@@dinglebop5700 you're thinking of flash animation, and i can't name like, a single show currently running that still uses it. most animation is still hand-drawn and frame by frame - just through drawing tablets.
Geez there's a lot of hate in these comments. I think this sort of observational video is really interesting, especially as a fan of animation and cartoons, but I guess some people are way too devoted to the things they love that they can't even take a non-negative criticism without being upset. This was a really interesting video though.
This is exactly what I hate about certain fans of some shows. They can’t take criticism without being super negative about it. Makes me want to sucker punch them through their screen, I just don’t like it. + This isn’t even controversial, it’s a damn piano
Know what I haven't seen yet in these kinds of videos? Setting the camera angle and focal length so that the piano keys match what is in the source animation and comparing how it actually looks. Particularly if someone not particularly familiar with playing the piano shown the video of one without the audio, then a pause, then the other without audio can spot the difference.
This guy says in the video That the cartoon isnt supposed to be the exact representation of the classical piece It has comedic value and he says that. He is a pianist And just criticized a cartoon That we all know and love. He didn't say anything hateful or mean He just showed some truths that I didnt even know So it was pretty cool. Obviously its hand drawn and took so much effort Its really incredible But not correct. And thats okay. Hell, animating at all is difficult let alone a whole instrument scene So just take the video with a grain of salt Or however the expression goes. I hope I said all that correctly Theres so much to say and typing comments on the phone isnt as easy as computer lol
My respects for the animators of this cartoon , they took the time to make tom play it correctly almost all the time , so few series has done it , Not saying that others are bad because they didn't play it correctly , but we have to appreciate the effort that they put here
Dude actually had the time and dedication to sit down and figure out exactly what was played in the animation, and actual Tom and Jerry stans (time travelers from 1947 I presume?) come out of the woodwork to complain... Well played, sir! 😂😂
It's funny how every other "pianos are never played correctly" video cites this animation as the One Accurate Piano Animation and yet you still managed to find flaws in it lol
In the minute 4:13 , if you slowed down the vedio, you will see that it not as it is described in a wrong way , but i guess it's the same way you played the piano correctly, it just not a slide on the piano... In my pov
Even if the piano animation isn't correct, you think children who watch tom & jerry are gonna observe it and criticise the episode?? Most of it is correct too.
@@mahdeeznuts It's just a cartoon, why would grownups criticise kid's cartoon? Imagine: Kid: Watches Tom and Jerry Dad: The notes are wrong this cartoon sucks Lololol
Well I understand the criticism but at least respect the animators. the first part all that matters, so it doesn't matter the next part was incorrect... and for those who are going against him he is just criticizing things and NOT complaining... so please show some respect.
@@koushalpant So their point is that since the viewers can't animate they shouldn't criticize animations? Yeah no that's stupid. Animation is directed to the audience so they are the ones that are gonna criticize them.
@@3F34N1M4T3S their point is what you said in the above comment "animating isn't as easy as you think it is" but this particular animation is almost 8 decades old and still more accurate than most animations today and it also won an Oscar so that's about it
@@koushalpant Still. There will be people liking and disliking stuff. You can't really do anything about it. This video isn't particularly giving a negative review anyways.
He has no obligation to do so, he just made a criticism of a specific part of the animation, which is not bad since it was not in an offensive way from what I saw and it was only in a constructive/good way. Also, animation is very very hard to do so
@RandomName "studios should be in shame" mf saying that the studio of an 3+ decade old episode should be in shame for animating an piano wrong, animation was frame by frame at that time and not like the modern animation.
![Summer Walker - Heart Of A Woman [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SFddctbZzw8/mqdefault.jpg)
At least they put effort into it unlike other cartoons, so I still respect it
Yeah
they won an academy award iirc, unlike warner bros, whose looney tunes short had the somewhat same premise and piece but the wrong notes
Like Amosdoll pointed it out.
yea respect it
Same
*Don’t judge him he has 4 fingers and a mouse is running on the keys.*
Yeah lol
yes lolololool
I dont judge him he have same finger like bugs bunny
Also mickey mouse and other more
Yeah Lol
Yes. Unlike other animations, this one is better.... Most are correct. I love this one. Try to check your lie in april is it correct?
trash anime
plus tom only has four finger
which make this even more awesome
Your lie in April uses rotoscope which is real pianist and violinist playing then the animators copy them. :)
It is
Not just "Your Lie in April", other anime nailed the piano animation.
Well considering that they had to animate it frame by frame from the past, it’s acceptable.
...
@@gapplssb
‘…’?
they still animate frame by frame??
@@wooper9629 no. Modern tools for animation eliminate the need for frame by frame animation in some cases
@@dinglebop5700 you're thinking of flash animation, and i can't name like, a single show currently running that still uses it. most animation is still hand-drawn and frame by frame - just through drawing tablets.
Someone should make a reanimated project of this where every note is correct. That would be pretty cool to see!
Hello. There is a reanimated project of Cat Concerto in the works and I’m the host.
The collab is on twitter
@@3GoldBalls how the status as of 2023 january
@@zian01000 focused on Big House Blues Reanimated right now
@@3GoldBallswhat's the status as of july
Geez there's a lot of hate in these comments. I think this sort of observational video is really interesting, especially as a fan of animation and cartoons, but I guess some people are way too devoted to the things they love that they can't even take a non-negative criticism without being upset. This was a really interesting video though.
This is exactly what I hate about certain fans of some shows. They can’t take criticism without being super negative about it. Makes me want to sucker punch them through their screen, I just don’t like it. + This isn’t even controversial, it’s a damn piano
I mean Tom has only 4 fingers lol
I just realised 🤣🤣
LOLL
Admit it,
When you were a kid you listened to the music tom played while imagining yourself playing that in school impressing everyone
Lol
Nah bro, just you on that one.
@@xuriusmediatardus8609 bruh
i actually had a piano and I would pretend I was Tom playing that exact same song. of course I wasn't good, but it's a memory to cherish.
i learned it and was planning to play it at my high school talent show last year but it got cancelled bc of covid
Tom tuned it's individual Piano keys differently. So, Tom is still playing correctly 😂
🙂
Know what I haven't seen yet in these kinds of videos? Setting the camera angle and focal length so that the piano keys match what is in the source animation and comparing how it actually looks. Particularly if someone not particularly familiar with playing the piano shown the video of one without the audio, then a pause, then the other without audio can spot the difference.
There were more interesting moments to break down in that episode…
True
This guy says in the video
That the cartoon isnt supposed to be the exact representation of the classical piece
It has comedic value and he says that.
He is a pianist
And just criticized a cartoon
That we all know and love.
He didn't say anything hateful or mean
He just showed some truths that I didnt even know
So it was pretty cool.
Obviously its hand drawn and took so much effort
Its really incredible
But not correct.
And thats okay.
Hell, animating at all is difficult let alone a whole instrument scene
So just take the video with a grain of salt
Or however the expression goes.
I hope I said all that correctly
Theres so much to say and typing comments on the phone isnt as easy as computer lol
THANK YOU!!! I don't know why everyone is acting like he's hating or something. He's incredibly talented!!!
You're really going to complain about the arpeggios being wrong while a mouse runs under the keys??
clearly a *mouse* has to follow along the notes!!
True classical music teacher moment
I always wondered why simply piano ads plagued me, until I realised
0:49 he plays true
1:34 i don't think that sound comes from piano
But he just giving some of the part in piano and explaining the animators save time
He said it
Bruh, bc what Tom is playing on the piano is based off a real song, he added the part they missed to save time!!
@ArchitCoffee Hungarian Rhapsody No.2 in C sharp minor - Liszt
It Felt As If The Audience Was Making That Sound Honestly Lmao.
3:58 actually sounds sorta good.
Honestly not really
True
Come on, they won an oscar for this!
For a four fingered cat he did pretty good
Didn’t it win an Oscar?
Yes
One out of seven Oscars that Tom and Jerry won (with 13 nominations)
I mean checking this is just a fun exercise, it's not meant to be taken as the cartoon having poor quality. The animation is still good.
My respects for the animators of this cartoon , they took the time to make tom play it correctly almost all the time , so few series has done it , Not saying that others are bad because they didn't play it correctly , but we have to appreciate the effort that they put here
hitting all of the white notes together and saying "it needs some black notes in it" made me LAUGH
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😆😆😆😆😆
😂🤣🤣
Ya bro 😂😂😂😂
🙂😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂🙂😀😃😄😁😆🤣😅😂
😂
Dude actually had the time and dedication to sit down and figure out exactly what was played in the animation, and actual Tom and Jerry stans (time travelers from 1947 I presume?) come out of the woodwork to complain...
Well played, sir! 😂😂
1:34 doesn't come from the piano.
His point is that the animators likely left that part out from the piano piece in order to save time while animating
That is the part from the original song, Tom didn't create the song lmao
Please can you make a tutorial for the Tom and Jerry concert madness from 2:40 to 3:10 .
It's funny how every other "pianos are never played correctly" video cites this animation as the One Accurate Piano Animation and yet you still managed to find flaws in it lol
Bro, they had to animate this frame by frame, a lot of effort too its hard to get every key correct so its still good the cartoon itself
4:16 my mind's too fucked up for that .-.
Could you do the TISM video with the rabbit on the keyboard?
Academy:*gives an Oscar for correct animation*
This guy:"NO!"
Tom only has 4 digits and has a mouse in his piano. Give him a break
4 digits🥹
Whats the name of this piece?
Hungarian Rhapsody No2 Liszt
Lmaoooo
WAP by Cardi B
Darude - Sandstorm
I had to. Not sorry.
Heliotrope Bouquet by Scott Joplin/Louis Chauvin
Awww i wanted he explain the parte where Tom put the loooooooooooong finger on the other side piano :(
Here is someone, who says a three year old, that Santa doesn’t exist:
Can we apreciate how this guy do this?
It would be awesome if u could do a tutorial for Stan by Eminem
honestly it's like 20 minutes to figure out
THIS IS UNEXCEPTABLE, THEY NEED TO RESPECT PIANIOSIM
This is unacceptable, they need to accept pianoism.*
@@GideonXD THIS IS UNEXCEPTABLE, THEY NEED TO RESPECT PIANIOSIM*
@@Nezuko-rm4qc This is unacceptable, they need to respect pianism.
Seeing how they had to animate back then, it was a great effort.
@@anaoshi_miyuki5690 THIS IS UNEXCEPTABLE, THEY NEED TO RESPECT PIANIOSIM*
youtube knows i’m watching something about pianos because they gave me a simply piano ad
In the minute 4:13 , if you slowed down the vedio, you will see that it not as it is described in a wrong way , but i guess it's the same way you played the piano correctly, it just not a slide on the piano... In my pov
Is this a digital piano ?
Yeah, you can usually tell by the sound of a note press
3:58 Like Jazz
Bro, Tom has only four fingers, give him a break 😅
Can you see if the playing in Your Lie in April is correct?
Isn’t the harmony pared behind?
Im pretty sure at the first scene there are sounds not from a piano
What's the Songs Name?
Have done the aristocats if not could you do that cause I'm curious
I thought this was moskowzski piano concerto
graveity fall's
bill ciper ya i want to see that
Even if the piano animation isn't correct, you think children who watch tom & jerry are gonna observe it and criticise the episode?? Most of it is correct too.
@@mahdeeznuts It's just a cartoon, why would grownups criticise kid's cartoon? Imagine: Kid: Watches Tom and Jerry
Dad: The notes are wrong this cartoon sucks
Lololol
@@Remises_16 You people are so soft, this video is not criticize the show at all, yet there kid like you mad about it
this video is just to prove that most of the part are incorrect bro, y'all so sensitive
@@Remises_16 Well, it's a media content too. We can analyse and see what makes something good and bad
@@Asm0sday -_- It's a cartoon we need to enjoy it not criticise. We can criticise the animation quality but not the extra details.
Well I understand the criticism but at least respect the animators. the first part all that matters, so it doesn't matter the next part was incorrect... and for those who are going against him he is just criticizing things and NOT complaining... so please show some respect.
IS ANGEL BEATS ONE CORRECT
3rd
and also he(Tom) play it with a had of four finger so the different is kind of obvious
Nobody:
The i’s being printed out on the piano: i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i
Finally someone realized
He sounds a bit like Brett from twosetviolin
Hi
You are amosdoll music.
Why Amosdoll being used here?
Fun fact: the song was also played by buggs bunny in the first clip, for buggs bunny it was incorrect!
The first part sounds like the troll face depressed
He played it correctly
I have been watching tom and Jerry for 6 year and I finally notice that tom hase 4 finger 🙁☹️☹️ poor tom
pls do the one in ep bats what i love about south in tom and jerry
is masha and the bear piano episode animated correctly?
The one one
Soul movie piano clip
2nd
Chill bro tom has 4 fingers
I know what I'm doing :)
Can you play transformer starting theme😊
Can you Stop Using Db? Please use C#!
It gives me a weird feeling on how cartoons play the piano. Something like a "acting all professional" and stuff.
Its doesn’t sound that bad for the first one tom
Well it’s hard to get a new blow but it’s okay.by emmy
Why are you hating on my boy Tom
also the fac tthe hammers are on bakcwards
"Actually it's incorrect" 🤓
"actually its correct" 🤓
@@Asm0sday Actually its ᑢᓍᖇᖇᘿᑢᖶ 🤓
Try Tom and jrrey
#Say_hello_to_Brazil ❤️
Smg4
You don’t need so much words
He was right not wrong
He wrong in most note
ℋℯ𝒽ℯ
But can you animate? 😐
Every piano doesn't sound the same bro
PiK-Yu! • 10.5T views • 50 years ago
A different piano isn’t going to change the entire sound of a note
Bugs bunny and tom did the same
Tom played it better
They both ripped of mickey from doing it
since you make lots of these why don't you try animating accurate instruments
Animating isn't as easy as you think it is. You can't just decide "oh yeah I am gonna make an extremely accurate animation because I felt like it".
@@3F34N1M4T3S that was the point of their comment
@@koushalpant
So their point is that since the viewers can't animate they shouldn't criticize animations? Yeah no that's stupid. Animation is directed to the audience so they are the ones that are gonna criticize them.
@@3F34N1M4T3S their point is what you said in the above comment "animating isn't as easy as you think it is" but this particular animation is almost 8 decades old and still more accurate than most animations today and it also won an Oscar so that's about it
@@koushalpant
Still. There will be people liking and disliking stuff. You can't really do anything about it. This video isn't particularly giving a negative review anyways.
Pianos are never animated correctly
👋Hi from Philippines
nobody cares where ur from
Hi
Please do The Simpsons Episode
There copy the Tom and jerry piano bugs the bunny just copy the piano
it's not ✅
Good at piano but not good at speech. "As you can see" could be removed from your video.
well it was close
HE WAS RIGHT STOP LYING
Did you watch the video before commenting?
Who cares
Hello random person
then try animating a cartoon character playing the piano ACCURATELY
He has no obligation to do so, he just made a criticism of a specific part of the animation, which is not bad since it was not in an offensive way from what I saw and it was only in a constructive/good way.
Also, animation is very very hard to do so
That's such a fucking stupid argument
@RandomName "studios should be in shame" mf saying that the studio of an 3+ decade old episode should be in shame for animating an piano wrong, animation was frame by frame at that time and not like the modern animation.