TXT has stable voices. And when they sing live you can really hear how powerful and beautiful their voices are. For Opening Sequence, I especially like Yeonjun and Taehyun's voices. The song is perfect for their voices.
@@pumpis2121 Kpop idols make a comeback and play MCR for about a week in the stage. So if you want to listen to txt's live, you should make a comeback and listen to MR removal on the a little later stage. :) The sentence is incomplete using a translator. 🥺🥺
I'm a MOA and these boys are extremely talented !! but i feel like these are pre-recorded !! because their voices are too stable while they are dancing so powerfully , the voices are usually a bit shaky when dancing and singing takes place togther , but that doesn't matter we all know they are really good vocalists !! 💙
Yes most of the time the comebacks are pre-recorded but I’m super excited for more performances of Opening Sequence so we can hear the boys vocals live 🥰
I think this is not pre-recorded because of the parts when they stop singing for example, in the "I'm bleeding painfully, painfully, painfully" part, Taehyun just says "fully". And in the last part he didn't sing anything. But I'm not sure
tbh in the official video i can hear when theyre singing or not at some part and yes this video is bs cause its not a mr removed but i know that they sang it live cause you can hear them in the official video as i said lmaooo. And i think that most of them didnt really sing their part but taehyun did most of his part even ad libs when u focus on his voice you can hear it
This is a song that it's actually harder to sing than GBGB take note they are also dancing that's why I really appreciate their vocals here. They really did a great job singing this! kudos to TXT. I mean I tried singing this song from the start until the first chorus and I was sitting but still it's hard. You really need a strong abdominal power for this because you'll lose your breath by singing this. That's why they left me in awe because they are so Talented!!!!! Salute 🙌🙇♀
I'm sorry, but in this stage I think this is pre-recorded vocals. No sound of breathing, no cracks, no gasps. That's why I don't trust in Mr. Removed completely.
I think this is live. In so many parts you can hear them breathing and also in some parts (for like 1 second) they don’t sing and you can clearly hear the difference in their voices. At 02:25 Taehyun doesn’t sings and it’s obvious. Sorry for my English I hope you can understand what I mean.
@@laarinsea Pre-recorded vocals mean you record the voices raw separately, so that makes the illusion of live vocals. They play them over the backtrack. In this case, I still think they're pre-recorded, even more so after watching the fancams.
It is live but with backtrack, you can even hear soobin's breathing and taehyun's voice slightly clashing with the backup vocals, and the parts where it goes silent is when they didn't sing
@@zieezie6234 it isn't live. No voice cracks n dancing like this while hitting those notes.... not possible. Those are prerecorded vocals. They are still amazing though
악의 없구 진짜 궁금해서 여쭤보는건데 라이브 아닌가요?? 이 영상 원본 봐도 태현이 목소리 2개로 들려서 라이브 인줄 알았는데 첫주에도 애들 트펀베 할 때 태현이 잠깐 삑사리도 났었고 숨소리 다 들리는데 라이브 아닌가용 더구나 태현이 독무 때는 잠깐 안 불러서 아무 소리 안 들리는데
Mr removed is typically to remove the pre-recorded backing vocals. The pre-recorded track is typically just used as support. Some groups use tracks with much louder recorded vocals usually because heavy dancing makes it very hard to be stable. But when it comes to txt, they don't need a lot of support. They are incredibly stable despite intense choreography. They are rock stars.
컴백하고 일주일 정도는 엠알틀어두고 무대합니다 그래서 이거는 울애들 라이브 아닙니다ㅜㅠ カムバックして一週間くらいはmrで舞台します。だからこれはtxtのライブではありませんᅮ ᅲ Usually the kpop idol makes a comeback and turn on the MR for about a week in the stage. So this is not txt's live.🥹
Kpop idols make a comeback and play MCR for about a week in the stage. So if you want to listen to txt's live, you should make a comeback and listen to MR removal on the a little later stage. :) The sentence is incomplete using a translator. 🥺🥺
![[MR Removed | 엠알 제거] TXT (투모로우바이투게더) - Good Boy Gone Bad (굿 보이 곤 배드) MR제거 220512](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EyaKFdiSTvU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed | 엠알 제거] TXT (투모로우바이투게더) - Good Boy Gone Bad (굿 보이 곤 배드) MR제거 220512](/img/tr.png)
![[MR Removed] TXT - NO RULES MR제거 20210604 (Live Vocals)](/img/1.gif)
TXT has stable voices. And when they sing live you can really hear how powerful and beautiful their voices are. For Opening Sequence, I especially like Yeonjun and Taehyun's voices. The song is perfect for their voices.
TXT’S VOCALS ARE MORE STABLE THAN MY MENTAL HEALTH
SAME
Nunca tan same
NO BUT FR THEYRE SO STABLE
WHAT THE HECK?! I GOT GOOSEBUMS WHEN TAEHYUN STARTED THE SONG! THEIR VOCALS OH MY GOSH
soobin first part and beomgyu 'why you laugh' part really need one breath to sing and they did it 😍🔥
They are so stable even when dancing;))))
Usually the kpop idol makes a comeback and turn on the MR for about a week in the stage. So this is not txt's live.
@@나는꼭하늘을날고말거 What??
@@pumpis2121 Kpop idols make a comeback and play MCR for about a week in the stage.
So if you want to listen to txt's live, you should make a comeback and listen to MR removal on the a little later stage. :) The sentence is incomplete using a translator. 🥺🥺
Bro this is pre recorded but their stable 🔥🔥🔥🔥
This song definitely the best intro for their comeback. Literally feels like having heartbreak when listening to this
와 격한 안무에 이 퀄리티가 가능한거야 ..? 최고다 투바투 ㅠㅠ❤️❤️
진짜 많이 늘었다...
엠알있는거 들어도 마이크 소리 잘들림
TXT , the future of kpop.
Okey but Soobin's smooth vocals??!! His voice sounds so good hear!! All of them!! My fav song
TXT literally doesn't need MR . I cannot find any part not satisfying without MR . Their voices are literally like honey 🍯
AMAZING STABLE VOCALS.
I'm so proud to be a MOA
Good job TXT 🥰
진짜 미치겠다... 너무 잘해ㅠㅡㅠ
They are so good voices
걍 음원이야 너무잘해 ㅜㅜㅜ
I'm a MOA and these boys are extremely talented !! but i feel like these are pre-recorded !! because their voices are too stable while they are dancing so powerfully , the voices are usually a bit shaky when dancing and singing takes place togther , but that doesn't matter we all know they are really good vocalists !! 💙
Yes most of the time the comebacks are pre-recorded but I’m super excited for more performances of Opening Sequence so we can hear the boys vocals live 🥰
I feel the same. This is pre-recorded vocals.
It was a cb show it's not fully live and has high bg 😂
I think this is not pre-recorded because of the parts when they stop singing for example, in the "I'm bleeding painfully, painfully, painfully" part, Taehyun just says "fully". And in the last part he didn't sing anything. But I'm not sure
tbh in the official video i can hear when theyre singing or not at some part and yes this video is bs cause its not a mr removed but i know that they sang it live cause you can hear them in the official video as i said lmaooo. And i think that most of them didnt really sing their part but taehyun did most of his part even ad libs when u focus on his voice you can hear it
they're so stable and experiencing this live was ethereal and levitating like the vocals the choreo the expressions everything was on point
OPENING SEQUENCE DESERVE TO GET STUDIO CHOOM PERFORMANCE + MV❤🔥
They are so freaking talented I got goosebumps
i think this is pre recorded.
This is a song that it's actually harder to sing than GBGB take note they are also dancing that's why I really appreciate their vocals here. They really did a great job singing this! kudos to TXT. I mean I tried singing this song from the start until the first chorus and I was sitting but still it's hard. You really need a strong abdominal power for this because you'll lose your breath by singing this. That's why they left me in awe because they are so Talented!!!!! Salute 🙌🙇♀
i zoned out and forgot i was listening to an mr removed video because they were singing everything lol
i need taehyun's voice injected in my blood
THE REASON WHY I LOVE THIS PERFORMANCE SO MUCH
I wish they got more live content...I don't know how to explain it, I want to hear their voices without the help of the song :(
moa go and stream txt new song GOOD BOY GONE BAD please😔
even in the actual vid perf, their vocals are so clear and stable ugh txt settingme standards so high with kpop groups
Ini stabil bgt
Kerren
0:54 kai 😍
I feel like we are going to keep having unrealistic standards for pop singers the more we keep believing pre recorded vocals are live.
Yaaas!👏👏👏
와..
갓벽바이투게더가 괜히 나온게 아니라고요..
Godbyeok By Together didn’t come out for nothing..
my new addiction
OMG THEIRRR VOCALL?!!! 🤯🤯❤
jesus christ they sound amazing????
I'm sorry, but in this stage I think this is pre-recorded vocals. No sound of breathing, no cracks, no gasps. That's why I don't trust in Mr. Removed completely.
Usually the kpop idol makes a comeback and turn on the MR for about a week in the stage. So this is not txt's live.
@@나는꼭하늘을날고말거 I know that but I find unnecesary to upload this as "Mr Removed". People confuse this as live singing.
I think this is live. In so many parts you can hear them breathing and also in some parts (for like 1 second) they don’t sing and you can clearly hear the difference in their voices. At 02:25 Taehyun doesn’t sings and it’s obvious.
Sorry for my English I hope you can understand what I mean.
@@laarinsea Pre-recorded vocals mean you record the voices raw separately, so that makes the illusion of live vocals. They play them over the backtrack. In this case, I still think they're pre-recorded, even more so after watching the fancams.
✨✨✨✨
Taehyuuun!!!!!
Their vocals while singing live really doesn't need MR at all
Woooowwwwwww......😘😘😘😘😘😘
..........?? 이게 진짜 mr제거라고...? 아니 걍 음원인데..?????
네 진짜 음원이에요,, 라이브 아닙니다ㅜㅜ
@@이지아-v9o 음원 아니고 ar이에요
@@김다은-p7k ar이긴 한데 진짜 라이브 할때랑 소리가 아예 달라서 라이브 하는건 맞아요!
@@김다은-p7k 라이브에요. 이지아님은 댓글마다 음원 및 ar이라고 하시네. 2:30초쯤 참고하세요
개쩐다
0:30 shit !!! Yeonjun 🔥🔥
TXT eating CD... FAX
네~원본 잘 들었고 이제 MR 제거음 들려주세요
Gilsss
우리 툽깅이들 cd 그만 먹ㅇㅓ..
معنى مثالية حتى مايحتاجون موسيقى
강태현 사람이냐
no doubt they’re amazing but this isn’t live 😭
It is live but with backtrack, you can even hear soobin's breathing and taehyun's voice slightly clashing with the backup vocals, and the parts where it goes silent is when they didn't sing
@@zieezie6234 it isn't live. No voice cracks n dancing like this while hitting those notes.... not possible. Those are prerecorded vocals. They are still amazing though
@@samehere310 i thought so, but their gbgb performance was amazing. I think they're focus more on that one to sing live rather than this one
혹시 투바투 몸속에 음원이 사는 건..
Is it possible that the sound source lives inside Tubatoo's body?
그래서 mr제거는 어디에 나오는거죠?
우리 얘들이 잘하는건 알고 있는데 이건 라이브 아닙니다ㅜㅜ
어? 그럼 뭐예요?
@@bbeomgyu0313 ar입니다, 원래 대부분 첫주는 라이브 잘 안해요ㅜ
@@이지아-v9o 아 그렇군요ㅠㅠ
악의 없구 진짜 궁금해서 여쭤보는건데 라이브 아닌가요?? 이 영상 원본 봐도 태현이 목소리 2개로 들려서 라이브 인줄 알았는데 첫주에도 애들 트펀베 할 때 태현이 잠깐 삑사리도 났었고 숨소리 다 들리는데 라이브 아닌가용 더구나 태현이 독무 때는 잠깐 안 불러서 아무 소리 안 들리는데
@@배서연-t7s 배서연님 말씀처럼 ar이 있긴한데 진짜 라이브 할때랑 소리가 아예 다르잖아요? (2:25참고) 라이브 하는거 맞아요!
음원이랑 개 똑같네...
It's the same as the soundtrack...
En serio son sus voces en vivo?
Si
no...
It's really necessary mr removed on a pre-recorded song?
it's pre-recorded but they are singing live. You can hear the part where they didn't sing the line especially taehyun's solo
i mean the mic is on so ig that's why they made this
Well pre-recorded doesn't mean that they didn't sing it live.. it just mean that they didn't sing it at the time the program was live
Mr removed is typically to remove the pre-recorded backing vocals. The pre-recorded track is typically just used as support. Some groups use tracks with much louder recorded vocals usually because heavy dancing makes it very hard to be stable. But when it comes to txt, they don't need a lot of support. They are incredibly stable despite intense choreography. They are rock stars.
Yes, Mr. Removed is not proof of live singing. This is clearly pre-recorded. But not everyone can tell the difference.
컴백하고 일주일 정도는 엠알틀어두고 무대합니다 그래서 이거는 울애들 라이브 아닙니다ㅜㅠ
カムバックして一週間くらいはmrで舞台します。だからこれはtxtのライブではありませんᅮ
ᅲ
Usually the kpop idol makes a comeback and turn on the MR for about a week in the stage. So this is not txt's live.🥹
Kpop idols make a comeback and play MCR for about a week in the stage.
So if you want to listen to txt's live, you should make a comeback and listen to MR removal on the a little later stage. :) The sentence is incomplete using a translator. 🥺🥺
님아 라이브에요.. 국제적 망신을 시키다니, 2:30초 참고하세요
@@내일도함께해와 진짜 ar 깐줄알았는데..
there's no background music yet .. it sounds like the original song lol their voices are so melodious