quality or durability of the construction materials; in moving parts they typically choose to weaken gaskets since those don't often cause catastrophic failure. This last technique is harder to discern because it can be confused with a company "cheaping out" even though it may sometimes cost _more_ because of bad runs and QC problems. A great example of the first type is when WD acquired HGST, a premium hard drive manufacturer. The previously quiet drives became very noisy and failure rates soared. An example of the second type is NAND flash, where nearly every company engineers their products to store 3+ bits per cell, which reduces the NAND lifespan by 2^n. Another example of the second type is panty hose which used to be strong enough to _pull cars._ Now you can tear one with your nail; they achieve this by superheating the fabric. In a rather infamous case for the last type, Pirelli made tires for Formula One which wore out after just 50km. Imagine changing your tires more often than buying gas! Another example of the last type is every line of yard tools which comes in "consumer" and "commercial" versions. Such as Stihl. The consumer tools are designed to wear out faster. Now you know why they embossed the size on the weakest part. It's called "planned obsolescence" and it happens in every industry.
@@Mavendow Just by reading the Pirelli one we can just ignore your comment, FIA asekd Pirelli to make tires that degrade faster. Imagine trying to sound smart while not knowing details.
Love how you graph the results, probably my favorite part of the tests. I screenshot every graph and save them in my Google Keep notes so the next time I'm shopping I can pull your graphs up. Thank you for these tests! Still waiting on an Amsoil vs Shell Rotella T6 test 😁
Our family owns a small hardware store, a True Value. We actually sell a bunch of DeWalt, Ryobi etc. Used to sell Milwaukee, but they dropped True Value as a vendor so we no longer have them.
Every time I wear an old tool out, I come to your page before replacing. I have been snapping these left and right the past week as we work on my daughter's old Jeep. They are all adapters I've slowly collected over the years. Now its time to actually buy some more, and guess what!?!?!? I knew just where to come for the best head to head review. Thank you so much.
“Professionally made in China” oh good I was worried that the factory was making these for fun with volunteer workers seeking to do some recreational tool smithing...
@@ProjectFarm These manufacturers' vocabulary is always getting more and more creative, I'm glad people like you test these everyday objects we constantly need. My serious feedback: I love your homemade testing rigs and appreciate going ahead and doing more than just the basic maximum torque test, keep it up!
TBH based on the review if you want good and expensive tools go japan, good but cheap tool go with china, Taiwan and malaysia are just there for fun lol
Ever think of doing a test on kobalt tools and batteries against leading brands dewalt etc. I have had very good luck with kobalt especially with their batteries holding up longer. Just my experience.
New subscriber here! This is the BEST channel for tools by FAR!!!!! clean and professionally made videos!!!! Says only what needs to be said, straight to point, no thoughts, feelings, or bias, and FACTS ONLY!!!! You sir, are rare lol especially by NOT including all your personal thoughts!!! Keep these going forever please!!!
PSA time: Timely video for me as I recently had a Milwaukee 1/2" adapter (not one that you tested in this video) shatter like a couple of those tested in this video. It was on the end of a Dewalt impact and I was setting larger (36mm) nuts/bolts for a beefy home workout rig I was assembling. I spent an entire day fastening dozens of nut/bolt combos w/o any signs of a problem. Then, the next day, I grabbed my 36mm socket and popped it onto the Milwaukee adapter once again and pulled the trigger to make sure everything was seated. As I did this, the adapter snapped against the resistance of the palm of my hand holding the socket (read: not much) in an explosive way like a couple of those tested in this video. Because of how I was holding the larger socket with my off-hand & was pressing the drill towards the socket, this jagged part of the adapter basically tore into my hand for a couple of rotations at the base of where my left trigger finger meets my hand. Due to the sharp and jagged nature of the failure point it chunked up a smaller section of that area down to the bone. Needless to say this was a painful mess that took me out of commission for a while. It's been a couple of months now and the area is still pinkish in color and is obviously still repairing and susceptible to damage. Moral: be VERY careful of using these sorts of adapters. I'm not sure the thinner gloves I normally wear would have saved me but it likely could have helped. I would suggest wearing some durable gloves whenever you're using these types of adapters because even if you feel you're using them in a relatively safe manner will below their rated limits... bad things can happen. Be careful folks.
@@richardlapoint1845 not a bad idea. I know I will from now on. I was out in my shop after I posted that last post and realized that I kept the two halves of the broken Milwaukee adapter. I wish RUclips had a way that I could post a photo so you all could see what I'm talking about since it's kind of hard to describe.
@@worlds_okayest_crossfitter i know exactly what you're describing, ive seen tools fail in that manner. Iused to work in shops and had a socket shatter and if i didn't wear glasses, would probably not be driving semi today.
@@richardlapoint1845 when you're younger you always hear the safety warnings from the old farts and just think that they're being crazy. well now I'm the old fart passing along the sage wisdom because I never would have guessed that this part could have failed from the stress (or complete lack thereof) it was under nor could I have guessed the manner in which it failed. I'm almost always the first guy to glove up and wear eye and ear pro. Almost. This was one of those rare occasions where I didn't and I learned my lesson in a painful way. I'm just glad it wasn't worse as it certainly could have been. Hoping to pass this experience along so that others don't have to share in a similar pain to learn the same lesson.
I watch your videos because they are THE BEST!!!!! Even if im not interested in the things you are testing, I still watch ALL of them!!! Keep up the awesome work!!!💕
Interesting that Hart has been around for years and was a respected brand, but ya gotta wonder if they reduced their prices at the expense of quality so as to get into Walmart. I can't find anything on Hart changing to a Chinese holding company, which is what usually causes a drop off in quality.
Great video! It seems that when it comes to your reviews of bits/adapters/etc., Husky and Kobalt are often omitted. As those are staples at Home Depot and Lowe’s respectively, it would be helpful to include them as well. I recently had two Husky socket adapters fail on me, and I would have been interested to see how the brand stacked up in your test. Also, it might be interesting to do a re-test of these adapters to see how they perform in extreme cold, moderate cold, and warm weather, as many people keep them in their un-heated garages and work trucks year-round and might benefit from knowing which brand(s) are better suited to working well when cold.
Can we take a moment to acknowledge and appreciate the fact that this man bought all of these adapters with his own money just to break them so we don’t have to. God bless you sir!
I always keep a ryobi impact driver in my truck. The thing is Incredible, especially for the price! 2500 inch lbs I believe of torque. It's strong enough for me to put a socket adapter on it and to pull lugnuts off my truck
I keep a 1/2 impact from Ridgid in my truck and we always take a battery and USB adapter. The battery and chargers are in my mud room always ready to grab one and go. I have a socket set that stays there as well.
Great point! From testing all of these, it serves as a failure point on short impact zones and adapters with longer impact zones (Bauer and Hercules) absorb too much of the impact.
No. It assists in applying the right torque, instead of getting the full load of torque immediately. Torque limiting extensions are the gold standard in tightening lug nuts because real people in the field will destroy the tool and parts they are working on if you give them the full load of torque immediately.
Protecting #8 or #10 fasteners may be a good application for the shock zones. But when using them on large bolts, it seems the stronger versions could be desired.
@@ProjectFarm The shock absorbing in the longer bits has nothing to do with it being an impact absorbing section, it's purely down to length. Try driving a 600mm screw with an impact driver: you'll get absolutely nowhere. If you use a regular drill, it'll go in no problem. More material means more springyness, which means less torque transmission.
I like that idea. I end up using dawn dish soap and water a lot working on carburetors as it seems to clean better than some of the industrial cleaners. It is also cheaper
Amateurs call it loyalty, pros call it a system. You want compatible items and perhaps even bulk discounts. But yes, DeWalt and Makita usually don't disappoint.
Sometimes a brand became popular not just without reason. Better buy good tools that last a lifetime than having to struggle with cheap tools that new renewing every few years
I have a bunch of long Makita Gold impact bits with the skinny zone I got on clearance, and it did sound from the video like it makes some difference (second test of the Bauer) if the zone is long enough.
Dewalt 20v cordless owner got the same socket #1 ! This video will show you don't buy your tools from Walmart the buck you save isn't worth the loss you gave in durability loss. Love this guy by the way he does a Outstanding Job at Tool Comparisons!
Very interesting results. I would of never guessed the Torque Smith, which I own would do so well. But I am getting the Dewalt for my impact tool set. Keep up the great work.
Watching PF's videos it seems like DeWalt is never in the bottom tier. Worst I've ever seen is about middle of the pack. I like that popular brands are always tested.
Crazy to see how much torque a quarter inch adapter can really take. It does make one Wonder though are people trying to disassemble entire vehicles using just a quarter inch wrench :-) great tests keep up the good work!
This test just gave me a lot of confidence in my dewalt impact adapters for my driver. I work in my car's engine bay frequently and the impact driver is amazing for some of the tighter spots
It’s strange to see a Milwaukee product so low on the charts!!! Thank you for all of your informational videos, Project Farm! You are a very intelligent & well rounded kinda guy. Thank you again for all of your hard work, & your EXCELLENT content!
That is why I bought DeWalt ,. I read bad stuff about their fuel line breaking too. I just went with the 899 and read reviews of people using them in coal mines and whatnot, without issues so I figure it should be fine for me.
@@booya6437Don't go by what you see on RUclips with their tools do not hold up, I work at home depot and we get way more Milwaukee returns than Dewalt, Makita and Bosch, ryobi and ridgid are also terrible we get a lot of returns from them Dewalt and Bosch are by far the fewest in returns with Makita coming in third. A Hyundai will drive just as nice as a Toyota brand new two year's down the line and let's see which has more problems the Hyundai will have more problems
@@ProjectFarm For my small stuff like these I get a block of foam and an organizer from Harbor Freight with the removable compartments, take out as many as I need to and fill the rest with the foam and carve out slots for the tools. I have about ten of them with things like rivets and tool, etc. and they're less than $10 each with the foam.
I’m honestly surprised by the results. I seem to gain a biased view of my fav brand because it usually doesn’t let me down, however the results speak for themselves! I have a video idea, could you do surge protectors? Btw I really love your channel, you have really helped my confidence in buying brands.
Once again, I had a tool break and typed in a search to find the best replacement. "Oh, Project Farm has a video on this!" Watched all the way to the end. Now I know what I will replace my socket adapter with and why. Thanks again Project Farm!
unless it actually absorbs shock which it may well be doing when used with an impact driver. he's using constant pressure to snap them, an impact driver uses momentary rotational shocks where the material has time to recover between hits.
I use Milwaukee shockwave adapters on automotive applications and it holds up very well, what I notice it is on the overall stronger non impact adapters twist over time, but the shock absorbent part takes the impact and prevents the adapter from twisting, delivering accurate torque every time rather than some lost on the twisting, I’m a year strong on a single adapter set with daily use lol
no its not. you would need a longer test setup with less torque to show the benifit of them (fatique testing). the "torsion zones " are trade off, you sac maximum torque for a longer lifespan at lower torques. this setup is maximum torsion test so of cause the one with the bigger diameter will perform a lot better: tau = 4*(F*r)/(pi *r^3) so if you need a adapter to remove huge rusted bolts with a tool to small for the job take a adapter with a big diameter, otherwise a sufficent one with a "torsion zone" will perform better in the long run
Hey! I'm not as experienced as Project Farm, but I've been abusing my husky adapters for the past year and haven't had a problem yet. That being said, I'd love to see a video testing them, as I use a ryobi driver, so it isn't exactly being pushed to any limits
id like to point out husky is one of those companies that rebrands other companies tools and sells them with their name (atleast sometimes) dont get me wrong i have quite a few husky tools and do like them but part of me wonders if they were manuafactured by them or do they just have a great sourcing team one example i can think of is their ratcheting wrenches they are actually gearwrench brand
@@diyoutube6061 Every brand is rebranded. Ryobi is made by the same people as Milwaukee. DeWalt is owned by the same people as Black and Decker, Bostitch, Proto, Mac Tools, Irwin, Craftsman, and a few others. Just about every single brand is owned by other brands, it's all the same. Even Snap-On is shared with Blue Point, Lindstrom, and Williams.
@@xploration1437 almost every Sunday morning when he posts i happen to be looking at my phone walking to get my coffee...and sure as shit I get the notification im looking at my phone on my way to get coffee lol
i had a cheap makita for over ten years and it finally gave out once i got into transmission work. ATF fluid is incredibly detrimental to the internals. Dont get em wet! i got a fairly cheap $20 milwaukee set with a phillips, 3/8 adapter and a bunch of other stuff i rarely used. the bit set outlasted my impact and i still use it today. anyway for a short while i used some harbor freight bits, the little black sockets ones. they were really convenient and never broke on me but wore down around the edges of the adapter. i think this helped wear out the driver too cuz i had issues with my overly expensive matco bit set later on. the cheap sets are good 'get me by' tools but dont use them more than a few months, they will wear your tools down.
Do I need a socket adapter? No. Will I in the near future? Probably not. Did I watch the entire video making sure to pause if I had to step away? Better believe I did
yea thats the thing i like about buying dewalt. they might not always be number one(though they often are) but theyre almost always among the top competitors. if you dont have time to test and compare every tool you buy, you can usually rest easy just picking up dewalt and knowing youll be getting a high performance tool. plus their battery system is by far the most versatile, its nice to be able to run an entire aresenal of tools off a single system(their 20/60v system).
I'd love to see you include more brands like snap on an mac in tests like this. And even in the cordless tool tests as well. And like always thanks for the videos!
I LOVE your videos as I have recently been spending a lot of money on upgrading my tools to the best quality, and your work here certainly helps me sort out the wheat from the chaff.
Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you!
Makita Gold: amzn.to/3Fxu8Mn
Dewalt: amzn.to/3AfYYVU
TEMO: amzn.to/3uTgder
Milwaukee: amzn.to/3aalG6X
ARES: amzn.to/3AeD1pV
Neiko: amzn.to/36dQLFQ
Irwin: amzn.to/3lfgQIN
Ryobi: amzn.to/3fMkRDr
Hart: amzn.to/3DektYY
Makita: amzn.to/33qGVPf
I was telling myself ‘Patience Patience and do not get any tools this holiday season until PF rates it and tests it. Thank you again.
lol. Thank you very much! I've got many more tool reviews on the way at viewers request
Project Farm I told myself the same thing yesterday at Lowe’s !! Lol
Buy a microwave.. microwaves are cool..
Im doing same.lol. best channel ever
this vid is 17 days too late for me lol!! now I gotta hope I made a good buy
Do I have an impact driver? No.
Do I need an adapter? No.
Will the outcome of this video directly benefit me? No.
Will I watch the entire thing with great interest? Of course!
Thank you very much!
My exact line of thinking
I’m from Canada do you Americans get the craftsman line in the USA I’d like to see them tested you can get the drill and driver for 100 cdn on sale regularly. It’s a great budget set I also have dewalt tools and the craftsman stuff isn’t that much worse.
@@ProjectFarm ^
I don't use all that stuff either
But the videos about undercoating or anti-seize got me thinking.
However, I don't even get most of these Products on the European market. But I can compare. FuidFilm for Example has Products that perform like Cosmoline Rp and meets the same military standardization.
You learn what to watch for 😁
I literally search your channel before buying certain products for their results. Thank you for your dedication. We appreciate you.
Same here.
Same, recently when I had to buy some (emergency situation) Radiator Stop Leak, I searched and didn't see any videos from PF, I was legitimately uncertain about buying any of them. lol
I'll walk away if not pf approved.
All the impact adapters that broke in the small cross area are breaking safely. Rather than twisting and possibly throwing chips, they break quickly and reliably, without shrapnel.
I also noticed that alone of them, the Bosch alone seemed to be doing the evil shrapnel thing. Sheesh, safety glasses and work gloves anyone?
That may be the case but it’s ironic that most of them are the bigger brands who had that but along with that claimed the biggest breaking strengths…. This is why people like him are vital, don’t believe the hype that big brands claim, save your money when you can and buy the tool for its quality, not it’s name
No, it’s made to be elastic of sorts. Stores the energy from each impact like a spring so in theory it doubles the motion.
This is so important to know and make clear...
The best impact driver adapter are the titanium ones. Super strong, and never had a problem with them breaking.
At some point manufactures will start putting on the product packaging - tested best by PF... :)
That would be nice, but I'm not holding my breath.
Thanks for the nice comment.
As seen on YT tested by Project Farm truck . That would be nice and give him some sort of % on sales
If so PF needs to get a royality check each time one is bought.
I run an Ace Hardware and bring in stuff that performs well. Also use the info from the videos to help with recommendations. Invaluable source.
My dad isn't an technology guy, doesn't even have an email address. But I told him about your channel and now he's a youtube addict for your channel and won't get off their computer. He loves working in the shop and can't get enough. Great video!
Thanks so much! Thanks for sharing.
@@ProjectFarm hi
In the future if i own a factory.. I will make sure that the product first is PROJECT FARM approved. Amazing presentation as usual
Thank you very much!!!
@@ProjectFarm remember you did the driver bit that was the best thank you project Farm
The board will hate you .
you'll first have to form a committee, then have a meeting, then form a group to oversee the committee, then the group will have to have a meeting, then the board will need to approve the committee, then have a meeting about the group, then maybe you can present to the board so they can have another meeting.......in between golfing that is.
@@gregturner2899 Don't forget the 3 martini lunches.
I have no idea how, but I think I've just chain watched this guy for like 3 hours... Learnt lots, but not sure where the time went haha. RUclips is a strange beast.
Thanks for watching!
It's not just RUclips, as many RUclips channels' content varies from person to person. PF content is legitimately no exception and is highly useful with testing, legitimate data, and time efficiency of each video he puts out. He dedicated his channel from experience and whatever gets him started from his heart, he'll put it out there. He saved a lot of industrial workers time so that they can get the best tools to work with by the various tests and various tools that PF utilized with in comparison to each brand. If it wasn't for this channel, I would somewhat be buying the average tools and others, but I seek for the best tools.
I cant explain with words how happy i am when project farm uploads a video.
Thank you very much!
Me too. I’m always looking for them.
Brainiac75 uploaded too? This day cant get any better
I have said it before, but it is worth repeating and I will say it again, This is the best channel on RUclips by far! Thank you for everything you do.
Thanks so much!
Best channel? 😮😮😮 Over something like ""the operation room", "Pecos Hank" or "The Stories of Old"?
@@spacecadet8843 as a weather enthusiast I will have to agree that Pecos Hank does have some really good storm chasing videos.
No other channel on RUclips actually impacts my daily work life like Project Farm.
Thanks so much! Glad I could help!
You had ONE pun opportunity!
#punappreciation
My understanding is the impact bits with “torsion zones” are designed for the bit to last longer in its useful life span. Meaning when you’re using the bit to fasten nuts/bolts, or remove them, the bits don’t undergo this kind of extended even torque you see in the video, rather they experience momentary shock force, that drops of rapidly. Those torsion zones are there so that the bits don’t twist over time or multiple uses, but are rather designed to absorb the momentary shock and snap back into original shape. They’re not designed for high constant torque applications, but rather many, many, many smaller momentary shock torque hits. So like if your driving a million deck screws - that’s where these bits shine, they will survive longer without twisting over time.
Thanks for the feedback.
I very highly agree. I want speed insert, good fitment, drive speed and balance. On the back end good edge retention always makes a big deal. It is very interesting that he's testing them in inverse which is probably the best way to save 1,000,000 hours...
I think objectively this video is just a steel composition comparison for nightmare testing. I think he's actually peering pretty deep here.
@@Ihavetopoop718 i agree with most of his testing methodology. In particular the tests involving bit edge retention and head strength over use/time. My only complaint is regarding the claim that the bits with "torque zones" are compositionally weaker under constant high torque application. That part the bits with torque zones are not designed for, they're designed as a system to survive longer the repeated hammer hits from hammer drivers as you're putting in lots of repeated screws (like deck screws) with lots of small momentary repeated torque blows from the hammer mechanism, acting like a spring and snapping back slightly after each hit - thereby not putting in a permanent twist to the bit, and protecting the head and teeth (Phillips, Torx, etc.) from damage. They're not designed for high torque applications like bolts that needs to be torqued to 150Lbs with a slow turn of a torque wrench or even an Impact Wrench...in this case obviously the thicker the better.
Well you have to admit testing these to the point of failure does give you some indication as to overall durability. Just look at how the DeWalt ran away with the title in the test which counts most... For use with impact tools that generate less than 2000 inch pounds... Which is coincidentally where the bit snapped.
@@ConcernedCitizenPPCA I agree...I grabbed some of those just to have. But still, there's a reason they design them with these torque zones, and its not for ultimate steady state torque strength, but rather repeated multi-use. So would be interesting to see them tested against each other within those parameters.
"Pretty simple setup" lol. Nothing you do looks simple. Appreciate all the work you put into these videos!
Thought the same
Thank you very much!
Agreed
Is this the AvE cross over?
These vids are second to none. They have helped with countless purchases and shown that the most expensive item isn't always the best.
Thank you very much!
Honestly the videos PF makes are probably some of the most useful videos on RUclips
Thanks for the nice comment!
I picked up the DeWalt brand adapters on a whim, then watched this video with fingers crossed, and low and behold, luck was on my side! Thanks for the in-depth reviews, you are the man!
I really appreciate the fact you buy all these products. I love how fair you make all these test. You should start including the comments where people make suggestions that you pick.
Thank you and great suggestion!
He often does videos based on suggestions left in the videos. It’s one of the reasons this channel is one of the best
@@jackconnely6048 I know I'm just saying he should include that persons comment in the video. Kinda like a shoutout for the idea
@@jakelewis9738 i think, it's nor only one person with that idea. I think he counts, how many times an idea is suggested...
Not here for shout outs. Only one guy deserves a pat on the back and it's the creator of the channel. I just want to see his work. The comment section is active enough.
Project farm puts the fire under company to make quality tools for their customers love for this channel
Thank you very much! Trust me, manufacturers do watch the videos and most of them appreciate the unbiased reviews. I've had offers for contract work testing products for major brands but have declined all offers. Thanks again
@@ProjectFarm I was always curious if you had feedback from manufacturers because of your videos. Thanks for staying unbias. It makes me questions what level of testing takes place from manufacturers of their parts in the first place... Granted not everyone is trying to be the best product on the shelf, but trying to be the best product at the best price for how it will be used is important for people to remember too.
I wonder how long before Torquesmith triples their price
Gotta fight fire with fire 🔥
@@ProjectFarm awesome you have influence! Awesome you stay independent!
At this point, we need a spreadsheet of all the best products so we can just buy all the good stuff! Thanks for another great test!
You are welcome. Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm I may start going back through and compiling an excel file with sortable tables for best performance and best performance per dollar.
@@alexfraley omg please do
@@alexfraley with great power, come great spreadsheets. You are the hero we all deserve!
That would be awesome
I work in mechanical construction and we always use Milwaukee adapters and we go through multiple a month. One of the most useful videos I've seen in a fair while, safe to say we will deffinatly be picking up a different brand next time, thanks a lot and always love your content.
You are welcome!
imagine boardroom meetings at tool manufacturing companies-
'So how did we rate on the latest Project Farm video?'
Lol, thank you!
I've always wondered if bigger companies hire people just to search the internet and social media just to find stuff like project farm posts.
@@probablynotwearingpants6228 I think they do. Pretty much all companies that produce or sell consumer products have Instagram and/or Facebook pages. That means they have a person or team responsible for their social media presence which involves monitoring as much as it does content creation.
@@MikeCookie1973 I know they have marketing, tech, social media and whatnot but i imagine somewhere there's a person solely devoted to finding any little mention of that company whether it be on youtube or some strange foreign language forum in another country. I guess like a forensic investigator for the internet.
hes like the lockpicking lawyer of power tools
“And the dewalt seemed to be enjoying the test a little too much” LOL!
Thanks for watching!
@@ProjectFarm Thank you for saving consumers so much time and money so we don’t have to figure out the best on our own! I would love to see an episode on ratcheting wrenches when possible
I am really happy that he made this video my socket adapter just broke a few days ago
Perfect timing! Thank you
LMDAO MINE TOO, I was making atvs and it snapped in half
@Project Farm
What about circular saw blades
@Tomoto man peach that's what broke my adapter because Milwaukee tools are the best
Been buying Dewalt. Got to buy this adaptor.
Sure beats setting up air tools plus no hose or compressor noise.
Dewalt able to be used with impact drivers up to 2000 psi
Dewalt after test two: did i stutter
Dewalt while applying slow and steady force: help me, I’m weak
Dewalt while using a impact: Unlimited power!!!
Inch/pounds, different to PSI
Ryobi, Hart and Milwaukee came out on the bottom in my testing of impact socket adaptors👌🏻
Great information. Glad our test results are consistent! Keep up the terrific work!!
Yep the Gen 1 Milwaukee socket adapters were stronger and built more like the Dealt he tested. The shock zone is a gimmick to sell more bits but its catching up to all these manufacturers nobody will buy them before to long.
Bro you saved me money lol. I upgraded to a brushless dewalt and broke a ryobi adapter and another no brand one qnd then ended up ordering the makita and so far so good
You're doing it wrong if you're breaking these things. Find another job or hobby.
@@replynotificationsdisabled
No, the point isn't usually to break them, but if you're going to buy one, wouldn't you want to know that you are buying the one that won't let you down if you're working late at night fixing something and it just happens to be the tool you have, or the tool that fits in a tight spot, and if you break it while working you can't just go get another one. I like to buy tools that last, like I like to buy cars that won't leave me stranded on the side of the road 20 miles from civilization.
Thank you for including Ryobi! It's such a common and popular brand for average consumers and hobbyists like myself. I'm sure a LOT of viewers are thankful to see the brand represented
Thank you. I'm working on several more videos that will include Ryobi. Definitely will include the brand more often in the future. Thanks again
Ryobi didn’t get a fair test for impact - it wasn’t seated all the way and broke at the detent notch.
The second impact test you came up with was pure genius! How the hell do you come up with these great testing scenarios? Love it man.
He works on a farm. Even just managing a detached house teaches you a lot compared to an apartment life.
Spot on comment; very clever testing methodology. And making sure the threads were properly lubed controls a key error variable.
PF really is the gold standard for grass-root RUclips product evaluation content. And especially, NO SPONSORSHIP. Can you imagine how much he has been tempted?! Please, stay true to your principles and never cross the line! Don't even look over the edge. There are enough people out here that value your purity to keep your channel healthy. We will endure the non-related ads so you get eyeballs (and good rates) because we recognize your commitment.
I've always been concerned with those impact absorption areas on these various companies impact adapters and bits and this test proved why! It makes some pretty rudimentary sense that less material provides less stability.
Thank you!
well they do break 'cleaner' it would seem
3:34 Made In Indonesia
idk why but when i hear "Made In Indonesia" on English video it makes me happy
btw Hello From Indonesia
Greetings!
See? Smart ppl live in Indonesia! While I already know thats true, I can only currently confirm this bcuz this lovely person knows where to get their unbiased consumer reviews. Greetings from USA, friend! U clearly have impeccable taste😊👍
PF is going global.
PF in Indonesia!! Niceeee 👍
@@deelanders6132 i literally watching this channel, when pf just testing the mower engine thing,
First PF video that i watch is what happen if you put dirt on engine....
Superb testing as always! Thank you! A++
Hi Electronicsnmore. Thank you very much! Looking forward to your next video!
That's exactly what I was going to say!
Project farm drops an impact tool test video
Tool manufacturers: "Guys, we might have a problem here..."
Thanks for watching!
@@ProjectFarm I just read that in your voice and cadence.
Houston we have a problem
Thanks for another super useful comparison. I picked up a Snap-on 1/2" to 3/8" adapter, after my Craftsman twisted off, due to their superior image. While it did not twist off, the square section is now loose in the socket part. These adapters are often useful when a deep socket is needed and it would be nice to know which work well.
I find myself rooting for the tools I have in my garage when you are testing on the channel... love the content, please keep videos coming, fair testing of well known brands helps when trying DIY! Thank you
I get kinda nervous when he tests something I own. I don't wanna find out it's a piece of crap, haha.
Same Here😂
Yeah i was watching for the dewalt adapter that maxed the test out 😂
Hey I just wanna say that we really appreciate everything you do. You make it easy for not only the average weekend warrior taking on home/car projects but also for everyday professionals who work day to day with the same tools/equipment you test to make sound decisions. I've been watching and following along for about 3 years and it's always been quality content.
Thank you very much!
The highest quality RUclips channel, thank you for all of your hard work!
Thank you very much!
Sir hands down this is for me the Best go to channel for reference to see tested things,
And my hats of to you for your help, hard work, and care,
I will always recommend the channel to all those who are interested.
Keep well my prayers for all in these troubled times, bless.
So nice of you! Thanks!
I’ve watched all the ads given. Your channel is the only one I do this for.
New TorqueSmith packaging 2021: "Now Impact rated! 3x Strength!"
Price: $14.99
Thanks for the feedback.
Do you have a link? All I found was this exact unit for 3 dollars.
@@kameljoe21 Viewer was just saying with sarcasm since PF reviewed with decent results and recommendation, price will increase in 2021.
@@CGW116A Yeah thanks.. I did not see the 2021 part or just missed it!
"PF approved"
At 7:18 the dewalt says that it can handle up to 2000 in-lbs of torque and it did just that. Great video never disappoints
The PSI value of the test rig is not equivalent to torque. It's just a measure that can be used across all tested products.
“Neiko brand brakes at 666 inch pounds” The CEO must’ve signed a deal with the devil lol
As soon as I saw that I came to the commits to see when someone was gonna say sum
@@slysoulslayer8994 lol same
I came just to say something similar
jajaajajajajajaa AND WILL CONTINUE FOR ETERNITY AS THE CEO ..
do a video on "torque sticks" and how close they get to their stated torque with an impact gun.
test on 2 or 3 different guns
Great video idea! Thank you
This is a good idea!
@@ProjectFarm That test requires impacts being turned down from highest setting and a constant psi level.
@@ProjectFarm , I think that's a Great idea. I have always wondered about those. While set up for such a test, maybe a test for impact extensions designed for transmitting FULL torque. I've never had much luck with an extension on an impact.
Perfect idea! Always curious to know if it's the appropriate torque after putting a customers wheel on with one. So they're able to get the wheel off on the side of the road without struggling.
Wow, you're up to almost 1.5 million subs?!!! I remember back when you first went viral with that Sea Foam video. Good job, PF!
Thanks so much!
It's been so long!
I have the dewalt impact adapter and feel confident to be aggressive with them after this review. Thanks for making these great videos!!! Very very informative and helpful when deciding what is sufficient for the price range or if you need maximum performance. Your channel is awesome man 👏
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
Fascinating video, and great testing. I notice that several of the adaptors broke where the size was stamped into the metal - see 1:45 or 3:27, for example. That's exactly what I'd expect for a brittle fracture like this; any notch will weaken the metal and provide a ready initiation site for the fracture. If that's a more general observation, it might suggest tools with printed sizes are stronger.
Thanks so much! Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks for another great video!
@CORNER MARKET PLACE While true, indestructible products aren't as profitable. Generally, high-volume mid- to low-quality companies will buy out the highest-quality companies and intentionally weaken QC and tooling. If not, they re-engineer the product or manufacturing to push the final product to its limit, though this technique is mostly seen in tech products. Another technique is to directly weaken the quality or durability of the construction materials; in moving parts they typically choose to weaken gaskets since those don't often cause catastrophic failure. This last technique is harder to discern because it can be confused with a company "cheaping out" even though it may sometimes cost _more_ because of bad runs and QC problems.
A great example of the first type is when WD acquired HGST, a premium hard drive manufacturer. The previously quiet drives became very noisy and failure rates soared.
An example of the second type is NAND flash, where nearly every company engineers their products to store 3+ bits per cell, which reduces the NAND lifespan by 2^n.
Another example of the second type is panty hose which used to be strong enough to _pull cars._ Now you can tear one with your nail; they achieve this by superheating the fabric.
In a rather infamous case for the last type, Pirelli made tires for Formula One which wore out after just 50km. Imagine changing your tires more often than buying gas!
Another example of the last type is every line of yard tools which comes in "consumer" and "commercial" versions. Such as Stihl. The consumer tools are designed to wear out faster.
Now you know why they embossed the size on the weakest part. It's called "planned obsolescence" and it happens in every industry.
@@Mavendow Just by reading the Pirelli one we can just ignore your comment, FIA asekd Pirelli to make tires that degrade faster. Imagine trying to sound smart while not knowing details.
Suggestion for a test: Rotary tools (such as Dremel, Proxxon etc. etc.). And/or the durability of the bits used on those tools.
Great video idea!
Nice idea as well.
Proxxon ❤
This would be a good test, I have an old craftsman and it’s blows.
Rpms under load....
Love how you graph the results, probably my favorite part of the tests. I screenshot every graph and save them in my Google Keep notes so the next time I'm shopping I can pull your graphs up. Thank you for these tests! Still waiting on an Amsoil vs Shell Rotella T6 test 😁
🤣 Glad to learn others use Google Keep in one of the ways I do! 👍🏽 Quite handy!
@@gus473 love Keep. It runs my life.
Could you imagine going to in to your local hardware store and seeing items that are project farm approved? That'd be so cool.
Our family owns a small hardware store, a True Value. We actually sell a bunch of DeWalt, Ryobi etc. Used to sell Milwaukee, but they dropped True Value as a vendor so we no longer have them.
What’s even cooler is when you already own them. It’s like the ultimate affirmation.
It would be better than the good housekeeping seal of approval.
Thanks for the positive comment!
I plan on putting a Project Farm Approved decal on my truck. It just won't die!!!
Every time I wear an old tool out, I come to your page before replacing. I have been snapping these left and right the past week as we work on my daughter's old Jeep. They are all adapters I've slowly collected over the years.
Now its time to actually buy some more, and guess what!?!?!? I knew just where to come for the best head to head review.
Thank you so much.
Great to hear!
“Professionally made in China” oh good I was worried that the factory was making these for fun with volunteer workers seeking to do some recreational tool smithing...
Thanks for the feedback.
Professionally made in Taiwan" as well
Ayyy! Do something you enjoy so you'll never work a day in your life! Or something along those lines.... 🤣
@@ProjectFarm These manufacturers' vocabulary is always getting more and more creative, I'm glad people like you test these everyday objects we constantly need. My serious feedback: I love your homemade testing rigs and appreciate going ahead and doing more than just the basic maximum torque test, keep it up!
TBH based on the review if you want good and expensive tools go japan, good but cheap tool go with china, Taiwan and malaysia are just there for fun lol
Yep use dewalt adapters myself never broke one yet for my uses.
Same here. Have the 3 piece adapter set and the 5 piece impact nut drivers. Never had an issue.
Great quality adapter!
Ever think of doing a test on kobalt tools and batteries against leading brands dewalt etc. I have had very good luck with kobalt especially with their batteries holding up longer. Just my experience.
New subscriber here! This is the BEST channel for tools by FAR!!!!! clean and professionally made videos!!!! Says only what needs to be said, straight to point, no thoughts, feelings, or bias, and FACTS ONLY!!!! You sir, are rare lol especially by NOT including all your personal thoughts!!! Keep these going forever please!!!
Thanks for watching and subscribing!
This guy is easily the most helpful guy with tools as a 15 yo with a project 67 GMC your vids help alot of knowing what tools are worth my money
Thanks!
Perfect timing, just finished Mustie1. Got to love Sunday morning on RUclips!
Great video by Mustie1 today rebuilding the 2 stroke motor
Thumbs up for mentioning @Mustie1
Ive been mad about spending 4 bucks on that dewalt for over a week this review made me happy about buying it now
Thanks for sharing.
I would imagine that the ARES brand is pronounced like the Greek god of war, Ares, instead of each letter being sounded out.
Great video as always.
Thanks!
When I see or hear Ares, I think of Xena Warrior Princess.
You're the best! Thorough, comprehensive, creative, and unbiased!
Wow, thank you!
I love these videos, and I love it even more when the tools that I have in my toolbox perform well or win tests!
Thanks for sharing.
PSA time: Timely video for me as I recently had a Milwaukee 1/2" adapter (not one that you tested in this video) shatter like a couple of those tested in this video. It was on the end of a Dewalt impact and I was setting larger (36mm) nuts/bolts for a beefy home workout rig I was assembling. I spent an entire day fastening dozens of nut/bolt combos w/o any signs of a problem. Then, the next day, I grabbed my 36mm socket and popped it onto the Milwaukee adapter once again and pulled the trigger to make sure everything was seated. As I did this, the adapter snapped against the resistance of the palm of my hand holding the socket (read: not much) in an explosive way like a couple of those tested in this video. Because of how I was holding the larger socket with my off-hand & was pressing the drill towards the socket, this jagged part of the adapter basically tore into my hand for a couple of rotations at the base of where my left trigger finger meets my hand. Due to the sharp and jagged nature of the failure point it chunked up a smaller section of that area down to the bone. Needless to say this was a painful mess that took me out of commission for a while. It's been a couple of months now and the area is still pinkish in color and is obviously still repairing and susceptible to damage.
Moral: be VERY careful of using these sorts of adapters. I'm not sure the thinner gloves I normally wear would have saved me but it likely could have helped. I would suggest wearing some durable gloves whenever you're using these types of adapters because even if you feel you're using them in a relatively safe manner will below their rated limits... bad things can happen. Be careful folks.
Thanks for sharing.
Thanks for the info, ill have to start wearing gloves then as i use my impact driver often when im home.
@@richardlapoint1845 not a bad idea. I know I will from now on. I was out in my shop after I posted that last post and realized that I kept the two halves of the broken Milwaukee adapter. I wish RUclips had a way that I could post a photo so you all could see what I'm talking about since it's kind of hard to describe.
@@worlds_okayest_crossfitter i know exactly what you're describing, ive seen tools fail in that manner. Iused to work in shops and had a socket shatter and if i didn't wear glasses, would probably not be driving semi today.
@@richardlapoint1845 when you're younger you always hear the safety warnings from the old farts and just think that they're being crazy. well now I'm the old fart passing along the sage wisdom because I never would have guessed that this part could have failed from the stress (or complete lack thereof) it was under nor could I have guessed the manner in which it failed. I'm almost always the first guy to glove up and wear eye and ear pro. Almost. This was one of those rare occasions where I didn't and I learned my lesson in a painful way. I'm just glad it wasn't worse as it certainly could have been. Hoping to pass this experience along so that others don't have to share in a similar pain to learn the same lesson.
I got several HF adapters in the toolbox. I used them as a diversion so my good set doesn’t walk away.
lol. Nice!
Looks like you need to move to Ryobi for your diversions.
I watch your videos because they are THE BEST!!!!! Even if im not interested in the things you are testing, I still watch ALL of them!!! Keep up the awesome work!!!💕
Thanks, will do!
I hear a 'Let's find out', I hit like.
Edit, man that TEMO coming out ahead again with those near-top numbers.
Thank you very much!
Go figure.. One of the cheapest ones finishes top 5 in both tests....
10:01 "The Hart brand is designed for exactly this so it should be bet- oh. It broke." 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hart beaker!
Save money, live better!
Thanks for watching!
Interesting that Hart has been around for years and was a respected brand, but ya gotta wonder if they reduced their prices at the expense of quality so as to get into Walmart. I can't find anything on Hart changing to a Chinese holding company, which is what usually causes a drop off in quality.
Great video! It seems that when it comes to your reviews of bits/adapters/etc., Husky and Kobalt are often omitted. As those are staples at Home Depot and Lowe’s respectively, it would be helpful to include them as well. I recently had two Husky socket adapters fail on me, and I would have been interested to see how the brand stacked up in your test. Also, it might be interesting to do a re-test of these adapters to see how they perform in extreme cold, moderate cold, and warm weather, as many people keep them in their un-heated garages and work trucks year-round and might benefit from knowing which brand(s) are better suited to working well when cold.
Thanks! Thanks for the video ideas if I revisit this test.
@@ProjectFarm
A test with tools in 10-30F range would be quite interesting.
What model Husky? I'm looking at the 1/4 in. Drive Impact Driver Socket Adapter Set (6-Piece) right now
Can we take a moment to acknowledge and appreciate the fact that this man bought all of these adapters with his own money just to break them so we don’t have to. God bless you sir!
Thanks!
I always keep a ryobi impact driver in my truck. The thing is Incredible, especially for the price! 2500 inch lbs I believe of torque. It's strong enough for me to put a socket adapter on it and to pull lugnuts off my truck
I keep a 1/2 impact from Ridgid in my truck and we always take a battery and USB adapter. The battery and chargers are in my mud room always ready to grab one and go. I have a socket set that stays there as well.
At first I saw the title and said to myself “how could this be interesting” ended up watching the whole thing. Well done again!
Thanks so much!
Doesn't having a shock absorbing adapter defeat the purpose of using an impact tool?
Great point! From testing all of these, it serves as a failure point on short impact zones and adapters with longer impact zones (Bauer and Hercules) absorb too much of the impact.
No. It assists in applying the right torque, instead of getting the full load of torque immediately. Torque limiting extensions are the gold standard in tightening lug nuts because real people in the field will destroy the tool and parts they are working on if you give them the full load of torque immediately.
Protecting #8 or #10 fasteners may be a good application for the shock zones. But when using them on large bolts, it seems the stronger versions could be desired.
$5 says it's marketing wank and a great excuse for a built in failure point so you keep coming back and buying more
@@ProjectFarm The shock absorbing in the longer bits has nothing to do with it being an impact absorbing section, it's purely down to length. Try driving a 600mm screw with an impact driver: you'll get absolutely nowhere. If you use a regular drill, it'll go in no problem. More material means more springyness, which means less torque transmission.
Man your channel is a treasure, thanks a ton for all the effort you put into these videos!
You are welcome!
What amazes me, is how you manage to mend the bits after the first test, to be ready for the second one.
Thats why PF is the best.
might just be the magic of buying two, or maybe using a different size adapter since most were sets of 3
Hi PF, would you consider testing degreasers such as "purple power" "greased lightning" and so on?
Thanks for the video idea.
I like that idea. I end up using dawn dish soap and water a lot working on carburetors as it seems to clean better than some of the industrial cleaners. It is also cheaper
Yes!
Gunk wipes!!!
ATF as a cleaner
The best review corner you can trust in the entire planet! 👍👍 Great job bud!! Thanks a ton!
You are welcome!
Man I'm super sick, home from work, and bored out of my mind, but watching you break things with your experiments always seems to help
Sorry to hear you are feeling ill. Thanks for watching!
I'm definitely not into the whole brand loyalty thing but I almost always buy DeWalt tools just because of these videos.
Amateurs call it loyalty, pros call it a system. You want compatible items and perhaps even bulk discounts. But yes, DeWalt and Makita usually don't disappoint.
Thanks for sharing.
Sometimes a brand became popular not just without reason.
Better buy good tools that last a lifetime than having to struggle with cheap tools that new renewing every few years
Very interesting! Those shock absorbing “zones” always baffled me and now I see they’re mostly for show.
Thanks for watching.
I have a bunch of long Makita Gold impact bits with the skinny zone I got on clearance, and it did sound from the video like it makes some difference (second test of the Bauer) if the zone is long enough.
Why would you want to absorb the shock from the impact rather than use it to break free a nut?
Surprise.
@@onionfx so you don't break as many bits
great testing man, your tests are always exceptional
Thank you very much!
Dewalt 20v cordless owner got the same socket #1 ! This video will show you don't buy your tools from Walmart the buck you save isn't worth the loss you gave in durability loss. Love this guy by the way he does a Outstanding Job at Tool Comparisons!
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Very interesting results. I would of never guessed the Torque Smith, which I own would do so well. But I am getting the Dewalt for my impact tool set. Keep up the great work.
Thanks, will do!
Watching PF's videos it seems like DeWalt is never in the bottom tier. Worst I've ever seen is about middle of the pack. I like that popular brands are always tested.
Crazy to see how much torque a quarter inch adapter can really take. It does make one Wonder though are people trying to disassemble entire vehicles using just a quarter inch wrench :-) great tests keep up the good work!
Thanks, will do.
Me: I can hold my breath for one minute ten seconds.
PF: I’m gonna test that
lol Thanks for watching!
Wrong! The correct phrase is "Let's find out!" 😎
Now let's test the Oscar brand. The Oscar brand is by far the most expensive of the bunch.
Made in Mexico!
@@taunokekkonen5733 and after 40 seconds it seems he has drowned in our humans sized aquarium.
This test just gave me a lot of confidence in my dewalt impact adapters for my driver. I work in my car's engine bay frequently and the impact driver is amazing for some of the tighter spots
Thank you!
I like how you pronounce Bosch absolutely correctly! :D
Thank you!
He didnt pronounce it correct. He pronounced it correctly.
@@lightningdemolition1964 okay, my bad! Pronounce is present and pronounced past. So if present is the case I want, then it's correct now, isn't it?
It’s strange to see a Milwaukee product so low on the charts!!!
Thank you for all of your informational videos, Project Farm! You are a very intelligent & well rounded kinda guy.
Thank you again for all of your hard work, & your EXCELLENT content!
Thank you!
That is why I bought DeWalt ,. I read bad stuff about their fuel line breaking too. I just went with the 899 and read reviews of people using them in coal mines and whatnot, without issues so I figure it should be fine for me.
Milwaukee accessories often don't perform well. They outsource it all.
@@StreetWorksMedia Milwaukee’s fuel line is top notch, not sure where you read your reviews.
@@booya6437Don't go by what you see on RUclips with their tools do not hold up, I work at home depot and we get way more Milwaukee returns than Dewalt, Makita and Bosch, ryobi and ridgid are also terrible we get a lot of returns from them Dewalt and Bosch are by far the fewest in returns with Makita coming in third. A Hyundai will drive just as nice as a Toyota brand new two year's down the line and let's see which has more problems the Hyundai will have more problems
My question is where do these things go, I am sure I own all 18 brands you tested and I can never find one when I need it.
Great point! Mine seem to go into hiding too. lol
I use these tools regularly so they go in a magnetic parts tray on side of my tool box. I lost them too often before
@Tilc Rekcil
Lol the 10mm is the Waldo of tools
@@ProjectFarm For my small stuff like these I get a block of foam and an organizer from Harbor Freight with the removable compartments, take out as many as I need to and fill the rest with the foam and carve out slots for the tools. I have about ten of them with things like rivets and tool, etc. and they're less than $10 each with the foam.
Cats man, cats
I've broken countless impact adaptors, this test was very informative thank you
You're welcome!
Same
2:35 PF up here trying to summon the devil by breaking all the socket adapters lol.....
Hail Satin!
I really love this channel and he’s doing an excellent job by review all tools fairly, Also he respond to every single comment 😅
I try! Thanks so much!
I’m honestly surprised by the results. I seem to gain a biased view of my fav brand because it usually doesn’t let me down, however the results speak for themselves!
I have a video idea, could you do surge protectors?
Btw I really love your channel, you have really helped my confidence in buying brands.
Thanks for sharing! Thanks for the video idea.
Once again, I had a tool break and typed in a search to find the best replacement. "Oh, Project Farm has a video on this!" Watched all the way to the end. Now I know what I will replace my socket adapter with and why. Thanks again Project Farm!
You are welcome!
"shock absorbent zone" is code word for "crap"
@Dante Alighieri Go big or go home. Literally 😂
unless it actually absorbs shock which it may well be doing when used with an impact driver. he's using constant pressure to snap them, an impact driver uses momentary rotational shocks where the material has time to recover between hits.
@@cliveramsbotty6077 He did use an impact 💁🏻♂️
I use Milwaukee shockwave adapters on automotive applications and it holds up very well, what I notice it is on the overall stronger non impact adapters twist over time, but the shock absorbent part takes the impact and prevents the adapter from twisting, delivering accurate torque every time rather than some lost on the twisting, I’m a year strong on a single adapter set with daily use lol
no its not. you would need a longer test setup with less torque to show the benifit of them (fatique testing). the "torsion zones " are trade off, you sac maximum torque for a longer lifespan at lower torques. this setup is maximum torsion test so of cause the one with the bigger diameter will perform a lot better: tau = 4*(F*r)/(pi *r^3)
so if you need a adapter to remove huge rusted bolts with a tool to small for the job take a adapter with a big diameter, otherwise a sufficent one with a "torsion zone" will perform better in the long run
Out of interest, I've noticed you rarely test Husky products from Home Depot. I want to see how they hold up
Thanks for the video idea.
Same here. I recently picked up a 6 piece set for under $10. For my uses they'll work just fine. But would've been nice to see them tested.
Hey! I'm not as experienced as Project Farm, but I've been abusing my husky adapters for the past year and haven't had a problem yet. That being said, I'd love to see a video testing them, as I use a ryobi driver, so it isn't exactly being pushed to any limits
id like to point out husky is one of those companies that rebrands other companies tools and sells them with their name (atleast sometimes) dont get me wrong i have quite a few husky tools and do like them but part of me wonders if they were manuafactured by them or do they just have a great sourcing team one example i can think of is their ratcheting wrenches they are actually gearwrench brand
@@diyoutube6061 Every brand is rebranded. Ryobi is made by the same people as Milwaukee. DeWalt is owned by the same people as Black and Decker, Bostitch, Proto, Mac Tools, Irwin, Craftsman, and a few others. Just about every single brand is owned by other brands, it's all the same. Even Snap-On is shared with Blue Point, Lindstrom, and Williams.
Oh hey PF, oh hi me walking to get my coffee on a Sunday morning...don't mind if I do!
What?
@@xploration1437 almost every Sunday morning when he posts i happen to be looking at my phone walking to get my coffee...and sure as shit I get the notification im looking at my phone on my way to get coffee lol
Hope you enjoy coffee and the video!!
@@dr_kellogg doesn't make sense at the beginning. But get you face out your phone when walking mindless sheep
@@JB-vt5sz its ok, your dad really does love you he just didn't want to be with your mom.
i had a cheap makita for over ten years and it finally gave out once i got into transmission work. ATF fluid is incredibly detrimental to the internals. Dont get em wet! i got a fairly cheap $20 milwaukee set with a phillips, 3/8 adapter and a bunch of other stuff i rarely used. the bit set outlasted my impact and i still use it today.
anyway for a short while i used some harbor freight bits, the little black sockets ones. they were really convenient and never broke on me but wore down around the edges of the adapter. i think this helped wear out the driver too cuz i had issues with my overly expensive matco bit set later on.
the cheap sets are good 'get me by' tools but dont use them more than a few months, they will wear your tools down.
Thanks for sharing.
Do I need a socket adapter? No. Will I in the near future? Probably not. Did I watch the entire video making sure to pause if I had to step away? Better believe I did
Do you only consume content which directly relates to your immediate or near immediate needs?
If I've learned anything from these videos, DeWalt it's usually a consistent performer.
Thanks for the feedback.
yea thats the thing i like about buying dewalt. they might not always be number one(though they often are) but theyre almost always among the top competitors. if you dont have time to test and compare every tool you buy, you can usually rest easy just picking up dewalt and knowing youll be getting a high performance tool. plus their battery system is by far the most versatile, its nice to be able to run an entire aresenal of tools off a single system(their 20/60v system).
In other words, even where dewalt doesn't excel they do a very good job of not putting their name on total crap.
I'm watching this amazing man like it's a full season on Netflix 😂
I'd love to see you include more brands like snap on an mac in tests like this. And even in the cordless tool tests as well. And like always thanks for the videos!
Great suggestion! Thank you.
I LOVE your videos as I have recently been spending a lot of money on upgrading my tools to the best quality, and your work here certainly helps me sort out the wheat from the chaff.
Thanks so much! Glad to hear!
How about doing a comparison of torque sticks and also compare their accuracy?
I'll 2nd that.
Torque sticks are garbage.
Use a proper torque wrench.
Thanks for the video idea.
@@evictioncarpentry2628 Torque sticks get you close quickly and stop you from over tightening. My time is more important than yours obviously.
New project farm? Drop everything for the engagement metrics!
Thank you very much!
PF,
About to watch another great video on project farm! Stay safe and have a great week!
General repair
Hi General Repair, Thank you and hope you have a great week too!