because beomgyu has such a deep voice, its hard to hear him in things like this and with tiring choreography, its usually extremely difficult to sing in a lower register as you're out of breath. but regardless of that beomgyu was still able to pull it off and you can hear his deep stable voice clearly
Yep.. and also because the parts when he is singing with Seori I couldn’t hear his voice compared to when it was Yeonjun and Seori. But his voice is really calming to me somehow
Ikr, soobin's voice in frost was so shocking, I didn't expect it before because it sounded so different from soobin's voice that I knew. Bighit really hides TXT potential and show it one by one. Bottom line, TXT is the perfect group. sorry for my bad english, i use a translator;)
Hueningkai then soobin but on live hueningkai sang for both parts.. since soobin had a hard time doing high notes during live but he still slay it however it is 😊@@rzz_mmr_.
Hueningkai! His adlibs is on fire! Taehyun's highnote never failed to amaze me! Beomgyu's smooth deep voice is so calming. Yeonjun's stability is chef kiss. Soobin's falsetto is 😉
beomgyu did amazing actually, it's just might be hard to hear his voice clearly like other members' cause his voice is already low/deep and he's also singing low notes. if you check today's no rules stage you can see that he confidently sings all of his parts and you can hear his voice clearly cause the notes not as low as here. he improved a lot!!
For those fandom who compares their rookie group to txt's live vocals, they should watch this and they need to realize that the group that they are comparing has only 5 members but still manage to pull off those hard vocals despite the hard choreos. They should be ashmbeamed to compare them to a 9? membered group.
빅히트.. 목 긁는 거 이번을 마지막으로 더이상 시키지 마.. 타돌언급 진짜 죄송한데 툽투 선배 뷔도 데뷔 때부터 1년 넘게 목 긁는 창법 썼는데 목 다 쉬고 나빠져서 창법 바꿨잖아...... 우리 예쁜 태현이 목소리 뷔처럼 낮은 톤도 아니라 뭔가 더 상할 거 같아서 그래.. 다음 앨범 발라드 들고 이해해줄테니까 제발 그 목 긁는 거 그만 집어넣어 좋은 건 알겠지만
이번엔 곡 장르가 락장르라서 락장르 특유의 창법으로 하기위해 그런것같아요 아예 목을 긁는 소리만 내는게 아니라 보컬 창법 유지하면서 긁는 소리를 내는거기도 하고 노래 컨셉상 이번 활동에 활용되는거니까 다음 장르때 락으로 나오지 않는이상 다음 활동때는 노래 창법 쓸것같아요:)
@@lobo_lobo_ 저도 락 장르라서 그러는 건 알지만.. 뭔가 이게 반응이 좋네? 그러면서 더 집어넣을까봐 걱정이 돼서요ㅠㅠㅜ 디어 스푸트니크나 Frost처럼 수록곡이면 상관 없겠지만 타이틀은 제일 많이 부를 수 밖에 없는 노래니까... 너무 이른 바람이긴 하지만 다음 앨범은 기계음 적당히 넣고 예쁜 애들 목소리 많이 들을 수 있으면 좋겠네요!
Soobin's vocal so stable despite the intense solo choreo at his part.. and he also sing the high note and the lowest note in THE SAME SONG. All rounder vocal king Choi Soobin ♥️
애들 다 대박인데 수빈이는 미소 지을 널 봤지 그 파트처럼 엄청 높은거 주지 않구 딱 맞는걸로 주니까 더 잘부르고 대박이다ㅠㅠ 아 그냥 울바투 넘 잘하고 있고 울 모아들이 꼭 1위 시켜줄게 이제 더 성공할일밖에 안남았다ㅜㅜ 글고 태현이 정말 대박이고 음원때메 목 긁는? 그런거 있는데 완전 대박...근데 목 아프면 그렇게 하지마 모아들 진짜 태현이 아프면 운다ㅠㅠ
*remember when the members said yeonjun never 2nd, 3rd places in monthly evaluation but 1st in vocal, dance, and rap. plus taehyun being tied with yeonjun at 1st place in vocal?? insane right*
the way beomgyu is singing in a low register WHILE DANCING IS SO IMPRESSIVE, I do music and it is EXTREMELY HARD to sing in a stable low register even if you are standing still, the fact that he is doing it while dancing wow
Yeonjun's voice is so stable singing live and he sounds so powerful! I remember watching their performance at award shows and I can say that since debut Yeonjun has consistently served his performances in every aspect, he does very well in live stages. And not to mention that he has consistently ranked no 1 in all categories during trainee days. He's really ace
This is their best live performance so far!! I love how loud and clear their voices are 😭 this is why I prefer the hand mics better. They've really improved so much!!! They can sing the entire song so stable despite this intense choreography 👏 IM SO PROUD OF THEM
txt raising the bar so high once again for the other 4th gen groups or even all kpop groups out there. this song is actually hard to sing because of the amount of high notes plus the tiring choreography but they did SO SO WELL, THEY NEVER FAIL TO AMAZE US
ok but can we all talk about hyuka’s adlibs at 3:08 and 3:11?? like damn his voice is so good!! vids like this definitely makes me feel so so proud of being a MOA
yes but he didnt sing any adlib live if u watch mcountdown mpd fancam(comeback stage mpd group fancam) uploaded. that adlib is just original audio though i like it
We dont do the "why is no one talking about *insert particular member*" in this household. Let's praise the member without acting like no one else is talking about him except you, because that's def not true :) Also, it's HUEning Kai :)
Idols from Big Hit have the most stable voice and no lip sync in their live performances at all thus far, among other idols from different agencies in Hybe, if not among all idol companies in South Korea, I must admit. Everyone should! BTS and TXT are real performers who set the highest bar for all idols by singing with their real voice live performance while dancing their hard coreos, like, ever! I've compared mr removed contents from most popular idols from 2nd to 4th generations, and BTS & TXT are the most stable and top notch notes in each of their performances. The world SHOULD respect them and admit their musicality!
![[MR Removed] TXT - NO RULES MR제거 20210604 (Live Vocals)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4hmDhFf1a2E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] [BTS - ON] Comeback Stage M COUNTDOWN 200227 EP.654 MR제거](/img/1.gif)
CHECK OUT MY COVER DANCE❤
ITZY - Mafia In the Morning with Chaeryeong❤
- ruclips.net/video/pcXRYwgu-xY/видео.html
you can't make me believe that taehyun is a human he's literally singing high note while jumping like HOW
I mean..didn't they practice singing on a treadmill? ;;
@@minllifluous4769 yes hyuka and taehyun did
ikr he is getting better and better
Soobin too... His vocal is really stable when je jump on trampoline
@@minllifluous4769 they did? Waw-
i love yeonjun's voice so much it's like it autotuned naturally
i will literally recognize his voice anywhere ITS SO UNIQUE
@@juliefritz866 EXACTLY
yeah it's like 90% nasal and it sounds sooo unique
Can someone tell me what is mr removed? What did they remove?
@@btskingofkpop9132 they removed the backing track (aka the song they play in the bg) so this is purely their vocals live
because beomgyu has such a deep voice, its hard to hear him in things like this and with tiring choreography, its usually extremely difficult to sing in a lower register as you're out of breath. but regardless of that beomgyu was still able to pull it off and you can hear his deep stable voice clearly
Yeah, agree lets love him.
His soulful and deep voice sounds so good still
@@ridadamayanti6057 it makes me love him more
Agree! And despite that, we can still hear him.
Yep.. and also because the parts when he is singing with Seori I couldn’t hear his voice compared to when it was Yeonjun and Seori. But his voice is really calming to me somehow
how tf does taehyun still continue his high notes while dancing and jumping like that !??!
taehyun is singing like he went through 18 divorces
Lmfaooo
PLS, THIS SEND ME- 😭✋
LMAOOO
1 for each year he's alive yes
LOL
that's the reason why yeonjun got the title *"Bighit's Legendary Trainee"*
Exacly
Wow they are really getting better every comeback. They can now sing 99% of their lines. 4TH GEN LEADERS INDEED!
Ikrrrr I fell in love
they are amazing!!
IKR?????
fr
IM SPEECHLESS THEIR VOCALS ARE VERY STABLE, 4TH GEN LEADERS Y’ALL
im too! definitely!
they aren't called that for nothing.
that is not their title, that title belongs to straykids and you have to respect that.
@@lamejortaehyungista5416 me when I lie
@@lamejortaehyungista5416 LMAO WHAT, txt has the 4th gen leaders tittle, stfu. Skz nunca lo va a tener.
the duality of soobin's voice.. here he's the soft falsetto king and when you listen frost his voice is on fire
Ikr, soobin's voice in frost was so shocking, I didn't expect it before because it sounded so different from soobin's voice that I knew. Bighit really hides TXT potential and show it one by one. Bottom line, TXT is the perfect group.
sorry for my bad english, i use a translator;)
@@ainurmafruridhoni9746 your english is good! and yeah you're right
You guys mean the chorus?
I'm sorry but the chorus was sung by Huening Kai and Taehyun
Hueningkai then soobin but on live hueningkai sang for both parts.. since soobin had a hard time doing high notes during live but he still slay it however it is 😊@@rzz_mmr_.
@@cloudywishhh but i don't hear soobin's voice there, i replayed it 10 times and i definitely hear kai's voice...
How beomgyu can stabilized his lower deep voice even after the jumping part?? He's so amazinggg
Because he had jump for almost 3 years now
@@fluffygyu8050 😭👌🤣
it's actually harder to control your voice when you sing low than singing high when dancing so beomgyu is really amazing for this
Yo for real!!!
This! I naturally have a deep voice and i find it hard even talking sometimes
hueningkai vocals like he is jumping and singing so effortlessly and all five of them
they ate cds
Hueningkai! His adlibs is on fire! Taehyun's highnote never failed to amaze me! Beomgyu's smooth deep voice is so calming. Yeonjun's stability is chef kiss. Soobin's falsetto is 😉
Ikr.... i'm so stuned by "i love you~" adlibs at the end
What is auto-tune in this world!?
I only know TXT's voice. It's literally better than their studio version.
Taehyun is literally jumping like a squirrel and how is he hitting those notes so effortlessly?? KING TAEHYUN INDEED
maknaes high note literally gave me goosebumps.. theyre too good to be real
my moa ego 📈📈📈
they be not eating cd's, they eat VINYLS!! OH GOD WHY SO GOOD?!😭
yeonjun and taehyun are mwah *chef's kiss*
munching CDs while watching movies
They eat CDs for breakfast and lunch, vinyls for dinner and illegal USB’s as snacks..
Yeonjun and taehyun are Crazy💘
@@Mello_Loves_Mujin lmao USB’s-
Only he himself would know
Hueningkai is so stable even if he has to sing while jumping wow his voice sounds really good too
저 안무에 이런 라이브가 가능한 일이란 말인가 진짜 얼마나 피나는 노력을 했을지 ㅜㅜ
존경한다 얘들아 너무 고맙고 자랑스러워
Taehyun really reminding us of his extremely diverse vocal range, so even the people in the back will LISTEN
Don't see anyone talking about Hyuka but he's also really stable.
Soobin’s voice is everything that is fine in this world 😭♥️✋🏻
taehyun vocals are so stable and his vocal range is insane
yeonjun, huening kai, taehyun really impressed me so much wow
TXT has the best live vocal among 4th gen groups. I'm so proud of them 😭
그 격한 춤 추면서 라이브를 이정도로 해낸다니 진짜...투바투가 케이팝 씹어먹자
Taehyun vocals are getting better. The way I see it he's so disciplined. Looking forward more of his performance!
전원핸드마이크인거부터가... 개사기임
애기들 런닝머신 뛰면서 노래연습하는거 볼때도 느꼈지만.. 진짜 저 안무 소화하면서 노래도 잘 부르는거 보면 ㅠㅠ 너무 뿌듯하다 실력만큼은 진짜 너무 인정..!
@@user-hn5bl6ik5e ruclips.net/video/XVuoy7-YDUY/видео.html
beomgyu did amazing actually, it's just might be hard to hear his voice clearly like other members' cause his voice is already low/deep and he's also singing low notes. if you check today's no rules stage you can see that he confidently sings all of his parts and you can hear his voice clearly cause the notes not as low as here. he improved a lot!!
For those fandom who compares their rookie group to txt's live vocals, they should watch this and they need to realize that the group that they are comparing has only 5 members but still manage to pull off those hard vocals despite the hard choreos. They should be ashmbeamed to compare them to a 9? membered group.
Ikr, they're only have 5 members but their vocal range are wider. I mean,, bro look how versatile TXT on every concept, never missed.
최범규 진성 파트 언제 줘요... 나만 또 최범규 진성 좋아하지... 하... 근데 이번에 수빈이 진짜 대박이다, 553 때는 가성 파트 엄청 많았는데 진성 사용하니까 진짜 잘한다. 553 때는 약간 불안해 보였는데 지금이 훨씬 나은 듯.
저도 범규 진정 처돌이….ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
빅히트.. 목 긁는 거 이번을 마지막으로 더이상 시키지 마.. 타돌언급 진짜 죄송한데 툽투 선배 뷔도 데뷔 때부터 1년 넘게 목 긁는 창법 썼는데 목 다 쉬고 나빠져서 창법 바꿨잖아...... 우리 예쁜 태현이 목소리 뷔처럼 낮은 톤도 아니라 뭔가 더 상할 거 같아서 그래.. 다음 앨범 발라드 들고 이해해줄테니까 제발 그 목 긁는 거 그만 집어넣어 좋은 건 알겠지만
이번엔 곡 장르가 락장르라서 락장르 특유의 창법으로 하기위해 그런것같아요
아예 목을 긁는 소리만 내는게 아니라 보컬 창법 유지하면서 긁는 소리를 내는거기도 하고 노래 컨셉상 이번 활동에 활용되는거니까 다음 장르때 락으로 나오지 않는이상 다음 활동때는 노래 창법 쓸것같아요:)
@@lobo_lobo_ 저도 락 장르라서 그러는 건 알지만.. 뭔가 이게 반응이 좋네? 그러면서 더 집어넣을까봐 걱정이 돼서요ㅠㅠㅜ 디어 스푸트니크나 Frost처럼 수록곡이면 상관 없겠지만 타이틀은 제일 많이 부를 수 밖에 없는 노래니까... 너무 이른 바람이긴 하지만 다음 앨범은 기계음 적당히 넣고 예쁜 애들 목소리 많이 들을 수 있으면 좋겠네요!
목 쉬어서 창법 바뀐게 아니고 초창기에는 힙합곡이라서 어울리는 창법으로 노래했던거고 ,, 나중에는 장르가 달라져서 그 곡에 맞게 창법을 바꾼겁니다 ,,
반응 호불호많이갈림...모아들은 당연히 좋아하지만 어짜피 담앨범에 락 컨셉안하면 긁는창법안하겠지만 일단 음역대좀낮춰ㅡㅡ
@@user-mq8ph6gk5d 좋거나 걱정된다를 반응 갈린다고 말하는 건가... 목 긁는 거 별로라고 하는 사람은 못봤는데
I'M IN LOVE WITH TAEHYUN'S VOICE FR!!!
핸드 마이크 쓰는 것부터 라이브 인증임 개잘한다 라이브 미쳤다
Yeonjun’s voice oh my god,, he ate that
HOW IS TAEHYUN DOING THAT
아무리 요즘 mr제거 믿기 힘들다지만 그래도 라이브를 진짜 한 경우면 어느정도 진짜 부르는 목소리 mr제거 영상으로 분간할 수 있는데 애들 진짜 잘한다 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 엠카직캠만 봐도 라이브하는거 티 남 진짜 열심히한게 느껴져서 너무 대견해
Gosh Yeonjun's voice is so unique it feels like it's autotune but it's not!!! And Taehyun OMG!!! all of them are sooooo good 4th gen leaders indeed
이번곡 진짜 높던데.. mr제거해도 안정적이게 다 너무 잘부르넹 울바투 꽃길만 걷자❤❤
TXT is one of the most stable groups. PERIODT.
Soobin's vocal so stable despite the intense solo choreo at his part.. and he also sing the high note and the lowest note in THE SAME SONG. All rounder vocal king Choi Soobin ♥️
This is one of the most stable performances I’ve seen in my whole life
literally same i'm in such shock rn
애들 다 대박인데 수빈이는 미소 지을 널 봤지 그 파트처럼 엄청 높은거 주지 않구 딱 맞는걸로 주니까 더 잘부르고 대박이다ㅠㅠ
아 그냥 울바투 넘 잘하고 있고 울 모아들이 꼭 1위 시켜줄게
이제 더 성공할일밖에 안남았다ㅜㅜ 글고 태현이 정말 대박이고 음원때메 목 긁는? 그런거 있는데 완전 대박...근데 목 아프면 그렇게 하지마 모아들 진짜 태현이 아프면 운다ㅠㅠ
THE VOCALS!!! I'M SPEECHLESS!!! 4TH GEN LEADERS INDEED!!!
짱바투다. 찢었다 너희는 못하는 게 뭐냐 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
라이브 진짜 안정적이다...👍
I followed TXT since debut, but I'm new MOA. I love their live vocals like this. And i really really love this song
Welcome baby Moa 🤗
You made a good decision
Me too...new moa
Welcome to moaville
me too uwu
same here, i followed then since debut, but imma new moa. they’re so amazing!🥰
우리 투바투 실력파라고!!!!❤❤
*remember when the members said yeonjun never 2nd, 3rd places in monthly evaluation but 1st in vocal, dance, and rap. plus taehyun being tied with yeonjun at 1st place in vocal?? insane right*
아~이그룹이 맨날 멤버들한테
CD먹인다는 그 그룹이구나. 아하!
🦊🐰🐻🐿🐧
I just got to stan txt, this comeback is so good and I’m happy to hear how good they are at singing live
WELCOME TO THE FAM MOA!!
@@jee2059 THANK YOU
연준이랑 태현이는 성량자체가 엄청크네... 다들 잘한다
mr removed, they are all stable and it's live,
That's TXT y'all. They never disappoint.
역시 mr제거도 완벽하넹..긍데 태현이 음방 계속될수록 목 나갈꺼같은뎅...
청량컨셉으로 부르는 날은 목이 좀 안풀린걸로 알아달래요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 무리인거 같으면 저렇게 안부르겠다는뜻인듯... 애가 똑똑해서 잘 할거같아여 ... 지금 거의 메보 인데 목 나가면 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
TAEHYUN AND HUENING KAI'S VOCALS THOOOOO CHEF'S KISS BESTIE
Taehyun's voice is what I am living for. His raspy voice, adlibs and high notes are just incredible 😍😍
*yeonjun doesn't need autotune, autotune needs yeonjun*
no
TXT doesn't need autotune, autotune needs them
Soobin's vocals are so underrated he is so stable.
yeonjun is perfect voice..The volume is high and the pitch is accurate. Yeonjun crazy!!!! You are the best💘💘
라이브 진짜 점점 더 는다
so you are telling me this isn't pre recorded ...they really do be eating CDs
Its pre recorded lol,
@@faeyzastuffid5307 it's not. it's live vocal. lem castle will describe if they lip-sync
@@faeyzastuffid5307 you can literally hear them overpower the track in the main video... Thats enough proof already
yeah, its live vocal
@@faeyzastuffid5307 you're always around saying its pre recorded even if it's not lmao
the way beomgyu is singing in a low register WHILE DANCING IS SO IMPRESSIVE, I do music and it is EXTREMELY HARD to sing in a stable low register even if you are standing still, the fact that he is doing it while dancing wow
Yeonjun's voice is so stable singing live and he sounds so powerful! I remember watching their performance at award shows and I can say that since debut Yeonjun has consistently served his performances in every aspect, he does very well in live stages. And not to mention that he has consistently ranked no 1 in all categories during trainee days. He's really ace
THEY'RE SO STABLE! THEY'VE IMPROVED SO MUCHH
This is their best live performance so far!! I love how loud and clear their voices are 😭 this is why I prefer the hand mics better. They've really improved so much!!! They can sing the entire song so stable despite this intense choreography 👏 IM SO PROUD OF THEM
txt raising the bar so high once again for the other 4th gen groups or even all kpop groups out there. this song is actually hard to sing because of the amount of high notes plus the tiring choreography but they did SO SO WELL, THEY NEVER FAIL TO AMAZE US
ok but can we all talk about hyuka’s adlibs at 3:08 and 3:11?? like damn his voice is so good!! vids like this definitely makes me feel so so proud of being a MOA
with gyus deep voice, tyun and yeonjun high vocals when LITERALLY JUMPING ?!? kai’ and soobs raw vocals sound so good together..
And BigHit was worried about them CDs disappearing, now we know wo got 'em 🤠
이 공연은 모든 사람들의 관심을 끌 만하다.
누군가 제발 그것을 퍼뜨려라 o_o 하느님 제발 우리를 도와주세요.
BIGHIT really doesn’t disappoint us with their live vocals
soobin’s vocal 😩 is 😩 so 😩 good 😩
Taehyun raspy voice
태현아 목 너무 긁는 방법으로 노래할려 하지마 ㅠㅠ
그렇개 하라해도 하지마 ㅠㅠ
무대 못 하는 것보다 너 다치는게 더 속상하니깐 ㅠㅠ
It's live stage. And their voice this freaking good!!. WOW! I must appreciate them. They are truly Vocal kings.
태현아 밥 먹고 다니는거지??ㅠㅠㅠ 씨디만 씹어먹은 것 같아...ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 우리 애기들 진짜 장하다❤️❤️ 얼마나 연습했을지,, 상상이 안 가ㅠㅠ
their vocals even with that intense dance 👏👏
Yeonjun's vocals unique and powerful, he's also v stable imagine doing those power dance moves and still sing
I ascended at Taehyun's highnote/adlibs my god he's going to be such a threat in the coming years
hueningkai's adlibs are amazing
yes but he didnt sing any adlib live if u watch mcountdown mpd fancam(comeback stage mpd group fancam) uploaded. that adlib is just original audio though i like it
@@applemint9046 he did on radio live...nd it was amazing🥰
@@alishas6857 what i meant is based on this vid though as i wrote above
@@applemint9046 yeah nd i told u that cause i thought maybe u want to see the live one....
다 늘었지만 최연준이랑 강태현이 진짜 늘었다
그냥 천재들...
Why no one talking about kai
Heuningkai really stable and good❤️❤️
We dont do the "why is no one talking about *insert particular member*" in this household. Let's praise the member without acting like no one else is talking about him except you, because that's def not true :)
Also, it's HUEning Kai :)
@@komalsharma7852 oh I'm sorry 🙏
@@komalsharma7852 its true tho not much people talk about hueningkai
Idols from Big Hit have the most stable voice and no lip sync in their live performances at all thus far, among other idols from different agencies in Hybe, if not among all idol companies in South Korea, I must admit. Everyone should! BTS and TXT are real performers who set the highest bar for all idols by singing with their real voice live performance while dancing their hard coreos, like, ever! I've compared mr removed contents from most popular idols from 2nd to 4th generations, and BTS & TXT are the most stable and top notch notes in each of their performances. The world SHOULD respect them and admit their musicality!
완벽하네. 이게 라이브지!
핸드마이크 쓰는 이유가 있었네
Yeonjun's voice is soo unique!!!
beomgyu’s raw vocals is making me feel things
엠알제거가 아니라 음원같음..💕
they're so stable while doing such a hard choreo
I can't even think of something to say. They are just AMAZING! 💯
OMG HUENING KAI'S VOCALS ARE 0N POINT. HES SO STABLE while jumping its like so hard to sing. and taehyun omg
hueningkai's adilbs at the end were so beautiful omgg they all sung so well, 4th gen leaders!
한국인 댓글을 발견하셨습니다....
지금 보셨다면 K-모아는 스밍하세요!!
와 미쳤다
Taehyun, proving that he’s the 4th Gen Main Vocalist
무대를 찢어 놓으셨다
👏👏👏👍👍👍
❣❣❣❣❣