Twin Peaks The Return: 1 Year Later

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 июл 2024
  • It’s been 1 year since we returned to the world of Twin Peaks created by David Lynch and Mark Frost. Greg and Ryan celebrate the anniversary of Twin Peaks: The Return by taking a look back at all the new information that’s come out after the season finale; specifically from the final dossier.
    Tweet to Greg & Ryan about Twin Peaks!
    Greg - / gregft155
    Ryan - / anvilone
    Subscribe to GameSpot Universe! ruclips.net/user/GameSpotUniverse?s...
    Follow Us - / gsuniverse
    Like Us - / gamespotuniverse
    www.gamespot.com
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 351

  • @rini6
    @rini6 5 лет назад +25

    It’s another year later and I’m rewatching and reading Lynch’s new book, which is an autobiography.
    My favorite scene is the typical fan favorite where Dale “wakes up” and says, “I am the FBI.” I do like the scene in which the Mitchum brothers talk about the dream Bradley had about Cooper (Jones) giving them a cherry pie and then it is a cherry pie in the box. Seeing the unexpected warm turn of events and a new side to the Mitchum brothers melted my heart. It ended with the disheveled homeless looking older woman reuniting with her son and getting her life back and that beautiful Angelo Badalamenti song on the piano. It was perfect.

  • @AlmostAnimixers
    @AlmostAnimixers 6 лет назад +224

    The thing about the show that's changed the most for me over the year is that, when it first aired, I really loved Part 8. Now, a year later, I really really love Part 8.

    • @jakek1735
      @jakek1735 6 лет назад +11

      Now that it's been a year is it finally okay to just call Part 8 one of Lynch's most important works? Because it is, and I don't feel like it was ever too early to say that.

    • @AlmostAnimixers
      @AlmostAnimixers 6 лет назад +8

      More than that. I think it was one of the most important pieces of television in recent history. It really shows just how far you can go with the medium. That's true for the entire show, but part 8 in particular.

    • @travisspazz1624
      @travisspazz1624 6 лет назад +4

      I swear to God if Lynch doesn't get nominated for best director at the Emmys this year!!

    • @michalslatina8004
      @michalslatina8004 6 лет назад +2

      U R not alone! Ep.8 is regulary Lynch´s next movie after Inland Empire. That´s for sure. In that episode Lynch briliantly combined Eraserhead style with Inland Empire style. And few others...

    • @zepter00
      @zepter00 6 лет назад

      Nick Ferrazza I took something from twin Peaks to the my production. Maybe you check it. ruclips.net/video/Y0GCIaepUII/видео.html

  • @Joemamashouse69
    @Joemamashouse69 4 года назад +24

    note to self: don't try to capture the ultimate evil in a glass box.

  • @Qwazin
    @Qwazin 6 лет назад +45

    No no no please no spin-offs. A large part of the charm with The Return to me was that it non-stop took us into unexpected territory by constantly re-inventing old characters and introducing new ones to the point where you never knew where anything was going. Let's not dwell on them. If it continues it has to be Season 4. Let's move forward.

    • @DethronerX
      @DethronerX 5 лет назад

      only if spin-offs eventually meet as Twin Peaks in the last episodes : D

  • @mattstefon4878
    @mattstefon4878 6 лет назад +12

    *spoiler*
    Eight-thirty am isn’t the anniversary of Annie’s kidnapping: it’s the anniversary of Evil Coop waking up and asking “How’s Annie?”

  • @danielplainview2584
    @danielplainview2584 6 лет назад +28

    Another hint that would support the idea that the Roadhouse sequences are part of Audrey's psyche and Audrey is in a mental institution is that Nine Inch Nails play a song literally titled "She's Gone Away".

    • @danielplainview2584
      @danielplainview2584 6 лет назад +1

      I think the Roadhouse sequences with all the minor characters are part of that, while the whole James/Freddie ordeal has, at least relatively speaking, real world ramifications in the storyline.

  • @SirGeeeO
    @SirGeeeO 6 лет назад +56

    I look at Dale and Laura's reaction as their minds sort of snapping at the influx of new memories mixing with the old memories after changing the timeline. Laura relived her death and Dale just gained a ton of new memories from the last 25 years

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 6 лет назад +8

      They're not in Kansas anymore, that's for sure.

  • @AlmostAnimixers
    @AlmostAnimixers 6 лет назад +56

    Has it really been a year? Wow. I've missed you've guys talking about Twin Peaks. I've been watching Greg talking about Legion (the closest any show will come to filling the Twin Peaks shaped hole in my heart), but I haven't seen Ryan since Twin Peaks ended. Good to see you guys back together talking about the awesomeness that is Twin Peaks.

    • @marian3nene45
      @marian3nene45 6 лет назад +1

      Nick Ferrazza that's because Ryan was stuck in the Black Lodge. 😉

    • @Mariangela2035
      @Mariangela2035 6 лет назад +1

      Check out Dark on Netflix

  • @thevulgarone4
    @thevulgarone4 5 лет назад +6

    Isn't it strange that Micheal Jackson's "Smooth Criminal" asked if Annie is ok and Annie replies every year "I'm fine".

  • @phadde
    @phadde 6 лет назад +67

    Wally Brando-centric is the only way fwd for the show.

  • @CrashHell
    @CrashHell 6 лет назад +42

    Annie says "I'm fine." at 8:38 am every day because that is the exact point when Evil Coop busts his head open while brushing his teeth saying "How's Annie?". Did you guys really read the book?

  • @DanielBurapavong
    @DanielBurapavong 6 лет назад +10

    So glad you guys came back and made this. It was like David Lynch and the cast coming back and making Twin Peaks: The Return.

  • @Funktaro5
    @Funktaro5 6 лет назад +52

    Your Twin Peaks reviews are the only reason I'm subscribed to this channel, so this is nice to see.

  • @srRaxel
    @srRaxel 6 лет назад +125

    I miss the weekly ritual of see the episode, don't understand a shit, watch your videos and talk about them with my roomia and people in fan pages

    • @YSOFTWARE
      @YSOFTWARE 6 лет назад +4

      try watching Legion, it gives me similar feelings

    • @_chris96_
      @_chris96_ 6 лет назад

      Ярослав Ерохин 😃☺

    • @Kazekoge101
      @Kazekoge101 6 лет назад

      Lol, same here the RUclipsrs analyzing it are more than half the fun.

    • @samstone011995
      @samstone011995 6 лет назад

      Ярослав Ерохин yes (da)

  • @justinplayfair4638
    @justinplayfair4638 6 лет назад +31

    Greg, Ryan, your Return reviews were some of my favorite RUclips things ever...thanks for the great memories!

  • @JediBunny
    @JediBunny 6 лет назад +9

    I miss Twin Peaks and all things Lynchian in my life so much... but this was yet another great video from you guys and filled the void a little for now! Thank you for great work as always :) let’s keep our fingers crossed for more Lynch television and/or film sometime in the reasonably near future...

  • @happyclam1266
    @happyclam1266 6 лет назад +15

    The Audrey scenes have grown on me this year, and the roadhouse conversations seem less jarring and more meaningful. The whole series seems more perfect now that I'm not scrambling around trying to figure out what the plot is.

  • @glitchy000
    @glitchy000 6 лет назад +4

    "I'm fine," is Annie's direct response to the lasting question: "How's Annie?"
    Also interesting to note: If you defeat your shadow-self, the Dweller on the Threshold, don't you cross over into The White Lodge (or something to that effect)? Crossing the threshold... after Cooper destroys his shadow-self.

  • @davidburney6480
    @davidburney6480 6 лет назад +2

    Strong work as always Greg and Ryan. The first image we see in Twin Peaks is Dr. Jacoby getting the shovels, and then pay off of this is getting Ed and Norma together. It took a while but brilliant!!!

  • @Picopunk3
    @Picopunk3 6 лет назад +28

    Random theory: Judy being Sarah and Bob being Leland had a child Laura (the devil.) The nuke allowed the black lodge realm to permeate our own by first pumping out gases into the trees of twin peaks (photosynthesis), secondly spreading through fire and later spreading through electricity. The influence of the lodge also used the moth-frogs in order to hollow out the people of our world so they could be used to facilitate incoming lodge entities e.g. Judy. When Laura was taken into the lodge by wearing the ring her consciousness began to permeated the town of twin peaks in order to facilitate a collective suffering. Therefore they are all in a way living inside her dream. Once coop reversed her death her consciousness stopped permeating twin peaks. We see this as I believe Lynch shows us both realms of existence, one where Laura died in which some characters suffer and one where her consciousness doesn't permeate the town and characters are happy e.g. Norma, Dr Jacoby. In order for the fireman to defeat Judy he placed a Tulpa of Laura (the orb) into an alternative plain of existence. As time progresses in this Odessa reality (which I believe is also Laura's dream) the influence of Laura's conciseness becomes stronger as she slowly begins to become aware of her past life of pain and suffering. Cooper has unwanted sex with Diane to speed the process along bringing back her memory's of being raped by her father. When her past is finally confirmed the reality of who she is 'ends the world.' Or at least ends her consciousness/dream. As her dream ends the lodge has nothing to filter it's power through. Because she's only a Tulpa she disintegrates much like Diane's Tupla does when she realises what she is. All the negative energy is destroyed. The fireman needed cooper for her to remember. He sacrificed himself for the greater good. Judy and Bob only really exist in the mind of Laura so she can repress the reality that she was raped by her father while her mother acted ambivalent to her abuse (the horse is the white of the eyes.) No Laura, no Laura's dream, no evil. BUT what's real and what's not is kinda a never ending question.

    • @benhasglasses
      @benhasglasses 6 лет назад +5

      This theory makes way too much sense.

    • @ShoutingAtHam
      @ShoutingAtHam 6 лет назад +2

      That's pretty good.

    • @marian3nene45
      @marian3nene45 6 лет назад

      THIS.
      IS.
      AMAZING. 🙌🙌🙌

    • @mariahpiesse4632
      @mariahpiesse4632 6 лет назад +2

      wow, this is amazing. but i dont know if twin peaks story is meant to make scense at all

    • @ZeroTheKnifer
      @ZeroTheKnifer 6 лет назад

      Interpretation is relatively open but there is evidence to shut this theory down in Mark Frosts books

  • @goldenarm009
    @goldenarm009 6 лет назад +14

    oh the happiness i felt when i saw this video in my feed. yessss

  • @daanimus
    @daanimus 6 лет назад +3

    If there is a season 4, will you two come to my viewing party? You were an essential part of The Return, and a delightful cherry atop each sundae episode.

  • @dawngrrrl
    @dawngrrrl 6 лет назад +19

    YAS! Thank you guys. Crazy it's already been a year. Still one of the greatest series of all time and still fascinating and bewildering. I haven't read The Final Dossier yet but this made me more excited to dig into it. Now all my favorite moments are rushing back to me and I'm emotional 😂

    • @DavidWKimber
      @DavidWKimber 6 лет назад +3

      Final Dossier will spin your head around. I've heard that the audio book version is even better, but I like having the hard copy with the way it's put together.

    • @dawngrrrl
      @dawngrrrl 6 лет назад

      David Kimber Awesome 👍 I'd rather have the hard copy too for the same reason.

    • @Bradley25
      @Bradley25 6 лет назад

      I listened to the audio book version. not sure why but I feel like I’d just absorb it better that way, was very enjoyable though

  • @TrueRennard
    @TrueRennard 6 лет назад +6

    I miss both Twin Peaks and watching your videos each week trying to figure out what was the episode about.

  • @marian3nene45
    @marian3nene45 6 лет назад +1

    I have absolutely missed your TP recaps. 😥
    subbed to you guys when you started doing TP-The Return..and I'M STILL HERE.
    ...
    Y'all SAVED ME from the Black Lodge with your other psyche mind-fraks about Legion...I've missed ya blokes! Whatever video you choose to do about TP (or Legion)...I'll be here. Cheers! 😉

  • @thepuresh5671
    @thepuresh5671 6 лет назад +7

    I really wanted to know if your theories on the ending have chanced since the last video. Anyways I was so happy to see you two again talking about Twin Peaks. I really loved the breakdowns!

  • @joey4track
    @joey4track 6 лет назад

    What a brilliant series, and one of the best seasons of any television show. And I totally missed your videos guys! It was great to go along on the trip with you two blokes.

  • @Tina37212
    @Tina37212 6 лет назад

    WOW!!! So good to see you guys again! Thanks so much for taking me back to Twin Peaks!!

  • @rogeriocardosobulhoes4513
    @rogeriocardosobulhoes4513 6 лет назад +5

    The best TV show ever. And you, guys, helped me to understand lots of hidden things. Thank you!!!

  • @nancykillsyou
    @nancykillsyou 6 лет назад +1

    That WAS Cooper, but it was from the timeline he had altered. The one where Laura had gone “missing.”

  • @JeremyRatzlaff
    @JeremyRatzlaff 6 лет назад

    I cheered so hard when I saw this pop on recommended! You guys were such an integral part of this strange adventure we all went on a year ago. Thank you.

  • @motkirby8806
    @motkirby8806 6 лет назад +1

    When Tulpa Diane revealed that Janey-E was her half sister, my jaw dropped to the ground. David Lynch and Mark Frost never went further with that revelation. I was sure hoping we’d get more detail but instead we got that ten minute sweeping scene. If we get a Season 4, I really want that reunion with the half sisters! David Lynch's top two leading ladies...Naomi Watts and Laura Dern in a Twin Peaks catfight. How exciting!

  • @austinyoung4675
    @austinyoung4675 4 года назад +2

    So, Audrey’s Billy is the drunk guy in the cell dripping blood from his mouth.
    We get that confirmed in one of the road house scenes.
    Which then makes if harder for me to accept all of her scenes and a few of the roadhouse scenes are in her head.

  • @CR3271
    @CR3271 6 лет назад +5

    12:43 -- That will never happen. You're thinking too mainstream, corporate television. If there's one thing you should have learned from this season, it's that Lynch despises main stream. That's why there was such a mixed reaction to season 3 in the first place. A certain portion of TP fandom was accustomed only to the network-controlled original series and not Lynch's larger body of work.

  • @elongatedmusket7430
    @elongatedmusket7430 6 лет назад +1

    Glad to see you guys! Episode 8 changed my world as much as the original series. It was Art, horror, love and the unknown. I watched it a second time immediately because it was so heavy.
    I feel like Laura was sent to this world with a Purpose. To find Bob and flush him out, contest him, something. And that she did! Had Leland not became the predator he was with Laura, Bob might have lurked about further. But if that is the case, Cooper had to save her with some purpose. And maybe when he did, and they salvaged the time line, both Coop and Laura was sent elsewhere. Their memories may not have left Coop, but their identities did - in a new parallel. If there is another TP Series, perhaps it will be those two....Laura finding out why she was frightened at "this house".....Cooper finding out what reality he is in.......and where it leads them both....with other cast members in their new perspective.

  • @thedrewsephYT
    @thedrewsephYT 6 лет назад +1

    Miss seeing you two dudes weekly to dissect episodes of this amazing SHOW. This was not a movie, totally a series. Oh how I love Twin Peaks. So many questions, so little time.

  • @timmoore173
    @timmoore173 5 лет назад

    This show means so much more to me than I can say. I re watched the return again recently and it still had such an impact

  • @msbookgal
    @msbookgal 6 лет назад

    What a summer last year was with Twin Peaks The Return. Thanks you for revisiting it with this video.

  • @camdenferrell8074
    @camdenferrell8074 6 лет назад +24

    Twin Peaks: The Return is a television show. Even if it was conceptualized as an 18-hour film, Lynch still had to ability to arrange scenes to work in 1 hour increments. The fact that most episodes close with a roadhouse performance pretty much establishes it as a television show.

  • @thermionic1234567
    @thermionic1234567 5 лет назад +3

    It was a long scene, but “Green Onions” made it worthwhile.

    • @jamnmikefx
      @jamnmikefx 4 года назад

      Never realised now long the scene was because I was jamming to Booker T

  • @DavidWKimber
    @DavidWKimber 6 лет назад +25

    Season 3 will be studied and debated for years to come.
    Highlights for me:
    Ep 8
    All scenes with Audrey and the little dude
    All scenes with the Giant
    All Vegas scenes
    Both Frost books
    The scene with the sick kid in the car in Twin Peaks (haunts me to this day)
    Andy
    Cooper waking up
    All Roadhouse scenes
    Final episode
    A third viewing is impending once I finish re-watching all of The Office.

    • @DavidWKimber
      @DavidWKimber 6 лет назад +2

      Also, gotta' light?

    • @Bean31600
      @Bean31600 6 лет назад

      David Kimber the scene we whattt is hapenninggg! Wee are late! She is sick! Haha that shit cracked me up until the kid starts puking then im like bobby wtff?

    • @MackofejFTW
      @MackofejFTW 5 лет назад

      Hmm I really liked dougie jones too 😀

  • @kool_thing
    @kool_thing 4 года назад +2

    Cahiers du Cinéma considers The Return a film. And the best one of the Decade. The French just love Lynch

  • @ria_x_rose
    @ria_x_rose 6 лет назад +2

    Honestly in true Lynch fashion i expected you guys to play out the full 2 and a half mins of sweeping the roadhouse😂.
    If i had to say what my all time favourite scene of The Return is it would hands down be the moment that Bobby sees Laura's picture for the first time in 25 years. Nothing will ever touch my heart more than that scene.😢❤
    For me looking back at it a year later one of the most memorable scenes to me is when Mr.C says Goodbye to Richard. I found that even though Richard was meant to be the second antagonist that his entire storyline (including Audrey's) was one of the most tragic especially since everything he had done up till that point was psycopathic and yet i still felt sorry for him.
    The Return was a true dream come true and although i found myself lost in all the timelines and theories i will forever be grateful for the journey that Frost and Lynch were able to provide us. The community is what really made the entire experience just that more worth the wait. Even if we never get all the answers we want i am completely satisfied with they way things have gone and i will still be 100% supportive if/when the story continues...even its a book😂❤

  • @giancarlodr.iodice1701
    @giancarlodr.iodice1701 6 лет назад +1

    An incredible enjoyable twisting out of the box voyage, really loved loving the beloved ones who shared the experience... Love Legion

  • @paulberry2884
    @paulberry2884 6 лет назад +5

    I thought a great alternative story would be about Jack Parsons, one of the great untold stories of the 20th century, which is featured in The Secret History. Parsons was a central figure in the nuclear tests that brought forth Babalon (Judy) and attempted to summon the devil through the means of sex magick. But it seems that Ridley Scott has a mini-series on Parsons coming out in June.

  • @fernandogarajalde4066
    @fernandogarajalde4066 6 лет назад +2

    I hardly got any sleep yesterday thanks to the Showtime marathon on two (yes, two) channels. No regrets, because I noticed so many things I missed since seeing this last year. I hope someone throws Lynch, Frost and Mac a boatload of bucks to do this again before I die.

  • @jeffha4057
    @jeffha4057 6 лет назад

    Outstanding summary of what has transpired since the end of The Return. Great video!

  • @Hessed3712
    @Hessed3712 6 лет назад

    This is such a great show. I did not have to wait 25 years to see the final season but I was on the edge of my seat waiting for it once I did watch the original Twin Peaks. Please do another season.....soon.

  • @brianchidester3334
    @brianchidester3334 6 лет назад +5

    Favorite scene was when Norma and Ed finally got together. Favorite current one is in the same episode: the scene, or series of scenes, where Mr. C. goes into the Convenient Store and visits Phillip Jeffries. The way it toggles at one point between the hallway and the forest is exactly what I always loved about "Twin Peaks," the penchant it has for existing in interval states, dream-states, between two worlds. I was at the edge of my seat for that scene when recently re-watching.

  • @modecom
    @modecom 6 лет назад +4

    I've really missed you two.

  • @kenbibi7631
    @kenbibi7631 6 лет назад +6

    Twin Peaks saga is very Gnostic in nature, Lynch Frost could be very much into the esoteric knowledge the way I see it... The Owl, The Lodge, The Divine Feminity and the whole concept of the world as an apparition in contrast to matter... Time isn't linear...

  • @Joi2049
    @Joi2049 5 лет назад +1

    really random, but the scene of amanda seyfried riding the car high out of her mind really sticks out for me. everything about that shot, from how the camera moves, the lighting, the symbolism.

  • @Stupoider
    @Stupoider 6 лет назад

    It was a hell of a ride, was a pleasure to experience it with all of you

  • @catalina9844
    @catalina9844 5 лет назад +2

    Can you take a deep dive in to twin peaks? Like a once a week deal? I love when you two talk about the tp universe.

  • @lenadillinger4873
    @lenadillinger4873 6 лет назад

    My favourite scene is the restaurant sequence with Angelo Badalamenti playing the piano, and the cherry pie... It is SO cozy!

  • @Brandon_Powell
    @Brandon_Powell 6 лет назад +17

    I don't think Odessa was a different timeline or reality and I don't think Cooper was literally Richard. I believe Cooper and Diane's plan was to summon Judy so Cooper could enter her dream where she was hiding Laura Palmer. I think the reason he and everything else seems so different was because it was a dream. I also disagree with the argument that he failed. The whole thing felt to me like a nightmare that is so bad your mind tells you that you're dreaming. Just before he asks what year is this you can hear the same sound The Giant / Fireman told him to listen to in the first episode of the season. This made Cooper realize that Judy had tricked him and prompted him to say the one thing he needed to in order to make Laura remember that she was Laura as represented by her screaming after hearing her mother's voice. This acknowledgement is what killed Judy or at the very least separated her from Sarah Palmer as represented by the lights going out in the house. I believe the lights going out in the rest of the world represented the dream ending. I don't want to put words in anybody's mouth or misrepresent their intentions but I believe when David Lynch refers to this as the end he is just talking about this incarnation of Twin Peaks. I believe David Lynch regards all incarnations of Twin Peaks as separate. The end of season 2 could be considered an ending as well as the end of fire walk with me. Keeping this in mind I think a fourth season is all but guaranteed.

    • @Bean31600
      @Bean31600 6 лет назад +1

      Brandon Powell i like thid theory the most that ive heard so far.

    • @Brandon_Powell
      @Brandon_Powell 6 лет назад

      Don Birnam Thanks. Glad to hear it.

    • @celiaguillen7338
      @celiaguillen7338 4 года назад

      what do you mean bu saying "separated her from Sarah Palmer"? Why do you think Judy was hiding Laura?

  • @4021971
    @4021971 6 лет назад +1

    The final scene with Richard and Carrie is my favorite scene from the return.

  • @bbearsmama
    @bbearsmama 6 лет назад +1

    Oh man-I so miss this show! It qualifies as a television show, imo. Kyle Maclachlan was pure greatness portraying so many characters. I LOVE the idea of continuing the series (or creating a spin-off) it but more with Frost focusing on the storytelling.

  • @shmendri
    @shmendri 6 лет назад +1

    0:47 This clip says everything about cinema. Thanks David.

  • @AoiKyuuketsuki
    @AoiKyuuketsuki 5 лет назад +11

    well, i just finished watching the return last week so i haven't had time to ruminate over the show like others have, but one thing that really gnaws at me (which i've seen no one else bring up) is bob's demise in part 17 (i'm just going to assume he's dead and won't come back).
    the way he went out felt very anticlimatic and almost disrespectful to the original twin peaks, in my opinion. bob was such a central and integral piece of the original twin peaks mythos and i feel like it would've been a lot more thematically coherent if his ending had something to do with that as well. the fact that his death came at the hands of a deus ex machina character that had nothing to do with the original show and that had just been introduced a couple of episodes earlier disappointed me a lot and left me with a feeling of "that's it?".
    i know that there had to be a reason behind this decision of course, i just don't know if i agree with it. i'm more or less fine with the ending of part 18 and all the other stuff that transpired in the finale that felt like they were taking twin peaks "beyond" what the original was, but i felt like they should've let bob's death signify the end of the first chapter of twin peaks by actually making it feel like it was connected to the original series.

  • @seven3962
    @seven3962 6 лет назад

    wow greg and ryan wow, this made my day. i recently watched all your twin peaks videos because the return has been on my mind, originally i wanted more but i think i’ve come around to appreciating it even though i still feel there was too much filler and unnecessary characters but it was amazing to experience in real time. i am with greg*, it’s a show not a film so no oscar snub imo but i hope they get some love from the emmys and kyle should’ve won the globe. please discuss lynch more if possible maybe discuss some of his films

  • @wesleyratko7830
    @wesleyratko7830 6 лет назад +2

    Missed you guys!

  • @Picopunk3
    @Picopunk3 6 лет назад +1

    I also really like the theory that Odessa is actually Sarah's dream and cooper travels there in order to expell Judy's influence over Sarah. Sarah tries to repress the memory of her daughter by drinking when she should be facing responsibility for ignoring Leland's abuse. By triggering the Laura tulpa from Carrie to laura Sarah finally confronts the memory of her daughter and finally receives closure. She is finally at peace and Judy's influence has been vanquished.

  • @HarriboJones
    @HarriboJones 6 лет назад +1

    Well, I think the first scene in the whole of the return with coop and the fireman chronologically takes place after the final scene. Judy is dead, trapped in their house now - the fireman prompts Cooper to remember Richard and Linda etc, and cooper does as he's just witnessed that. Then cooper fades away just as Laura did when she was on the shore, as if Judy is killed and Laura was saved, Cooper would never be in the lodge in the first place. Just how I read it

    • @silencio1234
      @silencio1234 3 года назад

      This is an amazing way of looking at the first scene. I am going to rewatch and keep this in mind

  • @amphitheatre
    @amphitheatre 6 лет назад +5

    still one of my favorite shows ever. unsure if i'd want more. i think this culture of explanation and closure that we have now would color my perception of a 4th season after this, especially since the return was everything i love about a good mystery story. if he did a s4 i'd have to think it was because people nagged him about wanting a 'real ending, man'.

    • @Funktaro5
      @Funktaro5 6 лет назад

      You really think David Lynch cares that much about what people want? If so, it's hard to explain his entire career.

    • @milton7763
      @milton7763 6 лет назад +1

      Agree with most of what you say, except your remark that "this culture of explanation and closure that we have no". The US has always had that culture and only in recent years is its movie and tv industry opening up to less linear storytelling, more ambiguous endings and symbolism. Things that have been a lot more common in Middle Eastern and Asian cultures for instance.

  • @watertommyz
    @watertommyz 4 года назад +2

    Twin Peaks The Return is a show about whether or not Twin Peaks should have been revived at all.

  • @cattathat
    @cattathat 6 лет назад

    Loved it!!! YES episode 8 is my favorite. One of The Best tv shows in decades. Seriously it should be shown in theater!!! ❤️

  • @bryanmolina8629
    @bryanmolina8629 6 лет назад +18

    Just really wanted more agent cooper . The books a bit slow for me .

  • @icowrich
    @icowrich 5 лет назад +1

    If the log talks to the Log Lady (and maybe soon to Hawk), then does that mean that the ringing at the Great Northern might be Josie trying to speak to Ben and/or Beverly?

  • @leifharmsen
    @leifharmsen 6 лет назад

    Thanks guys. Good analysis, creative ideas.
    It was a telemovie-series. You can't apply the old categories to our culture's new binge-watchable series format which is as high resolution as a movie but is much much longer. Heck, didn't Twin Peaks invent this format? Dallas hinted at it, but Twin Peaks actually ran on it. Technology caught up with it and it proliferated. Twin Peaks deserves an award just for that. Soaps don't count because they require amnesia, not memory.

  • @PhilHeesen
    @PhilHeesen 6 лет назад

    Thank you for doing this video!

  • @NeverSaySandwich1
    @NeverSaySandwich1 6 лет назад +2

    Still one of the greatest tv seasons of all time

  • @behemothbear
    @behemothbear 6 лет назад +6

    4:24 Nah, I still think she's trapped in the wood of the real Roadhouse.

  • @howsannie4675
    @howsannie4675 5 лет назад +1

    Emmys & Oscars : two birds one stone. 🏆

  • @sounakbanik3087
    @sounakbanik3087 6 лет назад +3

    I've missed you guys. It's been a year?? Wow

  • @Panyc333
    @Panyc333 6 лет назад +2

    To anyone I recommend watching season 3 I also recommend these videos as a compendium.

  • @phunkym8
    @phunkym8 3 года назад

    favourite scene is the french woman taking her sweet time while gordon cole smiles from ear to ear

  • @SuzyBriseno
    @SuzyBriseno 6 лет назад

    The Return has stayed with me throughout the year, although the ending broke my heart. I so enjoyed your breakdown and looked forward to it each week. Among others, I miss Mr. C. and his evil son, Lucy and Andy, Hawk and Margaret, Jane-E, The Woodsman and Candy, Mandy and Sandy. Funny, but I was thinking of them today, for some reason. Saw Legion the other night and thought it was trying but failing to be another Twin Peaks.

  • @lacotufaradioactiva
    @lacotufaradioactiva 6 лет назад +1

    I suscribes becase of you two. Loved "the return", i wish u 2 do more content together!

  • @skewerthis1234
    @skewerthis1234 6 лет назад +3

    You know if someone could edit the return with more of the music from the original series it would be perfect. The scenes from the return definitely feel a little quiet and awkward at times, so if there was that iconic twin peaks music, it would feel better.

    • @JakeTheSnake1337
      @JakeTheSnake1337 3 года назад

      idk if it's late or not, but there is a fan edited version of the return with more of original music and shortened scenes. It's like 9 episodes now, but you can't get it legally anywhere, only pirated version

  • @joeyjeffrey5892
    @joeyjeffrey5892 6 лет назад

    I still think about this season every day.

  • @TinyKittenKisses
    @TinyKittenKisses 6 лет назад

    The thumbnails of these gamespot videos were what got me into watching all twin peaks, every week i found them so weird, that i started the show and it was all worth it. Then when i catched on with the episodes i watched these each week after the new episode

  • @WeWereOnline
    @WeWereOnline 6 лет назад +4

    the golden shovel painting

  • @peterfitzgerald5077
    @peterfitzgerald5077 6 лет назад +5

    Greg and Ryan! Nice 💪

  • @GaryALucas
    @GaryALucas 6 лет назад +1

    I was puzzled when 'Richard' introduced himself to Ms. Tremond as Cooper.
    I thought that may have had something to do with the Fireman's decision to remove or alter the timeline, or whatever he did there. It did also seem that Carrie Page having a fragment of memory of the other timeline also had it's effect. What do they say? Deux ex machina.
    Was that Diane at the motel entrance spying on Richard and Linda? Was that her or Linda following Richard and Carrie on the way to Twin Peaks?
    My favorite scenes were when the Blue Rose task force visits Buckhorn and bring Hastings to the entrance of The Zone, and the bit with the Woodsman.
    I thought right away after Audrey's Dance that she was in an asylum and Charlie was the dream version of her analyst. I also thought this was probably inspired by the 1984 David Bowie video 'Loving The Alien' in which the inmate dreams and wakes suddenly at the end, very similar. I'd bet Lynch remembered that, maybe unconsciously.
    I doubt there will be Season 4, but I wouldn't be surprised if Frost writes another book or so, belying 'The Final Dossier'. After all that was Agent Preston's version, so that might be what is meant by final. And there are several loose ends, to say the least. But then at least Lynch likes that.
    Thanks to you both for the astute analysis, I found the most incisive of the ones I saw, and rather funny as well. cheers :/

  • @Bradley25
    @Bradley25 6 лет назад +1

    At the final scene Laura starts screaming after being asked what year it is, when Phillip Jeffries appeared at the FBI office out of nowhere he was also said to freak out when asked what year it is. I’m wondering if there is any correlation?

  • @epictoycinema7828
    @epictoycinema7828 6 лет назад +1

    I missed you guys

  • @svens8674
    @svens8674 5 лет назад

    So glad you threw in the Lynch behind the scenes video. xD

  • @speedmaster123456789
    @speedmaster123456789 6 лет назад +3

    We need season 4... :(

  • @MelodyYoung
    @MelodyYoung 4 года назад

    Random thought but Gordon has a dream where he is asked "Who is the dreamer?" and it's also revealed towards the end that a pretty big chunk of the story ( at least some of the Roadhouse scenes ) are actually taking place inside of Audrey's mind.
    This is just a random thought, I haven't dwelled on it enough to build any kind of theory around, but I thought it was worth mentioning.

  • @martynkentfrancis
    @martynkentfrancis 6 лет назад

    The best analysis / breakdown of TP Season 3, bar none 👍 good job

  • @eleni1968
    @eleni1968 6 лет назад

    THere is another shot of the cube when Cooper appears the same couple reappear and are about to have the same encounter for the first time; its the parallel universe: Dale /Richard & Diane/Linda

  • @StarryEyedCece
    @StarryEyedCece 6 лет назад

    Yay! Missed you guys!

  • @kenmcauliffe3028
    @kenmcauliffe3028 6 лет назад

    Wow, I have missed you two!

  • @saullyons8626
    @saullyons8626 5 лет назад

    Awesome video. Thanks for your thoughts! BTW where did you find that awesome twin peaks t shirt???

  • @NewjerseyFan
    @NewjerseyFan 6 лет назад +3

    Dougie goes to the Casino and plays the Slot Machines and screams HellloooooOOOOOooooo and wins everytime and the old homeless like woman ends up claiming some of that money if i recall it showed her in a later episode looking well off then what she was at the Casino the first time around.
    Dougie Scenes were my Favorite.
    The Sweeping Scene was great
    Jim Belushi and the other guy who are brothers ( crime lords ) were fun too watch
    Bobby reacting to Laura's Photo
    the opening scene with Cooper and the Fireman.
    the scenes with the fireman
    all the Scenes with Agent Albert ( R.I.P )
    This Is The Water, And This Is The Well, Drink Full And Ascend, The Horse IS White In The Eyes And Dark Within scene
    Cooper traveling the dimensions or other worlds before becoming " Dougie "
    Cooper coming too at the Hospital
    Dougie/Cooper taking out the hitman for police to take away
    Cooper seeing Laura Palmer again in the Lodge
    Andy, Hawk looking for what's missing on the table and Andy's Woman ( i forget her name that bugs me ) says she ate a piece of chocolate so that was missing
    Audrey's Dance
    I would love too see a season 4. but if they don't do it. i can understand it would take a long time too make. I just love this world so much

  • @peccavo
    @peccavo 5 лет назад

    Audrey & the 9th Circle of Hell. I know in popular imagination Satan and Judas get a lot of play, but most of Dante's attention in the 9th century are to two people who hurt each other in life frozen together: Ugolino and Ruggieri. They are frozen up to their necks, and Ugolino is gnawing Ruggieri's head.
    I think it's a statement on how a bad marriage is like the 9th circle of hell, with two people locked in place, hating each other forever.

  • @yaloolah42
    @yaloolah42 4 года назад

    I had a dream last night, half-awake and half-asleep, pondering Twin Peaks.... and a very odd fate for Albert came to mind.
    Dale comes back, just showing up in that hotel room, and asks for Albert because he has some forensic stuff he needs gone over. Gordon tells him that Albert is gone, and they go through a typical drawn out "He was a great friend and man" scene.
    BUT THEN.... it turns out that he really meant "gone" and not dead because it turns out that Albert is now a three-legged coffee table in the Red Room. Cooper walks in, slowly as usual, then stops. He stares at the table and slowly breaks into a grin and says, "Hello, Albert." No reply from the table, but apparently it says something that only Dale can hear.
    And from then on out, every time someone's in the Red Room, before anything else happens, someone has to say in backwards-talk "aPoLogIEs In aDvaNCe fOr aLBerT."
    Because they can hear him too, and he's still just as sarcastic.
    And he can also move around.
    It happened in a dream, so it's true XD

  • @Funktaro5
    @Funktaro5 6 лет назад +4

    I haven't got to Let's Rock yet, but my rewatch of episode 8 totally gave me a whole new level of appreciation for it.
    Every scene I loved before I've loved even more in my rewatch Like the scene between Red and Richard Horne. Red's the one character that I really needed more of, and if another season ever happened I could see him playing a prominent role.

  • @RevolverLancelot
    @RevolverLancelot 6 лет назад +1

    Season four should be The Continuing Adventures of Douglas Jones.