Green Day - Retrospective Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024

Комментарии • 120

  • @jefferyjones8399
    @jefferyjones8399 7 лет назад +60

    Warning grew to be one of my favorite Green Day albums.

    • @Bedroomrips
      @Bedroomrips 6 лет назад +1

      Jeffery Jones honestly. Super underrated but all the songs are amazing

  • @dirtydayf
    @dirtydayf 7 лет назад +96

    I cant believe The Grouch is your least favorite song on Nimrod haha It's SO good imo

    • @paullap88
      @paullap88 6 лет назад +8

      I agree. Green Day's the Grouch is excellent.

    • @craigpatrick1
      @craigpatrick1 6 лет назад +9

      thats my favorite on Nimrod

    • @d00r9
      @d00r9 5 лет назад

      Ik,I also love it

    • @antboyttt509
      @antboyttt509 5 лет назад

      Dirty Dave Hill my least favorite is Haushinka

    • @d00r9
      @d00r9 5 лет назад

      @@antboyttt509 i think its ok

  • @flucyd
    @flucyd 7 лет назад +24

    Nimrod is my favourite album hitchin a ride's bass is a masterpiece and is one of my all time favourite songs

  • @Amber_xo_133
    @Amber_xo_133 3 года назад +8

    The Father of all album is Green Day's final album to be released by Reprise Records as the band confirmed that they had fulfilled their contract with the label.

  • @mrtroller9979
    @mrtroller9979 7 лет назад +14

    21st century breakdown, discovery and nimrod are my favourite albums of all time

  • @j6154
    @j6154 7 лет назад +8

    Good review, little disappointed one of my 2nd favourite song by them didn’t even make the top 5 of 1,039 (road to acceptance), but overall great review

  • @94jmbottaro
    @94jmbottaro 7 лет назад +17

    i think green day is one big story of how this kid (in the first album) grows up to start a revolution. all the events leading to revrad

  • @NKRevolution
    @NKRevolution 8 лет назад +7

    Fantastic video

  • @caxx1943
    @caxx1943 6 лет назад +34

    Green Day sounds like the misfits tried to play The Who
    Most pop punk bands sound like if the misfits played abba
    As I see it Green Day is NOT pop punk. They sound more like classic rock with a punk rock sheen. At least that’s my take

    • @lil_pemsiofficial9268
      @lil_pemsiofficial9268 5 лет назад +4

      Caxx The Misfits? The legendary New Jersey horror/hardcore punk band with Glenn Danzig singing about killing people? Them trying to play The Who sounds like Green Day?
      I have so many questions

    • @ShadowRM72
      @ShadowRM72 4 года назад

      ​@@lil_pemsiofficial9268 That's what he says xd

  • @v11cu96
    @v11cu96 5 лет назад +3

    Thanks for giving Insomniac some much needed love!

  • @louiethorne1955
    @louiethorne1955 6 лет назад +9

    UNO isn’t great, but let yourself go Is so great imo

  • @tannerjamesmusic3945
    @tannerjamesmusic3945 7 лет назад +19

    dont get me wrong good riddance is a great song but ITS OVERRATED

    • @pumatech49x9
      @pumatech49x9 6 лет назад +1

      Bruh who cares what other people think

  • @swiggityswooty6814
    @swiggityswooty6814 4 года назад

    Your music tastes are soooo good. Makes me love this channel so much

  • @andrewvallee5738
    @andrewvallee5738 7 лет назад +9

    Hey dude do you listen to the descendents? They are considered to be the godfathers of pop punk

  • @greaseballjones7705
    @greaseballjones7705 6 лет назад +5

    I like how you didn't even bother ranking Uno and Dos😂 For real though the trilogy broke my heart a little.

    • @geoschilling
      @geoschilling 2 года назад +2

      I really enjoy the trilogy, every single song on uno is high energy and exciting. Love it, Dos is the worst of the three. But still has some good material. And tre is cool, all have good songs

  • @alexanderchilton911
    @alexanderchilton911 8 лет назад

    Guess who just found a new favorite channel

  • @mr.breakfast_3theoneandonl25
    @mr.breakfast_3theoneandonl25 6 лет назад +6

    And I gotta disagree with you on the thing that Dookie is their best album

  • @noc_yt
    @noc_yt 6 лет назад

    Oh my god thank you so much for giving Insomniac the credit it deserves. I almost like the album more than dookie (almost) because of songs like Panic Song which like you said i never hear people talk about so it's so refreshing to finally hear someone give it some praise.

  • @matteopera3479
    @matteopera3479 3 года назад +1

    Actually I love all their discography, except for Father Of All...(I like Sugar Youth and Meet Me On The Roof), although there are surely some highs and lows

  • @samuelblinne6040
    @samuelblinne6040 6 лет назад +3

    I love 39 smooth

  • @delimex3795
    @delimex3795 10 месяцев назад

    Dawn (posting after the announcement) you said most pop punk bands are bad i would understand it just depends on which ones your talking about.

  • @mr.breakfast_3theoneandonl25
    @mr.breakfast_3theoneandonl25 6 лет назад +2

    I always really liked the trilogy, I think it's definitely better than 39/smooth and the trilogy doesn't deserve all the hate it gets I think. Dos I think is the best out of the three.

  • @chickennoodlegamer915
    @chickennoodlegamer915 Год назад

    I honestly love all of green days discography. 21st century breakdown is where they peaked imo, and I also agree the trilogy is their worst work, but I still really like songs off the trilogy and father of all is a fun album too
    (also completely unrelated but I dont agree with green day being pop-punk. I've heard alot of pop-punk music and green day is way more punk)

  • @samfrehley786
    @samfrehley786 10 месяцев назад

    My personal ranking of the albums (including Shenanigans):
    14: Father Of All Motherfuckers (1/10)
    13: ¡Uno! (2/10)
    12: ¡Dos! (3.5/10)
    11: Revolution Radio (4.5/10)
    10: Warning (6/10)
    9: 39/Smooth (6/10)
    8: American Idiot (I’m not sorry) (7.5/10)
    7: Shenanigans (8/10)
    6: ¡Tre! (8.5/10)
    5: 21st Century Breakdown (8.5/10)
    4: Nimrod (9.5/10)
    3: Dookie (10/10)
    2: Insomniac (10/10)
    1: Kerplunk! (10/10)
    Father Of All is almost unforgivable. The title track has decent instrumentation and Sugar Youth is a passable song and that’s it. Uno and Dos are pretty bad too. I like RevRad, But there’s a lot of forgettable tracks and outright bad ones too. Warning isn’t really that bad, But I don’t find myself coming back to it very often. I find American Idiot incredibly overrated but mainly because I’ve burnt out every song on the album for myself. Shenanigans is pretty damn good. Not many complaints there. Tre is a pretty damn solid album with songs like 8th Avenue Serenade, X-Kid, Dirty Rotten Bastards etc. 21st Century Breakdown is pretty kickass, But it’s a bit too long and there is filler to be found. I’m also pretty pissed American Eulogy didn’t end the album. Nimrod is the same case. Dookie and Insomniac are pretty interchangeable and both are damn near flawless leaving Kerplunk as one of my favorite albums of all time.
    Sorry for the rant, But I’m also pretty scared of the new one coming out next year. I really love this band and they were the band that got me into music. Anyways, Great video man! I’ve watched it once every few months for the past few years and I wanted to make my own thoughts clear though not exactly needed. Thank you to anyone who actually read this whole thing lol

  • @joeydigiorno9581
    @joeydigiorno9581 6 лет назад +2

    You dont like the grouch?

  • @joshgulisano1863
    @joshgulisano1863 6 лет назад +1

    I used to work at this toy store, and one of the worst aspects of working there was probably the fact that good riddance was played I wanna say about everyday and every 30 minutes. I am now sick of this song, which is sad because it is a genuinely gorgeous piece. It just gets played too much.

  • @kunalsharma2098
    @kunalsharma2098 5 лет назад +1

    Trilogy, specially Uno was actually good not bad, won't agree on that.
    Put overall Trilogy was really something really shocking at its worst coming from a big Green Day fan.
    Still love Green Day obviously for life, and Revolution Radio do make them back to form.

  • @MysticClaws100
    @MysticClaws100 6 лет назад +4

    Hey, have you given Demolicious a try? It's basically just demos of the Uno, Dos, Tré songs. Many people prefer them to the actual studio albums, you might too

    • @louiethorne1955
      @louiethorne1955 6 лет назад

      MysticManiac100 tbh I find that weird, there just the same songs, but not polished

    • @remyvilleneuve4879
      @remyvilleneuve4879 5 лет назад

      Yeah... I don’t understand why people would like them more.

  • @PrototheDodo
    @PrototheDodo 4 года назад +1

    I feel like they kind of fell off during Trilogy era but came back HARD with Rev Radio.

  • @mr.kakashi9579
    @mr.kakashi9579 6 лет назад +1

    In may opinion, I think that insomniac, nimrod, and warning are really underated compared to the two giants of good albums know as Dookie, and my personal favorite album, American idiot

  • @Joelster-og4pf
    @Joelster-og4pf Год назад

    1: Nimrod
    2: Dookie
    3: Warning
    4: Insomniac
    5: American Idiot
    6: Revolution Radio
    7: Kerplunk
    8: 39/Smooth
    9: 21st Century Breakdown
    10: DOS!
    11: UNO!
    12: Father Of All…
    13: TRE!
    The first five, I love every single song on that album.
    The first two GD albums and Rev Rad are good listens.
    21st Century Breakdown is a little bloated.
    The trilogy, I don’t hate. I think there are some nice songs through every one of them, but there still are some meh and dull songs.
    Father Of All is a little lazy, but the first half is ok. Plus, Graffitia is good.

  • @drainedeyes4268
    @drainedeyes4268 6 лет назад

    Goddamn dude I totally agree with you on American Idiot not being a political story. The beauty of it is that it's specific and cohesive enough to feel like it has a plot, yet subtle and abstract enough to be able to put yourself in it at times. I love the Jesus/Jimmy dichotomy and the reveal that Jimmy was a persona and not a person. Great shit. I found this album when it came out, and just finished listening to it from front to back again, and it doesn't matter how many post rock, shoegaze, or revival punk holes I fall down, this record will always feel near perfect to me. I agreed with pretty much every point you made in this video, spot on.

  • @nikiyerbamate
    @nikiyerbamate 6 лет назад +2

    IMO Uno is everything you said it was. I think Dos, however, is better than Tre. F*** Time is terrible and so is Nightlife, but apart from that I think Dos is a really solid record.
    I suppose my least favorite track here apart from the MAJOR two blunders here is Ashley, and even that's pretty decent.
    And Wow! That's Loud is EXTREMELY overlooked.
    Just my opinion, nothing against you.

  • @G00B3RR1L3Y
    @G00B3RR1L3Y 8 лет назад +3

    Would be cool to see a retrospective of R.E.M. If you're into them.

  • @hadinasrallah8928
    @hadinasrallah8928 6 лет назад

    how the fuck is a 500 sub dude way better than 99% of the "music critics" on yt? this is good shit

  • @sagiepuff
    @sagiepuff 4 года назад

    It makes sense! It isn’t weird, it’s catchy.

  • @dombrown7513
    @dombrown7513 2 года назад

    How is the grouch your least favourite on nimrod? It’s so good and “Last ride in” is so boring there’s nothing to it

  • @tommydolan4281
    @tommydolan4281 7 лет назад +1

    hard to say green day is the only good pop punk band when alkaline trio exists but w/e. great reviews.
    listen to goddamnit youll love

  • @DrewpBalls935
    @DrewpBalls935 4 года назад +2

    Why does ever body hate Know you enemy And UNO,DOS, TRE

    • @grug9789
      @grug9789 3 года назад

      Know your enemy is just
      ✨no✨

    • @DrewpBalls935
      @DrewpBalls935 3 года назад

      @@grug9789 know you enemy
      YES

    • @grug9789
      @grug9789 3 года назад

      @@DrewpBalls935 it’s just way too repetitive

  • @BennSimonn
    @BennSimonn 2 года назад

    I love Pulling Teeth

  • @simont1299
    @simont1299 5 лет назад

    Did not realise Green Day had this many releases.

  • @v-g-z3689
    @v-g-z3689 5 лет назад

    I think the reason why people hate the Trilogy is because nowerdays, nobody can take the sound of 60´s rock ´n´ roll anymore. It is a very old-fashioned Sound, that very fiew bands can pull off nowerdays. To me, the Trilogy celebrates Sex, Drugs and Rock ´n´roll in the best way possible. Go to a dirty party (maybe a fancy dress party) in a small, sweaty location, get fuckin wasted, possibly pop some pills. Let the DJ Play 60´s rock´n´roll like the Kinks or so. Mix in 1/3 of Green Day´s Songs from Uno Dos and Tre throughout the night and you will love the Trilogy.

  • @switchblade9records
    @switchblade9records 4 года назад +1

    Let ur self go is a good song

  • @craigpatrick1
    @craigpatrick1 6 лет назад

    Insomniac and Kerplunk are my favorite 2

  • @howbuska7214
    @howbuska7214 4 года назад +1

    Did you listen to the new Green Day Album?

  • @itzartixyt9782
    @itzartixyt9782 2 года назад

    I can agree with you ranking Dos! album. Tbh in my opinion "Fuck Time" is so weird and cringe

  • @ethanthebigmuscleman
    @ethanthebigmuscleman 3 года назад

    Nightlife is not their best but it has one of my fav bass lines in any gd song ever

  • @weakweek85
    @weakweek85 Год назад

    There’s a lot of good stuff on the trilogy. It’s criminally underrated. Is it great? No? Garbage? Also no

  • @jacinto1477
    @jacinto1477 4 года назад

    Video is good, but I completely disagree with what you said about nimrod and warning.

  • @charlietheoneonly16
    @charlietheoneonly16 2 года назад

    This man ranks No Pride as the worst song from insomniac. You just ruined my day.

  • @mr.kakashi9579
    @mr.kakashi9579 6 лет назад

    Again, I get it it is your opinion, but my least favorite song from this album is extraordinary girl, but that's because it really doesn't stand out for me but, it is still pretty good

  • @Jeroen_Penninck
    @Jeroen_Penninck 7 лет назад +10

    Ok, I see you've put many effort in making this video.
    But please say punk rock instead of pop punk.
    That's my only complaint, great review otherwise.

    • @Jeroen_Penninck
      @Jeroen_Penninck 7 лет назад +1

      In their early early years they were surely punk and no mention of pop at all, later they became a pop-punk band..

    • @Jeroen_Penninck
      @Jeroen_Penninck 7 лет назад

      Ok that's true, everyone has their own opinion on that, I am happy that i can discuss with someone that has a clear poin-of-view instead of some dudes that just hate shit for no reason.

    • @Jeroen_Penninck
      @Jeroen_Penninck 7 лет назад

      Ok thanks for the recommandation, I will check it out!

  • @nishchalrawal9182
    @nishchalrawal9182 3 года назад

    I was laughing at your expression, when UNO came and at last you were begging REVRAD to be better than trilogy and it was good yeah. But were you aware that Father of all.....was on it's way lmao

  • @thetonytaye
    @thetonytaye 7 лет назад

    I'm wearing that same shirt right now

  • @Caleb904
    @Caleb904 6 лет назад

    When I first discovered Green Day through my friends I bought American idiot, and I said i didn’t like Jesus of suburbia because it was too long. Man I was an idiot

  • @daanpauwels2280
    @daanpauwels2280 7 лет назад +1

    Dookie and Nimrod are GREAT, the rest is good, not one album is bad like you said. American Idiot is overrated but contains two of the greatest songs ever recorderded; Jesus of Suburbia and Give Me Novacaine. Tré is the worst of the trilogy though... but better than Revolution Radio (because it's the most overproduced AND has the worst songwriting).

  • @DanceOfTheDawn5963
    @DanceOfTheDawn5963 4 года назад

    You look like jared dines if younger him had long hair

  • @tyde4610
    @tyde4610 4 года назад +1

    Fire, Ready, Aim is pretty bad, maybe even worse than Nightlife

  • @uhno1939
    @uhno1939 3 года назад

    THE TRILOGY IS BETTER THAN FUCKING DOOKIE

  • @carlosgarciaruiz1102
    @carlosgarciaruiz1102 4 года назад

    I assume you don't know the buzzcoks if you think green day is de BEST or first pop punk band

  • @davidsepulveda5961
    @davidsepulveda5961 Месяц назад

    6:05

  • @Joela393
    @Joela393 3 года назад

    You mention how pretentious it is to mention that you had a album list or whatever but you keep saying fuck the radio?

  • @jojonr619
    @jojonr619 7 лет назад +2

    l really like the trilogy

  • @StJimmy-hj1bo
    @StJimmy-hj1bo 6 лет назад

    can we just enjoy music and not let this sort of bullshit bring people down.

  • @kv6256
    @kv6256 5 лет назад

    They fell off after Nimrod.

  • @lillianbookout7777
    @lillianbookout7777 7 лет назад +3

    Green Day is not pop punk

    • @Luke-cp2jz
      @Luke-cp2jz 7 лет назад +2

      I'd say so. They're before pop punk got really popular but they're too mainstream for punk I think

    • @IMSvideos13
      @IMSvideos13 6 лет назад +3

      I beg to dream and differ.

    • @fannytoothnana6853
      @fannytoothnana6853 5 лет назад

      Lillian Bookout They are.

    • @litigatedparadox8946
      @litigatedparadox8946 4 года назад

      IMS Productions from the hollow lies

  • @jackko21
    @jackko21 6 лет назад +1

    Now they are over produced pop punk emo

    • @aleksandarmarkovic221
      @aleksandarmarkovic221 5 лет назад

      you're telling me Nimrod is overproduced emo?

    • @litigatedparadox8946
      @litigatedparadox8946 4 года назад

      You’re telling me that Green Day is emo?

    • @jackko21
      @jackko21 3 года назад

      @@litigatedparadox8946 yep they wear black eye shadow and have the emo hair style nowadays

  • @nathanhillier7499
    @nathanhillier7499 7 лет назад +3

    personally I love uno dos and tre as a whole more than dookie

    • @kelvinbiancamore3366
      @kelvinbiancamore3366 7 лет назад +12

      You're on drugs

    • @mrtroller9979
      @mrtroller9979 7 лет назад +5

      Дарья Анжелика or has a different opinion than you?

    • @sonja3204
      @sonja3204 6 лет назад

      I'm curious as to why that is. ( I'm a Uno,Dos,Tré fan as well)

    • @windews3227
      @windews3227 6 лет назад +2

      Your opinion is wrong
      It's a joke god dammit

    • @LunaticSmile88
      @LunaticSmile88 6 лет назад

      nathan hillier of

  • @kieranrobinson6203
    @kieranrobinson6203 8 лет назад

    Very opinionated. You clearly feel your opinion is the only one that is worthy of being listened to. And you don't understand this band at all may I add.

    • @bjorksarmpits148
      @bjorksarmpits148 7 лет назад +12

      Kieran Robinson you're only saying that because you don't agree with him, it's a review, OF COURSE HE'S GONNA HAVE OPINIONS

    • @litigatedparadox8946
      @litigatedparadox8946 4 года назад

      He’s just sharing his opinions it seems like he’s acting as if his opinion is the most important because he’s the one making the video