Thank you for making this video. I have been eagerly waiting to know this comparison. I am glad you did it. Now its clear I might be the same image sensor/hardware (rear camera).
Pretty interesting since early non-direct comparisons made me think the new 3a was noticeably better. Your direct comparisons make the 3 XL look slightly better overall in all aspects and audio. I think maybe because it can shoot easier at a closer range. Still many shots look virtually identical.
The 3a mic sounds worse, but probably not a deal breaker. And DEFINITELY not worth paying so much more for the 3. There was some nice scenery. Where were these pics taken?
yea I agree, its small details but the pixel 3 definitely takes better photos. The pixel 3 has a slightly better processor then the 3a so its most likely that and not the actual camera.
There is not such thing as having a better processor will help you getting better pictures. The 3xl display is a little bit crisper ( not the photos/camera ) use common sense, hope this helped you. Got the 3a xl and I'm 100% happy with it, amazing phone.
Great video!. Love Pixels...I'm actually waiting for Pixel 4 this fall. I wish it will be even better especially in hardware....the main mistery for me about Pixel 4 is how they will implement the front camera/s. Right now for the price I would go for Pixel 3a. Great overall smartphone.
As usual I really love all your photo sample so amazing so beautiful your country. Please do camera review for Sony Xperia 1 and Asus Zenfone 6 my friend. Thanks...
Pixel 3 has a bit more richer colors than Pixel 3a. Probably due to Visual Core 2 chip. Night shots are very close but Pixel 3 has a bit more detail and Pixel 3a has a bit more blown out shots. Audio better on Pixel 3.
I read the comments and I see some people saying that the three Excel look better but I had a 3XL and I have a 3AXL now and I feel like they look the same to me unless I'm not paying attention correctly?
that's because of the PVC built in the pixel 3xl. but the quality difference was minimal not a major one. but when u compare the price between these two phone, then its a huge difference!
I believe that an important difference is in the videos .. I believe that the 3a has the same problem as the 2 with 1080p at 60fps, or indecent, while the 3 should maintain that of the 30fps, even if no one has confirmed it to me yet
The 3XL does have an ever so slight edge over the 3a XL in all situations - and since they have the exact same camera I can only conclude that the 3a XL's camera has been "dumbed down" deliberately just a bit to protect their more expensive model.
I know that the video difference are the fluidity and the stabilization and the quality at 60 FPS (better in pixel v3) but in your test they are identical.. i don't understand.. One my question is: the quality at 60 FPS is the same at 30fps? Because with pixel 2 at 60 FPS is terrible
I think the conclusion is, that if you are only buying a Pixel phone for its camera, it's pointless to spend more than 2x the price for the 3XL. There isn't a single soul who's gonna say "hey, you took those with a 3aXL and not the 3XL ! " Same goes backwards. If you already have a pixel 3 or 3XL, don't bother buying the cheaper one, you aren't gaining anything, but loosing wireless charging, bigger battery, speaker quality.
Please make a snapchat camera quality both videos and pictures of the pixel 3xl and the iPhone XR or X .. please do add under sun effect too .. thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏.. I really love your reviews
Yeah, I got hooked by the clickbait thumbnail :) Both phones produce similar great results, the senior model is slightly ahead in daylight pictures with more popping and warmer colors, but some will like the junior for producing the more "naturalistic" (or dullest) photos. I like the junior pictures at night, its colors are more delightful, and as you said, the selfie game is a gamble, both can produce the better result, you just don't know when they will produce it. For videos, the senior wins by its superior sound quality
it would make sense to release a 4a at the same time witht he Pixel 4. Personally I would be happy with just a 4a with a somewhat higher price but a better screen. My main issue with the 3a xl is the screen...just not bright enough
@@RedskullPro That does indeed make more sense. I'm very interested to see what Google has been cooking up. Thanks for the great comparison, nice area you live in.
@@betonscheitel8635 The HTC is a very good phone as far as software and durability, and it build like a tank. Unfortunately it won't hold the charge under 40% now.
well...i guess it depends what is the most important thing for you in a phone...for some are the cameras, for some the screen, etc :) Maybe this isn't the right phone for you!
yes, if you look at daylight shots with shadows. youll see the details in shadows in 3a XL is better than 3 XL, 3 XL was like it was too dark you cant see the details anymore.
Maybe it's who knows what, BUT, the Pixel 3 XL to 'me', seems on 4K videos to be absolutely better in video quality and extremely important audio quality as well, yes I see a substantially improved difference in video quality on the Pixel 3 XL over the Pixel 3a XL! /// Is 25% to 35% better quality worth it on price, to me, yes, and the (25% to 35%) is just a verbal tool/trick, to try and get my point across, your welcomed to say, 3% to 5%, if you would like to. Thank you and I hope we have passed the audition,, (That's a joke), ha ha ha 📱🔮🌐
add pixel 2xl to comparison ... battery , camera ,.... 🤗😊
I don't have that phone anymore
@@RedskullPro you don't even need to
@@RedskullPro The 3a does not have the spectral/flicker sensor and the Pixel Visual Core from the regular Pixel 3 correct?
Thank you for making this video. I have been eagerly waiting to know this comparison. I am glad you did it. Now its clear I might be the same image sensor/hardware (rear camera).
I like your camera test videos very much. Short, many pictures, interesting informations.
Me too and all the photo look amazing...So beautiful country...
Pretty interesting since early non-direct comparisons made me think the new 3a was noticeably better. Your direct comparisons make the 3 XL look slightly better overall in all aspects and audio. I think maybe because it can shoot easier at a closer range. Still many shots look virtually identical.
The 3a mic sounds worse, but probably not a deal breaker. And DEFINITELY not worth paying so much more for the 3. There was some nice scenery. Where were these pics taken?
Link to music please that was on 1:45 mark
Zenfone 6, Samsung S10e, Pixel 2 and 3 camera comparison my notch hair boss Alex! 👌
Damn! Lovely cameras! Wish i had one this good! Keep it up Alex your doing great! 99
1 more to go!
Some beautiful shots.
Thanks for checking out the video!
Am I the only one who thinks the Pixel 3 camera is crisper than the Pixel 3a? I think it takes sharper pictures too.
yea I agree, its small details but the pixel 3 definitely takes better photos. The pixel 3 has a slightly better processor then the 3a so its most likely that and not the actual camera.
There is not such thing as having a better processor will help you getting better pictures. The 3xl display is a little bit crisper ( not the photos/camera ) use common sense, hope this helped you. Got the 3a xl and I'm 100% happy with it, amazing phone.
The 3 have a Pixel Visual Core which the 3a lacks. Yes processing can make a big difference in the photo quality.
Great video!. Love Pixels...I'm actually waiting for Pixel 4 this fall. I wish it will be even better especially in hardware....the main mistery for me about Pixel 4 is how they will implement the front camera/s.
Right now for the price I would go for Pixel 3a. Great overall smartphone.
Perfect video! Thank you very much. Instant fan!
Glad you enjoyed it!
As usual I really love all your photo sample so amazing so beautiful your country. Please do camera review for Sony Xperia 1 and Asus Zenfone 6 my friend. Thanks...
Pixel 3 has a bit more richer colors than Pixel 3a. Probably due to Visual Core 2 chip. Night shots are very close but Pixel 3 has a bit more detail and Pixel 3a has a bit more blown out shots. Audio better on Pixel 3.
I read the comments and I see some people saying that the three Excel look better but I had a 3XL and I have a 3AXL now and I feel like they look the same to me unless I'm not paying attention correctly?
I will be getting a 3xl now.
What about battery ? Which of them has superiority over another ? To me battery is very important also
I will cover the battery life in the full review...in 3-4 days... I haven't had enough time to test it properly
Other phones: My camera isn't so stable, i should use gcam port.
Google phone: Hold my beer!
Apple: I cant do that 😞
haha!
True that!
Apple left the chat..
What do you mean the pictures look the same? Pixel 3 CLEARLY has finer details and better dynamic range.
Pixel 3 XL owner and I agree with you but it's not by that large of a margin
that's because of the PVC built in the pixel 3xl. but the quality difference was minimal not a major one. but when u compare the price between these two phone, then its a huge difference!
3a XL for the price💪🏻💪🏻, nice video!!
Thanks for checking it out!
I believe that an important difference is in the videos .. I believe that the 3a has the same problem as the 2 with 1080p at 60fps, or indecent, while the 3 should maintain that of the 30fps, even if no one has confirmed it to me yet
Great video as usual! Keep it up Alex!
Great video!!!! Please do a camera comparison between the Pixel 3axl and the Realme X!!!!!!
I am not sure if I will be able to get the Realme :(
Hope youll do a Realme 3 Pro soon. Love from PH ❤️
I'm trying to get it
The 3XL does have an ever so slight edge over the 3a XL in all situations - and since they have the exact same camera I can only conclude that the 3a XL's camera has been "dumbed down" deliberately just a bit to protect their more expensive model.
Thomas Müthing nah it’s the image processing.
Of course, anyone who knows how to post-process photos can push photos like 1:20 to look identical.
Nice video. I think we can't compare them because they are too identical.
Btw, which country is this? I am excited from the architecture!
yeah, super close indeed. The pictures were taken in Cambridge, ON, Canada
I know that the video difference are the fluidity and the stabilization and the quality at 60 FPS (better in pixel v3) but in your test they are identical.. i don't understand.. One my question is: the quality at 60 FPS is the same at 30fps? Because with pixel 2 at 60 FPS is terrible
Great video, thanks
google just reduced the prices of the 3 after they had a promo for the 3a trade in program.
Great comparison
Both beautiful and fantastic but I would go to 3 XL. ❤️❤️❤️
There is a slight difference. Specially in low light. Almost non-existent but there definitely is.
possible
I think the conclusion is, that if you are only buying a Pixel phone for its camera, it's pointless to spend more than 2x the price for the 3XL. There isn't a single soul who's gonna say "hey, you took those with a 3aXL and not the 3XL ! " Same goes backwards. If you already have a pixel 3 or 3XL, don't bother buying the cheaper one, you aren't gaining anything, but loosing wireless charging, bigger battery, speaker quality.
Please make a snapchat camera quality both videos and pictures of the pixel 3xl and the iPhone XR or X .. please do add under sun effect too .. thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏.. I really love your reviews
honestly...i never installed Snapchat on any phone...ever
@@RedskullPro please you could just do that .. alot of people really want to see that comparison
yayy thanks for this ill be getting the 3 xl
Great phone!
Yeah, I got hooked by the clickbait thumbnail :)
Both phones produce similar great results, the senior model is slightly ahead in daylight pictures with more popping and warmer colors, but some will like the junior for producing the more "naturalistic" (or dullest) photos. I like the junior pictures at night, its colors are more delightful, and as you said, the selfie game is a gamble, both can produce the better result, you just don't know when they will produce it. For videos, the senior wins by its superior sound quality
Yes, my thumbnail worked as intended! I did have to beg her for like 10 minutes to let me take pictures :) Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Good review , and to be honest the pictures look the same on both phones. Pixel 3a for me.
Pixel 3 and pixel 3xl has same quality vidéo / picture ?
Yes
Awesome brother
Awesome camera comparison as always
Thanks boss!
*Redskull uploads new video*
Alex's gf: "ah shit here we go again"
That's exactly how it goes!!!
I'd take either, but 3a XL l°°ks interesting! Cheers Alex
Yeah, for the price it is pretty awesome. If the screen would get a bit brighter... would have been the perfect phone
If your hand wasn't covering the 3a XL mic... Then the 3a XL mic is terrible.
Hopefully Google will release a Pixel 4a next year around this time, I will definately upgrade to that from my S8.
it would make sense to release a 4a at the same time witht he Pixel 4. Personally I would be happy with just a 4a with a somewhat higher price but a better screen. My main issue with the 3a xl is the screen...just not bright enough
@@RedskullPro That does indeed make more sense. I'm very interested to see what Google has been cooking up. Thanks for the great comparison, nice area you live in.
It's going to be 1000 dollars 😩
The sound is better in the Pixel 3 XL
I just ordered the pixel 3a last night. It will be definitely better than my three year old HTC 10.
the HTC 10 is very good. So dont be disappointed. It has a slightly bigger sensor then Pixel 2/3. It is the same sensor that the original Pixel has.
@@betonscheitel8635 The HTC is a very good phone as far as software and durability, and it build like a tank. Unfortunately it won't hold the charge under 40% now.
Yeah 'almost identical' is right. The details and colour saturation are definitely better on the Pixel 3.
cool, thanks for sharing
Known for Google's phone camera, but are these google's bezel phone worth..? in 2019-20..?
i don't like bezel.
well...i guess it depends what is the most important thing for you in a phone...for some are the cameras, for some the screen, etc :) Maybe this isn't the right phone for you!
Does this take better pics than the OnePlus 7 pro
I haven't tried the OnePlus 7 Pro yet
Looks like if you want the device for the camera the cheaper is the value option
yeah, the Pixel 3a is the way to go for an awesome camera on a budget!
Looks like you actually set the same picture side-by-side. Basically confirming Google uses the same picture
a bit of ingenious zoom to make them the same size :)
@@RedskullPro ..oops...wanted to say "uses the same sensor"..;)
oh! :)
It seems like most youtubers say the lower volume phone sounds better to them.
Lowlight Video of 3xl Looks better and not shaki
Thanks for checking out the video!
Btw. I think 3a XL has better dynamic range
You think? They kind of look the same to me...i've been stating at like 200 pictures the entire morning
yes, if you look at daylight shots with shadows. youll see the details in shadows in 3a XL is better than 3 XL, 3 XL was like it was too dark you cant see the details anymore.
Great thanks
Thanks for stopping by! :)
Spotting the difference in images between the two is not easy 😂
I don't even know if there are any differences... they look the same to me. Thanks for sharing!
@@RedskullPro Yeah it's basically nitpicking at this point
Looks like The 3xl records better video at night than the 3a Xl.
thanks for watching!
Would choose 3xl over iphone 8
I. Mean would you choose 3xl over iphone 8?
Realme 3 Pro review Please
Trying to get it...
@@RedskullPro I hope u get it fast
Your reviews are so detailed and good
it's difficult because it's only available in India...not even on Aliexpress :( and most websites that have it don't ship to Canada :(
@@RedskullPro what about this website
forwardbuy.com
i'll check it out!
Maybe it's who knows what, BUT, the Pixel 3 XL to 'me', seems on 4K videos to be absolutely better in video quality and extremely important audio quality as well, yes I see a substantially improved difference in video quality on the Pixel 3 XL over the Pixel 3a XL! /// Is 25% to 35% better quality worth it on price, to me, yes, and the (25% to 35%) is just a verbal tool/trick, to try and get my point across, your welcomed to say, 3% to 5%, if you would like to. Thank you and I hope we have passed the audition,, (That's a joke), ha ha ha 📱🔮🌐
Is it just me or do the 3a pics look slightly more realistic/natural???
Tbh this is making my brain hurt trying to spot the difference.
I donno...i can't really spot too many differences...some shadows here and there...but not much
Hangisi daha iyi????
huh?
@@RedskullPro what is better? He asked im turkish :D
Interesting Comparision Brother 😃
Regards from Europe from my Channel Bro's 😀
hey man, thanks for stopping by!!
1080 video has better stabilization than the 4k showed here.......
1080P from any phone has better image stabilization :)
Good
Thanks boss!
@@RedskullPro Happy moment bro
Keren gan
Completely the same, great job Google!
It's the Russian accent?
No
I believe is a romanian accent🙂
3 xl...
Thanks for sharing!
Picked up by a thumbnail woman
yes! The thumbnail worked! :D
Are you a dog or a snake ?
neither
👍♥️👌
Thank you, Thank you!!
Try to make a better quality video please