Dear Rabir and Imtiaz please continue to make amazing film. I thought Tamasha was your best. I watched it back to back three times. Please market your movie well to make it international theatre and I tunes etc.
Such a matured and intellectual conversation between ranbir-imtiaz. Imtiaz addressing ranbir by saying sir, this shows how much respect he gives to his actor even after being a director.
Seeing this makes me understand how a gem like Tamasha came out of this director-actor collaboration. Frank, Insightful and conversational - this was a joy to watch.
If they launched Tamasha on the international level in different languages then tamasha would be bigger hit than rockstar and jab we met.. just love the tamasha and it's narration
Yes and dear have u saw that scene when ranbir was receiving the best actor for Sanju movie and before receiving that award imtiaz stood up and came to him hugged him for a minute.. that was phenomenal to watch ..must see it
why cant we have a hour or more of this conversation!!!... such casual genuine conversations are great to watch where not the star but the person behind the star is talking.........such a great concept....hope to see more of these and hope they are longer.....felt like was lost in time and didnt realize how quickly the video ended
+varun ozarkar Thanks Varun - I’m always being told about the super-short attention spans on YT and how no one watches anything longer than 3 minutes. Clearly you’re not one of them :) - Anupama
+Film Companion Yes, even I agree with Varun, we love this concept Anupama and would like to see much more of these conversations in future too:)) Great work and thanks for sharing here..
The boring interviews... the facts... yes please not more than ten minutes... but something like imtiaz ali and ranbir... its adds far more than just another knowledge bit... and u might not believe... but it stays with you.... btw thanks fa this....:)
Ranbir and Imtiaz equal masterpiece! Ranbir is my favourite actor and I love hearing them both talk they seem to have an amazing connection which shows of on films I can listen to them talk for hours on end!
Very different from any other thing I have seen. They are having a very real conversation, probably after a few minutes, they are oblivious of the cameras. Nice.
Ranbir look very curious to know about lyf he seems very fragile and want learn or seeking about himself by other.. He is a good humen being with lots of emotions, i knkw somebody like him..
Aaj 20-10-2019 ko Imtiaz sir se Jaipur me milna vo bhi chai ki thadi pe it's like Dream come true. He is so humble and down to earth , i can't imagine. 40-45 minutes are like 45 seconds
I enjoy every Ranbir and Imtiaz Ali video of them interviewing each other. The way the speak is so calm and engaging, I could watch them all day! Rk and Imtiaz should host a show about movies, it will be simply amazing!
I am lucky to be alive where I get to see Ranbir's films! He's amazing and my favourite ❤ and I agree with Ranbir rockstar is literally perfect for me and I loved Bombay Velvet it was amazing for me and his chemistry with Anushka was one of the best I've ever seen!
100% agree with Imtiaz.. after Jordan meets Nargis in the second half, the film really has nothing to say. It becomes a redundant bore. I'm so happy that Imtiaz realizes that. I don't dislike Rockstar, I just thought it could've been a classic if there were more story arcs in the second half because as Jordan is walking into his own rot, the film starts to rot.
Rockstar was about the passion..even though that passion lead to self destruction. Character of JJ was a flawed one, the movie would have been so bland if it had a perfect ending...the reason we all loved the movie is because it leaves us wanting more.
We need more of these conversation which allow us to understand the depths of film makers and everybody else involved in their journey. Helps us understand films better, watch them in a new light. A film is not done and dusted as soon as it's out of theaters, it has an existence of perpetuity. These conversations, help us revisit a movie with different perspectives or notice background circumstances evolving into a new and wonderful experience of watching it again. Thank you anupama. Love this concept of film reporting.
I recently got married. I agree with Imitiaz Ali's POV. I am married only 'cos I love my spouse a lot and nothing feels like work to me. I only hope my husband feels the same way about me. I do feel loved. Thank god for that. I liked the conversation about failure too. I left my job at a MNC 'cos I had to relocate post my marriage. I am experiencing a lot of rejection wrt jobs and I have experienced lot of rejection before as well. Everytime you feel this is it. This is the most you have to suffer but it doesn't end. I keep trying and trying. Upside is that my husband takes really good care of me. I am a simple person and don't really demand much.
Such conversations are treat to watch, cause they come across genuine. There will always be audience for such talks and for them you should extend time. Even totally enjoyed your conversation with imtiaz unfiltered... it was just awesome. Would love to see more such conversation . Thank you for such initiatives.
My favourite duo .. & fav trio wen A.R Rahman comes into the picture .. and would be amazing to see Alia bhatt joining .. n see the whole club together some time.
Insightful talk between actor and director. Love both of them. I liked socha na tha but had no idea imtiaz was the director. The way both of them grow with time is so awesome. Would love to see them again.
I find myself coming back to the video for many reasons as both people are true and vulnerable enough to stir emotions on the other side of screen. I feel a connect towards both of these, and the "capacity to endure tumult" is what titillated me. It's and interesting subject to dwell and if possible I would like to ask Imtiaz which books should I read to understand the idea better. Thanks.
I really wants to know that in Tamsha the character of Tara was the real person or she was just consciousness of Vaid? I think she wasn't really a real person.
Dear ImtiazJi, just wanna ask u one question : how does it feels when after working with probably the best actor of his generation ( Ranbir, of course) u suddenly drop ur standards and work with an absolute joker ( Kartik Aryan).
I have such philosophical conversations with friends and my partner. I am sure many people have deeper and meaningful conversations than these two. To me these two are not inspiring, but normal like most of us. Just because they are doing it on a public platform, they are no special. It is also ridiculous that they have turned the ability to have a conversation into money making. They are succeeding by the false image that they so willingly create that they are special. Grow up guys and get a real job to earn your living.
One thin for surely i tell with whomever imitiaz ali do film specially bolly couples they vll go through breakup nd girls married to someone else...kareena nd deepu u all know
I could hear Ranbir and Imtiaz discuss bollywood/life/movies all day and not get bored!
+barliman butterbur oh fuck off
Same here
Aneesha Singh me too
Aneesha Singh same feelings
Same pinch.
Dear Rabir and Imtiaz please continue to make amazing film. I thought Tamasha was your best. I watched it back to back three times. Please market your movie well to make it international theatre and I tunes etc.
Rockstar and tamasha 😍😍
Just watched Tamasha back to back thrice, and I am here.
@@atifayaz3495 can anyone give me movie link
@@ritikthapa365 kumse kum kuch to kharid k dekho find it on zee5 or netflix
I'm 4 years too late to watch this but now I can rest in peace.
What do you mean?
me too
@@anonymousperson8077 ...he meant to say ...about film..Tamasha
@@louise221b ...he is talking about Tamasha
@@picturesbypost
I meant what does he mean he can rest in peace because people say that to people who die rest in peace
Rockstar and Tamasha are my two favorite movies of these times! Waiting to watch more!
found 1st person like me on RUclips.....cheers bro😍
Such a matured and intellectual conversation between ranbir-imtiaz. Imtiaz addressing ranbir by saying sir, this shows how much respect he gives to his actor even after being a director.
This kind of conversation happens when you are high. seriously!
really deep and meaningful. love listening to these guys speak. Its so real!
Both are high only baba, that's why we also get it 😂 level of chill is lovely! We get hot headed very quickly
Sheesh
two souls who loves films and art of film making...this is beautiful!
well said
this is called matured discussion
imtiaz Ali is a school of thoughts.
Seeing this makes me understand how a gem like Tamasha came out of this director-actor collaboration. Frank, Insightful and conversational - this was a joy to watch.
End of Ranbir Vs Ranveer Drama! If someone asks who is the best actor of this generation then show this conversation. Period!
After Animal - Is there any confusion bro?😅
Obviously Ranbir suprassed many GREAT actors toh ranveer kya cheez hai?
Jagga is there to, person with speech impediment yet so expressive without mocking it
The debate never existed! Ranbir 🐐
And they both addressed each other as ' sir'
If they launched Tamasha on the international level in different languages then tamasha would be bigger hit than rockstar and jab we met.. just love the tamasha and it's narration
no offense but Rockstar is much superior✌🏼
Both were great. I watched recently for the first time. But Rockstar is a masterpiece
Love to listen to Ranbir Kapoor and Imtiaz Ali talk about the film world.
Yes and dear have u saw that scene when ranbir was receiving the best actor for Sanju movie and before receiving that award imtiaz stood up and came to him hugged him for a minute.. that was phenomenal to watch ..must see it
why cant we have a hour or more of this conversation!!!... such casual genuine conversations are great to watch where not the star but the person behind the star is talking.........such a great concept....hope to see more of these and hope they are longer.....felt like was lost in time and didnt realize how quickly the video ended
+varun ozarkar Thanks Varun - I’m always being told about the super-short attention spans on YT and how no one watches anything longer than 3 minutes. Clearly you’re not one of them :) - Anupama
+Film Companion Yes, even I agree with Varun, we love this concept Anupama and would like to see much more of these conversations in future too:)) Great work and thanks for sharing here..
The boring interviews... the facts... yes please not more than ten minutes... but something like imtiaz ali and ranbir... its adds far more than just another knowledge bit... and u might not believe... but it stays with you....
btw thanks fa this....:)
Ranbir and Imtiaz equal masterpiece! Ranbir is my favourite actor and I love hearing them both talk they seem to have an amazing connection which shows of on films I can listen to them talk for hours on end!
Very different from any other thing I have seen. They are having a very real conversation, probably after a few minutes, they are oblivious of the cameras. Nice.
I love how they disagree in so many things, yet they admire and respect each other
Ranbir look very curious to know about lyf he seems very fragile and want learn or seeking about himself by other.. He is a good humen being with lots of emotions, i knkw somebody like him..
Rohit Malhotra whom
Is it a way to tell that u are like him!!😇
Aaj 20-10-2019 ko Imtiaz sir se Jaipur me milna vo bhi chai ki thadi pe it's like Dream come true. He is so humble and down to earth , i can't imagine. 40-45 minutes are like 45 seconds
I enjoy every Ranbir and Imtiaz Ali video of them interviewing each other.
The way the speak is so calm and engaging, I could watch them all day!
Rk and Imtiaz should host a show about movies, it will be simply amazing!
I am lucky to be alive where I get to see Ranbir's films! He's amazing and my favourite ❤ and I agree with Ranbir rockstar is literally perfect for me and I loved Bombay Velvet it was amazing for me and his chemistry with Anushka was one of the best I've ever seen!
ranbir u rock.imtiaz u r the best
My god, my god hearing and watching imtiaz calling ranbir "sir" is just so transparent and not being filtered of him
100% agree with Imtiaz.. after Jordan meets Nargis in the second half, the film really has nothing to say. It becomes a redundant bore. I'm so happy that Imtiaz realizes that. I don't dislike Rockstar, I just thought it could've been a classic if there were more story arcs in the second half because as Jordan is walking into his own rot, the film starts to rot.
Rockstar was about the passion..even though that passion lead to self destruction. Character of JJ was a flawed one, the movie would have been so bland if it had a perfect ending...the reason we all loved the movie is because it leaves us wanting more.
Wtf bro rockstar is the best
@@aspiringbanker2552 i mean you stole my words man !
I don’t think there was anything wrong with Rockstar. People will keep appreciating the movie even more in the coming years.
7 saal pehle kaafi pate ki baat bol gye bro. Rockstar started and plot was good, but it needed something more, as you said arcs.
We need more of these conversation which allow us to understand the depths of film makers and everybody else involved in their journey. Helps us understand films better, watch them in a new light. A film is not done and dusted as soon as it's out of theaters, it has an existence of perpetuity. These conversations, help us revisit a movie with different perspectives or notice background circumstances evolving into a new and wonderful experience of watching it again. Thank you anupama. Love this concept of film reporting.
rockstar is a complete film ..its a film which comes in a decade rockstar is a classic ranbir sir u acted superb h
"Marriage is a great institution," she says, "if you like living in institutions"
Dil garden garden ho gaya Ranbir k munh se Jamshedpur ka naam sun kar❤
I recently got married. I agree with Imitiaz Ali's POV. I am married only 'cos I love my spouse a lot and nothing feels like work to me. I only hope my husband feels the same way about me. I do feel loved. Thank god for that. I liked the conversation about failure too. I left my job at a MNC 'cos I had to relocate post my marriage. I am experiencing a lot of rejection wrt jobs and I have experienced lot of rejection before as well. Everytime you feel this is it. This is the most you have to suffer but it doesn't end. I keep trying and trying. Upside is that my husband takes really good care of me. I am a simple person and don't really demand much.
Meenakshi Venkataraman Hope your job and husband are taking good care of you now
Good heart
All da best
One of the best interviews I've seen. Loved it!
Such conversations are treat to watch, cause they come across genuine. There will always be audience for such talks and for them you should extend time. Even totally enjoyed your conversation with imtiaz unfiltered... it was just awesome. Would love to see more such conversation . Thank you for such initiatives.
honest, genuine and inspiring.....loved it :)
simply amazing concept for a video where a normal person can emotionally connect to!! plz keep making such videos!!
RANBIR KAPOOR is one of my favorite actor
Love you so much Ranbir Kapoor❤😊
Rockstar is really some of the best films made in India in the last decade and was ahead of its time.
I love two great people talking about their fields. So much to learn how they approach or thinks to particular situation
I so much love Ranbir and imitiaz ali❤️❤️❤️
The last 3 minutes are golden advice 🧡✨
Ranbir jordan's😍
Rockstar is perfect, the public is not ready for that in 2011
That's the difference. He work so much on the charecters. While describing about tomato scene from jab we met he was calling kareena geet. 👏👏
2 fav personalities in same clip😍
brilliant ... better than interviews
Imtiaz first film .. socha na tha .. l think socha na tha is best film best romantic scene , best song . Ayesha and abhay chemistry is beautiful...
I can't help think Ranbir wore Jordan sneakers for this interview as an inside joke XD
Lol
Imagine imtiaz seeing kartik Aryan act after working with ranbir 🤡
Karthik aryan is overrated
And plz dont compare an actor like rk to him
Level of comfort in this interview 😄🤘
Damn the alternative point that imtiaz made about Rockstar's ending could have been interesting...
5:55 man I wish Imtiaz had gotten into that space of "itna koi maza to aa nahi raha hai"
His Jordan's are cleannnnnnnn🙀
thanks.......... thanks ...................... for uploading this video ................
Going to watch Rockstar today in the theatre…….very excited 😍🌟 (24 May ‘24)
I ❤ Ranbir. He's Smart dress and Handsome. ❤
That time was epic ❤
The talk is so intense and deep
In interview Ranbir also acting as a actor
Both are like babies sitting and talking intellectually
My favourite duo .. & fav trio wen A.R Rahman comes into the picture .. and would be amazing to see Alia bhatt joining .. n see the whole club together some time.
How can u forget irshad kamil
sanchi gulati there's a video where the 3 talk on "highway the film" channel
Imtiaz Ali's concept of marriage is waaooo👍
If Gunjan is agree then I'm also agree😁
I really enjoyed this interview, so insightful!
This was inspirational.
I m 5 years too late to watch this but now i can die in peace. 2.0
Ranbir and imtiaz combination is like chilum and weed . It will take you high . One of my favourite combination.
Insightful talk between actor and director. Love both of them. I liked socha na tha but had no idea imtiaz was the director. The way both of them grow with time is so awesome. Would love to see them again.
Two masters of bollywood 👌👌
8:28 so touched!
Jis desh Main tamasha jesi Movie flop hoti hain wo desh kabhi aage nhi badh sakta
Imtiaz, AR Rehman , Ranbir
Magic
IF ANY ONE THERE PLZ TELL IMTIAZ ALI AND MAKE ROCKSTAR PART 2 PLZZZZZZZZZZ.
I find myself coming back to the video for many reasons as both people are true and vulnerable enough to stir emotions on the other side of screen.
I feel a connect towards both of these, and the "capacity to endure tumult" is what titillated me.
It's and interesting subject to dwell and if possible I would like to ask Imtiaz which books should I read to understand the idea better.
Thanks.
i am always game for really long videos. Please always try to upload long conversations. Its a humble request
come on imitiaz sir....answer that last question.....i wanna know ur take on that
LISTEN if I WANA KNW ANSWER !
I agree with Ranbir here...
Dear film companion please organise some more sessions like this . Actor and director discussing film its really helpful for upcoming filmmaker
BEST DIRECTOR AND BEST ACTOR
TAMASHA IS SUPERB MOVIE
I M GREAT FAN OF U BOTH
HEARD THAT TAMASHA DID 100CR IN WW HAPPY FOR IT BT U GUYS DESERVE MORE
Imtiaz founded Ibtida in his college. He's wearing a t-shirt from that club.
only thing in rockstar to change was nargis other than that i agree with what imitiaz said but yeah changing her would have meant a lot
I really wants to know that in Tamsha the character of Tara was the real person or she was just consciousness of Vaid? I think she wasn't really a real person.
The boss said, ek ladki ke piche kyun itna scene create kr rha h, and the employees were invited on his birthday where he proposed Tara.
Ranbir said *chutiya* I can die in peace.
Good work need more
damn manzz didn't take a single breath, they just talked the whole time
ranbir and imtiaz sir two legeng who dont work for money h
Dear ImtiazJi, just wanna ask u one question : how does it feels when after working with probably the best actor of his generation ( Ranbir, of course) u suddenly drop ur standards and work with an absolute joker ( Kartik Aryan).
I'm sure Imtiaz really realized RK's value during Luv Aajkal shoot😂
Nailed it😂
producers naam ke bhi koi cheez hote he..
Jordan wearing Jordans😊😊
Post Ramadhir Singh, it's getting tougher to find the parallel between Cinema & Literature.. 😂😂 Even this poetry session seems like a silent sulking
Very nice conversation ..
farhan akhtar when he made lakshay😍
Me watching this video in 2024 ❤
super lyk.. 👍👍👍👍
Imtiaz Rocks
Your first film is great.... Imtiaz ali
I have such philosophical conversations with friends and my partner. I am sure many people have deeper and meaningful conversations than these two. To me these two are not inspiring, but normal like most of us. Just because they are doing it on a public platform, they are no special. It is also ridiculous that they have turned the ability to have a conversation into money making. They are succeeding by the false image that they so willingly create that they are special. Grow up guys and get a real job to earn your living.
funny coming from a person who took so much effort to type such a long speech and telling others to get a job :P
You are such a dumb fellow. No one created false image. Put your ego oneside and try to learn to think logically
0:32 it's true
I like this dude!
Ranbir and Imtiaz need to team up again 😭
One thin for surely i tell with whomever imitiaz ali do film specially bolly couples they vll go through breakup nd girls married to someone else...kareena nd deepu u all know
Love them💝
Jordan wearing Jordans.
perfect