About food safe 3D printing

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 дек 2019
  • Let's talk about food safe 3D printing. I noticed on 3D printing forums, that users only ask about food safe filament type, like PLA or PETG, but some of these materials can be very toxic, depend of the coloring material or additives. It is important what type of nozzle we use, some of them contain lead. Very important task is Bacteria Buildup, gaps between layers are perfect place for them. In this video I was testing one good solution for food grade 3D printing, and that is coating with two component food grade epoxy resin. Results can be seen at the end of the video.
    Download STL for the cup:
    www.mytechfun.com/video/35
    Szent Istvan University, Faculty of Food Science:
    etk.szie.hu/
    Bacterial tests are made by Department of Biotechnology and Pharmaceutical Engineering (University of Novi Sad)
    www.tf.uns.ac.rs/site/index.ph...
    This work was presented at 3rd International Conference on Biosystems and Food Engineering, but only abstract was published. That's why later I created this video.
    www.biosysfoodeng.hu/
    10:20-10:40 # Igor Gáspár, Jovana Grahovac: Food safe 3D printing
    *Update (2020-06-02): I bought 3 types of antibacterial filaments too, test will be published in near future, no need to send be those filaments any more (mentioned in video)
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 280

  • @pippanappleton2421
    @pippanappleton2421 4 года назад +178

    Brilliant! Systematic and scientific approach to answering a question that so many of us have wondered about. Really well presented video too. Thank you

    • @KLP99
      @KLP99 3 года назад

      Absolutely agree. Now to find the results of future tests. I'm curious especially if the spray or painted on items to be tested later, have been already.
      The most we can learn, the better.

  • @delscoville
    @delscoville 4 года назад +76

    Good to know. I haven't printed anything for food use, but everyone who 3D prints should know this.

  • @SeamusHarper1234
    @SeamusHarper1234 4 года назад +52

    This is awesome, finally a professional approach to this problem.

    • @SeamusHarper1234
      @SeamusHarper1234 4 года назад +3

      @xr7fan The problem is, that there are a lot of 3D models out there that are used in the kitchen an these are not really safe. By the way, 3D printing is not in the least about cost efficiency. Maybe you want a special cup. Your very own cup to cherish. With your name engraved.

  • @marshj6594
    @marshj6594 4 года назад +30

    I've always wondered whether or not bacteria truly did have a higher likelihood of growing on 3d printed parts, but I didn't have the materials/lab to do any tests. Thanks for using your resources to give us a definitive answer to this important question!

  • @drderrp
    @drderrp 4 года назад +26

    Thank you for doing the leg work on all of this. Science!

  • @jonduke4472
    @jonduke4472 4 года назад +19

    Thank you for the research.
    Another branch to try is the SLA UV resin printing. It is supposed to be inert after curing.

    • @volkanklc9490
      @volkanklc9490 3 года назад +2

      I also wonder the results for SLA but I guess it's almost imposible to eliminate residual monomers from uncured resin even washed the part with IPA and postcured.

    • @jonduke4472
      @jonduke4472 3 года назад

      @@volkanklc9490 interesting. Thanks for the reply. Some of 3D printing channels have done light testing of other cleaning products. I wonder if there is something more effective than IPA. But for now, no 3D prints near food!

  • @bunbunHD
    @bunbunHD Год назад +1

    I'm researching potential 3d printing some molds for production cooking and I REALLY appreciate all of your knowledge on this topic. Even 3 years later (and many more to come I imagine), your video is helping people. Thanks so much for making it!

    • @alexpanov
      @alexpanov 9 месяцев назад

      reading this in Sept 2023!

  • @mak3r710
    @mak3r710 4 года назад +26

    Awesome videos, one of the best explanatory RUclips channels I came across! Love the scientific approach to everything. Keep the good work up ❤️

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +5

      Wow, these kind of compliments are ready motivating. Thx

    • @ROBOROBOROBOROBO
      @ROBOROBOROBOROBO 8 дней назад

      ​@@MyTechFunThis video helped me a ton after many years. Thank you!!!
      So PETG smoothed and Epoxy Resin is the best result.
      Is the surface smoothed because of the Epoxy Resin? Or because there was perhaps another process not mentioned here

  • @joshuaa.c.newman7430
    @joshuaa.c.newman7430 3 года назад +11

    I’ve been doing some experiments to handle the two hard-to-address issues: microbial harbors and heat deformation (since I’m working on a coffee set). My process right now is:
    1: Design so that there are no hard-to-clean spots
    2: Print PLA with a steel nozzle. Finding the chemical properties of a given filament/color turns out to be hard. I’m keeping it to white Hatchbox PLA for now because white pigments tend to be pretty innocuous. I would LOVE a spreadsheet of filaments that are certified Food Safe and ones that you think are likely OK, perhaps with some that are definitely not OK so we know what to look for!
    3: Thoroughly dissolve, smooth, and seal the surface with Plastruct Plastic Weld, which seems to be mostly MEK with a little bit of ABS dissolved in it.
    4: Boil the piece for five minutes. This anneals the plastic really evenly. Uneven shapes and densities don’t fare as well as circular ones, of course.
    One really great feature of this step is that, if you see bubbles forming on the surface before it starts to boil, you know that there is a little void in there! Mark it with a pencil for later attention.
    5: Quench the piece in cold water. I don’t know why this works, but it really seems to enhance the rigidity and heat resistance.
    6: Touch up where there were voids with Plastic Weld. Check by submerging again.
    7: Wet sand smooth
    8: Make sure Plastic Weld has a day or more to fully dry before using it, ideally by keeping it somewhere warm and dry. I don’t want MEK in my body.
    What I’ve noticed so far is that coffee does not stain anywhere, while it was staining earlier in the process before I started getting as homogenous a surface as I’m getting now. That’s certainly not an indication that microbes CAN’T grow, but if there was staining then it definitely could because that would mean that coffee couldn’t get out of the voids.
    I would love your thoughts on this process!

    • @clockworkvanhellsing372
      @clockworkvanhellsing372 5 месяцев назад +1

      Iglidur i151 and i181 by igus are deliberatly designed to be used in the food industry and have a rating to be in permanent contact with drinking water. They may be an interesting option.

    • @joshuaa.c.newman7430
      @joshuaa.c.newman7430 5 месяцев назад

      @@clockworkvanhellsing372 Interesting!
      It doesn’t solve the microscopic layer fissures problem though.

    • @clockworkvanhellsing372
      @clockworkvanhellsing372 5 месяцев назад

      @@joshuaa.c.newman7430 yes, the micro fissure issue still stands, althought the material is mold resistand. It's probably as good as it's going to get.

    • @joshuaa.c.newman7430
      @joshuaa.c.newman7430 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@clockworkvanhellsing372 Mold resistant is certainly a step up!
      I’ll check it out!

  • @antalz
    @antalz 4 года назад +1

    Great video. A lot of what's in this video was already suspected, but it's great to see some real science to test these hypotheses.

  • @victorrangel3204
    @victorrangel3204 3 года назад +1

    Really appreciate you taking the time for this. Very well explained, w evidence!!!! Thank you

  • @trixiestterror
    @trixiestterror 3 года назад +3

    I'm so excited you're working on this!! I just did some looking and found a copper antibacterial filament called Copper3D which has been shown to decrease bacterial growth over time. If I order some for my application, I will definitely send you a cup to test. This work is so important, please keep going! ^_^

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад +3

      I already tested antibacterial filaments (copper3d too), one of my latest video

  • @thefoldp
    @thefoldp 4 года назад

    Nagyon jó ! Talán a PP-t szívesen láttam volna még az anyagok között, és információt az élelmiszerrel használt műanyagokról általában (gondolok itt például a mindenütt kapható műanyag merőkanálra, amit nyilván mindenki beleáztat a forró levesbe). Kíváncsian várom a szilikonos kísérleti eredményeket!

  • @DIYsCool
    @DIYsCool 4 года назад +1

    Great video. You covered a lot of variables that are all important to the outcome but can be inconvenient if we are looking for an easy answer.

  • @martintatak8851
    @martintatak8851 4 года назад

    I really appreciate scientific approach to this topic and your work. Thank you very much!

  • @MrLunox
    @MrLunox 4 года назад +2

    Very informative, i was always suspecting this but dont have the knowledge or equipment to test it, thank you for your work !

  • @colemirek
    @colemirek 4 года назад +2

    Thank you for making this and helping me with my issues. I wish I saw this sooner.

  • @r3v3rs3r
    @r3v3rs3r 4 года назад

    Very interesting! I work on food industry for almost 13 years now and I0m looking forward for 3d printing o penetrate this industry woth efectively food safe materials and solutions with minor need of post processing! Looking forward for more videos on research an solutions to fix this kind of problem!

  • @tonyharion9816
    @tonyharion9816 4 года назад +3

    Thank you so much for taking the time to do the research and for sharing this great info!

  • @ligius3
    @ligius3 4 года назад +5

    Annealing isn't actually such a bad option. I printed a small cup with 35% infill and placed it in the oven at 70C for ~1h. Then it could resist the dishwashing cycle several times with no noticeable issues. I'm still worried about the surface finish and the fact that water (from washing) might be trapped inside the comb structure inside, no way to check for that, except by weight perhaps.
    I bought food-grade epoxy to coat an identical cup and I got the mixture wrong, it never hardened properly, remaining slightly sticky. So that's another parameter to worry about.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +3

      Thanks for sharing your experience!

  • @epedja
    @epedja 4 года назад +1

    Very informative. Must see for anyone thinking in 3D printing stuff involved with food. Thanks!

  • @Reny.Rosales
    @Reny.Rosales 3 года назад +1

    Excellent video! Was looking for this guidance for a while!

  • @NicksStuff
    @NicksStuff 4 года назад +3

    Very interesting, keep us posted on follow-ups!

  • @P90Camper
    @P90Camper 4 года назад +2

    I am very much interested to see where this goes, particularly about the type of food grade epoxy resin. I have seen some brands in the US - artresign that is food certified but I have never used it. Thanks for doing this!

    • @georgesirmalenios8754
      @georgesirmalenios8754 3 года назад

      The problem is eventually the food grade epoxy would wear off. That's my concern with it.

  • @nekospaw
    @nekospaw 4 года назад +5

    This is a question frequently asked on the various groups I'm part of - thanks for such a comprehensive look at this! I do have to ask on the viability of SLA printed objects (however I have yet to dig into if food safe resin is avilabile so may be a moot question)

  • @privateprivate8366
    @privateprivate8366 Год назад +1

    I just hope, as was shown at the top of the video, that people aren’t taking “food grade” at face value. There are a lot of people who will do so, not see this video, not question it and think they’re off to making kitchen and pet food accessories, where they come into close and semi-permanent contact with food and it won’t turn out well.

  • @gedr7664
    @gedr7664 4 года назад +3

    Awesome video -- thank you very much for your hard work!

  • @Paddzr
    @Paddzr 4 года назад +10

    Nice video, I wonder how transforming Resin printed (photon/mars/epax) parts into food grade would work.

  • @travisantoniello
    @travisantoniello 3 года назад +2

    Great video on a very interesting topic I've always wondered about. Thank you!

  • @rafaelacerete4733
    @rafaelacerete4733 2 года назад +2

    Hi great video thank you so much!! quick question PLA + EPOXY food safe still safe ?

  • @TheSmokintbird
    @TheSmokintbird Год назад +1

    Fantastic work, Greatly appreciated!

  • @mariomeszaros1179
    @mariomeszaros1179 10 месяцев назад +1

    Szuper Videó! Köszönöm az infókat!

  • @Ungineers
    @Ungineers 4 года назад +1

    Great work, other thoughts I've had on food safe 3d printing, dipping prints in a thinned polyurethane varnish like 'wipe on poly' and it would be interesting to see how soaking a used part in a sterilising solution like hydrogen peroxide would affect the amount of bacterial growth.

  • @Marc42
    @Marc42 3 года назад +2

    Very useful, thank you very much Igor!

  • @shguevara
    @shguevara 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the thorough research!

  • @scottgoelzer3240
    @scottgoelzer3240 4 года назад +1

    I have had good luck flowing cyanoacrylate glue ( super glue) to smooth and strengthen parts. This glue is also used to closed wounds. Have you tested it as a food safe coating?

  • @kaizentechnic7962
    @kaizentechnic7962 4 года назад +1

    Normally listening to 2x I actually had to put this on normal speed to understand, great content! Following and subscribing

    • @tomsmith3045
      @tomsmith3045 4 года назад

      :) I agree. I don't think there was a single unimportant word in the entire presentation.

  • @Shazmataz
    @Shazmataz 2 года назад +1

    Köszönöm szépen!

  • @dekurvajo
    @dekurvajo 3 года назад +1

    Thank you Igor, it was a very big help to my research!

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад

      Glad to help. What kind of research, if not a secret?

  • @galvanizeddreamer2051
    @galvanizeddreamer2051 4 года назад

    Very good video, lots of very useful detail.
    I have a very specific question however: What of a TPU printed mouth guard, kept submerged in isopropyl alcohol when not in use? From a toxicity standpoint, I have heard that TPU is completely inert, albeit I have not looked into the additives. I am aware that TPU is Hygroscopic, but a combination of the drying effects of alcohol and the disposable nature of 3D printed objects makes it seem almost an acceptable flaw, if only due to being easily circumvented.
    Your point regarding silicone molding may also be valuable in this situation. Due to the low temperature resistance of PLA, a positive mold could be made of the teeth, which can then be transferred to a negative, and then transferred again into silicone.

  • @Withaoreo
    @Withaoreo 3 года назад +2

    Thank you so much for taking the time to research and share your information! There seems to be many websites trying provide guides on how to make 3D prints food safe, however their credibility is questionable.
    Do you think heat smoothing PETG would provide a food safe seal?
    I made a coffee bean funnel, would you consider something like this "low" or "high" risk? I have been sealing with 2 part epoxy (FDA approved) however I wonder if it is overkill.
    Thanks again!

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад +1

      I am not sure about heat smoothing PETG, I don't have those experiments. I only tried smoothing PolySmooth filament with isopropyl alcohol, it give better (but not perfect) results. ruclips.net/video/DcWiA-sqPnI/видео.html . Coffee bean funnel, if it is dry, not hi-temp, then I would say "low" risk. And if it is coated with epoxy, for me that's "no risk" (with FDA Epoxy as you mentioned)

  • @CubifyFan
    @CubifyFan 3 года назад

    I work for a special education facility that is seeking to train students on the autism spectrum for vocations in both the food industry and in the additive manufacturing industry. We would like to find ways to safely integrate these two programs. Your two videos are the most comprehensive look at the problems inherent is using 3D printed parts in a food environment. Thank you so much for that.
    Aside from the food safety issues, one of the issues that we are trying to fully understand regarding anti-microbial filaments is the relationship between time and efficacy. For instance, if we use an anti-microbial filament for a frequently touched surface, what might be 'safe' intervals between being touched by one student and then another? It seems that there are a LOT of unanswered questions that must be addressed if we are to develope 'best practices' using Cicla3D, Copper3D, XYZprinting or other anti-microbial filaments that come along. But, it is definitely worth pursuing.
    Thank you for moving us well along that path.

  • @hubertseidl93
    @hubertseidl93 4 года назад +8

    Great video. Thanks a lot.
    Regarding making 3D-prints food-safe: there are food-safe resins for resin-based 3d-printers (SLA). and there is a lesser known way to treat FDM-based prints with such a resin to smoothen in. in other words, the FDM-print gets sealed in the resin. Still, I wouldn't go for a long term usage.
    My own 3D-prints that I use with food are usually just clips for bags with an additional screw that allows to fill rice, beans etc from a bag into another container. I wouldn't let it get wet.
    By the way, there is always the option to let it soak in alcohol and desinfect itself with UV-light.

    • @OperationBaboon
      @OperationBaboon 4 года назад +1

      "there are food-safe resins for resin-based 3d-printers"
      can you name a few? or are you just referring to dental grade materials?

    • @LT72884
      @LT72884 4 года назад +2

      Exactly. As an engineer in materials,medical and areospace myself, one thi g that is never ever mentioned in any videos about if 3d printed parts are food safe.... the mere fact that if they are sterilized with an agent that has LOW surface tension such as rubbing alcohol. Ipa surface tension is about 21 dynes/cm vs water at about 73 dynes/cm. The low surface tension of rubbing alcohol allows it to get into the dimples, cracks, etc and sanitize it. In fact, ipa can get into spaces smaller than viruses, this ia why it is used in facilities that manufacture filter that filter out viruses from the blood. This ia why bleach water has a hard time with 3d printed parts. Its surface tension is the same as water. However, hot soapy water has about 25 to 30 dynes/cm as well. The soap helps break up that tension.

    • @travisantoniello
      @travisantoniello 3 года назад +2

      @@LT72884 That's so interesting - total layman here and never would have considered the surface tension of fluids limiting their abilities like that. Thanks for the insight!

  • @GabryDX
    @GabryDX 4 года назад

    Thank you very much for your work. I'm really curious to see the results of the use of food safe varnish and polyurethane spray. Hope to find the next video soon :)

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      Next video in this topics will be testing antibacterial filaments (3 types). Everything is prepared, but currently we are not allowed to go into laboratories, university buildings are closed, because of this current covid situation.

  • @emmanuelroy1608
    @emmanuelroy1608 3 года назад +1

    Very professional , thank you !

  • @CodesmithSoftware
    @CodesmithSoftware 4 года назад

    Excellent video and well explained, I'd like to see how the antibacterial filament works out when you get around to that

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад

      I bought 3 type of antibacterial filaments. Test probes are already in labs, only I am waiting for results (labs were closed due covid19 situation)

  • @yoanfilipov3747
    @yoanfilipov3747 4 года назад +1

    Brilliant content! Thanks

  • @ukaszsokalla182
    @ukaszsokalla182 4 года назад +2

    Hi, thanks a lot for posting this video. Very helpful. Great approach, I wish you had more views.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад

      Thanks. I wish that too, but RUclips has weird algorithms nowadays.

  • @wrenbird8352
    @wrenbird8352 4 года назад

    have you looked into high temp 3d printing like that of "vision miner" ? it may defeat the monetary argument for 3d printing but would be interesting to see if it could work. also it could open up the use of a steam sanitiser like that in the restaurant industry due to its heat resistance.

  • @AdnanASyukri
    @AdnanASyukri 2 года назад +1

    Amazing! Thank you for such rich information!

  • @tonydeser839
    @tonydeser839 8 месяцев назад

    Brilliant! Thanks a lot for sharing your evaluations)
    Im thinking about making chocolate molds of silicon by using 3d model as a shape!

  • @laszloszigeti5150
    @laszloszigeti5150 2 года назад +1

    Üdv Igor. Szuper lett a videó :) Profi magyarázat

  • @Eigengrau608
    @Eigengrau608 4 года назад

    Thanks for this cool study!

  • @haydenbird8306
    @haydenbird8306 4 года назад +1

    Excellent ! Thank you

  • @tomsmith3045
    @tomsmith3045 4 года назад

    This is fantastic. The most thorough explanation and research of food grade 3d that I've seen. I didn't expect to have the plastic add-on components and metal contamination covered. One thought, though, along the lines of resistance to bacterial growth. While the test done on water rinse was scientifically accurate and suitable for mass produced parts, I don't know that it is representative of a home user who will rinse the objects with soap and water and dry. I also don't know how much the texture of a 3D printed part compares to other non-plastic textured materials, such as brushed stainless steel or wood. Commercial kitchens don't use those surfaces much, but home users do, and they are generally considered safe. You absolutely proved, though, that the texture and potentially voids of 3d printing ARE an issue. This is great info.
    Personally, I would be hesitant to use epoxy coated parts because I know that epoxy will gradually wear off and enter the food, and to me the risk of additional toxic chemical contamination (cancer risk) is higher than bacterial compromise. I know the plastic itself will do that, but it's one more layer of chemical that I don't perceive a need for. I also would be hesitant to use bio-resistant filaments, because I don't want to ingest the ions. I don't know how the rate of exposure would work, because the ions are very likely to leach out at greatly different rates depending on use - ice cube tray with water, compared to hot tea (acidic). But all in all, this is fantastic information. Thank you!!

    • @LT72884
      @LT72884 4 года назад

      As an engineer in materials,medical and areospace myself, one thi g that is never ever mentioned in any videos about if 3d printed parts are food safe.... the mere fact that if they are sterilized with an agent that has LOW surface tension such as rubbing alcohol. Ipa surface tension is about 21 dynes/cm vs water at about 73 dynes/cm. The low surface tension of rubbing alcohol allows it to get into the dimples, cracks, etc and sanitize it. In fact, ipa can get into spaces smaller than viruses, this ia why it is used in facilities that manufacture filter that filter out viruses from the blood. This ia why bleach water has a hard time with 3d printed parts. Its surface tension is the same as water. However, hot soapy water has about 25 to 30 dynes/cm as well. The soap helps break up that tension.

    • @yodasuki
      @yodasuki 2 года назад +1

      @@LT72884 this video doesn't state if they used soap, also like you said alcohol can get in small places, would like to know if they could run the tests again with cleaning it with this, also note the temps of the liquid used. as even a small bit of heat i am sure can kill some viruses.

    • @LT72884
      @LT72884 2 года назад

      @@yodasuki luckily, my internship for my medical and aerospace degree, i repeated this experiment. I cultured 10 very dangerous pathogens, and soapy water cleans just fine, and so does alcohol. Right now im redoing the entire project to test other ideas haha

  • @tejonBiker
    @tejonBiker 4 года назад +1

    This info is gold, thanks for sharing

  • @holgerholgerholger
    @holgerholgerholger 3 года назад +1

    Great video! What about using PP (polypropylene) ? There are food-safe PP filaments and you can just put it in a dishwasher (after each use). Shouldn't that be one of the best options?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад

      PP is used commonly in injection molding, but it is hard for 3D printing, won't stick to bed.

  • @ale6242
    @ale6242 4 года назад +3

    So just curious by "under the tap" do you mean washed with soap? or just water? if soap was used was it anti-bacterial? Love some proper science!!
    Look forward to more vids!

    • @ddegn
      @ddegn 4 года назад

      I'm not sure if normal "food safe" materials would be bacteria free if they weren't washed with soap. I'd like to see some controls in these tests.
      It's great to see these sorts of technical videos about 3D printing.
      Thank you *My Tech Fun.*

    • @Spartacusse
      @Spartacusse 4 года назад

      Even if they weren't, and that was added, there would still be bacterial growth, because water can not penetrate the smallest of the nooks and crannies due to it's viscosity.

    • @yodasuki
      @yodasuki 2 года назад

      @@Spartacusse and thats why you add soap.. from the way he talked about it they just used water. also you can use water and alcohol and then clean with soap.. make sure its warm.. I;d like to know if that would help

  • @android01978
    @android01978 4 года назад

    Fantastic video. How safe are food safe epoxies? I would worry if you don’t get the proportions 100% then you will still end up with volatile compounds. I also wonder about resin prints. If they can make food safe epoxy, surely they can make food safe resins?

  • @LootSaga
    @LootSaga 4 года назад +1

    Great video and impressive slides!

  • @JasonLooseArrowAlso
    @JasonLooseArrowAlso 4 года назад +1

    Thank you!

  • @75keg75
    @75keg75 Год назад

    Generally food safe is good for aquariums. Curious if the materials would be good for aquarium use even with bacteria propagation as often you want bacteria growth to process fish waste.. I understand petg is quite good. I also know some additives aren’t great as they could leach. Having said that I did a custom diy background with cement. This tank was made and cured for about 2months and flushed repeatedly. I have had no fish die from that.
    So thoughts on materials for fish tank usage?
    Thoughts?

  • @mohandbir1783
    @mohandbir1783 Год назад +1

    thank you for this great work !
    I have a question, in this particular experience you checked the small cups.
    what if the food we put inside these cups is cooked in the oven, is it safe to eat ?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  Год назад +1

      Depend, but something like Cookie cutters, yes, it should be OK. But try to clean the cutters as much as possible.

    • @mohandbir1783
      @mohandbir1783 Год назад

      Thank you for your answer!

  • @MondoMurderface
    @MondoMurderface 3 года назад +1

    Very informative, thanks.

  • @karmakh
    @karmakh 4 года назад +1

    Excellent info!

  • @liamedge9527
    @liamedge9527 9 месяцев назад +1

    Fantastic Help!

  • @hunelektroBF
    @hunelektroBF 4 года назад +1

    I am happy to see the collaboration with Novi Sad. Sanding could also help to get a smoother surface. Great explanation :) Greetings from Serbia!

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      I work a lot with University in Novi Sad. Sanding, you mean sandpaper? (peskarenje ili šmirglanje)? Pozdrav iz Budimpešte.

  • @dinosoarskill17
    @dinosoarskill17 4 года назад +1

    I am loving your video topics

  • @jensemilhansen1602
    @jensemilhansen1602 4 года назад +1

    Very interesting. Keep on the good work

  • @JohnAldred
    @JohnAldred 4 года назад +3

    Very interesting. As you're doing some legitimate studies into the food safe properties of different filaments, I'd contact the manufacturers of the more exotic filaments to request samples for testing. I'm sure many of them would be happy to oblige, especially if they believe their products to be safe for this kind of use or simply want confirmation one way or the other.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +2

      I contacted two companies so far, but they are not interested, I am "nobody" with less than 200 subs. I added my workplace address in description if anybody wants to send me few meters of antibacterial filaments. Cups needs approximately 1m filament, but I would like to print 3pcs for better statistics.

    • @JohnAldred
      @JohnAldred 4 года назад

      That's a shame. Well, count one more towards your subs. :)

    • @maximilian.arnold
      @maximilian.arnold 4 года назад

      @@MyTechFun Another sub for you. Great video and thanks for making it.

    • @3dprintingscience528
      @3dprintingscience528 4 года назад +2

      @@MyTechFun Hi Igor, Im from Polymaker and although subs number could be a criteria of selection for specific marketing partnership, we are also very interested in project which could benefit the 3d printing community and bring the industry forward, Im very happy to collaborate and help you in your testing. I just emailed you and hope to be able to start a collaboration together.

  • @danielbrillantes2791
    @danielbrillantes2791 4 месяца назад

    Thank you, this video is very helpful!

  • @benjaminlush8570
    @benjaminlush8570 4 года назад +1

    Thank you!!!

  • @ThePepenoso
    @ThePepenoso 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for the info

  • @Skyliner_369
    @Skyliner_369 4 года назад +1

    did you try acetone vapor smoothing some prints? should get the surface completely smooth.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад

      That works with ABS only, but ABS cannot be used with food

    • @Skyliner_369
      @Skyliner_369 4 года назад

      @@MyTechFun d'oh! right!

  • @Firas95k
    @Firas95k 4 года назад +1

    Great work! Continue please

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      I will have few more tests in this topics, only I have to wait our labs to open again (after covid 19 break). I am waiting results from testing antibacterial filaments and also testing silicone molds created from 3D printed casts.

  • @animes25
    @animes25 4 года назад +2

    3d print model and using thermoforming to make the mold, I think it can work as food safe

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +3

      Yes, where possible. I am just working on similar project. I will post my results in 1-2 months.

  • @goury
    @goury 4 года назад +3

    Don't underestimate how long trace amounts of some poisonous thermoplastic can reside inside the melting zone.
    You should just replace the throat and the nozzle.
    Also smoothing does nothing to pores.
    It still remains porous.
    So just coat it.

    • @geeklany
      @geeklany 4 года назад

      You can put it in a pressure pot, to fill the porus with epoxy... Can't you?

    • @goury
      @goury 4 года назад

      @@geeklany why not just coat it with epoxy?
      Also you can't

    • @geeklany
      @geeklany 4 года назад +1

      @@goury what can't I? If you put it in a pressure pot, the epoxy is going to fill the pores. It's a known way to stabilize porous Wood for example. You can also stabilize bread with it, and turn it. Peter Brown did a video about it, it's fun (should not be eaten... It's a gag 🤗)

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      Pores on surface will be covered by epoxy. That's enough for food safe. If you want to cover pores deeper, add some acetone to epoxy (see xtc-3d epoxy tutorial). With this you can improve strength.

  • @KLP99
    @KLP99 3 года назад +1

    I've heard some 3d artisans use acetone to smooth their finished products? Would that seal the gaps and prevent bacteria from moving in and setting up shop?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад

      With Acetone you can smooth ABS or ASA, but they can't get FDA certificate, not even in nature version.

  • @alfs3
    @alfs3 3 года назад +1

    Thank you very much for doing this experiment as we have some food/water bowls to print and they must be food safe - great video!

  • @darek6820
    @darek6820 4 года назад +1

    very nice, ty fot your work!

  • @TheAdeptGuitarist
    @TheAdeptGuitarist 3 года назад

    Nylon 6/6 coated in epoxy and polycarbonate. Both require a much higher printing temperature and are less forgiving to print. UHMWPE possibly?

  • @nicklasnilsson5791
    @nicklasnilsson5791 Год назад

    Nice video,
    But what about food safety from a migration standpoint? Would be material be able to comply with EC No 10/2011?

  • @IBICO74
    @IBICO74 Год назад +1

    You also get FDA approved ABS filament.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  Год назад

      Hm. ABS as base material cannot be used in food safety applications. That must be some very modified material. Link or brand please?

  • @samswift1718
    @samswift1718 4 года назад

    Thankyou for the fantastic video, how about 3d printing a mould and casting silicone ? I think silicone can be washed at high temps?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      That's exactly what I am working on now. Earlier on our department we created some silicone casts for chocolate (only not from 3d printed objects). But it is important to use silicone with food safe certificate. There are a lot of different types.

    • @samswift1718
      @samswift1718 4 года назад

      @@MyTechFun oh thats brilliant yes thankyou for doing all of this work I look forward to seeing your future videos, its people like you that make the internet such a nice place! :D

    • @kseniafedosova9169
      @kseniafedosova9169 2 года назад

      @@MyTechFun will there be a problem with a silicone? e.g., can the silicone have traces of lead?

  • @nowinowi9232
    @nowinowi9232 4 года назад +1

    Very interesting information.

  • @Unnaymed
    @Unnaymed Год назад

    copper/brass is antibacterian, why we can't use it for food? very reactive with acid?

  • @Rouverius
    @Rouverius 4 года назад

    Thanks.
    Oh, what about SLA printer?

  • @AlexDubois
    @AlexDubois 3 года назад +1

    It might be possible to find a biodegradable filament which is food safe, which would limit the impact of 3D printing surface. Certainly not for the same use cases, but could be an easier path to start with?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад

      Few weeks ago I tested antibacterial filaments too. Interesting results (and most of them have FDM certificate)

  • @oleost
    @oleost 4 года назад +1

    You should have a look at Colorfabb HT. As far as I know they are FDA approved, and it can withstand temperatures up to 100celcius. So it can easily be washed in machine. This is what I have used, and always was my things in washing machine at high temperature.

    • @oleost
      @oleost 4 года назад

      ht.colorfabb.com/what/ colorfabb.com/ht-clear

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад

      @@oleost In near future I will testing cleaning methods like: hi-temp in washing machine (with similar filaments you mentioned), sterilization in micro wave (we do this at home for our baby bottle, plate..) , ultrasonic cleaning, using antibacterial soap before using the 3D printed object (in this video there is a time interval between cleaning under the tap and antibacterial testing, because this is simulation of using in kitchen.

  • @adanhu
    @adanhu Год назад +1

    Nickel coated copper nozzles should in theory be another food-safe option

  • @avejst
    @avejst 4 года назад +1

    Great Video
    Good test
    Thanks for sharing:-)

  • @brezovprut4431
    @brezovprut4431 4 года назад +1

    Please, is this research viable during this COVID situation for printing antibacterial respirator valves?
    Are these only reasons bellow why SLS PA12 valve is confirmed safe for medicine use unlike FDM ones:
    1. Superior SLS printed surface unlike FDM layerlines (prone to virus/bacteria growth)?
    2. PA12 more advanced thermal and chemical properties (offer successful sterilization and disinfection)?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад +1

      In this research we were testing only effect of bacteria (and yeast). The virus reportedly survives for over 48 hours on the plastics (or even 90 hours, according to some other studies). Yes, both reasons, SLA surface is smooth and can be thermal sterilizated. One of possible solution (instead sterilisation) is using the antibacterial filaments (which tests are in progress currently, but again only for bacteria and yeast). Coating with Epoxy can raise the thermal properties (Epoxy term.res. is up to 150°C, but layer of exoxy is thin), I don't have exact numbers, I think still not for sterilization. Anealing of plastic can raise this thermal resistance, but problem is that object deformates significantly (with valves you need precision). One of the solutions we are also working on is sterilisation with ultra sound. First experiments shows promissing results, but this research is still in progress (it is hard to progress, education is moved online here in Hungary, aproach to our laboratories is limited). Regards, Igor

    • @brezovprut4431
      @brezovprut4431 4 года назад

      @@MyTechFun Btw, i am speaking of (powder based SLS, not resin based SLA). Italian company printed SLS parts only because of freedom of geometry that technology offers unlike FDM and SLA. And wasn't sure if its printed only because of geometry and PA12 material? Because i am trying to get successfull results with more affordable technologies available on everyones desktop (FDM and resin SLA).
      Again thanks a lot for deep answer, your previous and future effort !!!!

  • @isabellaelisa2496
    @isabellaelisa2496 4 года назад

    what you can tell about PSU filaments material? I heard that's truly food-safe, but I don't know if its still safe in an common 3d printer

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  4 года назад

      PSU filament needs very high printing temperatures (360°C), full metal extruder, 150°C bed.. Bacteria would grow up in these pores too after some time, but big advance is that it is very temperature resistant, it can be washed on high temperatures or sterilized in microwave like I described here for few seconds: ruclips.net/video/fFOc6d4Ry9M/видео.html

  • @peterbizios1385
    @peterbizios1385 Год назад +1

    Are certain beds considered not food safe? I currently have a PEI on my Ender 3 S1 Pro. Thank you

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  Год назад +1

      PEI is teflon coating. You probably have a teflon coated baking dish too in kitchen.

  • @HighlandViolinist
    @HighlandViolinist Год назад +1

    Very good info! I've seen many arguments online for whether you can print things for food, so it's great to have evidence on what is and not foodsafe.

  • @jeremiahembs5343
    @jeremiahembs5343 3 года назад +1

    I would think that as long as you are printing in layers it would hide bacteria between those layers. Coating final product with food grade silicone would help. Or using the printer to create a mold instead of the final product would be the preferred method. 3d printing is basically for prototypes, not for final products if the final product needs a smooth finish. Resin printing produces a much smoother surface, but smells very bad and is toxic to print with most resins, but some resins are used in the dental industry and so might be food safe or from them vacuum molding can be done. Matter Hackers HM resin seems to be the best I've used so far in terms of toxicity and smell, but is a more difficult to get to stick to the build plate, but it would be worth looking into if you investigate resin printing as a food safe method.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад +1

      I agree with your suggestion. Also, currently I am testing a PLA like filament which can withstand 110°C without annealing and it also has food safe certificate. So, it can be boiled in water for cleaning. Video will be published in few weeks after bacterial tests..

    • @jeremiahembs5343
      @jeremiahembs5343 2 года назад

      @@MyTechFun Oh that's a good idea. Boiling could really help sterilize.

  • @kay6736
    @kay6736 5 месяцев назад

    Have you retried Polysmooth using a nebulizer instead of a brush since this video? Was hoping Polysmooth would work, but disappointed to see it failing here.

  • @ninajmisfit13
    @ninajmisfit13 3 года назад

    Can I use ABS FOR CHOCOLATE? I won’t be putting it in harsh heating elements. Just pouring for the mold shape.

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  3 года назад

      ABS is not recommended to have direct contact with food.

  • @ImTimT.
    @ImTimT. Год назад +1

    Were the cups washed with soap or just rinsed as the video shows?

    • @MyTechFun
      @MyTechFun  Год назад

      In this test just under the tap. There is another similar test, using a dish soap too

  • @guillep2k
    @guillep2k 4 года назад +1

    Some objects can be "food safe" if they are meant to be used only once.