i went to school with brandon barnes, the drummer. at the time, bands like pegboy, and face to face were all over the scene. its cool to see them covering a band from their roots/youth.
I still cant see how people say a cover is really bad because they like the original band. Its a tribute damnit and this one is a very good one. You cant compare RA to pegboy. Theyre both great in what they're doing
IMO this cover sounds amazing. Tim has so powerful voice that fits in this song. But I understand you people who listened to Pegboy and expected something closer to original.
Not as good as the original, but you know what? Who cares? At least somebody is giving Pegboy props....it's nice to see a band that is enjoying success pay homage to the bands that made them what they are.
I don't really see the big problem people have with this cover, I thought it was actually pretty solid. Then again, I guess I might understand if people don't like Tim's voice, since he sings it quite a bit differently from the original, but I enjoy covers that aren't carbon-copies of the originals, and I thought he implemented his own voice into it well instead of trying to be the original. It's not like they're pretending to be Pegboy, they're just playing a tribute to a band they love.
@lagann37 rise against is actually post-hardcore with punk influences except theyre going mainstream lately. i dont mind it, rise against has been my favorite band for years.
You have to remember that "Strong Reaction" came out in 1991, so like you said, it is kind of silly to compare the two since they are from totally different eras (one is commerically viable by today's standards, the other more or less pre-dates pop punk) and the bands play totally different styles. And yes, the RA guys do like Pegboy - I know they are one of Tim's favorite bands, and Joe definately likes them.
Where's the "hhaaaaayyy-ayaaaayaayyayy...?" That's one of the things that makes this song rock, and they didn't have anyone sing that part. Suks, man...
I don't think he had a guitar in Heaven Knows or Give it All and had an acoustic for Swing Life Away when he had longer hair. It is an old guitar, yes, but I don't remember it from the videos. He got his Out of Step White Gibson Les Paul after this one. Best guitar ever! Chis also had his Obey guitar, which was also sweet.
Not a terrible cover by any means, a good strong "hats off" to Pegboy. I like it. I wouldn't say Tim has a filthy voice or anything, but he's never gonna have that perfectly clean voice either. There's always something in there throwing grit and gravel into his vocals.
Fuck yes no one know pegboy I love this song !!!! The whole album is great and props to rise against cus I love you too and for covering a jam like this🖤
yeah, tim use his beloved gibson sg cherry...or i think that this is his guitar...because he use ist not so often like the white gibson les paul supreme anymore
Not bad, but it ain't Pegboy. Thanks for posting, always interesting to hear band covers. My friend and I saw Pegboy open for Social Distortion in Toronto years ago. Excellent show, both were great live.
seriously who cares what they are, they don't want a label over them, either would I, labels are restrictive, and punks hate restictions, it's a way of life not a genre of music.
No, it's a perfectly fine one. Honestly, which part is terrible? Literally, the only real difference is the chorus (the vocals are one octave higher, big deal).
How in the hell did this band get so big and pegboy didn't! Unbelievable socalled punk kids listen to today...this band is radio friendly mallrock that ruined this awesome punk rock song geesh
As much as I enjoyed Rise Against when they were in their prime, I have to say they absolutely butchered this song. Pegboy's version sounds 10x better and Tim doesn't do this song justice. I'm only glad that it wasn't an even better song from Pegboy they ruined.
That is one fucked up way to butcher a great song. Rise against i guess is ok if your into them, but if they were going to do such a half assed job covering a fucking awesome song from a fucking great band they probably should have just not done it, cause if you ever seen or heard the original song, you will realize how truly bad this cover is.
i went to school with brandon barnes, the drummer. at the time, bands like pegboy, and face to face were all over the scene. its cool to see them covering a band from their roots/youth.
I still cant see how people say a cover is really bad because they like the original band. Its a tribute damnit and this one is a very good one. You cant compare RA to pegboy. Theyre both great in what they're doing
I really like the way they played this song,i think Tim's voice fits in great
one of greatest covers ever!
IMO this cover sounds amazing. Tim has so powerful voice that fits in this song. But I understand you people who listened to Pegboy and expected something closer to original.
Not as good as the original, but you know what? Who cares? At least somebody is giving Pegboy props....it's nice to see a band that is enjoying success pay homage to the bands that made them what they are.
I don't really see the big problem people have with this cover, I thought it was actually pretty solid.
Then again, I guess I might understand if people don't like Tim's voice, since he sings it quite a bit differently from the original, but I enjoy covers that aren't carbon-copies of the originals, and I thought he implemented his own voice into it well instead of trying to be the original.
It's not like they're pretending to be Pegboy, they're just playing a tribute to a band they love.
PEGBOY ! Awesome band !!!!
@lagann37 rise against is actually post-hardcore with punk influences except theyre going mainstream lately. i dont mind it, rise against has been my favorite band for years.
BUT THAT'S ALRIGHT AND THAT'S OKAY 🤘🤘🤘🤘
You have to remember that "Strong Reaction" came out in 1991, so like you said, it is kind of silly to compare the two since they are from totally different eras (one is commerically viable by today's standards, the other more or less pre-dates pop punk) and the bands play totally different styles. And yes, the RA guys do like Pegboy - I know they are one of Tim's favorite bands, and Joe definately likes them.
i think it's also an innuendo of 88 fingers Louie...cuz former guitarist dan and bassist joe were in this band.
Where's the "hhaaaaayyy-ayaaaayaayyayy...?" That's one of the things that makes this song rock, and they didn't have anyone sing that part. Suks, man...
Word. Pegboy rocks! I may have to check out Rise Against now. There are better Pegboy songs that they could cover, though.
Ohhhh... You are right. That version of Give It All is incredible.
Can they please record a studio version of this? Tim's vocals on the chorus sound so great.
Sadly, this is 10 years ago, so he wouldn't sound this way anyways.
@@nahailyenvanakkor eh even if he sounds different, I’m sure he’d still be able to kill it.
superb
I don't think he had a guitar in Heaven Knows or Give it All and had an acoustic for Swing Life Away when he had longer hair. It is an old guitar, yes, but I don't remember it from the videos. He got his Out of Step White Gibson Les Paul after this one. Best guitar ever! Chis also had his Obey guitar, which was also sweet.
Excellent quality and pretty good song too. I haven't heard the original but they play pretty solid here.
Not a terrible cover by any means, a good strong "hats off" to Pegboy. I like it. I wouldn't say Tim has a filthy voice or anything, but he's never gonna have that perfectly clean voice either. There's always something in there throwing grit and gravel into his vocals.
Fuck yes no one know pegboy I love this song !!!! The whole album is great and props to rise against cus I love you too and for covering a jam like this🖤
yeah, tim use his beloved gibson sg cherry...or i think that this is his guitar...because he use ist not so often like the white gibson les paul supreme anymore
Not bad. Pegboy is one of my favorites !
Awesone ! Rise Against +10 !
Love this sound, ah, if it could be in better quality like studio one.
its the older MTV ones, it has a blood to bleed one live, from before they had zach.
@TeamHingaOkinawa Which song are you listening to?
Not bad, but it ain't Pegboy. Thanks for posting, always interesting to hear band covers.
My friend and I saw Pegboy open for Social Distortion in Toronto years ago. Excellent show, both were great live.
wow, it's surprising that they know who Pegboy is...you know...with the fame and all....
Nice cover.
much better than i thought itd be. i wish they played it faster, and when todd or mr. precision was in the band instead of zach.
Tim had long blond hair. Like in the Heaven Knows, Give It All, Swing Life Away & Nervous Breakdown video.
is that tims guitar from the old MTV videos when he was with long blonde hair, before they had zach?
Opps - sorry. That was supposed to be a reply to Pantyh4x0rZ.
@xxxLawlessxxx if you dont like rise against then why look up them playing live?
i bet you know that flavor better than good
seriously who cares what they are, they don't want a label over them, either would I, labels are restrictive, and punks hate restictions, it's a way of life not a genre of music.
@xxxLawlessxxx oh.
in my opinion he doesnt have that flithy throat sound
I love the butthurt Pegboy fans in the comment section. It's a f*cking cover, get over it.
it's a horrible cover, get over it
No, it's a perfectly fine one. Honestly, which part is terrible? Literally, the only real difference is the chorus (the vocals are one octave higher, big deal).
its a good cover, but well, pegboy are the shit.
rise against are like grasshoppers to pegboys roaring lion
How in the hell did this band get so big and pegboy didn't! Unbelievable socalled punk kids listen to today...this band is radio friendly mallrock that ruined this awesome punk rock song geesh
gigi puig
Wow, you’re so fucking edgy, bro.
its not nice to talk about your mum like that
sorry but he bombed it
1thess523 you mean killed it
That's a song ya just don't cover.
Ed Pontius and yet they did and did a great job
who the fuck had long blonde hair?
As much as I enjoyed Rise Against when they were in their prime, I have to say they absolutely butchered this song. Pegboy's version sounds 10x better and Tim doesn't do this song justice. I'm only glad that it wasn't an even better song from Pegboy they ruined.
Strongly disagree. The cover sounds great.
The only thing butchered is your ears if you think that. This version was great.
Get your head out of your ass
nah, this isnt punk you dorks
gromstoso well it sure as shit isn’t thrash metal lmao
That is one fucked up way to butcher a great song. Rise against i guess is ok if your into them, but if they were going to do such a half assed job covering a fucking awesome song from a fucking great band they probably should have just not done it, cause if you ever seen or heard the original song, you will realize how truly bad this cover is.
Too bad the Pegboy version totally rips the shit out of this one. Don't cover a song you're just going to fuck up.
yikes. way to slaughter a perfectly good Pegboy song.
who the fuck had long blonde hair?