Why Germany is Souring on Immigration
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 ноя 2023
- Get Nebula for just $2.50 a month: go.nebula.tv/tldrnewseu
Germany's governing coalition appears to have made a screeching u-turn over migration with their new restrictions and push for more deportations. So in this video, we'll break down their shifting policies on immigration and politics behind this decision.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
🗣 Discord: tldrnews.co.uk/discord
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahEFmsW1yGTNEYXA
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk/funding
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
////////////////////////////
1 - www.politico.eu/article/angel...
2 - eu.boell.org/en/2021/12/16/as...
3 - www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/7...
4 - www.statista.com/statistics/8...
5 - www.dw.com/en/germany-immigra...
6 - www.destatis.de/DE/Themen/Ges...
7 - eu.boell.org/sites/default/fi...
8 - www.bamf.de/SharedDocs/Meldun...
9 - www.bbc.com/news/world-europe...
10 - www.voanews.com/a/germany-tou...
11 - www.dw.com/en/migration-germa...
12 - www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/germa...
13 - www.theguardian.com/world/202...
14 - www.politico.eu/europe-poll-o...
15 - www.theguardian.com/world/201...
16 - www.dw.com/en/germany-cdu-urg...
17 - www.infratest-dimap.de/umfrag...
18 - www.dw.com/en/germany-growing...
19 - www.project-syndicate.org/com...
20 - www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/1...
Taking immigrants without checking their background & their respect for democracy/rule of law is stupidest thing any country could've done.
And how exactly do you check such things?
Practically background checks of some sort are possible, but to evaluate their respect of western norms is not realistic, and to base policy on it would be moronic.
@@Diego-de6dq How are you going to do background checks on people from Afghanistan, Syria or Myanmar?
You cant so you put education level or job criteria in place, Canada or NZ have done this for years with good results@@srdjan455
@@srdjan455 1. Ban all illegal immigration.
2. Ask multiple questions regarding how they value democracy & western liberal values, after they applied through legal means.
As per pew survey middle east countries' citizens has 80%+ support for theocracy as opposed to democracy.
3. Grant them residential permit not citizenship for say 5 yrs. Check their behavior / activities both in real life & online.
4. Any discrepancies & straight deportation.
As an immigrant myself I just want to share 2 things.
1. Not all immigrants want to integrate. It saddens me when I see what I came to get away from follow me. Not all of us appreciate the freedoms we are given and are not nearly as tolorate.
2. Western nations can't help others if they don't help themselves.
No language classes for months, not issuing work permits, putting migrants in a heim far from town amongst themselves. Doesn't help with integration ..
That’s true, Indians and Latinos don’t want to interstate, they just like to stay in their bubbles.
Thanks, totally obvious common sense, lost on virtue signaling & neoliberal economic politicians (there neoliberal economic case of massive immigration, i.e. good for elites)
I think there is a difference between integrating and renouncing your previous culture completely. A lot of Europeans expect the latter and call it "integration". You travel to the US, a nation almost entirely composed of immigrants with the exception of the indigenous cultures, and you will see Italian neighborhoods, Irish parishes, Chinatowns, Hispanic communities, Muslim Mosques, Cajun quarters, and much much more. This all contributes to the wider American culture they have. Europeans need to learn that not everyone, in fact the majority of immigrants will probably never completely leave behind their previous tradition. They will just integrate it into the culture they have adopted as their new home.
My mother is an immigrant from a Caribbean country of African descent, most of my family members from mother's side either have 0 Dutch friends or are integrated and have Dutch husbands. My mother herself lives in a 98% White province and somehow the vast majority of her friends are also foreigners. The only foreigners I know with White friends tend to be married to Dutch people, like a Hindustani man with a Groninger wife, their children typically all speak Dutch and Low Saxon and married other White people.
In the West of the country it seems like Dutch people are slowly going extinct, I live in a mostly White neighbourhood in a big city but almost all the children are of various foreign descent, mostly of the most recent migrants (Syrians, Iraqi's).
I live in Austria and we are also cracking down on the refuge crisis.
I have zero issues with someone from another country wanted to immigrate, but do it because you like the country, the culture, the language - NOT because you like the freebies that tax payers provide. If you don’t want to integrate, don’t immigrate!
However you made the Russians in 1945 go less hard on your nation, pray that some who know the trick are still there to make your people survive those `tolerant politics´.
Someone from Afghanistan will never be able to integrate. Only people from European backgrounds. If you can tell them apart, they'll stay apart.
@@shantyclips6358if this people came legally to Germany and they work here and pay tax and not doing criminal things I have no problem with it when they want not “ integrate “. So long they they respect our way of life.
First the US is bombing and exploiting Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Palestine, Egypt , Pakistan, African countries and many more and later Germany and other European countries have to correct the errors. The game started long before the crisis.
@@shantyclips6358 Idk chief lots of brown people can integrate, especially ex Muslims and LGBT members
Im Nigerian, im not a migrant in any sense since i still live in my country and intend to do so for the rest of my natural life. But I've watched this madness unfold and marveled at the display of foolishness by the West. All that one needs to understand about migration is "how would I go about it if this was a stranger to my home?" The absolute same rules apply as you wouldnt throw your doors open to any suspicious character. Yet the West went about this for years now and stupidly thought nothing would go wrong. Im sorry but it may be too late to reverse the horrors that will befall you for this insanity. I pity also your tax-paying citizens who have unbeknownst funded this sacrilege and will yet be at the receiving end when the rot explodes in your faces. Can you imagine what you robbed your citizens of in order to fend for millions of ingrates?!?
Yeah, it's pretty ridiculous. Being kind to people is noble but you can't make yourself a martyr for them
The west is the governments and they do not share the interests of its people. Trust or else this problem wouldnt have continued to this extend. As I see it. There is evil powers at play here using illegal immigrants as weapons against western countries. Next is Asia
My old neighbor was Nigerian (I live in the US). We still keep in touch with him, even went to his daughter’s wedding. They are hard-working nurses, and their kids are in college or high school. I don’t understand the problem with Nigerian immigrants like them, so I’m not sure what you’re getting at. They tend to be upwardly mobile, at least in the US. 🤷🏻♀️
And what exactly do you think happens if we stop taking in people? They won't simply stop trying to get here. And it creates conflicts elsewhere. Although I have to agree the way their immigration was/ is being handled is pathetic. You have those that try to contribute to society but aren't allowed in and those that are unwilling to accept our rules yet are being tolerated and thus constantly cause conflict.
Wise!
One lesson for Europe: You don't burn your home just to keep the homeless warm.
very well said
Especially the homeless from Middle East.
@@jeckjeck3119 And don't forget about the homeless from Africa also
@@jeckjeck3119dont burn someone's home then.
@@frankie._.4167
We are better of getting people from Asia, hard work is part of their culture, and they are less religiously dictatorial. Revoke Asylum seeking from certain nations.
I know a Korean girl who came to Germany, she was a student and academic, yet she was kicked out when her visa was over. Yet we have countless people with permanent residence in Germany who do nothing.
You can see them in some districts in Berlin, they can't speak German or English and just sit around
That's exactly the problem that makes me mad. There are even hospitals that have to reduce capacity because their staff runs into bureaucratic visa problems and were kicked out.
In my opinion everybody should be allowed to come to Germany and live here, as long as they don't break any laws and are able to support themselves through employment and pay taxes.
As for refugees, when the "refugees" from an area consist mostly of young men that leave their parents, women and children at home, then they are not really "refugees". They come to Germany primarily to make money. So classifying them as refugees makes the problem *much* worse. Since refugees are not easily allowed to participate in the workforce, the welfare system has to support them.
The system is nuts. A lot of them have a money available to pay to human traffickers. If the system would allow them to legally immigrate as workers, not as refugees, that money would allow them to support themselves for a few months while they look for a job.
So it really is not a pro/contra immigration decision that has to be made, the way forward definitely should be a "pro legal immigration" and "anti illegal immigration" policy.
it's the abberation of the judiciary that wont allow people getting kicked out if their country of origin is deemed "dangerous"
The rich and democratic countries should form a union with freedom of movement of university graduates.
That is really unfair
@@zurielsssand thats the Moment everybody starts studying liberal arts to become an academic and to profit off that
It is really bad in parts of germany where migration centers are placed. Lots of theft in small villages where everyone knew each other. Now filled with people who dont care about your home or stuff
If they do crime deport them!!
I left Germany for Canada in 1982 and was in Munich recently and was in shock how everything changed
shock how? Do you see the immigration in Canada (mostly international students) better than the refugee crisis of Europe ?
It's disgusting
@tanayjoshi7269 wrong. Not just student. Africa, mid east, India. It's disgusting. Vomit is too kind
How much did things change?
is it just me , or does the new rules sound like something that should have been done in the first place? It`s amazing to help out others, but one must make sure their own constituents are happy & well maintained. Taking action against those who break the law is even more important when it comes to immigrants!
@@julm7744We humans may all be the same, but certainly not our cultures. And because cultures are not all the same, these differences can cause problems.
@@julm7744Humans are not the problem, 7th century fairy tale ideologies are.
@@julm7744 Who cares about skin colors? Probably you and people like you. Just understand that people from outside have different incompatible cultures. You think that you helping someone, but in reality you are exploited by masses of economic migrants who play victims, offer nothing, but demand a lot. Citizens must be the priority for government, not random migrants without valid cause for an asylum who broke all possible rules to get to a welfare state.
How many have you taken into your household then mate?@@julm7744
In the first place, we have immigration laws which these politicians broke! Nothing new needs be done except enforce the laws we have. Nobody in without a visa. Refugees get sent back when war is over. No passports. Very simple.
I remember attitudes towards refugees from then Middle East souring dramatically after the incidents of sexual assault and rape happening in cologne. I don’t fault the German people for their shift in attitude. I think even if it is the minority of people doing these kinds of negative things, the citizenry shouldn’t have to live in fear of attacks.
Inshallah
Is it the minority? Please show me where you get that fact from
Lol minority, About 90% of them are like this.
@@Waebeii 25 percent of immigrants beinf rapist would still be a minority right ?
@@Waebeii Number of immigrants of Germany/number of rapists and you have your maximum tally which is something like 1/10000, and this would be if all rapists were immigrants which is clearly not the case...
I'm a doctor from Eastern Europe and I'm working towards living and working in Germany. I speak German on B2 level, preparing the C1 level exam (Fachsprachprüfung). I have a partner in Germany, but we can't be together for more than 90 days in a 180 day period. It's extremely frustrating to have to deal with so many obstacles, especially when I witness how some immigrants can easily stay here, get help from the country and all the benefits without ever actually wanting to become a functioning members od society (of course, there are many exemptions) while higly educated people who already speak German and have, to a great extent, integrated into Germany have to overcome so many obstacles with little to no help from the government. Not to mention the extreme waiting periods and tedious bureaucracy because the system is overloaded by people who just want to use it, but don't intend to give back in return. Many of my German friends are frustrated with this situation and it doesn't surprise that people are slowly changing their mind when it comes to immigration policies.
P. S. Here's an example of how backwards the system is: I had an interview in a clinic regarding my future employment. I told then that I need to pass the C1 language test in order to work as a doctor. They told me it's ok, I can do a Pflegepraktikum with them for 6 months in order to prepare for the exam and get to know the health care system, and once I pass the exam, they'll keep me as a doctor. I got a contract, I would have a small pay, I had someone vouching for me (my partner), I paid private health insurance, I had B2 language level certificate, I had enough money on my bank account - and i STILL got denied a visa for a short 6 months period, even though I wouldn't have cost the country one cent. So frustrating.
Yes, this is the case in many immigrant-heavy Western countries. The skilled workers who come in legally often get the short end of the stick whereas those who are here illegally or have otherwise gamed the system to skip the line get to suck up tax-payer resources. I especially liked how I, a first-generation immigrant myself, got accused of being a racist bigot when I pointed out how this type of system can only collapse in the long run, particularly since our productive tax-base which pays for all these programs is shrinking (see: the silver wave) and that we must make changes to our policies. It's true Western nations have an inverted population pyramid and the only way to stave this off with any immediacy is with immigration. However, there are smart and stupid ways to go about this. Bringing in massive amounts of unskilled immigrants who cannot and will not ever become as productive as skilled immigrants is essentially a form of slow national suicide, but like I said: pointing out the obvious makes you a racist bigot, regardless of whether you are a POC and an immigrant yourself.
I am honestly confused as to why so many white westerners seem to hate themselves and their own damn countries. Good god.
really bad situation in german. I feel the stupid german people love the illegal asylum beggars rather than educated and skilled people. I also received a job contract from a german employer who said that they will take care of the vis process and i dont dont need to worry about the visa process. I am a physiotherapist. But still i am highly tensed about the german bureaucracy which make things difficult for skilled people and makes it very easy for asylum beggars from middle east and north africa
It is sad. But this is the "social state" and the world.
If you work and are competent. You get a middle finger.
If you are an arrogant piece of shit and pussy, you get support.
That is not just about being from middle east, africa or europe.
Is overall. I have worked all my life, never did the german stat suport me.
Some people I know, german and not-german, have been under state support since decades and still get support....but never worked and playing games and taking drugs..
I can tell you only one thing. Never give up.
And do sometimes the asshole or the crying pussy, depending what you have in front of you.
People in generall do not fking care about principles and ethic..
I do not tell you to leave them, but you have to outsmart the employer and the state workers.
Do not tell completely bullshit, but "biegt die Warheit".
For example tell that in your country "you are a political activist (especially for LGTB+) and you are scared for your life."
If you go and say I am a professional, competent, I like to work and be with my GF.
They wont care.
Good Luck.
Seriously tell them you are a gay and that your life is in danger. (Give a Fuck, when you got the papers and stay in Germany, stay here).
When applying for jobs, my gender is "diverse". I ask myself, do you want a competent professional? The answer is no.
So fool them in their terms. When you get the job and the papers...who fking cares...
As a German, living in Berlin, it was crazy to see all these Ukrainians standing in line at Berlin's main station last year - and it continued for WEEKS.
I was like global politics in front of your own eyes.
It's also crazy if you think about it: Germany is (obviously) highly sensitive to antisemitic acts - welcomes refugees - that then start antisemitic acts. oh man...
Ukrainians and anti-semetic acts? Electing a Jew as a President, having a Jew as a previous PM? Yeah, sure, try harder Russian bot
Germany for Germans...the Austrian painter
I lived as an exchange student in Germany for a year. I am also from a western country and it was challenging enough for me to adapt to the country’s culture and language
The idea that you can bring in millions of people without having big issues and problems is completely naive, and if you are “pro immigration” you need to have a plan in plan to handle these problems. Naively hoping that everything will magically work out is only going to fuel a backlash and labeling any kind of resistance to it as “bigoted” will only increase appeal of racist politicians who are more than happy to exploit peoples frustrations especially if there is no mainstream alternative for people to try to productively work out the issues of high levels of immigration.
An intelligent comment. Did you try their raw meat? Haha
Naivety is the right word. Merkel thought all humans work the same way as she and other Germans do. She didn´t understand that different cultures have completely different values and mentalities. In a way her way of thinking was stuck in a peaceful German mindset.
Germans are defination of barbarism.@@AYVYN
Germany and Europe as a whole did kill millions of mixed race people. Instead of deflecting they should be looking for solutions. The issue is right wing politicians resorting to 20th century propaganda to demonize civilians* who fled American/ European caused wars. Here in the US, people try to demonize Haitian civilians while being completely ignorant of the history destabilization of Haiti and the presence of American mercenaries. These super powers just don’t hold each other accountable for their war crimes and then expect civilians to find accommodation somehow. Read up on The Hague Act.
@@tosche774Merkel is from DDR - part of an Union were dozens of cultures were working closely together.
So she thought it will work the same way - but it didn’t. SU had shared goals, ideology and an unified language. Nothing of those works with this type of migrants that flooded Germany.
This also happened in Sweden, we turned from one of the safest countries to a country with a ton of shootings and explosions
You chose migrants who are bottom feeders. You could have chosen better performing ones like Indians, Chinese, Vietnamese. But no, you purposefully chose the worst ones because the Asians aspire for middle class jobs within one generation. So do not act dumb and innocent.
Muslims?
@@ramumanickam1643
Who else?
@@ramumanickam1643yes, muslims. Not only that muslim population is the one who commit more secual assault in Sweden
Shocking that this week it was announced that Sweden was experiencing its worst security crisis since 1945, with 30 times more shootings than cities like London.
being german it feels like I am living in a foreign country
Being German, I can't confirm that.
Same if you're French or English. This shit had to stop
As a German Thank you for this wrap up of this issue. Very focussed on detail with a lot of graphs and numbers. This way it's possible to make for your own oppinion off of actual facts and not just feelings and political agenda.
It says a lot about the way this issue is handled in German media that I need a foreign channel to get these informations.
Same crap in the UK.
@@Guitar6tyGet rid of Sunak and Yousaf! Why are you guys being run by people who aren’t British! The UK belongs to the Anglos and the Celts!
Want to know something sad? Even we Canadians are getting very sour on immigration, and its because it feels like they dont want to be Canadian, they just want a safe place to spread their hatred it seems. It really starting to make my country terrible, so I really feel for countries like Germany and Sweden for speaking out about the problems.
Well, immigration worked well for Canada ruining relations with India because Khalistanis who immigrated to Canada and got Canadian citizenships care more about establishing Khalistan and threatening Indians and Air India flights instead of caring for their own country which they’re currently citizens of. Similarly, all the refugees the Canadian government accepted from the Middle East brought their cultural and religious baggage with them that they want to deliberately ruin Canada’s ties with Israel and threatening Hebrew people and institutions in Canada. So overall a great success. 😃👍
Canada is the last one to speak lol, you guys got more land than people. Depressing land. No immigrant is willing to stay there anyway, they find their way to better places like the US or somewhere in Europe. What does it even mean to be Canadian lol? Quebec is mainly made of jewish immigrants and well the rest is Asian and somewhat white, with sprinkles of minorities here and there. Canada got no identity buddy. It’s an immigrant land so don’t hop on the wave
Even the French Canadians don’t want to be Canadian.
@@Seth9809 what even is a Canadian? What do they look like? What language do they speak?
Canada will be majority non-White soon. It's over for this country and you can thank immigration for that.
My grandparents emigrated to Germany back in the 60's from Turkey and I'm just absolutely shocked about the mistakes our government did since 2014. There's nothing about being racist by saying that we need a heavily reduced, as well as controlled immigration. Usualy a country should know whom they allow to cross the border, but the waves of agressive, violant young arabic men is just unbelievable. Most of them just can not be integrated into the German society. Especialy those who literally are against western/ european values with their extreme religious world view should be send back to their home immediately.
Some Germans would say this to ur ancestors as well… how the tables have turned 😂
@@Besthinktwice Unfortunately Germans hate Turkish immigrants and even the children of Turkish immigrants which are born and raised in Germany in the fifth generation but they show sympathy for any arabic immigrant with their 12 children from the marriage with the first grade cousin which cant even speak a sentence in German and have a extreme religious and Anti-Western (Anti-German) worldview. I don't know why they hate people with Turkish background that much but I think its never gonna change, unfortunately.
So true.
They are refugees, you can't legally send them back.
The US has military bases in Syria which are illegal and unwanted by the population, are you surprised they are escaping from being slaughtered
This can be said about the turks as well from a misguided pov. I am a Tunisian who lives in Germany and the presence of Turkish organised crime is not to be ignored. This doesn't lead me to say that turks are radicals and criminals because it doesn't make sense, many of my associates are Turkish. Similarly, I obviously have many Tunisian friends and associates it's rare for me to come across some of the people you mentioned. I'm not saying they don't exist, but your framing tells a different story: "we turks are different than others"
Before multiculturalism and uncontrolled immigration violent crime was rare in Canada.
Same in Germany.
I also experienced something like this a lot as a Swiss person with a background in migration (Both my parents are from Turkey and I was born in Switzerland, as a result of immigration, who gained citizenship at birth).
My father has been working restlessly to integrate himself into the culture & rules of the country to gain citizenship and has spent majority of his life in the country since he was 20-ish years old.
But I see a huge difference from the new wave of immigrants who refuse to integrate themselves, refuse to speak the local language, refuse to seek higher education & continue living off of taxpayers money despite the given opportunities and privileges. This doesn't apply to everyone but it is very prominent compared to what you see, let's say, 40 years ago.
And add a housing crisis on top of that and rising inflation +other factors etc., it becomes harder to manage which also makes it understandable to as why the immigration laws are getting stricter.
Younger people around my age and younger(16-25ish) tend to dislike the country they are living in, and I don't see as in why that is the case.
But this is something germany should have been done years ago.
The resources aren't endless and they also need to set their boundaries.
Majority of immigrants around this time would be better off outside of western countries in my opinion, we cannot bear it for many reasons.
I'm proud of German individuals for finally standing up for themselves.
I live in the US. Completely agree with you. When in Rome, do as the Romans do. I also believe that, like charity, "humanitarian obligation" begins at home. Take care of your own people first! The whole can see we have a lot of illegals that have come through the southern border especially during this idiotic president's administration, and a huge proportion of them are unaccounted for. We are in for a long rough ride in the coming years.
@karamation
I worked in Germany in the 1980s.
Mainly with Turkish and Yugoslavia n guest workers. Maybe like your father. ? They ALL worked. None of them demanded a free home and Welfare . They probably had hard times but eventually they settled in. The refugees (!) we get now are nothing like that !!
@2msvalkyrie529 Exactly. My father was one of the hard-working individuals. I wholeheartedly agree with you.
He did not have it easy, but that is where the issue is.
Refugees during these years get everything, welfare, shelter, food, money, all of that without having to work, that is good but it shouldn't be given for years without requiring them to contribute to the country.
I am sad and disheartened that my father had to go through this since I know that he'd work & integrate himself regardless of what welfare he got.
The reasons we have none of these obvious laws in place already is because of ”humanists” and socialist groups constantly stopping much needed basic legislation regarding these things, and in many cases changing and removing already existing legislation.
It all basically stems from marxism and ”anti-racism”.
you were an immigrant / migrant. they are just travellers wanting a free lunch. a huge difference.
One aspect is missing, the Hessian CDU, campaigned especially on a very hard migration restriction platform, won the state elections and the SPD, which is traditionally strong in Hesse, pursued a migration-friendly course with the Federal Minister of the Interior as the leasing candidate and was absolutely destroyed in the election
SPD was strong in Hessen until the 70. Then it was mostly CDU with only brief stints of SPD mixed in. Much like the Bundestag, in a way. Hessen has always been a rather conservative state. The very bad SPD result this time is mostly credited to Faser, who isn't too well liked by ... anyone.
@@mikestone6078 I don't think the SPD would've done much better with a different candidate...
@@srccde Not MUCH better, but a little less bad, perhaps. I mean, they will actually win by becoming part of the gorvernment and replacing the Greens. So they shouldn't complain to loudly.
@@mikestone6078 Cope
I didn't realize elections were happening. When was this?
Impressive, as a German, this is better news coverage on the issue than from most media here.
But you guys still need to fix your burecracy 😅
Lesen Sie nur die BILD?
@@EllieD.Violet Sie lesen wohl nur die SZ ?
@@tomashass9229 bring in the indian christians or filipinos. Best model of immigrants in any country
@@tomashass9229 Nein, ich lese einen guten Querschnitt durch deutsche respektable Presse. Und die englischsprachige Presse. Und die franzoesische, spanische und italienische Presse. 😊
As an american woman living in austria and who previously worked in Germany, I can tell you, while in Germany, I was harassed almost daily (i am not exaggerated) by middle eastern/African men-and even followed on more than one occasion. In austria, an already socially conservative country by my american standards, it’s becoming almost as bad. I’m harassed etc constantly by these people. My friend is an elementary school teacher in Salzburg, and she teaches 100% first generation kids in her school (she works with kids ages 10-15). She tried to teach the Muslim girls, as young as ten and already in hijab and burka, women’s rights and independence. They tell her if they don’t marry at 18, they will go to hell. They don’t play during recess, they aren’t allowed on field trips-the Muslim boys are of course. She says some of the boys threaten her, she says some of them are bigger than her already and say they don’t listen to women.
Please listen to these stories
So no one gonna mention what happened in cologne on the new years eve back in 2016?
The difference between legal educated migrants vs illegal uneducated migrants and refugees cannot be overstated. The first camp is absolutely a net plus for Germany, the other camp not so much
Immigration is - with few exceptions - a net detriment to Germany. It is largely used to avoid reform of a broken welfare state and to artificially suppress wages, giving companies the illusion they still don't have to pay fair, livable wages to their employees. Nearly all immigration is strictly into the welfare system (and in many cases through no fault of the immigrant), because entry level wages are far below welfare, nearly all jobs require employees to already be conversational in German and it takes months to years for working permits. None of which is told to the immigrants beforehand. On the contrary some get told (by varying sources), they'll have a job, a house, a car and a desperate German woman waiting for them - which never materialize. The current welfare system rewards criminality of all kinds and punishes honesty and hard work. And given that that is the starting point of all migrants who do not already have a job lined up before their arrival... yeah. Immigration is rarely a benefit.
It's a little dehumanising how you put refugees In with people who throw away their documents.
Doesn't matter much anyway, where else do you think the middle Eastern refugees will go to while Germany and the EU keeps supporting Israel.
@@notfunny3397Egypt.
@@notfunny3397you have a ton of Muslim countries that aren't at war, why don't they just go there?
Also, Israel didn't start the war, but they'll finish it. Go pound sand.
If samone is illegal, doesn't tell you samthing about,the qualification of that person.
We told them this would happen in 2015. They called us “racist” and “without sympathy”. Time always has a way of proving the truth. 😂
Still racist.
Tldr would have called you racist until a couple of weeks ago.
He only thinks what main eu countries thinks.
@@ChrisGrumpIts not racist to do something about people who come to your country, unwilling to integrate into society and accept their values. There are people who are willing to integrate, get a job, and become useful members of society, and there are parasites. These people are also unfortunately becoming a stereotype for immigrants, which only gives actual racists something to cling on to.
@@ChrisGrumpew i smell an immigrant
@@ChrisGrump racism is a virtue when it comes to your type
It was ridiculous to have taken in all of these people in the first place . Now you have to deal with such a stupid choice.
It wasn't stupid: It was selfish, the corrupted establishment stayed in power to their deaths, and now the successors have to face the problems and resolve them. Which will be easier with empty funds, right?
Not simply ridiculous.
There is left and "green" politics that want to impose Europe a "multicultural" society. That has never really worked without major problems - as the communist "progressive" societies did not work.
And the "liberal" political establishment wants immigration to keep wages for workers low. Merkel worked mainly for big business in Germany.
Something important to understand about people found to not be correct asylum seekers (and thus techically waiting for deportation) is that these people can be the people that the actual asylum seekers were seeking asylum from!
Wise words, but to get a job in our GOV you must be deaf to exactly such truisms!
Good
Europeans deserve a homeland where they can be safe
then they shouldn’t have fucked up the borders everywhere
@@unbelievableHoruz Irrelevant to this time
@@MW_Asura no
and others dont ??
@@unbelievableHoruzAnd especially Europe should deport first who are moreover ungrateful...
It has just become to much. A look in the schools is enough. How are migrant children supposed to integrate themselves if they are the majority in their classes?
Scaling immigration back is not only something we should do for ourselves, but also for the migrants already here.
We got to digest what we put on our plate first, then we can think about taking more
The stories from the school are so horrific. The cute cuddly ideals of the previous generation are being obliterates there, as women live again in constant fear but get no help because its ok to be terrible to women if your certain ethnicities. Which is inherently racist, which racist people feed on. Its deeply ironic to pitch treating everyone as human and then not remember that all humans form groups and all those groups seek power with a total moral abandon if allowed.
This isnt going to last until the next generation guys. The schools are nightmarish, and the children arnt buying any of this. Not when the ideals they are fed are a double standard.
Seriously, screw double standards. Rule of law, and nothing else.
Funny enough, it's German girls and women who have the highest grades. Nice oppression you have there.
In before it turns out the US takes in way more and has been for a long time.
Too many immigrant kids especially from low SE families do indeed drag down a class not always intentional though and having in general too many children from any low SE group in one classroom is problematic. I think our problems might be much more black and white than we like to believe richVSpoor.
First the US is bombing and exploiting Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Palestine, Egypt , Pakistan, African countries and many more and later Germany and other European countries have to correct the errors. The game started long before the crisis. Germany always supported the US and now we are complaining.
Anything in life that is “uncontrolled” will end badly.
I live in Germany, it‘s awful with the immigrants nowadays….
"Never saw that coming" said nobody at all.
What I would like people to understand is criticizing the immigration politics of your country is not the same as criticizing immigrants, it's not racism.
The Media and the left see that different. They will do everything to destroy your live or smear your Reputation.
@olafsigurson5333 you can criticize the stupid immigrants that ignore laws, customs, and are given free passes by your government. From what I hear they allow them to r*PE women, be thieves, sell rats and wild unclean animals as food, beat people.up on busses, roam in gangs and attack innocents. None of that is racist, these people are just stupid.
Depends. Most people that vote for the AfD are racist or ignorant.
If you want to solve a problem, you don't ask the people that proposed shooting people.
People claim, its about migration policies, but in reality they ust hate migrants, even if it means giving up the the stability of the state.
It is not racism either to criticize young, foreign men who play the victim while joining gangs or foreign women having babies to collect gov't money. It is OK to be white and it is OK to have opinions when immigration isn't working out.
soyboy@@Besthinktwice
I was recently in Germany and I was really surprised by the fact that sometimes I simply did not see any Germans lol. Just walking down the streets either on the city center or in the suburbs, I'd see like 10 people who clearly were not German before I saw someone who resembled a somewhat European person.
The only places where I'd find a more "German crowd" would be on fancy markets or far far away from big cities.
I´m a native German and live in a medium sized city. Maybe 1 in 10 people I see outside is actually white. Just an endless sea of muslim women with hijab and 4-8 children with them, every single time. It´s over for Germany. Es ist vorbei.
You build you home and garden and the govt. comes and shits in the garden.
Germany should have put an emphasis on Education levels and a obligation to learn german fast in the first place.
Germans don't even speak German.
@@voiceofreason2674 Interesting. What language do we speak then?
@@voiceofreason2674 I'm scratching my head. What do you mean?
@@huckleberryfinn6578arab
according to a few friends i have from there, they speak broken muslim german mix which is garbage
Well just look what's happened. And happened in Sweden. Everyone needs to wake up to this
I live in germany and its become nuts...
I really hope our politicians will realize soon that we can't help everybody and we have to select who needs help the most, because if we keep this up we won't be able to help anyone in the future.
My German friends are now too scared to go out at night - 10 years of migration has turned their town from safe, friendly, liberal and low crime to divided ghettos of extremism, crime and rape....
It's good. They should be, they created this mess, they were blaming all the other countries and putting themselves in morally superior position, schooling all the other countries on "openness and tolerance".
They decided to show the example and lead the energy transformation, to befriend russia and to take migrants.
And there was and still is enormous support for all that in german society.
They are responsible for it, they are choosing it.
Its called cultural enrichment
which town
@@xerron698
Just don't accept anyone from Middle East.
Town name?
Migration is a problem if the groups coming don't integrate and have an identity hostile to the host nation. Doing so is a long term problem and not worth any cheap labour in the interim.
having german authorities and talking heads doing everything they can to erase german identity didn't help either
@@delfinenteddyson9865 The mystery is why people voted for those politicians. Some people have a naïve view of the world. Unfortunately when this view is shown to be wrong its everybody that suffers the consequences.
@@alanrobertson9790 I guess the downside of growing up in a pacified and wealthy country makes you blind to the ills of the world
@@alanrobertson9790I don’t know if it’s in germany too but here in NL we have a kieswijzer which is basically a few questions to see which party alignes with you the most, but lately these kieswijzers have had questions in which the answers could be interpreted to be both right or left. leading to people being recommended far left parties which they most of the time don’t even agree with.
@@alanrobertson9790Because of the naive belief of many people that "all humans are the same so we should show them love and compassion", while ignoring the reality on the ground that people are not the same. Our cultures and beliefs can cause some serious damage to the community and society at large.
Never forget when in 2016, 2000 illegal immigrants took to the streets, rped 2 german teens and were never caught.
"We need more workers because we have an aging population" is such a terrible excuse to destroy countries all over the west. It's not even true. It's always a net negative. The same amount of resources cannot sustain the extreme amounts of people, and even if that were the case, it won't be the same nation anymore within a few years of that trend. PEOPLE are the culture. Our way of living each day, the rules and laws we all agree on, the shared story of how the country came to be. All of this is so important, and the outsiders do not share that at all. If they instead looked INWARD as to why people are having less kids, why they don't take the jobs that oh so desperately need workers, they COULD fix those problems and start growing steadily while maintaining the integrity of the people. But no, instead they betray them for free voters and money in their own pockets. I spit on politicians in Europe.
The problem is politicians are too interested in looking good meaning short term solutions that just kick the issue down the road...
Well the earth is already overpopulated global warming is slowly happen and if our population keeps rising and if people starts having more children there will be no food left on your table when you retire. So be greatful amd it's cheap to bring in people that make them. It's good for our planet.
Imagine a German politician worrying about Germans and this being controversial.
By and large, most (insert nationality here) politicians who run on "worrying about (insert nationalities here)" are just colossal pricks who only care about lining their pockets and/or taking total control.
i remember that painter
Imagine the failed artist returns now . He would definitely hate this modern Germany which has become a cesspit of multiculturalism
@@ltdgamer7705 Pretty impressive considering the comparison displays a total lack of brain cells
@@ltdgamer7705the painter is from Austria
No country is obliged to take in strangers and shaming them for not doing so will not change their minds. Every country should be allowed their own policies and stances
Well.....
Every country that
- has its own asylum laws,
- joined the EU human rights treaty with included asylum rules,
- or joined the Geneva UN asylum convention .....
_kinda_ has to. Take in people in need of protection from dire harm.
Scarcely any of those states really does.
But formally all who dont want to, should consequently leave those treaties.
Otherwise they break their own legal commitments.
Problem is : those rules and treaties where written before globalization and modern tech made it possible for giant number of people to move around.
@@user-un8tv1pp8mif the people don’t want it, we shouldn’t be obligated to, much less forced to. Isn’t that what democracy is about?
@@tirididjdjwieidiw1138 Sometimes democracy and state of law/human rights are impossible to align. Thats why things like basic rights and process of law where invented after all - because democracy or majority interests sometimes go against what we feel are fundamental human rights.
I´m not arguing either way here. Just pointing out the fracture lines.
That we as rich western and northern societies can either keep to those humanist rules we gave ourselves - or decide to abandon them and keep migrants from trying to find survival with us.
The migration movements will not stop. They will expand over the coming decades. Hard.
With climate change making the globes areas where currently 1-3 billion people live uninhabitable, that development will swell far beyond what we see now in the coming decades.
And the question wether we allow them to survive with us, thereby fundamentally changing our societies?
Or decide to block those mass movements by any means neccessary to keep millions of desperate people out, or let them die where their life is no longer possible?
Will have to be made.
I have my personal idealist hopes that humans will try to save other humans.
But I fear it will mostly go the other way - that fear and xenophobia will drive societies to violent isolationism.
If one thinks consequently about those developments?
Its either give up on moral basic rules. Or decide to let people who cant survive under the conditions they suffer from die. While using drastic measures to try and stop their survival-driven movements.
There really is no practical middle way.
And make no mistake:
Seeing how already tens of thousands drown in the mediterranean or die in the texan desert trying to make it to the US? It doesnt look like humanism and saving desperate folks is currently winning.
With migration fear and the rise of xenophobe political movements, most societies have already decided to rather kill people than endure them coming to our socities. And as of now its not even an existential question for us, for the moment its just about fear of suffering living standards and demographic shifts.
The Elites in Brussels wanted to strong arm European countries into taking in immigrants without limits or rules. If Europe needs cheaper workers or younger workers, then do what Moslem countries do. In the UAE, 9 out of 10 residents are guest workers with a contact allowing for their work and residency. They also do this in Saudi Arabia. There is no need to give them state benefits for free. These "guest" workers are satisfied with the agreement which doesn't promise them citizenship nor do they expect citizenship. It's not necessary. In the case where they are fleeing from war, it is good to give them residency but there is no need to give them citizenship. They can return home after the war if possible. If not, they can stay as "guest" workers.
90% of those people get their asylum claims denied, yet can stay forever and after 18 months get full social benefits - housing, healthcare, child money.
Finally it happened. I am from germany and the germany citizen are burdened too much with all the 'sociality' and 'help' which our government gives to all but their own citizen.
We are the country with the most taxes world wide and one of the most spend money on other peoples problem.
Don't misunderstand me, I am full on with helping people. I have helped homless and friends who have had it harder than me.
But its a no brianer that you can't help if you have nothing. And the german government is on his fastest way to have nothing. Well, to be true or so called 'state' has nothing anymore.
Maybe because we have given to all but us.
I say we but I mean like the politicians with hidden aggendas.
Houndreds of long and old businesses got torn apart by germanys 'socialism'.
Finally they stopped this madness but i fear it is to late.
Having the right priorities is very important
Why don't European countries encourage starting families for their native population?
Because of their self humiliation of their past
@@dsnvamsidharbabu.its in every western nation i guess everyone is ashamed
@@alanwatchesstuff this mentality can't save their future.
It was about time, even though the measures are need to be more strict. People who immigrate to a country MUST oblige to that countries laws and customs.
@@Besthinktwice Verbrechensstatistik "crime statistics"
No, they don't.
Part of the good of people moving around is retarded customs being changed.
When I'm in a different country, I laugh as their stupid customs, so they become ashamed and change them.
Why not just ban immigration from Muslim countries?
@@finn2485lol
Germany is now trying to relocate their illegal immigrants to other EU countries.
7:00 It is funny to see the CDU rising around questions regarding
1) immigration
2) Russia
while
1) the wave of immigration they are pointing their finger at comes from the policies defined by Merkel
2) Merkel encouraged economic relations with Russia and reliance on their gas
The CDU aren't really gaining much support though. They're up about 3 points from the last election. It's just that the SPD have crashed in support
The CDU really doesn't like Merkel despite her being the former Chancellor 😂😂😂
The CDU is acting like they weren't in power for 16 years and aren't responsible for pretty much all the problems Germany has right now... 😂😂🤣🤣
The CDU means Christliche Demokratische Union Deutschlands which is freaking hilarious because all the chancellors were Jews except of Adenauer and Schröder which is a fcking crime against humanity if you ask me.
Merkel just continued Schroeders policies, who was from SpD
Always felt Germany was never able to say no because they saw themselves in some kind of never ending debt from WW2.
And how they pay back that debt? How they pay back debt for 27 miIions Soviets? By importing arabs and africans?
Oh God, I can't believe what some people write.
Makes me actually happy all of this is happening
That’s exactly how it is. German here. Right now, as soon as you say we should rethink our immigration politics you are labeled nazi. Say something against wokism or lgbt and you are a nazi as well. That’s how it is in Germany right now. You are either pro immigration or a Nazi and while we let everyone in and give them money, our own retired people are left to collect Pfand bottles because their retirement money gets cut every year…
They were defeated, shamed, and forced to abandon their culture.
....and then WW2 happened.
How are they paying debt, and to whom? As I know, 27 milion Soviet citizens killed. How is debt being paid, by importing 3rdworld imigrants?
Instead of points system they should just set a limit on taxes you have to pay per year and limit a number of supported professions(aka Skilled worker visa in the UK) to prevent corrupted schemes.
8 years ago I lost my dad, the man literally worked himself to death, working 16 hours a day. Because my mom passed away many years prior, his retirement fund went to the state. I was kicked out of the house, despite being able to pay the mortgage. Ppl under 21 aren't allowed to have a mortgage. When I applied for a social rent home with urgency my application was denied. With 15k to my name, I became homeless at 18yo. The reasoning for the denial was that my dad had bought a home, so it must have had remaining value. Therefore I could easily pay for a hotel, the government lady said. Never felt so cheated by my own government. Meanwhile me and my dads taxes and his retirement fund were being used to get asylum seekers here, pay for their houses which I couldn't get and so on. How can one explain this? Now 8 years later I have my own place, a well paying job and I'm currently looking to immigrate to Poland or South Africa myself. As I don't want another penny of my taxes to be wasted by those morons.
South Africa has been getting really bad recently, would not recommend moving there
You're welcome to come to Poland. Learning the language will take a long time, but the local fauna and flora is absolutely beautiful.
I'm so sorry to hear that...Yes, the system in Germany is so broken, we also want to immigrate somewhere else. High taxes are just wasted on people who don't deserve it.
@@lucasmcguire1554Immigrating to SA was a better choice in the 60s/70s/80s.
@@RollerBaller amazing country actually! My steph mother is from there. I can speak the language a little bit, writing however is a real challenge indeed!
Finally, it looks like Europe is starting to wake up. It may be a bit late, but who knows.
Decade too late , maybe drastic actions can revert this damage
Europe has been doomed since Christopher Columbus came to the Americas, that was the start of the fall of Europe. They should have left too.
Its just blip this are not things that can be solved by politician sadly as history show us many times before this are things that are solved by mob and is always bad and ugly.
Hopefully not too late to stop the right-wing parties from taking over with this single issue.
@@EnderCorePL it is too late pendulum was swinged too far left and now it will come back even more far, we can see rise of right wing parties around the globe and this is left doing. Iam not going to comment of its good or bad it is what it is new cycle as many many many times before but this process was hastened by left wing ram headed politics almost at level of fascist social engineering and this never worked before and will not work it only grow resentment in population even without real issue even if its good because is imposed by force and then people go into opposition by default.
I suggest to the industrialized countries that they establish factories in African countries and train immigrants and employ them there, thus solving more than one problem at the same time.
I'm against the west taking the brightest from less fortunate countries. The brightest need to stay in their countries to elevate their own economies ect. Yes, Industrialized countries need to open up factories, businesses in less fortunate countries. Of course the west has always stolen the best from the less. It's that mind-game that needs to stop.
There is no u turn. None at all. It’s just words to soothe the people, while uncontrolled mass-migration, sponsored by the state via NGOs, continues without pause.
as a muslim in the eu (poland), this isn't germany souring or restricting immigration, it's just them starting to fix the issues cause by their mishandling of mass influx of unchecked syrian refugees, and it's literally only aimed at criminals and those that are refusing to become useful members of society, if a country is gonna let you into their land unconditionally and even give you free money, free housing, free education then you have to at least learn the language and get a job
After the events of 7th October in Israel, the population of muslims in Europe is going to be vastly reduced.
Why did you immigrated to Poland instead of western Europe?
@@gilgameschvonuruk4982 He might be a native.
I have a lot of polish friends so it seemed like the best choice, I might try germany or something in my later years of uni (i speak german), but poland has been pretty cool so far, and learning polish has been a fun challenge tbh. @@gilgameschvonuruk4982
they shouldn't be a controversial opinion. forcing certain standards to be met and kept while in a country, especially when you are being paid by said government to get on your feet is paramount.
the most unfortunate problem is that, as always, certain personality types just abuse goodwill, so of course there was going to be people with no intention of assimilation or even legal status green card, and just wanted a more affluent place to live and a welfare check, and unfortunately several german governments naively thought this wouldn't happen.
Last time I went to Germany, I realized why Germany is souring on immigration.
why ?
@@lawtraf8008 a lot of people who don't like Europe and don't want to be Europeans.
thank you for your honesty
@@djp1234thats what happens when you teach your people That you are inferior z
That's exactly what India was doing but now we rising middle class don't take These Wine sipping historians seriously
Cryyyy
this is awesome and I fully support this. the media is constantly trying to manipulate us to feeling sorry for them. I'm from Canada and the point system has been really destructive. .
If you say something about the high crime rate of these muslim arabs here in germany you‘ll loose your job and bank account immediately and be called racist and nazi. 60,000 knife attacks and 800 group rapes last year. Muslim arabs are hunting down young girls on the streets. Police do nothing. Don‘t wanna loose their jobs.
Meanwhile in Italy there is an influx of people without documents who claim to be 17. These need to be taken in and cared for and will then ask to be reunited with their parents who will come over later.
These youngsters all claim they were born on the 1st of January. 🙄
It's not a U-turn until they send all the freeloaders back. I came here in 2000. It was not very foreigner friendly but by 2005 Germans had started becoming much more open and welcoming. By 2010 it was a great place and the Germans (younger Gen) seem to be moving into the local gov jobs making life much more easier. Sadly since 2015 I have only seen a massive detriment to society. Everyone I know, knows at least one person (if not directly effected themselves) who has been on the receiving end of this diversification. Ironically if you arrive on a tourist visa anywhere in the west with a recent criminal conviction, you will be denied entry on public interest grounds, yet say commit serious crimes and don't receive hard sentences nor are they deported. Most of them don't attend their integration courses. Only do what is necessary to keep the benefits coming. All of them have expensive kit, iphones, shoes, etc. not like the Cambodian and Vietnamese refugees I grew up with.
people are racist, you move in
you move in, you're tolerant of others like yourself
others like yourself move in, you become racist
you become racist, you try to ban others like you from moving in
Tale as old as time
Sometimes the reason, why those people are still here is just because their home countries don't take them back. Only 20% of the people who should be deported will actually be deported in the end. The government now tries to make deals with their home countries, but it's difficult
@@KupoxChan the reason is, they destroy their documents and don't provide the info for the gov to be able to get new travel docs. a tent city on an island in the north sea would soon change that attitude
@@KupoxChan I think that Germany cares too much. Oh no, that country doesn't take you back? Welp, no financial aid for that country it seems, we need that money to support your people over here. We're simply past the point of being nice - We tried, it failed.
@@xmine08 they can't take you back if you don't have travel documents. and if the person doesn't provide the information to enable issuing the travel documents, they can't be sent anywhere. even if it is known which country they come from
It's interesting that these so called "desperate people who seek refuge from war and famine" never stay in the poorer countries, they just pass on their way to the wealthiest ones like Germany, Scandinavia etc... Desperate people aren't picky like that
depserate people can't get help from other desperate people... this is obvious, come on, your perspective is so infantile
85% of all refugees are welcomed by intermediary/poor revenue nations (source: UN bureau of statistics)
I understand your point, but who tf goes from a fucked up country to another fucked up country?
@@fleur5782 Which country in Europe and the EU is that fucked up? We all like to complain, but compared to Afghanistan or Syria... even the worst European country is a literal heaven on Earth
@@beatjunkybg Aaa sorry, I thought you were suggesting they'd migrate to other 3rd world countries and stuff, but yeah, you're right 💀
Probably because people can’t be respectful of the culture to which they move. It isn’t the responsibility of the host culture to adapt to the immigrant’s culture, but the other way around.
I’ve been saying this for a long time that Europes terrible migration policies would only make its residents resentful and cause a rise in nationalist and far right sentiment. People are reactionary and when they’re made to feel unsafe and they’re concerns are ignored it’s only predictable the end reaction
Thats what the deluded open border folks dont want to hear. The longer they wait to acknowlege there's an issue the worse the backlash will be. They can look at Sweden and Denmark to see what their options are. The outcome will be one of the two, with the Swedish one beeing more likely.
@@yves2932 hopefully the swedish one is aggressively anti migrant.
Exactly this immigration crises especially from Muslim countries have brought these countries on there knees. Now they think enough is enough and they are absolutely right
Chegou num ponto que os nacionais estão sendo mortos, violados e presos. Obvio que isso não dara certo.
I hope theres a rise in far right nationalism europe-wide. Then we can build the utopia we wanted.
I was speaking to a German social worker and he was telling me how surprised he was at how resistant to integration this new wave of migrants are. I don't know if its a 'new wave' thing, or people from the first who are dragging their heels through the system but I reckon there's maybe a feeling of unappreciation. Add to that recent hate crimes by migrants and yeah, its soured
I think it has a lot to do with the fact that because of the large groups of immigrants coming in, there is no more need to adjust because people can surround themselves with people from the same cultural background and language. Why put effort in learning the language and German customs when you can easily avoid it and surround yourself with what you already know?
Illegal migrants, speciall araba illegal migrants and muslims have a mentality of an invader. They want to establish Sharia Law and take away your rights at the same time they want to establish a theocratic regime in Germany and all of Europe. It is naive to believe they can integrate. We need to deport them all
Me and some female co-workers of mine had some unpleasant experiences with some foreign students as well. We noticed that male students from patriarchic countries refused to talk to us and rather turned to our male colleagues or that they treated us quite disrespectfully. We probably found a solution to this problem but I was quite shocked that people who are so ignorant to inform about German work culture come here to study and act that way. However, this is a minority and most foreign (also males) are nice and respectful.
@@lucmeijboom this could’ve easily been avoided if refugees were dispersed enough of others like them around to feel welcome and to talk about issues they specifically face while not having so many you basically make a jewish ghetto where they can isolate themselves and now theirs going to be a cycle refugees form ghetto like places isolate themselves and refuse to integrate those that do want to integrate face issues of stereotypes and negative perceptions burning them making them believe that they shouldn’t integrate and now germans start developing ill feelings because these people dont want to integrate ect ect
@@lucmeijboom If you leave a place and then are surrounded by the exact people from that place, you wont change. Integration only works using social pressure.
3:30 Having a similar immigration policy to Canada is a bad idea. We have way too many immigrants here and a ton don't even know English. The immigrants don't even try to participate in Canadian culture a lot of the time (a good amount do though and they are very much appreciated)
So the numbers do say that there is a big replacement. Well well... what do you say to that...
On a trip to Berlin a few years ago, we did a bit of bar hopping where I ended up speaking to these gay men about what life is like in Germany, especially with the recent influx of foreigners. They were full of compliments about Turkish Germans: respectful, hard-working, honest people etc. When the conversation moved to immigrants from the Middle East, Afghanistan etc., let's just say the tone changed. These Germans, some millennials, some Gen Y, and some older, who had never before felt scared to be who they are in their own country, said they were sometimes scared because of the violence and intolerance of these new immigrants. This is not acceptable. If these people refuse to accept Western values, they should be sent back now! Enough!
Send all of middle east to western Europe.
are you a gay
This is exactly what the right wing factions of the time said would happen
And we were called racist for it.
To imagine it has all come down to this,
Apathy and suicidal bliss...
It's all over except for the cryin',
With a whimper instead of the roar of a lion...
I'm surprised it took this long ... This was always unsustainable. Too little, much too late though. The people and politicians who lacked the forsight to this logical outcome need to be held accountable. Importing people to have children for us, while ignoring the massive cultural, religious differences, and different values and work ethic, never made any sense.
It’s about ten years too late
Not really, west Germany still has hope
Because the economy would have had a really great time with 4 million workers less/s
@@st1ssl214yes, it would have. Before you stole their land, gold, resources, now you just be stealing them. Leave alone to fix their own countries!
What 10 yrs? Always wrong. Since the start, countries have laws and borders. Because of greed and power, western politicians decided to lure immigrants and break laws. Now we all live in ghettos.
@@st1ssl214 Germany could had those workers from other states, not from those mulim states. Those are only problem.
It’s pretty clear why. You walk around town, listen to people speak and you will hear 50% german and 50% Arabic,Turkish,Persian,Russian,Polish,Kurdish etc.
the cultural difference is also quite annoying, as migrants from the Middle East or first generation Germans with parents from those countries are (in general) quite loud and vocal, which is bad manners in public.
Personally I’m from one of the big towns in Germany and in some places, when you walk around it won’t feel like Germany. May as well be in Syria.
Also, the German government has done a terrible job making immigrants integrate. No one is really forced to. I have worked with people who came here 20+ years ago, barely speak any German and don’t know how to behave „properly“. And obviously immigrants won’t force themselves to integrate, it’s much easier to just stick to what you know.
I’m Scottish and been living in Germany since the 1990s. Integration has to be from both sides. You have to make the effort to learn the language and work etc but Germans have to start correcting people’s grammar in a friendly way and teach people how to behave in a casual way. This also applies to schools and kindergarten. Kids should be expected to integrate but they don’t. My daughter has been rejected by immigrants every time she has tried to be friends with someone because they don’t/won’t mix with Germans although she’s only half German herself. These kids should be forced to sit next to German kids and to play with them in the playground. At the moment they segregate themselves which is easy to do in some cases when there are only a few Germans in the class in some parts of cities.
@@scarba they are muslims what do you expect? we are their filthy enemies. they will never want to sit next to us
I could not care less about what language I hear tbh
@@nerida3347 in your own country you dont want people to talk in your language? Wtf.. they could talk and laugh about you, plan to murder you, and you wouldnt even notice. How stupid are you?
Uh oh…Klaus Schwab and the WEF isn’t going to like this!
I, as someone living in Germany, have noticed one of the greates issues for some germans is the labor problem. The reason why there is a shortage to begin with is the pay. You get close to no money while spending way over your budget on rent and such. I would belive that if pay would rise, the number of bluecollar workers would also rise. The issue unfortunately is difficult to resolve because these are all privat companies some of which are not able to pay more (many definitely do tho). But im sure even the newly immigrated will soon see this problem
Well, companies want cheaper workers for menial tasks..
The middle class is dying. And foreigners do the job for less money because for them it's still better than living in ruins.
I think this is fair, I want to study in Germany and possibly migrate afterwards and I still think its understandable. These countries are offering you a massive opportunity (atleast given my country's current state) so the least you can do is learn their language and have a good educational background to offer them something in return. Why should they let you in if you have nothing to offer and live off their backs or even cause trouble for everyone?
I wonder what country you're from?
@@Besthinktwice how is this the conclusion you came to?
he is saying immigrants are supposed to contribute not leech and that he wants to be one that contributes
where is the hypocrisy? that he is an immigrant?
@@Joey-wo6ds not even an immigrant yet, I just want to study classical music in Germany because a grand piano in Germany probably costs more than all the pianos of my music school here combined lol. If it works out, only then I will stay, I'm not dead set on leaving my country, it's not an easy decision..
Same for me, I am from Venezuela
@@Besthinktwice Wow, your reading comprehension skills are just disastrous!
It’s seriously impressive how twisted and far away from reality you’re conclusion of this comment is …
I’m really intrigued and curious, where did you go to school and what is your actual level of education?
Because if you import other cultures, you also import their problems.
If life here (UK, France, Germany etc) wasnt so much better, nobody would be trying to get here, and that is precisely why we must protect it.
Our leftist think Europe will always be a good and safe place after importing millions people from various countries, cultures, mentality and problems.
Culture clash, crime rate, segregation, comunautarism, hate crime,.....will increase once the welfare system is cut.
LEGAL, not just illegal overimmigration. WAY overdue in the US too!
When the rest of the world restricts immigration: 😐
When Germany restricts immigration: 😨☠
This is very fair, as an Austrian whose roots are from Nigeria, it’s not possible for certain groups of ppl (especially strict religious ones), especially those who oppose the western/European culture, to integrate.
We can’t and shouldn’t accept that!
My parents immigrated from Nigeria to Austria in the late 90s, worked their asses off, learned German asap, did an education (Ausbildung) and are very thankful the opportunity they received living in Austria. That’s how it should be.
Yes Jennifer .! It's actually the ingratitude that annoys people .
The outrageous sense of entitlement that these new " refugees " display. They quite openly say how much they despise
the Culture and History of the host country while living in a free apartment and Welfare cheques !!
Unbelievable !!
I'm sorry to say, but we humans are herd animals. We always react the same on the same set of trends, hence boom/bust cycles in the economy. And when the economy is down, lot more competition on the jobs that are left and you always without a doubt are gonna see anti-immigrant sentiment rise due to competition on the labormarket. And I don't know if you noticed, but Germany is facing de-industrialisiation as a result of fucking up their energy supply, courtesy of Merkel closing and demolishing all the nuclear energy reactors and the US giving the final shot bombing the North-Sea pipeline.
@@stijnvdv2 …no, it’s not simply “competition in labor market.”
Do you not understand the national security of planting a FOREIGN POPULATION within your own soil that DOES NOT SUPPORT YOUR COUNTRY???
A large number if these people are only there for the money, they will get citizenship for that, but in their hearts and minds they will destroy this country in a heartbeat for the sake of their religion and roots. They should have never been allowed in the first place…. Now they will cry victimhood and racism - after benefitting so much from the Western ideals they hate so much.
People really don't understand that just because they immigrated doesn't mean that they respect the culture or the country.
You'll never be Austrian. Also Nigerians shouldn't be in Austria. Now that's how it should be.
Why am I watching this, I live in New Zealand.
😂
Here was I, an Irishman, questioning why I was watching this.
Hope summer is nice down there.
@@ronanmurphy98as an Irish man who now lives in NZ ill tell ya..it sure is! What's also better is the health service...HSE can't hold a candle...I've worked in bother and detest the HSE
I am in the US watching this
I can't tell you
@@highbread817 it’s called being interested in world affairs 👍
This is not just the case in Germany, EU is flooded, (Sorry not sorry I am just saying how it is)
I already left my home country 5 years ago , due to the fact immigrants were able to get gov support but me with both my parents dead had to live on the street at 17yo.
(Netherlands)
In France you have an entire city caleis thats filled to the brim with people France cannot kick out due to no papers. The highways in paris have tentcamps everywhere.
This video however is useless as we have no voice in Europe.
Ty for your imput.
I have nothing against those who wish to integrate but those who does not are not welcome.
Theres only so many resources to go around and we gotta prioritise those who were born here and those who put in an effort to belong.
If we keep taking on dead weight then we’ll eventualky sink.
It’s sad what Merkel has done to Germany
Markel had a good idea, what she didn't account for is how the system would be abused by the unworthy.
*Europe
Women should not be in politics or voting they rely on their hearts instead of their heads
She is the daughter of a pastor. She just meant well. Also I still remember how welcoming people have been, when the first refugees in 2015 arrived at the Frankfurter main station. So it's not just Merkel. People wanted to help.
Merkil also made the mistake of cosying up to 🇷🇺 gas , Nord stream gas pipelines… and pulling away from Nuclear energy..which 🇷🇺 wanted…
Germany is too nice. To be blunt, the problematic people are those illegal immigrants who believe a certain religion which I cannot mention. They come to Germany and realizing that the Germans are too nice plus the fact their numbers are growing by the millions, they muscle in and do not want to integrate to the original German culture which is centered on another religion. This is why I pity France and the UK of their problems from the supposedly "good" citizens from that religion which I cannot mention.
Islam, be aloud about it and there is a massive wave of ex-muslims exposing abhorrence of Islam. The more you shy away, the more aggressive they become as they see you as a soft target.
Let me help you to spell the name of a certain religion, that cause these problems - I S L A M.
Stay home, you're not welcome.
Greetings from Germany.
Living in canada, ive seen seeing similar issues. Trudeau has been increasing imigration for year and we are just really noticing now. Housing is expensive for many reasons but buraucracy is fast to get more people but slow to support them. Idt most developping countries were built with this type of mass migration in mind
Germany is also looking north to Sweden and seeing the chaos that has ensued there and are deciding that maybe they've done enough and that they'd still like Germany to be Germany when all this is over.
Germany has worse chaos
@@henry-5676 Naaaw, dude. The problems in Germany are nothing compared to the amount of shootings in Sweden. Look that up yourself.
Something I heard of a immigrant about immigrants which they said to him "I am not stupid and therefore I am not working for Germans".
It made him angry that other immigrants think like that. Some just come for the money.
I honestly cannot comprehend where the German naivety is coming from. 'Germany', the nation that comes to mind when we think of the term, really does not exist anymore. It's only downhill from here.
It most likely wasn't naivety on our politicians part. This was meant to happen.
We have a city here in Germany where they took in 100 refugees from allegedly Ukraine. All with Ukraine passports, but no one speaks Ukraine because they bought the passes on the black market, gg. Our government is so f.. weak.
As a German I want to emphasize that the new policies are a lot of window-dressing and won't help. About 600 additional annual deportations are planed as of the government plans ->about 300.000 asylum seekers are coming to Germany 2023.
I am ashamed of the government 😅
If these 300k changed to all qualified immigrants, would be a completely different story.
You should be, you (as a german society) created this mess, you were blaming all the other countries and putting themselves in morally superior position, schooling all the other countries on "openness and tolerance".
Germans decided to show the example and lead the energy transformation, to "befriend"/support russia and to take all those migrants.
And there was and still is enormous support for all that in german society.
Germans are responsible for it, and germans are choosing it.
@@wilg9400qualified immigrants don't prefer germany much due to their burecracy. That's why more skilled immigrants like Indians and Chinese head to places like US, Canada etc
Yeah true, very strong 'if' and 'would' though.@@wilg9400
@@MareenaJacob-kg7ctalso due to learning german. They already know English that's why it's easy to settle in canada and usa along with ex British colonies
Imagine thinking flooding the Shire with millions of orcs would cause no issues whatsoever.
Bruh
Bruh I was just watching Lotr before stumbling upon this comment
@@goodnightmyprince6734 He's right.
The Scouring of the Shire
Here in Canada, a major problem is that the federal government is the one that regulates how many immigrants come to the country but a lot of the burden on providing immigrants with services such as healthcare, education and housing falls on the provincial or municipal governments. This mismatch creates problems especially since many immigrants like to come to only a few major cities in Canada and all the burden falls on them. However, the federal government hasn't recognized that some regions are more affected by immigration than others and either don't help at all or help all the regions in Canada 'equally' even though not all of them face the same problems.
I don't understand the people that hate on us and call us Nazis for making that decision. We literally have no space for so many immigrants and most of them don't even intigrate themselves but rather stick to their own values and cultures which causes many arguments and even clan wars in some cities.
Some have to seek shelter in all kinds of places and finding an apartment in the city gets more and more tough.
We can't build as many apartments as we need to give every single one shelter. It's just not possible...
I will never understand how people can vote for politicians who are more focused on solving the problems of people who aren't from their country or solving problems for other countries.
Guilt complexes leftist social indoctrination, and a general decline of family structures. The stronger the family structure, the stronger the local community bond, the less likely they are going to fall into these traps..
Well said
I mean its a little bit like in the states. You got the choice between an old leftist geezer or a man who is only 2 years younger with 44 criminal charges. In germany pretty much every party except the AFD is/was pro migration. And AFD is notorious for having Nazis in their members and for not really having any plan what they would do instead. So people just always try to vote for the "lesser evil". Its always the same game here in germany. The usual parties fuck up, AFD votes increase, usual parties backpaddle and the cycle begins again.
I refuse to vote until there is a party that is not completely morronic. The head of "the Greens" (they had 30% votes at times) didnt even know what "insolvent" means, which is a term you learn in school (not university.. just normal schools). It is quiet embarassing. But I also feel like that this is the case for the majority of countries... Name one country that doesnt have a corrupt and/or moronic government full of lobbyists.
The issue is not the voters, the issue is the system. Parties that have the size/resources to build a government are all on the payroll of big companies, which should be strictly illegal, but it isnt. German automotive + politics is a closer bond than politics + public. And since the only ones that could change that are the ones on the payroll, nothing will ever change.
its because we already have a stupid majority of voters due to state media propaganda, leftist teachers and a big portion of 20% migrants/with migration background. while all smart germans leave the country to prosper somewhere else, there is nobody left to vote for a change
because if you dont you will be called a racist, islamophobe and xenophobe, people critiziced the politics heavily but because of social media and young people being pushed into a very leftist point of view everything that was said was deemed "wrong" and "unmoral" and therefore silenced... and then you have the same people telling you that facism is wrong and that you should stop being a facist
The biggest mistake Germany committed was being too tolerant to people who are inherently intolerant like Arab-speaking Muslims from Syria and Afghanistan, while shutting down its doors to highly skilled Latin American and Filipino Catholics.
Syria and Afghanistan are pretty different. In Afghanistan Dari Persian is spoken. My mother used to work as a teacher educating many refugees. Students from Syria had been, according to her, way more polite and respectful towards their female teacher. Those who had been from Afghanistan used to be pretty disrespectful bc of her gender and caused a lot of trouble.
"inherently intolerant"? Are you saying that Arab-speaking Muslims from Syria who are fleeing war zones and oppressive regimes are "inherently intolerant"? I disagree with your statement that Arab-speaking Muslims are inherently intolerant. It is entirely unfair to generalize an entire group of people based on their ethnicity or religion.
Just realised that you called Afghans “Arab speaking” 😭 Europeans always make fun of Americans for not knowing anything outside their country, but it seems like Europeans are the same 😂
@@supalupallama Islam is inherently intolerant. If a Muslim acts tolerantly towards LGBT or women, it’s because they are a decent person, not because of their religion.
@@supalupallama if they want to permanently settle in Europe or the United States, then they should discard their Muslim religion by converting to Catholic or Protestant Christianity and never impose Sharia law to native-born Europeans.
I as some Germans left my country due to many refugee's and rising costs like in the wealth system. Also crime rate rose a lot there is trash everywhere on the streets. Those people brought their problems with them and share them with Germany. That's why some of us had no choice then to leave to a less migrant friendly country where you actually have to work for your living.
From my personal expperiance I have been stalked, harrassed and followed many times and now it is common knowledge that traveling once dark can be very dangerous as a women travelling alone.
Do not get fooled. There is no labor shortage in Germany. There is a shortage of people willing to work for pennies knowing they won't be able to afford a decent apartment plus other costs due to the inflation. Everywhere you go here in Germany there are job ads for people to work at bakeries, restaurants and those kind of segments of the economy where you make very little money and work too many hours.