Crystal Wong he did, but at the same time he didn't. He killed all the Time Lords and the Daleks but it turns out lots of Daleks survived and as he is still alive, it is not complete genocide
***** I am, and was when I made this comment, but I was referring to before they saved Gallifrey. Clearly you aren't capable of understanding my thought processes, are you?
Nowhere near the most telling. There are many who have no idea who the timelords are, but everybody everywhere knows the Doctor. Saying "I killed all the timelords" may not mean much to people, but saying "I am the Doctor, Google me" can even put carnivorous shadows in their place.
Conrad Jonsson no, I think that in reality, the Tardis is thousands of years old and he is well over a thousand himself, by now, just as Moffat said... after all, he’d been aboard her for over 500 years by the end of his 4th incarnation!
WiiNV whittaker is a really good actress, the problem is, of course, the writing. how could she possibly perform like this when there is no depth to the episodes?
techno156 can i just say i have never read any word that describes a sound more perfectly than what you just said. vworp vworp is exactly what she says.
The Tardis, his first love. The girl, that he snatched away. Stole her and ran off into adventure and spent his whole life with her. It's a magical love story, that transcends time and space. And in the end he even gets to marry her, or at least a part of her, when he marries River Song, who is the Tardis's child.
Terror Man No, River is Amy's and Rory's child and also metaphorically partially the TARDIS's child because the exposure to the time vortex has turned her partially into a Time Lord. The Doctor did NOT marry his own child...
+GorTesK And the Tardis even KNEW River was on the way.....Rory thinks Idris is delerious when she tries to tell him that "the only water in the forest is the river".....that is word for word what River says when she reveals she is Melody.
This explains why when Rose looked into the matrix everything she saw revolved around the doctor. The TARDIS loves the Doctor and that love engrained itself into Rose becoming the Bad Wolf and eventually The Moment. Which is why the Moment hears everything about the doctor too.
Rose absolutely is the moment, the bad wolf literally manifests within the moment (hence why her eyes glow with time energy when she says the words and why she can make time portals).
SamTheVole it wasn’t Rose nor Bad Wolf. It just assumed its form. if it was Rose/Bad Wolf, it would be similar to those glass people in “Twice Upon a Time”. it would have been her, but it just wasn’t.
@@emilythezeldafan848 I'm trying to determine if you mean the episode where they go through that crashed spaceship with the weeping angels or a later episode
"please...I don't want you to..." in this, he is so young. just a young creature whose hearts are aching. but then in an *instant*, when he is sniffling, oh what a very old man he is. so very, very old in that shot. must pick yourself up and pretend to walk forward again. thank you Matt Smith, for being the very first and so far the only to get me to believe how simultaneously young and old the Doctor is. He's hundreds of years old in this scene - and I believe it. The Doctor and his forever companion.
while I agree that Matt is a great actor, I will say I take away the way he portrays the Doctor differently. I don't see him as actually being young still. He lost that in the Time War. Instead I see him yearning to be young again. The way he dresses oddly. While Tennant and Eccelston dressed a little more normally, Matt Smith wears a bow tie and a fez. Which is more similar to classic Doctors like Baker. Especially Baker who was at times very childish. Him crying for the TARDIS isn't him being childish, I think it is more him realising just how much he is that is due to the TARDIS. At least that's my take on it.
The biggest reason I find this so heart-breaking is that The Doctor knows how alone he is and always will be. Everyone always eventually dies, a part from the Tardis. Her being alive and speaking meant that he could have a companion forever with him and because she became someone who could never speak to him again it just broke his heart.
And yet she is still there, still the same lovely grand lady who has taken him everywhere he's needed to be. Still... such banter between the two. Like an old married couple really.
For me, what Matt Smith does with his jaw after she leaves him is what gets me the most. He just has to swallow this loss. He has no choice. He just has to swallow it, and live with this pain, and this loss, the rest of his life. I don't know why but what he does with his jaw is so incredibly emotive to me.
Yeah it is. But somehow it's still a loss. The fact that she says "this is when we talked", he knows he will never be able to communicate with her again. He knows that there is so much he could have asked, but now has lost that opportunity forever. Until they retconn it and have her say "when I said "We" I meant that version of you" lol
I should hope he can emote with his jaw there's fuckin loads of it (Just jokes i love 11, 10 was my favourite and IMO no one else except Matt could've followed that)
i know what you mean, it's those little details that Matt always puts into his performance that just,,,get to me and make me so attached to his doctor. he makes the doctors age and centuries of experience with loss so palpable
That and the chin wobbling are what REALLY get to me. Every now and then I come back to this scene and the SECOND he starts to fall apart, I'm a sobbing mess. Killer acting from both Matt and Suranne, and still one of the best scenes of the whole show for me.
The Tardis exists throughout all of time and space so when she says "This is when we talked" she's not just referring to present Doctor... she's talking about all of them. A lot of comments are saying she's known the doctor for X amount of years but the Tardis/Idris knows every Doctor that's been, and every Doctor that's to come and it's just sadder when you think about it like that.
This is the other thing about "I just wanted to say hello." For her, it's that moment, but simultaneously, it's also the first moment she met him. She hasn't been waiting a thousand years to say that. She's been saying it throughout time. This was just the moment the Doctor heard it.
@@pareidolist Doctor - "You don't always take me where I want to go." Sexy (TARDIS) - "No, but I have always taken you where you need to go." She doesn't care what the Doctor wants, because deep down She knows what he wants. So She gives him what he needs, precisely when he needs it.
Here I am, a 63-year-old retired man who watches this scene over and over and never fails to wipe away a tear and get all sniffly, like The Doctor. Superb, and what makes the show so compelling. Now onto the video where Capaldi leans over to River Song and says, "Hello, Sweetie."
38 and I do the same buddy. The 'you can have it all!!' Speach from rings of akheten is another good one...too many to count. Dr who is just so damn epic at times.
"I'll always be here but this is when we talked..." always hits me so hard. For the Tardis to know this is the only time she gets to speak with the Doctor and for her to cherish it this much, it just hurts.
If you STILL think Matt Smith is a bad actor, or a bad Doctor, then give this scene a re-watch. No, give this episode a re-watch, because Neil Gaiman poured his heart and soul into this script. A truly amazing episode, the best of Series 6 for sure.
@@Discrimination_is_not_a_right I dont think hes a great actor and hes certainly not my favourite Doctor,, but episodes like this bring me back every time - and you're right, discrimination is not right!
@@lewisfraser4153 matt Smith is the only doctor to correctly portray how ancient and sad the doctor really is. Watch the speech in the rings of akahaten(excuse the spelling)
Matt Smith is most certainly not a bad actor. He IS a good one, but he is not excellent. He is wonderful when it comes to emotional scenes.. but when it comes to threats and intimidating.. he just.. can't..
Thinking on the other Doctors, I find it hard to imagine any of the others delivering it so well. They all had their moments and this was one of Matt Smith's.
When his voice wobbles on “you took her from her home” I got legit goosebumps; and then the subsequent sequence just makes this one of my all time favourite scenes from the show
This was one of the best Doctor Who Episodes in the history of the series, and a great piece by Neil Gaiman. This scene in particular is so moving. For the first time we are all shown the relationship of the TARDIS and The Doctor from her point of view, which was compelling and heartbreaking. My favorite quote from the episode, however, is from The TARDIS when she asks, "Are people always like this... Bigger on the inside?"
For my money THE best episode of Matt Smith's tenure. The sadness of this scene where he realises he won't be able to speak to the Tardis in this way again coupled with the gratitude and love he feels when he realises how profoundly it has helped shape and steer his life not just his journey really gripped me.
still... the body was sort of absorbed or something... maybe she stored it for later and we'll get to see the TARDIS speak again... suppose not though... I really liked her!
Eline Teune Now that we know the TARDIS is capable of creating a holographic interface in the form of people who enter the box, and that the interface can hold conversations, it's possible we might see Idris become the interface for the Doctor/Clara/someone else. :D
:-) I don't really mind what kind of face she gives herself... as long as they talk to each other again, it was so adorable to watch... like seeying a weird married couple :-)
"Fear me. I killed hundreds of TimeLords." Fear me. I killed all of them.
9 лет назад+9
+Jebediah Kerman Technically he should have said "I killed the rest" the simple fact that just one other time lord was killed by someone else negates the fact that he could have killed all of them. That being said this is one of my favourite quotes...
"Look at my girl!!! Look at her Go!! Bigger on the Inside" "See house? that's your problem, the size of a planet but, inside... You! Are! Just! So! Small!!!" *"Finish him off girl"* And at the end, I didn't realize that she whispers to him "I love you", I love how they portrayed the relationship between the dr and the t.a.r.d.i.s, they saved and stole each other. And if you think about it, basically they have been together through all of time and space.
Guys, look at his hand placement at 3:35. Those are the positions of both of his hearts. All throughout time and space and those adventures, it's always been the Doctor and the Tardis. He's literally holding himself together after that awful loss!!! *cries for 900 years*
It also killed off hundreds of time lords, some of whom were friends. And it was about to do the same to the Doctor, his sexy, and his companions, Amy and Mr. Pond!
Papa Acachalla so true, and out of all of the traveling companions and even besides River Song who is/was his wife at one time the Tardis is his second true love I want to say
For anyone wondering what the theme is that plays at 2:05 when Matt is talking to the TARDIS for the last time the score is called "The Impossible Astronaut". It's one of the most beautiful themes in the franchise and I'd figure I'd share it since I know a lot of people love the theme.
Harry Kenway I think you'll find that all 13 incarnations of the Doctor had a hand in that. Remember, he's still just one person. It's the viewer that thinks of his regenerations as being separate people.
Matt's acting here is awesome. The way he conveys pain during the final moments he has talking with the TARDIS. One of my fave Smith moments. He just encapsulates the character so damn well. MY doctor.
You know with all that romance stuff with Rose Tyler and River Song, I forget that the TARDIS is the Doctor's one true love. The others come and go but she stays and never leaves his side. Side note: I'd love for Suranne Jones to be a future Doctor. The thought of the Doctor recognising the fact that she gets to see Idris again in some for is so gratifying.
T: I've been looking for a word. A big complicated word. But so sad. I found it now. D: What word? T: Alive! I'm ALIVE D: Alive isn't sad T: It's sad when it's over So true
+Paola Gisselle Mejia I am sorry but just give me a minute, because that is cool as fk
9 лет назад+1
+Paola Gisselle Mejia Technically he should have said "I killed the rest" the simple fact that just one other time lord was killed by someone else negates the fact that he could have killed all of them. That being said this is one of my favourite quotes...
How it must have felt after having so many young companions, to finally speak with and connect with someone who has literally been with him since the very beginning. Someone who has been through and 'understands' where he has been, how long he has travelled and what he has done and been doing. I think that is what makes this scene so very sad. After all it could be said that she was his very 'first' companion and the only one that has stayed. His Tardis. His Sexy. God, that nickname kills me every time. xD
It was not shown then but in the later seasons, the Tardis has found a way to communicate with him. He actually talks to Tardis, in fact, he often argues with the Tardis. There was a time when he wanted to die as Peter Capaldi and Tardis kept trying to convince that the universe needed him. They went back and forth for a while. Even Jodie argues with the Tardis
The TARDIS...... She's alive..... I completely forgot about this episode and this scene is so emotional. The very first time the tardis got to talk to the doctor. 900 years. The way he breaks down after she goes back into the box.
"fear me, I've killed all of them" - chilling line. I've wondered why he changes tone so quickly, but maybe House isn't intended to hear that, a little aside to himself, or us.
She did. Apparently, the original line, according to a Doctor Who magazine, was supposed to be "I love you. And I forgive you. Always." or something along those lines.
900 years the Tardis has been waiting to tell the Doctor that it/she cannot live without him, a normally inanimate object was given life for a short time and in that time we saw the soul of the one constant in the entire show, the one thing that has been there from the start and has never changed - The blue box. For so long the communication has been one way, we know the doctor feels empty without the tardis and views it as more than just a machine, but on this one occasion we saw that little blue box has always felt the same way about it's pilot. It is here that he knows no matter how hard things get, no matter how desperate, that he will never truly be alone. The Tardis will always protect him, she will always protect her 'thief' and whatever comes their way, they endure it together.
How exquisitely painful this was to watch... That beautiful moment where one's heart is shredded in the most lovely fashion where one can not help but say thank you for it even though it's perfectly counter-intuitive to be grateful for such stunning pain. Only the marriage of the best of the best ensemble of actors, writers and crew can pull off such a bouquet of bittersweet. It's rare and lovely and utterly rips your heart into teeny tiny little bloody confetti to scatter at the artists' feet. Thank you for posting it. Along with all the other moment of the modern Doctor Who.
This scene is everything that makes Neil Gaiman great. It has the grand scope, the amazing concepts and the big moments that make you cheer but also the small, human moments that make you cry.
God, this is my favorite episode from Matt Smith's era, and that's saying a lot, because I love a lot of them. But this one gets me everytime. There's so many great scenes, some funny, others delightful, and also some truly terrifying. And of course, the melancholy and sadness that goes with the Doctor. Neil Gaiman really wrote a gem. The way he explored the relationship between the Doctor and the Tardis is JUST one episode, and so well at that, it gets me everytime. I love everything about it.
This episode was brilliant and beautiful and heart breaking. Neil outdid himself on the writing and the actors brought it to life wonderfully. Watching this again tonight after watching Sandman. Well done.
Watched like ten seconds of this... and now I'm on my way back to the episode just for the music... and the feels, of course. One of the very best episodes! Heart-breaking, though...
I love how in the end she greets him instead of saying goodbye because she knows the Doctor doesn't like endings.
I FORGOT THAT PART NOW IT'S EVEN MORE DIFFICULT TO BARE
Oh you Got me
And she isn’t really dead.!
And it isn’t really there ending, because she will see him again, every time he enters the Tardis
She already said goodbye when she first met him but as she said she always gets the order wrong
"Fear me, I've killed hundreds of Time Lords"
"Fear me, I've killed all of them"
says it all really
Doctor Who is a show where the villains threaten genocide and the main character thinks he's committed genocide
Crystal Wong he did, but at the same time he didn't. He killed all the Time Lords and the Daleks but it turns out lots of Daleks survived and as he is still alive, it is not complete genocide
***** I am, and was when I made this comment, but I was referring to before they saved Gallifrey. Clearly you aren't capable of understanding my thought processes, are you?
Nowhere near the most telling. There are many who have no idea who the timelords are, but everybody everywhere knows the Doctor. Saying "I killed all the timelords" may not mean much to people, but saying "I am the Doctor, Google me" can even put carnivorous shadows in their place.
@@britishman5300 U r mentally bad? Do you even english? The hell does calling someone mentally bad mean?
"Fear me, I killed all of them." I love that line.
He said that with so much sass
Yeah, kind of a shame it's revelaed that he didn't
Kask Daxxe At the time he believed he had.
Kask Daxxe SH-SH-SH-SH-SH-SH-SH-SH
Technically he did kill of them. Locking them in time for and in a variable point of time, forever. Technically, yeah. He did kill them.
She spent over 1,000 years waiting to say hello to him.
Ryan Stone 700 actually. that is what she says. and the doctor does not know his age as he keeps mentioning. the Tardis probably know better
Conrad Jonsson no, I think that in reality, the Tardis is thousands of years old and he is well over a thousand himself, by now, just as Moffat said... after all, he’d been aboard her for over 500 years by the end of his 4th incarnation!
(Already crying, reads this and cries even harder)
Conrad Jonsson however long she waited, it’s still so beautiful she just wanted to say hello
how old was the doctor when he first entered the tardis? I heard he was around 300 years old at that time, but im not sure.
In 3:30 I never knew the Tardis said "I Love You" to the doctor she whispered it so low that I never really heard it
***** yeah it really makes this scene even more sad but more beautiful also it show how strong the connection the tardis and the doctor has
Omg I just notice now...
ScRreaМz Damn! Even I just noticed that
BREAK MY HEART EVEN MORE WHY DONT YOU!!!
I never caught that till you pointed it out.
I love Matt's acting in this. He goes from victorious and giving House a beating and then totally emotional. His reactions to Idris are perfect
+Phoenix 24 omg when he said "No, I don't want you to!" he sounded so sad and I just want to hug him
i know right! Amazing actor, amazing doctor! I love the way he acts so much!
I agree. I also liked the acting of Suranne/Idris and liked their chemistry.
A Depth beyond Whittaker!
WiiNV whittaker is a really good actress, the problem is, of course, the writing. how could she possibly perform like this when there is no depth to the episodes?
"Alive isn't sad"
"It is when it's over."
That's an understatement if I ever heard one...
Kind of deep.
"Nothing's sad till it's over. Then everything is."
“Everything ends... and that’s always sad. But... everything begins again. And that’s... always happy.”
And thus, how to make a scene between A NORMALLY SILENT OBJECT and a Timelord, into a sad one.
That's normal; it's sad anyway, but this is SUPER MONDO sad.
techno156 can i just say i have never read any word that describes a sound more perfectly than what you just said. vworp vworp is exactly what she says.
Hey, they make you feel sorry for a salt shaker.
The tardis is never silent. Sometimes she makes that scraping screechy noise when taking off and landing.
@@mushroomhead3619 also it means the tardis is alive not an object
The Tardis, his first love. The girl, that he snatched away. Stole her and ran off into adventure and spent his whole life with her.
It's a magical love story, that transcends time and space.
And in the end he even gets to marry her, or at least a part of her, when he marries River Song, who is the Tardis's child.
+GorTesK Thank you for that, I needed it
So the doctor marries his own child?
Terror Man
No, River is Amy's and Rory's child and also metaphorically partially the TARDIS's child because the exposure to the time vortex has turned her partially into a Time Lord. The Doctor did NOT marry his own child...
+GorTesK i kind of thougth she was like a adoptive mother to him but oh well?
+GorTesK And the Tardis even KNEW River was on the way.....Rory thinks Idris is delerious when she tries to tell him that "the only water in the forest is the river".....that is word for word what River says when she reveals she is Melody.
This explains why when Rose looked into the matrix everything she saw revolved around the doctor. The TARDIS loves the Doctor and that love engrained itself into Rose becoming the Bad Wolf and eventually The Moment. Which is why the Moment hears everything about the doctor too.
Rose isn't the Moment. The Moment simply took Rose's form.
Rose absolutely is the moment, the bad wolf literally manifests within the moment (hence why her eyes glow with time energy when she says the words and why she can make time portals).
@@samthevole The Moment only took the physical appearance of The Bad Wolf but it wasn't actually her.
SamTheVole it wasn’t Rose nor Bad Wolf. It just assumed its form. if it was Rose/Bad Wolf, it would be similar to those glass people in “Twice Upon a Time”. it would have been her, but it just wasn’t.
The moment has a consciousness and is telepathic. It saw rose and the bad wolf in the doctors future and took that form.
"I don't understand, there isn't a forest in here." Foreshadowing at it's finest.
the only water in the forest is the *River*
I feel like a disappointment cuz I can't connect what it's foreshadowing
@@Ultima_Prime the River Song thing-
@@emilythezeldafan848 I'm trying to determine if you mean the episode where they go through that crashed spaceship with the weeping angels or a later episode
@@Ultima_Prime i was talking about her identity reveal during a good man goes to war (sorry I didn't get to this, overslept nd now I feel crappy-)
"please...I don't want you to..." in this, he is so young. just a young creature whose hearts are aching.
but then in an *instant*, when he is sniffling, oh what a very old man he is. so very, very old in that shot. must pick yourself up and pretend to walk forward again.
thank you Matt Smith, for being the very first and so far the only to get me to believe how simultaneously young and old the Doctor is. He's hundreds of years old in this scene - and I believe it.
The Doctor and his forever companion.
Renee Baker Matt Smith is a magnificient actor
Like his TARDIS, he is both young and old.
You can hear her say "i love you" as she fades away
@@paul_scaryback666 oh my god I never noticed that thanks for pointing it out
while I agree that Matt is a great actor, I will say I take away the way he portrays the Doctor differently. I don't see him as actually being young still. He lost that in the Time War. Instead I see him yearning to be young again. The way he dresses oddly. While Tennant and Eccelston dressed a little more normally, Matt Smith wears a bow tie and a fez. Which is more similar to classic Doctors like Baker. Especially Baker who was at times very childish. Him crying for the TARDIS isn't him being childish, I think it is more him realising just how much he is that is due to the TARDIS.
At least that's my take on it.
The biggest reason I find this so heart-breaking is that The Doctor knows how alone he is and always will be. Everyone always eventually dies, a part from the Tardis. Her being alive and speaking meant that he could have a companion forever with him and because she became someone who could never speak to him again it just broke his heart.
And yet she is still there, still the same lovely grand lady who has taken him everywhere he's needed to be.
Still... such banter between the two. Like an old married couple really.
The Old Girl is always there. His greatest companion.
Beautifully said! 😪🥰
clear conversation with her at the time of the 12....
See, where is the shard of this for Timeless Child? Jodi would have been great at mourning the loss of mortality if only the writing had gotten there.
Who would have ever imagined that a "hello" could be infinitely more heartbreaking than a "goodbye"?
She wanted to have a voice, to talk to him. She is not leaving, no one is leaving so "Hello." is PERFECT
If you listen carefully when she disappears back into the TARDIS completely you can hear her whisper "I love you".
“… Hello, sweetie.”
The same people who imagined episodes coming out in 2024 would supersede episodes coming out in 1960
For me, what Matt Smith does with his jaw after she leaves him is what gets me the most.
He just has to swallow this loss. He has no choice. He just has to swallow it, and live with this pain, and this loss, the rest of his life. I don't know why but what he does with his jaw is so incredibly emotive to me.
Yeah it is. But somehow it's still a loss. The fact that she says "this is when we talked", he knows he will never be able to communicate with her again. He knows that there is so much he could have asked, but now has lost that opportunity forever.
Until they retconn it and have her say "when I said "We" I meant that version of you" lol
Trik Stari
The Doctor actually reworks the TARDIS console so she can communicate.
I should hope he can emote with his jaw there's fuckin loads of it
(Just jokes i love 11, 10 was my favourite and IMO no one else except Matt could've followed that)
i know what you mean, it's those little details that Matt always puts into his performance that just,,,get to me and make me so attached to his doctor. he makes the doctors age and centuries of experience with loss so palpable
That and the chin wobbling are what REALLY get to me.
Every now and then I come back to this scene and the SECOND he starts to fall apart, I'm a sobbing mess. Killer acting from both Matt and Suranne, and still one of the best scenes of the whole show for me.
The Tardis exists throughout all of time and space so when she says "This is when we talked" she's not just referring to present Doctor... she's talking about all of them. A lot of comments are saying she's known the doctor for X amount of years but the Tardis/Idris knows every Doctor that's been, and every Doctor that's to come and it's just sadder when you think about it like that.
This is the other thing about "I just wanted to say hello." For her, it's that moment, but simultaneously, it's also the first moment she met him. She hasn't been waiting a thousand years to say that. She's been saying it throughout time. This was just the moment the Doctor heard it.
@@pareidolist
Doctor - "You don't always take me where I want to go."
Sexy (TARDIS) - "No, but I have always taken you where you need to go."
She doesn't care what the Doctor wants, because deep down She knows what he wants. So She gives him what he needs, precisely when he needs it.
@@wanderinwolf3804 It's not about doing what he wants. It's about taking him where he's needed. Often, that isn't where he wants to go at all!
Here I am, a 63-year-old retired man who watches this scene over and over and never fails to wipe away a tear and get all sniffly, like The Doctor. Superb, and what makes the show so compelling. Now onto the video where Capaldi leans over to River Song and says, "Hello, Sweetie."
John White it’s a great scene!
It's really really okay to cry!
38 and I do the same buddy.
The 'you can have it all!!' Speach from rings of akheten is another good one...too many to count. Dr who is just so damn epic at times.
Did you watch the original doctor who?
70 now aye?
Lord, the delivery on that line at 1:13, "You took her from her home." So much emotion packed in six words!
>So much emotion packed in six words!
Even more than: "Don't you think she looks tired?"
"Finish him off, girl!"
"I'll always be here but this is when we talked..." always hits me so hard. For the Tardis to know this is the only time she gets to speak with the Doctor and for her to cherish it this much, it just hurts.
If you STILL think Matt Smith is a bad actor, or a bad Doctor, then give this scene a re-watch. No, give this episode a re-watch, because Neil Gaiman poured his heart and soul into this script. A truly amazing episode, the best of Series 6 for sure.
How anyone can think he's a bad actor is beyond me.
@@Discrimination_is_not_a_right I dont think hes a great actor and hes certainly not my favourite Doctor,, but episodes like this bring me back every time - and you're right, discrimination is not right!
@@lewisfraser4153 matt Smith is the only doctor to correctly portray how ancient and sad the doctor really is. Watch the speech in the rings of akahaten(excuse the spelling)
Matt Smith is most certainly not a bad actor. He IS a good one, but he is not excellent. He is wonderful when it comes to emotional scenes.. but when it comes to threats and intimidating.. he just.. can't..
Matt Smith is my favorite doctor
''See house, that's your problem: Size of a planet but inside you are JUST... SO... SMALL''
Matt's delivery of that line was... perfect.
I love how you can read the rage in doctor at this point but he still turns in remorse as he knows he's taking a life. Subtle but beautiful.
And it contrasted perfectly with the line Idris/the TARDIS said earlier in the episode… “are people always like this? So much bigger on the inside?”
Thinking on the other Doctors, I find it hard to imagine any of the others delivering it so well. They all had their moments and this was one of Matt Smith's.
That "hello" line gets every time
Sadder still when she says ' I love you'
When his voice wobbles on “you took her from her home” I got legit goosebumps; and then the subsequent sequence just makes this one of my all time favourite scenes from the show
This was one of the best Doctor Who Episodes in the history of the series, and a great piece by Neil Gaiman. This scene in particular is so moving. For the first time we are all shown the relationship of the TARDIS and The Doctor from her point of view, which was compelling and heartbreaking. My favorite quote from the episode, however, is from The TARDIS when she asks, "Are people always like this... Bigger on the inside?"
For my money THE best episode of Matt Smith's tenure. The sadness of this scene where he realises he won't be able to speak to the Tardis in this way again coupled with the gratitude and love he feels when he realises how profoundly it has helped shape and steer his life not just his journey really gripped me.
still... the body was sort of absorbed or something... maybe she stored it for later and we'll get to see the TARDIS speak again... suppose not though... I really liked her!
Eline Teune Now that we know the TARDIS is capable of creating a holographic interface in the form of people who enter the box, and that the interface can hold conversations, it's possible we might see Idris become the interface for the Doctor/Clara/someone else. :D
:-) I don't really mind what kind of face she gives herself... as long as they talk to each other again, it was so adorable to watch... like seeying a weird married couple :-)
"Fear me. I killed hundreds of TimeLords."
Fear me. I killed all of them.
+Jebediah Kerman Technically he should have said "I killed the rest" the simple fact that just one other time lord was killed by someone else negates the fact that he could have killed all of them.
That being said this is one of my favourite quotes...
The doctor lies
Every time you see them happy, you remember how sad they're going to be.
And it breaks your heart.
Nice use of the quote from 'The Doctor, the widow and the wardrobe' :)
Just a friendly reminder that the crying was all Matt here, Gaiman didn't put it in the script.
Except they reshot this scene many times.
@@Golftimetoday So it was scripted in the end
1:44 - "Finish him off, girl". that was 10th dealing with the Family of Blood, lurking in 11th subconscious.
This was my absolute favourite episode with Matt :') This part makes me cry every time x'D
***** you mean wait for it exterminentary
your a whovien why didn't i know this XD
It's hay fever time, yes, that's it, that's all it is, really...I'M NOT CRYING!
@@lucyb6793 learn how to spell and maybe next time I will.
"Alive isn't sad."
"It's sad when it's over."
Those 2 lines always kill me
"Look at my girl!!! Look at her Go!! Bigger on the Inside"
"See house? that's your problem, the size of a planet but, inside... You! Are! Just! So! Small!!!"
*"Finish him off girl"*
And at the end, I didn't realize that she whispers to him "I love you", I love how they portrayed the relationship between the dr and the t.a.r.d.i.s, they saved and stole each other. And if you think about it, basically they have been together through all of time and space.
I loved how they personified the Tardis.
Hell, I love any episode that uses the Tardis as the main plot.
Ikr?! Not utilized enough
3:14 that little "Please... I don't want you to..." gETS ME EVERY TIME ;-;
Ooh I never noticed the "I love you" part!!! SHE SAYS IT! 3:29
Wow I never noticed that either, thanks for pointing it out!
She was able to get out the words the Doctor never could
wow! thanks for that! I thought she was gonna say that before, as her last words that "never got to tell him"
how didn't notice that till now either thx
Why would you do this to me?
#TheFeelsOfTrenzalore
Guys, look at his hand placement at 3:35. Those are the positions of both of his hearts. All throughout time and space and those adventures, it's always been the Doctor and the Tardis. He's literally holding himself together after that awful loss!!! *cries for 900 years*
"finish him off, girl!" wow... the doctor can be ruthless when they touch "his sexy"
Those who harm ANYONE he cares about -- TARDIS or otherwise -- soon learn how ruthless he can be.
NEVER piss off the Doctor.
@@julietfischer5056 The family of blood
It also killed off hundreds of time lords, some of whom were friends. And it was about to do the same to the Doctor, his sexy, and his companions, Amy and Mr. Pond!
Never piss of Sexy. She does so love her bohemian.l.
Could be a wrong decision.
3:32 The TARDIS said "I love you"
I had never heard that before!
Papa Acachalla omg, it's so quiet, but it's there. It made it 100% sadder... :(
Papa Acachalla and when the lever goes down, a second before the Doctor begins laughing, you can listen the TARDIS' laugh also
Papa Acachalla i heard it the first time and was like oh my goddd :( think i heard it the first time though because i wanted her to say it
Papa Acachalla so true, and out of all of the traveling companions and even besides River Song who is/was his wife at one time the Tardis is his second true love I want to say
I wanted to run away, so I stole a Time Lord...
The Missus Robinson of TARDISes
0:02 - 0:16 ''The only source of water in the forest is the river...''
no-one else in the comments noticed she's giving him rivers name
gohanmoreno7 when I first saw this episode I remembered that line and I didn't know why but it stuck with me up until River's reveal
If this scene is playing within my vicinity and I'm not crying, check for a pulse.
And to think, I never realized how beautiful the Tardis was until now....
For anyone wondering what the theme is that plays at 2:05 when Matt is talking to the TARDIS for the last time the score is called "The Impossible Astronaut". It's one of the most beautiful themes in the franchise and I'd figure I'd share it since I know a lot of people love the theme.
Hi sorry, do you also know the song that plays at the start with at like 0:08 I can’t find it anywere
12: I killed all of them, brought them back, then told Rassilon to get off my planet. What did you do?
I farted on a crowded elevator once .
And you killed all of them ?
MsSharondenadel 😂😂😂
Actually 11 himself brought them back?
Harry Kenway I think you'll find that all 13 incarnations of the Doctor had a hand in that. Remember, he's still just one person. It's the viewer that thinks of his regenerations as being separate people.
There are very few times the Doctor shows anger, this is one of those times and it's beautiful.
Leave it to Neil Gaiman to give a voice to the character that was always there, but always ignored. Brilliant episode.
One of the most emotionally powerful scenes in all of Doctor Who. And just all around best episodes of Doctor Who ever made. Seriously so good.
Matt's acting here is awesome. The way he conveys pain during the final moments he has talking with the TARDIS. One of my fave Smith moments. He just encapsulates the character so damn well. MY doctor.
the best line in this episode is still from Amy when the Doctor shows her the human Tardis and she said "did you wish really really hard?"
It's enough to make a grown man cry, but not this man get back in their tear.
You know with all that romance stuff with Rose Tyler and River Song, I forget that the TARDIS is the Doctor's one true love. The others come and go but she stays and never leaves his side.
Side note: I'd love for Suranne Jones to be a future Doctor. The thought of the Doctor recognising the fact that she gets to see Idris again in some for is so gratifying.
T: I've been looking for a word. A big complicated word. But so sad.
I found it now.
D: What word?
T: Alive! I'm ALIVE
D: Alive isn't sad
T: It's sad when it's over
So true
"Fear me I've killed thousands of time-lords"
"Fear me I've Killed all of them" 😂😂😂
+Paola Gisselle Mejia I am sorry but just give me a minute, because that is cool as fk
+Paola Gisselle Mejia Technically he should have said "I killed the rest" the simple fact that just one other time lord was killed by someone else negates the fact that he could have killed all of them.
That being said this is one of my favourite quotes...
+Tristan Lane give a rest..spend your time better.
One of the most tear jerking scenes in 11's run.
Breaks my heart every time. The Doctor’s truest companion...
How it must have felt after having so many young companions, to finally speak with and connect with someone who has literally been with him since the very beginning. Someone who has been through and 'understands' where he has been, how long he has travelled and what he has done and been doing. I think that is what makes this scene so very sad. After all it could be said that she was his very 'first' companion and the only one that has stayed. His Tardis. His Sexy. God, that nickname kills me every time. xD
The Moment confronting the Doctor "Why did you park so far away? Is it so the TARDIS won't hear you?"
It was not shown then but in the later seasons, the Tardis has found a way to communicate with him. He actually talks to Tardis, in fact, he often argues with the Tardis. There was a time when he wanted to die as Peter Capaldi and Tardis kept trying to convince that the universe needed him. They went back and forth for a while. Even Jodie argues with the Tardis
A sassy Type 30 who always took him where he _needed_ to be.
You never took me where I wanted to go...
No but I always took you where you needed to be...
Such a grand lady. He's lucky to have her really.
The TARDIS...... She's alive..... I completely forgot about this episode and this scene is so emotional. The very first time the tardis got to talk to the doctor. 900 years. The way he breaks down after she goes back into the box.
Did anybody else hear her whisper "I love you" before she disappeared completely?
I never noticed until just now when wearing my headphones that she whispers "I love you" before she fades away. 😭
WHY DID I CLICK ON THIS? I just barely saw the thumbnail and teared up. Now I'm a damn river.
A river in a forest? :)
a River Song? :-P
Why not cry for two Ponds?
Such a sad yet tenderly sweet scene.
Wonderful acting by Suranne Jones (Idris/the Tardis) and Matt Smith (the Doctor).
Picturing inside the studio during voice acting. Especially around 1:24 until the epic, "GAAAAAAHHHH!!!"
"fear me, I've killed all of them" - chilling line.
I've wondered why he changes tone so quickly, but maybe House isn't intended to hear that, a little aside to himself, or us.
3:36 He's holding both of his hearts.
BY GOD YOU ARE RIGHT
Jesus, i never noticed that
Thanks, not like I needed mine or anything...
Doctor - "Alive isn't sad"
TARDIS - "It's sad when it's over"
Never a truer line spoken
Did the TARDIS say at 3:30 "I love you" or did I mishear it?
She did.
Apparently, the original line, according to a Doctor Who magazine, was supposed to be "I love you. And I forgive you. Always." or something along those lines.
Jamestopboy Yes, after the "I love you", we can hear the beginning of the "And...".
Jamestopboy Yes, after the "I love you", we can hear the beginning of the "And...".
I don't believe it was abusive; she's a living thing... inside a console... and the console just got bashed.
@@Jamestopboy forgive for what, i just wonder
I love that the tardis is talking to Rory about River. River/Melody was conceived within the Tardis making her almost like her own child
His most faithful companion, never failed never left, always there in the dark.
I think this is the best cast the series ever had. All the actors just shine so brightly here.
"Fear me i have killed hundreds of time lords" "fear me i have killed all of them" heart breaks into a million billion pieces
“Alive isn’t a sad word.”
“It’s sad when it’s over.”
That didn’t hit me until recently
A special moment for the Doctor himself but also an opportunity for his companions to get a glimpse of the inner man. Nicely done.
i've watched this countless times and only just noticed that as she fades away you can hear her say "I love you".
900 years the Tardis has been waiting to tell the Doctor that it/she cannot live without him, a normally inanimate object was given life for a short time and in that time we saw the soul of the one constant in the entire show, the one thing that has been there from the start and has never changed - The blue box.
For so long the communication has been one way, we know the doctor feels empty without the tardis and views it as more than just a machine, but on this one occasion we saw that little blue box has always felt the same way about it's pilot. It is here that he knows no matter how hard things get, no matter how desperate, that he will never truly be alone. The Tardis will always protect him, she will always protect her 'thief' and whatever comes their way, they endure it together.
She has literally spent an eternity, watching over them all, finally she had the chance to offer comfort to him
"Alive isnt sad"
"It is when its over"
-Cut to Rory breaking
''Bigger on the inside!!''
best its ever been said
How exquisitely painful this was to watch... That beautiful moment where one's heart is shredded in the most lovely fashion where one can not help but say thank you for it even though it's perfectly counter-intuitive to be grateful for such stunning pain.
Only the marriage of the best of the best ensemble of actors, writers and crew can pull off such a bouquet of bittersweet. It's rare and lovely and utterly rips your heart into teeny tiny little bloody confetti to scatter at the artists' feet.
Thank you for posting it. Along with all the other moment of the modern Doctor Who.
This scene is everything that makes Neil Gaiman great. It has the grand scope, the amazing concepts and the big moments that make you cheer but also the small, human moments that make you cry.
'Doctor are you there?'
'Yes my love'.
3:29, never noticed before... listen close "i...love...you"
my heart melted when she's said her final words "I LOVE YOU".
ok that click here to subscribe thing at the end is probably one of the coolest outro's I've ever seen
You have to upload the speech of Akhaten !
Part of it is up now just in case you haven't seen it yet.
Those beet red glassy eyes at 3:35. Great acting. Matt Smith was a great Doctor.
The amount of times I've seen this episode and I've only just realised she whispers "I love you" as she disintegrates!
"Fear me I've killed hundreds of Time Lords"
Dr: "Fear me I've killed all of them"
that my friends is highest of bitch slaps!!
God, this is my favorite episode from Matt Smith's era, and that's saying a lot, because I love a lot of them. But this one gets me everytime. There's so many great scenes, some funny, others delightful, and also some truly terrifying. And of course, the melancholy and sadness that goes with the Doctor. Neil Gaiman really wrote a gem. The way he explored the relationship between the Doctor and the Tardis is JUST one episode, and so well at that, it gets me everytime. I love everything about it.
0:14 SHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT THIS?!!!!
It was reference to the People of the Forest working as a Military in the plot to have River Song kill the Doctor.
"Finish him off girl!"
I like that...
That fading "I love you..." as she disappeared into thin air at 3:30.
Oh my. (clutches chest in melancholy)
*sobs perhaps disproportionately to the video clip* Oh my word, this episode! Right in the feels!
This episode was brilliant and beautiful and heart breaking. Neil outdid himself on the writing and the actors brought it to life wonderfully. Watching this again tonight after watching Sandman. Well done.
I still can't believe that House was voiced by Michael Sheen.
Bro, the Doctor's trembling lip when she say finally got to say "Hello"
I swear someone had to be cutting onions.
"Size of a planet but inside you are just so small!" Loved that line
This was so beautiful. So well done. So well performed. She also was AMAZING in human form!
Watched like ten seconds of this... and now I'm on my way back to the episode just for the music... and the feels, of course. One of the very best episodes! Heart-breaking, though...
1:22-1:56 One of the most satisfying villain deaths. ever. 1:46-1:56 especially.