RADV Vs AMDGPU-PRO Performance Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 янв 2025

Комментарии • 32

  • @doompenguin7453
    @doompenguin7453  3 года назад +14

    Yeah, RADV is better.

    • @CosmoHQ
      @CosmoHQ 3 года назад +2

      Thank God they Easily swappable , so I choose a driver depending on what I'am playing

  • @VandrerenErik
    @VandrerenErik Год назад +8

    Yeah, not worth the hassle installing AMDGPU-PRO at all. I've been gaming with RADV in Fedora for over a year now and I haven't even bothered checking Windows again for absolutely nothing. I'm so glad I can finally game pretty much anything on Linux and don't need to touch Windows anymore.

    • @apachebcn
      @apachebcn Год назад +1

      I love this
      But I compared my rx6700xt with Linux vs Windows, and truck simulator game is faster and stable with windows 😟
      I tried with Manjaro and biglinux, both with kernel 6.1
      And I like to play with Linux
      I not know this RADV
      Is included in kernel?

    • @douglastotes7557
      @douglastotes7557 7 месяцев назад

      @@apachebcn its not the default, in some distros like big linux you have to install radv but... big linux has a utility to change the mesa version and the kernel too, for the kernel I recommend: linux-xanmod-LTS 6.6 and for mesa TGK stable = RADV ( english it's not my native language )

  • @stiefn3825
    @stiefn3825 3 года назад +6

    It seems PRO is slightly faster (2-5fps) in native Vulkan Applications, whereas RADV often completely outshines the former in wrapped games.

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  3 года назад +10

      This is true only for Wine/Proton games, probably because the PRO driver is the same as the one on Windows and is just optimized for those games. I did some testing after I uploaded this video and found that Linux native games which use Vulkan have the same performance on RADV and GPU-PRO, with RADV slightly outperforming GPU-PRO in games like Metro Exodus. I did want to focus on Proton games in this video since that is what most people play. Another interesting thing is that RADV performs much better in CPU limited scenarios. Back during the summer when RADV had poor performance in DOOM Eternal, I opened an issue on Mesa's gitlab page and one of the devs said that he couldn't reproduce the issue, and RADV performed slightly better on his end. Turns out that RADV just performs better and better the more CPU limited you get, and he was running the game at 1080p on an RX 6900XT, so he though RADV already performed better. Well, after that they worked on it and now RADV is on par with GPU-PRO.

  • @Azarilh
    @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

    So normally you would see a few more frames per second for the Pro driver, but few games have terrible performance with Pro for some reason.
    So i would stick with the Mesa driver but i wonder if it's possible to interchange easily between the two depending on the game.

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  10 месяцев назад +1

      Any game running a translation layer from DirectX to Vulkan will run at a higher average and 1% lows on the RADV driver. When running a game that runs on Vulkan natively, RADV is either equal in performance or worse than Pro.
      You can choose which driver to use for which game by specifying it using the VK_IDC_FILENAMES environment variable. If I want to launch RDR2 with the pro driver, for example, I would put VK_ICD_FILENAMES=/opt/amdgpu-pro/etc/vulkan/icd.d/amd_icd64.json %command% in the steam launch options. The location of your .json file may be different from mine.

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

      @@doompenguin7453 Oh wow thank you!

    • @mc-not_escher
      @mc-not_escher 9 месяцев назад

      So it’s negligible, right?

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 9 месяцев назад

      @@mc-not_escher Normally seems like it. But according to the video the pro driver seem to be pretty bad in certain games. So i would stick with Mesa.

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  9 месяцев назад

      @@mc-not_escher No negligible at all. When the pro driver is bad, it's really bad. Also, games like DOOM Eternal get like 40fps more with the PRO driver, so it's not like it's useless, it's just that 99% of the time you should be using RADV.

  • @apachebcn
    @apachebcn Год назад +1

    Im understanding, RADV is vulkan
    Im using manjaro with kernel 6.1 and graphic rx6700 tx
    And my xplane11 if i configure to use vulkan go extremely slow 😮

  • @KATalyzt_
    @KATalyzt_ Год назад +1

    I don't know how to install priv drivers :(

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

      Priv?

    • @KATalyzt_
      @KATalyzt_ 10 месяцев назад

      @@Azarilh Yeah, but... Where? Haha

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

      @@KATalyzt_ No, i dunno what it is.

    • @KATalyzt_
      @KATalyzt_ 10 месяцев назад

      @@Azarilh Huh?

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

      @@KATalyzt_ nvm...

  • @EmpInd
    @EmpInd 2 года назад +2

    Does AMDGPU-Pro comes with AMD Catalyst or Adrenalin software?

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  2 года назад +6

      No, those are Windows drivers. No fancy GUI on Linux, I'm afraid.

    • @kaltimoktober
      @kaltimoktober Год назад

      @@doompenguin7453 idk, corectrl is fancy enough.

    • @Azarilh
      @Azarilh 10 месяцев назад

      @@kaltimoktober Yes but it's not official.

  • @helpimahugedisaster5728
    @helpimahugedisaster5728 Год назад +1

    Any tutorial how to install RADV

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  Год назад +2

      Installed by default on most distros. On Arch, you just need sudo pacman -S vulkan-radeon lib32-vulkan-radeon.

  • @warnacokelat
    @warnacokelat 2 года назад

    how do i install pro drivers? it looks like im still using the open source drivers even after installing it from the AUR. total noob here.

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  2 года назад

      You need to set the driver in the game's launch options. For steam, you go to the launch options and paste the following:
      VK_ICD_FILENAMES=/usr/share/vulkan/icd.d/amd_pro_icd64.json %command%
      and the game should use the pro drivers. Also, the AUR package is out of date, use tkg's PKGBUILD instead. Tkg's github page also includes instructions on how to use the drivers.

    • @warnacokelat
      @warnacokelat 2 года назад +1

      @@doompenguin7453 yea i did use the launch option but it still says im using radv. will try the PKGBUILD.

  • @DrVektor
    @DrVektor 2 года назад +1

    what is RADV? is it opensource driver? is it means "V= vulkan?"

    • @doompenguin7453
      @doompenguin7453  2 года назад +10

      RADV = Radeon Vulkan. It's the open source Vulkan driver developed as part of the Mesa project.

    • @DrVektor
      @DrVektor 2 года назад +2

      @@doompenguin7453 Thank you.