Used VA STI vs Used VB WRX - Which is the better buy?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 дек 2024

Комментарии • 111

  • @lostisles2760
    @lostisles2760 День назад +5

    I bought a 2017 sti a year and a half ago with 124k miles and the car hasn’t gave me a single issue after being daily driven since purchased, I’ve done the water pump, timing belt, spark plugs, thermostat, all fluids and the car has been a dream to drive

    • @lostisles2760
      @lostisles2760 День назад

      Just hit 140k miles today as well saving money for when I’ll need that replacement motor 😅

  • @pauletecelebradocusi3555
    @pauletecelebradocusi3555 День назад +2

    I have a VB and 6 mo later I helped my son a 2016 sti. I can enjoy both now😂

  • @NexGenSubies
    @NexGenSubies День назад +7

    I have 9K miles on my 23 VB, looking to get back into a 21 STI. I do not enjoy the VB like I thought I would’ve. At first it was fun and such but over time I found it boring, I tuned it and still didn’t feel the same. Feels big and like a boat is the only way I can describe it. VB is overall a great commuter car, great power for dirt cheap, looks are subjective to each person.

    • @a124as
      @a124as День назад +1

      STI is legendary

  • @davidzebar6876
    @davidzebar6876 День назад +4

    Having driven both, there's no comparison. The STI is so much better and raw to drive.

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 18 часов назад

      Stock yes. But simple tune on the vb and the sti looks slow comparatively

    • @joshsiyavong
      @joshsiyavong 17 часов назад +1

      @@kingvega666it’s not all about the speed. It’s about how connected the car makes you feel and the character of the car. Yes you can make the VB faster for cheap but the reality is no mods will ever make it feel as solid, connected , or mechanical as the STI . That’s worth more than straight line speed.

    • @davidzebar6876
      @davidzebar6876 10 часов назад

      @@joshsiyavong right. The WRX feels like someone slapped a turbo and coilovers on an economy sedan and called it a day. The STI feels like a rally car that someone turned into a street car. I was surprised at how different they feel even with similar performance numbers. I drove the JDM version that revs to 8000rpm so the difference was even more stark

    • @joshsiyavong
      @joshsiyavong Час назад +1

      @@davidzebar6876 I had a 2020 wrx had coil overs, a few bushings, short shifter , and exhaust. I then drove my gf STI for a week. I realized that no matter what I did to the wrx it would never feel as good as the STI it was kind of a defeating feeling. It’s not to say the wrx is bad I still loved it. But the STI Is for sure a step above as advertised. Heavy metal Rex has another STI comparison video and the wrx guy said that after driving the STI it just feels solid and wrx does not feel solid lol

  • @Kopernicus67
    @Kopernicus67 День назад +4

    With no new STi, the old ones are just too pricey for people on a budget. If you don't mind spending $1000s over just to have something, I'm happy for you, I really am. But the value isn't there per $ for me.
    I had that choice back in '23, when my Q5 got taken out by two deer in succession over three weeks. The kids were all now driving age, and my wife said go get what you want. No more SUVs for me, back to a manual CAR. Budget was $30-40k. The STi were all over $40k with miles. STis are also owned by enthusiasts, which means they either had been driven hard and maintained, all the way to abused and not maintained. The VB Premium was just a better value. Sure, I wish I had the trick diffs and the beefy transmission, but I'm pretty happy with what I have.

    • @marcspence1905
      @marcspence1905 6 часов назад

      I have a 18 sti with low miles for a good price.

  • @joshsiyavong
    @joshsiyavong 2 дня назад +11

    I bought a 2020 STI limited in January 2023 for 37k out the door. The STI had 17k miles and was certified pre owned. So it was a great deal imo and car was not abused and has a 7 year 100k miles warranty. I traded in my 2020 wrx. I have driven a VB one time and it was very nice , felt quick, and felt better tuned than the va wrx. With that said both cars don’t feel as connected or solid. Hard to explain you just have to feel it. The STI feels more special when driving it. The rumble is intoxicating and never gets old. The steering feel is a lot better. The transmission is really the star and feels so mechanical and stout compared to the wrx. If you’re looking to keep things stock besides cosmetics, bushings , coilovers, and a cat back buy the STI if you can find a stock one and can afford it is the way to go. If you’re looking for cheap power go wrx. Both are amazing but nothing will compare to the analog feel and sound of the rumble. The STI is truly special. It’s also hard to know how good it really is after a 10 min drive. Before I bought my STI I drove my gf STI for a small test drive and wasn’t that impressed. I then drove it for a week and after I wanted to get rid of my wrx cause the STI felt so much better in every single way. If you drove both for a week I think 98% of people would choose the STI over the wrx.

  • @Young_Bourdain
    @Young_Bourdain День назад +1

    I test drove two different 2019 STI Limiteds. Loved the cars but the price was insane at the time. I held off and ended up going with a new GR Corolla in March. Two things I just couldn’t get past: the price of the STI being about the same as they were brand new even though they had 30-35k miles, and not knowing what mods had been on the car. One of the cars still had an accessport installed and the dealership selling it listed it as “Completely stock”
    Very happy with my GRC as a daily. I wouldn’t mind saving up for an STI hatch to make into a track car. I am glad to see the searches done in this video showing that STI prices are coming back down to earth.

  • @b.1922
    @b.1922 День назад +1

    Love the sti but i bought a vb about a year ago and honestly love it as my daily. The sti isnt worth the bs just het the vb unless you are going to track it just like other comments have stated. Once again love the video man!! Cant wait ti see whats up next for your vb! (Also posting for algorithm)

  • @Stealthoverwealth
    @Stealthoverwealth День назад

    I was in this exact position last August. Decided to stop riding bikes so I sold my sport bikes and bought a 21’ sti limited with 29k miles. It was adult owned, 100% stock and was a certified pre-owned Subaru. I paid 40k out the door in Dallas Texas. I definitely over paid, and my warranty is already gone (tuned, cat back, intake) but I would buy it again. Loving every drive I take! I think there are better deals around than I found, and definitely better deals if you don’t want an STI specifically. The character the car has and how fun it is to row through the gears is hard to describe without experiencing it.

  • @michaelgallamore1496
    @michaelgallamore1496 День назад +8

    I purchased a 2024 TR last week under invoice with the STI short throw and the STI performance muffler. The interest rate was 1.9%. I looked at the 2024 Golf R but the interest rate was >6% and had dealer mark ups that would have put it in the mid 50k range. It was the same with the Type R which was quoted to me at 54k for a 2024! The TR was a crazy deal! So glad I decided on that instead of waiting on the TS.

    • @reganmian
      @reganmian День назад +1

      That’s sick man. I think the TR is the sweet spot of old school, track fun, affordable and new. Actually hate the digital dash on the tS and new BRZ. TR might be easier to maintain over the tS as well, if kept stock

    • @andrewoxner2941
      @andrewoxner2941 День назад +1

      @@reganmian My out the door price, tax title and everything, on my 2024 TR was $41250 with that 1.9%

    • @Itsdjsigi
      @Itsdjsigi День назад

      How did you get under invoice?

    • @andrewoxner2941
      @andrewoxner2941 День назад

      @@Itsdjsigi this was my 4th car from them, i also built a strong case about TRs not selling and that they had already had theirs for 136 days.

    • @Kopernicus67
      @Kopernicus67 День назад

      Subaru discounts, I got $2k right off + STi shifter installed for free. I went through the same progression. Our local VW dealer was more than happy to hold a Golf R for me, but he said he gets ONE a year, and that it would be a bidding war over MSRP. I like all hot hatches (except the Hyundais and Kias, sorry), but Subaru is the best value.
      Have fun with your TR!!!!

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад +1

    Im actually convinced that its because of the ease of tuning to make more power on the VB that they didn't bother to make an sti version

    • @marcspence1905
      @marcspence1905 6 часов назад

      Wrx can become an sti but an sti can't become a WRX unless you downgrade it. Even though its essentially an Impreza Wrx.

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    11:35 the "infancy" of the 2.4 liter is overcome by the 90k warranty and with research you'll find its a sweetheart of an engine to work on etc.

    • @MrNbkelly
      @MrNbkelly 11 часов назад

      It's also been pulling around the big-ass ascent for years now lol. I trust the FA24 a lot!

  • @Father4ev3r
    @Father4ev3r 2 дня назад +9

    Unless you have the time, patience, tools, know-how and a money tree... steer clear of a used STI. Used ones are often someone else's mod problem. New VB TR for me!

    • @NexGenSubies
      @NexGenSubies День назад +1

      @@Father4ev3r I bought a used 21 STI in 22 with 6k miles. Perfectly fine for another 6k miles before I traded in for a Supra. It all depends on mileage and if it was tuned or not. Sub 20k miles I think you’re fine if it’s been bone stock the entire time. Some ppl buy 50K+ miles STIs and they run another 50k without issues. Luck of the draw lol

    • @suba-dude5516
      @suba-dude5516 День назад +1

      I disagree. I've had 4 STI's never moded and treated like a baby. Sold one with 60K miles, sold the other one with 45K, and the last one I sold, I sold it with 1K miles to get my TYPE RA... all amazing cars. Now, my 2018 TYPE RA has less than 3K miles on it and also never moded... whomever buys it from me, will be lucky.

    • @Father4ev3r
      @Father4ev3r День назад

      @suba-dude5516 Well... I did say often, not always. You're extremely fortunate to have gotten 4 (assuming used, being in line with my comment) unmodified STIs, bordering on unicorn rare. At the time when I was looking late last/early this year, I did find several, slightly used and unmodified STIs in the North East, but not willing to pay "new car" prices (35+k,plus shipping) for a 3yr old, 25k+ mile used STI - even if dealer Certified used.

    • @BDA0531
      @BDA0531 День назад

      @@suba-dude5516So you sold all of your STI’s right about the time the power train warranty expires?

  • @stefanosodano
    @stefanosodano День назад

    Buying a used STI you definitely need to either be very mechanically savvy or budget a fair amount for the inevitable engine replacement, speaking from experience... However the value proposition increases regardless if you keep the car long enough but different strokes for different folks

  • @1966DodgeCoronet
    @1966DodgeCoronet День назад +1

    aftermarket wheels = red flags 🚩 😂😂😂 … it does make the mind wander for sure

  • @OilyWRX
    @OilyWRX День назад

    I agree with everything you said Awais. If you are looking to taking the car to 450WHP on a VB it will require a turbo upgrade and maybe some fueling along with the FMIC, intake, jpipe, AP, and tune. For the VB though most would probably want the STI trans to hold the power and not limit their tune due to the split case WRX trans. Also getting better brakes is a must as well with the power. In terms of cost for modding FA24 makes more with less till you get to a certain power level then fueling cost more and you need the trans and brakes.

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    9:18 perfect example you can get a lot more car for the money you spend then tune after your warranty

  • @reganmian
    @reganmian День назад +3

    You’re convincing me to wait a couple years to get a new VB to my garage. Current daily BRZ isn’t going anywhere

    • @NexGenSubies
      @NexGenSubies День назад

      @@reganmian buy a 22-23 used WRX base. They’re around 22-30k from what I’ve been seeing

    • @reganmian
      @reganmian День назад +1

      @@NexGenSubies $35k for the premium with assurance that nobody tuned it is fine with me. Especially since they so often sell below MSRP. tS is too close to Type R pricing

    • @NexGenSubies
      @NexGenSubies День назад

      @@reganmian I agree! I’d rather have a FL5 at that price point

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 18 часов назад

      I couldnt get out of my brz fast enough. Car was so slow for daily driving

    • @reganmian
      @reganmian 17 часов назад

      @ I don’t have it for speed though. I just like fun shifts and corners. I think the camero is amazing and a better alternative for speed. I also looked at Miatas. Different strokes for different folks. I want a WRX for passengers, mountain bikes and surf boards. I’m not getting a modern outback

  • @monorailconrad117
    @monorailconrad117 13 часов назад

    im not gonna lie, GOOD stis are in range of VB prices, so it just depends on what you want. the risk you run into with the stis is the possibility of replacing the engine. i personally have liked my vb especially since i lifted it, i havent really focused on engine mods

  • @44actual
    @44actual 2 дня назад +28

    Best answer is to buy a new VB. You can thank me later.

    • @WRXFan
      @WRXFan День назад +1

      100%. Used Japanese cars aren’t a bargain like they are for German cars such as bmw, Mercedes, etc. Japanese cars, especially Wrx’s, don’t lose much in value

    • @Gergm7991
      @Gergm7991 День назад +1

      Yes agree. Especially when you can get 10-15% off a new VB , depending on time of year / month and trim level. WRX sales have been down this year and so dealers are willing to deal.

    • @Itsdjsigi
      @Itsdjsigi День назад

      @@Gergm7991where are you seeing dealers take off 15%? That’s like 4-5k off?

    • @Gergm7991
      @Gergm7991 День назад

      @@Itsdjsigi I’m in central NC (Carolina) and got ‘23 Premium earlier this year for $5K off (almost 14%). Could have got a little more off a Limited. 15% is probably the upper limit and not common but I’ve heard many others say they got $3-4K off.

    • @nationalgeo2191
      @nationalgeo2191 День назад

      @@Gergm7991I was offered a new ‘23 STI premium for 32k. I forget what the msrp was at the time but I remember the offer being well below it. It’s funny too because I knew it wouldn’t be long before it was impossible to get a brand new one of that generation. At the time I couldn’t even afford the car. 3 months later the new generation came out and within weeks ‘23 STIs were selling for 45k brand new.

  • @truckinguy92
    @truckinguy92 2 дня назад +3

    This is rather subjective especially since there’s so many variables. As far as I see with most of the VA STi are expensive. Considering what most people do with these vehicles, mod them to the hilt, and then drive them into the ground, I wouldn’t even consider buying any WRX used.

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  2 дня назад

      It is but people don't look at it that way. They do think one is objectively better than the other for one reason or another b

  • @kingvega666
    @kingvega666 18 часов назад

    Great video. Hoping to trade my stinger gt in on a new 25 purple vb. Miss having a manual.

  • @leohummrich8026
    @leohummrich8026 День назад

    I was between the 2 when I bought my vb 8 months ago and I haven't regretted it, yes the sti has the cool factor but that's it. The vb is just better.

  • @BDA0531
    @BDA0531 День назад

    As someone who’s owned 2 VA STI’s and now a VB, I would not get a used STI as a daily unless there was a solid warranty

  • @juanticimo
    @juanticimo День назад

    Great Video Awais, the truth is , if you want an STI just get an older chassis, like the GD. THey are the best anyway, esp the 05 model year. Then daily a VB which with as you stated simple boltons, is way faster anyway and daily that. The VA STI is a strange concept because the engine tech is so old. Yea it can make serious power, but you need to drop 20k to do so

  • @user-zv3fe4nz8o
    @user-zv3fe4nz8o 13 часов назад

    Without maintenance records it’s really sketchy to buy used. Most people don’t take care of their cars. I was a tech for a few years. If you can find a low mileage, no winter driven vehicle with maintenance records I’m interested.

  • @eduardomaldonado5793
    @eduardomaldonado5793 День назад

    Was looking at a vb wrx for a daily after boosting my 2015 si but will be going with a gr corolla just for the driving experience alone

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 18 часов назад

      Lol theyre having engine issues so good luck

    • @eduardomaldonado5793
      @eduardomaldonado5793 17 часов назад

      @ lol yeah so I’ve heard there’s still time to think if I could get a good deal on a ts or just wait for them to drop in price cause they will then I’ll get one of those

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    I bought a used vb premium for 29k with 12k miles never happier, I love STI and always wanted one but for the price difference I don't see the value you can make the vb much more powerful with the difference you save

  • @freddyrivera318
    @freddyrivera318 Час назад

    Used STI for sure

  • @leohummrich8026
    @leohummrich8026 День назад

    There are vb wrx trs at my local dealership in morsville NC for 41k

  • @brandonfoltiny3943
    @brandonfoltiny3943 День назад

    Not sure where you are located, but I'm up in NJ. I bought my 22 Premium with 12k miles on it about 1.5 years ago for 30k. It wouldn't surprise me if some of these are real prices

  • @Grand.Kanyan
    @Grand.Kanyan День назад

    Just now getting interested in wrx's so probably a dumb question but what is vb? And whats the difference from a regular wrx?

    • @metalmonster34
      @metalmonster34 День назад +1

      The VB is a wrx that's 2022+ year chassis vs the VA chassis of 2015-2022 wrx.

    • @GordonGray-c8m
      @GordonGray-c8m 9 часов назад

      VB is the platform/chassis of the car. The 2015-2021 STI would be considered VA WRX STI.

  • @CruelUnknown
    @CruelUnknown 2 дня назад +2

    I got a used 22 VB 🤷 best of both worlds?

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  2 дня назад +3

      Dude used VB prices are ridiculously low.

    • @Jesusisthetruth99
      @Jesusisthetruth99 2 дня назад

      ​@HeavyMetalWRX my used 22 with 3k miles was cheaper than all the used 10k-20k mile VAs. Just depends when and where you look.

  • @jonathanb1987
    @jonathanb1987 2 дня назад +4

    You are completely wrong with the STI transmission. If you drive in the snow with the STI, you absolutely will use those differentials. It is a night and day difference between having limited slip vs open differentials. You have so much more traction from a stop and maintaining that traction as you drive. I have owned both the VA WRX and STI. The WRX slips just as much as my wife's Forester. Yes the symmetrical open diff AWD system is definitely better than fwd, rwd, and even other awd systems from other brands. However, it still doesn't beat the STI drivetrain in snowy conditions.

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  День назад +2

      Honestly you're still driving cautiously in the snow, or trying not to drive. You arent rallying in the snow. Is it better? Maybe...however I said you don't NEED it. The WRX AWD is more than capable in the same SAFE snow driving, in my opinion.

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 18 часов назад

      Never had any issue in my wrx in the snow. Sti owners just think they have something special 🤣

  • @603VB
    @603VB День назад

    3:31 Looks like I need to just buy a wrecked STI when I want to do my 6 speed swap…

  • @muchcat1113
    @muchcat1113 2 дня назад +2

    Honestly the only reason I kinda wish I would’ve bought an STI instead is for the more analog driving and the trans. Other than that, the VB is sweet. It’ll make power way cheaper than a compared to an EJ. First Subaru I’ve owned and I love it.

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  2 дня назад +1

      Gotta try the TR steering. It's not hydraulic like the STI but it's better than the stock 22-23.

    • @jonathanb1987
      @jonathanb1987 2 дня назад +2

      I bought the STI for the analog driving. I have never felt the need to do power modifications to the car. Getting lighter wheels and adding a slightly louder exhaust did enough for me. I agree that the FA24 is the better tuning platform now. It has so much higher of a ceiling than the EJ25. Since you plan on modifying your VB, I think you made the better choice for you. I made the better choice for me based off what we want out of our cars.

  • @TheIndulgers
    @TheIndulgers День назад +1

    For me, STI all the way. Both are great, but the STI is more special. The wrx just feels like a faster economy car. The LSD and transmission makes it worth the price imo.
    No one with a STI regrets not getting a wrx. Same can’t be said in the reverse. Something to be said for a warranty though.

  • @GordonGray-c8m
    @GordonGray-c8m 10 часов назад

    Before a week ago i was convinced a used STI was the way to go but after test driving some VB's im now convinced a new VB is the way to go. The used STI's just look so dated and a mechanical issue timebomb

  • @matthewwain9958
    @matthewwain9958 2 дня назад

    Was looking longingly at two STI's at local dealer. I'm never happy with cars lol.

    • @eduardomaldonado5793
      @eduardomaldonado5793 День назад +1

      lol ain’t that the truth went from a si to a wrx to a type r then back at a 9th gen si currently waiting for my turbo kit to arrive for it😂

  • @groo2765
    @groo2765 День назад

    Weren’t the STI’s 40k+ a year ago. I’m surprised. I need to sell my narrow body.

  • @davec3568
    @davec3568 День назад

    I had a '16 STi. Great trans/awd, mediocre car overall. If you're going to get an STi, I'd go for something pre '08.

  • @WholeCosmos
    @WholeCosmos 2 дня назад +1

    You're forgetting the limited slip diffs and driver contolled center diff being able to adjust the front to rear bias. The open diffs of the new WRX are garbage on sand rocks and dirt. New WRX It relies on the braking torque vectoring alone witch is fine on tarmac but not loose surfaces. and the rear bias is not adjustable. the older drive train Just for the differential setup older STI is worth it if you plan to go off road and want to stay on the dirt track or not get stuck.
    ruclips.net/video/WBQlK89PyxQ/видео.htmlsi=fu4rPofqHfyAI9Yr

  • @a124as
    @a124as День назад

    not even close. STI is a legend

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  День назад +1

      @@a124as actually WRX is the real legend.

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 17 часов назад

      No offense but sti owners are the biggest joke, I had a big turbo va wrx and sti fanboys wouldnt even wave or look in my direction. You all think your sti is on par with a Porsche or some other special sports car. Snobby asses cant even show other subarus love. They killed the sti because the vb is better. Hell i think the va wrx was better. They just new you asshats would buy a sti 🤣

  • @deigobams3
    @deigobams3 День назад

    Easy. If you want a 400HP weekend or track car, get the STI.

    • @kingvega666
      @kingvega666 18 часов назад

      Lmao its reverse bud. Sti is much harder to make over 400 and the engine is a weak link. Its almost like you didn’t even watch the video. Sti is dead for a reason.

  • @benscott6826
    @benscott6826 День назад

    New. Mainly because most wrx owners abuse and don't maintain

  • @elosbeatz5899
    @elosbeatz5899 15 часов назад

    Damn I shoulda waited to buy my Base model for like 32k I owe like 25k stilll on it :////

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    The vb is more powerful than the sti even with barely any upgrades just a tune

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    ruclips.net/video/7QnX22r83h8/видео.htmlsi=5ooYBO0Mxx4Sknv7

  • @pharmztko
    @pharmztko День назад +3

    I love the guys that think they need a STi to drive to Starbucks 😂.. if you want a race car or track car, buy STi.
    If you want a daily, buy a new VB

    • @steve8803
      @steve8803 День назад +3

      @pharmztko I love the guys that think they need a wrx to drive to Starbucks 😂.. if you want a race car or track car, buy wrx.
      If you want a daily, buy a new beige corolla.

  • @chrischarles9218
    @chrischarles9218 День назад

    LOL the comments.

  • @zachmarzolf8795
    @zachmarzolf8795 День назад

    ruclips.net/video/kOhDxXNU6SE/видео.htmlsi=eUm9rmmlOvDu3VTl

  • @Uncontrollableconstipation
    @Uncontrollableconstipation День назад

    There is no VB in Gran Turismo 7 so not even considered a race car. Stick with the VA STi

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  День назад

      Lol bro, by that logic the 2021 Toyota Himedic is a race car. 😂🙄

    • @Uncontrollableconstipation
      @Uncontrollableconstipation День назад

      @HeavyMetalWRX lmao I'm just saying why isn't the VB in the game while a bunch of other cars made the same year are.

  • @marcspence1905
    @marcspence1905 6 часов назад

    Anyone looking for a low mileage 18 sti 67k miles HMU!

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  4 часа назад

      I'll give you $15k 😂

    • @marcspence1905
      @marcspence1905 4 часа назад

      @ I have an 2001 Rsti if you bump that number up. 15k you can get a GD sti.

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  4 часа назад

      @marcspence1905 My man I'm broke My price is only going to go down 😂😂

    • @marcspence1905
      @marcspence1905 4 часа назад

      @ Where I come from thats called low balling. Go offer 15k to the next sti owner they will just laugh at you.

    • @HeavyMetalWRX
      @HeavyMetalWRX  4 часа назад

      @@marcspence1905 jokes on all of them I don't want to go backwards lol I'm very happy with the newer engine