The Half-elves of Middle-earth
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 янв 2021
- The Half-elves of Middle-earth were small in number but crucial to the story and the survival of the kindreds of Men and Elves. Thank you all so much for watching, let me know your thoughts on the Peredhil in the comments below! As always, a great thanks to the online artists whose visual works made this video possible! If you are one of the artists, please let me know and I will post your name and a link to your work in this description!
#Silmarillion
#LordoftheRings
#Tolkien
#Lore
Consider donating to our Patreon for the Westernesse Podcast and Discord Server:
/ menofthewest
Check out our Merch:
www.spreadshirt.com/user/Yoys...
Check out our music channel:
/ @musicmotw
Join us on Facebook at:
/ yoystan
Join us on Twitter at:
/ yoystan
Related articles:
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Half-e...
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Mithre...
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Elwing
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Eldarion
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/E%C3%A...
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Elrond
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Elros
The Tale of Beren and Lúthien (Silmarillion) (Updated) - Part I:
• The Tale of Beren and ...
The Ruin of Doriath - Timeline of Arda #8:
• The Ruin of Doriath - ...
The Tale of the Fall of Gondolin (Silmarillion) - Part I:
• The Tale of the Fall o...
Lord Elrond Half-elven - Epic Character History:
• Lord Elrond Half-elven...
Elros Tar-Minyatur, First King of Númenor - Epic Character History:
• Elros Tar-Minyatur, Fi...
The Darkening of Númenor - Timeline of Arda #11:
• The Darkening and End ...
Thank you for your (Valar and Elf tiers) patronage!
Adrian De la Torre
Peter Sheppard
Chris Ortner
Blair Scouten
Samuel McBee
Jonathan Putnam
Mark Kralick
Tobias Göldner
Adam Rink
Merten
Ryan Ramsay
John Hume
Diego Perez
Berni McCoy
Daniel Orlandi
John Crowley
Susan Henry
Atlas
Maz Gibs
Ryan Warren
Renato Filipe
Imiel Elenen
Chiara Siasat
Tyler Lund
Hydro Knight
Joshua W
Ádám Kis
Memory Troll
Dale Starbuck
Dan Mazzei
April Green
Corwin Nemeth
Bryar Keyes
Matthew Rivas
Holy
OneErlend
Hjertholm
Metalguy87
The new Men of the West logo was created by Raffe - Twitter: RaffetheRandom
The final image “Bag End” was created by Wayne Glassbrook at designly.net
The first song was developed and produced by my associate Galafee.
The last song used in this video is from:
library.techsmith.com/
Many related and/or used art come from these artists and sources:
Ted Nasmith:
www.tednasmith.com/
Jenny Dolfen:
goldseven.wordpress.com/
Alan Lee:
www.iamag.co/the-art-of-alan-...
John Howe:
www.john-howe.com/portfolio/g...
Hildebrant brothers:
www.brothershildebrandt.com/Br...
DonatoArts:
www.deviantart.com/donatoarts
Magali Villeneuve
www.magali-villeneuve.com/
Wolfanita:
www.deviantart.com/wolfanita
Gerwell:
/ gerwell
Mirach Ravaia:
www.deviantart.com/mirachrava...
Kaprriss:
www.deviantart.com/kaprriss/g...
EKukanova:
www.deviantart.com/ekukanova/...
steamy:
www.deviantart.com/steamey
Laurelinartistry:
/ laurelinartistry
SaMo-art:
www.deviantart.com/samo-art/g...
kimberly80:
www.deviantart.com/kimberly80...
Anke Eissmann:
anke.edoras-art.de/anke_illust...
Matthew Stewart:
www.matthew-stewart.com/middle...
Sara Morello:
www.artstation.com/artwork/Z5...
Justin Gerard:
www.artstation.com/artwork/BB1k4
SarkaSkorpikova:
www.deviantart.com/sarkaskorp...
alystraea:
www.deviantart.com/alystraea/...
www.deviantart.com/alystraea/...
SaMo-art:
www.deviantart.com/samo-art/a...
annoulaki:
www.deviantart.com/annoulaki/...
fawwaz1:
www.deviantart.com/fawwaz1/ar...
maril1:
www.deviantart.com/maril1/art...
"Elves can die of a broken heart."
Oh! So Padme was an elf, got it.
Dying of a broken heart is a real tragedy that can and has happened. In fact, Carry Fisher's mother died of a broken heart not long after her daughter passed.
@@teleportedbreadfor3days I though it was because too much partying in the 80's
@@alfonsocaballero3630 No, it was of a broken heart. She was devastated.
@@teleportedbreadfor3days Debbie Reynolds story still gives me the goosebumps even today each time I remember it as her fate literally mirrors the fate of Padme, who coincidently happens to be Leia's/Carrie Fisher's mother in the Star Wars Saga as both died of a broken heart. It might be just coincidence but still creepy nonetheless
takotsubo syndrome is the medical term for a broken heart
Remember all this came from the mind of one man, incredible
Look into Tolkien beeing a fremason and how he was granted access to fremasonic libraries of the real history of this earth. We are a much older species than we have been told. And we never imigrated from Africa, ever.
@@nicholas5569 lmao!
@@nicholas5569 Utter rubbish. Professor Tolkien would reject this for the nonsense it is.
@@nicholas5569 Well said.
@@Dyrnwynn there was many family members of tolkien in the masons whether he was one himself idk. I always thought tolkien believed in ancient cultures from the past because the numenoreans suffered the same fate as Atlantis where they went from a divine society who fell into greed and the gods then destroyed them. Atlantis is most likely fake but the connection could be there for tolkiens inspiration
The half elves changed the paths of both races. Each age had their own half elf that would change Middle Earth.
They indeed were instruments of Eru-Ilúvatar's will.
Luthien and Earendil of the first age.
Their descendents (earendils twins) elros and elrond of the 2nd.
Galador and elronds children in the third age.
Arwen reintroduced the blood of The first king of numenor back into the line of Kings being the niece of Elros.
Arwen and her brothers were given the life of thd Eldar because of their Fathers' choice. They didn't have to make a choice, until Arwen rejected immortality in order to stay with Aragorn. Arwen actually gave her place aboard the ship to the undying lands, to Frodo. She said, " in my stead, you shall go, Ringbearer."
Correct
who gave their place to Bilbo?
Thats just movie crap. Arwen and his brothers had the choice
@@krishacz Valar gave Bilbo and Gimli the chance to go to Valinor
@@arckocsog253 her brothers, but yes. when elrond left, his children had to decide as well, whether to leave with him as elves, or to stay and die as men. Im sure i read that the twins made the same choice as their sister and stayed.
Genuinely bought all the books because of this channel
A wise investment
I hope they've enriched your life as they have mine! 👍
Bought all of them like 14 year ago in england...best purchased ever
Enjoy!
That's a lot of books! It took me a couple of years to get them all.
I’m currently hanging out in hell with my master because halflings destroyed my jewelry.
@Boomstick McNugget lol yeah
good for the halflings.
Don't worry you'll have company soon, I think a cousin just showed up this week?
Oh my got so funny so humorous. I dying laughing. I det now.
Youre still alive as a spirit,you both but can not take a form again
I've long felt that Tolkien's works were about the "fall from grace" (for lack of a better term) of the world. Seeing first hand the depravity of WWI, he tried to answer the question of "how did we come to this?" He created a mythology for Britain, and it was a tale that stretched from creation, to the utopia of Valinor, to repeated downfalls over thousands of years until we come to us mundane folks of Middle Earth. The half-elves represent that last legacy of what could have been. A tragic tale of something divine that has been lost.
The Silmarillion was essentially the story of the Elves fall from grace then their later redemption, paralleling in part the story of Adam and Eve up to and including Jesus Christ. Men or rather the Dunedain, followed a similar path of sorts with the blessing of the island of Numenor and longer lives, their rise and slow decline over the centuries until Aragorn and Arwen's union created a final reconciliation between elves and men. Tolkien did say that Britain lacked it's own mythology and that was one of his motivations behind his works. WWI no doubt shaped a lot of Tolkien's views going forward and he incorporates those experiences into his works with the fall of Gondolin, the War of Wrath, the Dead Marshes, etc. his works could be considered antiwar depending on how you interpret them, not so much on the nose as GRRM's A Song of Ice and Fire, but more in terms of the cost of war and fighting the inevitable, in Tolkien's time that was industrialization (i.e. the Scouring of the Shire) and how the rural agrarian country side he grew up in and loved was slowly disappearing to this new urban mechanized environment. The cost of war could be measured up in Frodo's experiences and ultimate fate having to leave because of the physical and emotional trauma, kind of like how many veterans struggle for the rest of their lives to learn to live with their physical and mental scars of war.
It wasn't just WWI, Tolkin was a devouth Catholic and the "fall from grace" is a major theme in Catholicism.
@@noahshreve5237 I see an additional overarching message: the good in the world lies in living and immaterial things. The need for the material - and to possess it, not just enjoy it - is where temptation to evil resides. Hence: Silmarils (in itself beautiful and not evil, until people try to claim them - their restoration to the earth is for the benefit of all), Dwarves 'delving too deep;, the Arkenstone, Smaug etc. The preservation of that is not a fruitless effort - it is a necessary one for the survival of all living beings. Those that understand this, or simply live by it, are the heroes of these stories and the keepers of the earth.
@@Knight860 Great comment. I often think that JRRT chose Samwise to be the unlikely hero as a hat tip to all the ordinary men of the British shires and counties without whom the Great War could never have been won, in the same way Frodo would never have achieved his mission without Sam carrying him - literally! - to do it.
@@Asgard2208 True along with Bilbo, Frodo, Merry and Pippin, they all are unlikely heroes whom no one expected much out of even Gandalf was amazed by their courage and determination.
Humans can die of a broken heart. I don't mean humans in Middle Earth but real, you and I humans. My great grandmother lived to be 96 years old and by all doctor accounts, was as healthy as she could be and it was expected that she would go on living for many years yet. My father, as well as her son, two daughters, three grandchildren all died around her and of those were included the family that lived nearby her and she truly felt alone and had a broken heart. She didn't pass away until she actually wanted to. She truly died of a broken heart and lost the will to go on. Such a great lady.
I'm sorry to hear about that Strifegar, she does sound like a wonderful lady.
I love the parallels between Beren + Lúthien and Aragorn + Arwen. The first time I saw the extended edition of the fellowship of the ring I lost my mind when Aragorn was singing the Lay of Lúthien
That part of the movie is beautiful. Its amazing piece of writing to have the two stories. Intertwine.
The sons of Elrond stayed in Rivendell into the fourth age with Celeborn. While Celeborn eventually sailed to the undying lands the fate of the sons of Elrond is unresolved. It’s never said if they sailed west or not
ummm Celeborn is doing something fishy....what is he doing with both of his grandkids at rivendell when his waifu and people all went to the west? ......."now that my waifu is not here...i can finally came out of the closet"- Celeborn. xD
@@wewenang5167 actually something else came to mind, celeborn also lived before his wife’s people arrived, witnessed time fading that was around them. He basically stuck around longer in middle earth for nostalgic reasons to relive the early days of elves after their sundering when they still lived under the stars, before the destruction of the two trees in Valinor, and the sap and fruit of those trees used to create the sun and moon.
One of my favourite topics, and one that people underestimate the importance of! Great job, my friend.
Thanks Dan, I really appreciate it, my friend!
I like anything with the elves. In the stories I've always felt safe when the heros stayed with the elves, but was alway sad when they had to leave.
"I would rather spend one lifetime with you then spend all the ages of this world alone"
Man I dont know if I could choose between being immortal or mortal. Both pros and cons would weigh in my mind and if I loved someone who didn't have the choice? 🥺
But from a biological standpoint its incredibly interesting!!! Did they become human once they chose? Did they retain their elven features and just age? I'm probably reading too much into it but they are one of the most unique beings
You made great points and asked such important questions. I’m also interested and curious to know their answers.
It's hard to say, isn't it? I almost don't want to believe that the moment that Elrond decided to be an elf that his ears might've become suddenly pointier.
The abilities of men seem so much harder to define, too. At least with elves we have a knowledge of farsight, a light step, and greater agility. Its almost bizarre to imagine Elrond acquiring these abilities at the time of his choice.. Equally bizarre is if that we assume that half-elves already had elven abilities, and so that this meant that Elros, when he accepted the Doom of Men, *lost* his ability to be more graceful and see further.
It's all a bit convoluted, but I've always thought of half elves that have not chosen their fate to just be elven by default.
Their Elven features would be the brightness of their 'spirit/power' and sight (meaning their ability to see the world), I doubt these would fade with age, as the Numenroean kings retained all faculties even with great age, and knew when it was time. Those who rejected heir time and held one became old and crippled and lost their strength. Aragorn stayed to the old way and when he knew it was his time, he lay down to die voluntarily.
@@user-xe2hl7cj4c nah..tolkien never said any of the elves in his creation got pointy ears lol
@@wewenang5167 yeah. He said that they're closely identical to Men. So they're probably like Men but taller and more graceful-like, more ethereal perhaps.
Ahhh an awesome LOTR lore video and a large Domino’s Pizza 🍕. Perfect way to end the week. God bless and Thank you Mr. West 😎👍🏼.
The bond shared between the first and second children of Iluvatar is one of my favorite themes in Tolkien's works. It is always beautiful when that bound gives birth to love.
Felt arwen died an elf much like faenor's mom. She chose to move on dont know if mandos will allow her to meet her husband in the after life without permission from eru
She chose the fate of men, she imparts to Aragorn that mortality is her choice instead of a rewind to her previous status after Aragorn dies. She dies like the ancient Numenoreans died, willingly and quietly. Greater than the usual kind of death.
She chose like Luthien, to be mortal and eventually leave the world like other Men.
Half elves, but no less iconic than the pure bred elves.
Well, actually Elrond and Elros are more elf than human. 56% elf, 38% human and 6% Maiar.
I get the sense that "The Choice" is more a matter of association rather than a once-and-for-all choosing. Earendil chose to be elven because he was stuck with elves and Ainur until the end of Arda. Elros wanted to be King of Numenor so, he chose mortality. Elrond lives in Rivendell with a bunch of Elven refugees. So, he chose to be counted as an elf. The choice seems to depend on the company you intend to keep.
Great video yoystan and to add to your question about Arwen I believe she and her brothers were given the choice to either be elves or humans and I think she was human she just decided to pass away in a special place that was important to both her and Aragorn. As for her brothers I think they stayed in middle earth until Arwen passed and they said goodbye to their nieces and nephew before leaving for the undying lands to be with the rest of the eldar!
If Legolas was able to recognise the "look" of a part-Elf human when meeting Prince Imrahil, perhaps there were more Elf/Man crosses than the ones in the histories. Maybe the Silvan realms were more relaxed about the purity of their bloodlines.
Have you ever wondered how awkward it was when Elrond finally turned up in the West without any of the children that Celebrian hadn't seen in over 500 years?
Another great video Yoystan! I found it quite intriguing when I was reading the Silmarillion and the appendices at the end of ROTK for the fact that each of these pairings set up some of the biggest stories and also becoming some of the most powerful families in Middle Earth and how they are all connected from Beren and Luthien up to Aragorn and Arwen.
So freaking good man. Whenever I watch your videos - for that brief duration whilst watching, I forget all the troubles of our own world, being immersed once again in the world of Tolkien. Just brilliant.
In 1981 I was married to an elven beauty. Alas, as you said about dying from a broken heart. She died in 2011 from a broken heart after our son had died early that year in January. Her gentle soul could not bear the loss of our son in a fire. I do not know how it was born by my soul.
This stranger is sorry for your loss. I truly cannot imagine it.
May you find solace in your grief ❤️
Yay, I didn’t realize how much I wanted this video! 🥰 As always, well done and highly informative. 👏🏻👏🏻
I'm so happy I found this channel! I've been fascinated in recent months in the world of Arda and it's history. This channel has been pivotal in my endeavor. Thank you for your time effort toward your content!
An especially enjoyable video! Thank you for all the work you do! This channel is a bright spot on RUclips!
Thank you. Another great video by the best source of Tolkien on RUclips. Please, keep up the excellent work!
Great video as always Yoystan!
I really enjoyed this one! Thank you for clarifying certain questions; I had no idea there were so many elvish/human love stories. Looking forward to the video on Aragorn and Arwen (last year's on Faramir and Eowyn is still one of my very favorite RUclips videos, which I revisit frequently).
Great Video on the Half-Elves!
May the Stars watch over you!
Another great video, Thank you for all your hard work and after finishing the Silmarillian myself your Timline of arda series is really great too :)
*Happy New year my friend! Thank you for all the great content!
Hello Yoystan,
Thank you so much for this video and especially thank you for finally explaining to me the mystery of the elvish blood in Prince Imrahil. He is one of my favorite characters. He is in the story for such a brief time and gets overlooked in all the adaptions, like Bombadil. For me though, his characterization makes him practically on the same level of hero as Aragorn.
Thanks,
Javier
I’ve been wanting to watch this one for a while. Great 👍
You have provided RUclips with an invaluable resource, sir. I thank you!!
Fantastic as always Yoystan!
Beautiful video. Would you be so kind to do one on Elladan and Elrohir? You always seem to be able to find even the tiniest bit of information on your subjects that is not common knowledge. Very admirable.
Elladan and Elrohir also appear in the fanfiction video Born of Hope.
Elrond’s children had to travel to Valinor with him when he departed, or they would share the fate of men. The Tale of Years tells us that both Elladan and Elohir stayed in Middle Earth with the grandfather Cleleborn for a time
Thanks. Great subject. I like your professor Tolkien in memoriam on the community page earlier
Amazing video as always!!
i like to think that Elrond's children were given the same opportunity to choose their path. mainly because the idea that Arwen would never again meet Aragorn in the afterlife is very sad.
Haven’t watched one of your videos in like 6 months, so I’ve got some hectic bingeing to do😂
"Hectic binging." Beautiful phrase 😂
Great topic for the next video. I cant wait!!!
Great subject I've wondered about
Perhaps you are half human half Ilúvatar. Truly this would make sense, with such power and depth in your voice. It could only be so
No, he is Tom Bombadil actually
Aha yes! I like the Peredhil and their stories.
My man posting a vid right before I call it a night
Unfortunately, as confirmed by Christopher Tolkien, Dior and his twin sons were mortal... because Manwe, in contemplating Earendil's fate, stated that all beings with even a drop of mortal blood, inherit the Gift of Men. But Eru gave to Manwe authority to decide the fate of those whose inheritance included the fate of immortals and mortals alike.... and as we all know, the decision was made to let the half-elf choose. But before this decision was made, both Dior and presumably his sons, had already died, with their inheritance of the fate of men being default.
Love the content and want to ask, if you have one, what is your favorite Middle Earth story out of the collective work? Mine is definitely the Fall of Gondolin, the stand alone novel was fantastic
Thank you for the support, my friend! Ah that is too difficult a question to answer. For me, it really depends on the mood I am in. Sometimes, The Hobbit and that adventure is just what I need, when at others I need the deepness and philosophy of the Silmarillion, or the epicness of the LOTR. I love it all!
@@MenoftheWest I too love it all, very much, and have ever since the animated films introduced me to the world, long before I saw the live action films or read the books
Akallabeth
Your pronunciation of Earendil reminds me of birdsong. That's awesome.
Picked up LotR again, on Audiobook, thanks to this channel
I haven't delved into this level of escapism since my teenage years...
I ❤️ Sunday nights in Middle Earth
🍻
A very great video as always Men of the West.
Beautiful
I always wonder about this half elves hope it a good video stay safe and as always I bid you stand men of the west
The choice given to Arwen was to marry Aragorn and have a mortal life & death or sail into the west and live as Elves, bound within arda, deathless, for as long as arda endures. So obviously she did get to make "The choice of the half-elven." As I understand it, if they chose to be counted among the Elves then the next generation would be able to make the choice as well, but once a half-elf had chosen to be counted among Men then the next generation wouldn't be able to make the choice.
☹️
I really love this channel and the work that goes into it. Especially the art work. While I love and appreciate the Peter Jackson adaptations, it's nice to see the work that came before it as well.
Yay! A nice late night surprise for me while in bed! Can’t wait to watch!
Thanks!
The Line of Imrazor and Mithrellas also continued in the House of Stewards (or the House of the Princes of Ithilien) because Denethor's wife, the mother of Boromir and Faramir, was Prince Imrahil's sister
Nice Mellon, right before 1pm...A video on one of the smallest species *in numbers, not size* of Middle Earth!!!
It's Interesting you brought up the Children of Hurin, I am currently rereading it for the 100,000th or so time...
But this the first time I read it after seeing The Mandalorian, and I honestly could see Pedro Pascal as Turin...it's weird!!!
Tell me what you think about that Fan Cast idea, But until what happened in the north during the War of the Ring, Marion Baggins Out!!!
Arwen's fate is a little hard to pin down, but the strong impression I've always had was that she had never thought about her choice that much (being quite young) until she met Aragorn. At that moment, "her doom fell on her", and she knew what would happen. She loved him and would have to give up everything to have him. She was spared making the actual decision because of Elrond's charge that Aragorn had to reunite the kingdoms and win the crown, so the decision was put off. But when everything went down, she put her hand in his and made the choice. I've always had the impression that this decision was fresh at the time she spoke to Frodo about giving him her place on the ship, and that she spoke with some pain because of her family (but that's just my view).
Good stuff!
God I love this world so much🥴. Thanks for another great vid!
As usual, good vid.
Apart from their stories being breath-taking they are also one-of-a-kind type of trope in fantasy. I've yet to come across another great fantasy book that made such considerations for its characters! The idea that self-creation as a biological choice and one's own destiny is full responsibility of the individual is marvelous.
I didn't know I needed this but I did
Whoa. I’m in love with this artist’s conception of Arwen. Liv is no slouch of course, but I like the redhead vibe. Seems to suit for some reason.
My #1 favorite thing is the fan art: how beautiful the elves and their cities are.
My brother is looking for all the audio books on cd for me. I've become a huge fan of the 1st and 2nd age over 3-4 weeks learned so much.
I love the you sing The last goodbye I can listen to that song for hour's
Yes!
I just had a thought--wouldn't it have been a bittersweet thing if Elrond had traveled to Numenor to say his final goodbye to his brother Elros at the end of his life? I wish Tolkien would have written about that meeting.
Same here.
O wow. I literally just rewatched the Fellowship of the Ring... as in the end credits are still playing.
who makes all those pictures? they are so beautiful
Please make a video about the Dark elfs of middle earth.
So Faramir and Boromir also have some Elven blood in them because their mother is Imrahil's sister.
Can you do a video on which maps of middle-earth and arda we should trust because I see many and don`t know which one Tolkien would consider canon
I like to think that Arwen was re-united with her father and brothers after she passed away in Lothlorien when Aragorn died. But there's nothing to indicate that that is so. It's just a little less sad to think that that is the case.
It's been ages since I read LOTR or the appendices where Arwen's case is handled, so I might not remember this all correctly, but it seems like she and her brothers were given the choice of the Half-elves. When she met Aragorn in Lothlorien, long before the events of LOTR, she made her choice for his sake and was destined to die as a human. Later, when Aragorn steps down from his throne, he tells her to repent of her choice, but she refuses. So she at least was given the choice, which makes it seem that her brothers had it too.
Oh man, if Aegnor and Finrod ever do find Andreth again she is going to kick their asses so hard
They were born with genuine love 🥰
You can really hear the reverence that Yoystan has for Elros, the same reverence that I have for he is one of the greatest men to have lived in Middle-Earth. Through Elessar his legacy and the glory of old Númenor endures!
FINALLY!!!
an interesting video this is
"Elwing, on the other hand, would learn the language of the sea birds in the undying lands and learn to fly among them."
This story must have been known to another who could fly through the skies, a great cetacean. As this mighty Fish of Wind slept within the great egg upon the mountain he surely recalled the tale of Elwing. Hence, in Mabe Village there appeared a lovely young girl. Many a day she spent at Toronbo beach with the sea birds singing as her heart yearned to fly with them.
Verily it be the nature of dreams to end. Though she was almost certainly fated to fade away as the sleeper stirred within the egg, she did not fade, she flew.
Live well dearest Marin.
May every distant land you fly to be all you imaged it would be and more.
Exellent
You deserve the highest form of Magic Anything.
That's sweet.
Please do a video on what if bilbo had killed Gollum/Sméagol
I thought it was pretty clear that Arwen became human and thus was able to join Aragorn and share the Doom of man.
The sound of your port-a-potty is pretty good. Also... hagrid and cheebacca were the best Elvis.
In an end note in War of the Jewels, Christopher Tolkien pointed out that Dior was a mortal man, because he was born after Beren & Luthien returned from the Halls of Mandos, when they were both mortal. So for a while, a mortal man ruled Doriath. That was something I always wondered. Also, only Earendil, Elwing & their children were given the choice, because they were the only ones offered the choice by the Valar. Why the choice was passed to Elrond's children but not to Elros' children is something I still don't really get.
Oh that is super fascinating! Thanks for letting me know!
@@MenoftheWest No problem. The enigma of Dior always bothered me. It took me decades to find that out.
Elros was mortal. That choice is irreversable.
Anyone who is part Man is mortal. That's a rule. There was an exception made for Earendil, Elwing and their sons. They were allowed to choose. But as soon as the choice is made to be mortal, that's it, your descendants are mortal too.
Well I think it might depend on translation issue; Fate of Arwen. Because in Finnish translations Tolkien clearly states that Arwen took her own life in Lothlorien after Aragorn died (Also kinda poetic and sad after all Arwen was known the last Elven maiden amongst the mortals and after her passing through her own hand also disappeared the last bit of magic from the world itself) because as an Elven kind she cannot die in old age, and no one wanted to kill her and Elves cannot die in disease or illness. Arwen Choose to stay in Middle-Earth but didn't become mortal...
Of course that would be helpful if we could ask the writer himself about this issue :P
Is it possible for me to get this as text format?
I like everything you do :-) (that I know of, that is!)
This raised the question, was the children of Hurin and the fall of Gondolin happening at around the same time or does one come before the other?
Pretty much the same time. In fact, when Tuor and his elf guide were on their way to Gondolin, they saw Hurin in the distance. Tuor and Hurin were cousins, btw.
@@maksphoto78 thanks heaps for clarifying. I suspected as much but wasn’t 100% sure. :-) It’s crazy that they never met properly and didn’t know who each other was. Especially since their fathers had a close relationship if I remember correctly.
What canon source says that Elladan and Elrohir went to Balinor in the Fourth Age? I'm not aware of any.