@@soobinspandulce I do not know if you can call it an improvement. TXT has always been stable. The difference is that they do not have to sing every single word from the chorus so they have time to catch their breath and their choreography is not shaking as it was in the case of 0x1 lovesong or LOSER LOVER. When your whole body shakes, it's even harder to be stable. Unfortunately, because of this, many people looked at them as if they were worse than other groups, not looking at the fact that they had a high key in the chorus and almost a high note
다들 춤추면서 라이브하는 안정도가 많이 올라갔고 제 눈에 특히 눈에 띄는 게 범규가 춤 노래 많이 늘었고 태현이도 춤 노래 늘었지만 노래에서 기교가 더 늘었는 것 같다고 느꼈어요... 다들 열심히 노력했구나ㅜㅜ 우리 투바투애깅이들 수고했고 앞으로도 연습, 무대 등등 열심히 하자!! 그리고!!! 건강하고!!!! (내맘속 투바투=연약하고 지켜주고 싶음)
It's not like they were bad before this comeback and improved they were actually amazing last comeback but somehow they were able to improve this time even more to the level where what was jaw dropping last cb seems like it's nothing compared to this.. It's crazy how all 5 of them are insanely stable and confident to sing every part despite the hard choreo!!! I was reminded once again how lucky I am to be a fan of them
i mean damn. no bias, this is the best mr removed I've ever heard. this is txt beating the "pre recorded" allegations lol love how they all sang live all throughout the song
Damn this is better than the studio version! Nothing beats Tyunning's stable vocals they really are the reliable maknaes. Huening Kai's clear vocals on that bridge and addictive verse is everything. Taehyun's whispers and adlibs are insane. I love Yeonjun's powerful rap and vocals on the chorus and I'm so proud of Beomgyu and Soobin this era, Beomgyu's low register and Soobin's falsetto are just amazing! The choreography looks so tiring but all 5 of them did incredible! This is the best MR removed video I watched honestly and I'm always nitpicky with vocals.
어떻게 음원이랑 똑같아...? 연습 많이 한거 보이구 ㅠㅜ 너네는 그냥 최고다... 이렇게 빠른 노래에 라이브 하면서 춤까지 완벽한 그룹 너희밖에 없어 ㅠㅜ + 최연준 랩도 엄청 빠르고 가만히 앉아서 불러도 못 따라가겠던데 완벽하게 불러버리네,, 그냥 짱먹어라 4세대 리더
Their vocals improved so much!! Taehyun, Yeonjun, and Hyuka were always stable since then but Beomgyu and Soobin improved so much in this era. They were not shaky, unlike the other comeback which amazed me even more. Good job Beomgyu and Soobin you did great!
txt is so stable as expected! but, i am really happy that beomgyu is so much better now. he's so stable compared to the past comeback. and of course, taehyun is soooo damn stable
Even with a hard choreography they are stable; they are unbelievable talented!!!! Yeonjun sings the chorus highly while dancing!!! Even her raps his lines amazingly
I stan them but this even surprised me. I'm so fucking proud to be a MOA. They sang it live as if the choreography wasn't hard. THE ONE AND ONLY TOMORROW X TOGETHER
![[MR Removed] TXT - NO RULES MR제거 20210604 (Live Vocals)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4hmDhFf1a2E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed] TXT - NO RULES MR제거 20210604 (Live Vocals)](/img/tr.png)
![[T:TIME] ‘Good Boy Gone Bad’ MV reaction - TXT (투모로우바이투게더)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wMhEfOKVI58/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] TREASURE (트레저) - KING KONG (킹콩) MR제거 240530](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hx8gt9IQg6M/mqdefault.jpg)
Even in the original performance video you can clearly hear them singing live, they’re insane. 4th gen leaders indeed.
They’ve all improved so much this cb 🥹
Yes, Yeonjun's part in chorus after Beomgyu's whisper was so clear and he sounds so full and mad and then Taehyun's adlibs too
@@BTSVTXTKIOF7 Yess absolutely agree with you These 2 are singing really powerful
@@soobinspandulce I do not know if you can call it an improvement. TXT has always been stable. The difference is that they do not have to sing every single word from the chorus so they have time to catch their breath and their choreography is not shaking as it was in the case of 0x1 lovesong or LOSER LOVER.
When your whole body shakes, it's even harder to be stable. Unfortunately, because of this, many people looked at them as if they were worse than other groups, not looking at the fact that they had a high key in the chorus and almost a high note
@@soobinspandulce ever since debut, they are already excellent when it comes to their live performances
진짜 다 잘하는데 미세한 부분도 안 놓치는 태현이가 너무 자랑스럽고 대견하다 ㅜㅜ 모두 너무 잘 했어 ㅠㅠ 너무 고맙고 사랑해
괴물살려 라이브랑 루저러버 엠알제거 보고 충격 먹어서 급하게 입덕했는데 지비지비 엠알 제거를 보니까 그 때의 소름이 이어지는 것 같음. 빨리 1위해서 앵콜 부르는 거 보고 싶다,,
강태현은 진짜 존경스러움..
범규 ㄹㅇ 노력많이했나봐...컴백마다 달라지네
i don't even need mr removed video. i can clearly hear which part they sang in the video itself. like the vocals so clear mann
Yup!!
역시 투바투 좋아하길 잘했어 이르케 라이브 걍 씹어먹었자나ㅠㅠ 얼굴도 잘생기고 맴버 다 만능인데다가 성격 좋은거... 이번 생은 잘 살았어ㅎㅎ 아직 모아 아니신 분들 얼른 모아 하시길....
그래서 모아하기로 했어요…신입입니다 반겨주세요
@@아리-l5f 어머 반가워요ㅎㅎㅎ 우리 같이 평모해요!!
진짜.. 늦게 입덕할수록 후회만 많아질 뿐이에요..
@@user-gracee 이제라도 알았으니까 괜찮아요ㅎㅎ 아 그리고 이제 막 입덕 하셨으면 볼 컨텐츠 많으니 보면서 즐거운 날들 보냈음 좋겠슴돠ㅎㅎㅎ
THEY AREN'T CALLED 4TH GEN LEADERS FOR NOTHING! THEIR VOCALS ARE INSANE!
다들 춤추면서 라이브하는 안정도가 많이 올라갔고 제 눈에 특히 눈에 띄는 게 범규가 춤 노래 많이 늘었고 태현이도 춤 노래 늘었지만 노래에서 기교가 더 늘었는 것 같다고 느꼈어요... 다들 열심히 노력했구나ㅜㅜ 우리 투바투애깅이들 수고했고 앞으로도 연습, 무대 등등 열심히 하자!! 그리고!!! 건강하고!!!! (내맘속 투바투=연약하고 지켜주고 싶음)
아 그리고 심지어 mr제거가 더 좋게 들림
범규도 그렇고 전체적으로 목소리가 엄청 묵직하고 강해진게 들리는거 같아요ㅠㅠ 눈물광광
아 마자요 진짜 우리 범규 더 목소리가 깊어지고 잘 들려요ㅠㅠ 9개월간 겁나 연습했구나 라고 생각했어요
2:12 KANG TAEHYUN'S WHISPER OMG, I DID NOT EXPECT HIM TO SING IT LIVE
ME TOOOO SHOCCKKKKKKKKKKK
How can he has enough power to control his voice from powerfull to whisper.. ;)
Taehyun is “human orchestra”(I think he physically can’t sing with auto tune. He will be in pain:)
yeaa i was so surprised when i heard it in the original video like "whaaat?? he actually whispered tht part omg"
Same!!
최연준은 원래 잘하는 거 알았는데 이번에 범규 진짜 연습 많이 한 듯 . . 지난 활동들보다 라이브 더 선명하게 들리고 춤도 더 예쁘게 잘추는 것 같다 .. 진짜 최고네 ㅜㅠ
범규 너무 멋있다
들어오자마자 데뷔조라고 들었는데
이렇게 성장한게 약간 뭐랄까 존경스러움..
본받고싶네
공백끼 길었던 만큼 실력이 더 좋아진것 같다 진짜 너무 안정적이야 진짜 누구한테 보여줘도 인정할 실력이다
공백기가 언제 길었나요…? 진짜 궁금해서….
진짜....진짜 잘한다.....와.....무슨 격한춤때매 음정 많이 흔들리려나..했는데...이게뭐꼬...
특히 강태현은 진짜 오디오가 비는 곳이 없음.. 다들 너무 잘해… 사랑해…
와 썸넬ㅋㅋ보자마자 감탄사가 절로.. 진짜 잘생겼다
OKAY BUT BEOMGYU’S DEEP VOICE????
와 찐라이브인데 개잘하네
I can really hear the music through their voices. Also can we appreciate how much emotions Beomgyu and Soobin put into the performance??
최연준은 약간 신 인 거 같음
Hueningkai’s vocal is really insane!!
It's not like they were bad before this comeback and improved they were actually amazing last comeback but somehow they were able to improve this time even more to the level where what was jaw dropping last cb seems like it's nothing compared to this..
It's crazy how all 5 of them are insanely stable and confident to sing every part despite the hard choreo!!! I was reminded once again how lucky I am to be a fan of them
연준이 성량(?) 들을 때마다 놀라움 진짜 엄청 커
그리고 진짜 다들 라이브 쩐다 ,,,,, 하 ,,, 사랑해 애들아 자부심 쩐다
I'm in love with Hueningkai's voice
Hueningkai’s voice is so clear and beautiful he literally is good at everything im so jealous
They are so stable! And think about how hard their choreography is!
i mean damn. no bias, this is the best mr removed I've ever heard. this is txt beating the "pre recorded" allegations lol love how they all sang live all throughout the song
but txt never had a pre record allegations? ..
yesss bc they always really sing live. i mean "pre recorded allegations" in general :))
@@NaiaraM02 I was about to ask if it is in general 😅. Anyways, agree
@@kristal5904 When TXT sang well and stably there was always someone who came and said it was pre-recorded.. It's a little annoying
4세대 남돌 탑 투바투인듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 라이브 열심히 부르는데 너무 잘불러서 놀람
누구 하나 구멍이 없냐 카이 음색 너무 좋음
태현이 목긁는거 극락이고 수빈이 범규 가성 진성
둘다 너무 잘부름 최연준은 음원이랑 걍 똑같음..
txt vocals are insane esp taehyun's vocal ... IM SPEECHLESS
Damn this is better than the studio version! Nothing beats Tyunning's stable vocals they really are the reliable maknaes. Huening Kai's clear vocals on that bridge and addictive verse is everything. Taehyun's whispers and adlibs are insane. I love Yeonjun's powerful rap and vocals on the chorus and I'm so proud of Beomgyu and Soobin this era, Beomgyu's low register and Soobin's falsetto are just amazing! The choreography looks so tiring but all 5 of them did incredible! This is the best MR removed video I watched honestly and I'm always nitpicky with vocals.
얘들아 너희 라이브 진짜 잘한다...
역시 투바투.. 라이브 미쳤다
I WILL NEVER GET TIRED OF PRAISING TXT’S LIVE VOCALS BECAUSE DAMN THEY ARE INSANE FOR THIS. ESPECIALLY KANG TAEHYUN!
근데 휴닝카이 목소리 진짜 좋다...
진짜 미쳤다... 저런 춤을 추면서 이런 라이브가 가능해? 사랑해 얘들아 모아 기 팍팍 산다 진짜 너희밖에 없어
TAEHYUN'S RASPY VOICE KILLED ME
우리 애들 라이브 너무 잘해 컴백 할 때마다 실력이 느는 것 같아ㅠㅠ
TXT heavenly vocals and the choreography is iconic
어떻게 음원이랑 똑같아...? 연습 많이 한거 보이구 ㅠㅜ 너네는 그냥 최고다...
이렇게 빠른 노래에 라이브 하면서 춤까지 완벽한 그룹 너희밖에 없어 ㅠㅜ
+ 최연준 랩도 엄청 빠르고 가만히 앉아서 불러도 못 따라가겠던데 완벽하게 불러버리네,, 그냥 짱먹어라 4세대 리더
와 울 애기들 실력 엄청는거 확 느껴진다ㅠㅠㅠ 자랑스럽다 두밧두❤️❤️❤️❤️
the fanchants 😩 haven't heard em in a while 🤌
Kang Taehyun is just sooooooooo good. Always going all out with his live vocals.
진짜 잘생기고 키크고 춤잘추고 라이브 잘하고 웃기고.. 다 완벽한그룹이네
최연준 이렇게 안정적이게 섹시하게 잘하기 있어..? 투바투 음원 씹어먹었네 체고다체고
진짜 누구하나 빠지지 않고 다 잘해서 너무 좋다 이번 활동 화이팅
Beomgyu does that smoothly husky voice so well tho! Love how the boys really embrace their individual colors but harmonize so well as a whole
Taehyun's vocals are literally top tier
txt are insanely stable, it’s crazy !! i love them so much
오를 능력치가 계속 신기록 갱신이다..
대단하다
그와중에 모아들 목소리도 귀여워
곤 배드~~
Their vocals improved so much!! Taehyun, Yeonjun, and Hyuka were always stable since then but Beomgyu and Soobin improved so much in this era. They were not shaky, unlike the other comeback which amazed me even more. Good job Beomgyu and Soobin you did great!
범규 성량 커진거 너무 대견하다ㅜㅜㅜ
txt is so stable as expected! but, i am really happy that beomgyu is so much better now. he's so stable compared to the past comeback. and of course, taehyun is soooo damn stable
this is insanely good! They're so talented! Hybe artists are really no joke!
1:15 범규ㅠㅠ 이부분 중독성있엉ㅠㅠ 엠알제거로 들으니 더 잘들려서 좋당 !
taehyun's "all the good boys gone bad" at last... he is best
우아 진짜 잘한다 다들 ㅜㅜㅡㅡㅜㅜㅜ음원이랑 똑같음 하 진짜 사랑스럽다 다들 ... ❤❤❤❤
진짜 개잘한다.............
투모로우바이투게더 9개월 만에 긴 공백 끝에 컴백 했는데,
라이브 너무 잘 하네요,
태현이는 진짜 매번 레전드야...
볼 때마다 너무 대견스럽고 짜릿해..ㅠㅠ
Their live vocals!words aren't enough to describe them. TXT the standard!
ㅈㄴ자랑스럽다....
애내 좋아한거 너무 뿌듯할때 많아 진짜 사랑해 툽깅이들 진짜 꽃길만 걷길바래 꼭 뜨자
txt live vocals + MOA lovely cheers and chants= perfection
격한 안무인데도 어떻게 안정적으로 부를 수가 있지?
투바투 사랑해❤️
태현이 사소한것도 다부르네..그 속삭이는(?)것도 부를줄은..ㅋㅋ
I'm so proud of them, they are improving day by day
Even with a hard choreography they are stable; they are unbelievable talented!!!! Yeonjun sings the chorus highly while dancing!!! Even her raps his lines amazingly
울 애들은 이런거 안해도 다 들린다니까..
라이브 다들 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠ
오늘도 툽부심을 키운다,,
와 잘한다👍🏼
팬은 아니지만 투바투 더 흥해라
아니... 모아분들 왜이렇게 노래 잘부르세여???
다 2세대 아이돌 팬 짬 거쳐 오신 분들 일거 같네요… 그게 꼭 제 이야기 같긴하지만… ㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
2:24 let's take a moment of silence to appreciate how stable yeonjun is while rapping
Meanwhile me dying when trying that rap bcoz out of breath, doesn't know how to rap and miss the melody:
강태현 미쳤네..진짜 다들 너무 잘한다 진짜 사기캐들..
wow he even did the whisper live at 2:12 ..nice
울 툽깅이들 너무 잘한다 진짜 자랑스러워 ❤❤
2:52 taehyun "all the good boy gone bad" sound satisfying to hear
긴 공백기 동안 연습 엄청 많이 한 것 같다 …
얘들아 수고했어 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ ෆ ෆ
라이브의 신인가...
HUENINGKAI'S STABILITY IS NO JOKE
아니 다들 라이브 왜케 잘해... 춤도 완전 빡세게 추면서 라이브까지 잘해버리면...ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
beomgyu is getting better day by day, so proud of him
Hueningkai really improved, I'm so proud
역시 투바투!! 말이 필요없네~💙💙💙
얘네 찐이네… 본업 잘할때가 젤 멋잇는건데.. 라이브 왤케잘해미쳣니..
So stable wow
How can Taehyun effortlessly shift from husky voice to whispering?
Taehyun sounds the same as cd
people don't give moas enough credit for being incredibly stable
완전 악바리로 부름 ㄹㅇ 호감♡
I stan them but this even surprised me. I'm so fucking proud to be a MOA.
They sang it live as if the choreography wasn't hard. THE ONE AND ONLY TOMORROW X TOGETHER
They sound so stable when they sing and the fact you can hear their live vocals in the official performance is just amazing! 4th gen leaders
썸넬보고 홀린듯 들어옴
이렇게 들으니까 범규 목소리가 더 낮아 보여.. 사랑해
진짜 툽부심
대박…개잘해 음원이랑 똑같네
이만큼 열심히 하는 아이돌이 또 있나.... 진짜 최고로 열심히 함 대단해ㅠㅠ
They literally got even better! I’m so proud of them all and they sound even more confident than before!
너무 안정적이다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
can y'all SEE the growth
I mean you can tell how much stability and work went into it
omg this one of my best mr removed stage
Taehyun's whisper!!!