Vocal Coach reacts to Nine Inch Nails - Hurt (Trent Reznor Live)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- 📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars....
☀️ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/...
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: / bethroars
Check out my second channel (Roar!) where I take on challenges: / roarrawr
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vocal Coach reacts reaction to analyses analyzes analysis of breaks down Nine Inch Nails - Hurt (Trent Reznor Live)
Original Video: • Nine Inch Nails - Hurt...
I hope this video helps you understand your voice and what you can do to grow as a singer
Book a lesson with Beth at www.bethroars....
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Social Media
Facebook: bethroars
Twitter: @bethroars
Insta: @bethroars
Hello everyone! I've started a second channel and I'd love it if you could check out my new video "I learned to Forge Steel"! I had so much fun making it. ruclips.net/video/KVlqmS_AFMs/видео.html
Mad World
Trent is definitely one of the musical genius of our time.
And a cool, nice, and all around decent human being. In a time when that is under assault.
But NIN keeps being ignored by reaction channels, unfortunately. The Downward Spiral and The Fragile have a lot of songs that are musical masterclasses.
@@rodrigorocha7282 it's probably far more profitable to react to more mainstream music, unfortunately.
I very much agree. His lyrics and the way he delivers it, with all its honesty, and sincerity, the way he sings it, he MEANS it. You could really hear the pain. It’s haunting and beautiful. It always makes me cry. Because I think many of us feel that way but couldn’t word it as he did. The composition with its dissonance, absolutely perfect for what he was conveying. Whenever I hear music like this, I wanna put myself in his mindset. I don’t know him so I can’t say much about him as a person, but I can say that he has a very beautiful mind. He’s a BEAUTIFUL MIND.
ahhhhh, the 90s. so much good music in so many different genres.
Anyone interested in music theory should explore this song. The entire composition is outstanding; from trents vocals, the dissonant piano, and droning noise. I cannot listen to this song without getting chills.
There‘s a channel for this. Ixi, a NIN nerd from Texas, has done a good analysis of Hurt and the whole TDS album. She also does really beautiful piano improvasitions of NIN songs.
Her channel deserves more viewers. Please Check her out: ruclips.net/video/1EJN_D9YjVI/видео.html
12 tone have done 2 vids about hurt. ruclips.net/video/kYtI4RE-LjU/видео.html&t
It's fantastic being at the live show when he plays it
There's an episode of song exploder on Netflix that interviews him about making the song and is by far the best episode of that series
@@DenisPasek Thanks so much for the shout out, fellow NINerd :) 🖤
Trent Reznor is amazing at emulating his emotions via his vocals. I've seen them over 20 times throughout the US at various venues and he ALWAYS brings the same energy to every single show.
NIN live is an experience. Some Bands have Songs where Fans sing along, but you along with thousands of People belting out every Song is something I’ll never forget.
Ive seen them once here in Chicago at Northerly Island. It isn’t a huge venue by any means. It is outside and right on the lake. That made it a really cool experience. It was so cold at Northerly Island that day…being right on the lake even in late May at night its coooold…it drops to about 42 degrees depending on the high of the day. It was my birthday so I remember that day really well..It was around 70 during the day and dropped like a brick at night. It was so cold Trent messed up Terrible Lie. You could hear how cold he was singing. But when he did Hurt near the end with the lights and seeing his breath because it was so cold…it was awesome. Something about the elements and how everything looked on stage mix with this song was an experience in itself. The whole show was amazing. It was my first and only time seeing NIN and for me that couldn’t get any better. Outside of that one hiccup which he handled like a pro…the show was fantastic. Ill never forget that.
That climax with drum and distortion is on of the best thing in music history.
That's probably the main reason I prefer the NIN version. Johnny Cash is an absolute legend, I just feel like the NIN version builds up to that final moment the entire song and then it hits like a truck, where the Cash one meanders a bit longer and kind of loses that momentum.
Gives me chills every single time. I always close my eyes during that bit to fully take it in; I had the privilege of seeing him live five times, and every single time I had to force myself to keep my eyes open because I didn't want to miss a single second. And it hits so much harder live, all of his music does. The perfect example of an artist whose live music is even better than the studio version.
I could not possibly agree more with you, Ben
@@fredwin that's why Cash is a country musician, "meandering and losing momentum" sums up country music quite well
@@felity1773 I understand, I've got nothing against the pacing of country. The song is just structured in a way that doesn't lend itself well to changes in pace. I'm pretty sure that's why Trent wasn't initially impressed with the cover, it really only stands out because of who Cash is as a person.
You really should just listen to all of NIN’s Downward Spiral…the entire album is a masterpiece.
Yes, please
Indeed
His best album in my opinion.
And then Further Down the Spiral
really shouldnt
Beth:
✅ Reacts
✅ Sings
✅ Chats
✅ Learns
✅ Roars
✅ Gets deeply existential and psychological and makes you contemplate your existence on earth and place in life.
SOMETHING I CAN NEVER HAVE is another amazing NIN song!
And she needs to check out the version from closure... By far the best live performance of the song
I listened to that song so much 20 years ago after a big breakup with "the one".
Such a thoughtful review of one of the most impacting song to me and probably many people. Those of us who were in our early 20s when downward spiral came out.. It was an album that just ripped you bare, and this was the pinnacle.
It's rare to see someone seriously consider what is happening in this song, and you did beautifully. Thank you
I first heard this album when I was 14. Been in love with NIN ever since 🥰
Trent makes soundscapes like no other. I love his movie soundtracks
Trent is really good at making complicated rhythms and dissonant sounds and turning them into music that sounds simple and beautiful.
Yeah. A few months ago, this song popped in my head, and I remembered a sort of "creepiness" to it. The dissonance made it creepy, calm, and beautiful. Something I remembered
Trent is definitely under-rated as a singer. If you listen to material and live shows from 89 till now, he's 1000% one of the best singers of our time, composer, musician, all of it. Someone that has specialized in his craft. Thank you again for this reaction!
The beauty and greatness of this song is Trent presents it as something he is experiencing in the now and Cash presents it as reviewing a lifetime of regrets, both very powerful and personal to themselves. I personally love both versions.
good way to put it
Even though Trent basically said "yeah this is John's song now, not mine" after he heard the cover.
@@kqatsi dude you JUST SAID the exact same thing i did but with more detail...
@@kqatsi "it really then, wasn’t my song anymore" because Cash had transformed a song so personal to Reznor into a song about Cash's own hurt.
@@kqatsi See... you had it HALF right... initially Trent didn't like the idea.. but after listening to the music AND watching the video.. he changed his mind about it and he was glad that Johnny had covered the song. So yeah...... next time get the whole story correct mkay?
I love NIN saw them 3 times, song still gives me chills
Trent Reznor is my favorite artist. His music is just so powerful. There is no one place his music sits, it is a spectrum of genius.
This song and "Something I Can Never Have" always hit me so hard. There is a wonderful live version of that song as well.
thank you Beth - someone actually reacting to the original version. i know Trent has said it's really a Johnny Cash song now (like Jimi and All Along The Watchtower) but i still much prefer NIN version. i was lucky enough to see them when they toured the album back in '94 and it blew me away then and has blown me away every time I've seen them since. Trent is the modern Mozart and a true living Legend Respect & Peace
Agreed. Its an unpopular opinion because Johnny Cash is much more mainstream, but I always thought people read a lot more into his cover because of his circumstances when he sang it. If you listen objectively its mostly just Cash doing Cash. His voice is pretty much gone at that point (Not that he really had much of one in the first place - nothing wrong with that, he made some great music), but all the feeling people read into it just isn't really there when you listen and compare it to NIN. Angst is the word and every time he sings it you can feel his pain, even if you have no idea who he is or what the song is about. I think if the same were true of Cash's version it might be a lot less revered than it is.
I think of them as two different songs and love them both. Johnny Cash's definitely made the song his own and it's excellent as well.
@@catocall7323 Thank you. *THAT* is the point Trent was making. *NOT* like Jimi and "all along the watch tower". Jimi *ACTUALLY* CHANGED THE MUSIC!!! Sorry... I know you're not the one I'm disagreeing with. But the people who seek to Fade trent out of *HIS* song is fucking ridiculous. Again sorry, but JOHNNY had *NOTHING* to do with the creation and power of this song/music/composition. It was *TRENT'S* life, pain, anguish, sorrow, misery, existence, creativity, and *GENIUS* that gave birth to this *Masterpiece.* *ALL* Johnny did was _resonate_ with what *TRENT* created. To say anything else... is ignorant.
Plus im not surprised that Trent says its a Cash song now, hes a man that has struggled with self worth and self belief all his life, i disagree with Trent this is and always will be his song in my eyes, i struggled with many things he struggled with and will always be able to relate with him more than cash, cash version is more a song of experience where as trent is more of a song about addiction self deprication and loneliness.
TRENT THE GOAT
It's such a different mood. The original has this grim, dark, gloomy vibe, like you're listening to the darkest corner of your mind. The Johny Cash cover is much more anthemic, like a strong set of final words. It just feels so much more impactful that someone not even half through his life emits so much sadness and desperation that inspires a person like Johny Cash.
"Gave Up" is definitely one that always hits me hard. It's not often that a song makes you take a personal inventory of yourself to see what you have become
How'bout "Wish" and "Last"? Those two are the best off of that "Broken" EP.
@@adamkeane2622 Head like a Hole still has a pretty relevant theme these days as well
@@fatcole1152 Amen to that!
Wow it's so great to see Beth doing great rock singers again )
I love the channel, but it's been mostly some unknown pop in recent months, so I didn't even watch.
I hope you'll keep on doing rock now! Thanks!
“Something I can never have” is another good one for a reaction
This song always make me emotional
Though it's not a vocal, the "wind sound" you mention is one of my favorite sounds used in a song of all time. Something about it just seems to speak of the loneliness, brokenness and emptiness that comes with the song.
I like Cash's version but the original has so many nuances to it that I really miss when others cover it. Especially the dissonant and "ugly" parts.
THANK you, Beth, I really love Trent's voice and singing technic, so unique and expressive and yes, sometimes fragile, but also so powerful! Great, brilliant singer, musician AND composer. And I love how the crowd listened him in almost complete silence during the soft parts without co-singing. Great audience, too! :)
What Beth says at the end about how singing this exposes your soul by making you address what your pain means to you - absolutely spot on. You need balls of steel to sing this
Trent is such an underrated singer..he gives his all in every performance. The man brings the energy throughout every performance and you walk away absolutely amazed at what you just witnessed. Rock God for sure!!
Your technical commentary allows me to appreciate music in a whole new way, Beth. Thank-you for sharing your knowledge and genuine love of music. Hugs from Canada.
Thank you SO much for doing the original of this. I feel anymore it gets overlooked due to both the Johnny Cash cover and that it wasn’t exactly singles material to begin with…. Enjoyed your bits of points on an important detail here and there both vocally and musically as to how/why the feeling of the song is created.
And, honestly, I’ve found the focus so hard on the Cash cover to where people have no idea it’s a cover AND vote near constantly that it’s better if they listen to both to be extremely grating. With how very different they are in how Cash filled out the music to a more radio-friendly form and such it’s understandably meant and manages to grab more people. - Note, I’m NOT running down the cover, it’s beautifully done, IMO. My frustration lies in the lack of awareness of and acknowledging the differing values of the original even if it may not be to the people/person's tastes.
I bring all of that up due to a point you made that I felt just summed it up and was so accurate: that each cover conveys whatever inside that person relates in some way to the original. How it’s a song that is made in a way and is presented by others to expose their personal meaning in a very self-baring way. That summation of how this song causes others to expose themselves so much through their covers of this honestly was such a beautiful way of sharing that idea that I got snuffily and teary with happiness sitting here in the cafe I frequent.
I saw NiN in Cleveland Ohio with my bestie in our favorite nightclub at the time. (the late-80s) I was amazed then, and I am still a huge fan!
You saw one of their first gigs then.
@@thedutchdjentleman The first year, at least. :) Trent Reznor was picking up momentum really fast in Cleveland.
Losing my dad and big brother last year the line "what have I become, my sweetest friend" hits me hard. I cannot apologize for how I was in the past 😖
Nine inch nails got me through the hardest times. His music means so much to me
Would love to see your reaction to another NiN song, called She's Gone Away. Prolly one of my favorite Reznor vocal performances and its tied to a show I love dearly called Twin Peaks. Keep up the good work Beth!
She's Gone Away is one of my favorite new NIN songs.
I avoid to say this often, and I don’t remember having ever directed this to a person I’ve never met, but very sincerely, I adore you Beth!❤️
You always carry yourself and show so much passion in every video you analyze and pick apart. Just so very sincere all the time. And I think that’s why so many people subscribe and follow you, because anyone can see you’re such a very genuine and lovely personality. Thank you Beth for all the love you put into your content for us.
Wow. Your analysis of this song brought me to tears. You're very right in saying that no matter how this song is covered, it brings that pain to the surface on an individual level. Such an amazing and well written song that captures humanity's fragility.
Had the pleasure of finally seeing them live. Trent is something else.
I once walked into a karaoke contest with nothing but the clothes on my back, and got 2nd place by singing this song a capella. I made one of the judges cry with my rendition. She voted for me to win 1st place, but the other judges voted for one of the other singers. I definitely understand the power of this song. Even without any music, it is powerful.
Such a fantastic song and performance, I definitely prefer this darker original version to the Johnny Cash one but the Cash one is still some good stuff.
This is the first Nine Inch Nails song I’ve ever heard. Unbelievable. It always kills me when I’ve heard a band’s name a million times and never gave them a listen, then I finally hear something like this and kick myself for taking so long to come around. Awesome song.
Everytime I hear any live version of this song by trent it makes me cry. I'd love to cover this but I doubt I could keep it together enough. It's such an emotional piece that's perfectly done
I agree 100 percent of your analysis of this masterpiece of self expression, a beautiful and emotional piece of music. There are not many songs that both lyrically and musically express the artists heartfelt emotions, struggles and message, and also touches the listeners heart and soul as well.
Such an incredible song. So moving, so powerful 🖤🖤🖤🖤
Yes, I absolutely did enjoy your reaction. Especially that it honestly moved you and of course your well put words about the song 😊
Thanks Mikael!
There is an even better version of this song that no one talks about. Nine inch nails did a tour with David Bowie where they played all their songs together. So there is a version of this song with nine inch nails and David Bowie together and it is magic.
Yeah, this! I kinda think people reacting to Johnny Cash's "hurt" should also post a reaction of listening to that extraordinary duet. (With the note - the duet was recorded a few years before Cash did his version.)
Cash's version has the sound of an old man expressing pain over lost relationships. Reznor's version has the sound of an addict expressing regret for destroying relationships.
you're a genius and i am glad for your analysis of a song that has made me cry many times.
I was at the concert were the filming of the original video to this song took place. Trent is an amazing artist and has been for 30 yrs now. I've been a fan since like 89( telling my age now lol). Great choice in songs Beth! Side note he is the entire band in the studio so you'll never find a more well rounded artist
Watching them live is another experience altogether! It's awesome that you review their version too :) Also, regarding your commentary referencing how the audience got quiet, they actually ask before the concert that on the slow songs we actually try and listen, instead of making noise, they passed some fliers while we were on the line :)
Love your reaction! I think Cash took a masterpiece of a song, and made it a masterpiece of his own. Neither is better, they are both masterpieces!
I love the NIN version of this song, but that's good point. I think it embodies the pain of the singer that is covering the song, so it can change so easily.
Great video. It was really interesting to see the same person analyze both versions of the song. Also, thanks for suggesting that everyone should sing Hurt. I've been posting covers one my channel recently so, as soon as I finished watching this video, I looked up the chord changes and played through it. It was the first time I'd ever played or sung the song and I got really emotional. I'll definitely be filming a cover in the next few weeks.
I was checking out Johnny and thought he wrote the song. Now I know Trent did. He was honored when Johnny asked to do it.
Any chance you could react to NIN's And All That Could Have Been? For me it tops even Hurt in how raw and painful it is. There's no decent-quality live versions of it like this BYIT version of Hurt though, since it took him almost 2 decades to play it live, and even then only a few times. But it's an absolute masterpiece I'd love to see your opinion on.
For the other side of his vocals, perhaps Happiness in Slavery; Wish; Last (basically anything off Broken); Somewhat Damaged? I'm Afraid Of Americans is a very interesting listen too, especially when contrasted against Bowie and considering the fact that Trent worked on the song with him.
I like both versions of this song. NIN and Johnny Cash do it in thier own stile. And it is very powerful message. And thank you for a great reaction video!!!
I really appreciate the love you have for music and the care you take at analyzing it. Thank you.
Hello Beth! I have listened to many vocal coach/teacher reactions and I have to say by far you are my favorite. I learn a lot about the different techniques artists use through your observations and explaining their techniques. I would love to see you do a cover of this song. Your Wicked Games cover was wonderful, but I think a cover of this would be even better!
this song is so emotional ty mr reznor
For me this performance hits more so cause of the crowd singing in the background. It's like we are all feeling it together 😞
A song about shame, regret, self-loathing and self-acceptance. Anyone who tries to fix their mental health issues goes through most of those things. Realising who you were, how you unintentionally hurt, and failed people around you. Losing hope for ever being able to have any meaningful relationship. Spending eternity on the bottom hating yourself but slowly realising there are only two ways out of it. Accepting that there is no possibility to change the past, but there is a choice to make the future better. It is nearly impossible to listen to this song with no tears. Johny Cash was saying his goodbye. Trent wrote a song about survival.
Couldn’t agree more with everything you said about this song. The atmospheric wind effect, his breathy vocals and the haunting piano melody draw you in straight away. You hit the chorus and you get the full effect of Trents amazing vocal range. To me the song is a build up of pain until there is a release and the live version adds to this, his vocal go from breathy to full force and at the end you have the band all playing then a finale that includes a huge drum hit, guitar and bass final note and a bright flash of lights. Song is perfect in every way. Beth if you enjoy this I highly recommend you watch the live version of Devin Townsends “Death of Music”. I was lucky enough to see it played live and to experience an entire audience be quite to just listen to a song was beyond amazing. Thank you so much for you channel, love your vids xx
I’m so thrilled to see you do this! The Downward Spiral is actually listed in my baby book as my “favorite music”? 😅 (baby to metalheads in 1993)
I found it again as a teenager and didn’t know that until much later.. it got me through some serious issues with depression and it’s a work of art, truly. So happy to live in the same time as Trent and see him mature as an artist and not let the industry burn him out ♥️
I loved being able to see what you had to say about the original version of this oh so sacred song, thank you!!!✨✨ love from Floriduuuh
You are SO amazing. Listening to your comments alongside the singing and music -- no words! Thank You : ))
This song and Sia’s « Breathe Me » are the kind of songs that you can relate to even if the subject is not really part of your life! The vocal performance and song writing are so personnal that it pulls you right in with them! Hard to explain!
Definitely ♥️❤️🩹
This is the best live performance of this song as well.
Nine inch nails was my first concert I ever went to back when I was in the fifth grade
I got tickets for June 17, 2022 at the Eden Project. Five times since 1989 I’ve seen NIN. The man is true genius.
I love how Beth describes the song writing.
Thank you for your reaction and insight. As many have said below, Trent is a genius and definitely overlooked. I am very happy that we all get to witness some exposure to his talent. Thanks again!
Songs like this, will go down in history just because of that feeling you explain. Beautiful thing❤️
This was BEAUTIFUL watching you feel this and hearing your deep insight on Trent's emotional singing. Subbed! p.s. I really liked what you said about this feeling like church music juxtaposed with a dark message. I feel like there's a certain reverence and intimacy in the crowd when it's performed live, too, how quiet and loud everyone gets in response and anticipation.
You are someone else
I am still right here
The truest words ever spoken about addiction
I saw Nine Inch Nails in concert back in 2006 and they were amazing. One of the best live shows I’ve ever attended. I remember when Trent played “Head Like a Hole” and he got in my face and we were screaming the lyrics back and forth to each other. One of the best concert experiences I’ve ever had.
Thank you Beth for doing the original version of this song. It is so powerful that tears stream doon ma face everytime I listen to it. Trent wasn't going to give Johnny permission to cover this as it is so personal to him. In the end, I'm glad he did, but the raw emotions that ooze out of every pore when Trent sings it is just purifying for yer soul. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!🤘🏻🇬🇧🖤
Reznor and a few others(Vedder, Cobain,....) do something that is rare, transmit through the voice 100% of their conscious emotions, and a fair part of unconscious ones too.
Next the Piano Version of "Something i could not have" !!!
@BethRoars, THANK YOU! I've loved this version since I was in the 5th grade....needless to say I had a rough home life. BUT, this song is the first song I ever learned on piano; and this live version is what brought me to the piano to cover the entire song. I LOVE that you LOVED IT! WONDERFUL! LOVE YOUR VIDEOS! YOU ROCK@@!!
Thank you for reacting to Trent Reznor's Hurt as well.
This song makes me cry cuz of how much i relate to it, i used to self harm, this song describes it perfectly
I know its about drugs, but its called hurt for a reason. Anyone who is hurting may relate to this like i did- trents voice is beautiful, and alot of emotions pour from his voice. Trent is an excellent musician and singer
Trent Reznor is a musical genius
This one made my night!! Excellent job of describing exactly how this song has always made me feel.
If you want to show someone a song of pure perfection, this is one of them! Gets me every time!
I cried when they played this song when I finally saw them live. So powerful, incredible
Love your commentary, and your easy on the eyes
Trent is a Genius!Thank you Beth!!!!
This is my all time favorite band. I'm glad you went over this, I'd love for you to do some of his earlier stuff too. Pretty hate machine is full of great songs. Ring Finger is one that comes to mind that I think you'd enjoy going over. Or Head like a hole.
Reznor = super genius… 👊💥
The performance was at the end of the second of two concerts where they've performed the entirety of The Downward Spiral front to back. It's an amazing show, you can find the whole thing on RUclips.
I love the tension he creates in the verses, first with the Bm#4 chord, plus he'll sing the major 3rd (D#) against the minor (D) then, as well. It's already very emotional and fragile with the vocal, but he often doesn't even give you a "stable" key center to mentally anchor to while you listen. He's truly one of the greatest composers of our time.
You have a way of explaining things that make it easy to understand.
You truly understand the depth and breadth of this song... how it reflects a person's pain when they sing it. The lyrics are broad enough to not be a specific hurt, but a general emotion that everyone can relate to.
just love the screen name
I've seen Nine Inch Nails 8 times.. Every time this song was amazing.. Contrast to most of the rest of the show being way more energetic..
The greatest musician of our generation IMO. He's constantly going above and beyond what any musician is doing out there.
Fantastic and insightful analysis as always Beth. Thank you for sharing your work with us.
I believe background noise effect is intended to symbolise the deafness the protagonist experiences from... let's just say having heard a loud noise. In the studio version it is much more pronounced in one ear.
I haven't watched this yet, but thank you thank you for doing this one! Looking forward to it.
Thank you, thank you, thank you Beth for this react video!!!! Trent Reznor is The King for me, I love all his art, all the music he made since 1990, that i found his music.
Peace and Love from Argentina!
Thanks for watching Pablo!
Enjoy the heck out of your posts! Keep up the great work !
The tightness you point out at the start is him sticking the hypodermic syringe into his arm... The loss of the end of hole.... Is the heroin hitting & him drifting away from the pain temporarily... Which is why the line, try to kill it all away, but I remember everything hits so hard.
Fantastic Thumbnail. Wish she would have listened to "Closer"
Trent's version of the song (at least to me) is about depression, and the two different tones of his singing represent the anger with yourself when your depression has ahold of you, and the utter exhaustion when you just can't bring yourself to do anything. To me he's talking to a partner, telling them that they need to leave because he'll just bring them down with him.
Johnny Cash's version is more about regret, for both the things he's done, and the things he'll never get to do. As somber as it is, Johnny's actually feels more uplifting to me, because his version is from a point of view of a life complete, where Trent's is not.
I was fortunate enough to see this live back in 1993. Amazing show live!
We are not just held in that single moment of silence. We are knowingly sharing in it. 🖤
This was uploaded on my birthday! Woah!
This song came out as Gen X was hitting 30. I was in treatment with a serious bout of depression. This song captured some of the things I was feeling and experiencing at the time. It is a bittersweet reminder of a dark time in my life.