Huawei MatePad Paper vs Remarkable 2 | Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- The Remarkable 2 and Huawei MatePad Paper, are Littered with issues. They need to be addressed. Check out this video to see all the pros and cons! You will learn all about the hardware, software and drawing experience.
You can Buy a MatePad Paper here:
goodereader.co...
Join the Good e-Reader Subscription Program! We would be happy to have your support.
/ @goodereader
**-------------------------**
If you would like to support our channel, consider visiting our Patreon page:
www.patreon.co...
**-------------------------**
Sorry Remarkable but, on principle, I will never agree to a subscription model.
I agree to that!
Same here!!!!!
True, if they did not change it, i never had bought one. Glad they did.
Yeap! That's shitty! And I think that's the first review that I saw that talks about that.
@@michaelwinkler7841 they did? I'm not sure to invest in a remakable, but I love to take notes by hand. At the end I have to much papers, and get lost. In my work I have to take a lot of notes, and I'm thinking for some years about remakable, but, it's a lot of money. and now the color one.... I'm not sure
Remarkable was always something I wanted, but the price is ridiculous. Now that you have to pay a subscription to use all of its features I have zero interest in getting one. Like zero. Negative zero. I think Ill stick with paper. Its a better writing experience and costs practically nothing.
The Remarkable (1st gen) used to be my absolute favorite until one day the battery died and their customer support told me they don't offer spares or a repair service. Their fancy "paper-like" writing experience really loses its appeal when the display stays blank. At the time I was shocked from the lack of customer support for such a premium priced device from such a small company, but after seeing this video (monthly subscription for basic software) it's pretty clear to me that all they want is to get rich. I'm reluctant to buy a Matepad Paper until some battery swap videos come up on RUclips, but once that happens I'll definitely go Huawei.
Huawei just released the M-Pen 2s Stylus. it supports side front tilting drawing and 4096 levels of pressure sensitivity as well as supports different types of thickness in writing.
Where can I buy it? Does the MatePad Paper recognize it?
How does the ppi change if the screen is exactly the same size with equal pixels?
rounding probably lol
I will never buy any device or app that force me to subscripion. And you all shouldn't too. Unfortunately too many people seems to accept some forms of subscription, but it's dengerous. If that trend will continue we will wake up one day without any property fully dependant on corporations and/or governmet will. It started with some apps, than some software features inside phisical devices, now BMW is testing subscription for phisical features of their cars - so legally we will not be owners of our wehicles in the future. What else? Breathing subscription? We all should stop buying stuff that force us to this bad business practices and put a pressure on companies to stop this madness.
The remarkable us truly a remarkable rip off
Since my main concern is writing feel, I'm going with RM2. I don't need the extra subscription since there is an app that allows you to drop files from your phone or computer.
If Writing feel is a concern, you should be going with Fujitsu. They are #1
@@goodereader For the price they should be
@@goodereader Fujitsu what?
QUADERNO gen 2 :)
Once more Huawei delivers more than expected for less and that's why they are getting squished. I'm typing this on my Good old Mate 20 Pro after Samsung Note 10+, iPhone 12 Pro Max and S22 Ultra I'm back on my almost 99% perfect smartphone ever in terms of design and power a true flagship still in 2022 and it is Huawei Mare 20 Pro. RECOMENDED get an used one while you can find one. Also it just gott Android 12 update. I'm not paid by Huawei or something but after many smartphones flagships no one feels like the Mate 20 not even the latest Mate 30, 40. BTW the Notch on the iPhone's pisses me off they are ugly made even the smallest one in the iPhone 13 but on Mare 20 Pro it doest bother me at all, why ?? Because it is made property and because of the overall design of the phone it is not noticeable. I even suggested to Huawei to get the same design on the Mate 50 Pro but 2022 specs.Also the cameras beat every iPhone until now. So the Huawei Pad sure is AWESOME.
This is just eyecandy tech that is not usable. They included android and any app that android can run, with a display that is not able to. A stock android tablet is better than this. Including everything you have in a sketchbook will not make it better. It's childish.
08:40 Actually, Lamy eraser with the built-in button is not supported in Remarkable by default, you need to add an extra-hack for it via the console from PC, which will last only until the next device reboot (unless you want to ditch the official firmware and install the customized one). Also, Lamy pen has a small issue with the tiny line of writing surface on the right edge on my RM2, the pressure is always weaker there for some reason. Overall, Marker and Marker+ deliver the best writing experience on RM2.
Auch. I know Good e-reader is critical to rM2, but "Not a viable product" is even more than usual. However, as a user of rM2, I totally agree with this video on rM2 and never recommend anyone new to rM2 mostly because of the subscription situation.
speaking of note-taking, handwriting and whatnot, rM2 is nothing more than a brick when it comes to non-roman alphabets. It does not recognize your non-alphabetic writing and what it worse It does not render epub if it is not in a roman alphabet (even with fonts contained).
However, i would never to use Huawei because of security concerns. You know, I dont want CCP to look everything I write. 😅
Hey there, we are not critical, we are speaking the truth. Literally everything we said about.. both units, are completely true objective facts
We showed screenshots, check out procedures, and on paper specs
And yes, we are correct, in the eyes of the consumer, the remarkable two is no longer a viable product as other devices offer countless additional features, and better writing feel with more advanced technology than the remarkable 2
That is also a concern of many people and why Huawei is not even for sale in many countries
@@5pm_Hazyblue I wouldn’t worry about that. It’s not overtly different to what you already have with Google, Apple, Facebook and Microsoft. Truth is you aren’t special enough for the Chinese government to specifically care about what you do or who you are.
Unless you are an anti China activist with a really big following, it’s really not an issue.
Also it’s an E-ink device. Outside of sending out your notes and downloading documents, you rarely need to be online with it.
MatePad for sure
BRUH I AS A STUDENT, WANT SOMETHING THAT CAN HELP ME, THE REMARKABLE WILL FREKN DESTROY THE HEKK OUT OF ME, its like having a pet that need to spend money on for food and other things
please, which device would you recommend, with a large screen, screen temperature control, just for reading and taking notes, with a stylus. Just like a big Kindle with a stylus and no more apps...thanks!
@Suleiman thanks my friend!👍👍
I have an RM2 and I love it, but I also got in before the subscription model and b/c of the referral program my tablet ended up being free. Would I get it again today if I was shopping for an eink tablet... I honestly don't know. Boox and supernote both have come a long way. When I bought my RM2 I was most concerned with feel and latency, and at the time the RM2 was far ahead on both, now it's pretty much even. I know I wouldn't go with Huawei though, security is too big of a concern. I do like that there is more competition in the eink tablet arena though and look forward to see what is out there in a couple of years.
Quite frustrating for me as somebody who is looking for a 10-inch or more e-reader. I had a Kindle 10 years ago which was cheap and fine for pdfs and (if I remember correcty) epubs. Coming back to the market this much later, as somebody who simply wants to read large PDF files, to see that nothing worth having is less than €400, and is still likely to have lots of issues, is disappointing to say the least!
@@legatrix ya it would be nice if amazon would offer a larger kindle for those who was that experience. Personally i stick to my kindle paperwhite for reading. I find it more comfortable than my larger RM2
I own a ReMarkable 2, I personally never use the pen tilting feature and very very rarely do I use the pressure sensitive pens. 99% of the time, I'm using a pen that doesn't use tilt or pressure, so that I don't have to use almost any force to write and thus also saving in the tip of the pen. When I say pen I mean the software option on ReMarkable, not actually a different pen. I just use the ReMarkable Pro pen. Also the tips aren't that cheap either...
Very good review. Good details
Nonsense expensive items both just get and iPad or a Galaxy Tab for the same price....this "peper feel gimmicks just dosen't worth it...if you want paper feel get a notebook and a pencil :)
It's not a gimmick. Where you been?
The MatePad has no place. Just get the Note Air 2. Same features. No limitations on what physical pen to use. A ton more virtual pen options. Aside from the leather feel, the Note Air 2 is superior in every way.
The Huawei is leagues ahead in terms of aesthetics.
你两个都买啦？
NO SUBSCRIPTION .... !!! 💩 REMARKABLE
Can anyone guide me to a good Boox Note Air 2 (or plus) vs. Huawei Matepad Paper comparison? Seems like that would be a more apple to apple comparison. Particularly an objective review on the pen and battery life aspects are something I am very interested in.
Let me first share what I do know (credits mostly to CME:XP RUclips channel):
- Matepad paper has theoretically better specs but higher specs might lead to unnecessary battery consumption.
- Matepad paper is front-lit and the light is impressively uniform
- Matepad will win in aesthetic department in both hardware design and UI
- Matepad paper uses a proprietary pen rather than a wacom one... This part is covered well in this video. However, there is still some objective review required for the latency and writing feeling i.e. if the Huawei pen is any good compared to the out of the box pen from Note Air 2.
- Matepad's display is probably more crisp than Note Air 2 but I doubt if there is any good reader that can beat Neoreader from Boox
What I don't know:
- Does ADB work on Harmony OS for using with scrcpy?
- How does one note/Evernote perform on Matepad paper?
- Usability and feasibility of the nibs from Matepad paper (covered to a little extent in this video but a little more details may be desirable as this is the only real deal maker/breaker) rest can be dealt with incremental firmware updates
- Does the increased battery capacity practically translate into increased battery life with the active stylus, constant Bluetooth connection, and a more power intensive (I think) CPU taken into consideration?
- A prognosis maybe? Is Huawei invested in making the experience better and answer users or this is just an experiment with a different technology waiting to be scrapped off from the company's roadmap.
I bought both, for writing experience ,Matepad Paper has better feeling and lower latency according to Boox Air 2 plus and better overall material quality.
However, Boox has more optimized software for general purpose.
Huawei Matepad Paper only need to improve sofware and add some handy features to enrich writing and reading expreience.
Nobody is buying Remarkable lel.
I'm intrigued by the writing input method. I can imagine two input pathways.. Does anyone know?
1. the pen contact point is detected by the digitiser, and the data is sent to the OS which then tells the app to create a data point. i.e. traditional input method.
2. the pen contact causes the e-ink cells to change colour directly, and some kind of digitiser layer feeds the contact points through the OS to the app, which is then recorded in the file.
The second method would allow for a much more responsive input experience, but I don't know if it's physically practical.
huawei easy win.
Just went dose a normal pen or pencil bents.
Sorry for Matepad paper : You can not use the madpaper with a secured connexion. So impossible for me ti use it at work. Ann Impossible to synchornise the agenda with your personnal or professional agenda.
I am really drawn to how they frame it as a distraction free "thinking" device. But the price, the age of this device... I don't know.
😍😍Huawei 😍😍
Thank you for your review but can tell us if with the matepade paper we can write and make notes between lines and circles etc on the pdf format?
Does anyone know if the HuaweI can be used to write over a PDF ?
2:48 Hard tip is better for writing Chinese. Soft tip is a big nono.
Best 13" e-note? For writing, document creation, reading. (Don't care music, video etc)
I'd also love to know
@@mochi_JP
I can't find this answer in all the internet. I'll go crazy
Onyx boox max lumi 2 or BIGME x6
Those two will do you good
@@goodereader i can't understand fundamental things, such as, for example:
1) can you write by placing your palm on the screen? does the palm create a disturbance? ruin the screen etc?
2) how can you cancel? is it comfortable, fast?
3) while I'm writing what happens when the page ends and you want to turn the page? how fast is the "page turn"?
4) once I create a file, after it is saved, can I later delete a few lines of text or it is seen as an image? i mean: can I work on/ edit a text document I have previously created?
5) how long does the screen last? tends to get scratched/ruined writing for a long time?
6) is it possible to create folders and subfolders for created files?
7) is there a copy and paste function (to a document to another)?
8) you can open multiple tabs and browse them (like on android)?
9) can bookmarks be created in handwritten documents and books?
10) are there any functions to quickly export underlines or notes taken in a book?
I share the philosophy of the remarkable, just writing and reading, no browser, no app etc but, in my opinion, it's too small.
I am worried that other devices, having other functions, will lose something in the fundamental functions of writing and reading.
in the reviews you should show a lot more things, related to the actual use that would be made of the device.
in the end I would be more interested in an e-notebook and therefore to the functions inherent to this, rather than audio, video, etc.
@@gingerrabbit6286 im no professional whatsoever haha but Idk if they'll reply again or not as they're ofc a busy channel so I thought I might be able to help out alittle
the onyx boox max lumi 2 does have android and is more like a all arounder, it has it all and so does the big me as far as ik, also being the more expensive 13 inch device.
the fujitsu quaderno without android on the other hand has the best paper like writing feel I believe and costs like 770 or so and is therefore simply a note taking device and that's it
I hope I could help u out at least somewhat if that's what u r looking for I'd say take a look at the quaderno gen 2 but keep in mind that only for 'alittle' more money u could already get the max lumi 2 :)
what would you recommend from Huawei matepade and onyxboox note air 2 plus??
I wish huwawi had a better pen experience😐
Can anyone tell me when the MatePad Paper will actually be available for sale though?
both horrible. buy a tablet instead. ridiculous.
Lol welcome to the world of eink
LCD and e-paper cannot be compared
@@goodereader You are right. Instead of regretting my decision later on, I can charge the tablet once a day and do not deal with the eink complications.
I have the remarkable 1 and its the best electronic note taking device there is period. Ive started looking for a worthy successor but just like the MatePad, most products try do be a jack of all trades and in doing so the excell at nothing, i want to read and write maybe draw on an epaper device, i dont need audio i dont need to watch movies on it or play games i just want it to excell an these 2-3 things,... dont support the amazon kindle format? Dealbreaker, Glass display with no friction when writing? also Dealbreaker
can I use it in Ukraine?
yes, you can
Але там здається, нема кирилиці. Але може скоро завантажать.
Yeah just buy a tablet , this is stupidly overpriced for that "paper feel".Hint : use a notebook with real paper.
Wrong channel for you