I have seen all comparison on youtube between those tow. Really this is the best one on youtube. I can see clearly the different. Especially the size, no one has mentioned about it or given clearly shut although it's important for travelling. Thank you alot Mr.bonjourhunu
Totally agree. Best video review and comparison between the two products. Thanks for sharing. BTW, your english is totally fine. Keep it up and soon you will be speaking as a native speaker.
Thank you for producing such a detailed comparison of the two products. I have learned more from watching your videos than some of the others out there. And your English is just fine. Keep up the good work.
My English is not good. I need to rely on Google Translate to make this English version. If my words using is inappropriate, or there are other problems, I really hope you can help me to point out by leaving a comment, that way I can improve my video quality, and I really appreciate this. thank you very much ：）
bonjourhuhu your english was fine! Btw, dji claim you can achieve dolly zoom in osmo mobile 2. Is it similar to zhiyun's vertigo shot? I feel like im going towards dji osmo because ive seen some people unable to make the app work! Was wondering if country compatibility might be a problem
Even if you only have a phone, you can also do the vertigo, but the video will be wobbling , The point is whether the zoom or move is smooth... and sorry I have no idea about the country compatibility.
This video was awesome - Thank you so much! I’ve been looking for a video that compares the two gimbals all week. You did a great job going through all the points and helped me a lot, although it’s still a tough choice - there are too many good options now.
One of the most sensible comparison videos I have seen on RUclips. You rock man. Thanks for the in depth analysis. You've been a great help to me for deciding between the two
Brilliant analysis - concise, to the point, good demo comparisons of the products themselves. Haven been waiting for a video like this for a while. Thanks!!
Man, you did a really good research and comparison on these two products and supported your conclusion with solid evidence. Well done. Your English is fine!
You did great. Your English is much better that many people I make contact on a daily basis who’s primary language is English. Thank you for the comparison Sir, I think I made a purchasing decision based off of your video.
Very informative, insightful and helpful to those who are in the market to buy their very first smartphone gimbal. Good work on the comparison and for digging deep into the differences as much as their obvious similarities. And your English is easy enough to understand. Keep those reviews coming!
Good comparison video between the two, your english is fine, so please do more videos in English in the future. Although I prefer the hardware features of the Smooth 4, I will be buying the DJI, purely for the software experience, I have a Zhiyun Crane+ and the ZY Play app on android is horrendous as most features don't work as advertised, they seem to introduce new bugs every update to the point some features stop working. Read the reviews on the Android app store before deciding which one to go with.
Again, I loved your in depth video comparison and thank you very much. Osmo for me all the way. I was worried about the tracking feature on the smooth, and their tech center couldn't give me a clear defined answer.
Brilliant and very helpful video. You addressed the important issue and uncovered the real problems. Your video has helped me choose the DJI, and I now know why I am choosing that product, i almost bought the Smooth, but I am glad I am now well informed. Thank You
Thanks for the comparison, really helped! Was starting to lean towards getting a Smooth 4, but wasn't so sure about the app as I use a pixel 2 xl. After watching this I think I'll definately go for the Osmo 2, for the easier/smoother experience, as I probably won't need the extra functions of the Smooth 4 anyway (only a beginner in filming video)
This video is so good. Your English is also fine. You will get better in no time. Your video explained all the useful points which others never brought up. It also made my decision easier. Thank you. Looking forward to many more videos from you.
Hello. Thank you for this review... and also thank you because you are one of the first youtuber that clearly mentionned the fact that some features of the Smooth Q4 won't work correctly with Android phones. Most of the reviews regarding phones gimbals, only speak about Iphones.... but most of the gimbals (Dji, Smooth Q4 or even Smoove Mobile), won't work 100% with android phones. For example, with my Osmo Mobile 2, I cannot use the slowmotion with my Samsung S8; But in fact, that's not réeally a problem because I can do Slowmotion in post production. I'm very happy with my Osmo Mobile 2. (great video quality). Have a great day. Yves
Bought a Smooth 4 and everything you have said in the the video is 100% spot on. Hope Xhiyun fixes the issues with the product soon via firmware and App upgrades.
Hi. Thank you for your review. I have finally decided to stay with Osmo mobile. I'm making a documentary but am not an advanced film maker and the many controls on the other model make it confusing. Also the object tracking is important for me. Thank you very much x
Impressive video, I have narrowed down my choices of gimbals, smooth Q, smooth 4 and the DJI Osmo, it's time to decide 🤐 I like how Iits possible to attach accessories to the DJI by adding an arm on it's side and using external microphone, hard to do on the Zhiyun models.
Your review was very detailed and helpful showing each advantage and disadvantage point by point. It seems if stabilization is the same, app experience is more important than a few features like Hithcock zoom which I never even thought to use. Your video has helped me to decide to get the Osmo 2! And thank you for taking the time to make the video in English, I know it must have been very hard. I taught English in Asia for 9 years so I know how hard it is! Thank you!
Thank you for your work! It is really good comparison! And I chose Smooth4. Still Osmo2 is hard to miss! / BTW as a non Native English speaker, it is really easy to understand what you said on the video. Thank you !
Hey bro thanks for the review. This is actually the most informative review I’ve watched about the two. I bought the OSMO 2 and really like it. But then seen the smooth 4 and ordered that and plan to return the osmo. After watching your video I realized how much bigger the smooth 4 is ( not ideal for my travel plans) and the app being glitchy. I guess I’ll keep the osmo and return the smooth 4 lol btw you can also do vertigo fx when editing
Thank you. This was very good. I was trying to decide which I want, and the DJI is better for my needs. Thanks so much for the great video. and don't worry your english is perfect for the video.
I can see so many reviews complaining about the Pano mode not working on Smooth 4. Why can't they just use their mobile's native cam to do it? That shouldn't be a reason not to buy Smooth 4. IMO it has more functionalities than Osmo Mobile 2 that is why I got one. And yes, I have Osmo mobile and Osmo pocket. Nice review though.
What hotkeys work in native camera app? i cannot use zy play app because it says, "not available in your country" and when i downloaded the apk from google it says i can't install it. I want to buy the smooth 4 but i want to make sure i can atleast use the full pan-tilt follw mode in native camera app
Hello, I'm looking for my first smartphone gimbal. Which one of this you suggest me among these choices - DJI OSMO 2 or Zhiyun Smooth Q or Zhiyun smooth 4. Thanks in advance.
Hmmm, reading the reviews I see a lot of the opposite saying the DJI app keeps crashing and my smooth 4 hasn’t crashed yet. I’ve had issues with the pan staying level on the Smooth horizon, but theirs an firmware update I’m going to test now. And a lot of dead DJI app reviews on apples website. I’m only mentioning this because I’m thinking of getting the DJI also and tracking is the last thing I have not tested yet in the Smooth 4, this is how I found your video. But I do appreciate the honest opinion for your experience , thank you. Question, what firmware and app version did you run on bot during this testing? Both being new products I’m sure have had updates. The other reason I’m thinking of switching to DJI is for the filmic pro support. Smaller, but no lighter, and a normal USB port for charging.
Very good comparison and your translation was very good. You mentioned in one of your comments that you have updated the firmware and the app, did this alter any of your findings in the original comparison? Particularly, did it help with the tracking issues and did it help with any of the app issues that you found?
Hi Bonjourhuhu I had the zhiyun smooth q before but the firmware was terrible when I wanted to record and zoom it would go on camera mode also the zoom mode wasn’t smooth at all that’s why I had return it.Now i was hoping the smooth 4 would correct all of those glitches but after watching your video I would have to wait for a firmware update otherwise I would have to buy the Osmos 2 thank you for your honest video.
Luis Lahud smoothq does have those glitches you said,so I usually just use its basic stability function, and use the ios own camera. Smooth4 does fix some bugs, such as it can smoothly zoom now, but the app still not good enough.
I've been looking for a comparison video and a test footage for so long! And finally you uploaded one.I was so worried about the OIS issue. Thanks for mentioning it. By the way, don't worry about your English. It's pretty good and understandable. I'm not a native speaker, so I also make mistakes. Keep going!❤️
Nice video man! I haven't find anywhere if the Smooth 4 is compatable with Android in 4k shooting? Altough it seems a lot better because of the many buttonsm the Osmo Mobile 2 seems to performer better..
I own a Samsung S9 plus and I badly need a gimbal. I’ve been checking so many videos and reviews and ended up watching this video. I’m still clueless on which one to buy. Can someone help me make the right choice? Zhiyun smooth 4 or osmo mobile 2?
Thank you for a very helpful and thorough video! I have a question. When using the filmic pro app on the Zhiyun Smooth 4 does the physical buttons on the gimbal still work? Can I be filming with filmic pro and still use the focus wheel? Thank you again! Please keep making English videos!
I have seen all comparison on youtube between those tow. Really this is the best one on youtube. I can see clearly the different. Especially the size, no one has mentioned about it or given clearly shut although it's important for travelling.
Thank you alot Mr.bonjourhunu
Totally agree. Best video review and comparison between the two products. Thanks for sharing.
BTW, your english is totally fine. Keep it up and soon you will be speaking as a native speaker.
thanks very much for your support.I agree with you, when I was traveling, I even thought that the smooth Q is a little big.
Thank you for producing such a detailed comparison of the two products. I have learned more from watching your videos than some of the others out there. And your English is just fine. Keep up the good work.
My English is not good. I need to rely on Google Translate to make this English version.
If my words using is inappropriate, or there are other problems, I really hope you can help me to point out by leaving a comment, that way I can improve my video quality, and I really appreciate this. thank you very much ：）
bonjourhuhu your english was fine!
Btw, dji claim you can achieve dolly zoom in osmo mobile 2. Is it similar to zhiyun's vertigo shot?
I feel like im going towards dji osmo because ive seen some people unable to make the app work! Was wondering if country compatibility might be a problem
Even if you only have a phone, you can also do the vertigo, but the video will be wobbling , The point is whether the zoom or move is smooth...
and sorry I have no idea about the country compatibility.
Thank you for posting in English! I appreciate it! You did fine.
bonjourhuhu I
Don't worry. Its understandable and comfortable.
This video was awesome - Thank you so much! I’ve been looking for a video that compares the two gimbals all week. You did a great job going through all the points and helped me a lot, although it’s still a tough choice - there are too many good options now.
After A Fashion ASMR thanks very much for watching: ) if u have any other questions, feel free to ask me, I ll do my best to help u.
Understood every word you said. Keep up the great work. Nice review.
One of the most sensible comparison videos I have seen on RUclips. You rock man.
Thanks for the in depth analysis. You've been a great help to me for deciding between the two
Brilliant analysis - concise, to the point, good demo comparisons of the products themselves. Haven been waiting for a video like this for a while. Thanks!!
Man, you did a really good research and comparison on these two products and supported your conclusion with solid evidence. Well done. Your English is fine!
Your English is getting better with each video. You are doing just fine :) Thank you for making this very detailed comparison!
Nice.. subscribed. English is light years beyond my Mandarin or Cantonese so no complaints here.
Murchy Murch h
You did great. Your English is much better that many people I make contact on a daily basis who’s primary language is English. Thank you for the comparison Sir, I think I made a purchasing decision based off of your video.
this video is really good with no inappropriate language or content. I subscribed keep doing what your doing
no worry
good english. understandble
wondering for my first stabalizer
Very informative, insightful and helpful to those who are in the market to buy their very first smartphone gimbal. Good work on the comparison and for digging deep into the differences as much as their obvious similarities. And your English is easy enough to understand. Keep those reviews coming!
Good comparison video between the two, your english is fine, so please do more videos in English in the future. Although I prefer the hardware features of the Smooth 4, I will be buying the DJI, purely for the software experience, I have a Zhiyun Crane+ and the ZY Play app on android is horrendous as most features don't work as advertised, they seem to introduce new bugs every update to the point some features stop working. Read the reviews on the Android app store before deciding which one to go with.
Yes, as you said, Zhiyun needs to work hard to fix its bugs.
Very good vidéo, I was worried about the app experience for the Zhiyun and you confirmed it. Thanks a lot you helped me decide!
Again, I loved your in depth video comparison and thank you very much. Osmo for me all the way. I was worried about the tracking feature on the smooth, and their tech center couldn't give me a clear defined answer.
Brilliant and very helpful video. You addressed the important issue and uncovered the real problems. Your video has helped me choose the DJI, and I now know why I am choosing that product, i almost bought the Smooth, but I am glad I am now well informed. Thank You
Thanks for the comparison, really helped! Was starting to lean towards getting a Smooth 4, but wasn't so sure about the app as I use a pixel 2 xl. After watching this I think I'll definately go for the Osmo 2, for the easier/smoother experience, as I probably won't need the extra functions of the Smooth 4 anyway (only a beginner in filming video)
Philip Chen Im glad this video helps u a little,thanks for watching
Thanks a lot for the video
Thank you for trying hard with your english so viewers like me can understand! Good job!
You did a fantastic job and your English was just fine. Keep doing videos like this my friend!
This video is so good. Your English is also fine. You will get better in no time. Your video explained all the useful points which others never brought up. It also made my decision easier. Thank you. Looking forward to many more videos from you.
thanks for your support
First of all your English was great dont ever worry about it you did great. The video was amazingly informative. Thanks
From India here. I loved your comprehensive and sincere review. They are splendid and simply put the best. Keep up the good work
love your review bro, its enough explaination and enough for me to decide which should i spend my money to :)
Well done, very good explanations which help to clarify and make your video more useful then most youtube videos on this subject. Thanks again
Hello. Thank you for this review... and also thank you because you are one of the first youtuber that clearly mentionned the fact that some features of the Smooth Q4 won't work correctly with Android phones. Most of the reviews regarding phones gimbals, only speak about Iphones.... but most of the gimbals (Dji, Smooth Q4 or even Smoove Mobile), won't work 100% with android phones. For example, with my Osmo Mobile 2, I cannot use the slowmotion with my Samsung S8; But in fact, that's not réeally a problem because I can do Slowmotion in post production. I'm very happy with my Osmo Mobile 2. (great video quality).
Have a great day.
Yves
You speak perfect english, don't worry about it. Thank you for the very informative video comparison! This is all I need! 👍👏
Bought a Smooth 4 and everything you have said in the the video is 100% spot on. Hope Xhiyun fixes the issues with the product soon via firmware and App upgrades.
I also hope so
Thanks for the honest review. Many of the reviews out there have affiliate links (they are paid) to give their positive reviews on Zhiyun
Hi. Thank you for your review. I have finally decided to stay with Osmo mobile. I'm making a documentary but am not an advanced film maker and the many controls on the other model make it confusing. Also the object tracking is important for me. Thank you very much x
Very good video my friend! You did a great job explaining all the important points on each product! Keep up the good work! Aloha from Hawaii!
Impressive video, I have narrowed down my choices of gimbals, smooth Q, smooth 4 and the DJI Osmo, it's time to decide 🤐 I like how Iits possible to attach accessories to the DJI by adding an arm on it's side and using external microphone, hard to do on the Zhiyun models.
I have a Smooth Q and I'm very satisfied with this product! Great Review by the way!
Excellent review, Great job! Well done very informative. Good editing. Great English. I would like your opinion on the Isteady pro mobile aswell.
Your review was very detailed and helpful showing each advantage and disadvantage point by point. It seems if stabilization is the same, app experience is more important than a few features like Hithcock zoom which I never even thought to use. Your video has helped me to decide to get the Osmo 2! And thank you for taking the time to make the video in English, I know it must have been very hard. I taught English in Asia for 9 years so I know how hard it is! Thank you!
Great job with the comparison.
Nice review thanks
Excellent video. Thank you very much for sharing. I just got the Osmo mobile 2 and you video helped me a lot. Subscribed to your Channel!!
I'm watching this video in 2020....And I have both of those gimbals....both are awesome for my Android....Nice review
Is update come for zihun smooth4 after this video or not...hows the exprence now...?
Plz reply i am plsning to buy...
@@heavenly1895 Yes ,I already updated the firmware for my Smooth 4, and everything seems just fine...and the focus ring works
soooooo formal and soooooo informative, nice vid bud!
This was such an informative video, thank you. Your English is great!
Your English is more than sufficient in this video. Thank you for posting.
Your analysis is excellent and English is is quite good.
Excellent and clear comparison, and I could understand exactly what you were saying....
Subscribed. Super video, I'll watch any of your similar videos going forward.
Thank you for your work! It is really good comparison! And I chose Smooth4. Still Osmo2 is hard to miss! / BTW as a non Native English speaker, it is really easy to understand what you said on the video. Thank you !
wow, this is a really well done video. Your english isnt terrible either :)
Great comparison video my man, English was really good. That 240p shirt tho :D
Your review is so good! Your english is great! Clearly explained. Thanks!
Excellent explanation of the Hitchcock 'Vertigo Zoom' effect! Well done. :-)
I'd like to try the gimbal but i was wondering if the audio would be muffled because the phone holder will cover the phone's microphone
Hey bro thanks for the review. This is actually the most informative review I’ve watched about the two. I bought the OSMO 2 and really like it. But then seen the smooth 4 and ordered that and plan to return the osmo. After watching your video I realized how much bigger the smooth 4 is ( not ideal for my travel plans) and the app being glitchy. I guess I’ll keep the osmo and return the smooth 4 lol btw you can also do vertigo fx when editing
great review huhu! keep up the good work
Thank you. This was very good. I was trying to decide which I want, and the DJI is better for my needs. Thanks so much for the great video. and don't worry your english is perfect for the video.
Very good idea Pro 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍😀
I can see so many reviews complaining about the Pano mode not working on Smooth 4. Why can't they just use their mobile's native cam to do it? That shouldn't be a reason not to buy Smooth 4. IMO it has more functionalities than Osmo Mobile 2 that is why I got one. And yes, I have Osmo mobile and Osmo pocket. Nice review though.
Great comparison. This will be helpful in making my decision in which to purchase. Thank you.
Awesome video, exactly what I was looking for👍👍👍
Thank you for the comprehensive and fair review. It is very helpful. Your English is fine. Thank you again.
What hotkeys work in native camera app? i cannot use zy play app because it says, "not available in your country" and when i downloaded the apk from google it says i can't install it. I want to buy the smooth 4 but i want to make sure i can atleast use the full pan-tilt follw mode in native camera app
Awsome and honest review. Thanks, Thumps up!
Hello, I'm looking for my first smartphone gimbal. Which one of this you suggest me among these choices - DJI OSMO 2 or Zhiyun Smooth Q or Zhiyun smooth 4. Thanks in advance.
verry good job , this is a first video compares OSMO2 /SMOOTH4 thank you !!
Nice video, very good job.
I understood what you were saying! You will get better with more practice, but I think you did great =) Thank you for the info!
Hmmm, reading the reviews I see a lot of the opposite saying the DJI app keeps crashing and my smooth 4 hasn’t crashed yet. I’ve had issues with the pan staying level on the Smooth horizon, but theirs an firmware update I’m going to test now. And a lot of dead DJI app reviews on apples website. I’m only mentioning this because I’m thinking of getting the DJI also and tracking is the last thing I have not tested yet in the Smooth 4, this is how I found your video. But I do appreciate the honest opinion for your experience , thank you.
Question, what firmware and app version did you run on bot during this testing? Both being new products I’m sure have had updates.
The other reason I’m thinking of switching to DJI is for the filmic pro support. Smaller, but no lighter, and a normal USB port for charging.
I like this honest and objective review very insightful thank you
Does your Smooth 4 record slow motion well? Mine didn’t work with slow motion.
Very good comparison and your translation was very good. You mentioned in one of your comments that you have updated the firmware and the app, did this alter any of your findings in the original comparison? Particularly, did it help with the tracking issues and did it help with any of the app issues that you found?
has osmo 2 acces 60 fps on sony samsung and huawei devices ? Zhiyun has not
Hi Bonjourhuhu I had the zhiyun smooth q before but the firmware was terrible when I wanted to record and zoom it would go on camera mode also the zoom mode wasn’t smooth at all that’s why I had return it.Now i was hoping the smooth 4 would correct all of those glitches but after watching your video I would have to wait for a firmware update otherwise I would have to buy the Osmos 2 thank you for your honest video.
Luis Lahud smoothq does have those glitches you said,so I usually just use its basic stability function, and use the ios own camera. Smooth4 does fix some bugs, such as it can smoothly zoom now, but the app still not good enough.
I've been looking for a comparison video and a test footage for so long! And finally you uploaded one.I was so worried about the OIS issue. Thanks for mentioning it.
By the way, don't worry about your English. It's pretty good and understandable. I'm not a native speaker, so I also make mistakes.
Keep going!❤️
thanks very much for your support : )
Did that base come included with your Osmo 2? Or did you buy it separately as an accessory?
虽然我的英文也不很好，但具体还了解。不错，加油～ 最终还是confuse买哪个。。。哈哈。。
Thank you very much! Very smart comparison.
Nice video man! I haven't find anywhere if the Smooth 4 is compatable with Android in 4k shooting? Altough it seems a lot better because of the many buttonsm the Osmo Mobile 2 seems to performer better..
I own a Samsung S9 plus and I badly need a gimbal. I’ve been checking so many videos and reviews and ended up watching this video. I’m still clueless on which one to buy. Can someone help me make the right choice? Zhiyun smooth 4 or osmo mobile 2?
very good review and yes u speak good english ty
How is the APP for both? Especiall y for Android. I heard Zhiyun Android app not good . Just wonder how is the DJI Android app?
Hi, how can you change the tracking mode speed on the zhiyun so it goes as fast as the dji
Great review. Thanks legend! :)
用心做的影片，很不错，支持！
your doing great. using English becomes easier with usage.
thank you so much buddy. it was a great help.
Nice comparison 👍
Hi when I use moment lens with smooth4 gimbal it’s off the balance do you have any Suggestions?
Thank you
like from me for the English u tried. appreciate that
Thank you very much for pronouncing 'Zhiyun' correctly. :-)
Hi , I LIKE YOUR VIDEO I HAVE A QUESTION DOES IT HAVE AN OPTION OF 360 ROTATE WITH AUTOFOCUS OF US LIKE SMOOTH Q HAVE PLz reply me
NO, both of them cannot rotate 360 degrees
bonjourhuhu thanks for your reply
Gave a Genuine and helpfull review sir
Best review I have ever seen. I wonder if there’s a way to shoot vertigo using dji osmo?
i'm afraid there isn't...
Thank you for a very helpful and thorough video! I have a question. When using the filmic pro app on the Zhiyun Smooth 4 does the physical buttons on the gimbal still work? Can I be filming with filmic pro and still use the focus wheel? Thank you again! Please keep making English videos!
No, most of the physical buttons cannot work.
Only the trigger and the locking/pan following switch can work.These two don't need to rely on any app
bonjourhuhu Thanks for answering my question! I was afraid that was the case. Maybe filmic pro will update their app to work with it!
OIS can't be turned off. It is built in the lens of the smarthphone.
good work. logical review 👌
why is my picture and video upside down?
nice video! What phone did you use?
Ruthless comparison brother!!
Hi which one works good with Samsung s9+
Nice video. My question is: Can the Zhiyun use the Filmic Pro app or just the Osmo 2? Thanks and I’m a new subscriber!!
thank you, and zhiyun cannot...
Filmic Pro is now fully integrated with Smooth 4 which for me sways the decision to it over the osmo despite your excellent video