When I first heard Side 2 of Low... I don't remember what day it was but it changed me. Same when I heard Heroes. I am a different person now in the best way ever.
Elite Albums He says 'albums tend to get worse as they go on'.....meaning he thinks each particular album gets worse as it goes on. So there's no contradiction by putting his first album last. Meanwhile I don't necessarily agree with the bloke.
Yes it is. Only the title track was from the TV show. The rest of the album was completely original material only loosely based on the snippets of music Bowie made for the show.
@@theeditorseye573 I just checked to see if you have made any more ranking videos and Boom there it was The Beatles Ranked. Just watched it on my TV. Superb! 👍
My list is completely different but still enjoyed watching this very much! My favourite album of Bowie’s is Ziggy Stardust - but my favourite Bowie song is Ashes to Ashes
It is great to see a list which takes every song into account, allowing for often overlooked albums, such as Black Tie White Noise, to receive the credit they deserve. I absolutely loved this ranking. Thank you.
One of the most interesting and meticulously scientific ways to arrive at a final result. Great to find someone I agree with on the top 4, though the order is slightly different. Maybe I could say that my top choice evens out the results of your tie. 1. Hunky Dory 2. Ziggy Stardust 3. Aladdin Sane 4. Station to Station
@Remimi2017 If it wasn't TMWSTH I might agree...there's no space for opinion in that masterpiece. IMO Aladidn Sane is one of my least faves but I am aware people rate it highly. TMWSTW is perfection..
I never listened to LOW side 2 until I listened incessantly to PHILIP GLASS’s LOW SYMPHONY. I was embarrassed I couldn’t enjoy side 2 particularly because I’d play Side 1 as warmup for a riotous Friday or Saturday night. GLASS did wonders for opinion of LOW. I suggest always that when every BEATles and Stones fan is dead the culture will still regard LOW Symphony and therefore BOWIE. BOWIE will be known in 22nd century because of GLASS’s LOW, HEROES LODGER symphonies. I lost regard for the BEATles and the STONES after repeated listening of GLASS’s interpretation of BOWIE’s music. Publicity machine can’t help those two bands in the next century.
Great list, tongue in cheek but heartfelt. Outside had some of the best songs on it but that stupid story line hurt it. Like you said, scaffolding. Thanx for your ranking.
I've never understood why people like Hunky Dory so much. To me it should be nearer the bottom. Granted, Life on Mars, Queen Bitch and Changes are Fantastic, but Kooks belongs with Uncle Arthur and the rest sound like Space Oddity outtakes. To me this is the musical equivelent of The Emperor's New Clothes.
Woah. Diamond dogs so low??? Blasphemy. Diamond Dogs wavers back and forth as my favorite Bowie album battling it out with Alladin Sane which is also my favorite Bowie song. It's all relative because we all appreciate Bowie from different periods. But it's safe to agree that Tonight and Never let me down are the worst.
1... David Live 2....Diamond Dogs 3....David Bowie, 1969 4....Low 5....Man Who Sold the world......... .....but I might switch the top two because I love Diamond Dogs so much.
Finally someone who likes Lodger! I think it is very great and diverse, and fits a circle the end with the start. But I respect people who doesn't think "geniously" as a transitional style.
I simply couln't agree less with the ranking... especially on low ranked albums like Ouside, Heathen, Low or Hours... or even Let's dance & Blackstar which is consists of nothing less than epic tracks... but i appreciate the effort in making a video like this. I assume you are a member of the earlier generation of Bowie fans. Hence your top 3 picks are from 50 years ago. Cheers.
I sincerely wonder why you left out the Tin Machine albums. Sure, they were called albums by "a band" back in the day (as a promo claim), but no doubt are they real Bowie albums like these 25 others. That "I am just part of a band now" thing is/was obviously just one of Bowie's many roles and guises, so leaving them out of any serious studio albums overview is just silly. Anyway, while Tin Machine II surely competes with anyone's choice for the bottom end of the ranking, the first Tin Machine album is actually really cool. Sure, Bowie made lots of much better albums, but it's definitely better than a few in his catalogue.
I agree with much of your ratings having followed his career the whole way. However you did Low and Heroes a great injustice by rating them so low. I was happy to see you gave Black Tie White Noise its due however,
I love your ranking. Specially the low place for low.😊. I really enjoyed listening to your opinions I am impress with what you told about teenage. Yes, I felt touched with that great truth about personalities. Alter egoes. It matchs with me. Only one disagree. You pointed "soul love" with only 7.5 !!! Thx for all.
1... David Live ...don’t care that it’s not a studio album, it’s Bowie at the absolute height of his game. mid chronic cocaine addiction, absolutely flying. The Man Who Fell to Earth era. Brilliant 2....Diamond Dogs....despite Rebel Rebel, this is still magnificent 3....David Bowie, 1969 ....brilliant folky songs 4....Low......still sounds new to me ( Heroes was all the tracks not good enough for Low, in my opinion, though Heroes was a great song) 5....Man Who Sold the world.........I love those long songs .....but I might switch the top two because I love Diamond Dogs so much. When I think of what I’ve left out it just shows how good he was up until 1978, infact it started to fall apart after he was cured of addiction. Let’s Dance, China Girls, Absolute Beginners, Ashes to Ashes not for me....who cares though,, there’s another six brilliant albums up to ‘78.
Completely disagree about the ranking of Bowie’s nineties and eighties lps. They don’t deserve such a high ranking. On the other hand ‘Berlin’ trilogy lps would have deserved a better consideration. Aladdin sane at the third place is also disputable. To me: ziggy/hunky/low are top Bowie albums. Heroes/scary/station are close second. Diamond/Aladdin are a bit a moreofthesame of Bowie ziggy-era: some immortal song but the albums are average considering it’s Bowie (not Bolan). Next day/Blackstar are tremendous albums but also painful ones given that are premonition of what Bowie could’ve done….
It’s all subjective, but I can’t really argue with your list because, well, it’s your list. ;-) My top four are identical to yours. But Blackstar would be fifth, and The Next Day would be sixth (I can’t believe you have TND ranked so low). And while you rank Station to Station high, it’s ironic that you rank the song Stay so low. I think that’s the best song on the album. Reality is better than Outside. And Low is better than Heroes. His 80s output is certainly his low point, but you can’t possibly rank Never Let Me down higher than Let’s Dance. I mean, I don’t particularly care for Let’s Dance, but the three hits are decent songs. And Never Let Me Down has virtually nothing worthwhile. But, all in all, not a bad list. Cheers.
Never Let Me Down is underrated. I’ve been listening to it all week. Maybe I like it so much because I grew up in the 80s. I like all those rock songs at the end that you don’t
colemann76 that’s probably the only Bowie album I find almost impossible to listen to. Time Will Crawl is okay, and the title track. The rest is cringe. It’s his worst record in my eyes. I do find it cool that you like it though. Cheers
Really enjoyed your list. While I disagree with a lot, I’ll focus on how we wouldn’t have have “Low” in either of our top 10s. Or how “Outside” is great or how underrated “Earthling,” is. I heard it the first time this week and was blown away. Also, where would you rank “Buddha of Suburbia?” I love it and it gets better with every listen.
@@austinheinbuch8642 my mind changed, it’s now ziggy. Specifically cause of the strings on rock n roll suicide. I still say from an objective perspective, low is best.
I give the song Life on Mars 11 out of 10, but then it is my my all time favourite. For me it was all down hill after Scary Monsters, and all the later albums were just too weak. Strangers When We Meet was the anomaly being absolutely brilliant, and Where Are We Now was the best last song for me. I would rate the LP Young Americans far higher than you, above Station taking the albums as whole works. Very interesting any way.
All downhill after Scary Monsters? Far from it. Heathen, Hours, Blackstar all brilliant albums, plus more. I'm guessing that you're not 'totally' familiar with all of the albums after Scary Monsters (and I do mean totally familiar to be in a position to judge). I feel the same about Life On Mars, probably my favorite song of all time. I highly recommend giving any of the 3 albums above at least 10 plays.
Why do you score under Ambient and Progressive Electronica songs? Those songs have a super ambitious structure and composition! My God, what little idea of music do you have?
Great video. Overall I think your system did a pretty good job of placing the bulk of albums in more or less the right place. Two objections however. 1. Low is too low. I feel you were a little tough in Side 2. 2. Reality....in my opinion a universally underrated album.
I have to disagree with you about Low. It could be my favourite Bowie album, especially because of side two
Same with "Heroes", the ambient tracks are great
That was my introduction to Bowie and to ambient music. Absolutely agree, great tracks.
When I first heard Side 2 of Low... I don't remember what day it was but it changed me. Same when I heard Heroes. I am a different person now in the best way ever.
Yeah he was a bit too cruel about the instrumentals, I actually like Bowie's instrumentals, especially his 90s instrumentals
I don't get it - how Letter to Hermione can get a score of 4? How is it even possible? An acoustic masterpiece
Low on 18? Are you crazy? It is my number two after the number one from me: Station to Station
TEE: the albums get worse as they go on
also TEE: his first album was his worst
Elite Albums He says 'albums tend to get worse as they go on'.....meaning he thinks each particular album gets worse as it goes on.
So there's no contradiction by putting his first album last.
Meanwhile I don't necessarily agree with the bloke.
You can't rate "Low" so low.
Nice pun intended
Yes one can. Glass’s symphony saves the album’s reputation.
The instrumentals were poorly rated. I disagree
Well made countdown, but boy do I have to disagree with a lot of this.
😂😂 me too. Wow.
Most underrated is The Buddha of Suburbia .
That's not a studio album
@@garrold7123 it’s still an amazing album
Yes it is. Only the title track was from the TV show. The rest of the album was completely original material only loosely based on the snippets of music Bowie made for the show.
@@garrold7123 Bowie went into a studio and recorded it.
Wow! I have watched many ranking videos but this was the one I enjoyed most. Beautifully presented and ridiculous bonkers placings! Superb job!
Thank you for your kind words...I hope you appreciate how my scienctific method makes the ranking process only 94% bonkers overall...
@@theeditorseye573 I just checked to see if you have made any more ranking videos and Boom there it was The Beatles Ranked. Just watched it on my TV. Superb! 👍
Check the Queen one, it’s also amazing
how is Let's Dance behind Never Let Me Down????
I disliked both albums.
So happy someone else rated Hearhen relatively up there. I’ve always loved it. Great list. Makes me want to listen to Bowie right now.
A 5 for "Loving the alien" and 7 for "tonight"?? Wtf man😂
My list is completely different but still enjoyed watching this very much!
My favourite album of Bowie’s is Ziggy Stardust - but my favourite Bowie song is Ashes to Ashes
Which happen to me my 2nd fave album and my fave song!
Thanks. Great piece of work. So much to discover - I lost him after Scary Monsters.
Low on 18 , Side B is Great
Great vid, loved it!
It is great to see a list which takes every song into account, allowing for often overlooked albums, such as Black Tie White Noise, to receive the credit they deserve.
I absolutely loved this ranking. Thank you.
Rank of the albums i've listened so far:
08 David Bowie 4/10
07 1.Outside 7/10
06 Space Oddity 8/10
05 Blackstar 9/10
04 Heroes 9/10
03 Ziggy Stardust 10/10
02 Low 10/10
01 Honky Dory 10/10
dude don't skip out on station to station, its a masterpiece
Very good content, definetly underapreciated
very well done sir! Would love to know your marking scheme!
Such a great video man! I have very similar list, although my favourite album is Station to Station with my favourite song ever title track.!
I feel stay should have scored a much higher number
@@robertgraham5486 yes please
It’s his greatest song by far
One of the most interesting and meticulously scientific ways to arrive at a final result. Great to find someone I agree with on the top 4, though the order is slightly different. Maybe I could say that my top choice evens out the results of your tie.
1. Hunky Dory
2. Ziggy Stardust
3. Aladdin Sane
4. Station to Station
How could you give only 6.94 for the man who sold the world? This is a master piece. But i liked the video. Keep doing that.
huahuahuahua it's always good to find different opinions but I agree with you
I am glad I read this comment first ... anyone that can rate TMWSTW that low I have no interest in their opinion
@Remimi2017 If it wasn't TMWSTH I might agree...there's no space for opinion in that masterpiece. IMO Aladidn Sane is one of my least faves but I am aware people rate it highly. TMWSTW is perfection..
Hunky Dory will always be my no. 1 Bowie album, but I think Man Who Sold The World should have come in much higher - such an overlooked album.
Great video!
how could you give stay a 6 are you kidding me
I absolutely love Alomar's rift, and I like the song, it just doesn't quite hang together for me, feels bitty, sorry!
I agree and Sweet Thing? Solid 10 But opinions are like? and we all have em!
Music can't be only measured by numbers. We are not robots and music isn't made for them.
The instrumentals on low and heroes are really good. Especially subterraneans on low.
I never listened to LOW side 2 until I listened incessantly to PHILIP GLASS’s LOW SYMPHONY. I was embarrassed I couldn’t enjoy side 2 particularly because I’d play Side 1 as warmup for a riotous Friday or Saturday night. GLASS did wonders for opinion of LOW.
I suggest always that when every BEATles and Stones fan is dead the culture will still regard LOW Symphony and therefore BOWIE. BOWIE will be known in 22nd century because of GLASS’s LOW, HEROES LODGER symphonies. I lost regard for the BEATles and the STONES after repeated listening of GLASS’s interpretation of BOWIE’s music. Publicity machine can’t help those two bands in the next century.
i think David Bowie's first album was great,i think most of his music 1980s was not his best.
The irony is that Serious Moonlight tour was actually very good.
I bow down to Scary Monsters.
But Station to Station.
And Earthling.
Thank you, I enjoyed that enormously.
Blackstar is my favorite
Great list, tongue in cheek but heartfelt. Outside had some of the best songs on it but that stupid story line hurt it. Like you said, scaffolding. Thanx for your ranking.
Great vid, but I must say I love Pin Ups The covers are done with real passion Do agree with the top 3 though
I've never understood why people like Hunky Dory so much. To me it should be nearer the bottom. Granted, Life on Mars, Queen Bitch and Changes are Fantastic, but Kooks belongs with Uncle Arthur and the rest sound like Space Oddity outtakes. To me this is the musical equivelent of The Emperor's New Clothes.
Woah. Diamond dogs so low??? Blasphemy. Diamond Dogs wavers back and forth as my favorite Bowie album battling it out with Alladin Sane which is also my favorite Bowie song. It's all relative because we all appreciate Bowie from different periods. But it's safe to agree that Tonight and Never let me down are the worst.
Let's Dance (the song) with a score of 5?!
That song got me into David Bowie and is arguably considered to be his most iconic song.
Yes ! Surprising ! It should be 3.😁
Im so Happy ashes to ashes is getting the proper merit
This would be good: a playlist of all songs over a certain benchmark, they ultimate greatest hits mix tape!
1... David Live
2....Diamond Dogs
3....David Bowie, 1969
4....Low
5....Man Who Sold the world.........
.....but I might switch the top two because I love Diamond Dogs so much.
David Live is fantastic
could u do a beatles or beach boys ranking, id watch that multiple times
yup, going to do the fabulous four next!
The Editor's Eye sounds great, i’ll keep notifications on
Job done FINALLY!
ruclips.net/video/WFcVI0KxZPA/видео.html&ab_channel=TheEditor%27sEye
Finally someone who likes Lodger! I think it is very great and diverse, and fits a circle the end with the start. But I respect people who doesn't think "geniously" as a transitional style.
Lodger is a great album
Thank you so much for your work friend. A true hero
Bowie's first album is my favorite and by far his best
Low is my personal favourite Bowie album so to see it ranked so Low kinda hurt. But I do respect your opinion
I felt that way about Bowie ‘69 and Reality
I especially enjoy the B side of LOW.
well, if it's literally called "low" ahahah
but i love the second half of low
I like the video, and I dont think is a good idea to rate with numbers tho, you can enjoy an album more than others even if got more dulls
Now that I listen Bowie albums, you putting Low at 18 is... Electric chair
I'm loving the love for Black Tie White Noise.
very well done
Poniendo calificaciones a las canciones de Bowie como un profesor. estas loco. me gustaria saber que calificacion te llevaras vos?
The first 'not annoying' ranking I've seen... the worst was by 'dan and dave'
I simply couln't agree less with the ranking... especially on low ranked albums like Ouside, Heathen, Low or Hours... or even Let's dance & Blackstar which is consists of nothing less than epic tracks... but i appreciate the effort in making a video like this. I assume you are a member of the earlier generation of Bowie fans. Hence your top 3 picks are from 50 years ago. Cheers.
Watched until Low was ranked at 18, my favourite album by far, Heroes is just a poor Low
Great video. Thanks for sharing it. I agree mostly with everything, however I think Hunky Dory is his best work
Honestly? I think I agree, instinctively. That's what's interesting about doing something like this...
I love the first album. It manages to be both consistent in quality and wildly experimental.
PLEASE rank Billy Joel's 12 studio albums
I quite like the second side of Low
Interesting song ranking, very similar to mine.
NICE LISTING....I agree with the top 10!
I sincerely wonder why you left out the Tin Machine albums. Sure, they were called albums by "a band" back in the day (as a promo claim), but no doubt are they real Bowie albums like these 25 others. That "I am just part of a band now" thing is/was obviously just one of Bowie's many roles and guises, so leaving them out of any serious studio albums overview is just silly.
Anyway, while Tin Machine II surely competes with anyone's choice for the bottom end of the ranking, the first Tin Machine album is actually really cool. Sure, Bowie made lots of much better albums, but it's definitely better than a few in his catalogue.
glad to see some love for black tie white noise.
Could you do Fleetwood Mac?
Sorry for late reply! Think I'm going to do the Beatles next, can't resist them....
@@theeditorseye573 noice
He didn't go on a creative hiatus after Never Let Me Down. He did Tin Machine. You missed that. You also missed The Buddha of Suburbia.
Other than that, you did a great job.
@@179rich However Tin Machine it's not David Bowie the same way Wings are not Paul McCartney
Hiya. I just felt Suburbia was too much of a film (or rather TV) track album, it disqualified itself.
I think I more felt Tin Machine WAS a creative hiatus....
@@179rich Thanks appreciated
I agree with much of your ratings having followed his career the whole way. However you did Low and Heroes a great injustice by rating them so low. I was happy to see you gave Black Tie White Noise its due however,
I love your ranking. Specially the low place for low.😊. I really enjoyed listening to your opinions I am impress with what you told about teenage. Yes, I felt touched with that great truth about personalities. Alter egoes. It matchs with me. Only one disagree. You pointed "soul love" with only 7.5 !!! Thx for all.
I have to say I really don't share this guy's taste. He's given some of Bowie's greatest work really low scores.
Man who sold the world should be much higher
1... David Live ...don’t care that it’s not a studio album, it’s Bowie at the absolute height of his game. mid chronic cocaine addiction, absolutely flying. The Man Who Fell to Earth era. Brilliant
2....Diamond Dogs....despite Rebel Rebel, this is still magnificent
3....David Bowie, 1969 ....brilliant folky songs
4....Low......still sounds new to me ( Heroes was all the tracks not good enough for Low, in my opinion, though Heroes was a great song)
5....Man Who Sold the world.........I love those long songs
.....but I might switch the top two because I love Diamond Dogs so much.
When I think of what I’ve left out it just shows how good he was up until 1978, infact it started to fall apart after he was cured of addiction. Let’s Dance, China Girls, Absolute Beginners, Ashes to Ashes not for me....who cares though,, there’s another six brilliant albums up to ‘78.
1Aladdin sane 2 Diamond dogs 3 Hunky dory but every album great
Completely disagree about the ranking of Bowie’s nineties and eighties lps. They don’t deserve such a high ranking. On the other hand ‘Berlin’ trilogy lps would have deserved a better consideration. Aladdin sane at the third place is also disputable. To me: ziggy/hunky/low are top Bowie albums. Heroes/scary/station are close second. Diamond/Aladdin are a bit a moreofthesame of Bowie ziggy-era: some immortal song but the albums are average considering it’s Bowie (not Bolan). Next day/Blackstar are tremendous albums but also painful ones given that are premonition of what Bowie could’ve done….
Always liked his Tin Machine phase
Es de joda el vídeo no?
You forgot to rank the "The Budda of Suburbia"
No Tin Machine ?
Let’s Dance (the song) is a 5/10? Okay…then I suppose I should move on while my blood pressure slowly rises.
It’s all subjective, but I can’t really argue with your list because, well, it’s your list. ;-) My top four are identical to yours. But Blackstar would be fifth, and The Next Day would be sixth (I can’t believe you have TND ranked so low). And while you rank Station to Station high, it’s ironic that you rank the song Stay so low. I think that’s the best song on the album. Reality is better than Outside. And Low is better than Heroes. His 80s output is certainly his low point, but you can’t possibly rank Never Let Me down higher than Let’s Dance. I mean, I don’t particularly care for Let’s Dance, but the three hits are decent songs. And Never Let Me Down has virtually nothing worthwhile. But, all in all, not a bad list. Cheers.
Honestly, I really enjoy Tonight, but I see what you mean. There are really weak points.
Tonight is his worst, IMHO.
Never Let Me Down is underrated. I’ve been listening to it all week. Maybe I like it so much because I grew up in the 80s. I like all those rock songs at the end that you don’t
colemann76 that’s probably the only Bowie album I find almost impossible to listen to. Time Will Crawl is okay, and the title track. The rest is cringe. It’s his worst record in my eyes. I do find it cool that you like it though. Cheers
5tar5z tonight was weaker in my opinion. Can’t listen to it
What did you think of the 2018 remix?
@@whatsupbossanova Clearly weaker and more tired sounding. It only has 3 good songs
@@davideoakland Have not heard it
0:31 As a person who used the American education system to determine how good an album is….Great method
Really enjoyed your list. While I disagree with a lot, I’ll focus on how we wouldn’t have have “Low” in either of our top 10s. Or how “Outside” is great or how underrated “Earthling,” is. I heard it the first time this week and was blown away. Also, where would you rank “Buddha of Suburbia?” I love it and it gets better with every listen.
My personal favourite is low and i would say it is objectively his best.
Why’s it objectively his best?
YOUNg Geezerrr best production, most experimental, in my opinion best lyrics.
Bridges 42 yeah I hear u I agree
So you say it’s objectively his best, but every explanation is your opinion.
@@austinheinbuch8642 my mind changed, it’s now ziggy. Specifically cause of the strings on rock n roll suicide. I still say from an objective perspective, low is best.
I give the song Life on Mars 11 out of 10, but then it is my my all time favourite. For me it was all down hill after Scary Monsters, and all the later albums were just too weak. Strangers When We Meet was the anomaly being absolutely brilliant, and Where Are We Now was the best last song for me. I would rate the LP Young Americans far higher than you, above Station taking the albums as whole works. Very interesting any way.
All downhill after Scary Monsters? Far from it. Heathen, Hours, Blackstar all brilliant albums, plus more. I'm guessing that you're not 'totally' familiar with all of the albums after Scary Monsters (and I do mean totally familiar to be in a position to judge). I feel the same about Life On Mars, probably my favorite song of all time. I highly recommend giving any of the 3 albums above at least 10 plays.
Only 6 for Stay on Station To Station.
Oh well, each to his own.
This is a 9 in my world all day long.
Why do you score under Ambient and Progressive Electronica songs? Those songs have a super ambitious structure and composition! My God, what little idea of music do you have?
i can't understand this ranking. *low* is my favourite album.
Hunky Dory so low on list ?
funny, loving the alien, is among others, my favourite
hours...is fantastic
When you don’t get the brilliance of ‘Low’ you cannot be taken seriously.
Stfu, actually listen to what he says. He would have put it higher, but he’s going with his numbers
Austin Heinbuch his numbers are wrong lmao. The ambient music was revolutionary for Bowie.
John Stewart Except he’s not going by revolutionary, he’s going by the goodness of the music. They’re super cool sounds but music wise not that good.
Great video. Overall I think your system did a pretty good job of placing the bulk of albums in more or less the right place. Two objections however.
1. Low is too low. I feel you were a little tough in Side 2.
2. Reality....in my opinion a universally underrated album.
I don't think he's much of a fan of instrumentals which personally I Don't agree because the instrumentals are AMAZINGGG
Not to nitpick but heathen was in 2002 not 2013
Hours is one of the best after Scary Monsters.
Let’s dance is an amazing album
Aladdin Sane
The Man
Lodger
My top 3 fave
hunky dory hard to beat
Loving the alien is one od bowies best songs, how the hell only 5?
how is let's dance so low on the list??
That 5 rating on Win hurtttt
Yes. 7 for me
Low so low? Although agree with one and two spots.
low on 18th is just disrespectful