@@Unknown_Planet Learning languages is a hobby for me. I just want to share some simple stuff, like tips, source material for studying and some curiosities. When I progress on learning I will increase the density of content.
Add some more Romance languages, primarily Occitan, Catalan, Neapolitan, Lombard and Friulian. It will be much more interesting and innovative as there are literally hundreds of the same videos like you do. These are now all on Google Translate (new update).
Proto-Bantu, interesting! I speak a Nguni language and understood nothing except for a few random words 😂 I thought it gave a flavour of Lingala and Kiswahili in the way it sounded and the vocabulary, however it sounded more like Lingala or some western form of the isiNtu languages, I'd say. Thank you for featuring our language for once!
Egyptians, Romans, Etruscans, Greeks, Sumerians, Phoenicians. Mediteraneans people litteraly created the human civilization. 🔥💪🏽 From the oldest nile valley’s farmers and mesopotamians neolithic to the youngest irano-anatolian Mesolithic.
As a hebrew speaker, it is almost identical. Understood 95%. He says: "We are residing in the city of Tyre (Tzur). To the rising of the sun, and in the north, high mountains. Mount Hermon and the mountains of Levanon. On the mountains there is snow and cedars. From the cedars wood, the people of Tyre make ships and wooden houses. The city of Tyre is surrounded by the sea". The last part i didn’t undertsand. One day , there will be peace between our countries
@@romero522 As long as you consider yourself better than other people and as long as you covet the lands of other peoples, there will be no peace between us.
@@ahmedzaki6746 as long as you assume what i consider myself instead of actually talking with and knowing us, there will be no peace between us The moment you will, there will be a chance
Modern Hebrew is a revived language based on ancient aka liturgical Hebrew. Ancient Hebrew and Ancient phoenician were essentially different dialects of the same language.
As a Filipino, we Filipinos are not direct descendants from Austronesians, rather we come from a large collective of their first-generation descendants, the Malayo-Polynesian peoples. This very group, who would soon to be us Filipinos, settled down on the Philippine archipelago. Meanwhile, other large groups of Malayo-Polynesians explored further seas and lands, making their way to places like Indonesia, Madagascar, New Zealand, and Hawaii. As we may need to remind ourselves, the Malayo-Polynesians are in all and every way Austronesian. That being said, we must hold dear our roots as Austronesians and Malayo-Polynesians. May the Austronesian peoples prosper.
As Filipino. Our blood are origin from austronesian ancestors that we have arrivals like Malay, Indonesian, and etcs that they lived in our country before Spanish colonial came.
wow Andy, different style of video but still very nice, also as an Indonesian, I can hear words like "beras" and "babuy" (which I assumed means babi or pig) in the proto-austronesian part. It is interesting how some words have not changed or slightly changed over thousands of years
Interesting video. The names for some languages are wrong. For example there was no language called 'Viking,' Norse was the language spoken by most vikings. The language spoken across the Roman empire, was Latin, not Roman.
Languages like Old English and to some degree maybe also Gothic (although that corpus is more restricted) probably could, in theory, without having to fill in too many blanks. As for Gaulish and PIE, probably not, as the first one is very poorly attested and the second one is completely unattested. You might be able to create a 'Gaulish-ish' and a 'PIE-ish' language at best.
Modern Hebrew is a revived language, which is based on liturgical Hebrew, which is an attempt to preserve ancient Hebrew. We know Ancient Hebrew and Ancient Phoenician were essentially different dialects of the same language, but it's possible modern interpretations of Ancient Hebrew and Phoenician are biased by modern Hebrew pronunciations. For example, Modern Hebrew possesses a lot of "shua" sounds, but these may have been more like an "s", and the "ch" sounds may have been more like a "k" in ancient times.
@@JeffNeelzebub I king of disagree about the "Sh" sound, it is more correct about Akkadian for example, but I would agree about the "Ch" since it's more of a modern tweak to the Hebrew language because it doesn't has it. The letter "Sh" actually has two sounds depends on wether there's a dot inside or not - "Sh" or "S". I think they did pretty well with the revival of the Hebrew language, with the only exception would be the "R" sound, from the way I hear it, but even ancient Hebrew had instances of that Semitic strong R sound, and other Semitic languages such as Aramaic and Babylonian. And yet, I don't think it was a total "revival" of a dead language, since Hebrew had been spoken by Mizrahi Jews (Middle Eastern Jews) for over 2-3 thousands of years, and known in general as the language of the Judaic scriptures.
@JeffNeelzebub Modern Hebrew is a combination of all phases of Hebrew. Biblical Hebrew itself consists of a few phases of Hebrew. In addition, it consists of Mishnaic Hebrew which got a lot of Greek and Aramaic influence. and medieval Hebrew. Got words from Latin, Arabic and Greek. Modern Hebrew organised them into a single spoken langauge for mundane use rather than writing, basic communication poetry and religious use. So in addition had to loan words and reuse Hebrew roots in existing templates in order to create a new meaning. For example, Reshet = web Mirshetet = internet.
@@JacobIX99 Hebrew had been spoken as a liturgical language, not an everyday language, and the pronunciation still different considerably from Modern Hebrew, mostly in a lot of semitic sounds that are no longer included in Modern Hebrew
Old Chinese sounds like a mother who would soon birth Thai, Lao, Khmer & Vietnamese 😂 Meanwhile, the Proto-Austronesian sounds closest to the various Filipino languages today.
As a Hebrew speaker, Phoenician is like 90% identical He basically says: "We are residing in the city of Tyre (Tzur). To the rising of the sun, and in the north, high mountains. Mount Hermon and the mountains of Levanon. On the mountains there is snow and cedars. From the cedars wood, the people of Tyre make ships and wooden houses. The city of Tyre is surrounded by the sea". The last part i didn’t undertsand. But thats like a dialect for us.
The Rus' could definitely understand Old Slavonic, but they spoke a bit differently. It would be more appropriate to represent them with "The Word about Igor's army". Old Slavonic presented here is a literary variety of Old Bulgarian
@@alexi9108The Slavic phonology has changed a lot since then. So it's very hard for modern Slavic speakers to emulate it. The pronunciation here is a mostly accurate representation of Slavonic around Thrace and Macedonia in the 9th century AD
The man in the thumbnail looks so familiar, I wonder who the living man is that inspired this face generated by AI, maybe an Egyptian man or Greek man or Afghan man (these ethnicities have thick eyebrows, olive skin and a lot of people with big eyes), thank you for the video but sorry I don't believe in reconstructions of dead languages maybe they are only accurate 40%
Egyptians, Romans, Etruscans, Greeks, Sumerians, Phoenicians. Mediteraneans people litteraly created the human civilization. 🔥💪🏽 From the oldest nile valley’s farmers and mesopotamians neolithic to the youngest irano-anatolian Mesolithic.
So we are not going to add Chinese and Indian civilizations? Also instead of saying sumerians. You should say Mesopotamians (Sumerian, Assyrian, Akkadian, and Babylonian civilizations). Granted I would also add Sabaeans as well.
@@keshi5541 Yes Mesopotamians civilizations and Ancient Arabia, within all Akkadians, Chaldeans and Sabaeans as well, sourced from Sumerians and Canaanites admixing. I know China and Indus Valley civilization did great also, but they aren’t Mediteraneans originated like those previously.
no te parece. La mayoría de las lenguas modernas son la peor versión de sus raíces. Pocas lenguas evolucionaron de verdad. Pues no ando lejos - el castellano antiguo en algo es mejor que el moderno, y el persa medio es mejor que el persa moderno. Pues sí, esto es opcional pero lo de inglés: el moderno es una mierda rara al comparar con el anglosajón.
@honsuaman8743se puede decir esto. Tendrías razón en decir que todo esto es aproximado y no exacto pero fallaste en lo demás dicho. También hay cosas fundamentales que muestran la simplificación de lengua y en alguna vez su degeneración. Y los conspirólogos fanáticos (yo también soy de alternativo pero permito que pueda equivocarme) todo consideran de mentira, todo. Aún lo más evidente.. La construcción de inglés "I love you" significa literalmente "yo amar tú" o "yo amor tú" - eso no es degradación? Nadie me va asegurar en contrario, pues te escribo en castellano y ya sé que no comprenderás lo de "yo te amo" porque no existe este tipo de construcción en inglés. Buenas! No os ofendáis, es que sólo digo de lo que hay.
supposedly they have common origin, and at the very least they used to be much more similar in phonetics; second they had a much closer trade and diplomatic relationship, leading to borrowings and calques. Third, any chinese borrowing (especially from buddhist texts and poetry) was still kinda fresh at the time and similar in both languages as they didn't had yet the time to adapt and diverge in the respective language.
@honsuaman8743 nah, there is something. These are languages with an old written history and Japanese at least has fairly old phonetic writing. So, it is reconstructed not only on what you said but also based on real historical written evidence. It is just an estimation as u said but there is evidence that leads estimations.
You spoke in proto austronesian, all the other dubbers were modern speakers of the ancient language they worked on it? Well, I don't no in case how the thing were with etruscan/ sumerian
@@Miklosh.Prostoi Yeah because of the Bantu migration. But In the past Afro-Asiatic used to be the most spoken language family. North and East Africa were Afro-Asiatic speakers. Central (Nilo-Saharan family) and South Africa (Khoisan family). Niger-Congo family used to only exist in West Africa & some part of Western Central Africa only back then.
Good job andy. Just one thing. The picture that you chose to represent vedic person isn't accurate. We have actual genetic samples from swat Valley, andronovo, tamir basin and iran and we know that phenotypically early vedic people were INDISTINGUISHABLE from modern Scandinavian people. In fact even today in 2024 despite thousands of years of we can still see kalash people and some afghan tribes still have preserved those phenotypical features to a large extent. Its important that we don't twist and turn actual history just because certain parts of it make us uncomfortable. Keep on doing the good work❤
please do not call our founders bulgarian, Kiril and Methodija where Macedonians form the southern part of our country wich was amputated a hundred years ago now, its true that one of the amputated parts is in present day bulgaria, but thier place of birth is located in present day greece in the southern amputated part, and not bulgaria, please correct this
Include also one of the oldest languages Armenian language spoken in Armenian Urartu kingdom (Ararat/Araratta country, by name of Holy mountain Ararat, mentioned in Bible where Noah's arc landed after Great Flood). Armenian Ararat mountain isunder occupation for 100y by Turkey. There is relation between names Ararat=Armenia=Urartu. AR - ARAR-ARARICH-means in armenian GOD, Creator, God of Sun, life...Armenian Highland is second chance for LIFE that God gave humans Armenia, Assyria, Babylon,Egypt, Greece,Italy,Arabia etc are old countries, many of the dissaperead, but Armenia and many other old countries exist :) Hayk (Orion star) or Aik is pro-father, founder of country Hayq=Hay(k)astan=Armenia after Hayk killed Babylonian king Bell. Armenia during its long history was also part of Roman Empire, many Byzandian kings were armenians. We had Great Armenia, Minor Armenia, Urartu kingdom, Kilikia kingdom etc. Armenia is 1st country in the world that accepted Christianity as a state religion in 301AD after Jesus Christ's Apostles Bartholomew and Thaddeus visited Armenia in 1st century, 1st Christian church/cathedral in the world is Armenian Apostolic Church Holly Echmiadzin in Echmiadzin city, near our capital Yerevan, Armenia. In Armenian Echmiadzin is translated as following: էջ ēĵ "descent" + մի mi "only" + -ա- -a- (linking element) + ծին tsin "begotten"), that is, Echmiadzin means "the Descent of the Only-Begotten [Son of God]" or "Descended the Only Begotten".
Lucian? Could you please elaborate if you have the time? My impression was that the AI doesn't know the stress rules of Latin. You know the type you learn with your first verses in Latin.
Hebrew has just one descendent, Modern Hebrew, which is very close. In the video there's Phoenician which still is a Canaanite language and pretty similar. Andy has published many video with Hebrew-semitic comparisons and many more with Judeo-European languages (Yiddish, Ladino, etc) so I don't get your comment
@@azael1474 what do you mean ? Hebrew is not the same as pheonician , they both fall under the category of Canaanite Semitic languages , but hebrew was used as prayer and sometim even as regular language for many years even before modern Hebrew, modern Hebrew is 70% made of ancient Hebrew with many missing sounds like aayin and khaait and rrrreish , 20% is new Hebrew words made from the same language laws , and 10% are borrowed words from Arabic , English and very rarely Slavic languages
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
0:30 Anglo-Saxons (Old English)
0:53 Goths (Gothic)
1:23 Gauls (Gaulish)
1:52 Vikings (Old Norse)
2:29 Romans (Classical Latin)
2:58 Rus' (Old Church Slavonic)
3:27 Etruscans (Etruscan)
3:49 Aryan (Vedic Sanskrit)
4:15 Ancient Greeks (Ancient Greek)
4:54 Ancient Egyptians (Old Egyptian)
5:28 Sumerians (Sumerian)
5:28 Phoenicians (Phoenician)
6:30 Proto-Austronesian
7:03 Old Japanese
7:45 Old Chinese
8:27 Proto-Tungusic
8:43 Proto-Eskimo-Aleut
9:18 Proto-Alqonquian
9:41 Aztec (Classical Nahuatl)
10:17 Mayan (Classical Mayan)
10:54 Proto-Tupian
11:30 Proto-Bantu
Potresti fare un video sulla lingua Sami di Ter? Questa è la lingua meno parlata in Europa.
Do the Shehri/Jibbali Langauge please
I like this new format! Where did you get the Proto-Tungusic from?
PLEASE DO NENETS
@@MarcoAntonio-rs4yv ciao
This new format is quite interesting, Andy! As a pinoy myself, I can appreciate my shared heritage as an Austronesian! 🇵🇭
Salamat, Andy! ❤ just in time! My coffee is done brewing and I wanted to get creative. Your videos inspire me!
Thank you!!! 💖💖💖
I have started my own language channel because of you guys. Your channel is a great inspiration.
You better know some *real* linguistics before you start.
@@Unknown_Planet Learning languages is a hobby for me. I just want to share some simple stuff, like tips, source material for studying and some curiosities. When I progress on learning I will increase the density of content.
@@language.wanderer Sorry, I misread the comment and I thought that you've started creating your own language.
Add some more Romance languages, primarily Occitan, Catalan, Neapolitan, Lombard and Friulian. It will be much more interesting and innovative as there are literally hundreds of the same videos like you do. These are now all on Google Translate (new update).
Oh and of course Corsican! (no pun intended…)
Proto-Bantu, interesting! I speak a Nguni language and understood nothing except for a few random words 😂
I thought it gave a flavour of Lingala and Kiswahili in the way it sounded and the vocabulary, however it sounded more like Lingala or some western form of the isiNtu languages, I'd say. Thank you for featuring our language for once!
I like this format. Nice work, Andy!
Everyone else: …
Aryans speaking: 🕺🏻🕺🏻🎶🎵
It's cause they were chanting in it, not speaking.
@@rohitknandyala I know
Its a prayer
Egyptians, Romans, Etruscans, Greeks, Sumerians, Phoenicians. Mediteraneans people litteraly created the human civilization. 🔥💪🏽
From the oldest nile valley’s farmers and mesopotamians neolithic to the youngest irano-anatolian Mesolithic.
@@simeoneutras2097 You're gonna make the neo Nazis mad with this one lol
Very nice like to see more of this style in the future.
As a Lebanese person, I understood a little bit of the Phoenician. This made me feel truly connected to the past.
Phonecian and Arabic are closely related after all
As a hebrew speaker, it is almost identical. Understood 95%.
He says:
"We are residing in the city of Tyre (Tzur). To the rising of the sun, and in the north, high mountains. Mount Hermon and the mountains of Levanon.
On the mountains there is snow and cedars.
From the cedars wood, the people of Tyre make ships and wooden houses. The city of Tyre is surrounded by the sea".
The last part i didn’t undertsand.
One day , there will be peace between our countries
@@romero522
As long as you consider yourself better than other people and as long as you covet the lands of other peoples, there will be no peace between us.
@@ahmedzaki6746 as long as you assume what i consider myself instead of actually talking with and knowing us, there will be no peace between us
The moment you will, there will be a chance
It looks like Hebrew (including modern) and ancient Phoenician are 80-90% exactly the same: I perfectly understood everything.
Indeed an Hebrew speaker will understand all or most of the Phoenician language as both are canaanite dialects
Modern Hebrew is a revived language based on ancient aka liturgical Hebrew. Ancient Hebrew and Ancient phoenician were essentially different dialects of the same language.
This is no surprise because modern Hebrew was constructed in large part from Phoenician words.
@@KohanKilletz no it wasn't, where did you get that idea? Why would they even do that? Biblical Hebrew is better preserved than Phoenician is
they are closely related, similar to Spanish and Portuguese, I think
I love this concept please we need more! :D
As a Filipino, we Filipinos are not direct descendants from Austronesians, rather we come from a large collective of their first-generation descendants, the Malayo-Polynesian peoples. This very group, who would soon to be us Filipinos, settled down on the Philippine archipelago. Meanwhile, other large groups of Malayo-Polynesians explored further seas and lands, making their way to places like Indonesia, Madagascar, New Zealand, and Hawaii. As we may need to remind ourselves, the Malayo-Polynesians are in all and every way Austronesian. That being said, we must hold dear our roots as Austronesians and Malayo-Polynesians. May the Austronesian peoples prosper.
No but before Austronesians dominated the Philippines there were already people in the Philippines like the Negritos and the Inati
Also for Austronesians, there are multiple theories, more than just Peter Bellwood and Frank”s.
As Filipino. Our blood are origin from austronesian ancestors that we have arrivals like Malay, Indonesian, and etcs that they lived in our country before Spanish colonial came.
just discovered the "Old Chinese" speaker was reading the famous poem of 蒹葭, and maybe the "Vedic" speaker was singing some chapter of Veda?
蒹葭苍苍，白露为霜
wow Andy, different style of video but still very nice, also as an Indonesian, I can hear words like "beras" and "babuy" (which I assumed means babi or pig) in the proto-austronesian part. It is interesting how some words have not changed or slightly changed over thousands of years
Phoenician is very close to Hebrew. I could even understand some words like anakhnu (we) or shemesh (sun)
Bellissima idea Andy😁
Sarebbe bella una seconda parte con il Proto-Ungarico, L'osco, il Longobardo, L' Umbro il Proto-indoeuropeo ecc
Ah, finalmente un ammiratore italiano
Interesting video. The names for some languages are wrong. For example there was no language called 'Viking,' Norse was the language spoken by most vikings. The language spoken across the Roman empire, was Latin, not Roman.
Thanks thanks about what we can learn
Why are there no transcriptions or translations of the read text in this format?
It would be nice to have (in this format) a video on Language Isolates. Like Ainu etc.
I wish you would do old Amharic.
Can you ressurect Frankish or do a comparison video from Frankish to Old Dutch to Middle Dutch to Modern Dutch? I love your videos, Andy ❤
Eu espero que programa que fala osso idiomas antigos esteja disponível.
Can some of the languages or ancient languages be revived, or not?
Languages like Old English and to some degree maybe also Gothic (although that corpus is more restricted) probably could, in theory, without having to fill in too many blanks. As for Gaulish and PIE, probably not, as the first one is very poorly attested and the second one is completely unattested. You might be able to create a 'Gaulish-ish' and a 'PIE-ish' language at best.
Wtf, I totally 90% understood Phoenician and I'm Hebrew speaker. I barely felt a different!
Modern Hebrew is a revived language, which is based on liturgical Hebrew, which is an attempt to preserve ancient Hebrew. We know Ancient Hebrew and Ancient Phoenician were essentially different dialects of the same language, but it's possible modern interpretations of Ancient Hebrew and Phoenician are biased by modern Hebrew pronunciations. For example, Modern Hebrew possesses a lot of "shua" sounds, but these may have been more like an "s", and the "ch" sounds may have been more like a "k" in ancient times.
@@JeffNeelzebub I king of disagree about the "Sh" sound, it is more correct about Akkadian for example, but I would agree about the "Ch" since it's more of a modern tweak to the Hebrew language because it doesn't has it. The letter "Sh" actually has two sounds depends on wether there's a dot inside or not - "Sh" or "S". I think they did pretty well with the revival of the Hebrew language, with the only exception would be the "R" sound, from the way I hear it, but even ancient Hebrew had instances of that Semitic strong R sound, and other Semitic languages such as Aramaic and Babylonian. And yet, I don't think it was a total "revival" of a dead language, since Hebrew had been spoken by Mizrahi Jews (Middle Eastern Jews) for over 2-3 thousands of years, and known in general as the language of the Judaic scriptures.
@@JacobIX99 It’s quite possible that our interpretation of Akkadian may be influenced by modern Hebrew as well. Just a thought.
@JeffNeelzebub
Modern Hebrew is a combination of all phases of Hebrew.
Biblical Hebrew itself consists of a few phases of Hebrew.
In addition, it consists of Mishnaic Hebrew which got a lot of Greek and Aramaic influence.
and medieval Hebrew. Got words from Latin, Arabic and Greek.
Modern Hebrew organised them into a single spoken langauge for mundane use rather than writing, basic communication poetry and religious use. So in addition had to loan words and reuse Hebrew roots in existing templates in order to create a new meaning.
For example,
Reshet = web
Mirshetet = internet.
@@JacobIX99 Hebrew had been spoken as a liturgical language, not an everyday language, and the pronunciation still different considerably from Modern Hebrew, mostly in a lot of semitic sounds that are no longer included in Modern Hebrew
Thanks for sharing this! I understood the Slavonic part, because I am familiar with the text😂
Old Chinese wow😮
Sounds so different from modern Chinese.
The consonant clusters to tones pipeline is interesting
my mom is Chinese and I am too and she could not understand surprisingly to how different it sounds
As a Hebrew speaker, I actually understood some of the Phoenician.
Pheonician just sounds like someone speaking Hebrew with a heavy accent
Very interesting chance of pace, you should do one for conlangs😃
Great suggestion! Thank you!
Very good.
Phoenician language اللغة الفينيقية ❤❤❤🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧
Old Chinese sounds like a mother who would soon birth Thai, Lao, Khmer & Vietnamese 😂
Meanwhile, the Proto-Austronesian sounds closest to the various Filipino languages today.
Maybe Proto tai-Kadai and proto austroasiatic too?
5:28 honestly i can kinda understand some of it cuz its so similar to hebrew
Can I have the timecode?
Perfect ❤
As a Hebrew speaker, Phoenician is like 90% identical
He basically says:
"We are residing in the city of Tyre (Tzur). To the rising of the sun, and in the north, high mountains. Mount Hermon and the mountains of Levanon.
On the mountains there is snow and cedars.
From the cedars wood, the people of Tyre make ships and wooden houses. The city of Tyre is surrounded by the sea".
The last part i didn’t undertsand.
But thats like a dialect for us.
how did you get these voices?
Interessante que no inglês antigo destaca o som do R.
The Rus' could definitely understand Old Slavonic, but they spoke a bit differently. It would be more appropriate to represent them with "The Word about Igor's army". Old Slavonic presented here is a literary variety of Old Bulgarian
It sounded more like weird AI-generated gibberish, vaguely Rus'-like
@@alexi9108The Slavic phonology has changed a lot since then. So it's very hard for modern Slavic speakers to emulate it. The pronunciation here is a mostly accurate representation of Slavonic around Thrace and Macedonia in the 9th century AD
Didn't expect Pronto Tungusic to sound so nice 😍
Even modern tungusic languages sound soft and nice. No guttural and harsh sounds and consonant clusters that present in turkic and mongolic languages
The man in the thumbnail looks so familiar, I wonder who the living man is that inspired this face generated by AI, maybe an Egyptian man or Greek man or Afghan man (these ethnicities have thick eyebrows, olive skin and a lot of people with big eyes), thank you for the video but sorry I don't believe in reconstructions of dead languages maybe they are only accurate 40%
Old Church Slavonic voiced Italian?
Thanks! Now I know that Old Church Slavonic are the Rus people!
Aquí el gálico suena más latín que el mismo latín. Pues era cierto, una lengua muy cercana de latín..
Well, the Latin speaker here haven't even heard of the penultima stress rule, therefore, it didn't sound Latin to me either.
And who’s voice is this? That’s not Andy!
where is akkadian, avestan and old Persian?
You should put Proto-Tamil or Dravidian
O Chinês antigo é fascinante 😳😳😳😱😱.
Gothic sounds wicked.
"Bible Gothic"
Egyptians, Romans, Etruscans, Greeks, Sumerians, Phoenicians. Mediteraneans people litteraly created the human civilization. 🔥💪🏽
From the oldest nile valley’s farmers and mesopotamians neolithic to the youngest irano-anatolian Mesolithic.
So we are not going to add Chinese and Indian civilizations?
Also instead of saying sumerians. You should say Mesopotamians (Sumerian, Assyrian, Akkadian, and Babylonian civilizations). Granted I would also add Sabaeans as well.
@@keshi5541 Yes Mesopotamians civilizations and Ancient Arabia, within all Akkadians, Chaldeans and Sabaeans as well, sourced from Sumerians and Canaanites admixing.
I know China and Indus Valley civilization did great also, but they aren’t Mediteraneans originated like those previously.
They all sound so cool and rich. Is it just me or do modern languages sound so lame in comparison
no te parece. La mayoría de las lenguas modernas son la peor versión de sus raíces. Pocas lenguas evolucionaron de verdad. Pues no ando lejos - el castellano antiguo en algo es mejor que el moderno, y el persa medio es mejor que el persa moderno. Pues sí, esto es opcional pero lo de inglés: el moderno es una mierda rara al comparar con el anglosajón.
So you see, the reconstructions we have of these older/ancient languages are in formal speech
@honsuaman8743se puede decir esto. Tendrías razón en decir que todo esto es aproximado y no exacto pero fallaste en lo demás dicho. También hay cosas fundamentales que muestran la simplificación de lengua y en alguna vez su degeneración. Y los conspirólogos fanáticos (yo también soy de alternativo pero permito que pueda equivocarme) todo consideran de mentira, todo. Aún lo más evidente.. La construcción de inglés "I love you" significa literalmente "yo amar tú" o "yo amor tú" - eso no es degradación? Nadie me va asegurar en contrario, pues te escribo en castellano y ya sé que no comprenderás lo de "yo te amo" porque no existe este tipo de construcción en inglés. Buenas! No os ofendáis, es que sólo digo de lo que hay.
imagine a heated argue in Vedic (Aryan)🤣 3:49
He is chanting not speaking
Rus' with an English accent
Like Greek, they sound like Arabic, English? and anything else you can imagine, except Greek 😂
How would you know what native Rus sounded like? I don't hear an accent since I trust the speaker actively speaking this way.
@@nyhylAs a Russian-speaker, I have a very noticeable English accent, and I can say that the announcer himself is English-speaking
@@nyhyl him T and D very no Slavic
@@agop_minosyan я носитель русскаго языка, но я слышу либо болгарскій либо чешско/польскій акцентъ, но вообще никакъ не англійскій
Gauls ( Gaulês em Português)
The Gothic guy may have had one too many, as his pronunciation of words like "managein" and "wisandein" sounds way off.
Ehhhhh, where's Proto-Uralic?((😭😭😭😭
Will do a 2nd part. :)
@@ilovelanguages0124 )))))
@@ilovelanguages0124 do Ge'ez.
Also Ge'ez is way easier to do because it's not an extinct language and instead just a dead one.
Good
I understood a lot of the ancient greek, the pronunciation was fine from what I can hear, but the pitch accent is a bit too much and over the top.
Classical Syriac, please
Good video but the letter are way too small to read Edit: actually they are readable but still very small
Please can anyone help me learning Zulu please please.
Now my head's spinning
Rus' sounded closest to Makedonian 🇲🇰
😂 because todays macedonian is not macedonan but assimilated by russian (church slavic) and is in fact very vulgar russian
I actually hear ancient language everyday, I speak Lithuanian 😅
Latino ,ho capito tutto il senso di ciò che dice anche se non tutte le parole .
Ancient Egyptian sounds semetic almost.
I mean it's an afro-asiatic language but that's interesting.
Why does Old Japanese sound a bit like Korean?
supposedly they have common origin, and at the very least they used to be much more similar in phonetics; second they had a much closer trade and diplomatic relationship, leading to borrowings and calques. Third, any chinese borrowing (especially from buddhist texts and poetry) was still kinda fresh at the time and similar in both languages as they didn't had yet the time to adapt and diverge in the respective language.
@@azael1474 Ah okay so it wasn't just me. Thanks
@honsuaman8743 nah, there is something. These are languages with an old written history and Japanese at least has fairly old phonetic writing. So, it is reconstructed not only on what you said but also based on real historical written evidence.
It is just an estimation as u said but there is evidence that leads estimations.
1
Sounds like the Gaulish guy worshipped the whole pantheon of his people. Strange I understood more of the Gaulish words than anything else.
Me too, and I suddenly felt a strange urge to carve out a menhir or go on a wild boar hunt.
@@ansibarius4633 Hey, looks like Caesar didn't get all of us.
😊
You spoke in proto austronesian, all the other dubbers were modern speakers of the ancient language they worked on it? Well, I don't no in case how the thing were with etruscan/ sumerian
BANTU?
Batu are divided into many languages and which language should it be?
Yes, this is largest language family of Africa. Example, zulu people, swahili people and congolesians speaks bantu languages too.
@@Miklosh.Prostoi Yeah because of the Bantu migration.
But In the past Afro-Asiatic used to be the most spoken language family. North and East Africa were Afro-Asiatic speakers. Central (Nilo-Saharan family) and South Africa (Khoisan family). Niger-Congo family used to only exist in West Africa & some part of Western Central Africa only back then.
Gaul sounds like Valyrian
Ancient Greek was very surprising compared to Modern Greek.
Why is vedic singing
Rus wrong germanized pronounciation
vine por la miniatura
Good job andy. Just one thing. The picture that you chose to represent vedic person isn't accurate. We have actual genetic samples from swat Valley, andronovo, tamir basin and iran and we know that phenotypically early vedic people were INDISTINGUISHABLE from modern Scandinavian people. In fact even today in 2024 despite thousands of years of we can still see kalash people and some afghan tribes still have preserved those phenotypical features to a large extent. Its important that we don't twist and turn actual history just because certain parts of it make us uncomfortable.
Keep on doing the good work❤
please do not call our founders bulgarian, Kiril and Methodija where Macedonians form the southern part of our country wich was amputated a hundred years ago now, its true that one of the amputated parts is in present day bulgaria, but thier place of birth is located in present day greece in the southern amputated part, and not bulgaria, please correct this
Include also one of the oldest languages Armenian language spoken in Armenian Urartu kingdom (Ararat/Araratta country, by name of Holy mountain Ararat, mentioned in Bible where Noah's arc landed after Great Flood). Armenian Ararat mountain isunder occupation for 100y by Turkey. There is relation between names Ararat=Armenia=Urartu. AR - ARAR-ARARICH-means in armenian GOD, Creator, God of Sun, life...Armenian Highland is second chance for LIFE that God gave humans Armenia, Assyria, Babylon,Egypt, Greece,Italy,Arabia etc are old countries, many of the dissaperead, but Armenia and many other old countries exist :) Hayk (Orion star) or Aik is pro-father, founder of country Hayq=Hay(k)astan=Armenia after Hayk killed Babylonian king Bell. Armenia during its long history was also part of Roman Empire, many Byzandian kings were armenians. We had Great Armenia, Minor Armenia, Urartu kingdom, Kilikia kingdom etc. Armenia is 1st country in the world that accepted Christianity as a state religion in 301AD after Jesus Christ's Apostles Bartholomew and Thaddeus visited Armenia in 1st century, 1st Christian church/cathedral in the world is Armenian Apostolic Church Holly Echmiadzin in Echmiadzin city, near our capital Yerevan, Armenia. In Armenian Echmiadzin is translated as following: էջ ēĵ "descent" + մի mi "only" + -ա- -a- (linking element) + ծին tsin "begotten"), that is, Echmiadzin means "the Descent of the Only-Begotten [Son of God]" or "Descended the Only Begotten".
in Latin... the accent is catastrophic
Greek the best language!
Macedonian 🇲🇰 better!
ANCIENT BOYS
Great video, but why not even one picture of a woman?
Where are Proto-Trans-New Guinea and Proto-Pama-Nyungan?
Gaul sounds something between Italian and Greek
The Latin sounds very "lucian" ;-)
Lucian? Could you please elaborate if you have the time?
My impression was that the AI doesn't know the stress rules of Latin. You know the type you learn with your first verses in Latin.
You never put Hebrew
Hebrew has just one descendent, Modern Hebrew, which is very close. In the video there's Phoenician which still is a Canaanite language and pretty similar.
Andy has published many video with Hebrew-semitic comparisons and many more with Judeo-European languages (Yiddish, Ladino, etc) so I don't get your comment
Phonecian would have been pretty close to the Hebrew of that day.
@@azael1474ancient Hebrew had more pronunciations like in Arabic AAyin and Hhait, and kh and rrrrr, plus it had more borrowed words from Aramaic
@@azael1474 what do you mean ? Hebrew is not the same as pheonician , they both fall under the category of Canaanite Semitic languages , but hebrew was used as prayer and sometim even as regular language for many years even before modern Hebrew, modern Hebrew is 70% made of ancient Hebrew with many missing sounds like aayin and khaait and rrrreish , 20% is new Hebrew words made from the same language laws , and 10% are borrowed words from Arabic , English and very rarely Slavic languages
@@ultimatedark5969 i just mean you can't have them all in one video, there are so many languages that weren't included even nearly
Where is Hebrew!!!!!!!!!
From the river to the sea Palestine will be free
Ancient Greek sounds more Albanian than Greek! 😁
What? You must be kidding
You should provide stamp