The Making of Tamasha | Imtiaz Ali | Inside A Scene
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- In our second Inside A Scene with Imtiaz Ali, we ask him to take us behind one of our favourite scenes in Tamasha. In this scene, Ved and Tara (played by Ranbir Kapoor and Deepika Padukone) have an argument at a coffee shop. The scene is intense and as Ali describes it, 'shameful'. One of the scene's most distinct moments is the use of A R Rahman's stunning composition, Agar Tum Saath Ho sung by Alka Yagnik. Ali tells us about how the song went through four revisions before making it to the movie. To watch our other Inside A Scene with Imtiaz Ali from Jab We Met, click here: bit.ly/2r8QJMW
Have you subscribed to Film Companion Reviews yet? Join us here - bit.ly/FilmComp...
Visit us at filmcompanion.in
Do Like, Share, Comment & Subscribe to our channel.
Subscribe: bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Follow Us On:
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
The Film Companion is a web channel intended to promote Indian cinema through films review, interviews, discussions, video essays and analytical compilations. It is intended primarily for the purpose of encouraging informed discussions, criticism and review of cinema and towards such purpose the programs use short extracts of cinematograph films, sounds recording and photographic works. These clips and extracts are of a minimal nature and the use is not intended to interfere in any manner with their commercial exploitation of the compete work by the owners of the copyright. The use of works are in compliance with the fair dealing exception provided under Sec. 52 of the Copyright Act, and we asset our use of the works under the exception provided for criticism and review.
One of my favourite scenes! Acted so brilliantly ❤❤
Tried&Refused Productions. Love your channel
👍👍👍👍👍
Hey! Why don't you make a video on how beautiful this film was? That this was Bollywood's La La Land made in 2015. At least that way this movie will get a 8+ IMDb which it deserves.
Jammy Pants!
Aaquib Raza this is tamasha and only tamasha. Please don't call it bollywood's la la land or anything else
"We fear people who might see through us"
Very true❤
:)
I also get Fear
True said!😃
If there is one who do so, where is the fear... There is LOVE ALWAYS💕💕💕
The best thing he said in this video❤️
Tamasha fans are increasing Exponentially so Nothing Can stop Tamasha to be a Cult Film. Thank you Ranbir, Imtiaz and Deepika for this Masterpiece.
Abhimanyu Gunawat It s becoming a cult classic
No! Harry met sejal is a cult.😀😀
@@Rahul-hn1iq harry met sejal will grow on you like this one, watch it again, its very symbolic, though i agree its awfully edited.
you missed A R RAHMAN & ravi varman
Yeah absolutely
The magician decoding his magic
No one like him!
magician is perplexed by his own magic
myokable a true artist can never aware of his true potential, isn't it? 😉
hmm true ..
Agree
This scene and the lead into "agar tum sath ho" song was so hard hitting that it made me feel exposed, vulnerable and hurt all at the same time. #Tamasha is a psychological exposition of feelings and pain and maybe even the effect that certain people have upon us. But whatever it is, it is a masterpiece! I've found myself coming back to this sequence and song a lot many times and I've always been captivated by it. Good work cinema :)
My emotion for this movie and song, word by word! :)
wow i love your comment, describes perfectly how i have been feeling about this movie since its realease
Akbar Khalid it's still haunting...ranbir could have done better....but Deepika stole the scene...was more into the emotions...
I was sobbing when their heads went on the table. I couldn't believe how moved I was. Such an amazing film.
It is indeed a masterpiece. Utterly exceptional.
Man man man..... This was one of the most underrated movie of decade some just cause of Indian audiences movies like bodyguard, Chennai express etc becomes blockbuster and movies like tamasha struggle!
yeah it was a masterpiece.
ANMOL dude forget Chennai Exp and bodyguard, even cheap cinema like Juduwa2 and that trashy golmal sequal becomes a hit. Expect what kind of films that would prefered to be produced if that is the case.
its just that bollywood audience arent ready for such movies and then they bark like bollywood can never be able to touch the hollywood or shit.
aminaf6 can’t really call Golmaal sequel such as Golmaal 3 as trashy, both have their own audience, I loved Golmaal 3 but I also loved Tamasha and thought it was a masterpiece when I first saw it, it all depends on how you connect with the movie. To each to its own.
its because people want to be entertained. not everyone is up for an art or niche cinema. They just want to have a good time in the cinema with their entire family. Tamasha is a movie one can watch by himself and enjoy the lessons, cinematography etc. You cant force people into watching these movie, at the end of the day public watch what they want to watch even if its judwa2
Only those people will understand Tara's pain who have loved someone due to a certain quality but still wanting to love even if that quality no longer exists in him/her...Tamasha is a roller-coaster of philosophical emotions...Imtiaz at his best...
Agree with you
Trueee man.
Agreed
such an underrated movie
Tamasha is a masterpiece, one of the best all time films in hindi cinema. It was the first time I was disapointed in our audience, if you didnt understand it the first time then OK just give it a second chance. Most people couldnt understand the complexities Ved was going through and I wish they did, I wish people understood the hard hitting reality of how the society could trap a man and keep him from being his true self like being caged. If you really understood it could change your life. I remember going out of the theatre learning a lesson on how to live life and so did my little sister. If this was a hollywood flick it wouldve been humongous, movies like 'Black Swan' wouldve tanked if it was a bollywood movie.
aminaf6 so true. Same for me. Wish I watched it in theatre
what i felt is that the emotions and complexities that ved goes through are abstract and u can understand it or relate it to it only if you have gone through something similar
People who didn't understand the movie know nothing about life
My absolute favourite scene. That whole song sequence is so beautifully shot. Special kudos to the cinematographer. The gentle touch of Deepika on Ranbir's hair and his emotional collapse, it couldn't have been shown more beautifully by anyone.
Absolutely loved this scene ! Deepika was absolutely natural in this film ! One of her finest performances !
No other actress could have acted like Deepika acted in this scene. So much of depth and understanding of the character which translated on screen beautifully. She didn't used glycerin to cry, that speaks for itself how wonderfully and honestly she performed her craft.
Chal be. Tabu, radhika, kalki, konkana, nandita ko bhool jayein!
@@ashishilluminati He is obsessed deepika fan
@@ashishilluminati ik bruh! Bt deepika was good too! And dont be so edgy:)
Yet people say Deepika is a bad actress..dumbasses
Sure she knows how to cry😂😂😂😂
"main nahi jaane dungi" this line breaks my heart everytime... realising someone won't love me this much ever
😭😭😭😭😭
09:06 the way he sighs. Exactly!!! Exactly!!!!
He was about to break....🙂
Yassss
That sigh was so poignant, it truly felt like he was watching and feeling it like an audience instead of a creator showing off his creation. That sigh gave away how moved he is by that scene. I think he would’ve broke down a little but didn’t want to seem like he’s being dramatic or is boasting about his work.
I noticed the same!!
I was about to talk about that. He was about to break own at that point.
I pity those who don't like this gem of a film. It's a masterpiece, period.
No worry, those people didn't deserved the movie at very first place. They were just looking for a mellow dramatic love story. Hats off to IMTIAZ ALI !
.. That heavy sigh of breath and the kind of lump in throat expressions by Imtiaz while sharing his thoughts at 9:06 - 9:07. Hard to deny such emotions, even the maker himself could not escape the profound effect of the scene, as the music began to hum. Hats off to all those involved in bringing this emotionally moving scene to life !!!
I think the reason why so many of us loved this scene so much, is because the people who portrayed it had such a good handle on the complexity of the emotions here. They weren’t acting out vulnerability, they were vulnerable. The point about how sometimes you wish to push away the only people who understand you, because you’re scared of them being able to see through to the part of you that you’ve denied for so long. This is some real basal energy. And that’s what the audience connected to, I think. I could watch the entire film just for this sequence. It’s a brilliant performance by every person involved in the making of it, the actors, the director, the writer, the cinematographer, the composer, the editor, and everyone else. I don’t know what it is that the actors tapped into while playing this out, but it was almost overwhelmingly powerful. This entire scene is just... raw. The messy, desperate nature of human emotion, an absolute masterpiece- the film, and the scene.
Underrated masterpiece and that scene gave me goosebumps, chills and I couldn’t stop crying 😭💔 also the song is the perfect match!
We need more collaborations of Imtiaz, Ranbir and Deepika... I am glad I had watched the movie in the theatre! :)
Imtiaz Ali: If Ranbir Kapoor wouldn't have said yes to Tamasha, I wouldn't have made the film
RANBIR KAPOOR
Same shd go for deepika
I think its love for the people that makes us do gud things...the trueself of us can only be seen by people who understand us very well...and they are very few...
@@yogeshjog6072 yes Deepika-Ranbir chemistry made the movie even more classic
syed marwan truly Ranbir and deepika.. They have an awesome chemistry.
Now im all curious about the previous versions of agar tum sath ho. Imtiaz/Rahman should also release the other versions too.
Brood Tuber IKR!!!!!
Same
Sameeee!!!!
Irshad kamil recited the lyrics of that version in one of his interviews
@@vaibhavnaik1977 Share the link?
This scene will go down as one of the most cult scenes in history of Indian cinema! It carries the essence of Tamasha. Almost, everything about this confrontation is perfect leading up to the song. Deepika and Ranbir barring their soul and are as raw as one can be and then the soul stirring rahman composition taking it away from there backed by brilliant cinematography.
No one understands and shows the complexity of the human mind on celluloid better than Imtiaz Ali. A true jem!
aditya sen exactly.
I am impressed with your observation @aditya sen
Look at her, how perfect she is in her craft ..no doubt ,legendary❤️ .i don't understand y ppl r trying to pull her down with all this negative today...irony is that she is also self made and sweet passionate person who is amazing at her work...
Deepika channeled her true feelings for Ranbir during this scene. She loved him truly! A girl wouldn't get tattooed for a guy she was "just dating". She has got this kinda of love from Ranveer now. She deserves the deepest form of pure love. ♥
Yes.. true..i Thought the same👌
She poured down her feelings
She has more failed relationship than him , let's not put ranbir as guilty
She will never forget RK...
Deepika is nvr RKs type..RK is more of a grounded guy and they only fall for ppl with emotional depth. Period.
RK!!! The greatest actor of this modern era... And yes what about Tamasha... This movie has impacted lives of many In a positive way... The most underrated rated movie..
" Apney asley pyar se dhoka?" The one line summary of this masterclass that didn't receive the appreciation it deserved!
Pls explain
This is called Direction and thid is what makes a film good. Understanding human emotions, human condition and life itself. Not all those technical stuffs so called 'intellectual film geeks' throw all the times.
Hands down! Tamasha is 'the' Cult movie of Imtiaz Ali! Impacted many lives...in the end that's the biggest earning for a movie...
Out of all great Ranbir Kapoor movies (barfi, rockstar, ae dil hai mushkil), this was the one which made him my most favourite bollywood star. I love this guy now
Ae dil hai mushkil... Seriously bro 🤔
Fr me its one of the wrst ranbir movie
@@arshdputhoor worst is besharam
Story wise his best movies would be
1. Barfi
2. Tamasha
3. Rockstar
Performance wise his best performances would be
1. Janardan ( Jordan) - Rockstar
2. Barfi - Barfi
3. Ved - Tamasha
And to be honest he overacted in Ae Dil hai Mushkil
@@changeisinevitable3040 Jordan was linear character while ved was complex character so i think ved is best performance from Ranbir Kapoor and then jorden then barfi as in barfi it was more body movements helped to flesh out the character
What an iconic scene. So happy you all had Imtiaz break this down, definitely justifies the beauty behind this scene and of course inspiring for future filmmakers.
This channel gives so much of good learning material for free. Thank You so much Anupama Mam. 🙏
The way this man explained the process, in precise and concise manner, I am in love with this man.
the way Tu sath ho starts 😍
It would be amazing if you release all the previous 3 versions of the song!!! It will be a treat for #tamasha fans!
this man and that Anurag Kashyap.. only these two truly know what it is to take storytelling and cinema as a passion.
Neeraj Ghaywan is another gem of a director. If you haven't yet seen Masaan, please.
@@shanblues7257 Masaan is one of the most beautiful and impacting movie bollywood has ever produced
I remember watching that movie and being so confused by everything. Now watching it for the second time i realize how deep and excellent it is. It is not a movie for everyone obviously you either love it or hate but give it a chance at least .
Finally i might say the alchemy between Ranbir and Deepika is like no other. Their performance is that movie is so excellent and underrated . Please give them more movies together it's a need.
my most emotional memory of this film.... thnk u so much.... made my day...
ruclips.net/video/Bq40s0EqVqo/видео.html
Dear Imtiyaz u said no glycerine or any other thing was used still tears were flowing down from both the actors. Never seen before such chemistry or maybe it was there hidden love for each other 💞 mind blowing 💖
It's really sad that in today's time imtiaz has to explain his movie scenes to us.. I think I m the biggest fan of Imtiaz's work.. N like tamasha n rockstar are the best movies which he has given to this generation.. Most of the people don't realise what they are in actual.. Once they find out it may get worse to live with that.. That's y people keep running away from their selves..
Clueless
NEHA SHARMA ya so true
well said yar 🙌🏼💯
Ranbeer +Deepika + Imtiaz = ......not getting words for u ...love the pair of ranbeer n deepika.
No words.. I had goosebumps while watching the scene and even after watching this video.. My fav Deepika scene she is amazing and no words for Ranbir.. and the song is still one of my very few favorites in my playlist.. Tamasha is a masterpiece all in all..
Man this is simply priceless, the way imtiaz delves into the emotional journey of it just makes it so much better
Everytime I listen to this song, I am welled up. Amazing composition and lyrics. But most important the act by Deepika and Ranbir kills you. It hurts to the core. I don't understand why people didn't like this movie. I can't expect a better movie with such a storyline.
I love everything about this scene...every word every note of "agar tum saath ho" is so pure heart touching & soulful...it is indeed very cinematic i cry every single time watching this scene😢😊😊❤❤💯
We demand those 3 songs too, PLEASE !!!
This scene was a masterclass of writing, acting and observation of human nature.
WOW. Didn't know so much goes into making every single nuance of a scene! Thankyou for this. Tamasha- The most underrated film ever!
"sometimes you really fear those people that can see through you" great line sir...
Amazing movie, Felt so good, I just rewatched some scenes today afternoon and then this video pops up in the evening. Tamasha is a work which needs multiple viewings to be understood. You cannot simply watch the film twice and say “Okay, I know this Film”. Brilliant dialogues again, Piyush Mishra is simply outstanding with his parts. Really hope we get another Gem like Tamasha very soon.
ruclips.net/video/Bq40s0EqVqo/видео.html
The way he is explaining each scene, adds more value to it
I don't know Indian movie stories r changing or what that makes me feel watching some deep n thoughtful movies. Mr. Imtiaz Ali has a precious mind, I adore him, his brilliant mind n dignity. Nowadays that I'm looking forward to find people who actually think deeply, he is a gem.
This Scene starred by Ved and Tara is The Best Modern Day Tragical heartbreak.None could have done better than these Two.They Deserve Standing Ovations 😇❣️
This is the only movie who really blew up my mind. I yelled inside so much much for months and at last I found myself. In my real life I too have a second personality where in I am just like a free bird. I am very aggressive by noticing so called social formalities. Every one is tagging others by saying hello how are you, no body cares how next person is but just as a formality almost every fucking people says this. I truly believe in this movie and will remain very close to my heart forever. It taught me a big lesson and dragged my attention towards pure emotions.
it is my most favorite scene in the movie.. just love Deepika and Ranbir.... cinematography and choreography is just amazing.. so intense !
one of most underrated movie of recent time... hats off
Arguably the best scene of the film.
This is by far the greatest scene of modern cinema. The feelings are so well understated and they lead to greater tention. Cinematography is so well done for this scene.
It's been a very heart touching for me in love with the acting of Deepika and ranbeer😍
I wish he also took us inside that scene just before the interval outside the restaurant when Tara confronts Ved and leaves him. 💔
Conflict is a crazy situation. And when conflict is internal, within, with noone but yourself, it becomes even crazier. The topic here is very well handled, shown, acted. Hats off first to pick such a topic for a bollywood movie, and then to the art itself... all the artists from actors to cinematographers to background music to singers... awesome work.
After that when he left and hide somewhere and she goes to find him and when she sees him and sit down at the ground. This made me crying badly. 😭😭😭 deepika acted outstandingly well. Like she is accepting her big mistake that breaking his heart or touching his most sensitive complexion in mind. Even believe me while. Writing this I still have tears in my eyes. It effected me that much. It's 90% my Story. God bless you sir Imtiaz you made psychological moments of love and reality inside in movie.
We r so very lucky to have RK in bollywood.
True..
It is very difficult to capture that kind emotion on screen but this scene really did capture brilliantly. I bow down to the team🙏
Only ranbir and deepika could do this scene so well - they have become such amazing actors.
And more then 2 years of the movie still rulling hearts thanks for the movie imtihaz sir
ruclips.net/video/Bq40s0EqVqo/видео.html
Tamasha is an underrated masterpiece.
The movie in itself is magnificent.
The acting of Ranbir and Deepika is appreciable. It is sad and unfortunate that audience not liked the movie.
Can you imagine the intensity of this scene???
@ 09:04 director also broke out in tears...
A film that changed my perspective towards life.....
"tum saath ho" is my absolute favourite.I cannot imagine any other song in that scene.
There are people like this character (Ved) in our society.. It's not bipolar.. It's frustration, suffering, pain of individual who has no idea that what the hell is going on in his/her life
The way he is justifying every moment of scene is just commendable. True Gem 💎
This has been one of the best movies I've ever seen, something that resonated in my heart.
Team FC, I love these videos, please more of these!
I could sit and watch this for not just a scene, but the whole movie!
But in tamasha movie there is no song agar tum sath ho
My favorite Imtiaz Ali film till date. Great insight into the scene. Really helped me understand the already complex, multi layered lead characters. This film will have a cult following down the years. Shame that people missed this gem.
p.s., And SRK strong elbowed this genius into making that pile of garbage.
Joke's on him!!!
Jesse Pinkman I think only Ranbir is perfect as a lead actor in an Imtiaz Ali fim
Dont need to be one to appreciate Tamasha. It talks to everyone who doesnt want to be the rat!
What was that about srk?
He missed a great chance of letting Imtiaz do his thing. I was so hyped for that movie. And it turned out to be yet another SRK business model. It could have been so much more. Had all the ingredients to be a great film. Bummer!
I dnt think it was SRK's fault.....it was imtiaz only who should be blamed for JHMS...he was the writer as well as director....I cud not even believe JHMS is his creation...esp.after tamasha.....but I dnt think Shahrukh is anyway responsible for the weak script
finally...it was one my favourite scenes in a movie ever..so SO beautifully crafted & performed by these two amazing actors !!
a big applaud for the whole team..and love the song as well..still listening to it every other day..
bdw, i've been waiting for ever for Kangana Ranaut-Imtiaj Ali Tape-Cast..when is it gonna come out ???
I would like to communicate with you. Can I get your email address?
Love this scene and i agree with the director's point of view about the turmoil that both these characters were going through. Wonderful performance by both the actors.
The best inside the scene I've seen so far... Thanks for this Film Companion!
brilliantly performed,shot exceptional background score.just everything about this scene is perfect.nd tamasha itself is a masterpiece.
Deep, pure, selfless love showed in this song. Blessed are those people who get such lovers.
This movie is so underrated because few people have that experience or wisdom to understand this... Imtiaz Ali is one of few my favorite directors and writers in the bollywood
This scene will live forever... How can you write such sence...this is insane
"We are our true-self only ,in front of few "..,Tamasha has been one of the best movies ,i have ever seen and i remember i couldn't get out of it even for next 3 days.I wonder why it was not commercially that successful and i feel good when people who admire such cinema are increasing .
One of the most iconic scenes ever made in the history of cinema!
Film companion thanks for sharing. Imtiaz Sir I am simply awestruck. thanks for sparing your time for wonderfully breaking down the scene and explaining the subtleties for the audience Tamasha is one of the best works in recent times of Hindi Cinema.
Tamasha is just not a movie it's just a saga of emotions hats off to Imtiaz sir for giving the character Ved & Tara I wish sir to make such masterpiece with Ranbir & Deepika
Absolutely love that scene, Imtiaz! Its beautifully acted and captured. Beautiful work with lighting set up as well!!
Love the stories and moments you bring up on screen!
Thank you very very much Film Companion for doing such a great work!!! You guys are really awesome. Lots of love!
This has been my favourite since the day I’ve watched. It is so relatable in some ways
this song is a modern day classic
Thank god for imtiaz ali. I mean without this director we wouldn't have the opportunity to see film like this in bollywood which presents the realistic situations in a dramatic way.
Thank you so much for sharing the insights, the process and the trivia. Loved it.
I love the song. And 'Tamasha' happens to be a favorite film of mine that I can watch again and again.
Sir tamasha fav movie h meri... Pagal kr dia tha movie ne muje 😊
Thank you so much Film Companion for this. ❤️
Always wanted the insight for this scene.
Loved the movie to the core. Huge fan of Imtiaz Ali, Ranbir & Deepika.
So sensitive. ...so emotional. ...the kind of feel Imtiaz generates is outstanding. ...love you deepikaaaaa
Not a big fan of Imtiaz but I love how he understands his own films so well. Not a lot of filmmakers can do that
Imtiaz sir is a gift to the industry.. its not everyone's cup of tea to understand his work...
9:06 Imtiaz in his head be like, "kya film banai yaar"
I watched Tamasha 6 times and this video 4 times!
This movie is a masterpiece ! Everything about it is brilliant ♥️ we should credit each and every one related to this film, thank you to all of them❤️ It will always be my favourite film
Thank you Imitiaz Ali ,Ranbir,Deepika entire crew cast for the masterpiece 🙏🙌
Never ever seen any film scene like this and song composition .
I am already emotional and having goosebumps 😍😍😍what a scene.... Hatsoff guys...owwww
A brilliant movie...mene jab ye movie dekhi i was like kyae ye is it my story? Theatre se nikal ke i was jus constantly thinking. Thanks to this movie it helped me become what i should....varna shayad uss hi duad mei bhagti rehti. Idk ye movie hit kese kyu ni hui.... it was superhit for me. So relating it is.