Limitless Pendant AI | MKBHD Tears Apart Humane Pin | Rabbit's Jesse Lyu Pits R1 against Humane Pin
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июн 2024
- Learn AI With Me:
www.skool.com/natural20/about
Join my community and classroom to learn AI and get ready for the new world.
Limitless AI Video:
• Introducing Limitless:...
Jesse Lyu Testing the Pin:
• Humane Ai Pin vs rabbi...
/ 1780077494127013988
00:00 Limitless Pendant
07:05 Humane Pendant
12:50 Jesse Lyu Pits R1 against the Humane Pin
17:13 Limitless Pendant Video
#ai #openai #llm
BUSINESS, MEDIA & SPONSORSHIPS:
Wes Roth Business @ Gmail . com
wesrothbusiness@gmail.com
Just shoot me an email to the above address.
I’ve been waiting years for something like this- my recall is bad and I’ve been caught out many times after meetings, not being able to recall certain key points relevant to my tasks for the day/week. This would be a lifesaver for me. And not just for work, I’d love this for arguments 😂 Being able to scroll back through conversations to see what was actually said when me or the person I’ve been speaking to deny saying something. Possibly a total nightmare, but I’m up for giving it a go.
Nothing but respect for MKBHD for keeping it real. He laid down some truth about Fisker EV too. Marques didn't get where he is by selling out. These small startups are looking to do one thing....get bought by a big player.
You will never see a bad report of apple from him. He will never bite the hand feeding him, that's exactly why he have to screw any possible competence for aifoun.
@@paelnever apple make good products hehe
@@paelnever He criticises Apple products all the time and he uses an Android phone. What the hell are you saying ?
@@phpn99 Yeah, he may not be Louis Rossmann when it comes to bashing Apple, but I don't think Marcus sugarcoats when Apple does something shady or stupid.
Forget the price. Apple product is the truth! Legit fucking stuff
I don't want to wear another gadget. I want this to be a smartwatch app talking to my phone, perhaps running local models there for simple tasks, and only connecting to the cloud when needed.
It almost 100% will be in some form, but a lot of us DON'T want to pull out our phone all day.
@@mc9723 which is why they said SMARTWATCH.
The Limitless Pendant could be very useful for students. I would have loved to have someone taking notes for me in University so I could have just concentrated on what the Prof was saying.
You are right. That would have been really so helpful. I tried to write as fast as possible and I wouldn't be surprised if the profs were annoyed by all the typing around them.
There is a Black Mirror episode dealing with a life recorder.
Marques was right. When you show off a product that should be a revolution, the basic functions should work as presented. The makers of Humane never said the product is clunky. They should have mentioned that before releasing it. I saw the keynote and there everything was fast and fine.
Small devs with a vision should consider open source
The Limitless guy reminds me of Data when he was mimicking human facial expressions and emotions. There's something really creepy about him. I was waiting for it to say the video was generated by AI at the end.
Totally agree, something very insincere about him
What you are subconsciously (and correctly) picking up is the fact that this guy is smiling with *only his mouth*- not his eyes.
And that 100% registers as disingenuous.
Autism might be at play here.
Right? He, and the product, seems so fishy
thanks for putting chapters!
I was thinking the same thing, the next time I'm undercover in a meeting, the limitless pending would make things less conspicuous...😅😅😅
2 months ago Humane was uploading promo demos of the pin to X and I as many others told them how noticeable the latency in the pin was, and how unimpressive it was. I explicitly told them not to release that product in that state, yet they released in that exact state. They definitely saw the negative critiques coming.
Oh nice, when I'm working on my laptop and scrolling youtube on my phone, maybe my apple watch/health tracker can notify me when this 24/7 audio recorder is out 😊
I love this concept of the Limitless pendant. Can't wait till it's released!
Iain M Banks ( RIP ) wrote some or my favourite sci-fi Books ever - Excession is possibly my number 1. The whole Culture series are incredible.
Between $19 and $29 for a subscription, that is basically a must have for this device, seems like quite a bit. Especially with kind of misleading advertisement, telling us that it does not require a subscription. Technically correct, but then you technically have just 10h of AI features per month, which - for this kind of device - is basically nothing. The rest of the time it is just an always-on micro that you have with you.
This is like buying bionic legs: sounds great until you realise your muscles have atrophied and the subscription to your legs goes up every two quarters. Such a device will make it so you can't store anything in your own memory. At that point imagine the possibilities if the device starts to gaslight you on behalf of the manufacturer and their "partners".
Yep.
Memory is a "use it or loose it" deal ... that is well studied and uncontroversial.
@@ZappyOhthat's right I forgot ab that, you're right. We should wait for someone to pay for a study. But we don't need a study to trust a machine that listens to everything and then whispers advice into your ear, that is as vanilla as can be.
I think I would actually love the Limitless pendant, but I would have to KNOW that the "confidential cloud" actually worked.
That's kind of like a "private locker" at a train station, not very secure... It's in the cloud. Nothing in a cloud is ever secure.
You will never know.
Some people will only "feel" it is secure.
LOL WhoTF are you? Get a grip, nobody cares about you. So don't worry about it
@@fedorp4713 Having worked a bit around that space, Cloud providers invest a lot of expertise into making things _very secure_. It depends on what the _customer company_ is doing with that platform.
If they wanted to, they _could_ apply encryption, such that neither the provider nor the company can read the user data - but I doubt they do, because it makes search tasks a real pain.
Still, Cloud is not inherently insecure. It's usually less private, but that's a decision.
Seems like a great product!
The pendant is getting bashed in the comments, but it’s a great idea for some use cases. We have an ageing population, for example, and this could fantastic for people with early stage dementia. Also, you know how quickly I lose pens? Livescribe would last a week. And that was supposed to be baseline function. The idea is that it’s supposed to become more like an assistant to help with everyday living.
seems like Limitless is a solution in search of a problem
I'd might try the Humane Pin for $199, and almost certainly at $99. I ordered the R1 on day 1, and the Limitless Pendant too. These devices are just the start of something amazing.
Star Trek got it all wrong with the communicator badge. The badge of the future projects an AI assistant into the real world to help you with everything.
D&D sessions will never be the same. Now, instead of taking notes, I can just read a summary of what happened. I can ask what new NPC's we met, and what new locations we visited. Might seem easy for most but I have ADHD so I always forget these things by the next session.
All three devices emphasize privacy but approach it differently according to their design. The Rabbit R1 and Limitless Pendant focus on secure, on-device processing, whereas the Humane Pin’s design, including a potentially always-on camera, might require rigorous privacy controls to gain user trust.
lmao your phone already has the hardware to do the promised functionality
All this early wearable "AI" stuff is incredibly dumb. We already have lots of small devices that can access AI services over the internet... which is all these things are doing.
Yeah, but inconveniently, having to unlock your phone, interrupt what you are doing, open the app and then making a question.
Those things have a HUGE potential. We are not there yet of course, but Someon has to start the journey
Hardware wise both limitless and humane are well designed though humane is overclocked to hot.
But we dont need those since we have phones, however we do need an always on mic and camera paired to your phone so AI can be more helpful.
Sounds like a new product is needed.
With AI Agents built in - I'd want one, absolutely!
Flabbergasted
Dumbfounded
Astonished
Gobsmacked
SHOOK
@@JOlivier2011 Shaken, not stirred
Shooketh even
Wearable AI tech reflects the value of authentic human data to train AI. It's the new oil.
Imagine being in a jungle and asking the AI for advice about how to behave in front of the tiger 50 yards away: "Certainly! Let's delve into the rich tapestry of-" GARRRGHH!!!
I actually have a solution to Humane AI pin's latency.
They should use Groq for inference on the new WizardLM-2-8x22b model (which is comparable to OpenAI's GPT-4). Groq can produce 550-800 tokens a second, compared to OpenAI's GPT-4's less than 20 tokens per second.
I believe this would reduce the latency from 5-10 seconds to 2-3 seconds.
The bottleneck would be their transcription (speech-to-text) on their device and the wi-fi connection.
💯
My Galaxy s24 phone does (and more) it too.
Rabbit r1 is the best one, especially that teach mode, I feel like there’s apps on my phone that does what the pendant do
I thought the rabbit was a s*X toy? Baha.
This looks interesting but try using it when the highway patrol officer pulls you over…. Oh my word. It’s a braver new world.
I agree… these devices are weird. But I like your take on supporting the innovative people. Good video Wesmeister. I need new eyeballs… anyone innovating on this project?
Thanks for the book recommendation.
The limitless sounds like a livescribe pen but with extra and less functions at the same time. And that has been out for over 10 years
loved livescribe as I used that device for studying from livescribe unit that recorded emergency medical technician class lecture notes. Now this limitless device would likely be even much more enhanced in that same potential student class note taking application; as now one would have artificial intelligence enhanced note taking capabilities on the fly; so this would be potentially very useful for pretty much any college student attending class lectures; this could in fact be the perfect study tool to review one's class notes on the same day right after class to help ensure and clarify one's critical class notes with one's assigned class college textbook readings to follow up on those mentioned class lecture note ideas and/or thoughts to practice processing those same ideas or thoughts discussed about in the class lecture; this would save the potential college student quite a lot of time as well as enhance their college student studying efficiency by a factor of five fold. Now for $100 for the limitless device itself and $20 per month artificial intelligence access this would be a rather very minimal cost effective way to protect and insure that one's educational investment is enhanced; as compared to what it costs nowadays with four year college tuition that is currently around $400 to $500 per college credit or about $5,000 per fall or spring semester; it simply cost to much to potentially fail a given potential quarterly class test examination, mid term examination or final examination. For most college students this would be a very welcome college study tool to be able to handle the inevitable class lecture information overload and allow one to preserve one's class lecture notes using artificial intelligence to assist one in identifying important class lecture notes pointing out potential important fundamental class lecture fundamental concepts and principles that may be on a future class test examination.
How can you be more excited about the R1 than the smartphone in your hand? 🤦
R1 most likely will face the same thing, they were smart to sell before the reviews come...
they promised to ship by end of march :)
Seems like we are at the ‘Google glass’ moment but for AI. Great ideas in principle but the technology isn’t mature enough for them to realise their potential. I got a Plaud AI last year and didn’t subscribe, realising I had an app for that already, and didn’t need another device. See how AR glasses failed to take off. Looks like we’ve got a few years of those kinds of pointless gadgets too. Once all this tech comes together, great. But we’re still a few years away from the mass market device. Could be two years. Could be ten. Be interesting watching Wes and others show us inching their way there…
Exactly
Why the lipstick?
That's different.
That might be usefull in buissness settings to record and transcript meetings for later recall.
OR
when you record everything, then store it as notes, then put those notes into RAG system with Assistent LLM -> you got PERFECT memory, brother.
Your wife said when she has bday? you remeber. She said that she likes something? you can ask assistent for good gifts ideas and bang - "you" "remembered" what she said.
Now, when I get high in the woods with my friends, and talk for hours about science and philosophy, I can get a transcript and summary the next day after we've all forgotten what we said.
All of these companies are trying so hard to not make a smartphone app! No I do not want your Bluetooth mic / speaker!
I'm not agree : Human Pin was , is , will be a failed and unuseful product ! Point ! 😂😂😂
I take it all back! 41.50$ Canadian for shipping 😮 Still in IF ravens are delivering them at that price.
the pendant's AI is primarily to record and transcribe
notably lacking the camera, and feeding that audio to a multimodal LLM for an voice response
also minus the laser UI
no apples to apples comparison there
Similar to apple blends in with daily life
Shocking 😮
As if these "go fast and break things" VC funded blitzscaling companies need consumer sympathy. Make it good or fail fast as intended.
*No subscription required* for this thing. Nice.
Realistically speaking: You require the subscription.
Without sub, the AI features are available for only 10h per month, those include transcriptions, summaries, notes etc.
So it seems that without the subscription it would effectively be simply a glorified always-on microphone, which would deconstruct the whole idea and make it unusable without sub.
Therefore you will have to get the subscription, which is $19.
Edit: If you pay yearly, of course. If you decide to pay monthly in order to first test it out and to be able to unsubscribe at any time, you're looking at $29 per month.
It's free, until you can't live without.
Just like fentanyl.
Wait... Free Fentanyl?! You In Vancouver or something?! Where they giving it out for free?!?!
$19 to $29.... Billed annually... He said it really fast and quoted down at that part...and like the other commenter said, the free option is hella limited... Shame, was thinking of getting one if it was actually free 😣
Can't wait to pay for another subscription.
It's a company's job to think about the consequences of making a bad product. Honestly, i don't even understand how this thing got so much vibe. It's terrible.
Humane pin would have been better if it was combined with eye tracking using smart glasses which the image was reflected back to and which eye tracking and hand tracking was used to interact with the interface
Good review Wes
I would just like a bluetooth pendant where I could just talk to Bard/Gemini in natural language... ask questions etc. Google almost made it with that lapel pin but it disappeared
You will have no privacy and you will like it. You'l even pay for it!
All of those just look like devices that should be an app... or more like update for google assitant / siri etc. so you can activate it from your watch, earbuds or whatever else.
I would love to have this, but I am going to feel really awkward recording people and asking for consent until it becomes normal.
10:52 -ish I don't have wires running to my Vive... Looks just like this pic.
So that’s what happened to Louis C.K.!
13:00 Oh no, why 1.5 speed. I heard words but not sentences, I had to slow it down to hear what they were saying, lol. :-)
this should be the default goal of all of these "future" AI product and even so far as social media integration ie input goes first to an AI to be placed in a RAG then submitted to "public" as "licensed content" which could be revoked at any time by you.
I should have the right to be represented by a "bot" and that "bot" should fall under the same guide lines of protection as other privileged communication include attorney-client, doctor-patient, priest-parishioner, two spouses, and (in some states) reporter-source. If harm-or the threat of harm-to people is involved, the privileged communication protection disappears.
The only issue is having a device emitting and receiving man made EMFs so close to the heart? 😅
I knew by looking at the humane pin it was gonna be a flop! Maybe if it only cost 50 bucks and no subscription. But it’s funny to me that these people thought it was a good idea!.
When I think back to the dark ages of the 90s, almost none of the gadgets did what they promised (never mind get updates to fix it) - and it was kind of accepted that was the case. Read the screen in sunlight - ha, no chance. Handwriting recognition - dreadful. Mobile internet connectivity - awful. Compatibility and file transfer - good luck. Kind of working functionality like the Pin was the norm. That was the price to pay for having gadgets back then. You were beta testing the future. Watching MKBHD review the Pin was like taking a trip back in time - and thinking how much things had improved since.
The Limitless Pendant looks great. I'm going to claim it is a medical device for people over 50 to help you cope with memory loss.
D.U.M.B.
I think the failing with the humane pin was that there was nothing that it did that your phone couldnt do better. I think were far off from these devices being practical. once the software is good enough on the hardware that we are already carrying around every day, then we can start thinking about new hardware.
Elon musk has mentioned Ian M Banks culture series as being influential for him, George Hotz names Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect by Roger Williams as being the best science fiction book on AI and the singularity.
Sam Altman has Asimov's Foundation and Aldous Huxley's Brave New World in his must read list but no AI specific scfi.
I for one can’t wait to lose my iPhone due to the addictive properties of the device. The sooner I can get my day to day apps on an alternative that I don’t need to look at my screen the better
Third eye is way too low, it needs to mount to the forehead like the ancients showed us how they hung theirs.
8:00 Most everyone has completely misunderstood Daniel Vassallo’s point. He didn’t say that Marques was wrong for giving a negative review. He was pointing out that the video title was sensational and irresponsible for someone with such a huge audience.
Bullsh1t. He said what he said. No need for you to spin-doctor things.
My google heard you... SHOCKING!
I see a future where we walk around like zombies carrying our AI wherever they, ( the AI ), want to go. All the conversations and thoughts are done by the AIs. Basically, we become their mode of transportation. Why build millions of android bodies when you already have billions of available targets? As for morality, the AI might conclude that it must be ok as Humans have already done this and it was accepted as the norm when they did. It would be logical, therefore, that a superior being, ( whether organic or silicon ), should be able to follow suit.
People's psychology won't respond well to perfect transcripts of everything they say.
I imagine people sifting through everything said today, in order to sound smarter tomorrow.
hanging on every little detail, critiquing self and sending self-consciousness to the moon.
This is actually exactly what I need
All this wearable tech is pretty stupid when it is fundamentally competing with smartphones. "Hands-free" isn't the super element people think it is, I can easily say "my smartphone is hand-controllable, no swiveling your whole body and also easy to get into unusual angles". If you can't bring everything a smartphone has to the table and then more, you're screwed, your product is DOA. This includes all the functionality as well as the processing power and other bits including privacy.
All that said the Limitless pendant seems much better thought out and for $99 you can give it a whirl as a toy without breaking the bank. My personal feeling is that the live-syncing model is better, having a small wearable that is a bluetooth window into your more powerful and functional smartphone.
Just read all the reviews for the Humane Ai Pin, and you'll see that it's unanimously considered to be poorly designed.
You can't shoot the messenger. Name me one good product that was unanamously reviewed poorly that didn't deserve it.
If the Humane team was smart, they would delay it for at least for another year and improve it, so it's actually good, and people see the value in it.
Seems obvious to me. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
Why do yotubers totally forget to ask the right questions????
Is it just to be the fastest to create void contents or what?
an app on a phone can do exactly the same, if not more, why do we need separate device?
August 2024 is not even close to Q4. What's happening? Bad sign tbh.
When it lives in your glasses/watch/ring/buds, these things become obsolete. Everyone loves unnecessary dongels, right? No.
For $100? Yeah why not buy it?
My phone already does more, better and costs less.
MKBHD is the goat.
I can just do this on my phone…
Not really, most of the time you'll have your phone in your pocket, and your phone in your pocket doesn't record very well. That said 99$ for a blue-tooth microphone plus a 19$ subscription is a bit overpriced, but at least not a scam like the 700$ humane pin.
You say these early AI products will be bad, therefore, the companies that release them should do more research and beta testing to help ensure that these products meet and or exceed the consumer’s expectations. The creators of the humane pin had to know their product was not ready to be released, yet for whatever reason, they released it anyway, considering its current functionality, it should have been released at a much much lower price point. I consider their premature release of this product to be highly disappointing if not unethical. Maybe they were losing so much money that they felt the need to release it whether it was ready or not, again, unethical. Glad I didn’t buy one.
No more head in the bottom right plzzzzzzzzzzz
These pins / rabbit AI make no sense… since the phone can do everything with a much better interface…
While I generally agree with your perspective on your videos, your take on the MKBHD review is just flat out wrong. The point of his video was that for him *as an early adopter*, the product cohesively sucked.He wasn't dunking on a few bugs or clinks in the product. He wasn't dunking on the engineering (in fact he praised at how amazing the engineering was). The overall function, the Job To Be Done, of the product sucked. Whereas an iPhone or any other smartphone that can do the Humane AI pins product more efficiently, with less friction, and is an overall better user experience.
Comparing the V1 Humane AI pin to the Tesla Roadster or the first iPhone is just a mischaracterization of what MKBHD was communicating. The Tesla Roadster and the first iPhone did phenomenal numbers in sales because, while it was meant to be for a niche segment of customers, was an amazing product experience.
who would let a ai run your day hehe the data they gonna have about you is crazy even when they say it run locally on your device there gonna be some meta data about you from your device like a sms the meta data of a sms have to be stored in 5 years...
Just don’t think folks need this yet. I don’t want or need one. Too much AI immersion. Man you are really stretching the use cases.
What was lacking from ai tech was never the ability to wear it. Any attempt to make money in this way is missing the point and just trying to make a quick buck.
Developing a UX that makes using agents straightforward and productive is where the real Innovation lies
You still have to push a button to interact with this thing. Its not it.
i didnt even pay attention on what this pendent does but the pitch is scam-like. like the virginity bracelets or something stupid like that. this will be a fail.
To me they have got the design right. This could be the winner and perhaps even bigger .
Holy revelation?! We need a stick on "third eye", kind of like the Hindu's use? Eye like the eyedea of it tuned into what my eyes are looking at, so it makes more sense to have it stuck to my forehead.
If there were some kind of place we could perch some kind of device right near our eyes, like some kind of glasses, that would make way more sense...............plus you could put in speakers near the ears.
Ugh, good luck little dot. You're the best of the lot, but you're looking for something to replace, and you just don't make enough sense.
Again, this can be a simple phone app.
All these new AI devices are quick cash grabs, don't fall for them peeps.
Is it the humane pin or human pin?
I have to admit that I found the Rabbit more interesting then this pin.
MKBHD ftw. Anyone giving him BS is weak sauce
Yeah, I'm not sitting down with someone for a meeting if they are wearing that shit.
The humane pin is so stupid
i just hope elon gonna send out some muse with some neurolink implanted for developers soon im waiting hehe