American withdrawal from Afghanistan - Vaibhav Singh on Urban Chatterati

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 окт 2024
  • Vaibhav Singh talks about American withdrawal from Afghanistan and changing geo-politics of the region.
    Join this channel to support:
    / @urbanchatterati
    For more content and to support: patreon.com/Ab...

Комментарии • 653

  • @mr.p2631
    @mr.p2631 3 года назад +57

    This should be a paid discussion. All that insight for free. This is pure gold. I think Vaibhav’s knowledge on geo politics is on a whole different level. Kudos Abhinav and Vaibhav for this insightful discussion.

  • @SimranKaur-pl1sm
    @SimranKaur-pl1sm 3 года назад +129

    Vaibhav Singh is an underrated and underutilized gem! He makes such valid points in such a simple manner that even the most commonly person can understand. This is a genius quality. Thank you Abhinav for inviting such knowledgeable guests on your channel! 🙏🏻

  • @saiecorp5646
    @saiecorp5646 3 года назад +110

    Very interesting conversation. Vaibhavsing is a great political analyst and Abhinav is always best. Thanx.

    • @urbanchatterati
      @urbanchatterati  3 года назад +10

      thnx

    • @torakmakto0873
      @torakmakto0873 3 года назад +1

      Nice entertainment.......😃😃😁....laugh riot's...

    • @mayankchauhan1401
      @mayankchauhan1401 3 года назад +5

      @@torakmakto0873 lol pakistan is joke america kabhi bhi drone attack kardeta hai aur vo bhi pakistani base se lmao.

  • @indiafirst2893
    @indiafirst2893 3 года назад +75

    Vaibhav singh is indeed one of the best person to discuss geopolitics. He has more insights on Pakistan/Afghanistan & it's mindset than most of others in India.

    • @torakmakto0873
      @torakmakto0873 3 года назад +1

      2 GUJJUS 💲elling the Nation🇮🇳 while the other 2 GUJJUS buying it....rest in Movid queue..😉💯..

    • @khybercircle2313
      @khybercircle2313 3 года назад

      he has not gone to Afghanistan... he does not know the geographical position, and shitting in India, Make discussion on Afghanistan..

    • @noteshub8225
      @noteshub8225 3 года назад

      @@torakmakto0873 afganistan chala ja na be..

  • @ashishgautam3679
    @ashishgautam3679 3 года назад +22

    Fabulous insights! You two are great analytics!

  • @anujvir2936
    @anujvir2936 3 года назад +28

    “China I don’t know what it is” …. “Pakistan is a Basket case” ….. HA HA HA… Classisc

  • @sukhbirnaidu4360
    @sukhbirnaidu4360 3 года назад +15

    Vaibhav Singh's prediction came true in less than 24 hours. News just out that Quad is coming up with an alternative for Belt and Road Initiative.

  • @niraj2020
    @niraj2020 3 года назад +8

    In defence analysis, I am very much interested in watching discussion of Vaibhav singh and Major Gaurav Arya both straight forward and proper analysis on ground whether good or bad.

  • @mahis7573
    @mahis7573 3 года назад +45

    This channel should have 1 million subscribers

    • @shahidiqbal-sx8nn
      @shahidiqbal-sx8nn 3 года назад

      u must foloow 1 milion time l b milion susc

    • @ARY4NNNNN
      @ARY4NNNNN 3 года назад +1

      @@shahidiqbal-sx8nn p0

  • @AMITKUMAR_Hindu
    @AMITKUMAR_Hindu 3 года назад +13

    Have Subscribed to every possible Nationalist RUclips Channel. Itna toh kar hi sakte hain 😁. It was great conversation specially as it was targetted to larger Hindi speaking population.

  • @prashthegreat
    @prashthegreat 3 года назад +2

    Just awesome conversation. Am watching this multiple times. Abhinav you should call Vaibhav and AIM more often and both of them together in a conversation on Defense and Geopolitics.

  • @effendi77
    @effendi77 3 года назад +11

    First off, at 2:21, Salala is NOT an airbase, it is a border checkpost, on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border.

  • @khurramhussein
    @khurramhussein 3 года назад +4

    With this level of Indian geo strategic understanding. I am so happy. Pakistan do not be afraid at all.

  • @Anup_BHU
    @Anup_BHU 3 года назад +34

    एक बात है , वैभव बड़ा पढ़ा लिखा आदमी है 🇮🇳🙏 हर हर महादेव

    • @shakirmevati2501
      @shakirmevati2501 3 года назад

      Jhatu hai yeh

    • @storm____gaming1212
      @storm____gaming1212 3 года назад +1

      @@Anup_BHU bhai enki dunia hi alag hai ye jadui dunia me rahate hai

    • @Anup_BHU
      @Anup_BHU 3 года назад

      @@storm____gaming1212 ha yar.....sale अनपढ़

  • @deshpremithenationalist3690
    @deshpremithenationalist3690 3 года назад +4

    One important point that was not discussed is
    how will taliban and Afghan government work together?

  • @abhisheknegi3819
    @abhisheknegi3819 3 года назад +1

    It's a great pleasure to listen Vaibhav sir..
    He is 1 of the finest speaker India is having Right now.

  • @priyanka3580
    @priyanka3580 3 года назад +2

    Whatever geo political knowledge i have i owe it completely to:
    1) Vaibhav Singh- this guy doesn't realize what a HUGE contribution he has done to educate the nationalist youth of our country! God bless you!
    2) Major Gaurav Arya- another gem!
    3) Abhijit Iyer Mitra- an all rounder!! Knowledge ka bhandaar hai yeh aadmi🙏

  • @dev-thapliyal
    @dev-thapliyal 3 года назад +11

    Eyes wide open debate ❤️👍🙏

  • @mukeshrawat6903
    @mukeshrawat6903 2 года назад

    अभिनव जी आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद जो आपने हिंदी में यह बातचीत रखी। आशा है इसी प्रकार अन्य विषयों पर भी विशेषज्ञों से वार्तालाप के वीडियो लाएंगे

  • @rajeevbali4694
    @rajeevbali4694 3 года назад +1

    Vaibhav sir और मेजर गौरव आर्य sir ji ko सुनना बहुत अच्छा लगता है jai hind 🙏🙏🙏

  • @ajaypkumar8272
    @ajaypkumar8272 3 года назад +3

    Vaibhav Singh's interview-hit pause,like , subscribe and then play🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @davender55
    @davender55 3 года назад +1

    Always insightful to listen to Vaibhav. Thank you!

  • @consummascient
    @consummascient 3 года назад

    Excellent Show. Vaibhav is an Excellent speaker and Strategic Expert.
    Really Loved this Show.
    Plzzzzz Keep it Up.

  • @priyapannu4
    @priyapannu4 3 года назад +4

    Excellent discussion 👏👏

  • @adeelarif8381
    @adeelarif8381 3 года назад +3

    Zero Logic of 40+ countries of NATO And US Super power economy against 25 K Taliban with no money and no weapons,
    Still Talaban fighting and killing and growing. HOW?

  • @truepatriot1857
    @truepatriot1857 3 года назад +1

    Hindi k liye thank you sir pls aise fruit full discussion late rahiyega... Vaibhav bhai big fan

  • @smitam6856
    @smitam6856 3 года назад

    Vaibhav sir is really 👌.He is really great .More knowledge than any one else.He explained simply.

  • @sumitkumarofficial825
    @sumitkumarofficial825 3 года назад +1

    Standing Salute to both of you great persons🙏🙏

  • @AlphaSierra380
    @AlphaSierra380 3 года назад +2

    Once again a good discussion with a expert and as always. Great questions

  • @zil1832
    @zil1832 3 года назад +2

    Very insightful commentary, rightly said.

  • @sabjitsingh3494
    @sabjitsingh3494 3 года назад +7

    I agree mostly but we shall not underestimate our nam policy.. nam ensure that india is not under big powers

  • @finalassault07oct42
    @finalassault07oct42 3 года назад +1

    Jai Shri Ram Abhinav g and Vaibhav G. I subscribed this channel.

  • @pps21april
    @pps21april 3 года назад +57

    You should have called a real geopolitical expert - Dhruv Rathee

  • @jojobabok9373
    @jojobabok9373 3 года назад +19

    27:40 Good video. But this part isn't exactly correct.
    The reason USA wants to hobble PRC's growth is not because of some immoral economic practices of the latter (is the US _really_ not guilty of this - equally, if not greater?🧐)
    The reason is the PRC is a threat to "American Primacy". (While Brazil, the example you gave, is not).
    (Rec: Smuggler Nation: How Illicit Trade Made America,
    Trade Secrets: Intellectual Piracy and the Origins of American Industrial Power)
    I agree with the call to pragmatic action on our part, but if we are to eventually attain pre-eminence ourselves, we have to educate citizens along realpolitik lines, uncompromisingly.
    Please don't exempt the US from this piercing scrutiny. Eventually, if we would've played our cards well, they'll mark us as a "strategic competitor" too. (And try to break us up into more _manageable_ pieces (Hint: 20th century Khalistan movement)).

    • @ifinditinteresting.8709
      @ifinditinteresting.8709 3 года назад

      You talked about USA's immoral economic practises.... Can you give some links on it?

  • @baijuv3
    @baijuv3 3 года назад +3

    If India wants to be powerful, it should make decisive moves when required without fear of diversified religious problem creators. Modiji looks promising but the team must be with his pace and vision to succeed.

  • @jayeshpathak1308
    @jayeshpathak1308 3 года назад

    In depth analysis, in short period.. Thanks Both यु गाईज 💐💐🙏😊

  • @AmitJhamb
    @AmitJhamb 3 года назад

    Nice discussion between two subject matter specialists .Jai Hind Vande Matram 🙏🙏.

  • @anilverma5780
    @anilverma5780 3 года назад

    Great conversation!!! 👌👌👌👌
    Full enjoyed Vaibhav singh yours comments and knowledge.

  • @MAHENDRADALVIGoa47
    @MAHENDRADALVIGoa47 3 года назад

    Enlightning discussion. Understood some nitty-gritty of international events connected specially with Afganistan.

  • @himanshut114
    @himanshut114 3 года назад

    Vaibhav Singh ❤️😍🤗 ..... Love you from Lucknow 🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @chandanbisht7702
    @chandanbisht7702 3 года назад

    Very interesting and open discussion on recent scenario on Afghan issue Vis-a-Vis Taliban involvement after exits of American from Afghan soil not from the region. It may be start of new chapter in geo-politics.

  • @ajaypuri130
    @ajaypuri130 3 года назад

    Vaibhav Singh amazing guest. Good addition to my knowledge base. Jai Hind.

  • @rratedgabru5349
    @rratedgabru5349 3 года назад

    Aa usual it was an enlightening session, Vaibhav bhai thanks for raising the self confidence of us Indians and showing us how deep in the waters our enemies are. 🙏

  • @abhijitchakraborty4659
    @abhijitchakraborty4659 3 года назад

    Bhaivab singh is very enlighting person about geo-politics..always love to listen him..

  • @ajaytibrewal8895
    @ajaytibrewal8895 3 года назад +2

    Discussion only in English such topics is also a colonial hangover from our universities, Thanks God we are slowly moving out of it.

  • @loke4321
    @loke4321 3 года назад +2

    प्रत्येक हिंदु ने दलित और आदिवासी से खान पान जोड़ रखना है !! खास कर के छोटे छोटे गांव के अनपढ़ लोगोने ज्यादा ध्यान रखना है !! अब भारतके मुसलमानों ने वासिम रिजवी और साऊदी सारकार को ईस्लाम रिफॉर्म के लिये समर्थन देना चाहिए !! हर हर महादेव !!

  • @waqarmohammad2582
    @waqarmohammad2582 3 года назад +3

    Please update yourself. As per NYT report, CIA chief requested meeting with IK which was denied. IK in his interview to HBO straight away said that Pakistan will not give bases to US.

    • @deiwakarsingh2508
      @deiwakarsingh2508 3 года назад +1

      अरे वैकूफ, इम्रंडी से क्यों पूछ रहा है , कभी बाजवा से भी पूछ लो
      वैसे तुम्हरे देश में इम्रंडि की क्या वल्यू है . सब जानते है कि देश तो परोक्ष रूप से बाजवा ही चालता है 😂lol
      चाइना के cpec में कितना इन्वेस्टमेंट हुआ है , पब्लिक क्यों नहीं करती हैं इमरंडि के पास इतना पॉवर है तो 😘

  • @arunrai4559
    @arunrai4559 3 года назад +2

    Very interesting conversation.

  • @neerajsharma872
    @neerajsharma872 3 года назад

    अभिनव जी, इस प्रोग्राम को हिन्दी मे करने के लिये धन्यवाद, एक प्रोग्राम अभीजीत एय्यर जी के साथ भी हिन्दी मे जरूर किजिये....

  • @Ankity11
    @Ankity11 3 года назад +1

    Waiting for a reverse interview. Vaibhav asking questions to Abhinav Prakash on Pakistan's and Chinese economic situation. It would be good to include strategy and geopolitics in that. What's your take Abhinav?

    • @jubnaa
      @jubnaa 3 года назад +1

      Indians have a false image of Pakistans economy being in the gutter. If Pakistans economy was like how indians say that it is then the situation would be like Venezuela or Lebanon. Pakistans Gdp is expected to grow 4.5% this year after only experiencing a dip of -0.4 last year compared to indias -7.6%.

  • @vickyarora2729
    @vickyarora2729 3 года назад +1

    Major gourav arya and vaibhav sir both r my hero ❤🇮🇳

  • @noone6952
    @noone6952 3 года назад +1

    बैभव सींग बहोत बुध्दिमान है । दूसरे लोगो को मैं प्रस्तुत करना चाहता हु, और वो कुछ इस प्रकार है, 1. MG K.K.SINHA SIR, 2. PRO. KAPIL KUMAR SIR, 3. Col. RSN SING SIR, 4. VAIBHAV SINGH

  • @SajidJee
    @SajidJee 3 года назад

    As a Pakistani, I appreciate your spot-on analysis. Few corrections that I would like to make:
    1) There is no airbase named "Salala", probably you were pointing to Shamsi airbase.
    2) At independence, Pakistani side of India was not known for Industrialization, but yes as bread-basket.
    3) People like Hafiz Saeed don't attract people in lakhs in their jalsas, only few thousand. Last of such type jalsa may have happened as far as 15 years back. So a decades-old logic can't be applied to the current situation.

  • @siddharthachoudhary2838
    @siddharthachoudhary2838 3 года назад +1

    Greetings sir, i just love your videos. Just a simple suggestion can we please continue with the thumbline like that of video titled India Pakistan with Sushan Sareen.

  • @drts6465
    @drts6465 3 года назад

    Always very interesting to listen to Vaibhav Singh. Just one suggestion, don't give too many interviews to prevent the repetition and poor quality. And FYI Turkish people are generally quite sensible, not hardliner Islamic and friendly to Indians. And baclava is just amazing :-)

  • @finenterprisespvtltd6707
    @finenterprisespvtltd6707 3 года назад +1

    Sahi Bola , Indians bureaucrats aur middle class ko dushmani Bhi Sahi SE Nahi Karna aata. Pakistan ko yeh pata hai aur Pakistan iska hamesha fayda uthata hai.

  • @pratikmandloi274
    @pratikmandloi274 3 года назад

    Good informative video, thank you
    Please make more such videos on geo political strategy

  • @Devendra.77
    @Devendra.77 3 года назад +6

    Jai HInd Vaibav Sir..

  • @mitraadhikary4047
    @mitraadhikary4047 3 года назад +1

    VAIBHAV BHAI ALWAYS LOVE YOU RESPECT YOU 🙌 ❤

  • @santoshkumarbabar7215
    @santoshkumarbabar7215 3 года назад

    Best insights, Thanks Vaibhav Sir.

  • @ashifmallick3726
    @ashifmallick3726 3 года назад +2

    48 country defeated by 60000 taliban

  • @rey1sri60
    @rey1sri60 3 года назад +2

    24:38 If the implications of what Vaibhav alluded to are really true, then I would say that Indian govt is using my taxpayer money well, under NDA and even the UPA before 2014.
    Jai Bharatham

  • @poorvasharma3881
    @poorvasharma3881 3 года назад +9

    16:00 Oh please invite him again and others who know how Sushma ji sabotaged this.. would be so interesting to know!!

    • @pratikagarwal3545
      @pratikagarwal3545 3 года назад

      Even i want to know what sushma swaraj ji do to stop that agreement and how it helped india ??

  • @anopqw
    @anopqw 3 года назад +7

    great analysis vaibhav bhai

  • @suranjibsaha6517
    @suranjibsaha6517 3 года назад

    Baibhav Sir... excilant analysis 🙏🙏

  • @jatinkhanna76
    @jatinkhanna76 3 года назад

    Great discussion

  • @jaspreetsaund9237
    @jaspreetsaund9237 3 года назад

    Subscribed just for Vaibhav said in the last second.

  • @dr.swaminathsharma1405
    @dr.swaminathsharma1405 3 года назад

    बहुत अच्छी जानकारी

  • @tapasranjanbiswal1748
    @tapasranjanbiswal1748 3 года назад

    Vaibhav Singh Ji Master Class

  • @khansheheyar
    @khansheheyar 3 года назад +4

    It's time to pay back India, you have always played the role of spoiler in our homeland Afghanistan, and have always supported foreign forces.

    • @kaustubhdeo3143
      @kaustubhdeo3143 3 года назад

      @Abdul Mateen aur bhai kaise ho, kya halchal

  • @finalassault07oct42
    @finalassault07oct42 3 года назад

    Vaibhav sir very true about Pakistanis Street Peoples. But some secular here don't understand this. 🤔

  • @sachin99604325638
    @sachin99604325638 3 года назад

    Its always interesting to listen Vaibhav Singh

  • @singhalmg
    @singhalmg 3 года назад

    Excellent explanations Vaibhav

  • @DEEP_PATEL22
    @DEEP_PATEL22 3 года назад +1

    Vaibhav is the one who can create nationalist ecosystem..🙏

    • @nnbg8000
      @nnbg8000 3 года назад

      Agree! and he can do that in his unassuming way! Really appreciated he invited AJC reps. on his YT channel a few weeks ago.

  • @npegasus2524
    @npegasus2524 3 года назад +1

    • From India’s standpoint, both US and China are friends and foes at the same time.
    • China is trying to follow US’ footsteps in nation building and power projection.
    • What China is trying to do, the US has already done it before.
    • Should the US/EU succeed in strangling China, they will come after India.
    • Should China succeed in becoming bigger power, it would have overwhelmed India by then.

  • @shashijha371
    @shashijha371 3 года назад +1

    Keep continue , thanks hindi me video me bna ne ke liye .

  • @VictorSamMikey
    @VictorSamMikey 3 года назад +1

    Good for Pak, bad for Indian investment in Afghanistan.

  • @harisingh98684
    @harisingh98684 3 года назад

    Bohot sahi bat kahi vaibhav ne

  • @rakeshpandey638
    @rakeshpandey638 3 года назад

    बहुत सुंदर परिचर्चा

  • @sudhanshusharan5720
    @sudhanshusharan5720 3 года назад

    Great discussion 👍🏽👍🏽🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @jasha9sandhu
    @jasha9sandhu 3 года назад

    Genius of vaibhav bhai is that he is a realist.

  • @vaibhavdixit275
    @vaibhavdixit275 3 года назад

    Vaibhav sir is realy good my name is also vaibhav 😃🤘 vaibhav rocks

  • @jaswindersian3159
    @jaswindersian3159 3 года назад

    The US is a resident Middle East (West Asia) and Indo-Pacific power. It will protect its interests in every which way it has to do.

  • @shubhamtiwari-oz1dz
    @shubhamtiwari-oz1dz 3 года назад

    Great conversation respect 🙏🙏🙏🙏 to both

  • @kishorjamatkar9436
    @kishorjamatkar9436 3 года назад

    I really thankful to u hindi conversation

  • @vivekbalachander7858
    @vivekbalachander7858 3 года назад +1

    Good discussion! Enjoyed listening to both of you. Jai Hind Jai Bharat.

  • @blackpanthermv
    @blackpanthermv 3 года назад

    Bahut behtar abhinav sir, please vikram sood sir ka hindi me bhi ek interview kriye.

  • @parthshekhar2394
    @parthshekhar2394 3 года назад

    Shamika Ravi was sacked from London? When did this happen?

  • @wolfwolf7246
    @wolfwolf7246 3 года назад

    Great talks.

  • @shweta_vish_12
    @shweta_vish_12 3 года назад +9

    Jai Hind 🇮🇳🔥

  • @buddhoo3137
    @buddhoo3137 3 года назад

    Good conversation 👍

  • @shabbirpatel2923
    @shabbirpatel2923 3 года назад

    Pakistan bluntly told to america absoutly no. Now america will demand for airport to india, we are looking forward how india will tacle if american demand from india.

  • @mehulsharma7650
    @mehulsharma7650 3 года назад +2

    China is 10 times the Indian economy and Pakistan is backed by China. Vaibhav and co feel good about themselves by bashing Pakistan. Itna aasaan hai toh todo Pakistan?

  • @hari83100
    @hari83100 3 года назад

    Vaibhav Sir , Please please read my comment and answer please ... Why despite of '71 surrender (of 93K ), POK wasnt taken back that time itself ???

    • @afzaalmajeed3816
      @afzaalmajeed3816 3 года назад

      KAbi aoo na rat ko chandhan ki tarah
      Tumhay chaey pilae abhinandan ki tarah 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @finalassault07oct42
    @finalassault07oct42 3 года назад

    Abhinav sir tell about every country's current roll and image but did not say about india's image in geopolitics. Sir please about india its roll in this region?

  • @inderjeetsingh7417
    @inderjeetsingh7417 3 года назад

    nice debate
    thx

  • @manjulavikas3443
    @manjulavikas3443 3 года назад

    Terrific !!

  • @Santosh-te9js
    @Santosh-te9js 3 года назад

    Vaibhav ji inse puchiye
    Kaun kaun se book laga ke rakhe hain

  • @mehtarashmikant4923
    @mehtarashmikant4923 3 года назад

    Vaibhav is highly good

  • @Rs-bt3ev
    @Rs-bt3ev 3 года назад

    who is super power now is it usa ...who r tbey now where is they rstanding with whom it ........is china or usa ..sir plz reply